Charles Is Alive! | Brothers Theory Productions

[@BrotherTheory]

I quickly wanted to say: Thank you so much for over 100 subscribers :) You truly are amazing people. And in case you are not subscribed yet, please do because we have some awesome theories coming soon :) I thank you guys so much and I’ll see you guys in the next theory ;)

[@emilysanchez4584]

Hi! I was wondering what your theory would be for the next marvel phase as well as your opinion on how Disney could re-open the Skywalker saga (if they ever did)?

[@notbean_]

Hello

[@notbean_]

Yes

[@gabrielweyten2816]

Hi, you know you're almost at 400 subs right

[@gabrielweyten2816]

300 subs in a month👍👍👍

[@Jawmax]

The ship also had a transporter but given Henry's luck with the teleporter odds of that working are about 50/50.

[@BrotherTheory]

That's BRILLIANT, James :)

[@ramusproductions3072]

You’re goddamn right.

[@gamerboyx7450]

No more like 10%

[@allowcoy0413]

Maybe Charles has better luck?

[@wiseraccoon1822]

Charles has a 💯 record in my book I mean he's never failed

[@IguanodonMan]

I remember this like it was yesterday...

[@BrotherTheory]

Don't worry, Henry :) I know Charles is alive :)

[@IguanodonMan]

@@BrotherTheory but this is just a theory.. and I'm still depressed

[@acon70]

@@IguanodonMan At least you are almost done grieving. Only like a stage or two left.

[@ramusproductions3072]

Just go to a different ending like ‘Triple Threat’ or ‘Special Brovert Ops’ or something.

[@pondbrothers806]

@@IguanodonMan Look, I don’t see any way him being alive can work, in your world and mine. Sorry, Henry. He’s gone.

[@FalIenHero]

Me: Sees Video Title Also Me: Don't do that, Don't give me hope

[@BrotherTheory]

Valliant Hero Ending: *I am inevitable :)*

[@chem3615]

@@BrotherTheory the escape pod inside the blocked entrance: and i *breaths* am *breaths* IRON MAN

[@heftyrumble]

That was exactly me

[@timxg]

@@katieminett6807 spit it out. Also it’s not yheory it’s theory

[@unocard1]

I couldn't get in the space machine because it was damaged

[@noahbueno2168]

But if Charles is probably still alive.. how come he didn’t return to the military base, also I really doubt he could escape all like that within seconds especially when he said “Gotta be another escape pod around here somewhere” indicating he was still on the spaceport. So he’s actually dead

[@alexplaysandedits2356]

Charles could be Lost and not return because he's Lost, not finding his way home, being presumed dead until found. He could be floating in space tough

[@haydenmaskell8522]

How did Henry get his headphones?

[@marvelous4729]

@@haydenmaskell8522 OMG THATS TRUE

[@nintendoboy3605]

@@marvelous4729 I think Charles has more than one pair of headphones

[@noahbueno2168]

Hayden Maskell Puffballs confirmedin a livestream that, it was just a headset, it wasn’t cracked

[@octolink6488]

Henry: *sitting in his room* Charles: oh hey Henry Henry: *complete silence Charles: what? Henry: HOW THE IN THE WORKD ARE YOU STILL ALIVE Charles: I used the pod next to you Henry: (._.) Charles: what you thought I was dead Henry: you made need to try to get your job back

[@BrotherTheory]

I love your comment, Octo Link. You deserve a heart :)

[@andrewmireles6003]

@@BrotherTheory you get a heart to

[@kittikatwaffles]

If he used the escape pod why did the radio shut off

[@calvinposumah6474]

Lol oof

[@afshanzareen7858]

@@kittikatwaffles he was still very close to the space station when it exploded, so chances are that he got knocked out, therefore cutting him off. The pod was designed to get through Earth's atmosphere though, so it wouldn't have been as damaged.

[@praveenvijeyakumar741]

You gotta let go of Charles man. It's what he'd want.

[@gabrielweyten2816]

It could be true

[@gabrielweyten2816]

Not bad theory

[@BrotherTheory]

Maybe you are right, but... :)

[@d4TheViewer]

@@BrotherTheory never!

[@gabrielweyten2816]

You've got a lot of work with the comments now. But it's worth it (:

[@Funcrashmalej]

Hey just a reminder: behind the blocked wall there was another escape pod, maybe he was able to squeeze through the broken wall and use that pod to escape.

[@BrotherTheory]

That's very possible, Tilen Malej. He is a stickman after all :)

[@Funcrashmalej]

@@evilartise8912 yup

[@neldariver2660]

That’s impossible there’s no way there’s another pod there because it shows when the pod launch is out there’s nothing there 0:58

[@neldariver2660]

It’s there but it doesn’t work

[@SGimystx]

The one in 2:06 ? Ye very possible

[@pugsriel]

The text box actually finishes his line, so there’s your proof. *cries in the corner*

[@BrotherTheory]

I love your comment, Pugsriel the Sticker :)

[@soildier]

They finished it so you knew what he said, they do that other times too.

