CHINA INDIA IN THE WORLD ORDER : A CHINESE PERSPECTIVE / LT GEN PR SHANKAR

[@estchu]

The problem with India is that it fails in every front in the comparisons except for the population. It generates much animosity by insisting to make frivolous compares like the kids in the school yard.

[@edwinkant]

@@estchu they dropping their jets at world record

[@LakesouthTiger-tw6es]

China and India lack mutual trust is more on the India side rather than China side. Contrary to many Indian's believe, China does not have much hostility against India. But India is hostile against China. India pulls out from RCEP in last minute because of China, India is against Belt and Road initiative because of Pakistan, India actively joins US's effort in containing China. India has to think hard on what is the most pressing issue for India: Is it the risk posed by China's rapid development or is it the lack of desired progress of India's economic development. Regardless how much military budget India plans to increase, India will not be able catch up with China because China GDP is 4.5 time of India. Back 40 years ago, right at the beginning of China's economic reform, Deng Xiaping decided to cut the military budget by half despite facing the threat from Soviet Union and had a border wat with Vietnam. Thing gradually improved since that time. India can take a lesson from that.

[@MarkMiller304]

@@LakesouthTiger-tw6es China is confident in its abilities while India is insecure about what it’s lacking. When you have a chip on your shoulders it breeds irrational fear. There’s also a difference on how each country deals with fear. China sees it as a problem that can be fixed while India pretends it’s not a problem then blames the problem on someone else when it could no longer be fixed.

[@healthlivinglifechoices9984]

They keep on harping China is the enemy...

[@glcr1062]

I only have one question for india friends, what is your National Language?

[@tupolevi]

ingariiiiishix

[@merrick6484]

Almost half of the population don‘t understand when PM Modi makes a speech. 😁😁😁 Every Indians love to talk, but everyone lost in translation. A fail state.

[@hangu4267]

作为一个中国人，我们好像对印度没有啥好关心的。 虽然离的很近，但好像没有啥可比性。 除了佛教发源于印度，其他，我天朝没和你们有任何关系吧。

[@Saba7a]

Similarly, INDIA is Not interested in Communist China, however, if it affects INDIA’s National and Security interests as well as INDIA’s SOVEREIGNTY, then INDIA as Necessity Has to take relevant proactive actions accordingly. That’s All.

[@wilson2009yao]

佛教跟中印没有关系：中国国内没有几个信佛的，而且国内的佛教教义与原始教义不同，而且佛教也不是来自印度，而是来自尼泊尔。 说到底，两个国家就是没有关系，无论从那些方面来看都是没有关系，也实在看不出有必要发展两国关系

[@UserUse-l9r]

@@wilson2009yao Right 😊😊🙏

[@samlin3865]

@@hangu4267 对于中国，印度只是一个可以用棍棒解决的小麻烦。要是印度要对中国的最先进武器感到担心不安的，那将是众生无法摆脱的烦恼。为什么不先想想改变你们贫穷肮脏的生活环境，多尊重保护你们的妇女免受强奸，让你们的母亲，姐妹生活的安全，人民的幸福生活，这些才是一个国家民族强大的必要条件。

[@davidchakravarty6836]

@@wilson2009yao Buddhism came from India, Buddha received enlightenment at Bodh Gaya which is in Bihar province of India. He used to speak in Pali and sanskrit which are Indian languages. His name Siddhartha is Indian name. His place of birth was Lumbini (presently in Nepal). During those days Nepal used to be part of Bharata (India). Get ur facts correct. If u read and learn with slant chinki eyes that's what happens. Or maybe it is CCP education?

[@engsudatta276]

Trust is an important value in Chinese inter-personal, inter-business and even inter-national relationship. But from what Modi government had done on handling border conflicts, curbing and banning Chinese enterprises, investments and apps in India, geopolitical issues, such as joining Quad .... China has no trust in India, as the Chineese saying goes: "Listen what he says and watch what he does". Chinese have learnt enough lessons in their encounters in and with India. Now, it is more cautious in its relationship with India, far different than 10 years before.

