REACTING to NIGHTWISH (Tribal) 💀🎸🔥

[@ne.laser_jon]

Anyone that’s here for the pauses and actual analysis and breakdown of the music, hit the like on this. Go chase now me lol! I LOVE the analysis over reaction

[@AnOldGreyDog]

Jonathan I don't bother with reactions any more. If you ain't providing added value, I ain't watching. That's why I like Chase and Tank (and Julia). And Friar Guylain, of course.

[@ChantalLalonde]

That is why we are here

[@ne.laser_jon]

MissDragonfly800 agreed! But he always apologizes for the pauses and has mentioned that there’s controversy about it. I think the vast majority want to hear what he hears and thinks

[@MacZussie]

it shifts with the mood which one I prefer. Yet there is an undeniable shift between him and Mr.Rock'n Roll 😂 although both are big fanciers of NW

[@tragicsupergirl]

I love that he instantly hears things that I never noticed. It really adds to my own enjoyance of the song.

[@peterachten4353]

“I go back one more because it’s my birthday, and I want to” Happy birthday!

[@samanthar1214]

Happy birthday 🎉🥳🥳🎉🎂🎁🎈 Shortest song on the album and Chase makes an 18 min video...we love our pause king 👑

[@ChaseCarneson]

⏸🤴🙋‍♂️

[@ChrisPage68]

Pre-pause-terous. 🤣

[@572Btriode]

@@ChrisPage68 Oh dear PM. . . . . . . . . :-)

[@graveheart5002]

@@ChrisPage68 That was awful.😄😂 I love it. Keep going.

[@KelbenArunsun]

@@ChrisPage68 Well played!

[@Joffreaux]

Kai said in an interview that he had to add 5 extra drums to his kit for Tribal. Can't wait to see this live!

[@StergiosMekras]

KZbin subtitles transcribed "Empuu" as "Emperor" ...I'm not even mad.

[@rianvandenhoof4124]

great nickname for the greatest guitarist on earth.......

[@Beatz-he5xe]

Lith Maethor hahaha

[@kuroyuki6254]

@Mantvydas Nenartavičius He's the greatest in our hearts

[@AnOldGreyDog]

I saw an interview with Kai where he made the point that this is the first album with Kai drumming _as Kai_ . On Endless Forms, they still thought that Jukka might return, so Kai kind of channelled Jukka when they recorded the drums. Now that Jukka has officially retired, Kai could put his own stamp on the drum parts for this album.

[@mmklassen]

Graham Douglas this is great insight, thanks for sharing. I love both drummers so much and appreciate how respectful and generous they’ve been toward each other.

[@granthoule7418]

Saddened to hear that Jukka has decided to retire glad though that he chose his replacement as that shows how much he loves his bandmates and they him. He could have just said sorry cant do it anymore and just left it at that. But he didnt.

[@susibelle2955]

@@granthoule7418 As far as I know, Jukka is still in a band management, he is doing paperwork now as he is also good with numbers. It was health issues that made it too difficult to play on tours. So he never "left" the band, just quit playing drums.

[@kpsmorera]

You can actually feel the change from Jukka’s drumming style, to Kai’s almost perfectly human-metronome style

[@nikolasmichaelides9444]

I am waiting for the live show drum cam of this song, and until I see it, I will remain suspicious that Kai has only 2 hands.

[@ChaseCarneson]

😂

[@mattyguitar22]

There is actually some drum cam stuff of Kai from Nightwish, can confirm he has extra hands and feet as well

[@VariaHellstorm]

Kai is all hands and feet. There's no real body, just extremities.

[@benrilomubarok586]

If you see Kai's play for Wintersun you will know that he's just using his ethereal body to play for NW

[@Doudoussin]

Tuomas : "To compose Tribal, I thought : okay, this is the theme : how do we execute this ? How would a band sound like 20000 years ago if you gave them modern technology ? And naturally, it would be very percussive, very primitive, very tribal, very heavy, dissonant." Marko and Floor on stage : HAHAHAHA FUNNY SKELETON GO DANCE ZHZOGZKZGLZG

[@kujika]

"How would a band sound like 20000 years ago if you gave them modern technology ? And naturally, it would be very percussive, very primitive, very tribal, very heavy, dissonant." Tribal makes a bit more sense now. Was wondering about the weird build of the song and ... the skeletons of course xD

[@greeniesr]

Can't wait to see Floor do the skeleton dance on stage....

