CHARLES AL-HAYEK: A History of Crisis, Exodus & Irresponsible Elites | Sarde (after dinner) #50

[@sardeafterdinner]

Welcome to Sarde! Please like and comment on the video to please the Algorithm Gods & if you can, support us on www.patreon.com/sardeafterdinner 00:00 - Sarde on Patreon 05:51 - History of Charles Al-Hayek 07:47 - Why is Lebanon in a constant state of crisis 09:56 - The First Exodus 20:09 - Deepdive into the Famine of 1914 38:39 - The Ottomans “The traditional enemy” 41:07 - Monopolization of resources by Lebanese during the Famine 48:09 - The deadly role France and Britain played in the Famine 51:15 - The agriculture collapse and the rural exodus 58:11 - The 3rd crisis and the 2nd exodus: The Civil War 01:04:35 - 160 years of failure “The Last Exodus” of 2021 01:15:52 March’s initiative: Emancipating the Youth in Tripoli through history 01:22:47 - 3 different curriculums lead to 3 different cultures in Lebanon 01:31:43 -Albert Naccache, a solution driven economist of the 20th century 01:40:56 - Heliopolis. 01:49:29 - The beautiful historical sites in Lebanon 01:55:06 - Theft of artifacts in Lebanon 01:59:06 - The diaspora’s historic role in Lebanon 02:02:37 - Charles’ love for Lebanon

[@bloodoranges2631]

24.10 bottom line. Mr former school teacher is a REFERENCE BEYOND AND ABOVE GOOGLE. Brownosing the Sunni host and the sunni community before and after upgrading from $chool to univer$ity teaching obviously pay very well . You are not to be trusted! The quote of ENVER PASHA is not apocryphal because those did exterminate 1.5 MILLION CHRISTIAN ARMENIANS! AND MANY OTHERS! And Kamal pasha AL JAZAAAAAR didn t get his horrible nickname in LEBANON by chance! 😡 the hundred thousands starved to death GENOCIDE victims of those bloody mass murderers ott🤮mans must be turning and cursing you in their grave as you defend their killers of committing GENOCIDE! AGAIN! not to mention the numerous others killed tortured during the 400 years rule of those savages! Tfeh! You are a mercenary historian!

[@bloodoranges2631]

Why dont you shed the light on the JANISSARIES! HOW THOSE OTTOMANS KIDNAPPED CHRISTIAN BOYS DURING THEIR MUSLIM RAIDS ENSLAVED THEM TRAINED THEM TO BECOME A KILLING MACHINE! FORBID THEM TO MARRY! THE CONDITIONS THEY WERE BROUGHT UP IN ! As well as THE SLAVERY HISTORY OF THE DAMN BLOODY OTTOMAN EMPIRE!

[@bloodoranges2631]

24.09 الطريقة السءيلة اللي بتلوء فيها تمك بهل الحلقة لما بتدافع عن جزارين يشهد لهم بدمويتهم اللي لا سابق لها بلتاريخ هي نفسها بحلقتك الماضية بالدقيقة اللي بتدافع فيها عنهم كمان! عن جد سءيييل انت اكيد قومي سوري موووو؟ مش حكيت كمان عن مرجع اصريت تجيب سيرتو بلحلقة الماضية لتشدد انو كلمة لبنان ما ذكرت ولا مرة بكل الكتاب!! شو هدفك عل مظبوط. ما لبنان وصل لهون بسبب ناس متلكم ما بيعترفو ب لبنان لا كبلد نهاءي و لا حتى كبلد بل متل السوريين بيقولو انو......غلطة تاريخية! و بكل خبث حاملين جنسية لبنانية ! أتخلى عن جنسيتك و سمي حالك سوري او تركي او عثماني او مواطن الهلال الخصيب بس مش لبناني! يلا ريحونا!

