Cimorelli Performs “This Is Me” from The Greatest Showman | Episode 1: Guess Who’s Singing

[@abbyi842]

they want us to think it’s lisa with the clues, but i 100% think it’s katherine by the voice. it’s airy, light, and beautiful; katherine.

[@khadijaajj3544]

I agree

[@oliviabrock975]

So many people have guessed Lisa in the poll. I definitely think it’s Katherine too

[@hadassac.4219]

I 100% agree with you

[@laraanzlovar6776]

I agreee!! And i think it is definitly not Cristina or Lauren.

[@mirandallibre7953]

@@laraanzlovar6776 noo

[@Lili-sw9st]

I want Dani, the brothers, and/or the parents to react to these and make their guesses to see if the family can tell!

[@TheJeyleenTroche]

That would be so cool to watch!

[@khamyaa6689]

Lisa and Katherine's bumps look soo adorable. And they all look beautiful!!!

[@clare_dwyer]

I think it’s Katherine because of the vocals and the body language while she’s singing. She looks very into it like she really believes and is confident while singing this song

[@isabellalee36]

But they pre-record this and they all just lip-sync for the video, don’t they?

[@they.ad0re.dqueen591]

@@isabellalee36 exactly

[@reyannamadray2228]

I think all of the are into it anyway

[@folklore_of_beth]

@@isabellalee36 that doesn’t mean you’re completely emotionless when you hear it. And who says they weren’t singing and just dubbed over it?

[@Emily-oy2nq]

@@isabellalee36 They do that for every song they sing and they still look into it everytime so that doesn't matter

[@theresab8846]

I think it's Kath, because I remember her saying that she cut her hair in order to look different from her sisters, so that maybe people would stop comparing her to them so much.

[@jasperbogaert3911]

same lmao

[@ilodder]

But I feel like Katherine looks different already. I think it's Lisa, those high notes didn't look like they truly came from Katherine.

[@camilafreitas2254]

YES ITS HER!!!!! She wrote in their book that she wanted to be a fashion designer

[@theresab8846]

@@camilafreitas2254 Aah, good point! I didn't know about that! ☺️

[@mariaalexa2026]

@@camilafreitas2254 another hint that tells us that it's Lisa is that she isn't really a crowd follower but idk if that actually tells about the clue about being afraid of "big crowds"

[@aehtay]

Knowing how Katherine sings, there's certain ways she says her words when she sings. Plus those high notes sound super light and airy and not as "belted" like Lisa normally does. I definitely think it's Katherine! I'd love to actually hear the original version of this before it was altered!

[@sarahalshuaibi2345]

True

[@МаликаВалиева-ю8ч]

yeah

[@patriciadasilva1082]

Yea

[@everyoneluvsnoel]

Me too!

[@baylieization]

Plot twist: it's actually their brothers.

[@khadijaajj3544]

Or barrett😂😂✌✌

[@archer3554]

@@khadijaajj3544 BAHAHA

[@maisorour4354]

😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@sophiafoisy470]

HAHAHAHAHAH

[@TheSmashMo]

This made me laugh out loud! 😆

[@Rednaxela137]

I hope when they reveal who was l singing each song they will also let us hear the original before the voice was altered higher/lower

[@saramartins1130]

@@katarinaaa45 when?

[@maggierenick2674]

@@katarinaaa45 they revealed it

[@twincherry4958]

@@maggierenick2674 who is it?

[@LouisaMarit]

It just HAS to be Kath. One can hear that very clearly in the first verse - especially third line - and when she sings "look out cause here I come". They want us to think it's Lisa with those hints, but Kath butcher hair ad well and even though being an extrovert, one can still feel overwhelmed by big crowds. Kath has such a airy and soft voice and e.g. the high notes would be way sharper if it was Lisa because she usually belts those. If Lisa sings high notes in headvoice they would not be that full of energy but they are here. + twins = new chapter in life and Kath is crafty

[@absolutetransportationllc]

Ya bit the. Think of Lisa to! Kath just found out like 2 months ago and Lisa found out 4 months ago

[@carolinalobato645]

And new chapter since she created her own youtube channel!!

[@ladejrarenette5105]

Lisa was the one who cut her hair

[@betty9382]

Might be Lisa too.. She is due soon or smth

[@quirstenaya1659]

i totally agree

[@kirstie3357]

Definitely going with Katherine on this one but sheesh! They definitely put in their all to confuse us. For the hints: the crafts definitely makes me think Amy, the hair make me think Lisa, the not feeling good enough makes me think Christina, the new chapter sounds like Lisa or Katherine with their pregnancies and the feeling uncomfortable in large groups of people sounds like Lauren. HOWEVER, I think the hints are probably not obvious ones so I’m immediately scrapping first guesses on all of them and going with less obvious answers. Katherine is the only one who isn’t the first obvious choice and yet answers to everything. The hair seems to be a big one and Katherine has said that she cut her hair shorter than her sisters to be different and not have to “compete” with them whereas Lisa said she cut it for other reasons not just to be different. For the singing: if Lisa did it I feel like their would be more vocal acrobatics, runs and so forth. If Christina did it we would have heard her distinctive vocal cries throughout. If Lauren did it their would have been more pronounced belting on the high notes And if Amy did it I feel like we would have heard more of her country/twangy accent. It sounded like Katherine’s voice, just altered a ton. It would be cool if someone took this audio and tried to alter it back!