[@willemhoek3226]

Can’t wait for 85.000 people at wacken to do the skeleton dance.....

[@Frankamaria]

the audience will do it ^^

[@lilo5437]

I’ll be standing on my seat 😂

[@emmason8237]

We'll have the venues shaking and the ground trembling 😂

[@rilenevanderzon7929]

@@willemhoek3226 thats what I whas tinking🥰 I realy love to se that one❤

[@branislavfx]

I think Kai Hahto has mentioned in one of his most recent interviews that he had to add a 5-6 new drums to his drum kit to be able to play songs on this last album. And did you noticed the final Floor’s vocal part - it’s one big 14-15 seconds piece in one breath, crowned by her vibrato adjusted to the beats of the drums? :)

[@MKEbcl]

To me this band is everything. From the music they make down to their individual personalities. This is how making music should always be.

[@marcel1416]

"Yeah yeah, pause pause..." -Chase Carneson 2020 Dude I am pretty sure that the vast majority of people don't mind you pausing that often. In fact, I like that you are pausing a lot, because you really have something informative to say during every pause, not just "wow, that's cool" or "great". But I am pretty sure I am not the first one who told you that ;)

[@peterbell3199]

Exactly, There are only a few that pause and then give us the viewer meaningful insight. Chase is one of the best at it. His pauses never bug me like most Reactors do.

[@alexisthibodeau1300]

This song isn’t even 4 minutes long but has the progression of a 10 minutes song... insane

[@staropramen478]

This along with Pan and Endlessness are the songs I look forward to the most to hear live. I also feel like these songs are gonna be a lot heavier live.

[@ralfmeyer9086]

And Music and Shoemaker, hihi 🤗

[@MacZussie]

Even the most stoic Finns need to go into some movement while it's performed live in concert....same to the rest of the world of course

[@dark_faerie]

I am very excited to see Pan performed live! In fact the whole album would be amazing!

[@avajanuary]

It's a couple hours before my wedding, and I have shit to do, but I just had to watch this one! Happy birthday Chase!

[@thisismyvanced3738]

Have a lovely wedding!

[@peterbell3199]

Congrats!

[@ralfmeyer9086]

Toumas; Floor how long can you hold the last note? Floor: Yes Forget, Happy birthday and stay safe

[@torarnemartinussen3363]

Have a damn happy birthday,,, Kai said with a smile: Toumas made me buy new drums to get the sound he was looking for... to be honest, I think this is perfection...stay safe

[@rijlqanturis625]

When they finally get to perform this live, the audience better be doing the skeleton dance.

[@darkiee69]

It'll be the metal macarena..😉

[@MustaLaatta]

maybe there's speial discount for those who can... 😃

[@alanfoster6589]

Disney's first "Silly Symphony" cartoon (setting animation to music) was the b&w "Skeleton Dance". Tuomas is a huge Disney fan. Unless the use of dancing skeletons in the Tribal video was sheer coincidence, it's an interesting homage.

[@Greyhound53200]

@@alanfoster6589 Great catch! I knew I saw that Skeleton Dance somewhere else.

[@Jared-91]

I'll be watching. I don't dance 🙂

[@GianaManetheren]

Happy birthday. Nightwish has learned you to listen to music differently, and you taught me. I love how you're not just going "wow" and "that's amazing", but are actually teaching us some things.

[@magnesiumrose]

I find your reviews are a lot like a Nightwish song: every note is purposeful. I feel like I'm watching a really fun documentary on musical components. The more pauses, the better. Happy Birthday! Thank you for continuing to give us fun details and videos. You even gave one on your birthday which is really kind of you. Hope you're safe and well!

[@wilburjunior9949]

Have a damn good birthday Chase!!! 🤘🎈🎈🎂🎊🎉

[@rome8180]

Dude, you notice so much and are able to articulate it really well. So much better than other reaction channels.

