Chef vs Puppet vs Ansible vs Saltstack | Configuration Management Tools | DevOps Tools | Simplilearn

[@SimplilearnOfficial]

🔥Professional Certificate Program in Cloud Computing and DevOps (India Only) - www.simplilearn.com/cloud-computing-devops-course?TVNCTK808I&Comments&KZbin 🔥DevOps Engineer Master's Program - www.simplilearn.com/devops-engineer-masters-program-certification-training?TVNCTK808I&Comments&KZbin 🔥Caltech - Post Graduate Program in DevOps - www.simplilearn.com/pgp-devops-certification-training-course?TVNCTK808I&Comments&KZbin

[@andywong2135]

11:48 SSH is Secure SHell, not secure socket hashing

[@SimplilearnOfficial]

Hi Andy, SSH is also called Secure Shell or Secure Socket Shell, which is a network protocol that gives users, particularly system administrators, a secure way to access a computer over an unsecured network.

[@theusernameyoudidntexpect6511]

Never have I ever heard it referred to as "secure socket hash". Its Wikipedia page doesn't even include the word 'hash', likely because it makes little-to-no sense in describing its function. Honestly, it sounds more like jargon someone made up to sound like they knew what they were talking about...

[@SimplilearnOfficial]

Thanks for your feedback. You can check out this link for more clarity on SSH: searchsecurity.techtarget.com/definition/Secure-Shell

[@rohitrajkumar1234]

@Charle MIJ not really :)

[@mjsp8]

@@SimplilearnOfficial so it doesn't stand for secure socket hashing then, like you said.

[@UtpalBhattacharjee]

Now both Ansible and Saltstack are available in AWS.

[@SimplilearnOfficial]

Yes! You are right about that!

[@Mac-pluto]

Also Azure and GCP

[@서기옥-x8g]

Yes. But It's a non-managed service. It needs to configure the EC2.

[@ninetouch9196]

Mac Sc don't care about those two

[@zavierarthur1589]

instablaster

[@mzs114]

Salt all the way! Have used ansible since 1.7 and last was 2.x, until I discovered salt. The speed of execution and flexibility of salt just blew me away!

[@SimplilearnOfficial]

Thanks for sharing your input!

[@belipipi]

Definitely agreed, Ansible is good for noobs, but when you wanna do serious things go for Salt. I worked with both and I will never go back to that Ansible hell ...

[@shiva5741]

The way of explaining with animations is awesome

[@SimplilearnOfficial]

Hey, thank you for appreciating our work. We are glad to have helped. Do check out our other tutorial videos and subscribe to us to stay connected. Cheers :

[@albertogonzalezmesas810]

Firstly, thanks for the video. In my opinion, Ansible is on the top. Easy for setting up, a lot of modules and if you want, make your own modules in easy coding like is python. No master-client arquitecture and tower or AWX like GUI. Pull and push working mode. The best

[@SimplilearnOfficial]

Thanks for watching the video and also for the tips!

[@mzs114]

Until you have event based requirement, then Ansible is rigid. Salt kills it in this area.

[@es3t]

11:15 author should take notice that Ansible is available and was in cloud providers such as AWS , also Azure and also GCP

[@SimplilearnOfficial]

Hi Konrad, thanks for sharing your feedback. We will look into that!

[@habs249]

Enjoying the very Alan Partridge voiceover. Thank you!

[@SimplilearnOfficial]

Glad you enjoyed it!

[@elib2429]

It should be noted for Puppet environments, the master node does not push to client nodes, clients PULL configuration catalogs from the master node(and this can be set on intervals)

[@SimplilearnOfficial]

Thanks for watching our video and sharing your knowledge.

[@irascib1e]

Saltstack doesn't use SSH for communication. The controller opens a port that the agents on each node connect to and the controller publishes commands through that port.

[@SimplilearnOfficial]

Thanks for watching our video and sharing your thoughts. Do subscribe to our channel and stay tuned for more. Cheers!

[@SimplilearnOfficial]

Do you have any questions on this topic? Please share your feedback in the comment section below and we'll have our experts answer it for you. Thanks for watching the video. Cheers!

[@neild4620]

Excellent video, summed up everything I needed to know.

[@SimplilearnOfficial]

Glad it was helpful!

[@ramprasad_v]

I didn't know that Ruby was used in chef & puppet. I will learn Ruby & excel with the two tools. Thanks 👍

[@SimplilearnOfficial]

You're welcome! Thank you for watching!

[@francisconavarro3890]

Ansible and Puppet Bolt are available in the Microsoft Azure Cloud Shell

[@SimplilearnOfficial]

Thanks for watching our video and sharing the info!

[@wolfflighttzw]

The comments about SaltStack requiring Minion client install are not accurate. Currently Salt-ssh requires absolutely no minion (client) installation.

[@ITSecurityLabs]

Great explanation. Thanks

[@SimplilearnOfficial]

Hi, we appreciate the kind comment! enjoy!

[@pjguibord]

Need to update this vid- great details, a great deal of it is out of date.

[@SimplilearnOfficial]

We agree with you. We will make updated video soon.