[@djrn1621]

100%%%

[@Anthony-fu6cl]

Very well said!! I agree completely!

[@SM-qu4gl]

Agreed

[@9thgalaxy778]

Thanks for the help, lol. I'm pretty sure it's not Christina or Lauren.

[@tornadicdoge627]

I feel as if Lisa would know if she did a lot of adlibs people would immediately think it’s her. And people would think this would be a perfect song for Lisa to sing. Katherine tone is more breathy/airy. And her way of pronouncing some of the vowels. Idk I just hear it here. But also Katherine sorta pronounces things like Lauren sometimes while singing. Which the belts could be Lauren Lisa or Kath. Lisa is taken out because of the fashion designer question. And so is Lauren. Also with the hair question Lauren is out. But kaths range is a lot more versatile than we are accustomed to. The first high note sounded like Laur. Yet knowing Kath can hit that note, it’s just either given to Lauren Chris or Lisa, I believe it’s her. The last high note sounded like Katherine way too much. And the clues. Katherine cut her hair to look different from her sisters. Never thought she was enough bevause back in 2009 when they debuted people would say she was the worst singer out of all of them. Also stating it took a toll on her personally. And the fashion designer part Kath said in the book. Also taking that Lisa and Lauren said they want to be singers and Chris wants to be a therapist/life coach. (Amy I forgot) I just fully believe it’s Kath at this point

[@imfromneverland3692]

9:50 only Kath does those kind of breathy adlibs. Okay but show-guessing aside, whoever thought the should all wear long dresses deserves a pay-raise.

[@Anthony-fu6cl]

That's exactly the moment that made me think it was Kath too. I love Kath's riffs; they're very raw and breathy. If Lisa did that riff, it would have been all one phrase instead of separated.

[@msquinn385]

I definitely feel like it's Kath ...just by the way she pronounces the words of the song..plus although there voices are altered ..I still here the calmness in her voice❣️💞🥺

[@mr.musica2.0]

Katherine never cut her hear like Lisa and they say she is starting a new chapter like Lisa been a mom

[@claraf1824]

@@mr.musica2.0 Kathrine is also going to be a mom this year, but I agree with you that she has never had the same short hair as Lisa... But... If you look back at some old photos, then you can see that Kathrine was the one with the shortest hair until Lisa cut hers💇‍♀️

[@chioma2844]

i agree with u

[@emma-di5ly]

Everyone is saying it's Katherine, but I'm hearing Lauren. This sounds exactly like how she pronounces her words when she's singing. She has a breathy quality sometimes like Katherine but can also belt like Lisa. My money is tentatively on Lauren.

[@jamiebuck879]

yeah i thought the exact same thing!! i’m thinking lauren!

[@darksages0675]

I also believe this is Lauren…. The moment the song started I heard her voice instantly…

[@andfourdance]

I also think her overdramatising her lipsyncing parts is meant to throw us off. It looks like she's singing harder than the track but I heard her too.

[@Okokbriana]

I am confident it’s Lauren. If the “altered” voice sounds like Kat, then it’s most likely not her lol. From the very beginning I just knew it was Lauren.

[@VanessaMArtistry]

Yup! Lauren....I thought Amy for a second....but the way she says come....it’s Lauren

[@katelynide3008]

This is really going to be testing how well I know their voices after 11 years of being a fan 😳

[@beetenwi9280]

Me thinking it’s Amy, me reading the comments: “It’s Kath!!”

[@snehaannrajesh7896]

Ahhh....i thought the same

[@lilycollins3159]

LITERALLY WHAT I DID😭😭🤣

[@neyo1958]

LMAO SAME BYE 💀

[@961Ele]

Me too lol

[@lilliehoughton8476]

I thought it was amy just because of the “overwhelmed by big crowds” clue. But all the other clues point to Kath and it sounds like Kath! But i never knew she wanted to be a fashion designer so idk

[@abigailr.22]

I know people are saying “it’s definitely Kathrine”, but I’m gonna say it’s Lisa. Not necessarily because of the clues, but it legit sounded like it could be her singing. Ugh, they sound so alike!

[@Ryan-um3mh]

It doesn’t sound like Lisa lol

[@neemamalamo4727]

I think it is Lisa too

[@mariapatrycja3909]

I have the same opinion, it will be Lisa

[@jiajones5751]

lisa has more control

[@amnedits4898]

It’s DEFINITELY Katherine! The breathy tone gave it away.

