Subhash Chandra Bose: A Mystery Unraveled - Purabi Roy -

[@MunaLife]

Thank you Madam Roy. Nowadays we are seeing some independent researchers trying to work on Subhas Bose but at one point of time you were the only one serious academician on the trail taking immense pain to visit foreign countries and sifting through archival records. You truly deserve our gratitude for what you have done for the country. Yes the Mukherjee commission report must be recovered and accepted in the parliament.

[@SarangDhanurdhari]

Mukharjee commission which is accepted by the public, privately justice mukharjee already revealed and the video is also available on KZbin that He is 100%sure that Gumnami baba was netaji subhash chandra Bose

[@sukumar426]

We must encourage her more of assembling of original de-classification of Subhas Chandra Bose, The Great Hero. If we have true love, we must raise the move through social media also.

[@shalinisharma4686]

Aap ne bahut hard work kiya hei. Yadi aap video mein evidences ko thoda attach karti to aur bhi accha hota. INA wealth ke baare mein pehli baar suna. Rs70000 crore huge wealth. Netaji ho Gandhi ya lakshmi bai ya bhagat singh jaise hamare aur veer sapoot.. Inhe kisi bhi post ya saboot designation ki jarurat nahi. Ye hamesha hindustaniyon ke dil mein Raaj karte hein. Aapne ye share karke Netaji ko true tribute di hei. Thank you .

[@muktikantasamantaray7875]

Thank u maim.We Bharatiyas have right to know about the greatest son of Bharat Mata Netajee.Jai Hind

[@deepakbanerjee9836]

Thank you so much for such a enormous and detailed research on a issue that is dear to most Indians.

[@suvadeepbanerjee1863]

Today incredible research of Anuj Dhar and Chandrachud also reveals that Netaji was living in India till 1985.

[@anuh5454]

We must thank her for her original work!

[@AnimeshDas11]

Most sensitive files in UK would be published in 2021- was told to Justice Mukherjee. Has anyone enquired last year?

[@hsmahbiv7474]

And now Rishi Sunak as PM , I hope he becomes a facilitator

[@buddhavivekanand7462]

apart from Nehru-Congress its the Bengalies who stabbed Netaji in the back.. Communist from Bengal called Netaji Tojo's Dog.. Bengalies Never called Bandh or Strike to pressure Congress for revealing truth.. Bengal Congress & Communists supported Congress Govt. of Indira Gandhi

[@meenakshighosh8584]

Bengali 😳😳.

[@adminabmtowers5848]

what she proposed as of an Indo Russian high level expert type committee is apt and most scientific

[@samirbarandas1396]

False news of air crash was circulated by japan. So japan is to suspected as playing a wrong game with netaji subhash. In any controvecial case liars are to be suspected. Japan told lie. Let us suspect the role of japan.

[@DipakBose-bq1vv]

@@samirbarandas1396 Japan tried to protect Netaji from the British agents who wanted to kill him on the spot, as Mountbatten and Wavell declared.

[@rmkrshn1887]

@@samirbarandas1396 -- Truth is beyond fact. Truth is eternal Consciousness as well as the path that leads to it. Any Fact that leads us away from Truth is to be shunned. Such shunning may require us to hide facts i.e., Lie . So , many times Dharma demands us to lie under oath also. Japan was / is a much more Dharmic , indic friendly nation than any of the European nation with their legacy of Global imperiasm & spread of Culture Vulture religion Christianity . Christianity is a destructive ideology , it is an enslaving ideology. Japanese have no such Schemes for cultural or religious domination of India. On the other hand , they are a deep respect for our culture , religions and philosophies.

[@DrGorachandGhosh2710]

The death mystery of Netaji is resolved by me using 50 rare photos of Netaji in the WWII since 18Sept2017 through the published books worldwide since 18Sept2017 in English. Again Notion press has published this book in Bengali on 22June2022. Purabi Roy must read my books as renowned Physicst worldwide.

[@RCDUP]

Salute to your hard work mam!!

