Charles Edward Stuart - Bonnie Prince Charlie after the battle of CULLODEN

Charles Edward Stuart - Bonnie Prince Charlie after CULLODEN: Charles Edward Louis Philip Casimir Stuart was born on 31 December 1720 in Rome and died in Italy on 31 January 1788. He was the son of James Francis Edward Stuart, the exiled pretender to the throne of Great Britain, and the Polish Princess Maria Clementina Sobieska. He gained fame as Bonnie Prince Charlie after his attempted invasion of Britain.
Music from musopen.org/:
A. Vivaldi - Concerto in A Minor, Op. 3_6 L'Estro Armonico
This work has been identified as being free of known restrictions under copyright law, including all related and neighboring rights

[@cerberus6654]

Here's an interesting piece of trivia... The Duke of Cumberland behaved with such savage brutality in the days following Culloden that he earned the nickname 'Butcher'. The day after the battle he supervised, personally, the killing of wounded Highlanders lying on the field. At one point his group came upon a wounded Scottish officer, a man of 'quality' and Cumberland ordered a young British officer to kill him. The British officer replied - to a general and a prince - that he "was an officer, not an executioner" and refused the order absolutely. That officer was James Wolfe, who became General Wolfe and who defeated the French outside of Québec in the Conquest, and died at the moment of victory.

[@TheKingsofFrance]

Very cool ! Thank you so much for sharing that with us !

[@plamenivanov92]

His other nicknames are Sweet William and Martial boy

[@doloresmurphy9761]

Wow! Thank you for sharing. Incredible

[@knutclau705]

Little known fact, in 1745/46 the hessians (hessen-cassel) sent 6000 soldiers to aid the british forces in suppressing the jacobite rebellion. The then heir to the Landgraf, Frederick ll (often confused with KING Frederick ll of Prussia) violently refused Cumberlands orders of carrying out "scorched earths" politics (he was safe from princely wrath, being his cousin, unlike Cumberlands officers) and gained the respect of highlanders (jacobites and loyalists), this being very much to his catholic creed and being amongst the "age of enlightenment" figureheads in europe at that time, later he was scathed for renting out his soldiers to fight the american tax-evaders and slave owners Whashington, Jefferson and Franklin, whilst only allying with Britain against France and Austria in a treaty of protestant powers (remember, he hself was a catholic!) against a catholic power block (catholic France and Spain allied with the protestant colonies!) But then, history is written by the victors... 😅

[@annfisher3316]

How interesting he spoke Gaelic, one rarely hears of this ability with royals. Your channel always gives gems of trivia. Thank you! ✌

[@TheKingsofFrance]

Glad you get so much out of it, makes me happy !

[@vishnukanagalingam1991]

The House of Stuart is very interesting. From being a Scottish noble family to becoming rulers of Scotland, England and Ireland and eventually becoming pretenders to the British throne. Thank you so much for making this video.

[@TheKingsofFrance]

Thank you for being here again Vishnu !!

[@christinemiller8158]

Many of his Scottish followers escaped to the American colonies after Culloden and played a crucial role in the American Revolution. Merci 🌸♥️!

[@TheKingsofFrance]

Thank you for sharing that additional information Christine !

[@robertpizor577]

I think it's a fascinating "what if" of history if Bonnie Prince Charlie won the Jacobite Uprising. There are so many variables: without the Hanoverians in charge maybe Parliament would have been forced to accept concessions under a new Stuart monarchy, or Charles proves so inept that the UK goes to Republican rule having run out of Protestant royal houses. Endless possibilities abound! Thanks for drawing attention to this fascinating time in history.

[@TheKingsofFrance]

I guess that's the thing with history, there are so many 'what ifs' ...