[@suin9213]

YES

[@hanne4413]

You said that so well, I thought exactly the same.

[@BethanSaunders]

it’s amy 😂

[@user-nc8ih2op8v]

Yep

[@oliviacharles3764]

@@BethanSaunders can you tell me what Amy’s new chapter is then??

[@alaskarose7573]

Me when I first heard what the series was:This is easy I have got it in the bag I have been watching them since the LITERAL beginning When I heard their mom can’t guess it: Do I know their voices better than their mom or is this gonna be really hard???

[@guilhermebarros1477]

CimFam we should try to reach at least 1M in every episode of the series to hype our queens. They really deserve it. I appreciate them reinventing themselves after all these years ❤️

[@afma4]

On repeat boy

[@sarahmarina9039]

Stuck between Kathrine and Amy. I feel like Amy has a higher range than Kathrine, so the big note at the end of this song is something she would be more likely to sing.

[@stefaniatauriel5634]

I don’t think that Amy has higher range, Katherine’s voice just more soft, but her range is high. I remember her high notes in some songs - they were breathy, soft and clear. Just as in this video

[@cookingcatholict8101]

IM ALSO STUCK W THOSE TWO

[@neelagoswami6959]

im stuck between those too cuz of the hair clue but I think it is Kath

[@mr.musica2.0]

Katherine never cut her hear like Lisa and they say she is starting a new chapter like Lisa been a mom

[@MrKouaVang]

@@mr.musica2.0 she had short hair from like 2013-2017

[@nadia1573]

The belts just sounded exactly like Lisa’s mixing. I’ve never heard Katherine belt like that, so idk. But I mean, if this is Kat I NEED that unedited version, so I can listen to those beautiful belts!

[@jefferyarnold5286]

omg! so i put it in my singing app on my pc and brought it down. the original note kath did in studio is a f5!!! like that’s one of her highest notes! also bring it down really shows that it’s kath 😂😂😂

[@carolynmiller3254]

I've heard Amy belt like that tho that's why I think its her

[@jefferyarnold5286]

@@carolynmiller3254 idk tho bc i put it down some semi tones in my app and it sounds sooo much like kath!! but i guess we will see who it is when the last episode comes out!! happy guessing!!

[@NS-ut6gy]

I’m stuck between Lisa and Kath but I’m tilting towards Kath. The belt sounded exactly like Lisa’s but we haven’t heard Kath belt much so it could sound similar.

[@jefferyarnold5286]

@@NS-ut6gy true tho. i really hope after this series she gets some higher notes!

[@VickyLu1]

I’m thinking it’s Katherine! I remember she said once that she would cut her hair shorter so it wouldn’t seem like she was “trying.” I feel like it’d be too obvious if it was Lisa. And Katherine is also starting a new chapter with her twins and is also crafty! 😊

[@jayk8919]

Exactly with that high note I feel like people would say Lisa bcz she tends to often do that. But I feel like it’s too obvious

[@Urbxx]

And microscopy thing, sounds like kat references

[@shree9371]

but what about being overwhelmed in big crowds? I feel like that would be Lisa. Kath is more extroverted and I don't think she'd feel that way...lol this is hard xD

[@almendra5678]

@@shree9371 I was thinking the same lol

[@Anthony-fu6cl]

Exactly!! I remember that too, I agree.

[@user-nc8ih2op8v]

7:56 is what makes it seem that it’s for sure Kath. Listen to how she sings that part, and compare it to any time kath has done a part where she has to go up into her head voice and you will see that the transition is almost identical to how kath sings stuff like that

[@Anthony-fu6cl]

That's a good observation, I completely agree! The way she hits the riff at 9:49 is so Kath too!

[@am13007]

I'm SURE this is Katherine. Like literally. Also because of the hints. She's starting a new chapter (the twins!!) And she is crafty. But about the hair, it could be Lisa so🧐

[@diorteez8405]

i mean back in the day she was always the only one with short hair

[@lourdesss333]

Yea the hair is where it through me off

[@emilyloveall5166]

EXACTLY!!! I’m on the same page. I also dont think that Lisa would get uncomfortable in big crowds. Wait actually- IDK.

[@mr.musica2.0]

Katherine never cut her hear like Lisa and they say she is starting a new chapter like Lisa been a mom

[@leslievitela3726]

But Lisa is pregnant and it’s her first

[@lamagnificayeti]

I'm guessing Amy! She's crafty and it her voice has a soulful vibe

[@alecatbooks2578]

Katherine. She's the only one I think who can belt a gentle voice!

[@viy5368]

when i know about cutting hair thing, everyone will think of lisa but i know she's not crafty. so my answer goes to kath ✨ *also its kinda obvious, katherine facial expressions is a real match to that voice and the tone tho, such a kath thing 😂

[@bethandcharlie6890]

totally agree

[@janakaembergs7646]

Lisa can be crafty she can beautifully paint!