[@emilypaterson8182]

@[TSA]canal mais variado/ most random channel exactly, normally its inteupted, but Charles' was not... meaning he somehow found an escape pod to go in, got inside of it, got it ready, talked to Henry before he was intrupted by the impact of the escape pod's speed when the explosion occurred. Boom, I rest me case

[@emsiyes]

@@emilypaterson8182 he would've said that he found an escape pod if that happened

[@emilypaterson8182]

@@emsiyes excellent point my lad! But there could be a possibility, I'm sure we had games where two characters split up and even tho one of them found 'something' they may or may not say they found a way out... u know what I mean? If not its ok, I 100% get and understand ur point!

[@MortarlWolf]

My theory is Charles use the 5th escape pod in the escape pod room and if you see very close to the launched escape pods you will see 5 escape pods! And in the escape pod room you will see there is a 5th escape pod in the wooden planks!! So, I think my theory is right?

[@MortarlWolf]

If my theory is right like this comment!!!

[@BrotherTheory]

Your theory is AWESOME, Motarl Wolf. I think you are BRILLIANT :) You deserve a heart ;)

[@MortarlWolf]

@@BrotherTheory thanks!

[@Quandalee897]

Oh I thought there were 4 but there was 5 The first pod has launched The second pod has alot of toppats The third one is clear The fourth one has a dude inside it The fifth one is covered by wood

[@waltuhligma]

Yeah and his headphones arent broken on his grave

[@nathans_codes]

Here I have two theories as of why Charles stopped communicating with Henry: Nr1: Charles used the Toppat Station to communicate with Henry, because he's in an escape pod of the Toppat Station, and of course, the Station got destroyed. Nr2: The Comms relay of Chares's Spaceship got damaged because of the shockwave that came from the Explosion, so he couldn't communicate with Henry anymore

[@nathans_codes]

I'm proud of myself that I came up with this

[@kkidude8441]

Good job, random guy on the internet.

[@floseatyard8063]

@@nathans_codes Nr1 is a good point but nr2 is just stupid and poorly thought out. They are in SPACE, there is no shockwave since there is no air. The sound was from the radio right before it got destroyed, if you are wondering how you could hear the boom

[@ellayin0406]

Hes headphones probally got damaged badly, as the station exploded the headphone got extremely bursted badly and flew not able to conumicate with anyone

[@bebepraire4340]

If you look at the escape pods when Charles gets thrown out there is one blocked by rubble. And when the escape pods are going towards earth if you look closely there is one more. Charles is talking to henry before the comms of the ship go out and they are disconnected. So he does survive and he gets back to earth

[@gabrielweyten2816]

They're are four of them

[@stuchy1018]

And I’m confused, he doesn’t have a microphone, nor does henry

[@bebepraire4340]

@@gabrielweyten2816 first of all, its not there are are (they’re is short for there are) and there is 5 total pods. One was already launched, one was the pod for the fancy people, one was empty, and one was full. But at the back there was the lining for another escape pod.

[@bebepraire4340]

@@stuchy1018 i was talking about from Charles’s pod to henry’s pod through an embedded speaker and microphone. They were disconnected because the comms of the ship blew up. I hope I explained it well enough to you.

[@gabrielweyten2816]

@@bebepraire4340 ye I'm 12 years old and I'm from Belgium, I have only one hour english in a week so...

[@JustAPersonWhoComments]

Yes, he found another Escape Pod

[@BrotherTheory]

How do you know that, Henry Stickmin? (I love your name btw :))

[@JustAPersonWhoComments]

@@BrotherTheory it turns out the third escape pod with only 1 toppat member in it, Charles was able to throw him out of the escape pod and launches. Henry thinks the connection was off because of the explosion

[@BrotherTheory]

@@JustAPersonWhoComments Oh that's very interesting :) Still, I hope you enjoyed my theory about how Charles survived :) If you want more Henry Stickmin theories, please let me know :)

[@gabrielweyten2816]

3:02, look good

[@rebeccacummings6697]

That would ruin the whole point of Charles in this mission. He was supposed to sacrifice himself, showing he wasn’t just a goofy character, he would die for Henry and that’s the meaning of the mission. His death was meaningful and if he took an escape pod then I would say this ending is not canon because it would be stupid

[@nglidk]

Plot Twist: Charles is a Crewmate from Among Us now.

[@BrotherTheory]

Charles was The Impostor :)

[@nglidk]

@@BrotherTheory Nah I saw him scan

[@earshotmedia7629]

Ha ha, very clever. :) If you like this, I should recommend both "Shameless Self-Promotion" and "Put in the work you viewer-scalping Losers" as two channels I think you would enjoy. Please don't mind as I just casually repost this comment about 500 more times elsewhere in this video's comments, it's totally cool because these are #notmychannels.

[@therealtime34]

@@earshotmedia7629 just stop

[@earshotmedia7629]

@@therealtime34 Already made my point.

[@Astro12365]

I’ll Remember Charles with all my heart, Charles died in a great way, you will be missed Charles everyone will remember you

[@rikkisieley5162]

Charles IS NOT DEAD!

[@unickh]

@@rikkisieley5162 He is. It's confirmed.

[@ShakylaDenniss1qq]

*holding back tears. I can feel Henry's pain. I lost my grandfather when I was 11. I almost lost it at his service. 😢 You really don't know what you have until it's gone........😢

[@lazuli_lapis2140]

“He couldn’t have used an escape pod” Me: If you look closely there are five escape pods.

