Christina Aguilera Vs Beyoncé - Who Sings Better (Same Song Challenge)

Xtina Vs Bey
The Voice of her generation Vs Bey
Songs:
New York,New York 00:20
Diamonds Are a Girl' Best Friend 02:01
At Last 03:01
I Will Always Love You 05:39
A Song for You 06:15

[@c_0910_K]

Beyonce sounds more accurate, clean, polished but Christina sounds more 'alive'.

[@buteratellme7194]

Beyoncé has better technique, so neat and well-executed Xtina has raw emotion

[@lloydr64able]

Xtina has the soul in her voice, beyonce is a ok singer, but in years to come there will be many more who can sing like beyonce, there will only be one christina aguilera!

[@jacocharzukanamericanautho2422]

Nah Xtina blows her outa the water badly! Beyoncé is good but she is overrated. Her power and range is far above Bey’s by a land slide. Their technical ability isn’t even comparable. Xtina is the greatest ever.

[@LIONARTO]

It's likely a thing of DNA rather so Born talent in voices are bit more common in black ppl but some Slavics also have superb voices

[@miri3977]

@@jacocharzukanamericanautho2422 Xtina will never compare to beyonce in this lifetime with her pushed and tense belts.Beyonce is better in every single register

[@sandhyanagarajan]

@@miri3977 I know! Xtina strains and pushes for all her belts, Beyonce's belts are tension-free. Also Beyonce has better low notes and more developed head voice.

[@sophieokalaga3142]

Christina has a better tone but Beyonce use a better technic

[@spanishlessons4075]

Exactly what I think, too.

[@jacocharzukanamericanautho2422]

Christina stomps in every way.

[@UughPeople]

This is pretty accurate ♥️

[@ernesfonse]

X has the emotion.

[@truthteller7228]

I love christina voice better

[@kamorirandall2752]

Christina diamonds are a girls best friend won me over

[@KylieMariayt]

Beyonces voice has never given me chills like Xtinas. Xtina is just on another level.

[@yaidelmarin4002]

But technically Beyonce is better, has much much control and can't pick high notes without growls, Christina Aguilera, never do it, it like she can lose the capacity to do it unless she is soprano and clearly her belting is more higher than the belting of Beyonce( although being mezzosoprano her belting is really high, but Christina's belting is one or two semitones over. If I must choose one I choose better control and technically if it still sound perfectly great

[@mysterycharm03]

@@yaidelmarin4002lol beyonce is a conventional vocalist and yes she adheres to the standard style of singing because she is restraining probably due too fear of damaging her voice or just by learning singing from a young age contrary to the people who actually are considered prodigies like Christina where singing talent is innate even without training at a very young age, they already have ears, absolute pitch and tone. I will disagree with the narrative that xtina is not a technical vocalist because she is actually is. She can restrain if she wants and use her natural voice (say something, save me from myself) but she growls, screech, when she belts she strains and becomes raspy but can still extend from its limits because she intended too. She is inspired by soul and jazz singing so she do both ways, restrain or unrestraint. Christina's voice is still intact contrary to her other peers where it already declined with constantly changing her singing styles, her voice texture and tone, she is defintely a technical singer. Aint no other man, fighter for example these songs are fast paced but she can still maintain the grit in her voice when singing, tell me then that she is not a technical singer: She knows her gift more than anything else and knows how to play with it, whether if bad or good.

[@amras1984]

Christina has got the soul and the amazing dynamics.

[@luigigabrielofficial]

Beyonce's technique is absolutely perfect. But I think that's the problem here. This video shows rawness vs perfection, and rawness sometimes inspires more emotion. If we're talking high notes and techniques, Beyonce wins. But if we're talking about execution, Christina takes the win hands down

[@jesseallard344]

I love them both but nobody can touch Christina's vocals.

[@spanishlessons4075]

Are you OK? lol

[@user-rw2dr5my1s]

Very true, Beyoncé is great, but not at the level of Christina.

[@virgoblaketv1281]

I literally have to turn the volume down when Christina sings

[@sugarwaIls]

@@virgoblaketv1281 everyone has, that woman just screams 🤣

[@ez3268]

I love xtina's voice, but sometimes her vocals are very pushed and not supported very well...

[@stevynsweeney6611]

Christina take this all the way home! Beyonce is great but xtina is incredible

[@axelgopa4143]

💎Christina Aguilera 💎

[@blahblahblahaha]

Beyonce wins when it comes to technique but overall I would say Christina has incredible tone, range, and power.