[@khia7550]

I think it is kath but I haven’t finished the video but with the clues she seems like she is more introverted then the rest of her sisters

[@viy5368]

@@janakaembergs7646 yesss you're right! but i think i kinda remember saw a clip saying that lisa don't really like diy 🙃 but not sure abt that hehe

[@amalua5458]

Amy is very into the arts too she even has an art page and she cut her hair too omggg this one is tricky!!

[@OlivesCloset]

"I cut my hair because I wanted to be different" Sounds like lisa 😭 *edit: stop attacking meee lolol it was a guess* 🤣

[@ihavenofriends566]

yep

[@sierracrum6040]

Yes

[@MKW_Bufftwizz]

That is not Lisa's voice tho...

[@richardduncaniv4934]

I think I lisa to

[@OlivesCloset]

@@MKW_Bufftwizz no I mean, sounds like something she would say haha 🤣

[@fabiovazc]

Its Kath, she uses less vibrato in her voice and this singing is really straight. I kinda usually confuse her voice with Christina's, but the amount of air in the voice.... Its Kath

[@angelicamartinez4739]

Non of them use vibrato, and they really should learn how to because they extend the final notes a lot and would sound much better 🤷🏻‍♀️

[@fabiovazc]

@@angelicamartinez4739 they actually do, Lisa.... Christina... You can see it on their Instagram... But actually in songs when you are singing in group harmonizing, you have to be intelligent using it cause everyone has a different type of vibrato, so if all 5 girls use it at the same time, It can turn into a mess.

[@Anthony-fu6cl]

I agree, I love Kath's straight tone! It's very crisp yet just the right amount of airy. Christina's voice almost has a little girly Britney Spears vocal fry to her voice, so I didn't think it was her.

[@worthfightingfor2299]

@@fabiovazc Yeah, exactly. Amy also uses vibrato.

[@NS-ut6gy]

Yeahh. Kath said in harmonies she usually sings in the middle but also higher parts so she’s definitely capable of singing those high notes. She sings in her head voice a lot (this song is very airy and calming if you kinda separate it from the voice altering) and the new chapter is definitely motherhood. I feel like the clues tried to make us think it is Lisa but I think Lisa would add a lot more high notes. Because of that I feel like when they alter Lisa’s voice, they’re going to make it lower because Lisa usually stays in a higher register.

[@jenncich6260]

Def kath. Her breathing patterns and “R”s are different.

[@jimmyb.6102]

when i heard lauren start “singing” i knew it was katherine. it wasn’t even her voice that told me it was the way she was singing it, if that makes sense.

[@Blackcanvasart]

My thinking exactly, Amy’s notes are darker and it’s much breathier than Lisa Christina. But it isn’t as bright as Lauren’s voice

[@luciafuhui]

I also use the breathing patterns to differentiate Kath’s voice from the others

[@nickpeterson379]

First time through, I was definitely leaning Amy, but after hearing the "... nothing I'm not worthy of..." at 9:06 that sounded exactly how Katherine falls off her higher notes. Listened to it a second time, and now I'm absolutely convinced it's Katherine

[@GoldenNina15]

Saaaaame. I was between Amy or Katherine during the whole song but when I heard that specific part I was like "no no, this has to be kath"

[@sarahsucupira3238]

This is kath, the hints, the words, the tempo she sings the notes, the way she holds it, this is kath for sure!

[@mackenziebuchter8406]

The Shallow is DEFINITELY Lauren!!!!! Now onto the actual song lol. At first thought this was Amy, but I didn't hear her fall offs at the end of phrases. The voice was light, which also led me to Amy to start off because we all know she is the alto in the group, and her voice would naturally get lighter when notes get higher. Then, I heard the even higher notes, and realized it was Katherine. The light and soft tone to her voice definitely gave it away. ESPECIALLY when it would get to her close ups, and you can really see how her mouth molded to her words. It fit perfectly!

[@marlih8973]

I agree with every sentence of this !!

[@Jo-ce5sn]

It's definitly kath. She always sings way softer and breathier than the other 4. You could still hear that. Never heard her sing such a high note, super proud of you kath

[@jasminecaron]

maybe the fact that you never heard her sing high notes is a fact that its not herrr;))

[@darrie2468]

No matter who sang, I think we can all agree that Amy PERFORMED.

[@saanikakodial]

When they were giving the hints, Katherine looked like the only one who wasn't lying so I really think it's her

[@claireacibo38]

I think it's Kath!! She opened up about her cutting her hair to be different from her sisters cause she was always compared to them before, her new chapter is motherhood, if you checked her Instagram story she did a DIY mother's day gift for her sisters, I also think that she said in a video that she wanted to be a fashion designer, and I think she said that she gets overwhelmed in concerts or places with big crowds even when she knows that she's an extrovert. She also opened up about her being a people pleaser and she was a guest in their friend's podcast and she opened up about how she felt like she wasn't good enough. Also the way she sings the song in the video is so passionate, like this is her song!!!! I might be wrong though!