[@unu7649]

ح. ظ ٩ح٩

[@YoussefMohamed-gl9us]

😊😊😊

[@padawanguy360]

What Charles said about Tripoli really resonated with me. As someone who is not Lebanese, when I visited Lebanon a year and a half ago, my friend Mary (who lives there) wanted me to see Tripoli, but I had heard the stereotype that it was dangerous so I was a bit nervous. Now, I'm so glad she convinced me to go; we saw so many cultural and historical sites there in only one day, including two Orthodox churches, the old hammams, the citadel, and the best knaffeh of my life. It was one of the most important days of my trip, and I almost missed out on it out of fear and propaganda. It reminded me of all the places in America that are considered "dangerous" but have a ton of unknown history. Great work as always, الله يخليكن

[@assiaassabir5772]

I am Moroccan and I'm having extreme enjoyment listening to this podcast. love Lebanon

[@sardeafterdinner]

We love you!

[@osamasaleh8456]

مؤرخ يتحدث لساعتين ودون أن يشعر المتابع بالملل! هذا مذهل واستثنائي.. تحياتي للأستاذ شارل ولبيت سردة، 🇱🇾✌

[@ghadalaban8198]

يا الله شو حبيت هالشخص والبرنامج كله جدا حلو شكرا لتعبكم .......تحياتي من الأردن

[@adamhosn4145]

Such an influential person. Educated, smart and charismatic!

[@Shiraz_Midi]

لبنان من الدول الناطقه بالعربيه والتي بقيت محافظه على جمالها وطبيعتها رغم ما مر عليها من مصائب ونكسات لكنها ارتقت بثقافاتها كونها خليط من الثقافات والحضارات.. تحية لأهل لبنان الصامد والقائمين على هذه القناة المميزه بلطافتهم وحلاوة ورقي تقديمهم لهذا البرنامج الرائع . شكراً لكم شيراز ☀️

[@batulkamar729]

I could listen to him talk all day. Great episode, and looking for more episodes with Charles!

[@alexlutfi3830]

By the way I am Iraqi from Sweden and for some reason interested in politics in the middle east, specially Lebanon. I enjoy every minute listening to you guys, keep up your good work 👍. Love and respect ❤️

[@sarahel-sayed8350]

This man is going endless places and I'm happy for him

[@teknobuild]

شكرًا لبرنامجكم الرائع وضيفكم الأروع، @ 1:28:30 جاب سيرة مصنع المعكرونة في بيصور وعن صاحب المصنع صلاح ملاعب بيشبّه القمح اللبناني القاسي ببشرتنا السمرا وهو عم يشرح للتلاميذ عن القمح. مشكور أستاذ شارل على صدقك ومعلوماتك القبّمة

[@hadjerbenounane9865]

I'm Algerian, and I really enjoy your discussions guys 💜💜

[@LMCIC]

Love to listen. Never get bored. Better than Netflix.

[@essamaljabban5074]

شكراً لهذا الحوار الحضاري التاريخي الممتع ، ولهذا السرد الجامع للطوائف . هذا ما نحن بحاجة إليه .

[@ziadmadi9347]

This is the single most important podcast I've seen, it should be force feed to every Lebanese citizen old and young, spread it like butter. PROTECT THIS MAN !!!

[@ibrahimsoukak437]

Guys this guy is amazingly intelligent. His voice should reach out to everyone. I really hope that your platform becomes one of the most influential in the world, because we need people like you to enlighten others. I'm always super happy to listen to your episodes, but on top of that very grateful for your reassurance that there's still hope, and there's still reason to fight. Please feel supported in every minute. 💪

[@from415daysofchanges]

I wonder how many young lebanese are listening to these eye opening podcasts... 😢💔 I always struggled with telling my friends about going and socializing in other regions of Lebanon since they would prefer to be limited to only few specific ones. Thank you for talking about the history and our current situation. We need to make more conversations about these things now more than ever.