[@emc1730]

Christina's tone is so good~

[@marinobalma240]

CHRISTINA AGUILERA ALL LIFE LONG❤

[@lordaroundtheworld]

Xtina’s voice is just more powerful. 💙

[@hotchocolate6320]

Of course it is people always praising Beyonce but no way she can sing like Christina

[@lourdesknowles4990]

@@hotchocolate6320 she sings better that’s why

[@hotchocolate6320]

@@lourdesknowles4990 absolutely NOT

[@hotchocolate6320]

People who like Beyonce's voice prefer man like gruffness and grunts🤪

[@squarcircle2254]

@@hotchocolate6320 lol Xtina’s voice sounds more manly than Beyonce’s.

[@HeBSingN]

Beyoncé is the way better singer technically but Christina’s gift is much more unique and rare. Her voice is absolutely HUGE so when she’s on she’s essentially unbeatable when it comes to belting. However Beyoncé is consistently “on” and Christina of consistently inconsistent. At their BESTS tho, Christina wins tho she’s the furthest from her best at the moment

[@stefanog.3737]

Yes man 🙃

[@yousifdiwan5720]

NYNY: Xtina DAAGBF: I love both but Xtina At last: Xtina but I love both. Even Etta preferred Xtina for a reason. I will always love you: I’ll say tie since it’s different vocal usage. A song for you: Again, I love both but Xtina.

[@Sarii_MD]

Christina Aguilera ❤️

[@Snoopcat_1114]

Christina is my choice. She has soul .

[@jawn5661]

Beyonce is literally Black. She is Soul.

[@Swahili14]

@@jawn5661 she black but no soul tbh

[@tteokbeki610]

She has soul she got class she got style with her bad ass

[@iconic4289]

Xtina of course

[@leonielaustria5751]

christina such a queen

[@lloydr64able]

Should of asked etta james who she hated singing her song 🤣🤣 sorry beyonce

[@lawrenceevans4871]

etta only hated it because she was jealous that beyoncé got to perform for the Obama's

[@toshiro8997]

@@lawrenceevans4871 exactly. Lmao not to mention that Bey sang her songs even better vocally

[@toshiro8997]

@Free My Grandma nah, I just know what singing is

[@toshiro8997]

@Free My Grandma explain what Etta better did 😂 quickly

[@remusxtian6692]

@@toshiro8997 Bro you say Beyonce is better than The Legendary Etta James?

[@moiseslomeli2425]

Christina Has Soul!

[@ABDlRlZAK]

And Beyoncé doesn’t? She’s literally known for her soul music..

[@GEMINICHAI]

@@ABDlRlZAK Beyoncé is NOT known for Soul music 😂 She is very much Pop/R&B. And I love them both, but it's clear that Christina has the more soulful voice.

[@ABDlRlZAK]

@@GEMINICHAI you haven’t listened to much of Beyoncé’s stuff then, we can end the convo there. I have listened to many Xtina songs and Beyoncé definitely has more soulful music in my opinion.

[@gospelsara8658]

@@ABDlRlZAKyou clearly haven’t listened to Stripped and Back to Basics then 😂

[@Mimi2012ization]

Christina is the Voice of this generation

[@vikavanesya3611]

holly shit after hearing xtina's voice timbre then beyonce, i just realised how yummy xtina's tone is

[@DaveGrinnell-st3qh]

Beyonce is like a fine champagne-light and ethereal. Christina is Courvoisier-rare, rich, and robust. Hearing Christina is like an out of body experience. Chills.

[@Queen76543]

Christins killed every song sorry B... Christina bom af......😍🤩😘💯😊🙌🙌🙌🙌

[@dylanbuchman8128]

When christina is good she's definitely as good as Beyonce. But she's not as consistent. Sometimes she's pretty off-pitch... Or something else is just off. Not knowledgeable enough to know exactly what it is that's off. But her voice does almost always sound more powerful than Beyonce's, and her tone is gorgeous when she gets it right. Love her lows and gentle singing. Her falsetto is unbelievable.

