CHARLOTTE TILBURY MASCARA BATTLE | Exaggereyes Vs Pillow Talk!

[@paulasushka3700]

Exaggereyes for me. I have oily and hooded eyelids and this is the only mascara I’ve ever used that does not budge. I have been very surprised at how easy it is to remove as well.

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Whoop!

[@sueanderson9860]

I use them both! Push up first and Exagereyes for second coat and lower lashes. 😊

[@anarenata8115]

Pillow talk is definitely the winner for you 😍 this is one of the most helpful comparisons I’ve seen on KZbin

[@misssjw]

Just sat here pondering why CT used false lashes in their Ad when they could have used you as a lashes model?! You have the lashes of DREAMS and I for one am insanely jealous

[@megdvs21]

It’s so interesting how mascaras are so different on different lash types and eye shapes everything you have said you love about the pushup ( more separation and lift and fanned out and less messy and easier to build with one coat ) i get with the exaggereyes and i absolutely love it, but i have rounder and a bit downturned eyes at least my upper lids give a more rounded shape, with very thin long lashes that are very straight so the cureved brush shape really suits my eye shape and i seem to get less lashes grouped together with a natural bristle brush than a plastic bristle brush 😀🙂this was such a great comparison to watch 🙂💕

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Crazy!😍

[@marielle7505]

Tough one. Both look good. That few more ml is a plus for the new kid, but in every day life, ease of use is so important. On a careless glance they look mostly the same. On very critical inspection, the pillow talk wins by a hairs lenght. If they would be exactly the same, I would still choose easy application over more product. Thanks, Charlotte!

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

In person there is a very clear difference but it is harder to see on camera 💞

[@cammiemr5172]

Random, but an amazing mascara I've recently tried is the Laura Mercier Caviar Extravagant Mascara. I highly recommend trying it.

[@Marzipanprincessa]

I love that one too!! 😍😍😍

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

I didn't get along with that one!

[@meganryan9945]

Wowza what a showdown! I’ll have to do my own test now that my exaggereyes has arrived🥰 both look stunning on you lovely❤️

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Thank you!

[@ST-fd6bi]

Exaggereyes definitely. No smudging (pillowtalk does.smudge on me), prettier more velvety lashes, huge volume and really good length. A great mascara.

[@carly8056]

Pillow Talk is the greatest mascara of all time. I have tried EVERYTHING. It kills me to pay the ridiculous price for it, but there is no other option on planet earth. Facts are facts! 😂❤

[@carolynmoore2144]

I really thought I would prefer the Exaggereyes but now I'm going to have to try the Pillow Talk!

[@gemmas8052]

The push up lashes definitely wins but I am team Mac stack!

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Love Mac stack too!

[@julieannsheridan6438]

Mac stack is my fav too

[@nicoletanzer6537]

This was super helpful. I know myself and 90% of the time I'm a 1 coat kind of girl, so you showing that difference really helps. Thank you!

[@katherineseymour6239]

I started off not liking Exagger-eyes as it was clumpy and smudged a lot while applying. Now I’m happy as can be as it’s not clumpy and if you let them dry, then there’s no smudging and looks great until I remove. This was a nail-biter of a showdown, such good fun ❤

[@teadivamuse]

The heaviness of the Exaggerise actually closes the eye making that eye look slightly smaller. I vote for Pillow talk pushup.

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

🥰🥰🥰

[@katherinekelly9689]

Hi Charlotte, my favourite look is the pillow talk push upside mainly for the wand size, also I fear I would break the glass by dropping it on the floor ( I’m a bit of a klutz), I very much enjoyed watching this video. Love Katherine xoxo

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Thanks for sharing!!

[@carriebrooks2664]

Charlotte, if a mascara doesnt clump, how will I get my 5 lashes to show up..😂😂. Ugh the late 50s are fun❤..love your Bambi lashes.

[@carly8056]

😂😂😂

[@marcellarosa211]

My prior HG mascara (Gucci) always smeared under brow and under eye. I recently learned that tubing mascaras don’t do this. I have been testing Tarte tubing and (bc I have fomo) I had to try Maybelline Sky High (yes it’s a tubing mascara)…I am snobily a luxury makeup lover and didn’t want to like the Sky High but OMG the Maybelline is amazing, volume, length, separation and it doesn’t transfer ANYWHERE (even after being outside in humidity for hours)

[@lisapierce525]

Loved watching you do the comparison. Your holy grail still suits you best. I have to use a volumizing mascara. My lashes are long and curved, they’re just starting to become more sparse.