[@lindhe]

Great overview! Thanks!

[@SimplilearnOfficial]

Hey Andreas, thank you for appreciating our work. We are glad to have helped. Do check out our other tutorial videos and subscribe to us to stay connected. Cheers :)

[@pankajmunje2255]

Excellent Vedio

[@SimplilearnOfficial]

We're thrilled to have been a part of your learning experience, and we hope that you feel confident and prepared to take on new challenges in your field. If you're interested in further expanding your knowledge, check out our course offerings in the description box.

[@tigrangevorgyan3584]

Hey Guys, thanks a lot for this video. It was really useful for me :)

[@SimplilearnOfficial]

Hey Tigran, thank you for appreciating our work. We are glad to have helped. Do check out our other tutorial videos and subscribe to us to stay connected. Cheers :)

[@easyappscompany]

Best Regards From Mexico City. Manuel Silva

[@SimplilearnOfficial]

Thanks, Manuel. Also, subscribe to our channel and stay tuned for more videos. Cheers!

[@ChrisChris-jh7uy]

Great stuff! But could you please give an example of "advanced tasks" you mentioned when you discussed the cons of Puppet/ Chef using Ruby?

[@zhinaaziz8009]

I need the answer too

[@MarceloLunardi]

top man! tyvm!

[@SimplilearnOfficial]

Glad it helped!

[@aneelysis]

When comparing the 4 solutions, what is your criteria for determining "Ease of Setup" and "Management"? Why is it easier to setup and manage Ansible vs the others? How are you determining that?

[@SimplilearnOfficial]

Ease of setup is the effort required in installing and configuring the tool on your system. Management refers to writing your configuration files that will manage the node systems. Ansible is easiest to setup mainly as it's clientless and easy to manage, as the code is written in YAML.

[@SimplilearnOfficial]

Thanks for your valuable input!

[@aneelysis]

@J W I've worked with Ansible and fairly familiar with it, I just was curious to know what the criteria that is being used when talking about "Ease of Setup" and "Management". Most people have would use a decision matrix to identify the guidelines that helped make the decision.

[@SimplilearnOfficial]

Since ansible is client-less, its easy to setup. Playbooks make management of ansible much easier.

[@pedrophsg]

Thanks for share it!

[@SimplilearnOfficial]

Thank you for watching!

[@besrabasant]

Btw... If you want to do advanced stuffs with Ansible, you can Python

[@SimplilearnOfficial]

Yes, it is possible. Thanks for sharing your insights.

[@sabestek8896]

Very good.. thx much for the lesson. quick question.. where does vagrant and openstack fit in all this as part of the devops toolbox .?

[@SimplilearnOfficial]

"Hi, OpenStack is a cloud operating system that controls large pools of compute, storage, and networking resources throughout a datacenter. While Vagrant is a tool for building and distributing development environments. Vagrant provides the framework and configuration format to create and manage complete portable development environments."

[@monocojo9939]

Great, thank u

[@SimplilearnOfficial]

You are welcome

[@learnaddict8994]

Now Ansible does has integration with AWS, Azure and GCP. Also with various various Network and Security vendors

[@SimplilearnOfficial]

Thanks for sharing your input. Do show your love by subscribing to our channel using this link: kzbin.info and don't forget to hit the like button as well. Cheers!

[@mzs114]

Tbh, except for a few points, this was pretty superficial comparison. For instance agent based tools will work across networks restrictions. And event driven automation of salt. I don't think any of the other tools have this. Also salt has SSH b Push based feature too.

[@SimplilearnOfficial]

Hey, thank you for watching our video and for the honest feedback. We will definitely look into this. Do subscribe, like and share to stay connected with us. Cheers :)

[@mzs114]

@@SimplilearnOfficial Yeah, looks like Puppet is also introducing event driven automation from June 2020. Please do search around.

[@SimplilearnOfficial]

Sure, we will look into that.

[@farizsamanha6051]

nice explanation!!! great

[@SimplilearnOfficial]

Glad it helped!

[@shehuidris460]

Great video 👍

[@SimplilearnOfficial]

Thanks 👍

[@hiredevops1621]

excellent overview! keep going!

[@SimplilearnOfficial]

Hi, thank you for appreciating our work. We are glad to have helped. Do check out our other tutorial videos and subscribe to us to stay connected. Cheers :)

[@theadmin1982]

You need to update your video as Ansible is available in AWS.

[@SimplilearnOfficial]

Thank you for bringing that to our notice. We'll have that fixed in our next update Thank you for watching!

[@monday6740]

6:55 That's a big step backwards ... Having an easy method, like YAML, means it is easy to use, but then isn't very powerful. That's what you get when you don't have a real programming language. Remember : these tools are meant to replace scripts written on servers (CMD batch on Windows and Bash or similar on Linux/Unix). These are no real programming languages as well, but they have lots of logic nevertheless (Windows Powershell even more). In that context, YAML seems like the worst, because it does not seem to have enough logic. It risks being used to just call scripts that do have logic, like Bash, or Perl, or whatever.