[@shaherkhadra]

الرائعان السيدة ميديا والأستاذ معين أصبحت متابعا لسردة البارحة كل ما أقوله أنني أفخر بكما وبهذه القناة وما تقدمه من البساطة العميقة إلى العميق المهم تحياتي لضيفكما ولكما كل المحبة والإحترام ضيفكم تشارلز أذهلني بموسوعيته ودقته مع تمنياتي بالتوفيق

[@maikel3888]

لبنان لازم يسمع اكثر لناس مثل شارل

[@Ibnhamar]

You guys are the biggest reason I’m able to study and upkeep the language as a non-arab and the subtitles, thoughtful discussion and hosts, and amazing guests are helping me learn the language and open my mind, about culture, politics, economy, etc etc. Can’t express enough or find the proper words to say how much I appreciate y’all and how highly I think of you guys. Thank you so much for this podcast.

[@MiChamp]

Grant you know more about Lebanon than most Lebanese citizens by listening to Charles :) unfortunately. Good luck in your language learning!

[@issamab4327]

This man is a national treasure

[@ramitannous133]

@@abbefolkseger6927 I'm shipping them now

[@lassadsaidani4639]

Je suis tunisien vivant en France et je trouve votre podcast très intéressant, surtout j'aime l'histoire et permet de comprendre que ce passe Liban que ces problèmes et les mêmes qu'en Tunisie. Merci infiniment.

[@farahani8500]

Charles should be yout guest at least every month. Very insightful and important podcast, we need more people like Charles in our country.

[@msa590]

Charles is a national treasure ❤️❤️❤️

[@ANYA2015-c9r]

Avec grand plaisir et par pur "hasard" si le hasard existe, j'ai découvert cette 2ème vidéo de M. Charles AL-HAYEK. La première c'était hier, elle a été suggérée par KZbin, c'était avec M. Jad GHOSN. J'ai toujours critiqué la majorité des Libanais pour leur aveuglement face à la réalité de la situation et leur communautarisme identitaire exacerbé. Oubliant que le progrès, va au-delà de ces choses et qu'il faut penser large d'une façon pragmatique, pour pouvoir assainir le Liban et permettre à la jeune génération un bel avenir. Monsieur Charles AL-HAYEK le dit explicitement, ce qui est très rassurant ! Bravo, continuez ce bon travail. Merci également aux hôtes d'avoir eu cette belle initiative. P.S. : permettez-moi cette remarque ; j'apprécie beaucoup moins ce pastiche de langues pour s'exprimer en anglo-franco-libanais, ce qui casse considérablement une si belle discussion.

[@bassamarnaout1071]

على فكرة كتير كتير حلو صرلي يومين ساردها عليه ! انا كل عمري بقول التاريخ يكتبه المنتصرون و هو اكدلي حديثي ! Thank you so much guys ! Seriously you are doing an amazing job ! Keep it up ! From Sydney with love ❤️

[@orbitaluse]

Guys keep on! I’ll support from Sweden. Listen to you from here and the talks that you are doing is so good and important to stay alive. Thanks for that 💛⭐️

[@Ttttyui370]

All episodes of sarde are normal, except for Charles Hayek, who gives value to the program in all aspects, he is educated and tactful

[@AliSaad05]

Agree 100%

[@captainego5149]

Sarde after dinner is by far my favorite podcast. I listen to them every day during work, im almost done with all of the episodes... Which is sad to be honest. I moved from Lebanon like a huge chunk of the youth did, to build a better future. And just listening to Lebanese people talk and have this chill vibe makes me feel slightly less homesick. Please give us more episodes ❤️

[@ImaneDahmane1]

Sarde is one of a kind ! Can’t stop listening ! For the first time I find a 2hours podcast very short ! We learn so much ! Thank you

[@itoma72]

Bonjour, je suis française, je vous suis depuis très longtemps, j'adore ce que vous faites ❤ continuez vous êtes les meilleurs

[@shouqal-alawi2867]

من البحرين 🇧🇭 وحبيت جداً هالسردة

[@ibrahimghantous5420]

Absolutely beautiful mind of this intellectual icon! I could listen to his explain all day and every day. Thank you for all of your transparency and hard work.