[@ItsMaleahA]

Yes I agree I saw she’s posted a few diy projects on her IG stories

[@coffeegirll]

What I got from this: the little snippet of “Shallow” was Lauren and “This Is Me” was Kath! :) Thank you to Cimorelli for doing a series that is special to long time listeners, it’s fun to test our Cimorelli knowledge! God bless each and every one of you❤️‍🔥

[@benmcgee2694]

shallow sounds like a mix between lauren and kath to me😁

[@qsara02]

It's 100% Kath! Hint 1: She's pregnant with twins! Hint 3: Wasn't completely sure of this one, thought it was Amy since she paints and makes her own jewellery, but I was sure it can't really be Christina or Lisa idk why hahahah. Hint 4: Kath mentioned once how she cut her hair during their early years on youtube so that she wasn't compared with her sisters because of that. For the performance itself, I thought it was obvious it was Kath because her voice really stands out! Like someone said, she has an airy/breathy aspect to her voice. I definitely crossed Lisa and Amy off the list when the high parts came because I think their belts would've been stronger. Kath is leading in the poll anyways so I'm assuming most of us are on the same page hahahah, just wanted to join in in the comments! AHHH I'm so excited for next weekk

[@carolinalobato645]

Watch Kath's personal channel, it'll help on the crafty hint

[@PicturePerfectMemori]

My thoughts exactly!

[@qsara02]

@@carolinalobato645 oh alright! I don't keep up with their individual channels cause I keep forgetting they each have one hahah. thanks :)

[@siimplyhamster1967]

It's Lisa! They said she cut her hair to make a difference... Who cut their hair really short? LISA

[@qsara02]

@@siimplyhamster1967 I see where you're getting at but I'm gonna have to disagree. They said the singer cut her hair to be different, Lisa's reason for shaving her head was more because of her bad relationships whereas Kath's reason was because she didn't want to be compared to the rest of her sisters by hair length

[@beccafrescoln8544]

I totally think it's Lisa. One of the clues said "I am starting a brand new chapter this year" and Lisa is expecting🤰🏻 Another clue said " I cut my hair because I wanted to be different" do you remember when Lisa shaved her hair off?💡 Now for the voice. I heard a lot of people saying that they thought it was Katherine which is a good guess, but Kath's voice is breath-ier then Lisa's voice. So that is why i think it is Lisa 😂😂😇 Thank you for your time! God bless!

[@pickles7168]

yeah, but it sounds like kath and she recently found out she's pregnant with twins

[@fafitah]

That's what they want you to think, but it's Kath for sure! Airy and soft. Lisa is quite more powerful, if that makes sense

[@Steffi5376]

No katherine literally said in one of the older videos that everyone was comparing her to her sisters when they first youtube in the comments which hurt her so she cut her hair so that she would be different and they woudln't compare her bcos she's different and that's why she's always had shorter hair Katherine is also expecting a bb!

[@emmameisel7494]

I agree I also feel like kath’s voice has a deeper quality to it so even made higher it still wouldn’t sound like this. I feel like it’s Lisa but also is it too obvious that Lisa was the one narrating this episode?

[@beccafrescoln8544]

@@emmameisel7494 thanks for agreeing with me 😂😅

[@JoseGonzalezTVV]

I’m so proud of you girlsss ❤️ I’ve been watching your videos since 2011.

[@guilhermebarros1477]

❤️❤️

[@Jessica-vf2fb]

Damn I was 5 then

[@serenaterry387]

I was 6 years old then XD

[@cimorellitheband]

Thank you!!!!!

[@arushabhargava9116]

i was 1

[@Nialllover0280]

I here anymore and I feel like she’s finally accepting herself and being confident. She’s very crafty and diy like! I heard lots of Amy I feel kath is more of a higher tone and this seemed lower like Amy

[@avaherrera1540]

Omg yes I totally agree

[@coryhartcruz]

I was also hearing Amy!

[@allyshaw]

But that high note threw me off

[@dominiquemichel7428]

I also thought from the hints that it could be amy

[@margaridaramos9461]

since the begoning i thought was amy!

[@who.is.brooklyn22]

my guess is Amy or maybe Lauren? hold on it’s gonna be Kath no Christina? wait it sounds like Lisa? i’m going to be so confused while guessing but i am so excited!!

[@elle11123]

The clue point to Lisa so that's my guess

[@absolutetransportationllc]

I think it Lisa too because I heard the high note and she is the only one who really hits them perfectly

[@maddief7161]

@@elle11123 I thought it was Lisa or Kath, their new chapters are babies, Katherine actually cut her hair right before Lisa. I think it was a podcast episode Kath said that she was always compared to her sisters so she cut her hair really short. They’ve all talked about not feeling good enough. But I thought it was Katherine.

[@shiro6889]

@@maddief7161 I think it's kath too

[@immoderate_]

Amy literally stops singing at 7:12 - can't be her haha!