[@dhrubaranjanguha4090]

Ashadharan apurba speech purabadi, amar anek anek sraddhya vakti o pranam neben. Jaihind

[@omanam3799]

Respecting & accepting the efforts and work of Purbi Roy to a great extent. But when the previous governments had desperately made attempts to prove Netaji dead; isn't there a chance that he was alive even after Russia and attempts made to prove him dead? Why is she so adamant on rejecting Bhagwanji theory? Why is that she not able to keep an open mind? It can be that Purbi Roy was successful in solving one part of Netaji mistry after plane crash and the other part by Anuj Dhar. If once Purbi Roy was treated as liar, today Anuj Dhar stands in that same position. I hope if both these people stand together then Netaji-Bhagwanji mistry or riddle could be solved. However Purbi Roy will have to be more open minded and ready for a discussion with Anuj Dhar of Netaji Mission for that. Also it is really disgusting that people find difficulty in accepting Netaji as Bhagwanji as it seems not matching to his personality; but could very much accept Netaji's hidden marriage and then deserting his wife & daughter. Well then does that suits his personality???

[@panchtattvashakti8729]

Then why did justice Mukherjee admit that Gumnami baba was Subhash Chandra Bose!!!!!!! There is a video to this effect!

[@SudipBhattacharyya]

Thank you madam for your hard research work and expressing the truth to us. Regards

[@chandrowtiesingh137]

Thank. U Madam Roy for your good works to reveal the truth about Netaji's death. The people must know.

[@vishnuacharya6352]

What good has the Nehru-Gandhi parivar done to escape consequences of their heinous misdeed, O Dear God!

[@jayantochatterjee6413]

I doff my hat to Dr Purabi Roy for her authoritative and exhaustive work behind the mystery of Netaji's death..on the basis of verifiable evidence in the archives of the British MI2 and KGB it stands proved that NETAJI DID NOT DIE IN ANY PLANE CRASH on 18th August 1945 as there was no plane crash at Taihoku Airport on that day. The only place I disagree with Dr Roy is the theory of the "Dummies" which does not make any sense whereby she says that Gumnaami baba of faizabad is a dummy deliberately foisted by Indira Gandhi. what purpose was to be gained by keeping Bose alive in the minds of the people thru these socalled dummies...whereas Justice Manoj Mukherjee of the Mukherjee Commission has privately stated in 2010 that he believes Gumnaami baba to be Netaji..Its a wonder why MODI has NOT followed up to conclusively prove the truth about Netajis death which will put the final nail in the coffin of the lying Nehru Gandhi Family .One theory could be that NETAJI was killed by the Russians and if this fact came out in the public domain then Indo Russia relations would be severely hit

[@arunavaroychowdhury5931]

I am thrilled to know about all the facts. My. Respect & gratitude to you Mam for sharing the facts. Hope” Satyadev Jayte” will prevail. Request the current govt. to help resolve the finding of the truth.

[@DipakBose-bq1vv]

Those who are against Netaji and want to insult Netaji, they can say Gumnami Baba was Netaji. If he was such a coward to hide in fear of Nehru-Pant-Rajendra Prasad, he could have stayed in Calcutta in 1940-41 to eat Mach-Bhat and surrendered to Gandhi rather than going to Afghanistan-Russia-Germany-Japan to raise an army to fight the British.

[@mohitsingh-sc4ej]

Thanku mam to bring all the truth ... But dnt know why people are not intrested in it

[@proudindian-g2n]

I really liked the talk by Dr. Roy

[@DrGorachandGhosh2710]