[@mcColorado4890]

I love how good mascaras are getting these days. I was blessed with pretty good lashes and I love them as dramatic as possible. But am picky about the wand!

[@addieblue111]

I just used the Exxagereyes for the first time today - it's a bit tricky to use but with 2 coats I got the effect that I wanted 😊 I am not a huge fan of the pillow talk because I don't like the rubber wand. In any case while I was applying it today in the morning, I was thinking of you Charlotte and I was wondering when were you go to make a video about it and here is the video now 😃. P.S. I was sure that the pillow talk is going to remain your favourite 💖

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Thanks for sharing!

[@gladysgarrity5721]

Hey Charlotte I absolutely agree with you I picked up the new one & I feel the same the old one is better in my book By the way your hair is looking really good ❤

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Thanks for sharing!!

[@michellegerrell2375]

I have lash envy!!! You have the most gorgeous lashes ever😍 both mascaras look fabulous but I have to say the push up lashes it still my fav! Still holy grail/gold medal status 😊 By the way my mascara faces are way more horrendous 😂😂😂

[@glambysophie1]

I´m team Exaggereyes. I liked the volume on this one. But my favourite one is the Lisa Eldridge kitten lash masacra 😊

[@Ripplehurst]

Very good review. Thank you 😊

[@nadiadncr]

Clicked so fast if it’s not Charlotte approved I’m not getting it you are my mascara guru great review 💕 the push up didn’t work for me I love the Chanel the tarte tubing and the essence lash princess purple 💕💕💕💕

[@gemjones3353]

This is a lash masterclass.. I’ve picked up some great tips , thank you. love both on you , however I prefer to use the exagger-eyes ☺️

[@renatarosa8163]

Great demo !Your lashes are amazing !I like both but I do prefer Pillow Talk !

[@Marzipanprincessa]

Thanks Charlotte, I’m so happy to hear your opinion! 🤗🤗 We have very similar taste in mascaras (as well), so I always find your insights very useful! 🥰🥰 The reason why I love the push up lashes so much is bc the wand helps me not to make a mess when applying it, so I’m not sure if I’m ready to give that up… but I am intrigued!! ✨✨

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

You are so welcome!

[@Hillemor1]

The description of the new one makes it sound like a tubing mascara. It is on its way to me, can’t wait to see if it will be good for my ever-smudging eyes 🙏🏼 perhaps I will try it with a different wand as I will obviously also make a mess 😂 thank you for testing, Charlotte! Would have been interesting to see a wear test as well 😃

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Hope you like it!

[@ProfMary]

I asked a CT rep if this was a tubing mascara and they said NO.

[@Hillemor1]

@@ProfMary good to know, thanks for sharing! A bit nervous to see if it will hold up on my oily eyelids then. 😶

[@valliii]

​@@ProfMary Weird, I asked the CT customer service and they said yes! So which is it?!!

[@tracyhixon7255]

Pillow talk! I use the dream pop every day!

[@painttheface]

Thanks for the comparison Charlotte! Amazing how I got very little volume from the Exaggereyes mascara and I found it to be just ok, it didn’t do (on me) what it clearly has done on your eyes! My lashes need ALOT of help though. I think they both look great on you :)

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

You're so welcome!

[@ProfMary]

I was hoping you would do a video on the new CT mascara. Thank you. Both eyes looked dramatic to me and I would be hard pressed to see which mascara was on which eye if you hadn't shown us. I did see Charlotte Tilbury demonstrate the Exaggereyes and showing that you can use the tip of the wand to apply to both upper and lower lashes. I have been doing that and it works for those inner and outer lashes and my lower lashes for me. I would be interested in which of the two was easiest to remove. That is often the challenge for me with mascara.

[@DM-eg6ow]

I was waiting for this review! I haven’t tried exager-eyes yet and that wand might be too big for my small eyes. I haven’t purchased pillow talk in a while. Maybe I’ll pick it up again during holiday sales

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

🥰🥰🥰

[@annemarietimmerman7213]

Yes, helpful, dear Charlotte, you are our mascara specialist!!!🤩🤩🤩🤩Stupid question maybe, but when you mix both, a layer Pillow Talk and than a layer Exaggereyes? Was just wondering what happens than. My most used mascara is still the Chantecaille one. Enjoy your day!!!😘😘😘😘

[@lornagilbert3219]

Loving your work as usual Charlotte! I prefer the push up lashes, BUT the push up lashes smudges on me and the exagger-eyes doesn’t. Hmmm, decisions, decisions…

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Thanks for sharing!!

