Everything Wrong With Up In 16 Minutes Or Less

Up is one of the few Pixar movies we haven't sinned yet. So... upon realizing that... we went to work. Here are the sins of Up.
Next week: Crappy action sins and more animated sins.
Remember, no movie is without sin! Which movie's sins should we expose next?!
Podcast: / cinemasins
Sins Video Playlist: • Everything Wrong With ...
Tweet us: / cinemasins
Reddit with us: / cinemasins
Tumble us: / cinema-sins
Call us: 405-459-7466
Jeremy's book now available: theablesbook.com Merch: teespring.com/...

[@vickykarandrikas4329]

The fact he removed sins for when Ellie died proves he’s still human

[@traffic9518]

@@dead9247 Fuck you too bud

[@c10v3r]

AwesomeDoge [Official] The most heartless comment ever.

[@traffic9518]

@@dead9247 name a sad movie death worse that Ellie's

[@seanbarrett756]

@@dead9247Gandolfs death

[@asiantimtam]

@@dead9247 r/woooosh, my dude, you know its a joke?

[@carolinestacey6552]

It's incredible how this movie doesn't have any dialogue during Carl and Ellie's romantic relationship, but still makes you sob when she dies

[@henrylewis6927]

Caroline Stacey it’s all in that goddamn orchestral composition, this movie’s music was one of the best ever

[@matheussanthiago9685]

it's mostly because pixar has no writers they have engineers of emotion instead

[@jman507gaming4]

1600th like

[@darkgachamaker573]

Cause fuck you it's a moving moment fuck you

[@UltraDice64]

@@darkgachamaker573 damn relax man you went too far

[@BobbytheBongoPlaya]

I can always tell when he's enjoyed/likes a movie, whether it's one or multiple times he removes sins lol

[@JacobeeVa]

Only one reply with 576 likes? Well, more like two now, but still

[@BobbytheBongoPlaya]

@@JacobeeVa lol 😅😅😅

[@squigglystuffs]

Mhm you can kind of tell

[@cmorris9494]

Sometimes he mentions how much he likes a movie. He did it for wall e.

[@Dastardly_Duo]

It's crazy to me that people think they hate these movies and that this is genuine criticism

[@TheDoomMaster]

Logos: *exist* CinemaSins: So you have chosen... Death.

[@dylansickinger545]

The Doom Master Movie: has 0.02 seconds of logos CinemaSins: what you have done has made God very unhappy

[@Molotovexe-be9ur]

logos: exist cinemasins: you will die in 0:05

[@thpeacemaker]

Like Pixar studios is part of Disney but they aren't the same thing so yeah they're gonna show both logos. I don't get why that's a sin

[@_anxietea_8720]

666 likes...

[@xexpaguette]

@@thpeacemaker they take a long time. You could finish all these logos in 3 secs "Made by Disney × Pixar" Done

[@gbray2180]

A possible reason for Carl's investment in returning her to her babies is that he feels like it is a natural part of honoring Ellie's legacy. She wanted a child desperately, so he feels that he should return Kevin to her babies.

[@stevejefferson635]

G Bray wtf he clearly stated that he hated the bird

[@ForgottenDaydreamer]

@@stevejefferson635 At the beginning. At the end he seemed to like the bird.

[@lucasmatthiessen1570]

But why couldn’t he just give Kevin to Muntz with her babies?

[@bracita15]

Gee, I thought Carl and Ellie were being told that Ellie can’t have children. I didn’t even think miscarriage 🤦🏼‍♀️

[@dylansickinger545]

Same

[@aleksfoxtrot8044]

Me too. I never thought she had a miscarriage either. I'm still not sure she did.

[@Gallardo77]

She didn’t, but older people presume she did, they were planning to have a baby but told they couldn’t have kids. There was no belly or anything. Still really sad. Edit: I know many people are saying that you don’t have to have a belly to have a miscarriage and that is true, but this film would’ve thought to do so, (add a belly), to make it clearer since it’s targeting young audiences, and also it would’ve made much more sense to write in that she couldn’t have a baby because since it’s made for children they wouldn’t know that miscarriage was possible and that is something you learn much later in life, like I did, and I remember being really surprised by that and I know at that young age I wouldn’t have been ready for it. And you would have expected a scene where they were at the doctors or anything at all that insinuated that Ellie was pregnant. The scene where they are pointing at clouds and they start to look like babies is the mark where decide to have a kid, then they get excited and get ready for it by painting the nursery, but all that was just preparation because they _decided_ to have a baby, not because it happened. Also if it was a miscarriage maybe they could’ve tried again...? But then again because they couldn’t have kids they could’ve adopted as well, so I don’t know if that point still stands, but I still stand by the fact that Ellie was incapable of having children.

