CHINA'S INVASION OF TAIWAN / MAJ GEN R NARAYANAN (R) / LT GEN P R SHANKAR (R)

#GUNNERSSHOT #InternationalRelations #UPSC #CSE #StrategicAffairs #defence
GUNNERS SHOT IS A CHANNEL FOR DEFENCE & STRATEGIC AFFAIRS, TECHNOLOGY AND WELFARE OF ARMED FORCES PERSONNEL.
GUNNERS SHOT is a channel in which the best of Indian Military and Strategic experts express their views and opinions.
GUNNERS SHOT is a non partisan channel devoted to high quality.
Support Gunners Shot with your contribution through GPay to [phone]
SUBSCRIBE TO GUNNERS SHOT KZbin CHANNEL@ / @gunnersshot9829
SUBSCRIBE TO GUNNERS SHOT TECH CHANNEL @ / @gunnersshottech-jl6gp
Join the channel as a member @ / @gunnersshot9829
THIS VIDEO IS AVAILABLE IN PODCAST FORM @ / @gunnersshot9829
Gunners Shot KZbin Channel has multiple .playlists to enhance your viewing experience.
All articles are available @ www.gunnersshot.com
‎Follow Gunners Shot WhatsApp Channel @ whatsapp.com/channel/0029VaEZ...
Twitter : @palepurshankar or @gunners_shot1
Join Telegram group @ t.me/gunnersshot
Disclaimer : Views expressed on this channel by this who appear on it are their personal opinions and can not be attributed to GUNNERS SHOT

[@G-jz1ht]

Jai Hind Jai Bharat, Good to see Narayanan ji after long gap.

[@rishipattanaik5402]

both explained beautifully the intricacies of Taiwan invasion. In news/YT without detailing most of the so-called expert will say China will easily invade Taiwan. Thanks to both of you. Jai Hind.

[@SRTendulkar999]

Living in US for last 34 years. Enjoy your show which reveals your and guests enormous expertise and experience, combined with a very logical explanation makes this a must watch show. You are absolutely correct no US government will jeopardize Taiwan’s freedom.

[@JBJP1]

This Episode is One of a Kind One of the Most Unique Shows on Gunnershot Such a show by 2 Indian Generals should create an International Buzz The Chinese Government would most likely try its level best that Chinese Citizens Are not able to Watch this Episode This Episode Takes AIR OUT of China's Macho Reckless Behavior in its Entire Neighborhood, be it Land or Sea Neighborhood Pranaam प्रणाम ਪ੍ਰਣਾਮ General Shankar sir General Narayanan sir

[@ramtal1125]

In light of superb podcast, adversary may try to grab territory from Bharat..also cannot depend on West for Asian partners to support. If cheen attacks taiwaan, Bharat should score and checkmate to take back occupied territory 😇 Congratulations for great efforts to educate Aam Janata and Dharmic Janata worldwide 🙏🏻👍👏👌

[@MsRkshukla]

China is not the China of 1962.That was a war hardened PLA just fresh from victory of 1949 war.Now they are weak paper dragons

[@divyarajbisen9853]

Super episode!!! Jai Hind Jai Bharat!!

[@hrushikeshtrivedi6792]

Great! Reminded me of studies for DSSC, Falkland & Gen Mcarthur at Inchon! Add :- Only internal stooge in Taiwan can give effects…else impossible Landings

[@Bhupeshsharma92]

Jai hind jay Bharat

[@padmavatigroup]

Jai Hind both General sir, Narayanan sir you have amazing knowledge & done mazing research, Keep it On sirji specially belong to Mother India ( Bharat ), because as younger I think our young generation should know Glory of BHARAT.

[@gunnersshot9829]

thanks

[@animishkhatawkar]

Listening to you both, is always music to my ears....... जय हिंद, वंदे मातरम.

[@sarikajain4566]

Bharat Grows & China Slows. Jai Bharat 🚩🇮🇳

[@TheKvjoshi]

Very detail information, glad to watch it.

[@gurdeepsingh1403]

Sat sri akaal Honorable Naraynan sahib ji Shankar sahib ji as well all listeners,as always wonderful analysis... JAI HIND, VANDEMATRAM...

[@dineshm3470]

It is very interesting to listen you both veterans

[@shreyanshgupta7648]

Namaskar Rajiv Sir ,Shankar Sir.Thanks for conducted this fantastic, knowledgeable show in Hindi. 🙏🙏

[@pristinethroat8103]

Thanks for the information and perspective .

[@viramshah]

Fantastic Analysis Generals, Jai Hind ❤

[@govindsharma3600]

Masterclass!