[@oliviasobsession]

Katherine! Just watching her sing it you can tell that song hits her harder than the others and means a lot to her. it feels so real and so genuine, it has to be her 🤞🏼

[@allen1730]

Ohhh, I thought this would've be easy. I can easily distinguished their voices but ohhh my, I have difficulty guessing it this time. Great Job Girls--I am leaning towards Lauren based on the clues provided and the high note.

[@justagamer5605]

premieres are awful when its come to cimorelli, i don't wanna wait!

[@kimbycurtismatthewswinstion]

I feel you, I'm a very impatient person I also hate waiting

[@pearlingeorge8977]

I hate it tooo!!! Coz their videos r such quality content!!😱😱😱

[@jcje844]

Ya haha

[@MichielBLKorte]

I think Lauren. Especially the hint about "growing up in the spotlight" hints at it being one of the younger girls. Lisa, Katherine and Christina were all 16 and over when they got famous so I think it's either Amy or Lauren, and while both love DIY projects, Lauren IS the most introverted and shy of the girls, which is hinted at in the hints. I also think Lauren cut her hair to be different at one point.

[@Rednaxela137]

I slowed it way down and it sounds like Lauren so I’m confused

[@gracesmith2769]

I disagree, because they showed clips of future episodes and one of them sounded EXACTLY like Lauren. So I think she’s singing a different one

[@devilcutie1190]

@@gracesmith2769 I think so too, def think Lauren is singing shallow from that short clip.

[@Noemie112]

@@devilcutie1190 i felt Shallow was an airy tone like Kath ahahah what i'm confused

[@Rednaxela137]

@@gracesmith2769 oh yes! True I forgot and Amy was singing another song too

[@Jj_.513]

I think it's Lauren just because of the way she is singing and the power and emotion she's putting into it

[@aquaflower123]

it was actually katherine

[@arianahoover8817]

Def kathrine. The tone and breath patterns are unique to her.

[@Ashleyyyy_xx]

How can you tell the tone when there's a voice effect on 😂😂😂

[@josefinaburatti6567]

nooo, the clues doesn't match with her

[@abbyyy33]

Sounded like Amy near the start but gradually more and more like Katherine!

[@sophtakesvlogs]

I want to say Amy because of how crafty she is with all her art and the way she sometimes adds art onto her clothes but idk

[@Liagreat97]

Yea same 🙊 omg i don’t know

[@carolynmiller3254]

Yesss i just know it's her

[@laneywalsh4234]

I think it’s Katherine

[@tornadicdoge627]

But Amy likes big crowds. And the clue was “I get overwhelmed with big crowds” Which rules amy out.

[@tornadicdoge627]

Katherine has said how Amy talks to anyone and everyone. And how she never would go up to a bunch of people like that

[@hollowhills13]

Watching for the tenth time, the pre-chorus the second time, the “for we are glorious”, it reminds me of Katherine, because she doesn’t have as high a voice, I find she reaches a bit. It’s not a bad thing, it’s her style, but yeah, that part makes me think it’s Katherine, all the way

[@laurawallbank]

Yes I definitely agree! I think it’s her too!

[@justagamer5605]

Me watching the trailer: oh i definitely got this in the bag Me realizing the their mother couldn't get it right: yup, nope, i don't got this love you guys!

[@gemmawagstaff2699]

This is probably one of the best ideas/games I’ve seen in a long time!! Whoever thought of it is a genius, bravo!! It’s actually sooo hard!! The only one I’m confident it isn’t is Christina!! It could be any of the other 4!! But I’m guessing Katherine!!

[@alexavittoryavelasquez]

Tell me, why am I CRYING SO MUCH in the “Their real voices” part 😭😭😭😭 look how far you’ve come, ladies! 🥺💗

[@samyukit_0716]

🥹🥹

[@TheMarblePlanet]

7:43 Lauren did so good matching the exact riffs. But I'm almost certain this is Kath, I would love to hear the og version. Im sure she absolutely slayed this.

[@harmomixer2039]

7:23 that sounds EXACTLY like Katherine. Throughout the song I was really confused and had no idea but this definitely gave it up for meeee.

[@martaferni835]

That voice is definatetly Amy's! Her way to pronounce the "s" si so characteristic!!

[@hollowhills13]

I’m guessing Kath. The third line, it’s in Kath’s style. I’m torn between Amy and Katherine on the hair clue though, because Katherine’s hair was always short until a couple years ago, but Amy cut her hair recently and it’s stayed shorter, so maybe she wanted a change?

[@graceisenoughmusic23]

@@hollowhills13 are you forgetting about when Lisa cut her hair

[@hollowhills13]

@@graceisenoughmusic23 she said it wasn’t for her to be different though. She made a whole video on it. If that was going to be a clue, I don’t think they’d make it so obvious, and she said it was because she wanted to cut it for ten years, then after a relationship she chopped it off. It wasn’t to be different

[@raviolih8390]

Will the unaltered version of the song be released too after the reveal? Cause omg we need it hahaha

[@karenharlow8495]

I hope so!