Netaji and INA gave our freedom NOT by any other Indian political leaders. The facts of Netaji and INA have published in the Amazon Books for the first time throughout the whole world (eBooks in English and Hindi published on 19 September 2017 and 11 March 2021, respectively; paperback book in English on 23 November 2019). The eBook in English was presented to the Prime Minister Narendra Modi in September 2017 as his birthday gift. Also, in December 2017 a hardcover book was published in India. Since Amazon has taken care about this important book, in January 2020, when I was in India, I have presented the hardcover book to the President and PM of India, some Chief Ministers, and libraries of some IITs, colleges and schools. The indirect war criminals Gandhi and Nehru did not believe the death of Netaji and they had claimed that Netaji was a war criminal, hiding in Russia under the protection of Stalin. Nehru knew the death of Netaji but he fooled and looted Indians by using the secrecy act of the British Raj. The grandfather of Anuj Dhar fought against Netaji and INA at Imphal as a soldier in British Indian Army. I lived in Japan for almost ten years (1982-1999) for doing research on optical materials and optical fibre communication technology as a Japanese Government Scholar. Since April 1999, I am engaged in doing part-time research on Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose with the advice of my Japanese Professor Dr Hiroyoshi Yajima and his father Late Masayoshi Kakitsubo who was the personal secretary of Netaji in WWII. On 19 September 2017, with the advice of my Professor Yajima, I have published the eBook by Amazon entitled “UNKNOWN FACTS OF NETAJI: JAPAN and SOUTHEAST ASIA” throughout the whole world including India. This book is forwarded by Dr Hiroyoshi Yajima and is dedicated to Masayoshi Kakitsubo. The Indian topmost copyright violators-cum-criminals Anuj Dhar and Chandrachur Ghose have stolen the Amazon eBook photos. I have come to know this on 8 October 2017, and I have acted as per the copyright laws in India. After stealing, these criminals have cropped those photos to remove the photo captions having the written notes in English and Japanese by Masayoshi Kakitsubo. Also, they made KZbin videos as if these photos of Netaji were snapped by their forefathers in the WWII. I am fighting alone against these criminals led by Anuj Dhar who was a congress stooge journalist and in 2001, he has created an NGO “Mission Netaji” at New Delhi for his livelihood to defame Netaji as GumnamiBaba. Now these criminals Anuj Dhar and Chandrachur Ghose are engaged to defame Netaji as GumnamiBaba without having a single proof of Scientific evidence. Moreover, they have written more than five defamatory books on Netaji and distortion of WWII history for their livelihood. Nehru made ten dummy Netaji after death of Netaji to prove his theory that Netaji was a war criminal hiding in Russia. Nehru wrote a letter to Clement Attlee on 27 Dec 1945 about his above claim. GumnamiBaba was one of the ten dummy Netaji. After death of Nehru, Indira Khan Gandhi and Pranab Mukherjee had maintained GumnamiBaba. Although Netaji died on 18 August 1945, but Vijay Lakshmi Pandit and Dr S Radhakrishnan saw alive Netaji in the Russian jail (1947-1952) for vehemently supporting the theory of Nehru. Till to date there is no proof of Netaji’s arrival in Russia after his death. These criminals are engaged to earn money by using the name of Netaji. Anuj Dhar and Chandrachur Ghose are money mongers to fool and loot Indians by using the name of Netaji as GumnamiBaba without having any single proof of evidence. In my all-Amazon books the truths, facts, and incidents of Netaji’s death on 18 August 1945 are published by using these amazing 50 rare photos of Netaji in WWII. Jai Hind, Joyotu Netaji, Bande Matarom. The Amazon links of India and USA for these books are: www.amazon.in/FACTS-NETAJI-JAPAN-SOUTHEAST-ASIA-ebook/dp/B075R69M6N www.amazon.com/FACTS-NETAJI-JAPAN-SOUTHEAST-ASIA/dp/1697954758

[@sandeepsarkar1607]

We call ourself bengalies ... This aged lady who has shown somuch of guts to bring back our Netajis real story and we young pseudo Secularist half educated Intellectuals brigade of Bengalies trying to discuss what was the down fall of Communism ...

[@user-uv8tc3yu7y]

Modi has to set a commission just to establish if Netaji died in plane crash or not. Further investigations can be done based on the conclusion.

[@TheGyanaranjanjena]

What is your take on Bhagwanji ??

[@prasantaroy2820]

She dodged many findings about gumnami baba

[@dipasinha663]

🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳JAI HIND 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳JAI BHARAT 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳

[@singhpraa3681]

Madam gumnami baba cremated in guptar gaat he is not a planted baba he is Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose even Justice Mukherjee agree it he is gumnami baba is the real shubhash Chandra Bose.

[@prasantaroy2820]

How u come to this almost conclusion that he was killed in Russia? If it is true whom vijoy Laxmi Pandit n lalbahadur sastri saw there? Sastri saw him in1966...if he was killed ,why they waited at least 20yrs for killing him? Pls give the identity of the man seen in the scenario of taskhand treaty n Vietnam USA peace treaty.... I think it is easier for Mrs Mukherjee to reveal the identity of that man..

[@munagauda5312]

All documents seem classified related to Netaji in India and also in other countries.😮why...why...why...!!!!

[@amalbhattacharya9815]

All We know Nehru how desperate he was to be Prime minister! Many thanks to Mam🙏

[@saswatabagchi6937]

Can you please elaborate where did you get this info( particular place and archive name ) reg the creation of improvise dummy of Bose .