[@humboldthammer]

The Jacobites may as well be called the Jesuits as they continue to pursue the reversal of the Protestant Reformation and a return to the Absolute Authority of the Pope and the Divine Rights of Kings. The Republican CHURCH became the synagogue of Satan -- Revelation 3: 9. Epochal Eclipse April 8th 2024. Matthew 16: 4 Jonah 3: 4-5, 8 Jonah 4: 11

[@williamknox9087]

Here's an interesting piece of alcohol trivia... The "Rusty Nail," a drink popularized in the 1960s by the "Rat Pack" (Frank Sinatra, Dean Martin, Sammy Davis, Jr.), is a mix of Scotch whiskey and Drambuie (typically 2:1). According to legend: "The story of Drambuie began in 1745 when it arrived on British shores under the guardianship of its original custodian, Prince Charles Edward Stuart (known as Bonnie Prince Charlie). It was the Prince’s personal draft, and he drank a few drops each day for strength and vitality. *** Pursued by the King’s men [following Culloden] he fled to The Isle of Skye. After a period of exile on the island his pursuers caught up with him and his fate lay with the Clan MacKinnon who bravely helped the Prince escape the British Isles for good. In thanks for his unwavering loyalty the Prince gave John MacKinnon, the clan leader, the secret recipe to his personal liqueur, a gift that the Clan were to treasure down the generations." Slàinte, mes amis.

[@rncine]

@ William Knox, thanks for your Drambuie history, always loved this liqueur. It was our favorite drink at the University ☺️

[@TheKingsofFrance]

Thanks for sharing that, very cool !!

[@lilyofthevalley5586]

I loved Charlie's story. When I lived in Scotland, I visited Falkland Palace which was the Stewarts Home. Always thought his story was interesting. Thank you.

[@TheKingsofFrance]

Thanks Lily, glad you like my 'non Bourbon' content as well !

[@robertdudley4017]

Thank you Nieke, for the insight of bonnie Prince Charlie's life flora Mcdonald certainly saved his life and helped him to eventually return to France.

[@TheKingsofFrance]

Thank YOU for watching Robert, was nice seeing you at Jon's livestream btw !!

[@robertdudley4017]

@@TheKingsofFrance morning Nieke, always a plesure to view and comment on your superb chanel, lovely to see you on Jon's chanel as I know you were tired.

[@historyfoxy5278]

What an awesome end to the day, watching your video! Great work! 🎉

[@TheKingsofFrance]

Glad you liked it, we should set up a meeting some day soon to discuss upcoming projects...

[@lynseybowe8693]

Thank you for sharing his story! This era of history is my favorite.

[@TheKingsofFrance]

Thank you so much for watching !

[@kevinh.7994]

Fun fact: Charlotte of the Palitinate had a better claim to the English throne after the Acts of Settlement, but she had converted to Catholicism making her aunt, Sophia of Hanover the next in line

[@TheKingsofFrance]

Thanks for sharing that information with us Kevin !!

[@johndorilag4129]

​@@dalesmith2987huh

[@katerynavolkova-shapovalen995]

And ... he was right and rightful. I was and I am always keen on this line of the family. Actually, I am for them! It’s SO sad that the Jacobites lost(. Thank you very much for this informative and interesting presentation!

[@TheKingsofFrance]

Thank you so much for watching and commenting !

[@leticiagarcia9025]

Thank you for giving us a look into Bonnie Prince Charlie. Have a great day.

[@TheKingsofFrance]

Thank YOU for watching !

[@Alusnovalotus]

I wonder why he didn’t start with the conquest of Ireland first. That would be a good Catholic base between France and England. Then try to turn the Scottish and the Welsh against England and have a two front invasion.

[@TheKingsofFrance]

Thanks so much for watching again !

[@janedee6488]

Thanks for the video!

[@TheKingsofFrance]

Thank you for watching again Jane, much appreciated !

[@jec1ny]

Some of my ancestors were jacobites. One of them served James II/VII at the Battle of the Boyne and followed him into exile where he died in poverty many years later.

[@TheKingsofFrance]

Have you visited the Culloden site ?

[@jec1ny]

@@TheKingsofFrance I have not. It's on my list of places I would like to visit one day. Perhaps after some normalcy returns to the world.

[@camilaaramburu2846]

Just wanted to say I love your videos, how they are made and I appreciate the effort put into them. You also have a lovely speaking voice! Keep at it !

[@TheKingsofFrance]

Thank you so much Camila, I really appreciate your kind words !

[@plamenivanov92]

It was actually Sweet William (William Augustus Duke of Cumberland)'s birthday one day before the battle of Culloden. Charlie hoped that the British soldiers would be drunk, but William Augustus, promised his soldiers he would celebrate after the battle. So during the battle the Royalist soldiers were sober. Charlie wanted to initiate a night attack before the battle but the soldiers practically got lost. When they finaly began the battle, Charlie's soldiers were tired and deprived of sleep and the royalist soldiers were fresh and battle ready.