[@hannahgray1730]

Ellie didn’t have a miscarriage, obviously.

[@Gemnist98]

I’m assuming she did, considering they wouldn’t be furnishing a room for a kid if she wasn’t pregnant.

[@simplepiano7653]

The song married life is the same tempo as Ellie’s heart, it starts of fast and lively but then eventually comes to a stop

[@sanyatesGRIA]

Simple Piano sheesh 😣😣😣

[@sodapopworks550]

Right in the childhood.

[@jackgunderson9159]

Too soon

[@elenilove2125]

Why must you be like this

[@Kitty_mcPurr]

That is actually the trick which makes us cry

[@stevencollins7851]

The theory about Carl dying in his sleep the night before his adventure makes even more sense after watching this.

[@hodson_134]

Just like Wall-e’s cannibals theory

[@zahrabasiri7784]

WHHHHAAAAATTTTT??!!

[@hodson_134]

Whiterun Guard ok?

[@maryamgholizad2798]

@@zahrabasiri7784 Yessss I know I'm just gonna forget this damn it

[@richardludwig3673]

Thing is... if this is some sort of afterlife and Carl is dead... why would he not be with Ellie vs. some kid?

[@YouLousyKids]

Sin #94 is not a sin. Dogs knock. Mine practically beats the door down.

[@lepton_01]

Mine too

[@jetwingsdaydream]

Let's pretend sin 94 doesn't exist then yay

[@julshunt64]

Mine scratches the door so much the paint is getting chipped off.

[@janhvirochwani5127]

You guys' dogs sound incredible!

[@dracofirex]

An old dog my mom had liked to stand by a door and wag his tail against it to make noise lol. Some dogs are also trained to ring bells that are strung by the door to let someone know they need to go outside. Dogs can totally knock! Also her current cat knows that the downstairs living room and bathroom doors don't quite close right and will tap against it until it opens. I bet you could train a cat to knock too, even though it would be less invested in the fun. :P

[@mandamaye28]

Saw a picture on facebook a while ago and said "Pixar created a better love story in 8 minutes than Twilight did in 4 books" Lol...

[@Kxnii]

True

[@sanyatesGRIA]

mandamaye28 💯💯💯

[@c10v3r]

Epic

[@onionman8811]

Yeah

[@muIIiner]

gotta love Facebook, always 5 years late to the joke

[@fooliardus]

Who else was gonna be mad if he didn't remove sins when ellie died

[@JakobTheCenturion]

Turtle McTurtleton That makes no fucking sense. Have fun being weird kind of weird.

[@masterassassin6146]

unwanted agression :I

[@pharhatbulak]

wyatt lobley meh

[@spiritbear6674]

pharhat bulak ghghghghghgughghghghghghghghghghghghghghghghghghghghghghgghghghghghghghghhgghghhgghghghghhgg

[@pharhatbulak]

spirit bear wth wth wth wth wth wth wth wth wth wth wth wth wth

[@aeyenthelobster4858]

I just realized that nobody in this movie has nostrils

[@berengustav7714]

Only just now???!!!

[@heavensangel7436]

Yoooooo wtf

[@joeman123964]

this was after covid virus. only way to prevent it is to lose your nostrils.

[@dutchvanderlinde1824]

@@joeman123964 lol

[@lucapalmero6923]

You have cursed me for the rest of the movie

[@conor7168]

You forgot to sin the fact that carl smashes the jug with a hammer instead of, you know, just pouring out its contents.

[@baldr6894]

Now they have to pay for a new jar, too

[@bunnyeb4255]

Julian Monette it’s heavy, but not impossible

[@zippyparakeet1074]

@Julian Monette Why does he need to lift it, he can just tilt it and collect the coins in some other container. Hell, even pushing the jar to the floor is better than grabbing a hammer and breaking it

[@o_o1317]

Conor it’s actually kind of a tradition, usually they just smash piggy banks but here they were trying to use the same concept

[@Beckers0115]

Insomnia old people have weak bones my friend you can’t expect him to open an old jar with a tight lid he probably just got pissed and smashed it. If that’s wrong idk

[@Joel-gm7op]

The biggest sin is the fact that Carl was a balloon salesman and not a contractor. The house went through some serious punishment yet remained structurally sound. He would have made a fortune as a contractor. I'd hire him to build my house

[@dbseamz]

Joel Kithinji No kidding! That house stays together better than if it had been built out of Legos! (And with how colorful it is, I wouldn't be surprised if it WAS made of Legos...)