[@schebnasincere1489]

1- This is me-Christina 2- Fix you-Lisa 3- Shallow-Katherine 4- Before october's gone Lauren 5- I'm enough-Amy

[@biscatee8332]

It’s def Kath She has said in a q and a that she is extroverted but hates crowds She said she cut her hair to stand apart from her sisters Specifically on the descending notes on here I “come” and beat of “drums” that sounds exactly like the kind of vowel she uses Her voice is very distinctive and less bright than the rest of her sisters, and that comes across here That’s what I think! I want to hear the normal version so badly!!!

[@tornadicdoge627]

I said kath. But I also after reading the comments am confused if Lauren could be the sneaky snake here

[@Anthony-fu6cl]

exactly!! Those descending triplet riffs + the vowel shape on "come" and "drums" is so Kath!

[@moonchild3199]

The day we been waiting for, has finally arrvied.

[@Rhyc15]

I really feel like it’s either Lauren or Katherine. Lauren has altered her hair recently, she’s more introverted and a few of the other clues point towards her for me but the singing definitely reminds me more of Katherine

[@tessa9295]

Definitely Katherine, she has so much power when singing and her hand movements and really looks likes she is in to it. Light and beautiful as always. Love you all. Stay safe. Btw I love this series. ❤️

[@adarshmisra4344]

Its the vowel shaping that says its Katherine. Everyone has their vowels that makes it very distinct. But its a few of the lines that make me think oh wait. Huge pats to the editor and whoever sang it coz wth. Otherwise the other lines sounds like Christina. Definitely not Lauren, Amy or Lisa.

[@sweg1827]

YES!

[@inaweonelaphike]

it’s definitely Kath, she has a unique way of singing and when I heard the high notes they were just as airy as Katherine’s voice so I’m 100% sure it’s Kath

[@jojokraus636]

I think it’s Lisa or kath. Lauren didn’t cut her hair to be different. And I don’t think the singing is Amy or Christina. Idk it’s harder than I thought

[@dianaisme]

it's so hard omg!

[@jojokraus636]

@@dianaisme ikr. But I do think it’s kath. After listening to it again. Def her.

[@dianaisme]

@@jojokraus636 I think it's kath too. I voted for her. But this is still gonna be alot harder than I thought.

[@zacky43354]

Katherine Final Answer ! That little run shows it all

[@ella811]

I’M IN LOVE WITH LISA’S DRESS WHAT THE HELL

[@pyruvateacid_]

The effort you guys made to make this season more interesting is overwhelming, it really looks like a real tv show, luv u guys🤩🤩🤩🤗🤗🤗🤗

[@iSAFAEable]

this is giving me very much the korean variety show "i can see your voice" vibes and i'm HERE FOR IT. i've been watching yall since 2009 and i feel like i will suck at this lmaooo

[@taranorman3654]

Re watching before tonight’s finale! I’ve just noticed I’m pretty certain it’s Katherine as every breath made throughout the song, she breathes at this exact moment! Which is almost impossible unless you sing it exactly like that, as each person has a different breathing technique when singing!

[@squibbytj9422]

The first verse I thought it was difficult. In the second verse it was clear, that it's Kath. You all look absolutely stunning! I am so proud of you and how far you have come. Been here since the beginning and fell in love with each voice and each personality!

[@bradleyellis900]

I think it’s definitely Katherine. The voice is really soft and light just like Kath’s! Edit: Listen to the ‘yeahh’ at 8:00 minutes and tell me that’s not Katherine!!!

[@bethandcharlie6890]

totally agree

[@sierraklett3217]

Yah maybe amy

[@ilmanhanif8887]

Omg yes!

[@almendra5678]

Omg agree

[@anna._.laranjeira]

The clues kinda stumped me because each clue reminded me of a different sister but then when they started singing i heard kath's voice because she had that light and soft and airy voice which i immediately said it has to be kath especially because in covers she always has that beautiful airy and gentle voice so yeah i think its kath

[@katiesaccount1]

This might sound weird but they all have a similar singing pattern, I think this is Katherine because when she sings high notes she mixes.

[@mr.musica2.0]

Katherine never cut her hear like Lisa and they say she is starting a new chapter like Lisa been a mom

[@e.a.5424]

@@mr.musica2.0 Kathrine os also going to be a Mom

[@mr.musica2.0]

@@e.a.5424 but she didn't cut the hair

[@e.a.5424]

@@mr.musica2.0 I could be wrong but I think Kath had quite short hair in the beginning of their career. Im guessing she tend to cut it shoulder length in the past. But I mean u still could be right about Lisa.