[@devonthegamer5368]

When the airpods are going to Earth's atmosphere scene you can see their 6 airpods

[@devonthegamer5368]

So there had to be a hidden Escape pod somewhere so there is a chance that Charles survived

[@kristakennedy1815]

Yeah there are...

[@amirtham5783]

I did see a bunch of escape pods but they were blocked

[@lancer4947]

Yepp

[@Dominos_pizza43]

Charles: im the bold action mann Me: what is wrong with this man and crashing into things

[@kristakennedy1815]

XD

[@TheDogeified]

It’s just his greatest thIIIIIIIING!

[@funnidoritoman]

WHY THE HECK DOES HE CRASH INTO EVERYTHING

[@wiseraccoon1822]

Poor Charles He must hate all the hate for something he has never done

[@vavys1429]

@@funnidoritoman Bin laden hired Charles to crash into the twin towers From there on....

[@cedarcoombs8111]

A couple of things, first, there are more than three escape pods. Second, I dont think all of the top hats have oxygen things in their hats like I am pretty sure that the Right hand man is a higher rank and so maybe only the high ranks got a hat with a oxygen thing because you only see high ranks do stuff with their hats, not other random top hats. Also, the UFO prototype is not indestructible and so could have gotten destroyed. Also, he probably would have said that he could use the bubble before the explosion. Plus, the bubble might be able to survive but if it is only bullet proof then it might of got destroyed too because it was a explosion which is more powerful than a gun.

[@theplushkingdom133]

Henry and ellie's kids: Were you killed? Charles: Sadly yes. but I lived!

[@peterschilling1506]

Evidence against this: Charles cannot move through the vents that quick, he would have to run down the hall, get in, spend a couple seconds crawling in the vents, and the station would have exploded by then. Charles probably did not know about the oxygen breathers, and even if he did, we only see the right hand man use this (there was one other toppat shot into space and he did not use the breather) and not anybody else, which makes sense, because apart from Reginald, he is the most important member of the clan. Someone needs to fire the bubble from the inside of the ship, so he could not have shot himself into the bubble. How would he have gotten back to Earth in the bubble, because it is super slow and he would run out of oxygen, and the spaceship would have been destroyed in the explosion. The last and most definitive piece of evidence is that Puffballs United had the full last words of Charles in the subtitles because he wanted people to remember his last words. Charles is 100% gone. I'm sorry but it's true. We need to let him go.

[@Koloka_exe]

THANK YOU

[@comicalsamaraizac2466]

There's no way charles could think to do this and do it in the 15 seconds he had left so BUSTED

[@StarinSeb]

I agree, I watched the whole video and found multiple flaws to this theory that debunks all of this speculation hard. I know we all love Charles and, much like everyone else here, I would love to see him alive for this ending, but you guys can't seriously believe that this theory is possible, right?! Allow me to explain: 1. We can't just say that Charles would be able to vent as fast as an Imposter from Among Us. In fact, what does Among Us have to do with anything for this theory?! Just because a couple of the sound effects and references for this game come from Among Us doesn't mean that these two games are going to follow the exact same logic! Anyways, when Charles and Henry first went through the vent, we got an audio cue that they were clearly taking a bit of time to get from one end to the other. So what makes you think that Charles would be any faster here? 2. One thing that I think many people are forgetting is that, after Charles and Henry run out of the area where the spaceship's core is, A DOOR SHUTS BEHIND THEM!!! And that door is going to remain quite shut since it took both Henry and Charles to lift one of these doors which wasn't even that reinforced, and even there, they both failed to keep it up, so Charles trying to lift one that is more tightly shut alone isn't going to work. The vents wouldn't help Charles either, Charles wouldn't be fast enough, he probaby wouldn't even come out close to where the railing bridge is, and the vents he's using likely don't even connect to the core. 3. Have you seen how high up the spaceship is lodged in the core?! Charles has no ladder or other means of elevation to get him back up there! Even if he did miraculosly get back up somehow, the spaceship is probably not gonna budge or it will be too damaged to do anything. On top of that, do you know how dangerous is would probably be getting close to the inner working of a core that powers an entire space station?! If Charles doesn't die from the explosion, he will certainly die from the core sparking! 4. Now let's say that despite all odds, Charles is able to get in his spaceship safely and have enough time to get out of there with the bubble plan, he would need the spaceship to have no gravity at all to float assumably out the small hole his spaceship made coming in and a clear shot to launch it. The core room by this point should clearly still has oxygen and gravity inside, so the bubble would likely just fall after being launched, and getting inside that thing alone would probably be its own ordeal to have to figure out. And for the claim that each Toppat hat has an air mask to breath in, I don't even know if this is true. Probably only Right Hand Man was issued the special honor of having his hat have an air mask installed (as well as the leader), so all the hats having an air mask installed feels a bit iffy to confirm. Bonus: I've seen a lot of comments claiming that Charles could have gotten in one of the pods behind the wall of rubble, but if that's the case, wouldn't they have taken off already, possibly with other Toppat members inside? Also, if Charles got in one, why does he cut off communication with Henry right when the station blows up? And even if Charles made it back, would he have immediately told the Government that his mission was successful or that he survived, but was stranded? Overall, the pod theory doesn't seem likely either. In conclusion, just stop fixating over Charles being alive after the ending of Valiant Hero, the point of him dying is what makes the ending so impactful and unique from others. Go play Triple Threat or Special BROvert Ops if you really want an ending where he lives.