[@wilson2009yao]

As a Chinese, I have to say, 1. there is barely no relationship between China and India, no matter in economic, political, military, or others from bilateral perspective. So, no relationship => no need to trust a stranger at all. And no need to control difference at all. 2. there is no similarity in between, no matter in economic, political, military, or others, from domestic perspective. 3. there was, is and will be the border issue. It is not kernel issue from both perspective, not an urgent issue either. 4. there is no cooperation at all. and there is no need to cooperate. 5. there is no competition either, therefore, I can not figure out anything China and India are competing for. For what? 6. there is barely no report of India in China's governance media. Previously, there are some in Chinese social media, but after VISA is banned by India, there is barely no. 7. Whoever become India's PM, it is not China's business, but India's domestic business. No matter whether Modi governs India 10 years or 100 years, there is barely no relationship to China at all. 8. Belt and Road is a multilateral proposal, not a forced business . If you hate it, just skip it. China does not force India to accept it. 9. Nuclear supplier group(NSG) has no exception to any state. China is not a member of NSG(since 1974) till they signed the NPT lease in 1992 and became a member of NSG in 2004. If India does not want to sign NPT, India will be rejected for ever. 10. China has only one issue, Taiwan issue, since 1949. Other issue including Xinjiang is only a propaganda from the Western world. They can sick China by new Chinese Issues in future in their propaganda, but can change nothing at all. 11. If the third-party(eg, Japan, S.Korea, ASEAN, Mid-East, or others) does not accept India's claim, do not blame China. Like the namely Global South, do they accept India's leadership? Really doubt. 12.It seems India always wants to make use of global issue, eg, the trade-war between China and US. But since 2017 of its breakthrough, it seems India benefits barely nothing from it. Eg, India's trade is not improved much as expected since 2017. 13.What did India got from India-Pacific Strategy, QUAD, or others? Got better Investment, trading, Free Trade Deal, or others? I can barely figure out nothing. 14. India's economy is inflated too much. Eg, India's GDP of 2023 is almost equivalent as China's in 2007. There about 4 million cars sold in India in 2023, while 8 million car sold in China in 2007. Meanwhile, about 40% of cars sold in India are

[@ranganathhegde908]

There is a relation Enemy

[@一宏-j5d]

我支持你的看法👍就是文章过于太长！😅

[@biggwong6912]

An Indian talked about Chinese perspective, more BS than facts. I stop watching it.

[@agborebot28]

China had border problems with Russia and still takes Russia as a best friend because China knew that it's through Russia that he can have global backup and security. India would have done same with China. India still has a long way to go because even most of his cities are still very undeveloped and 80% of the population still in poverty. China is far ahead of India in every domain except population

[@gshrdy5415]

China is trying to fight with every country around it, didn't see with your eyes open?.

[@lachen7]

India is spending a lot on their military on numerous low intensity conflicts. A few soldiers death here and there doesn't bother the establishment that much. But they need to realise that this is a no win situation. India needs to quickly resolve these issues. Nagaland, Manipur, Assam, Arunachal, Mizoram, Meghalaya, Tripura, Kashmir to name a few.

[@ShenQingYi]

India always think they are very great and always want to compare with China. I think India should go and compare with USA or UK .

[@healthlivinglifechoices9984]

In the west they are hated...for your stupid actions

[@gshrdy5415]

Dude, having grown the economy not to threaten anyone, it is very hard these days, world always becomes two blocks and fight each other to wipe out humans the burden on earth, but if you have common sense you should stop the war instead of grabbing other people's land and trying to prove you are better.

[@junpengsshen-mq2ec]

India is not important to China。😂But every india expert was focus on China。😂As a Chinese ，I have to say: "Leave us alone，just leave!" 😂😂😂😂

[@霜月-b2z]

制造宗教对立，制造假想敌，是印度执政团队的惯用招数，否则它无法团结内部各种反对力量，在国家的发展和执政地位前，他只能选择保证权力还在自己手上，就像台湾民进党，它不搞反共反中，它就不能保证握有政权，至于对发展台湾经济是否有利已经不重要了

[@gshrdy5415]

Then why bother them, you bother countries like Philippines, Vietnam, Indonesia besides India, you don't leave anyone around alone idiot.