[@ChaseCarneson]

I really appreciate it. Thanks dude. 🙏

[@jaimeazcarraga7426]

The evolution of your face from 14:45 on shows perfectly how much of a MONSTER VOCALIST Floor is 😂. I counted 8 bloody bars without a single breath. Madness 😱

[@jonno55]

Hello Chase. Since you began reacting to Nightwish I am hooked to your way of reacting. First it was "oh, nice music, very well played, they are so professional". Musically I was a complete nitwit. Now I know a little more about how structured the songs are and how intruments working together. A bit more technicallity at my side. Your reactions are just world class, loving them so much and sometimes even watch them several times, just to know more about how songs are built. Keep the good work going. And as many of the followers say: pause as much as you think you need to fully explain all you hear so you share it with us. And BTW, happy birthday. Worth checking out: Ayreon

[@peterbell3199]

Exactly, I've been a music lover since I was a kid, and played in school band thru high school, but I never had anyone explain music to me. I just played what was on the sheet music. But Chase is helping learn more about the music structure and how it works, and it's been great to learn this while listening to my favorite Nightwish songs!

[@Donna-C]

7:56 - You launched straight into the skeleton dance 👏 😂 Empu’s guitar work! 🎸 Those drums! 🥁 That last note! 🎵 Wow!!!!!

[@phils866]

One aspect of quite a few Nightwish songs I have noticed is they can't be easy to sing. They don't conform to 'ordinary' rhythms or metres, and breath control has to be expemplary. Not that Floor seems to have any problems, but then, she ain't human! This song is gonna be so nuts live!

[@DougsShack]

These last two songs are probably the closest I can come to choosing a favorite. Endlessness might nudge out Tribal mostly because I'm a sucker for Marco.

[@MissIssay]

Marko and those lyrics, yeah!

[@mmklassen]

Marko is EVERYTHING. I’m a total sucker for him as well. My favorite song on the album for sure. Endlessness.

[@DougsShack]

I'm reading through his autobiography again. He is definitely my man crush. 😄

[@Razgriz__1]

I absolutely can not wait for Chase's reaction to Endlessness.

[@MissIssay]

@@Razgriz__1 same! Though there is only one song that I'm extremely curious how Chase would react to, and it's "Master Passion Greed"

[@novaasher1185]

Happy bornday, Simba 🦁 Hakuna Matata! 🤘🏻🔥🙆🏻‍♀️😎

[@saulmanuelferreiragoncalve6054]

Happy birthday Chase. Another excellent reation to another Nightwish excellent song.

[@gameoners]

Do a Weak Fantasy in Tampere, Kai is killing it there!!! "Tribal Poetry" 👌

[@dennisweifenbach2647]

As i continue to listen to Nightwish I am increasingly impressed with them. And an ever increasing admiration for Tuomas and his genius. If there was a road map for Nightwish it would never stop folding out into something new. With this song I could swear there were 3 drummers. Amazing just how much gets packed into a song like this. Kai is fantastic.

[@lilo5437]

This and Shoemaker are my favourite songs of the new album. Can’t wait for the video!

[@hopegreer3357]

Happy Birthday!!!! Thank you for the pauses!!! The info you give about the layering and off beats I would have never noticed. More pauses and rewinds are always welcome!!!

[@greylight5]

Happy birthday! Appreciate your commentary as always.

[@marievie91]

Wooooo, been waiting for this one 😀 This put a *huge* smile on my face, like the energy was radiating through my screen! Danced, smiled, laughed, air-drummed along, it was a crazy one I'm telling you! Keep being awesome and giving us lovely insight on music, your knowledge sharing is *chef's kiss* ...! Happy birthday!!!

[@ChaseCarneson]

Thank you very much for all the support. I appreciate you

[@gympee]

Happy birthday Chase!!!! Thank you so much for sharing your reactions with us. Have a Damn Good Day!!

[@svenriedel6328]

Happy birthday Chase🎉🍰🍻

[@finlaredo]

Happy birthday! And thanks again for detailed informatic reaction.

[@paisa20]

Happy birthday!!! , thanks for the reaction

[@Jacqueline.1964]

Skelletons for your birthday.... it had to be! Happy, happy birthday saturday and lots of love!

[@rebeccalee2644]

Another great reaction. Thank you and Happy Birthday 🎂 🥳 🎉 🎈

[@Dianen65]

Yes Tuomas has al lot of dept and emotional intelligence but so have you! Love this song and after listening to your reaction i have a better understanding why. Thanks for the great birthdaygift!