[@vihangwaze96]

I liked this discussion. Very beautiful & detailed analysis. Salute to you both respected Sir

[@gunnersshot9829]

Thanks a ton

[@Govindan7]

After watching the video, I suddenly remembered the Battle of Waterloo. Waterloo Battlefield, location, 3 miles (5 km) south of Waterloo, Belgium, where, on June 18, 1815, the Battle of Waterloo took place, marking Napoleon’s final defeat. In this battle, the British Duke of Wellington’s 68,000 allied forces, including British, Dutch, Belgian, and German troops, and some 45,000 Prussians led by Gebhard Leberecht von Blücher, overcame a 72,000-strong French army in a battle described by Wellington as “the nearest run thing you ever saw in your life.” The battle changed the course of European history. If there is a Naval war in South China, Asian History will change. India's unreliable superpower instigated the Chinese to attack when the country was suffering from COVID-19 to wipe out two growing Asian powers. Whoever follows Dharma, Sri Krishna will support.

[@kunalbahl1985]

jai hind jai bharat

[@edge1688]

Jai hind sir

[@user-qx2zi1fb8c]

sea mines bhi toh hongi china ke swagat ke liye also, china has no experience of a war after Vietnam. Kaise Karega

[@amrutk5]

🎉

[@shrutiChandak74]

Namaskar 🙏💐

[@vikrambakshi5959]

More discussion on Airborne assault capability to secure beach head will be most appreciated Sir

[@gunnersshot9829]

That complicates the problem even more

[@Sahil36000]

Awesome discussion from both Military heads. Just one question sir to both Lt Gen Shankar and Major Gen Narayan. I see that the china would not be in position to invade. Lets assume that states also intervene along with Philippines South korea and Japan. Do you think it will turn into a nuke flash point, meaning dooms day for the world ?

[@gunnersshot9829]

possible...

[@suhasdoke1157]

Fotunate to watch both Maharathis explaining the whole scnario to a very fine grain

[@sanasama2209]

34:50 General! A correction - Mountains in Taiwan don't get snow, it's only a rare phenomenon when they get

[@gunnersshot9829]

Taiwan's climate is subtropical, except for the very southern part of the island, which is tropical. Summers are long and hot, lasting from April or May to September or October. The winters are short and mild, although snow does fall in the mountains and occasionally at lower elevations in the north. The biggest snowfalls are normally in January and March and on average snow falls around 24 days each winter, Snow Mountain 雪山 is Taiwan’s second highest peak (not counting Jade Mountain’s sub-peaks) and is possibly the most beautiful place in the whole of Taiwan. The main peak is 3886m above sea-level making it a very cold place to be in winter but the scenery is second to none.www.flickr.com/photos/stuintaiwan/4261972145/

[@vikrambakshi5959]

Sir, if there are cross channel relations won't the reverse work for the Taiwanese not to oppose a landing??

[@gunnersshot9829]

Possible

[@vikrambakshi5959]

Sir, I am certain that the PLA would have thought through all this. What do you think is their plan to overcome these issues to enable invasion of Taiwan

[@gunnersshot9829]

Ask them

[@letsfight9472]

🫡

[@MrSudhir61]

Sir ये वाला सर के ऊपर से निकल गया 😀

[@gunnersshot9829]

Sar upar karne seeko.

[@JaiAdiShankaracharya]

General Sir, in ancient context if mighty Cholas can conquere ASEAN territories, in the similar context why can't modern PLAN retake Formosa

[@gunnersshot9829]

hmm

[@rajeshgargav-ve9dr]

SIR YADI CHAINA TAIWAN PAR HAMLA KARTA HAI TO KAYA AMERICA PURI TAKAT SE TAIWAN KO BACHAYEGA KAYA AMERICAN NAVY SIDHE CHAINA SE FIGHT KAREGI ESME SHAK KI BAHUT GUNJAISH HAI KAYA TAIWAN AMERICA PAR 100 PERCENT NIRBHAR RAH SAKTA HAI KAYA AMERICA KE LIYE TAIWAN ETNA VALUABL HAI YEH SAB DEKHNE KI BAAT HAI

[@gunnersshot9829]

Hmm

[@vijayahuja7698]

Good Morning Sir, Thanks but I think new war will not be on conventional normandy terms. War gaming with help of thousands of Drones, Rockets, submarines, space war and as you mentioned 12:1 so sending soldiers during peace time deceptively so that they can create ruckus and /or attack from inside. Sorry just rookie thoughts😅. Pranam

[@gunnersshot9829]

You are out of depth. Believe what we say….drones rockets etc don’t offset 200 km of sea

[@vijayahuja7698]

@@gunnersshot9829 Ok got it Sir, thanks for the reply

[@ShangDaiNagaland]

If US,Japan,S.Korea, Phillipines are in Taiwan contingency ,What if Russian Army and North Korea comes to China's assistance?. I think in that case it will be a protracted war or may eventually lead to Nuclear exchange.

