CHINA'S PERCEPTION OF THE BORDER PROBLEM / LT GEN P R SHANKAR (R)

#GUNNERSSHOT #InternationalRelations #UPSC #CSE #StrategicAffairs #defence
CHINA'S PERCEPTION OF THE BORDER PROBLEM / LT GEN P R SHANKAR (R)
GUNNERS SHOT IS A CHANNEL FOR DEFENCE & STRATEGIC AFFAIRS, TECHNOLOGY AND WELFARE OF ARMED FORCES PERSONNEL.
GUNNERS SHOT is a channel in which the best of Indian Military and Strategic experts express their views and opinions.
GUNNERS SHOT is a non partisan channel devoted to high quality.
Support Gunners Shot with your contribution through GPay to [phone]
SUBSCRIBE TO GUNNERS SHOT KZbin CHANNEL@ / @gunnersshot
SUBSCRIBE TO GUNNERS SHOT TECH CHANNEL @ / @gunnersshottech-jl6gp
Join the channel as a member @ / @gunnersshot
THIS VIDEO IS AVAILABLE IN PODCAST FORM @ / @gunnersshot
Gunners Shot KZbin Channel has multiple .playlists to enhance your viewing experience.
All articles are available @ www.gunnersshot.com
‎Follow Gunners Shot WhatsApp Channel @ whatsapp.com/c...
Twitter : @palepurshankar or @gunners_shot1
Join Telegram group @ t.me/gunnersshot
Disclaimer : Views expressed on this channel by this who appear on it are their personal opinions and can not be attributed to GUNNERS SHOT

[@MustafaHassan-g4s]

Amazing conversation. Love from Peshawar, Pakistan.

[@draloksharma]

As long we have people like you, India shall shine. Thank you General

[@pyrology101]

Another masterclass General. Looking forward to tomorrow's collaboration with PGurus.

[@Maltman55]

Thanks!

[@anilp2297]

General, a very fresh perspective. Thank you.

[@BharatiyaVaasi]

A phenomenal session sir!

[@rgzutshi]

जय हिंद Gen Sir! Request you please do consider that people haven't had the privilege of seeing the things that you've seen or been to places you've been to so the writings reflect the same. With you sharing your experience writings and perspective will improve.

[@lajranitalwar7173]

Fully AGREE WITH YOU. THEIR DEESCALATING AT FEW PLACES MIGHT BE TAKEN AS ACCEPTANCE OF POST '62. SAYING CONTENTION HAS RESOLVED TO 75% IS PLAYING IN THEIR HANDS😢

[@manofsan]

Sir, can you talk about BRICS more, in the future?

[@gunnersshot]

Ok

[@skanil8453]

So far we have identified the problems and perceptions, but the moot question is how to overcome the problems.

[@lajranitalwar7173]

General Saheh, you have read China in its stark . . . 😊

[@gautamganguli1221]

I heard Dr Jaishankar- he did say that 75% of the problem is solved- but only in the points of dispute at the L:adakh sector.

[@gunnersshot]

Hmm

[@birkaransingh6392]

Yup its reversible

[@Sudusa]

Chi'n must realise why they built great wall of china

[@rajenlama.6850]

Sir, you have asserted each and every minute thing/policy of China in black and white. You also said in this audio video, Britishers left us in problem obviously correct . When will China stop the ideology of imperialism ?

[@sabesankandasamy9331]

China will never allow another Asian power to emerge especially India and Japan, economically and strategically.

[@tonyraheja1]

Very enlightening sir.. Thanks.. Appreciate the clarity on the muddled 'Chinese Perception' Looking forward to more such videos.