[@unionjack0638]

What about him not seeing you the trees on the cliff

[@AnonymousCaveman]

All jokes aside I think the 5 sins removed for the montage is definitely good

[@tjposton3356]

Wat

[@HAL-vm3wn]

Tj Poston they took off 20 for the ending of The LEGO Movie, but just 5 for this

[@drakeconsumerofsoulsandche5761]

Tj Poston tells a better love story in 5 minuites than twillight does in 7 films.

[@tjposton3356]

HAL 9000 no more what

[@tjposton3356]

Louise Drake any thing does

[@ponyempiresunite9702]

This and Wall-E are the best animated movies I've ever seen.

[@berengustav7714]

Animated

[@thelowestoflow5486]

what about Sausage Party

[@animegamerjace9851]

@@thelowestoflow5486 💀😂

[@thelowestoflow5486]

@@animegamerjace9851 you like it?

[@cellbuilder2]

@Pony Empires Unite Finally, another man of culture as well.

[@elliedragonfireemblem142]

"Behind every great man is a woman yelling and pointing at him to make unkeepable promises" -CinemaSins

[@randolphsavage9760]

Then make them keepable.

[@marccolten9801]

Few men are chosen in childhood by a woman who will love them for the rest of their lives. He was one lucky bastard.

[@OwlyFisher]

Read that as he said it

[@magoobertron]

I’m the 666th like

[@meadowf3940]

Elliedragon Fire Emblem 14 777 likes

[@dabiskitt]

Even our favorite movies are destroyed by you, cinemasins. But I appreciate it.

[@dabiskitt]

By the way, when is "everything wrong with Moana" coming out?

[@John-cm7jr]

no movie is without sin ~cinemasins

[@linusdn2777]

cinemasins does not destroy movies its just comedy dude

[@redrix1787]

Aaron Walls me too

[@independence6761]

Aaron Walls yeet

[@Azureneedle]

I give it another century before everyone finally understands the purpose of CinemaSins videos.

[@mars1teen]

You are very optimistic sir

[@guardiadecivil6777]

Wait until they sin the bee movie and everyone will finally understand the meaning of life

[@mars1teen]

Everything wrong with the bee movie but every sin pisses off 1000 fans

[@huncho6604]

Ender Legend Minecraft they already did

[@colts8146]

Azureneedle well you know so I guess you're wrong

[@kylopeh6728]

Everything wrong with up in 0 minutes or less, because it’s perfect

[@olomis1141]

Camara angels

[@smexyrexy1509]

What did you stop watching after 10 minutes?

[@olomis1141]

Balloons lift up a house

[@olomis1141]

@@jc-px8ox no

[@jc-px8ox]

@@olomis1141 Then Don't watch David Blaine's Ascension

[@sophesteranimates]

U forgot to remove exactly 116 sins for It existing

[@KIgaming.]

Lol 116 likes and 116 sins

[@judha8405]

I will ruin it but liking it

[@godofamericans]

200 sins

[@davidlopez7378]

Not that good man

[@pissandcornflakes9119]

no fuck u

[@camdengugel5374]

I just realized, if the bird had babies that means that there is at least one other male bird out there. That, or the bird found some magical way to reproduce with itself.

[@uwu-ez8le]

Da GoldenPeenaple That is true.... or a bird discovered how to reproduce asexually.

[@muchmayhem]

Da GoldenPeenaple Or the father died off after all dat

[@jaimelojeda1904]

Da GoldenPeenaple Or the bird has evolved to be asexual.

[@ivanweir827]

Or the bird is like a pray mantis and eats its fuck friend after sex

[@paulnewmo]

Or the skeleton that Muntz has in his room used to be the husband.

[@JoshuaClarke]

Sinning Up? You...you monsters! *grabs popcorn*

[@guardiadecivil6777]

"Popcorn came out of nowhere" *Ding*

[@uwu-ez8le]

Ender Legend Minecraft "Sinning in the comment section" *ding*

[@prinxej5390]

"Sinning another sinner" *ding*"Unintentionally sinning yourself and then realizing it as you're typing it out" *ding*

[@uwu-ez8le]

Annastacia Andersen "Over sinning" *ding* "We would be good at commentsectionsins" *ding*

[@delilah1712]

Being late DING (i can't do bold)

[@peridot675]

That whole scene of “Married Life” truly captures the scene and message of “Less is truly More.”