[@balagtas1020]

if you like jazz you'll like christina, if you like classical and pop you'll like beyonve

[@debdorsey659]

Christina. No contest

[@alanmartin4184]

Aguilera the best singer

[@ramirogutierrez6312]

CHRISTINA FOREVER

[@jamesreacts111]

Agree Beyoncé has better technique but even when Beyonce is amazing and powerful I feel nothing from her. There is no pain or storytelling in her voice. Christina's tone for me kills it even though she is hit and miss but xtina's life and reason for singing from the bullying' domestic violence in her upbringing comes through. I feel xtina

[@gabrielhaddad7610]

Xtina all the way

[@vanialopes9676]

christina

[@goldengirlz5754]

xtina wins but bey is just as talented no doubt it ..even bey has praised xtina and admitted her admiration towards xtina❤

[@lourdesdungca1959]

Christina ❤️

[@claudiodaten9703]

Beyonce ever❤️

[@ivanurbeso3430]

Even though, I love both of these ladies, but in my opinion: Christina has great vocals, her voice is strong and very rough, but the only thing the problem about her vocals is her technique, and it's pretty obvious that she could control her voice. Beyoncé, on the other hand, was simply incredible and excellent of her vocals, her technique was perfect, she suddenly have full vocal quality and had a good range, and condsidering her having a star quality vocals. So in conclusion, Beyoncé had a better vocal technique, Christina was clearly amazing but she could do better if her technique was right and perfect, and in other words too, they're still amazing in their own way, both are clearly talented singers.

[@a_awake]

Christina don't be joshing around.. Song For You?!? Are you kidding me? Christina and Herbie improvised with her looking like the reincarnation of Marilyn Monroe slays everything that ever existed, ever. Christina wins. It's no competition.

[@hotchocolate6320]

No competition at all Christina will always win

[@nguyenat8576]

Beyonce sings better for sure. But to whom i prefer to hear? Christina!

[@sameffendi9578]

I have to say that only Christina Aguilera can sing so many genres. Mariah cannot, Beyonce cannot. So my heart goes to Xtina ❤

[@rafaelcavalcante3850]

Xtina always😍😍😍

[@shirmela8347]

i know I'm biased... xtina always.... 😁

[@Tenchu_87]

Ok. Beyonce is obviously a good performer. But christina is on a whole different level. The comparison is like pitting any country singer up against Chris Stapleton. Sure they sing good but Chris Stapleton just is always gonna be a better vocalist because of talent effort and emotional content. Christina is just better all around. Stop being a hater. Christina is a generational talent. There won't be another christina. She hits raspy notes and clean vocals effortlessly. She can hit runs like no one else. Christina is the CLEAR winner here.

[@lamadrina5384]

Agreed. And Chris Stapleton is a better soul singer than Beyonce, not to mention country singer!!

[@camara1194]

Christina without a doubt. Not even a contest nor any comparison.

[@pavelkratinoha5232]

Christina

[@amistake2307]

Beyonce , she is better technically but I prefer xtina's tone

[@angelquinterovibe]

I love both these ladies. But. Before Beyonce's voice had a hive, Christina's voice had an entire high heaven shook. And dare I say still does. Those are just facts. This is no contest. Believe what you wanna believe.

[@Nancy-uw5zm]

Christina！！！

[@jeejardeleza2007]

Christina Aguilera is still the queen! Everyone knows that. Except the heaters! Haters gonna be hate but you can't bring christina down 😊

[@Tina-eb1hz]

Come on now, everybody knows Beyoncé’s voice is more powerful than most singers out there. If CA and Bey sang together on stage, Bey’s voice would over power hers in vibratos, runs, and growl are just more crisp. And I actually prefer Christina over Bey, but these are facts, vocally, technically Bey is a stronger singer.

[@jeejardeleza2007]

@@Tina-eb1hz HAHAHAHAHHAA 😂 xtina toe nails is laughing hard at "if they sang together on stage bey voice would overpower CA" clean your ears bro. 😂😂😂

[@Tina-eb1hz]

@@jeejardeleza2007 it’s fine, you can laugh! People who deny the truth like yourself are often funny. Listen, I love Christina, and they definitely have different styles of singing, however Bey is the strongest both vocally and technically. And YOU know that only the people in this chat will agree with you. Everyone else in the world would chose Bey over CA in terms of what I stated above any day. And that’s facts.

[@jeejardeleza2007]

@@Tina-eb1hz Please clean your ears! 😆

[@Tina-eb1hz]

@@jeejardeleza2007 Ears are squeaky clean, thanks! And the answer is still Bey! Don’t even get me started on dancing while singing and breath control, CA looses by a landslide. But again, I don’t have to tell you what you already know! This exchange was cute! Have a great day! 😂😂🤣🤣🤣

[@gustavoprocopio9804]

Christina aguilera é a melhor.