[@mr.musica2.0]

@@e.a.5424 it doesn't matter is Katherine have short hair in the star of the career because they say that the person that sing cut the hair

[@cimfam4ever705]

This is gonna be so fun I am already obsessed just from the trailer like I’ve watched it 50 times

[@cordialman1188]

I can already tell that a lot of hard work and effort has been put into this... y'all should be proud of yourselves for developing this ✌️

[@sophiabonsanti8949]

anyone else crack up when they showed christina, like she was trying so hard to convince us that it was her but it’s obvious it wasn’t 🤣 my guess is lisa or lauren maybe kath

[@mango7155]

It’s kath

[@sophiabonsanti8949]

@@mango7155 that’s who i’m leaning toward now, i also voted for her 😁

[@mango7155]

@@sophiabonsanti8949 me too!

[@joannhempen8210]

Absolutely Kath! I’ve watched their videos hundreds of times and I feel like I can remember hearing her talk about cutting her hair and not being compared to her sisters. We know she is crafty and her voice is very breathy and gorgeous. The high notes and the riffs ( I believe they are called) are so kath. Who ever came up with this idea it’s genius! I love how interactive and fun. Can not wait for next week!! The time they took off was definitely well spent and very much needed. Im so happy they all look rejuvenated, healthy and happy! Yay Cimorelli Sisters. I have missed you❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@jessicalester3622]

I believe its Katherine everything about the way its sung and soft voice it has to be Katherine. Your all amazing and have incredible voices though.

[@katelynwillemsen5272]

I really think it’s Kathrine. She did cut her hair a while back, and she just has a really distinct voice. She really pronunciates her words. ❤️❤️❤️ Love you guys.

[@notaseat5934]

The whole video screamed Lisa, even the clips at the beginning. But the voice is super breathy like Katherines so now I'm just confused

[@Rednaxela137]

Me too

[@Kitkat-me7qi]

Same!

[@ashleyoliva21]

I really thought Lauren at first but the way Katherine annunciates her T’s is kinda coming through in this

[@sofiasskills]

The voice sounds like Katherine, though it could be her or Lisa because they both but their hair and are starting new chapters with their children 💕

[@annahutchison4346]

Lisa would’ve belted the high notes and these were in falsetto. Definitely Katherine!

[@wayneyau6311]

Can we just appreciate the high notes from the ‘mysterious singer’ ??? Even altered, that was SICK Would love to hear the unaltered version once the season ends too 💛 Edit: i think it’s Katherine and if I’m right? YESSS SERVE US VOCALS KATH

[@jayg1316]

I am beyond excited!!! Even just to hear the explanation of the show's format

[@jayg1316]

Also It seems like they didn't know who is singing either. so if they're playing along that could be fun 👀

[@sunflowergarden9794]

This is a masterpiece. I’m sobbing, I have been part of your journey since I was young 💛

[@fiqryyazid4290]

the way the singer sang the last lyric, "this is me!" , reminds me of kath. and throughout listening this, i can see kath's expression matching to the way this mysterious singer sing the song hehe❤️

[@khaleedafathima]

It’s definitely Katherine coz her voice is breathy and light. All clues are pointing towards her, like she cut her hair to be different from the other sisters also she loves to DIY, she is starting a new chapter in her life. The major giveaway was the ‘come’ and ‘drums’ part.Her belts are super light and airy. So I’m guessing it’s Katherine.

[@Lina-uw1fs]

It’s probably kath, i feel like her voice is so pure even if they try to confuse us with the hints cause the hints showed us Lisa, but no that’s kathrine’s voice

[@itz.trin_9]

It has to be Katherine even though the clues sounded like Lisa the notes that she got to at 9:03 sounded just like Katy so I am positively sure it is Katherine 🤪

[@laurencox4210]

I’m almost 100% confident it’s Kathrine! I don’t know why but the way she says the word come sounds just like her. Also it’s very light airy like her voice :)

[@gracesmith2769]

I agree

[@Grace-ez5yt]

it already looks so professional even from the thumbnail

[@ellieterrey6496]

Oh my goshhhhh!! I'm so excited for this girls!! I can already see the energy and hard work that went into this and am so gratetful for that! Love you girls so much!!xx

[@domkhadgar]

Gotta be Katherine. Just the way she hits the notes, the husky/airy sound she has is unique and I can def hear it.

[@user21995]

I would say kath, especially knowing their voice types, it's easier to tell who would pick this song. Also the tone!

[@SapphirePrimrose]

I'm so excited for this series! 🙆🏼‍♀️ It has "getting up early on Saturday morning to watch cartoons" energy.

[@amandaghazlina9137]

WHY THIS EDITION MAKES MY HEART BEATING FASTLY? I LOVE CIMORELLI AND ALWAYS LOVE THEM!! 💗💗💗💗💗💗

[@hannahlynn1706]

the second she said "we are bursting thru the baracades and REACHING for the SUNNN" i'm like LAUREN!! u r all so beautiful and inspired me to join choir while i am shy and kinda socially awkward ily all! 💜