[@hounaidaabdulkader3658]

د. شارل حايك لازم نسمعو كل يوم.. جزيل الشكر لاستضافته مرة ثانية.. و انشالله مرات ومرات.. يذكرني د. شارل باستاذ التاريخ الذي علمنا خلال ثلاث سنوات الثانوية في عكار ( ثانوية رسمية) كانت طريقته شبيه جدا جدا بطريقة د. شارل وكانت ساعات التاريخ معه من أجمل مراحل الثانوي في الثمانينيات رغم كل الظروف التاريخية البشعة والاغتيالات واجتياح إسرائيل لبيروت.. كنا نعيش تاريخ أسود بكل معنى الكلمة

[@faisalasmar8914]

One of your best episodes. Charles did really well. Keep it up.

[@familyinsy]

حلقة رائعة وتوصيف دقيق للتاريخ والواقع. شكراً لكم

[@ritamilan3158]

This is the 5th time i watch this episode and i can't get enough!

[@randafarhat7635]

شكراً على ساعتين كلهن متعة وثقافة ووعي . ايصال هيك افكار هو فعل ثوري متل ما شغل شارل حايك مع March كمان فعل ثوري . بداية كتير موفقة للموسم الثاني . برافو

[@smileforhiba]

please keep inviting Charles to the podcast! I'm learning so much about Lebanon

[@majdal-halabi3711]

شو هالسردة الرائعة ❤️ شكرا الكن و شكرا ل شارل طريقة حكيو و تفاعلو و البناء الي بيبني فيه الموضوع و خط سيرو بالتاريخ ممتع جدا و سلس 👌🏻

[@anfalarkan5905]

I learned a lot of things during these two episodes. Thank you for bringing him and for asking smart questions💙

[@AlanaI-t3e]

نسمعكم من السعودية 🇸🇦❤️

[@bumaye6982]

🌹

[@lucifer9880]

We have many lebanese here in lebanon from al-saigh family!

[@BlavvvckBlvck]

❤️

[@Ligneverte-xz1nx]

شارل، بمناسبة الحديث عن الفساد الإداري د، كيف بليلة وضحاها انتقلت من مدرس بثانوية، لمدرس بالجامعة الأمريكية؟ وكيف قبلت ووين المبادئ اللي حكيت عنا؟

[@lamarerobinson4209]

At minute 28:40 and I have to stop and say Thank You to Médéa and Mouin for having Charles Al-Hayek back on Sarde. He is a national treasure. Un. Be. Lievable. Ok, back to podcast! Thank you! Wow -- the voice of women and children in the history of Lebanon. I wish this were a whole discussion in itself.

[@wajedel-halabi3610]

Incredibly insightful, love it! Very few people talk about just how much we've lost of our culture, it's so nice to see that people still care❤️

[@jumamajumana4141]

من اجمل الحلقات ...حضرتها شي ٢٠ مرة و لا زلت ....

[@f.musterman5441]

سردة شكراً كتير علاستضافة الحلوة لشارل....هاد الفكر المختلف اللي الناس لازم تطلع عليه ... متابعكم من ألمانيا

[@omchesty]

عنجد انا مبهور بأستاذ شارل وكتير كتير هو ثروة ثقافية عنجد best platform sareede thank you

[@abboudshaheed6483]

شكرا للدكتور شارل. الكلام عن المجاعة خلال القرن الماضي مؤلم جدا. ولكنه يمكن ان يفسر سبب الكثير من سلوكيات آبائنا وأجدادنا الذين انتقلت التروما لهم. نحن بحاجة لحلقات أكثر مع هذا الرجل

[@msa590]

re-watching favourite episodes whilst the show is on break. what a wonderful year of episode 🧡🧡🧡

[@adamk2473]

عفكرة سردة هو الشي الوحيد يلي بينشاف عليوتيوب هلايام

[@YSharony]

حلقة فوق الممتازة، شكرًا من مصر

[@hadmostafa]