[@ChaseCarneson]

He's an amazing person

[@Beatz-he5xe]

Happy birthday Char...thanx for once again a brilliant reaction and analysis

[@pii3242]

Happy Birthday, The Master of Pauses aka Chase!🌹🥂🌹 Your bithday and you give all those pause gifts to us! Have to listen again, many times,, to hear all You hear👍

[@gayleeidson6724]

THIS song is going to be AMAZING live ❤️ !!! What an awesome reaction today ! ( You ALWAYS have awesome reactions !). Hoping you have a Kick-Ass Birthday . Thanks for taking the time to include the NIGHTWISH Army in your day !!! Be blessed and have fun doing the skeleton dance ALL day !!! Haha !

[@DudeTK]

Happy birthday Chase . Love your reactions.

[@emmason8237]

Practice that skeleton dance, the entire Wembley crowd will erupt when they hit that part live. Great, expressive reaction - as always! Happy birthday!

[@disneymaniac001]

Me: Pan is my favorite from the album. *listens to Tribal Me: Pan is my second favorite from this album.

[@ThyLLiS-]

Hi Chase. I really like your reactions, you always are able to find some details in songs in just one hearing, that in my case took me several listenings to get. I'm really impressed. I see that you already did some Epica Reactions. If I may, I request you to react to Epica - Chasing the Dragon (live Retrospect 2013). This is a really hard song to sing, and Simone Simons was 3 months pregnant at that live, which adds another difficulty to this very hard song and makes it an unbelievable performance.

[@Wotsefaqq]

Another great Example of Kais Play is how he counts the Skeleton Dance with the Kick Drum and aligns it with the "Huh"...1 Kick, 1 "Huh", 2 Kicks, 2 "Huh" up to the Multikicks what a musician

[@peterbell3199]

damn, I need to go back and re-listen, I didn't notice that before.

[@missrubyphoenix]

This is one of those songs I listen to when I'm very very angry and want to smash things around me, I turn it up all the way and it drains all that aggressive energy pretty quickly out of me

[@neelefrey]

I particularly like that song about this album. It just has this special sound that grounds me, I don't know how to express it ... I would suggest you to listen to the song Sahara (live with Floor for sure) A completely different sound and so far there are hardly any videos about it. Greetings from Germany 💕

[@ronnyseffinga7950]

i second that but AFTER ........Human Nature pls... the Tampa Florida version is the best btw

[@Thorgrim247]

I also will also second that request! I love Sahara and the Arabian vibe to the melody. Also love Floors chanting and dancing towards the end. Only complaint, it is far too short!

[@neelefrey]

@@Thorgrim247 Unfortunately that's true, but I love the atmosphere of the song

[@Thorgrim247]

@@neelefrey Agreed! Be well!

[@nadinehees6572]

Happy birthday

[@emiliostrange]

happy birthday chase. this is my fave off of this album :)

[@sanderhoogeland9161]

Happy birthday. Endlessness is great too, like they all are.

[@chilly2go]

It's your birthday Chase and I hope it's a damn fine one and yet you gave us all a gift with this reaction. ☠️🔥🤘😉

[@barbaravance6774]

🎇🎈HAPPY BIRTHDAY!🎈🎇 This is one of my favorites from this album. Kai is a fantastic drummer. I imagine this will be a very taxing live show, when tours resume. I love your reviews! They are actually intelligent. Not just praise and agreement with fans. Your actually discussion of the music and vocals shows your love of music

[@StLauncelot]

Happy b'day, lindo! ^^ Congratulations for all your effort! Very precious! >

[@lawwix]

I always like your videos before watching because I know by now they're always so good!

[@annelipohjonen6792]

Hello from Finland, I came here to see the song and I absolutely loved how technical (nerdy) you get with the song. I have heard of your channel before from Tank so this was the first video I have seen from you but most certainly the last. Thanks for the video Chase it was awesome!

[@ChaseCarneson]

Thank You for watching it! 👌👌👌

[@xenagold7167]

Happy Birthday Chase. Hope you had an awesome day. 🎉🐶🎉💐

[@geezer161]

Happy Birthday Chase great reaction keep up the good work

[@juanramirezpasten6507]

Happy birthday 🤘😀, great analysis as always.

[@sarahculler4249]

Happy late birthday!! I just had mine as well! 😄 And what a song!! One of my faves by Nightwish 🤘🏻

[@black4pienus]

Not everyone gets dancing skeletons on their birthday. lol. Happy birthday!

[@kingcognito]

Oh nice, a happy coincidence - today is my birthday! Happy belated birthday and Thanks for the gift of wonderful reactions! :)

[@marianogonzalez1977]

Happy BDay Chase!!! Enjoy life as much as you can and keep the vibes up...