[@gunnersshot9829]

Hmm

[@sunilbhatia8622]

Sir, Has China occupied Indian territories to the tune of about 4000 SQ KM previously under our control and pushed back the No Man’s Land into our territory. I have also heard the post where Maj Shaitan Singh had made the supreme sacrifice of his life and awarded PVC has been dismantled by the Indian army.

[@gunnersshot9829]

Lot of rumours

[@TheKvjoshi]

What about attack from south of Iceland, where Taiwan is not expecting. Can China over power Taiwan?

[@gunnersshot9829]

not possible

[@JBJP1]

Question: The Nature of the Topic was very serious tonight But the Tone of the 2 Generals was marked also by an Element of Sarcasm, Humour (if tongue in cheek) and The Style of Narration Itself (was to a Layman's Ears) seemed intended to MOCK, Belittle PLA's or CCP's or Xi's Seemingly Mad Ambitions Is this Meant to Give/Convey a Message to the Enemy as Well ? Does this Tone carry a Geo Political Message as well.. Is it part of giving a Blow to Morale of the Enemy ? Is this a Part of Military Diplomacy Or Military Messaging As well ? Or ... Besides the Contents of the Episode tonight, Other parts.... Tone & Style were just coincidental ?

[@robythomas6535]

A correction to your maritimel inputs. PLAN is a confirmed Blue Water Navy, not brown water. The commentry on PLAN aircraft carrier operations and naval operations is plain wrong. Please do not expose the panel to naval ops.

[@gunnersshot9829]

That is your view. Not ours.

[@JaiRudraNath]

Inspite of our wishes, China is now No 1 power in the world if I see - area, military capabilities, access to resources, influence and everything combined " comprehensive national power" And we are begging for talks with China with nothing on table to negotiate with .. this shows where we are in terms of our policies.. and they are building roads on PoK as well for years now.. I suggest instead of shaming them, we need to rethink where we are going wrong in our belief system.. its clearly not working.. We want countries around to love us .. China wants countries around to fear them.. I think they had many success stories to tell their children why they are right .. China learnt their lesson in 100 years of national humiliation.. we never learnt our lessons in 1000 years of total humiliation.. and still hazy about how things work ..

[@gunnersshot9829]

hmm...ignorance is bliss

[@Sam14342]

​@@JaiRudraNath China Is playing Long Term game. China is working to improve its capabilities. China will not attack Taiwan -India before 2040.

[@ricarica2194]

Unabke ti understand completely on hindi. Non from south can understand so we have to just skip this specific videos

[@Govindan7]

Read my comment. I think this is a more complicated operation than the Normandy operation."Has the balance of power ever changed so much in so little time than at the Battle of Midway? In the space of just 5 minutes, American dive bombers scored hits on three Japanese aircraft carriers, dramatically turning the tide of the war in the Pacific. Taiwan's straight width is 180 Km. If Taiwan starts using Supersonic missiles every Chinese Ship numbering 680 ships can be destroyed within five minutes not three Warships. "252,000 active personnel (2024) 680 ships (2024) 198 aircraft (2024)". To destroy 680 Chinese warships, Taiwan requires only 700 missiles. It can be launched from mountains/ hills. Taiwan Island's width is 144 Km. So the missile range should be 144 Km + 180 = 324 Km. So China can't capture Taiwan.

[@thexfactor3097]

59:15 - 59:35 same is true for India but the Taiwan is Pakistan... See China won't say we'll fight US as openly as they say about taiwan, similarly India doesn't say that much about China either because it's just too powerful, so Pakistan is the best option

[@gunnersshot9829]

Hmm

[@chaitanyadharmadhikari3517]

Will India be the target if Taiwan is difficult to conquer?

[@gunnersshot9829]

may be.

[@mkavinraaj9916]

can you do it in english so that "INDIANS" can understand.

[@gunnersshot9829]

That is an offensive statement

[@sumitsingh3938]

Totally one sided discussion . Its better to have a counterpart especially from china.

[@gunnersshot9829]

Hmm

[@Amitesh888]

Sir why are thinking that China will take Taiwan by force it also take it peacefully there can be also peaceful reunification and xi will also prefer that.

[@gunnersshot9829]

watch the video again...I have spoken of it.

[@Amitesh888]

@@gunnersshot9829 Sir I have watched half.Sir I have watched half.

[@akatokzhimoakatokzhimo9433]

Advertise ,kills my mood everytime, this advertise have rights to kill my mood?

[@gunnersshot9829]

????

[@Red.bulldozer3]

While indians are expecting possible invasion of Taiwan by China, they failed to realise China quietly building up forces to occupy rest of ladakh and Arunachal Pradesh 😂

[@gunnersshot9829]

You and your propaganda...perfect ass

[@gautamtendulkar8808]

Jai Hind Jai Bharat