[@dominikbessler2507]

Mon Day with saltstack you can write states in pure python with the py renderer

[@SimplilearnOfficial]

Thanks for your input!

[@n1cl4s]

As far as I know Ansible is available on AWS.

[@UtpalBhattacharjee]

Right

[@MrChaos2peace]

Since when Puppet was easy to setup? I find it very resource dependent and needing a tons of troubleshooting for the comm between Master -> Agent to be seamless b4 even the first proper CM runs. I am leaning more towards Ansible now, its already RHAT owned and a yum installs it.

[@SimplilearnOfficial]

As compared to Ansible, Puppet setup is definitely not as simple. Anyways, thanks for your thoughts!

[@mzs114]

Checkout salt befor deciding on DSL based tools like chef/puppet. Ansible users will experience the power of event driven automation with salt!

[@MaestroCipher]

11:48 Secure socket hashing? Are you sure?

[@koguma3928]

Might have meant Secure Jungle Hashing... where you run through the jungle with a buddy.

[@MaestroCipher]

@@koguma3928 😂😂😂🌴🌴🌴 to the point!

[@ahmadpoorgholam8964]

awsome

[@SimplilearnOfficial]

Thank you!

[@sirius4k]

I went from only having heard about Ansible and being able to proficiently provision Windows/Linux endpoints in a couple of months, so I'll give my vote for Ansible. Their documentation is very good, not perfect. I checked how Puppet configuration blocks or tasks look like, compared to Ansible, and I didn't like that at all. By using these tools, you are looking to easily manage a large number of endpoints, Puppet seems to go the other way in that regard. Edit: Oh, and no Agents, which is the best.

[@SimplilearnOfficial]

Thanks for watching our video and sharing your thoughts. Do subscribe to our channel and stay tuned for more. Cheers!

[@1MartinArmy]

I would say SSH is a "Secure Shell".

[@karendn20]

What do you mean, "Chef" is a "Knife tool" in communication? It includes both SSL and SSH?

[@SimplilearnOfficial]

You can go for becoming an AWS solutions architect. You can check out this video to learn more: kzbin.info/www/bejne/rmLLp35uZdCAo9E. Hope that helps!

[@SilentSolution]

Nice

[@SimplilearnOfficial]

Thanks. Cheers!

[@Knackiii]

i choose saltStack in my team

[@SimplilearnOfficial]

That's great! So show your love by subscribing to our channel. Cheer!

[@mzs114]

I choose salt after 4 years of work with Ansible, it has better model.

[@ruimingxie7171]

could u please share the powerpoint in this video, thank u very much

[@SimplilearnOfficial]

Hi, thanks for watching our video. You can check the slides by clicking here: www.slideshare.net/Simplilearn/chef-vs-puppet-vs-ansible-vs-saltstack-configuration-management-tools-dev-ops-tools-simplilearn-120294258

[@SimplilearnOfficial]

Very welcome!

[@yevgenyzamsky1558]

Ansible uses WinRM to interact with Windows machines, as far as I know.

[@ronanluciopereira8800]

Very good. Thanks a lot. One question I have is which of this tool supports deploying to clients on private networks behind NAT. I mean when you have servers on private networks distributed on different locations

[@mzs114]

I would suggest salt, has yaml not some DSL, but any toll with an agent should work.

[@akshayareddykaipu2583]

I am looking for someone who can help me with the Hyperion installation and configuration using puppet scripts. Any help would be greatly appreciated. Thanks

[@mansoorahmed2121]

But puppet also use YAML?

[@SimplilearnOfficial]

YAML is used in Puppet for mainly providing a hierarchy for the data. That's very minimal as compared to how Ansible uses YAML. Happy Learning!

[@DeepakSharma-iu6wn]

Ansible is also use declarative approach not procedural

[@SimplilearnOfficial]

Glad you enjoyed our video! We have a ton more videos like this on our channel. We hope you will join our community!

[@TheDreamzFactory]

Guys, I am little new to this battle, Does Ansible provide automatic configuration restore for a host? I believe such a thing is possible in chef, Wherein if any host's configuration is diverged let's say manually deleting the package, It will be restored automatically w.r.t its the configuration defined in chef cookbooks.

[@SimplilearnOfficial]

Yes, this is provided by all 4 tools. Thanks.

[@TheDreamzFactory]

@@SimplilearnOfficial Could you please let me know this in ansible perspective how it is achieved, Appreciate your response.

[@SimplilearnOfficial]

Watch our tutorial on Ansible to get a better understanding of how Ansible achieves everything mentioned here: kzbin.info/www/bejne/np3LnoR4j8-VrM0.

[@SM-ok3sz]

You pronounce declarative like decorative.

[@SimplilearnOfficial]

Good eye! Our mistake.

[@puyatecla9903]

The future of linux is dark, knowledge is fading away people are more interested in Windows-nization, why don't you just make linux a "dockerized app"? or kubernetted one is you prefer

[@SimplilearnOfficial]

Thanks for sharing your input. And yes, we can make deodorized applications: developers.keboola.com/extend/component/docker-tutorial/howto/.

[@jimmmaximilia2913]

Im learning Powershell DSC..