[@wionporky9937]

The Indians are over estimating themselves. The Chinese is not interested in India. They are just trying to outbid themselves. 😂😂😂

[@p.k2570]

These generals are stupid as hell thinking they know everything of geopolitics 😂😂😂😂

[@dhrubajyotidebnath6192]

Then why are you watching 😂😂😂

[@wionporky9937]

@dhrubajyotidebnath6192 Watching a comedy 😂

[@brianliew5901]

​@@dhrubajyotidebnath6192To see how Indians boast about their achievements. 😂😂😂

[@霜月-b2z]

@@dhrubajyotidebnath6192 关心世界各国的局势是中国网民的日常。就像我对lgbt不感兴趣，但我必须知道它在世界各国的发展以及各国对它的态度

[@JaiAdiShankaracharya]

Very knowledgeable session General sir 👏 Your USP is making Bharatiy audience aware of Chinese thinking which nobody does more frequently and potently than you do.. Your efforts to increase this awarenss is highly appreciated

[@triochansingh5083]

India education and culture need to be fine tuned to meet 21 century expectations .

[@jrkr7357]

Below is world power ranking : No 1. India No 2. Bharat No 3. India Mumbai No 4. India Ambani No 5. India Adani No 6. US No 7. Russia No 8. Japan . . . No 33. China

[@ChunWang-vb7yu]

🤡

[@一宏-j5d]

世界上有三个国家与地区以被殖民统治为荣的！第一是印度！第二是香港！第三是台湾！😅……

[@rtcjaco]

還有韓國、日本、菲律賓等等好嗎，不是每個國家都有力量反抗西方霸凌集團。

[@khtan585]

What a load of BS ji

[@yiminwu7549]

India is a world superpower. Love from China

[@gshrdy5415]

I don't think India wants to be a world superpower, this business of superpower involves fighting and dying of millions of soldiers on each side, I think India wants to be a superpower of peace.

[@Saba7a]

A very thorough analysis of the challenges INDIA faces from 2025 onwards. Therefore, it is very essential to thoroughly scrutinise the issue, especially the Communist China’s Surreptitious attempts in undermining INDIA’s economic and military growth at exponential rates. It is essential to spread awareness among all the patriotic Indians ( especially the Awakened Indigenous Hindus) JAI SHREE RAM !!!

[@michaelngan99]

"especially the Communist China’s Surreptitious attempts in undermining INDIA’s economic and military growth at exponential rates." LOL, DO YOU EVEN KNOW WHAT IS "EXPONENTIAL RATE"?

[@shiromaru8236]

China will never undermined India. Just watch what Rtd Lt General had explained India have continues unsecured and unable to understand China had created unnecessary issue with China. India have lost several years of opportunities to work with China instead adopting the secure habit of US seeking alliance and in the end will be left out and cry for cooperation with her biggest neighbour. By then the other global south will also catch with help of Belt and Road. India have been trying to follow big brother to BBB just look at the high speed rail with Japan still only build a few kilometres while Lao is happily running their high speed and had improved their export to China. Let’s wait and see what high speed rail India will BBB.

[@CheeLiekHo]

No need to undermine India's economy. It screwed itself as long as it pretends to be a rich and powerful superpower.

[@pyrology101]

Not easy to fool the good General.

[@CheeLiekHo]

This guy's view that China wanted a subservient India is absolutely wrong. Russia is a powerful bordering country and China is very friendly to it. It is India's political elites and media that are obsessed with comparing and beating China.

[@gshrdy5415]

India doesn't want to join any block, USA and China are trying to force India to their block, Russia is already with China.

[@ap_0011]

India has a very long way to go before it can take on CHINA . India needs to educate its population and generate employment instead of thinking of going to war with CHINA. India has been doomed not because of CHINA or any enemy from outside but from within which is the "Caste System" that has kept India down for ages. India doesn't want to address this issue, on the contrary it keeps defending and glorifying it and sugar coat it but that will only make the situation worse in times to come.

[@panyaboonc5621]

@@ap_0011 , but the western countries and many in this world preferred India keep the castes system and keep practicing their religions. Because the western countries and many others do not want to see a 2nd China in Asia to compete with them.

[@ap_0011]

@@panyaboonc5621 Blaming others for your own problems will not solve the problems. This is what India needs to understand

[@JaiAdiShankaracharya]

Hope somebody from our govt listen to you and implement your valuable suggestions

[@ascoaptwwasmqx2840]

Already with US subvert operation against India from Maldives, Khalistan to Bangladesh, India cannot foolishly take on two superpower at the same time.

[@triochansingh5083]

The Chinese, Japanese and koreans,turks, all have made their 5th gen fighter aircraft, where does india stand in this science, technology and manufacturing aspect?.Serious analysis on india failure need to be addressed.