[@MultimodalLogisticSystems]

Question is - why were Nehru family members so perturbed about Netaji being alive!

[@ankurdhiman739]

Who would have been the prime minister if bose had came back?? As simple as that.

[@swarnamohanty3121]

Neheru had kept Netaji secretly as Gumnam baba , being afraid to hand over him as war criminal toU.S .

[@swarnamohanty3121]

@@ankurdhiman739 Subas Bose was leader of Forward block party .Do you think Forward block could have got minimum 275 MPs in loksabha to make Netaji PM ?

[@ankurdhiman739]

@@swarnamohanty3121 do you think nehru was elected by the people of Bharatvarsh before independence as pm

[@ankurdhiman739]

@@swarnamohanty3121 that's why he wrote to then ambassador of japan to sleuth on nephew of netaji whether he is meeting neta ji or not.

[@ravichandel8690]

more hard facts needed make a debate video with anuj dhar and others

[@SandeepKumar-nn6pr]

Anuj Dhar is liar.

[@purabiroy7224]

This purabi Roy is famous researchers of Netaji subhasBose .That I know from T.V. She is enough educated.

[@purabiroy7224]

I am not that important lady .I am purabi Roy/daughter of late AmarendranathRoy ,student of B.V.S.V.

[@a73366]

According to you Russian Govt seems to be agreeable to divulge all secrets vis-a-vis Netaji, but still nothing is happening, Why? During anti-National Congress govt it could be understood that they didn't want the truth to come out because all the well-guarded secrets of the Family at least many of them could come in the open; but what is the hesitation of the present govt. As far as we all know Modiji has no known secrets that has to be kept under wrap, then what's the mystery?

[@snbjaihind4923]

Most welcome.netaji Subhash Chandra Bose as baba jaigurudev is alive today for the under prosseuding government of India, गुमनामी बाबा रामभवन अयोध्या फैजाबाद स्थिति की कहानी भारत सरकार का एक बहुत बडा षणयन्त्र. है।

[@sreem8729]

Mohammad yunus was ambassador to Turkey Iraq. So the files might be in Turkey .

[@banerjeesiddharth05]

👍👍

[@shivampriyadarshi327]

Maidam Thank you very much 🙏🙏

[@eather2023]

Uniqe

[@saurchouksey]

Jai hind

[@arindammazumder5146]

Thishh ishh not clear mam out of 10 dummieshh, one washh gumnami baba, one washh the buddhishhth monk beshhide nehru'shh body who are the reshhth. And what intereshht it would have shherved nehru to create 10 dummieshh who wanted him dead, now even if he killed one how would he had known it was Netaji ? Inshhtead of clearing the doubt you are creating more. And how could you know the buddhishht monk washh below five feet, that ishh not clear by that shhingle photograph publishhhed.

[@tuhinkantidas9799]

who is Md. Unush?

[@prasantaroy2820]

This lady can not show even a single evidence... All is hypotheticall....some statements are beyond logic.... U will have to be super brilliant to judge n analyze a superman who has a yojic entity within himself.... U must have a yojic psychology within yourself to realize such kind of people.. Only a historian or scholar will never ever be able to explain the various stages of life of the like of Subhas bose

[@narendrakhilnani6578]

Who paid for Baba's expenses?

[@meenakshiverma1043]

Rss and INA members

[@DipakBose-bq1vv]

Those who are against Netaji and want to insult Netaji, they can say Gumnami Baba was Netaji. If he was such a coward to hide in fear of Nehru-Pant-Rajendra Prasad, he could have stayed in Calcutta in 1940-41 to eat Mach-Bhat and surrendered to Gandhi rather than going to Afghanistan-Russia-Germany-Japan to raise an army to fight the British. According to Chandra Bose, there was a DNA test and it was negative. That should be the end of the debate. There is evidence that Netaji never died in the plane crash as Taiwan Government said clearly there was no such accident on that date. Mukherjee commission has the same opinion. Prof Purabi Roy investigated the Russian angle and found out that Netaji reached Russia in 1945 and was received by the Indian consul of the Azad Hind Sarkar. She did extensive research on Netaji in the Soviet Union, which are now published as a two-volume book by the Asiatic Society in Calcutta. The son of Abani Mukherjee one of the founder of the CPI, in 1920 in Moscow said that his father met Netaji as they were in the same camp until 1946. My wife went to the archive of the NKVD/KGB in Moscow, as she is a highly connected Russian citizen. There are documents on Netaji in that archive but Netaji was described as a triple agent of Japan, Germany, and Britain. In the Hindustan Times special website created by Anuj Dhar, there is one who used to live in Quetta in Balochistan and he has seen Netaji being taken by the British Soldier in 1946 to the no man's land in the border between Iran and Balochistan for execution. There was an agreement between Stalin and Churchill that they will exchange each other's prisoner and in 1946, Netaji was a citizen of the British Empire. In 1946, there were a number of such exchanges. Thus, Netaji was executed by the British in 1946 in Balochistan. Gumnami Baba has nothing to do with Netaji.