[@illlli7469]

It’s Beyoncé for me but I also love Xtina

[@MsFeela]

xtina = real voice ////// Beyonce = echo

[@charlottexroyalty7819]

Beyonce = true singing Xtina= Screaming and vocal suicide

[@secretbounty6103]

ShadesofP!nk nope

[@kam4360]

THE DUMBASS LIES U SCREAMTINA FANS TELL

[@guillerminablanco3435]

Beyoncé sucks

[@carolinaviescafernandez5490]

I think they cannot be compared, Beyoncé tends to sing in a healthier way but Christina is just too powerfull. Beyoncé could be a mezzo though but I couldn't pick one over another they both 2 flawless

[@JORGE-nd5yb]

xtina

[@rafaelhanlet]

christina aguilera of course wins over beyonce

[@cortezmiller1899]

I think most people like Beyoncé because she is a great performer. Can she sing? Um yes! But it’s more than performing to me. Christina Aguilera has both she really can sing and perform.

[@mcmohitchauhan21]

Xtina is at such a level that Beyonce can never reach. Xtina's voice alone beats anything that beyonce has ever attempted. Xtina's soulful, silky, smooth, dreamy, powerful, rich, full tone is a gift from god while beyonce's voice is just generic at all levels. Anyone with actual ears would know what a once in a lifetime VOICE xtina has.

[@ilirianaili7545]

Hahahahhaha funny tho

[@elyseedalas7253]

Lol your joke was funny

[@mcmohitchauhan21]

@@elyseedalas7253 Like you. LOL

[@mcmohitchauhan21]

@@ilirianaili7545 True though

[@Tina-eb1hz]

Eeehhhhh I beg to differ, Beyoncé’s ear for sound is impeccable and it shows in her tone. I don’t think Christina is there yet. I feel like she has much more to offer vocally.

[@jennie-pm1xy]

beyoncé queen of vocals

[@jeremiahpalmer-ik4ld]

& NO SOUL

[@jeypeepsv1]

Queen of vocals?? Your joking

[@DeshayZion-ow2lj]

@@jeypeepsv1and xtina is?

[@piper2521]

They’re both so amazing just in different ways

[@amberbrown9564]

You can't compare the 2, because Christina's voice is much more powerful. There's no argument. Ppl can love Bey all they want and she is talented but her voice isn't that impressive.

[@Tina-eb1hz]

Nope, it’s the opposite actually.

[@nickabockanumber9699]

Lol beyonces is wayyyyyy better

[@ABDlRlZAK]

You are very delusional, get your facts right, Beyoncé is a star rated vocalist and Xtina isn’t, get that in your pea sized brain. Go ask any vocal coach; they’ll all tell you Beyoncé is vocally superior in every way.

[@CorryOwensJr]

@@nickabockanumber9699 wayyyyyy

[@Face_Reality]

Beyonce is more pleasant to listen to and she knows when to add the power. You don't start the song off powerful, that's way too much. It's not tasteful. It's not always about power. It's about knowing when to do something. With I will always love you, they showed beyonce singing the beginning of the song and Christina singing the end. The beginning should always be softer. And Christina definitely doesn't have a jazz voice like at the beginning of this video. Both ladies can sing great though.

[@cautionontherun30]

Christina's vocals are just to high and sustained and on point Beyonce has to arrange fill in to compensate her lack of power

[@yebostephen6307]

Beyonce does not lack power.

[@yamen2504]

Xtina for sure Beyonce isnt bad at all But she's changing the songs what is she trying to do Ok put your touch but dont change the instrument of the song New york??????? A song for you?????? Cool you have a perfect control with your vibrato but dont use a lot!

[@neooperation7194]

legend x

[@jukebox1209]

Beyonce for sure.

[@sebassebastiangiraldoibarr9603]

Una colaboración entre estas 2 cantantes aria estallar el mundo

[@gabyreveluv]

beyoncé

[@followdelight4021]

Christina blows bey out the water

[@Omerrdd]

Shut da fuk up even you don’t believe this

[@lamadrina5384]

With Christina you hear the VOICE; with Beyonce you are hearing a voice padded by doubling, and other delays, and electronic saturation. That is why her voice sounds distant. It is!

[@itshardtochangehandles]

Yeah, definitely Christina. Beyonce is talented, but her voice can't hold a candle to Christina's when it comes to power, emotion, or grit. If we are going for some background, passive listening, Beyonce sounds nice. But if I want to listen to something actively or something that evokes emotion, I'll take Christina any day over B.