[@gurjotsingh8934]

India is a joke on the face of this earth

[@bbharatillusion4574]

With this type of generals, you will lose every war😂😂😂

[@Shaft1367]

@@bbharatillusion4574 😂 😂

[@RamachandranNairR]

On 22 nd july 2024 Chief Economic Advisor (CEA) V. Anantha Nageswaran has suggested that India may stand to gain more by “replacing some well-chosen imports with investments from China” thus helping both boost Indian manufacturing and plugging India into the global supply chain as it looks to tap advanced economies’ push to diversify beyond China through a China plus one sourcing approach. But India is not re-thinking the issue of allowing Chinese investments into the country, Trade Minister Piyush Goyal said on 30 th july 2024. TRADE MINISTER SAID NO INVESTMENTS FROM CHINA So General, why are u crying every day on india allowing chinese investments? Is it one of ur another propaganda towards this bjp govt??

[@pyrology101]

A wicked doer giveth heed to false lips; and a liar giveth ear to a naughty tongue.

[@bobbylow175]

An Indian General talking about China’s perspective and not a Chinese General. Just think about that. All I hear are just very very salty comments and a bruised ego.

[@ganesanswaminathan1114]

Thank You in making us to think differently. Good Analysis. God Bless You.

[@yogeshbhadresa9235]

🙏 Thanks for sharing nice information. During 2025 - Modiji is visiting China for 5 days. Any comments on this visit?

[@TheKkpop1]

India is not at the same level as China. At best, you can compare it with Pakistan or Bangladesh.

[@davidchakravarty6836]

A senior officer like u who has such great understanding of China should be actively be part of NSA and Defence Ministry and Strategic decision making process, giving u free hand and autonomy. Instead we have a loose talking ex Major of the army who has a huge KZbin channel who talks nonsense half the time and only tries to play to the gallery.

[@KPAU07]

There is no comparison. 5X GDP what can you expect?

[@davidchakravarty6836]

Cooked up GDP, don't worry

[@h.stiwari10]

Happy new year Sir. Hope our defense planners are taking into consideration your analysis and concerns

[@JL-po5on]

Even per capita , India is only 1/5 of China’s, but India has always spent way much more on military percentage GDPwise comparing to China, UK 2.3% or France 2.1%, The Stockholm International Peace Research Institute calculated India’s defense expenditure at 2.4% of GDP in 2023. “By comparison, China, with its much larger economy than India’s, spends about 1.7% of its share of GDP on defense,” India has spent 40% more, way much more than Chinaper capita GDPwise year in year out , has become a country of war monger, in reality achieved 1/5 of CHina has done so far will be fair, in fact we can see what’s has lagged behind lost counts including some of which like the global GDS network, ISMB, nuclear reaction tech, Hypersonic missiles, drone techs, robotics, AIs, 3d printing, space techs are all far behind, even the electricity required to run a wind tunnel like CHina’s JF 22 , the world’s fast speed wind tunnel, which will reach Mach 30, that’s the backbone of all aviation vehicles development including 6th gen fighter, space craft, hypersonic missiles, air freighter like Y-20 or Y-40, domestic plane like C919 or 929, even us ‘s wind tunnel can reach Mach 5 only now, Chinas power generations is 2 times of us, plus all the infrastructures like HST net work, Bridges, green energy, tunnels, highways, fully automatically run sea ports ,EVs, even China’s shipping building capacity is 232 times of US, India has raised too high a bar to catch up with the most advanced fields of China, and the world’s most advanced, India is simply not worthy a peer competitor; by looking at the host and guests, they all speak English, a language of their old master, the colonizer,none of them even speaks Indian at all, that’s a clear sign of least self respect lacking(or is there a unified language existed for Indians to speak besides English?) i bet lots of the development China has made includes domestic and foreign educated intellectual asset’s devotion, i rarely see any India’s students studied abroad willing to return to India after graduation, yet China probably has a 98% return rates of US educated students after graduation, comparing with Indians, the smartest one obviously don’t love India at all. Indian are clearly braggarts, not diligent builders ,you reap what you sow. You don’t need to worry about China, China will take back what’s the British took from Tibet eventually ,but that’s all; China will not be interested to occupy India since no one with senses in China will recruit 1.4 billion Indians 5 time poorer than them, its an economical suicide.