[@plamenivanov92]

His father was known as The Old pretender

[@paulkoza8652]

Thanks. I wondered what happened to Bonnie Prince Charlie. Now I know.

[@TheKingsofFrance]

Thanks for watching again Paul !

[@latifamiah5742]

Awesome!

[@TheKingsofFrance]

Thank you so much hun !! 😘

[@happycake2234]

Oh, thank you. I've been on a bit of a Jacobite rush the last few days.😅

[@TheKingsofFrance]

Glad you liked it !

[@TheEggmaniac]

I sometimes think that the Stewart dynasty ( House of Stewart also know as Stuart) who had been deposed as the kings of Scotland and England, just used the Scots, particularly the highlanders for their own ends. The Stuarts, under Bonnie Prince Charlie, ultimate goal, was the crown of England. They saw the highlanders as a way back into power, in Britain. So they could hopefully take back the crown of Scotland and England. I dont think they really cared much about the Gaelic highlander culture. When the rebellion they started, was over, Bonnie Prince Charlie escaped to France. He then lived out the rest of his life in a very comfortable existence in other countries such as France and Italy. While the defeated highlanders were left devastated and their culture destroyed, by the victorious British forces. Many of the defeated highlanders including their families were murdered, or forced to flee. Some immigrating overseas. The rebellion was a much greater risk for the Scottish highlanders to take, than wealthy aristocrats like Bonnie Prince Charlie. It seems it was a clash between the two aristocratic dynasties of the Stuarts and Hanoverian contenders, for the crown and so the rule of Britain. Where the generally, average and unwealthy people of a country are just used as disposable pawns in their game and left to pay the price.

[@andromeda331]

Another great video! Thank you! I wonder how different things would have been if the Stuarts remained on the throne?

[@TheKingsofFrance]

Thank you so much for watching again !

[@plamenivanov92]

Clan McDonald's motto was "By sea or by land"Clan Douglas (the clan of Archibald Douglas Earl of Angus)'s motto was "Tender and True" Clan Wallace (William Wallace's family) motto was "For Liberty "

[@michellebruce5092]

Awesome live video I enjoyed it. Could you do Casanova. He was an incredible person in history. Have a great day 👍😀

[@TheKingsofFrance]

That's a very good suggestion ! Thank you !

[@williamknox9087]

And after having a few Rusty Nails, you can sing along to one of the many fine Jacobite songs available on KZbin, such as Welcome Royal Charlie. Just be sure to have tissue on hand.

[@TheKingsofFrance]

Oh now I'm curious. Must look those up !

[@williamknox9087]

@@TheKingsofFrance My favorite Jacobite songs are on the Ex Cathedra channel (Welcome Royal Charlie; The Wee German Lairdie; Wha'll be King but Cherlie?) There are also a number of songs celebrating the French monarchy. Vive Henri IV is fun, but if I had to pick a favorite, it would be De notre jeune Roi in honor of Louis XVII. To me it is the more poignant because of the tragic circumstances of the young king's life and because Louis XVII was the subject of your first video. Musically, the melody or tune is the same one used in other anthems such as God Save the Queen (United Kingdom), My Country, 'Tis of Thee (United States), and Grand Dieu Sauve le Roi (France). The melody has been ascribed to Lully, but this not seem at all certain to me.

[@plamenivanov92]

when he was in exile whit his brother Chares II James II Charlie`s grandfather was a soldier under the comand of Turenne

[@plamenivanov92]

Prince William Duke of Cumberland had a couple of nicknames The Butcher Sweet William and Martial boy

[@antongerber7370]

Hi, thank you, great channel. Do you have information on King Hugh Capet? Many thanks, regards.

[@TheKingsofFrance]

Hi Anton, thank you for watching and commenting. I haven't done anything on Hugo Capet yet, but eventually I will be getting to him as I'm slowly working my way back when it comes to the French kings.

[@davidmajer3652]

This excellent video is the inspiration to imbibing in a snifter of Drambuie. To Bonnie Prince Charlie.

[@TheKingsofFrance]

Thanks David !