[@nickabockanumber9699]

Legit so wrong beyonce is the real voice lol

[@mikel4531]

Queen B hands down

[@tonyrocket2103]

@Rj-Lamar No Bey def won

[@TrungNguyen-mq4qk]

Beyonce can sing but Xtina's voice ATE hers

[@mikel4531]

@@TrungNguyen-mq4qk No

[@ahmadmagee1007]

Last I checked No vocal legends speak of Beyoncé’s “vocal abilities”

[@mikel4531]

@@ahmadmagee1007 Because Beyoncé is underrated vocally.

[@ernesfonse]

Xtina wins easily

[@yunesyousuf3563]

Beyonceeeeeé for sure but Christina is rlly good 2❤❤

[@execastillo9071]

Xtina aguilera ❤❤

[@koolaid1982]

💎 CHRISTINA KILLED THAT 🙌🏾😍

[@MarcoAntonioFitz-nn8im]

Xtina!!! ❤

[@jamwithcam]

xtina :))

[@raniyahtaylor3905]

So basically Christina is better.

[@MP_Guz]

both are very good. however I'm inclined towards Christina because her style is more complex.

[@Bidneyb]

Beyonce

[@sonnywharekura8914]

beyonce.

[@guillerminablanco3435]

Christina Aguilera and Who?

[@t-bonetv7608]

beyonce all the way

[@pedrowalker1926]

Eu acho que a Xtina é muito, muito absurdamente boa, só que ela excede MUITAS vezes. Beyonce é ponderada até nos exageros. É como se ela controla até quanto vai sair da zona de conforto. Xtina nessa parte soa muito desenfreada, sem direcionamento, mas gente xtina é maravilhosa também. Não tô diminuindo nem tirando o mérito dela.

[@BRANDON56812]

Beyoncés technique is better and overall more consistent.

[@Sejuani89]

Christina's voice is like watching an acrobat at a circus doing thrilling and death-defying stunts to gain cheer and applause from the crowd. Beyonce's voice is like watching a gymnast doing her set for an olympic competition as perfectly as she can to get a gold medal. I prefer to be thrilled.

[@gospelsara8658]

Perfectly said 😭

[@ajf2005]

Both are good singers but Beyoncé is the better vocalist.

[@nicolezonderhuis8504]

Christina !

[@ashleyluther4121]

Beyonce is the bom

[@blueblackyellow]

Xtina hands down and i love both

[@gemma1874]

Both fans and fantastic vocalists

[@pmfcrew6551]

Xtina Tone Alone is unmatched.

[@michelalagha502]

Ofcourse the star rated vocalist, beyonce

[@o_fidan]

Beyonce.

[@hotchocolate6320]

Christina gives me chills Beyonce has a cute little voice though lol

[@kendallcadence2163]

You don't have to discredit Beyoncé to uplift Christina. Beyoncé has a very powerful voice 🥰

[@hotchocolate6320]

@@kendallcadence2163 her voice is so cute

[@kendallcadence2163]

@@hotchocolate6320 Ikr? That's why she's a star rated vocalist.

[@hotchocolate6320]

@@kendallcadence2163 yeah that's right so is Christina her voice is the bomb!!

[@kendallcadence2163]

@@hotchocolate6320 Christina actually isn't a star rated vocalist. Maybe with a little more practice she'll get there, though!

[@factpreacher5691]

From technical stand point Beyonce is better vocalist, xtina strains her belts. You might like her tone over Beyonce but that doesn't mean she's better, tone os subjective while technique is not. Beyonce has so much more to offer, that's why she's the greatest entertainer today and lastly Beyonce's musicality evolves so much while Xtina has the same sound from 2000.

[@Tina-eb1hz]

Yes - in vibrato, runs, and growl. It’s that Beyonce is trained at every register so that her voice can hit those high and low notes effortlessly. Her breathing is amazing.

[@hotchocolate6320]

Christina does not sound the same since 2000 her voice has evolved way past then are you people really that tone deaf Christina can blow whether you like her or not

[@hotchocolate6320]

@@Lemongraass so you are saying she sounds better on her first album than she sounds on back to basics? No way

[@hotchocolate6320]

@@Lemongraass her music has declined not her voice

[@srdmusicgroup1037]

@@hotchocolate6320 but you said voice in the first comment

[@joellromero]

Beyonce is better GREAT

[@janellegonzales5808]

Beyonce beating Christina Aguilera singing

[@hamzayagoubii727]

Beyoncé everything