#Charles انت شخص رائع يعني حكيك بياخدنا لهداك الزمن وبنعيشة لحظة بلحظة بتشكرك كتيرررر وياريت نشوف كمان حلقات معك ببرنامج سردة #شكرا معين وشكرا ميديا ❤💐

[@danielh8437]

watching as much as i could before i move to Liberia (worse than here). i love where this is going. you have me long term

[@moatazmattar4714]

Much love from Egypt 🇪🇬. I love listening to Charles hayek

[@moatazmattar4714]

@@abbefolkseger6927 👏 👏 👏

[@heshamhallak3894]

حلقة رائعة فعلا ....شارل حايك احييك من سوريا على مجهودك و مقاربتك للتاريخ

[@samirarafat7491]

شخص رائع بكل ما تعنيه الكلمة. هذه هي العقلية الثقافة التي نحن بأمس الحاجة لها للنهوض. شكرا لكم على هذه الحلقة

[@awwad70]

تحيه لكم تحيه لشارل على موضوعيتك وصدقك في سرد التاريخ اللبناني بتجرد

[@Unknownbx11]

Brilliant content, work and efforts. Thank you very much for the great Sardes with care to details and respect to the audience. Much love.

[@patrickaoun6661]

​J'aprécie énormement la presentation de M. Charles...c'est vraiment la meilleur façon d'explorer notre histoire. bravo

[@LibnanArz]

Nice to see returning guests.

[@ramihalaoui6809]

ما اروع ضيفكم العزيز…كل الشكر

[@samirariss6017]

شكرا جزيلا على هاذه السردية. لم اكن اعلم اهمية التاريخ لنتعلم من الماضي لايجاد الحلول.

[@bellebelle9956]

Thank You. Emission tres enrichissante.

[@Watcher6868]

من اروع الحلقات ( السردات). شكرا. الشكر ايضا للضيف الكريم (موسوعة تاريخ وحاضر)

[@ibrahimhajj2841]

Learned a lot, one of the few interviews where the guest talks much more than the hosts :) good idea for bringing him back.

[@FlyingDoormat]

Love from Haifa 💜🤍 🇵🇸

[@omarabdulrahman4335]

بحب أسلوب الأخ شارل مميز ويفوت دغري للنفس، ومحفوف بالتعقل والثورة على التاريخ السائد.

[@nabilsater]

I really enjoy these discussions. You guys are doing an awesome job.

[@SFranny]

I'm floored by your podcasts. Thank you so much. 💓

[@bgasmi2260]

Best podcast ever

[@mayebkar]

تحيه من الكويت برنامج في منتهي الروعه وضيوف محترمين وصادقين الف تحيه للبنان الجريح

[@hounaidaabdulkader3658]

سردة تفوقت على نفسها.... حلقة بديعة بكل المقاييس.... ربنا يبارك بعلمك ومعرفتك وثقافتك يا د. شارل 💙💚💛🧡💜💖❤

[@sos75]

👀

[@hounaidaabdulkader3658]

@@sos75 سامر سلامة... لاحقني عالدعسة🤗🤗

[@bpeet315]

Moukhifin, when I watch you guys it's as if I'm with you at the table and included in the conversation. Keep up the great work!

[@truth2910]

I'll have hope if this video reaches at least 1 million views. I'm aware that there's no electricity and that the internet is awful in Lebanon but still I think Sarde After Dinner are underrated....

[@Htch232]

سردة احلى سردة ياريت كل اللبنانية بيسردو ويطلعو من من اللي هم فيه ويفوتو على لبنان ومحيطه العربي ويمسحو الطائفية حتى يحترمنا كل الناس

[@ranihmahdy4990]

يا اخي احبك يا استاذ شارل محسيت بالحلقة ولا بالوقت نهائيا .......و يا فرحتي من عرفت انو حلقة اليوم حتكون معك 💗💕💕💕

[@nazihsafieddine1574]

To comment on this Sarde, in one word .....OUTSTANDING. Very well explained indeed. I hope that every Lebanese will listen and learn from it. You mentioned the word "Nawloon" meaning a travelers ticket at the beginning, a word I heard over 50 years ago, it amazed me how you discovered this word. Well done and thank you. Thumbs UP Dr. Charles.