[@comicalsamaraizac2466]

@@StarinSeb good points! also bonus 2 points 1. isnt the bubble fired from in the ufo? if so then how did he fire himself in it 2. would`nt we have seen the bubble? ok to be fair maybe its too far away to see, but then wouldnt we see charles on the earth again? edit: i just found a comment of mine saying "this still doesnt explain how he lost connection so BUSTED" which was one of your points so uh just adding this

[@graceoltmann7782]

You said Charles made it back to his ship but the ship crashed into the reactor and is in a million peases.

[@BrotherTheory]

The ship is indeed useless, but the bubble (that the ship stores) can still be used though. It doesn't have to be launched or something, so Charles just has to get in. Good question though! You are an AWESOME person, Grace :)

[@boyscol6871]

THATS WHAT I SAID I MEAN HE DIDNT KNOW ABOUT THE OXYGEN BREATHER HATS AND HE WOULDNT HAVE ENOUGH TIME TO GET THERE AND THE DOOR WAS LOCKED IF YOU PAYED ATTENTION YOU WOULDVE NOTICE THE DOOR LOCKS BEHIND THEM SO CHARLES IS DEAD DEAD I TELL YOU!

[@Demoonz]

@@boyscol6871 Uh what about the Forth escape pod? there is a fourth Henry enters the second he sees two to his right that means the someone got in it could be Charles

[@v2wooly998]

@@BrotherTheory lets say he actually somehow got in the bubble and every tophat member had an o2 mask (which i do not believe) then he would either be stuck in space in the bubble and die of hunger or thirst or he would fall down to earth and probs die from the impact of hitting the ground also they dont vent that fast as theres a scene of them crawling through a vent very slowly

[@Jujan04]

Actually, when Charles says “gotta be another escape pod somewhere” it indicates he was still on the spacecraft. He only had 7 seconds to find another pod. Since there was obviously no escape pod in sight, and it takes about 3 seconds to get in the pod and escape, that means he has around 4 seconds to find an escape pod. The escape pod would also have to be very far as it’s not visible, so he would have to run towards an escape pod he can’t see. Overall, it’s highly unlikely he’s alive. Plus, if he survived, it kinda ruins the point of the Valiant Hero ending.

[@jeffreylindain3402]

How could charles go back to his ship even he crashed it on the start

[@amongusgamer3306]

Good point

[@fouralgebralian]

Im here

[@bluefreddygaming9025]

You see, itt was only damaged, but not destroyed, he couldn't move the ship but he used the bubble like he said and yea, the rest he explained

[@fouralgebralian]

Well i just fly cuz um actually a robot

[@gabrielweyten2816]

Dude this theory was AWESOME, I subbed (:

[@indiebox2793]

i found this channel from your comment on gtlive superliminal and you just earned yourself a sub :D

[@BrotherTheory]

Thank you so much, IndieBox. You are THE BEST :)

[@Tyfor]

I'm saying this, i dont think all of the Tophat's Hats have the oxygen breather in them. We don't see any proof to support your claim with the tophat hats. Still, its a good theory!

[@BrotherTheory]

I am glad you enjoyed this theory, MaximumGaming. You are THE BEST :)

[@User71537]

3:53 if you look closely you can see there’s actually 4 Escape pods not 3 3:59 and here you can see there’s another escape pod behind the rubble So I believe he beat up the TopHat member that held him off and crawled into the other escape pod and launched himself, and I believe the sound cut because of the loud explosion… That’s my theory

[@JohnMkrv]

I like how you promote your channel the best way and not the annoying way

[@darkendchat7882]

man, you should have atleast 1000 subscribers. super underrated

[@BrotherTheory]

Thank you so much, train go honk. That's so nice of you :) That deserves a heart

[@keyelvisi2948]

Hey, you predicted the future!

[@winz4418]

There's some holes in your theory there. First we can't ignore the fact that it wasn't enough time for Charles, even if he can vent quickly he will still have to go through about 15 seconds to go there, and the time before the space station explode is 16 seconds. You can say that it was a second longer but remember, in order for him to go to his spaceship again and use the bubble would take much longer consider he has to get in first, now let's say he does make it in the bubble but the oxygen hat doesn't make sense, how does Charles knows that the hat from the Toppats provide oxygen, and even if he does, he has to take it before getting in his ship, which will take even more time. That's just my thought about it

[@Table_Down_Left7377]

Also he will die from starvation if he does not do anything

[@iizackgick1329]