[@biggpicture2930]

Perception of india's neighbouring nation, non china? Posting found Let's see how much land India has taken from his neighbors. ---Annexed Kalapani from Nepal in 1962; ---Annexed Turtuk from Pakistan in 1971; ---Separated Eastern Pakistan from Pakistan to become Bangladesh in 1971; ---Annexed Tin Bigha from Bangladesh in 1972; ---Annexed Sikkim to become one of its states in 1975; ---Tried to invade Mauritius but failed in 1983; ---Committed massacres of Sikhism, captured their territories and attacked Harmandir Sahib so Sikhism believers assassinated Indian Prime Minister Indira Gandhi in 1984; ---Invaded Sri Lanka in 1987; ---1st time invaded Bhutan and failed in 1990 due to international pressure, but has controlled its defense and diplomatic affairs till now; ---Supported and financed the terrorist organization Tamil LTTE to rebel against Sri Lanka government but gave it up later under great international pressure. The betray triggered huge anger of LTTE so it assassinated its Prime Minister Rajiv Gandhi in 1991; ---Annexed Dooars from Bhutan in 2006; ---Annexed Moreh from Myanmar in 2013; ---2nd time invaded Bhutan but failed in 2017 due to international pressure; ---Tried to invade Maldives in 2018; ---Invaded Nepal and one of its soldiers was shot dead by Nepal Security force in Jun of 2020; ---Keeps nibbling lands from ChinaTibett and Kashmir that led to a war in 1962 and border conflicts with China till today; ---Keeps nibbling lands from Pakistan Kashmir that led to daily border wars and gun fights; ---And more….

[@tonyraheja1]

Oops.. I didn't know all that... Should be discussed

[@sandeepreddy6295]

@@tonyraheja1 @biggpicture2930 lists all lies. If you want to know about the 1962 war, then read - Himalayan Blunder by Brig JP Dahlvi

[@lajranitalwar7173]

TIBET TIBET . . . TIBET😮

[@georgezwills]

It is not our government or tri-services' forward policy Sir. It is Bharatwasi's policy and it has 2 steps, 1st secure Bharat's original Eastern borders, and 2nd restore Tibet as our neighbour, R.O.C. and P.R.C. both are fired from being our neighbour, and till we achieve this we will keep on electing strong government which gives free hand to our tri-services to achieve our 2 steps... very simple to understand and difficult to accept.. yeh toh hokar rahega.. Rezang-La ki veer C-Company ki kasam, Veer Shaitansinh ki kasam..

[@gunnersshot]

Hmm

[@jkthink78-q1x]

Great analysis General Sir. I am wondering if China is ambiguous to India’s position i.e. they are not sure if India is an independent player or a US ally. This causes it to be aggressive locally and friendly globally. The net effect is an India-China border dispute ends up benefiting US in the Pacific and Taiwan. Second China’s idea of power is “active domination” i.e. be seen at all times growing economically/ politically/territorial etc. That as you can imagine puts them at odds with everyone including India. India’s idea of power is “passive in the short run but opportunistic in the long run”; we are somewhat dormant but we wake up sporadically to big opportunities and that scares the devilry out of China who believe in “active domination on all fronts”.

[@gunnersshot]

Hmm

[@karnakarna4490]

China has stomach for dispute for a long time we do not have . We want peace by conceding on all vital points .

[@sandeepreddy6295]

Their stomach for a long term dispute may be one more facade.

[@yadurmahabala1313]

Simla convention of 1914 had failed.

[@Gear_labs]

I think India will soon start talking about border after unsc seet confirmation then single dispute on border 😅

[@lajranitalwar7173]

DON'T GET DECEPTED BY CHINA

[@AmalTan]

Came to know about something completely new today. I also believe that India-China relations are so structurally antagonistic, that we cannot be friends for atleast a century. However with China getting weak in the future as you have explained. It can end up like USSR. In that condition US unipolarity would return, something not good for India. Thats why I think we should not completely ally with US against China. What do you think Sir?

[@gunnersshot]

Hmm

[@biggpicture2930]

Comparitively, india is way more instable.

[@AmalTan]

@@biggpicture2930 Democracies look like that, but are much more resilient.

[@adm7038]

It is China’s aim to ensure all peripheral nations, especially India never possess a challenge in the future. They will seek to continuously minimize our presence in the Himalayas all they way to the plains. Likewise when we gain strength it will be in our interest to minimize Chinese capabilities in Tibet and ensure our northern plains are well protected. They only way to solve this is the reestablishment of an independent Tibet. Tibet needs to be strictly neutral much like Switzerland in Europe. Anything less than this will only keep the pot boiling permanently.