[@kulkarniravi]

@JL-po5on nice propaganda. China's prosperity is built on fake economic bubbles which are all bursting. No institutions to speak of, one party dictatorial rule, population collapse. You forget all these and say India is not a peer. You are right, India has a greater potential and a day will come when China will be struggling to catch up.

[@SrikanthIyerTheMariner]

Yawn.

[@pyrology101]

Pride goeth before destruction, and an haughty spirit before a fall.

[@JL-po5on]

@ Wise or normal peoples know sky is not the limit, financial reality and tech advancement kills all lip service braggarts.

[@panyaboonc5621]

If China occupied India, China would have to accept the 1.4 billion of average IQ only 76, with poor education, poor hygiene, poor civil mentality, super superstitious, etc ,, to take care. China is sure going to face huge amounts of problems and will definitely pull China backward instead of moving forward. So don't worry. China is not interested in occupying India even India offer free to China. But India just wanted to take back what was belongs to them.

[@shyamprasad6823]

Very nice Podcast. An eye opener.

[@JayantKashyap]

Namaskaram general sir. __/\__ Thank you for your efforts to educate us on our number one threat.

[@vicolew]

YAWWWWNNNNNNNNNN!!!!

[@vinayakramyou]

Wishing you a very Happy New Year. God bless you and regards.

[@gunnersshot]

Happy 2025 to you too.

[@vinayakramyou]

I only hope the Government of India takes cognisance of this video?

[@PahatRout]

I have been amused by what I called: Indian plans for practically everything. Just review the reports by ADB and UNESCAP reports since the 60s where India wanted to connect practically the whole of Asia with railway and road connections. And I believe their rather ambitious plans for railway came from the fact that the British left them with a working railway system after WW2 and with that they thought they could develop the railway system! Of course, inheriting a "working system" does not equate to be able to build one from nothing! Of course, Japan had wanted the Indian's ambition to be realized. Take for example, when Taksin could not realize the DaWei Port in southern Myanmar, Japan and India was called in by ADB to connect that port to Danang (?) Of course, it could not be done because there is simply insufficient volumes to sustain that ambition of rail-road connections. One wonders as to why they tried this project when Indian proposal to connect India to Bangladesh-Myanmar-Thailand- Cambodia-Vietnam had been proposed since the 60s!

[@patrickgz]

who is winner, second, third, forth and so on is not decided by the players themselves. it is decided by judges and majority crowd. its like sports, for example football players can say what they want on cameras, but what really matters is result on field and acceptance of majority crowd of the result. its the same in all sports, even between school competition. it doesnt matter what home or away crowd thinks, its the 'outside crowd' of these spheres of influence that matters simply because they are majority. its the same as maradonna's 'hand of god' goal. what does the majority crowd think about it is what matters?

[@chtan17]

India has to rethink its foreign policy. Its grip on Maldives, Bhutan, Sri Lanka, Bangladesh, etc is getting weaker because of its childish and selfish stance. Using BRICS to keep Turkey and Pakistan shows it is abusing its position in BRICS. It makes more enemies and loses world respect for its poor sense of fairness.

[@arumugamrs]

Indian education should be Democratic, Secular and no commercial in school and college education.If it is not implemented India will not Develop.

[@AX-sq5vm]

😂china is way head Try looking in mirror

[@andrewfuzh]

India is definitely leading. Chinese is 20 years behind.

[@Sunyi_park]

we must be very careful dealing with china

[@jrkr7357]

Why you need to be careful to deal with China when you can just go deal with US ?

[@maxchi1176]

@@Sunyi_park so you just go to deal with u.s then...they your slave Master then 😂😂😂

[@rajenlama.6850]

Jai Hind sir and wishing a very happy New Year 2025 and may God keep you and your family in sound health with prosperity. You are absolutely right that abrogation of 370 in J&K is also one of the main reasons as can be seen in the back foot of China from the external border of India. Comprehensive thought analysed very beautifully and found enjoyable topic. Thank you sir.

[@RadicaSingh-h1t]

Big issue is Bangladesh Hindus

[@Saba7a]

A very thorough analysis of the challenges INDIA faces from 2025 onwards. Therefore, it is very essential to thoroughly scrutinise the issue, especially the Communist China’s Surreptitious attempts in undermining INDIA’s economic and military growth at exponential rates. It is essential to spread awareness among all the patriotic Indians ( especially the Awakened Indigenous Hindus) JAI SHREE RAM !!!