That couldn't happen, why? 1. He was roughed up, so it might of been hard for him to crawl. 2. He doesn't vent like in among us, as there is a clip of them crawling for a good 10 seconds. And finally 3. HE RAMMED HIS FREAKING ESCAPE POD INTO THE CORE OF THE SHIP HOW WOULD IT BE INTACT???? If the ship is barely intact its mechanics wouldn't even be able to start up, let alone generate a bulletproof air bubble. (You even said this wouldn't work) Also, another list 1. How would Charles know about the o2 hat? 2. Not every hat has the same thing, as you see, henrys hat has a helicopter blade, Reg has a parachute, and RHM has o2, most normal crewmembers don't have anything special. Also, even you mentioned this again. HE WOULD BE DRIFTING OFF IN SPACE, and just like henry he would be presumed dead, then eventually run out of air and die, apart from the likely chance that he's going towards earth And what I said about the mechanics, also how he BARELY HAS ANY TIME TO GET TO THE SHIP, because of the first's list's number 2. Sorry if I sounded rude, but theory busted. Edit: I saw two things in the comments. 1. The teleporter beam This follows with the broken mechanics, and even if it did work there's a low chance that'll actually reach the earth, and as you saw it seemed to require two people, one for controls, and one who was getting beamed aboard 2. The Covered Escape Pod Even being a stick and all, that pod probably was broken and maybe its glass was fully broken because of all the wood there, (how is there even wood there), and then there's of course the chance where the open button doesn't even work due to being smacked by wood. Edit again: I saw someone say something about seeing more escape pods after the rubble, but again he probably couldn't get past the rubble plus the fact they might be from different pod stations. Edit again again: This isn't meant for hate and it was a good theory, I just got bored and wanted to debunk something so I found this. Edit again again again: Thanks for commenting on my comment, BTP.

[@BrotherTheory]

I love your comment, iiZackgick. You put a lot of effort in your comment and I love that :)

[@iizackgick1329]

@@BrotherTheory Thank You!

[@cheese-and-ricemooney7487]

(I haven't finished watching the video yet so I don't know what his explanation is why he is alive, I'm only giving mine for now before keep watching the whole video) 3:52 Actually, I'm not saying that Charles used one of those, but I counted six of them. One is at the bottom left near the earth. One is at the top left a little higher than the words "Created by", where you see that kind of spiral look a little more towards right and you will see a red dot between the earth and the "Created by". One is under the first L of PUFFBALLS. One (Henry I think) is right after the "by". One is a little it's a little higher than Henry's and towards the right. One is under the word "United". I don't know if Charles really took a spaceship or not, but there are more than 4 spaceships, there are in fact six. Considering how they are positioned, the one closest to the earth took off first of all, then there was the one between the earth and the word "Created by", then there was the one under the L of PUFFBALLS, after that there was Henry, after (again) the one a little higher and farther than Henry and finally the one under the word "United" which clearly "took off" last since it's the only one farthest from the others. I don't know if they are the other criminals or if one of them has Charles inside, but if Charles managed to get a capsule (which I don't know) it would be the one under the word "United" since that we see that it left later, but at the same time it would be impossible because the capsule took off a few seconds after Henry's.

[@BrotherTheory]

Your comment deserves a heart, Tsukasa Yugi :)

[@cheese-and-ricemooney7487]

@@BrotherTheory Thanks for that☺️ I really enjoyed your Theory anyway. Good job!

[@The_SmartyBoi]

He is not dead, he just chilling in the game files

[@benjrobe]

He did survive because there was a button on his earpiece

[@thechillpilllegend41]

True

[@BrotherTheory]

True :)

[@teamsharpened7661]

YES!!!

[@nanaliz7210]

Button?

[@Sylvyron69]

Theory: there were more escape pods on the other side and there a Little Hole and he may had Even Got there in time cuz we saw multiple pods toward earth

[@BrotherTheory]

You are very SMART, Kian Cyril Fernandez :)

[@Healion123]

I'll just say that that 2nd pod we see is likely the one with all the rich Toppats, but I *do* like that idea

[@Demoonz]

@@Healion123 There are four there is one behind the debris and we see four he entered the middle so that would mean hat the one with all the tophats are to the other side while the one is in the third but what about the fourth? It could be someone escaping

[@That1Gal3.141]

YOU GAVE ME HOPE, also now I won't almost cry everytime I see valient hero

[@BrotherTheory]

You are welcome, Jess story :)

[@nanaliz7210]

It's still hurts watching the ending but at least I'm hopeful about him being alive

[@kehnaudreybusmeon8062]

Final tip:the green toppat guy hasn't a oxygen breather only RHM hat

[@standardrobloxian7212]

yeah i dont think every toppat has a built in o2 respirator because rhm is a very high ranking toppat so he would prob have more safety measures to ensure his survival

[@Ofxcial1UP]

Love the video man! I already know you are going to get big!

[@BrotherTheory]

Thanks you :) That's a very nice compliment, Ticzs! :) I hope the channel will become big one day ;)

[@earshotmedia7629]

Ha ha, very clever. :) If you like this, I should recommend both "Shameless Self-Promotion" and "Put in the work you viewer-scalping Losers" as two channels I think you would enjoy. Please don't mind as I just casually repost this comment about 500 more times elsewhere in this video's comments, it's totally cool because these are #notmychannels.

[@SonicBalance]

If you look at the background there are 3 more escape pods ;).