[@caitrinabbott4006]

I use the pillow talk over the too faced mascara primer and it lasts all day even in this Florida heat!

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Whooooo impressive!

[@garnwalkerstables]

Perfect timing, I’m just ready to order this and give it a try.❤👍

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Hope you enjoy it!

[@Gemma1558]

Loving your hair like that!❤

[@Korrina-g3w]

I have very short, sparse lashes and was hoping that the new CT mascara was going to help my poor lashes out, no far badgang gal by benefit is the only mascara that gives me any length and volume, but i have not tried the push up, yet. I will keep trying the exagger eyes a few more times, if it doesn't improve i will try the push up.

[@cammiemr5172]

Ty for trying these 2 mascaras and sharing!!❤

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

You are so welcome!

[@dianebraden629]

I never like the pillow talk mascara and I did find my using the exaggerates to make more of a mess, but I really loved it.

[@QuickWorksBeauty]

Legendary Lashes Volume 2 used to be my favorite, but Exaggerereyes is my favorite now. I can’t believe the volume and length of my lashes. I no longer need to use my L’Oreal lash volumizer.

[@lisasmith7]

I was gifted the exaggereyes for my review. That bottle could be used as a weapon. I like it. It has been open several weeks. It got less messy for me. Have a great weekend ❌️ ⭕️

[@mandycowan1927]

I didn't like the Pillowtalk mascara as I don't like the wand. I've just ordered the exaggereyes so I will let you know. Normally I go with your preferences, but I'm a sucker for mascara and I have to try the new versions. xxx

[@Balletbabe485]

Oh, I’ve been waiting for this!! I’ll be staying with my OG Push Up

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

🙌🏼🙌🏼🙌🏼

[@iindadupont4018]

I also love mascara lije you. Do. I like push up lashes better. pillow talk is much easier to remove which is also important

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Thanks for sharing!!

[@bevyoung2009]

I pick the pillow talk. I love the brush.

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Me too!

[@0773heidi]

I prefer the pillow talk one x

[@bevyoung2009]

I love mascara too. I can't put on false eyelashes.

[@sunshinestate4001]

I did try the new mascara and did not smudge on me and have a very oily eyelids.I like the new for this reason and had the same issue with mess.Little harder to control.I think it has its own technik how we need to hold the curler.

[@angelaborne2431]

I like the push up pillow talk mascara

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

🥰🥰🥰

[@lisalovesphotography]

I believe the Push-up Lashes looks better on you, Charlotte. It gives lots of everything you want. 😊

[@r.c.7779]

You are DEFINITELY the mascara queen! Do you still love the Benefit fan fest and how does it rank amongst these

[@angelaborne2431]

Have you tried Lisa Eldridge kitten lash mascara? That my holy grail.

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Of course! Review is in the playlist💞

[@HerGreyness]

Charlotte, what eyeshadow do you have on? Would appreciate info! I ordered the CT new mascara in small size to try..I have been using Lash Clash but it’s a PIA to get off (I only have 3 lashes)😂

[@pennypenpen5371]

I'd say push up lashes. I zoomed in as I watched 👀😁 and I'd say that's the clear winner 👌

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

🙌🏼🙌🏼🙌🏼

[@SusanD101]

Exaggereyes would suit me, probably without the eyelashes curled first as I usually do.

[@huirossi8483]

1st coat, the new mascara looks more volume and PT looks more separating. After 3 coating, I think they look pretty much the same.

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

The difference in person is more noticeable it's hard to see on camera💞

[@lebenslustundbewusst7808]

Exagger Eyes ❤

[@lauramiller5877]

Push up but both look great 👍

[@40loopylou1]

Nice try, Charlotte, but I have short straight lashes and end up with so much mascara on my lids I don’t need to wear eyeliner 😂

[@ddavidjp]

does anyone know if the brushes in the travel size and regular size push up mascaras are the same size? i always buy the travel size because of its perfect brush size for me. i want to try the regular size because it’s more cost effective to buy the regular size but i’m worried the brush would be bigger than the travel size brush.

[@cristinakastner5102]

How do both compare to the CT full fat lashes?

[@michelleromani2870]

How many seconds do you wait in between coats?

[@kittencakes9836]

Nothing will get me to spend money on anything but Dior Iconic OverCurl mascara. It never smudges it comes in brown and looks fantastic on my clear straight lashes. Curls them right up and they look long separated lifted and fake! I’ve used it for years and tried many others over the years, then said there’s no point! It’s just wasting to even bother.