[@barundutta462]

First do a case study then say. Listen to Anuj Dhar what he has to say. The DNA test was fake. Of course it will be. Please listen to Anuj Dhar. He spent 18 years researching these matter about Gumanani Baba.

[@rohanmishra3117]

My comment would appear harsh but if you really want to resolve the mystery, please check the facts. Read Mr. Anuj Dhar's latest book Conundrum on the entire mystery. He has covered all the aspects brilliantly. Please go through them

[@DipakBose-bq1vv]

@@barundutta462 Anuj Dhar is evil; he wants to discredit Netaji. Who is funding him?

[@DipakBose-bq1vv]

@@rohanmishra3117 I have verified the so-called"facts". Anuj Dhar is evil; he wants to discredit Netaji. Who is funding him?

[@DipakBose-bq1vv]

@@rohanmishra3117 Anuj Dhar is trying to discredit Netaji.

[@dr.geetasingh5537]

Yunus gaddar

[@amitmukherjee5998]

Gumnami baba was actual netaji.

[@joyashrighosh8190]

Just I have read the book "UNKNOWN FACTS OF NETAJI: JAPAN and SOUTHEAST Asia" published here in India in December 2017 by Dr Gorachand Ghosh based om 50 rare photos of Netaji in Japan and unpublished articles of Masayoshi Kakitsubo who was the Tokyo and Cambridge University's graduate. He was a Japanese Government diplomat, Interpreter-cum-PS of Netaji (11 May 1943 until his death) and according to his advice the book is written. It is the direct TRUTHS and FACTS of Netaji's death on 18 August 1945 by the Plane crash accident and there is no conspiracy theory or any journalist reports are published. Purabi Roy is the top most conspirator as an Historian to fool the Indians and particularly to the Bangalis. This lady is taking the advantage of Netaji's freedom struggle and his link with Russia. Netaji and INA gave our freedom as written in Dr Ghosh's book. Moreover, the CPI is used to say "NETAJI as TOJO's KUTTA", May be you know this sentence from your CPI husband.

[@DipakBose-bq1vv]

Mukherjee Commission said clearly that Netaji never died in that Plane Crash as there was no air crash on that day; it was supported by the Taiwan Government. Thus, what you are saying is just stupid. Japan government tried to protect Netaji, so they spread the rumour that Netaji died in a plane crash.

[@jayantochatterjee6413]

It is an Established fact now that there was NO PLANE CRASH on 18th August 1945 at Taihoku Airport...The Taiwanese government has stated this to the Justice Mukherjee Commission . Family members of Netaji refused to appear before the Justice Mukherjee Commission to state that he had died in the plane crash in 1945..Dr Sisir Bose wrote to the connission to say they had no personal news of Netaji after he left Calcutta in 1941...there is NO Authentic Death Certificate certifying Netaji died on 18th August 1945..When there was a proposal to bring back "the ashes" from renkoji temple the Calcutta High Court under Chief Justice BS Mishra cautioned the government to first ESTABLISH the ashes were that of NETAJI..the move was dropped..in 1992 when there was a proposal to confer Bharat Ratna on Netaji posthumously it was struck down by the Supreme Court ..Hence Ms Ghosh it is advisable to please maintain decorum in your speech and ascertain the facts before calling anybody a Liar and a conspirator .there is enough evidence in files of governments around the world which say NETAJI was in Russia even as late as 1964 .These Governments have no axe to grind ike the lying Nehru Gandhi family

[@DipakBose-bq1vv]

Anuj Dhar is evil; he wants to discredit Netaji.