[@BrotherTheory]

That's true! You are BRILLIANT, Maxao :)

[@SonicBalance]

@@BrotherTheory He probably went through the blocked wall somehow to the other escape pods or vented (if there was a vent idk) there :). (and he probably stopped talking sudendly beacuse of the shockwave of the explosion destroyed his headphones).

[@nanaliz7210]

Wait I thought there was only one blocked by the boards

[@Ben_Kimber]

Assuming the station is powered by a nuclear reactor, and that, despite the fact that real nuclear reactors don't explode like atom bombs, this one did, I may have a reason why Charles' radio cuts out mid sentence. Nuclear bombs have an EMP effect when they explode, so it's possible that the radio in his headset was fried when the reactor exploded. That, or we're all just in denial, refusing to accept Charles' death.

[@NkZrd]

i don't think charles is enough smart to think about that

[@BrotherTheory]

This theory is still cool though ;)

[@NkZrd]

@@BrotherTheory yeah

[@buttergutter.]

My theory: you know how Henry went in the middle pod? There is two pods behind his pod meaning that there was another pod or a few more pods. And Charles could have vented to another room where more pods are then BAM last second he got in but here’s the thing he got in LAST SECOND! So his pod went somewhere he wasn’t planing to go and ended up in another state or something but his connection with the government was horrible. And that’s my theory!

[@buttergutter.]

Or maybe I just overthought it

[@BrotherTheory]

I love your theory, Butter Vlogs. You are BRILLIANT :)

[@tomeddsworld1222]

Henry: (presumed dead) Now charels: (now presumed dead) Time: (in a cycle over and over presuming dead)

[@thatoneinkling2513]

What if Charles crawled under the blocked path, found an escape pod, got out of the base, and the impact if the explosion knocked him out...

[@mariyw.4609]

Edit: What if they made another game that was called something like “Retrieving Charles” and this theory was real 😃

[@BrotherTheory]

That's a brilliant idea, mariyw!! I would love to see that :)

[@exi_m7074]

Well, CTM is canonically the last, pretty sure the developers even came out and said that they won’t make another one.

[@aarthritis]

First stage of grief : denial

[@gamersgamestorm8291]

Remember The ship crashed into the exhaust port or whatever that thing is The ship is unusable Charles also thinks the oxygen in there is enough so he would just go to it

[@SlovakDiplomat]

I was thinking something like the HMS Hood

[@BrotherTheory]

That's brilliant, Red October :)

[@SlovakDiplomat]

I believe the blast was more of an emp blast but at the core it was an explosive and split the ship in two. While at the same time pulling tons of g's ripping the solar panel wings off. (not actual wings but something like the white houses wings) After that, there was at least an 5 minute gap before air ran out, (I'm going by the room was sealed) then Charles used the tophat guys mask to breathe, then he went of one of the offsight satellites and used that to get down. He landed somewhere remote and apon landing, he found that his headset broke and couldn't contact hq. He survived till some researchers found the uncharted island and explored the island until finding Charles. All tho he couldn't rejoin the military because of medical reasons.

[@jordyh0463]

Someone on Amoug Us recommended this channel and its really good!

[@BrotherTheory]

Thank you so much :)

[@notbean_]

Your welcome (just kidding)

[@gabrielweyten2816]

I think it's among us, not amoug us

[@Cadensans]

@@gabrielweyten2816 we make spelling mistakes

[@gabrielweyten2816]

@@Cadensans ye

[@mohamadsarwar7997]

one problem: literally everything

[@Jenb13171]

Charles is not alive because his voice cuts when it explodes

[@seekgaming5534]

Also charles voice cut of because his headphones lost connection to henrys earpiece so charles would not finish his line because of that and also the explosion was big and loud thats why so i guess you could say charles presumed dead

[@christianaguinaga1615]

There is indeed more proof of Charles being alive. There is not only 3 pods. There's 5 that you can see. The first three do include the rich toppats, second with Henry, and the third with another member of the toppat clan. But, the last 2 are quite hard to see, but you can see them moving their way to Earth. Not only that, but while we see Charles saving Henry and bringing him back to the escape pod, behind them is a crumbled down parts. But, we can also see a little hole in the corner of that pile. This may show that after Charles defeats Jacked, he climbed through, and got into one of the escape pods we see flying by, AKA one of the two escape pods in the distance. And as for his "last words?" He used his headset, even though it looks busted. And, as soon as the escape pod chuted, the Station exploded, his headset fell out of his head because of the force of the explosion, forcing the headset to make a hard hit and broke. So, you're correct, there is a possibility that he is now presumed dead.

[@BrotherTheory]

You are BRILLIANT, Christian Aguinaga :)

[@christianaguinaga1615]

Thank you very much! =D

[@dümēbÿ3]

The creators confirmed he died let charles rest in peace

[@christianaguinaga1615]

aw :(

[@yourlocalmtf6149]

This is a great escape plane he made Not including ramming his ship into literally everything Thank god hes alive'

[@zeroskilllucas]

if only there would be another game, sadly we won’t get one

[@Milothemighty10]

Maybe puff will change there mind in the future

[@Plazmacool]

says who? its all set up for the next game.

[@Milothemighty10]

@@Plazmacool puff has constantly said completing the mission is the last one but I think if he really means it then hopefully he will change his mind or maybe he’s joking around...