[@jessabeauty917]

Exaggereyes seems similar to YSL Lash Clash.

[@carinam4258]

I haven’t found anywhere anything about the removal process. Is this a tubing mascara? I was looking at the ingredients and can’t tell. The only CT mascara I like is the pillow talk but I have watery eyes and sometimes it doesn’t work for me either…😘

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

I haven't had any problems, I use an oil based cleanser 💞

[@carinam4258]

@@CharlotteHoldcroft😘

[@elainebines6803]

Without reading other comments. Ok q tip at the ready, dipped in pink lid bioderma miscellar water, spelt wrong, sorry. Great tips, thankyou. I'm team exagera eyes 😊

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

🙌🏼🙌🏼

[@lauratrevino6024]

Have you tried layering them?

[@sueanderson9860]

I cannot apply mascara prior to doing eyeshadow EVER and im 62! I make a dreadful mess and end up having to take most of my eyeshadow off! 😂😂

[@noelleona5100]

The push up mascara flakes and smudges horribly on me and I’m not oily at all. I’m dry and live in a dry climate. It’s u fortunate cause I do like the wand/formula ortherwise. But it is a mess after an hour!

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Argh so annoying! 💞

[@tzoe875]

With the 3 coats on I’m not sure I see much of a difference. With one coat and even two I liked pillowtalk better. I thought the new one is a tubing mascara? Maybe I’m confused.

[@bevyoung2009]

Hello beautiful Charlotte 😍

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Hello 😊

[@Pilatesdxb]

I think for my long too curly lashes, the Exaggereyes is the best out there. And i tried almost all. Push up lashes is beautiful but it smudges and transfers all day unfortunately. This one doesn’t move, easy to clean and I get no clumps . It’s a 10/10 for me

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Thanks for sharing!!

[@dianebraden629]

Except doe the mess, I really did it see a difference in your lashes.

[@nikolavyvadilova5255]

Did anyone try legendary eyes 2? It s much better than Pillow talk for me

[@marcibigney9212]

I cannot find one that doesn't transfer 😭

[@redouteshabby2024]

I am a packaging girl and really don't care for the Exaggereyes tube. How can you beat the beautiful classic pink Pillow Talk packaging?

[@cathystein1285]

Hi Charlotte. Pillow talk wins for me. The exager eyes is almost too much

[@audreyso1201]

Oui le gagnant est "Pillow talk". Merci pour le partage

[@melindagenitempo2359]

Sorry but YSL Lash clash is still my HG ❤

[@WendyPokato]

I am SO gutted I didn’t watch this before I’d bought the new one. As a trusty fan of the pillow talk I don’t know what came over me to get the new and im so disappointed! Dammit x

[@SarahHovley]

Push up lashes. Plus a glass bottle seems dangerous for someone like me who has fumble fingers.

[@sandypapadopoulos4969]

I'm Team Pillowtalk😊

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

💞💞💞

[@Aisstylish]

Pillow talk.

[@millsy1236]

Team push up lashes here

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

🙌🏼🙌🏼

[@Anyways936]

It's push up for me. I ordered a travel size of exagger eyes. Before it arrived I was underwhelmed by the reviews popping up. When it arrived, I remained underwhelmed. I had high hopes that it could exceed push up...RIP exagger eyes.

[@bevyoung2009]

I would buy the pillow talk for myself.

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

🙌🏼🙌🏼🙌🏼

[@jillpotts7472]

very similar. i like pushup better

[@CharlisDailyDiary]

💜💜💖

[@bevyoung2009]

Team push up.

[@GlitterLife0216]

Push up lashes

[@wittjablonski2699]

I think the exagger eyes looks better on you

[@jennawoodard8386]

💕💄

[@Littlen80]

Well, I think maybe you have to master how to use the new one… Both sides beautiful but the winner is Pillow talk lashes… For my daughter and I the new mascara is brilliant ❤ no smudge, easy to remove ❤ Thanks for the video ❤

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

I've had the new one for a good few weeks now 💞

[@Littlen80]

@@CharlotteHoldcroft❤

[@catnip4587]

The new mascara is a fail for me. Doesn’t hold the curl. Seems like it makes my eyelashes droop and the package is so heavy. the Pillow aTalk wins. No contest

[@LeslieMiletich]

pillow talk is better

[@evelynrosado9711]

They look “clumpy”.

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Definitely not...

[@psyched3lic347]

Bought the Exagger eyes yesterday, and I usually use Fenty Hella Thicc. I have to say, the product was okay. I will still use it, but just for me, Fenty in one stroke still beats it.