[@plamenivanov92]

his exact name is Charles Edward Louis John Casimir Sylvester Severino Maria Steward his brother`s full name is Henry Benedict Thomas Edward Maria Clement Francis Xavier

[@plamenivanov92]

Prince William Duke of Cumberland`s birth name was William Augustus

[@reniasva]

Repeating myself: well done!

[@TheKingsofFrance]

Thank you so much for watching again !

[@reniasva]

@@TheKingsofFrance I always will!

[@seastorm1979]

What a shame that the phonograph came later, it would be interesting to hear his voice

[@ingrid118]

❤️❤️❤️

[@TheKingsofFrance]

thank you so much Ingrid !

[@mimfi]

Oh, the Stuarts. Not a fan because of the happenings between Maria Stuart and Elizabeth I. I remember a song about Bonnie Prince Charlie taken by rowboat to Skye. I thought he was a child then. And I thought he was going to Sky=Heaven. In Finland we say "taivas", meaning both sky and heaven.

[@TheKingsofFrance]

Thanks for sharing that additional information Maarit !

[@winnienguyen4420]

I think had he tried hard enough he could have at the very least become king of Ireland.

[@TheKingsofFrance]

Thanks for watching again Winnie !!

[@fredii2810]

Could you do one on Elisabeth Farnese please ? ☺️☺️☺️

[@TheKingsofFrance]

Elisabeth Farnese is scheduled for April 30th !

[@fredii2810]

@@TheKingsofFrance omg thank you so much 🙏🙏🙏 sorry if I insisted so much 😅😅

[@amyjones8114]

Ranald MacDonald. giggle

[@TheKingsofFrance]

Not to be confused with a certain clown...

[@plamenivanov92]

@@TheKingsofFrance Ranald and Flora McDonald what's the connection between them

[@martyrea79]

@@plamenivanov92 none, just a very common Scottish Highland name.

[@knutclau705]

Addenda: the '45 was actually the fourth rising! 1689, 1715, 1719 and 1745...

[@lindenmanmax]

The Jacobites are so well known and beloved in the English-speaking world that I sometimes get a little salty on behalf of other armed reactionary movements, like the Vendeens and the Spanish Carlists.

[@TheKingsofFrance]

Thank you for sharing your thoughts on this matter with us.

[@Donalyn30]

HEY There !.. Havent seen you in Chat lately!..Just wanted to make sure your okay.. You know where to find me.. Hope to talk soon!.

[@TheKingsofFrance]

Heyyy ❤️❤️❤️… yeah i’m good. I forgot my password lol. I went to HD but no one was there… will try to get ahold of someone this weekend !!!! How are you ???

[@Donalyn30]

@@TheKingsofFrance I am good!!.. You were mentioned today.. and I wanted to reach out and make sure you were okay. "you know who" and I aren't talking anymore , but it is what it is.. A owner, had asked me about the time i mistakenly told you to FO.. lol.. asking me if I had been serious about it .. and im like NOOOOOOOOOOOO, not at all..lol MAN, taht was horrible.. i can't believe i messed up, like that.. I couldn't apologize enough for that.. in Fact.. i recently told " you know who".. to FO , for real... she ghosted me too many damn times.. for reasons ive never come to know about.

[@TheKingsofFrance]

@@Donalyn30 i’ll definitely try to get a hold of someone, seems like we need to catch up for sure !! Will probably be Sunday though… have lots planned for tomorrow cuz I’m busy here as you can see lol !

[@Donalyn30]

@@TheKingsofFrance OK, chat soon!

[@plamenivanov92]

It was considered Charlie's father James Francis Edward should marry Louise Adelaide the daughter of Monseiur Le Regent but it did not materialize

[@fredii2810]

🤗🤗

[@TheKingsofFrance]

Thank you for watching again, Madame...

[@caledoniantours220]

The Jacobite were fighting the government, not the English.

[@TheKingsofFrance]

Thanks for watching.

[@markherron1407]

I found out that James Francis Edward Stuart and his son Charles Edward Stuart ARE BLACK 🖤 Blessings and Hugs 💖💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕!

[@TheKingsofFrance]

Thanks very much for watching and commenting Mark !

[@badassunicorn5351]

I did not like how the show made him out to be a bit of a moron. Love love love your videos!❤️

[@TheKingsofFrance]

Thank you so so much.