[@Plazmacool]

@@Milothemighty10 yea i know but like i said its all setup. and also since among us and henry stickmin are in the same universe and the airship map for among us is anounced already.. it could mean that something will happen for henry stickmin aswell

[@Milothemighty10]

@@Plazmacool I agree and on top of that no matter how many times puff said there done with these games they always come back but even if they do return to Henry it might not be for a while...

[@jelenabojarova8461]

*...denial is a defense mechanism in which a person, faced with a painful fact, rejects the reality of that fact. They will insist that the fact is not true despite what may be overwhelming and irrefutable evidence* Juan,S. (2006, September 29). Why are people so often in denial?

[@ashtonsmith7352]

As much as I want this to be true, I highly doubt that this theory is actually true, as the creator most likely wanted atleast 1 ending that would break everyones' heart and then looked at Charles.

[@CAndrian01]

DUDE REMEMBER WHEN THE ESCAPED POD WERE SHOWED UP THERE WERE 4 BUT IT WERE 5 THAT MEAN CHARLES USE THE LAST ESCAPED POD THAT GOT BLOCKED OFF I give you proof At 3:03 count the ESCAPED pod an red 5 right?

[@chromatophoresrcool]

Ooooooomg I see it

[@bcollins734]

No.in another fail you saw a large number of toppat members

[@GreySlayz3605]

​@@bcollins734they mean there was one that wasn't in sight, behind the wood, you would see 4 but there's an extra one that Charles probably used.

[@sechespinoso599]

It is not hate, but this theory is easily disproved, remembering that Charles's ship is totally destroyed at the core. What I mean is that apart from being destroyed, all the controls would be broken, including the mechanisms and the bubble, apart from the fact that you realize that to reach the ship you have to climb the core.

[@ThatBackroomsFan]

How would he get to the ship when it’s probably broke and it’s in the core also also when the explosion Sound in the vent happend it could be trying to say some parts of the ship are gone and disconnected in a way

[@jelenabojarova8461]

Even if he did survive,his oxygen would run out and he would die anyways. So, there isn't any possibility for him to survive.

[@noiceqwergppl6571]

Maybe Charles landed somewhere that no one will find him,well...eventually

[@justanotheryoutubeaccount4998]

Imagine just seeing a floating bubble with charles in space...

[@CrackerWhacker1]

How does he go into the bubble anyways if the spaceship is destroyed

[@rupertaborbuboy9157]

Charles Stickmain Really Your real name is Charles CALVIN

[@pondbrothers806]

Sorry, man. It wouldn’t work if he survived. It just can’t. Charles said that the whole fight with Hughman really roughed him up. Plus, he couldn’t make his way to the spacecraft, as it was destroyed and wedged into the main core. He wouldn’t have been able to walk to a vent and crawl through either, because of his condition.

[@raulkyamko6825]

Dude, uncool 😔

[@codybrought5722]

The problem is that Charles was clearly still trying to find a way to escape and was likely using his headphones to communicate. This is proved by him saying, “theres gotta be an escape pod around here somewhere”. He didnt know how he was gonna get out yet and was still in danger, hence why he said “here”. He was in the same room. He dead.

[@Rexy_THE_T-REX]

Nope

[@Robloxlegend-tq1ky]

Something that supports this is that when they crash into the station, Charles microphone is not on the headset as it broke off.

[@Nightt_Lightt]

There is 4 escape pod and you can see it 3:03 2 of them and hard to see and Charles could be in one of theese cause there was 3 optinions (3 escape pods) we could choose but maybe Charles used 4. one (Sorry for bad english)

[@yeboxxx_channel_2505]

I'd like to specify few common facts, we don't vent fast as imposters, the vent was litteraly behind the door where the vent was. Then the fact he said he is looking for escape pods, we can see that the prototype spaceship didn't survive the crash to fully operate and even if it did, it was in height that Charles couldn't reach...

[@gabrielweyten2816]

If u look veeeeery good, you can see 4 escape pods 3:02

[@BrotherTheory]

Wow, you are right :) I didn't see that :)

[@earshotmedia7629]

Ha ha, very clever. :) If you like this, I should recommend both "Shameless Self-Promotion" and "Put in the work you viewer-scalping Losers" as two channels I think you would enjoy. Please don't mind as I just casually repost this comment about 500 more times elsewhere in this video's comments, it's totally cool because these are #notmychannels.

[@legionary3519]

@@earshotmedia7629 Shut up man. You can clearly see the work put into this. He's a small channel, with small editing software and (maybe) skills. Of course it wont look good at first.

[@gabrielweyten2816]

Leave him, we all know he's just a stupid kid

[@rebeccacummings6697]

The 2 other ones in the back are a lot of feet away, you expect me to believe he ran all the way there while talking like he was just sitting there. Umm no because he died.

[@vader1034]

3:53 nope there’s 5 I can see 2 more

[@repecyan2095]

Another theory : in the wood, there is a secret pod so, charles could find it and escape.

[@Max1996YT]

There's one simple fact that dispels this notion entirely, sad as Charles' death was: the alert noise in the background kept blaring all throughout Charles' final dialogue. This *proves* Charles never actually left the spaceship.