[@eminabrestovac]

I am really not seeing an issue wth your pausing. It is a reaction to a song, not a song itself. And you don't just stop for the sake of stopping, but to say something insightful and we do appreciate it. Thanks for one more reaction to Nightwish, I am loving it! :)

[@thisismyvanced3738]

Happy birthday! And what a way to celebrate it. This is one of my favorite songs as well! And that one last note every time gives me a floorgasm

[@Andromeda7553]

Happy Birthday Chase! 🎉🎂 Have a good one 😄

[@justdave9610]

Happy birthday Chase 🎂🎉🎈 and thanks for giving us this reaction on your birthday

[@justdave9610]

Have a damn good birthday

[@danielberger1378]

Happy birthday, Chase! I hope, you had a damn good day.

[@saltefan5925]

Happy (belated) birthday Chase! Great reaction and analysis as usual. Quality like this is exactly why I subscribed!

[@josejesuscontrerassalazar9140]

HAPPY BIRTHDAY CHASE!! 🎉🎊🎁🎂

[@fermytube]

Good analysis as always and Happy damn birthday !!!

[@jamboree2723]

Happy birthday! One of my favorites on the new album as well!

[@kimvanvugt3472]

Happy birthday Chase🎉

[@joguipo]

Happy belated birthday bruv. Particularly loved this one... Although I really don't think you pause enough times. Everytime you pause we get a good, free, music lesson. Big love from Spain

[@elsmoerenhout5837]

Love your reaction, as always! And congratulations! 💐

[@kurtfrazier526]

Happy Birthday Chase. Love your videos dude.

[@1337nano]

Happy birthday Chase, thanks for the reaction keep em coming and all the best wishes!!

[@Garbox80]

A very happy birthday to YOU Chase. One reactor actually said about that sceleton dance something along the lines "oh come on, yes it',s a tribal sound, we're not idiots". I actually think that it was a bit of a "tongue in cheek" kinda thing to add that there, funny. But also it probably has a deeper meaning as they're sceletons, I haven't thought about the lyrics enough to "crack the code".

[@kimseymour5250]

Some of Kais best work it’s just phenomenal:) PS I spent a lovely day with my nan today. We played games had food and a great chat. Happy Birthday Chase. We could use a lot more people like you in this world.

[@mattimelanen2418]

Happy birthday, Chase! And thanks for this reaction 😁👍

[@pookha50]

Happy birthday Ginger Vampire!! Thanks for the great reactions!

[@Greyhound53200]

Happy Birthday Chase !!!

[@silverlightx6]

Keep on Pausing! Also happy belated birthday!

[@ChantalLalonde]

Happy birthday Chase!!

[@RandallMorris222]

Happy Birthday, Chase! Great reaction, as always. I love your insight.

[@sandraleuchtenberger1145]

Happy Birthday Chase! Hope you had a damn good day. Loved your reaction-as always.

[@iDEATH]

Happy birthday, Chase!

[@keithteaser]

Happy Birthday ..Have a damn good day..great reaction..

[@annukkas]

Congratulations! 😊🍾🍻

[@BK45AUS]

Everytime i hear this song i have visions of the fans at a concert in skelly suits doing the dance, also cant help but see Emppu's power stance.

[@meikewassmuth4801]

Happy birthday Chase!

[@ThisTrainIsLost]

That rhythmic vocal rasp or growl first showed up to surprise during “The Greatest Show On Earth.”

[@marcoteunissenvanmanen9918]

Congratulations on your birthday, and thank you for a very thoughtful analyses of this wonderful song! Keep doing this, pauses included

[@donspice]

Nice analysis. Haven't really listened to Nightwish since Tarja left (yes... I'm one of those...). I think I might start giving Nightwish some love back now haha. Going on a tangent here, found your channel thanks to Band-Maid. I think two nice songs from all female bands that you might want to analyze are "Nemophila - Oiran" (Also a Japanese band) and "The Warning - Dust to Dust LIVE @ The Whisky a Go Go" (3 Mexican sisters [!]).

[@erikaverink8418]

Congratz on your birthday, and i always love your reactions. And i love it that you point out parts , i always take for granted. So keep on going back on songs, and listen to that part again.

[@Griso1973]

Have a damn good birthday Chase!!!