[@husamjob9543]

وانا عالطريق عالشغل وعم اتسمع عالحلقة لايف فظييييييييييع هاد الانسان فظييييييييع 💐💐💐💐🙆🏽‍♂️ استمر يا معلم يا حايك

[@bahjt]

حلقة رائعة . يا ريت لو نقدر نسمع عن تاريخ سوريا و لبنان المشترك

[@arasm.o8950]

لبنان لسوريا . . . . . . . . . . . . . . وسوريا للبنان

[@mak7033]

لبنان ما كان لسوريا لأن لا لبنان كان لبنان ولا سوريا سوريا.. هيدي اوهام سياسية لتبرر اطماع النظام بلبنان بتشبه الأوهام الطائفية لنظامنا.. ما بيسوى نكون شعبين جارين علاقتن جيدة و بيشتركوا بكتير ثقافات وتراث وعادات؟

[@helagn3931]

It's 2AM and i couldn't sleep. but i got you guys (and food!) to keep me company. Merci d'exister and glad u're back. love from Tunisia

[@sardeafterdinner]

sahtein!! glad to be back!

[@rmaroun]

All great guests, but the most informative remains Charles and Dr Najat - glad to see Charles back on the show and I'm sure no one will complain if it becomes a regular segment 😄

[@miketlais6497]

Charles Hayek is a very smart guy. He makes history very entertaining. Many Thanks!

[@sardeafterdinner]

You’re normal

[@mohamedelbayoumi7761]

When education meets the understanding. And when potential meets talent. You get this. A great episode as usual. Amazing start for season 2. ❤️💋

[@MK-xc6iv]

♥️♥️♥️♥️ Love you guys. I was never a fan of history in school, but your guest sure changed my perspective ☺ From Kfarnabrakh here!! 😅

[@SultanCR7RM]

رجعوا شارل من جديد صرت من محبيه وتحيه للطرابلسيه 🇸🇦

[@motasemazzeh1450]

enjoying the history talk from Jordan , keep up the good work

[@zingw]

سردة شكرا الكن انو عرفتوني عشارل حايك . تعرفت عليه من الحلقة معكم باول موسم و من وقتها لهلق ما بقفيلو فيديو . عنجد رائعين .

[@springbleik]

Amazing, insightful, entertaining, intellectually stimulating. Keep it up, guys.

[@hashemqatawneh5351]

Greetings from Jordan ❤ Great episode We want more of his amazing talks about the history of our REGION 🙏

[@RegenmeisterMo]

Top quality guest and topic

[@mutasemzi]

سردة ممتعة جداً مع شارلز ولايك ل إهدا✌️، شكراً سردة

[@TheAbia48]

ممتاز! أن نطلع على التاريخ من وجهة نظر متطورة صادقة وجدلية تحية شارل الحايك

[@ahf554]

The talking of guy is so attarctive, its like I am watching a well made movie .. not only this, he adds a lot of value via his ideas.. one of the best guests of this broadcast

[@JpK-pf6tl]

This one of, or even the best interview I ever watched...very interesting and engaging.

[@zuhairth]

excellent....I will watch again

[@hadeera.ghareeb8032]

Wow, This guy is awesome, Super enjoying this. I am an Egyptian.

[@olas.867]

I guess our schools should play this episode in class on the first day of school, and every mom and dad MUST gather their kids and classmates to watch it

[@sebouhtorikian1735]

SO HAPPY YOU GUYS ARE BACK! This season i will be watching you from Yerevan 🇦🇲 I still haven’t caught up with all the episodes from the previous season but looking forward for the new ones.

[@sardeafterdinner]

We’re happy tooo

[@mrnchediac6292]

Waiting for the interesting sardeh with Mr. Hayek coz the first episode was so good and interesting Good luck in this new one

[@haidersaaby5935]

What a beautiful sarde, eye opening, engaging and informative! Thank you!