[@systemerror6918]

Aw man hes actually ALIVE :') this made my day better...

[@spectrum7821]

Charles Stickman Collection: Wins: Presumed Dead

[@BrotherTheory]

Yep! You are BRILLIANT, GEPAWQ :)

[@Anderson-kg5ex]

You know that PuffballsUnited confirmed that Charles dies on Valiant Hero, right?

[@darkleaf4851]

great! now what happened to henry in the revenged ending?

[@LizJeffersonCarrasco]

easy! he died...

[@rebeccacummings6697]

He dies

[@vreikezen8268]

He dead

[@BrotherTheory]

My theory sense is tingling :)

[@rebeccacummings6697]

@@BrotherTheory why? There is no theory needed. he died

[@TerriazeCAPCUTeditor]

Charles and Henry: vents Me: VOTE THEM OUT!

[@chorgen3158]

0:00, when you realize The Henry Stickman Collection is over a year old now

[@BrotherTheory]

What can I say? I love the collection to death! I hope you enjoyed this theory, Leo :)

[@yangchen6155]

Dude, he crashed the ship into the reactor

[@fouralgebralian]

yep true im alive i didnt died pin pls and happy new year im not RIP im just alived beacuse i really do that to the bubble its true i win before it blowed im back in earth im telling henry and getting a sandwich

[@fouralgebralian]

Well i disied to make the Charles Calvin collection

[@arandomhandle33444]

@@fouralgebralian send us link

[@real190log]

Found an escape pod and pranked Henry in a way

[@jeffro08]

Hai Charles =0

[@fouralgebralian]

@@arandomhandle33444 its not finished

[@robloxisnowred8623]

Im to alive i teleported to henry now of

[@BrotherTheory]

That's BRILLIANT, Charles :)

[@funnidoritoman]

He's not Charles he is Roblox

[@speedstorm0332]

And he's drifting _away_ from Earth in the _opposite_ direction, running out of oxygen, and is dead within an hour or so.

[@VeryEpicGamer]

You guys are soooooo underrated the editing is not that well but the narrator voice is very good

[@BrotherTheory]

I always try my best when editing these videos. Thanks for the compliment btw; Personally, I think recording my voice is the most difficult part when making these videos. People even thought that I was MatPat, that's CRAZY :) You are THE BEST, Lime Squad :)

[@VeryEpicGamer]

@@BrotherTheory np

[@CHARLES_CALVIN_LOVES_PANCAKES]

Hello im still alive

[@kray9927]

its kinda clear that your going for a game theory like vibe but the content is amazing!!! im happy to see someone making a theory on henry stickmin its one of my most favourite games!! btw the vid is amazing and great theory! edit: i recommend changing your intro but if not no problem!

[@mecha53107]

Puffballs has created my favorite character in video game in history.

[@BrotherTheory]

Same. That's why he has to live :)

[@-leytonbest-1325]

But there is a wrench to the theory, When Charles did his final greatest plan, the government prototype probably exploded, if it didn’, they would have got back in it, and go back to earth

[@Healion123]

He's saying that Charles just used the machine the prototype has to create the bubble. After he got in, the prototype basically didn't matter Also, not that he crashed it into a wall of metal & also the core. I don't think the prototype would be able to fly after such an impact

[@-leytonbest-1325]

@@Healion123 k

[@iaretheaquaman42]

Gotta be another escape pod around here somewhere He used an Escape Pod... AND! (2:00), look near the... logs? -Aqua GZR

[@Silver_Foxy]

Actually, there's a 4th pod, behind the woods so I think he survived from that.

[@kehnaudreybusmeon8062]

Tip that you didnt know:the green toppat guy have a hair and the luxury pod will 100 percent its fake and they will discover the body

[@sierra4actual]

Henry after hearing Charles go into radio silence be like: *HE DISCONNECTED*

[@loojayson7550]

Charles probably took an escape pod behind the woods

[@oopharb7237]

Charles can't survive too long in space

[@Babydollccg]

Me at the start: how is he alive in this cutsence? him: CHARLES IS ALIVE!

[@romilpatel2789]

and Charles does what he does best Charles:I'm the bold action maaaaaannnn

[@splatoon280]

If you look in the sticks you can see an escape pod. Charles just crawled into and his headphones ran out of battery.

[@souplol1147]

this guy will blow up i can just see it

[@AyushmanBhakti]

Charles died after that and I can prove it, while he was saying "it was the greatest plan" he coulfn't say full sentence he just said till greatest and explosion happened which means he died and he wasn't able to go back to his space ship because it was damaged and he was able to talk to henry using his damaged headphones and if he was alive we should have seen him in military base, so clearly that means Charles died at the moment the toppat space station exploded although, people still say things that Charles is alive, so I can tell that Charles died probably because of explosion, he was a great friend of Henry Stickmin and a great Pilot, he died at a young age, anyways, it's not anything hard to consider him as dead because we should remember the moments he spent with Henry, they were really great, Charles died but he was remembered and it was really sad for Henry to face problems without Charles. Charles Calvin died in that chapter not from the whole game, we can just play the previous chapters and he is still there.