[@biggpicture2930]

But independent tibet is never the intention of india. India thinks it inherited the british india and thinks tibet, myamar etc should be part of india, and have been annexing surrounding nations since independence

[@jatinpatel1224]

India has no border with China, that is stand and stance of Indians. Inept politicians do not know how to teach Yunnan, Tibet, Uighur, Mongolia and Manchuria occupier. We condemn global manipulator in chief by currency exchange rates, promoting corruption in democracies, exploiting minerals and labor in China, violating human rights, no democracy in China leading to autocratic rule, and not raising this issue by EU, US the champions of business, trade, human rights etc etc etc, with naive, inept, corrupt and gullible politicians of jhumlatantra and lootmar-e-khangress have denigrated interests of Indians. China is not called out for violating all issues. Liberate Tibet and end this issue, break the bones of PLA princes, abduct agrresive PLA intrusions and negotiate from strength instead of talking and talking and talking. You retired General, and still keep analyzing instead of doing karma to get where we need to be. Thank you for not doing your karma when you were General. You should focus your discussion on eastern border of Tibet and discuss why Indian army does not target the highway build by PLA through J&K and CPEC through PoJK.

[@gautamganguli1221]

You ignore the policies of the Govt of India in Delhi over 75 years which vastly increased the military as well as economic disparity between India and China and India adopted a meek and submissive attitude. Today we have to solve today's problems with a vastly powerful and absolutely unscrupulous neighbor bidding to be tomorrow's superpower.On what basis do you blame retired generals for decisions and mismanagement of the Delhi based Government of India and its successive ministers?

[@biggpicture2930]

You also ignore your neighboring nations. Perception of india's neighbouring nation, non china? Posting found Let's see how much land India has taken from his neighbors. ---Annexed Kalapani from Nepal in 1962; ---Annexed Turtuk from Pakistan in 1971; ---Separated Eastern Pakistan from Pakistan to become Bangladesh in 1971; ---Annexed Tin Bigha from Bangladesh in 1972; ---Annexed Sikkim to become one of its states in 1975; ---Tried to invade Mauritius but failed in 1983; ---Committed massacres of Sikhism, captured their territories and attacked Harmandir Sahib so Sikhism believers assassinated Indian Prime Minister Indira Gandhi in 1984; ---Invaded Sri Lanka in 1987; ---1st time invaded Bhutan and failed in 1990 due to international pressure, but has controlled its defense and diplomatic affairs till now; ---Supported and financed the terrorist organization Tamil LTTE to rebel against Sri Lanka government but gave it up later under great international pressure. The betray triggered huge anger of LTTE so it assassinated its Prime Minister Rajiv Gandhi in 1991; ---Annexed Dooars from Bhutan in 2006; ---Annexed Moreh from Myanmar in 2013; ---2nd time invaded Bhutan but failed in 2017 due to international pressure; ---Tried to invade Maldives in 2018; ---Invaded Nepal and one of its soldiers was shot dead by Nepal Security force in Jun of 2020; ---Keeps nibbling lands from ChinaTibett and Kashmir that led to a war in 1962 and border conflicts with China till today; ---Keeps nibbling lands from Pakistan Kashmir that led to daily border wars and gun fights; ---And more….

[@biggpicture2930]

But how to negotiate from strength, when you are weakling? Talk louder?

[@gautamganguli1221]

@@biggpicture2930 I am not sure if you're a Chinese bot.The entire litany you sing is a tissue of lies.

[@gautamganguli1221]

@@biggpicture2930 Nobody is a weakling. Everybody has strengths and weaknesses.In the Galwan stand off the occupation of the Kailash Ridge put the Chinese on the back foot during subsequent negotiations. At Yang Tse the repulsion of 300 Chinese soldiers put China on the back foot there.The same thing repeated frequently on a larger scale is the key. Because on paper the Chinese are more powerful than India.

[@NaggarajCH]

Sri, Please hindi to reach every Indian

[@kunasagaran5740]

What about the people at international level? Instead there should be one session in Hindi and one in English. This channel educates the world about India.

[@huanwang-ur5ve]

friends, india ganna falling aparts in few years

[@gunnersshot]

Really! Ha ha