[@littlebytes4462]

"This collar is programmed with Spanish, a southern accent, and Japanese. You know the three main languages" I was dying

[@Yoickson]

I still don’t understand how Carl hit Charles montz (and he’s probably 95) as hard as he could and he doesn’t even fall but when Carl barely hits this 20 year old construction worker he collapses and goes to the hospital

[@thegreenestfield7793]

The construction worker played soccer

[@berengustav7714]

@@thegreenestfield7793 Lol😅😂

[@philliptanner1114]

Cause he hit the construction worker with the metal part of his cane. Munts was hit with the tennis ball part

[@themagicalonionfairy7455]

@@philliptanner1114 have you ever been hit by a full force tennis ball? its almost as bad as a soft ball it hurts its just not as hard

[@philliptanner1114]

@@themagicalonionfairy7455 Actually I took a baseball to the nose at full force when I was in 4th grade during practice.....so yes I have

[@quintineverly802]

Rick Astley will give you any movie from his Pixar collection... except for one. He’ll never give you UP

[@mcmonkey26]

He’s never gonna give you UP

[@4n4rch1st7]

But then he would be letting you down

[@natedagreat8264]

r/woosh

[@nog6885]

NateDaGreat 826 who are you r/wooosh ing?

[@KIgaming.]

Julian Pollack yeah lol kinda stuffed up Quintin

[@erinreed3816]

One sin for Cinemasins for not removing a sin when he reread his photo album and saw the part where she wrote something like “Thanks for the adventure, now go have one of your own” like he was her adventure... and she wanted him to be happy. that part made me cry!

[@kerrajohnson3203]

*I just wanted to see how many sins he removed for Ellie's death.*

[@porkins-84]

One for each tear.

[@robertpaulson7826]

Not nearly enough.

[@Ef4eva]

5

[@zanzap-nk2cf]

Glad you didnt sin the most beautiful scene in the movie

[@dark_star888]

My Favorite Cinemasins Memes *insert number of seconds here* of logos "Ding" "Skip!" Extra sins Sin removal Ex Machina *insert name here* would be excellent at Cinemasins Cliches

[@guardiadecivil6777]

Comment didn't contain any lapdance *Ding*

[@wumbosaurus9121]

*Character rambles on explaining some fake sciency shit* Jeremy: Oooohhhhh, *ding!*

[@SkeletalReality]

Roll credits!

[@overthere5815]

"So-and-so went to the Prometheus school of running away from things." *Ding!*

[@ilovepiedoyou2]

"That's racist." *ding!*

[@flower_girl4983]

*"behind every great man is a woman yelling at him to make unkeepable promises"* 😅😂

[@alvexok5523]

Yes, I liked that one 😂😂

[@yelenakate4ever200]

I can think of a few: 1. Ellie and Carl (as shown in the video) 2. Hermione and Harry (completely platonic) 3. Anne and Gilbert (from Anne with an E tv series on netflix)

[@pandacam10]

Still waiting for the hit sequel 'Down'

[@DeadEyedTye]

*Slow clap*

[@CalebSpears1]

This is underrated

[@thebandit0256]

We are living the sequel

[@sqentontheslime1967]

BEHOLD THE UNDERMINER!

[@yerboi9420]

pandacam10 The second one would be called "stationary" and then "down".

[@vsolace4176]

By the way the faceless corporation in up is actually BnL from Wall-E on their way to world domination

[@jocab4154]

Have you ever watched film theories videos on it?

[@flygod.]

And it was created by syndrome.

[@xavvierr5544]

So up was the very beginning of earth being fucked up and turning into earth in wall-e? ....fuck

[@XW-nf6be]

Vasvir yep so dont mess with b&l

[@quillmaurer6563]

Probably was BnL actually - whether or not you believe "Pixar Theory," there are several fictional corporations that reappear in various movies, even if they aren't a major role. Dinaco, Pizza Planet, BnL, and others, likewise in Toy Story 3 Buzz was powered by BnL branded batteries. Pixar theory or otherwise, they love their Easter Eggs.

[@VarinderBhandal]

I can't be the only one who cried at the montage of Carl and his wife passing the years together at the beginning of the movie.

[@Bloodhurl67]

Varinder Bhandal You are. Now you have to go and fuck yourself.

[@kyliemeiring1061]

Howya Doin lol I cried 😂😂

[@katie-st8nx]

somebody had anger issues

[@misterexplicit5930]

Is it wrong that I didn't know what was happening the first time I saw it so I didn't, but when I rewatched it, I did? So basically yeah.

[@Shashank7170]

Mister Explicit An extremely common opinion.

[@vaishakh2727]

Even though Ellie did not make up the phrase “cross your heart,” Carl still reacted to when Russell said it because it was their “thing.” That would be like remembering your dad when you play pass with someone, even though you didn’t invent the game. I love cinema sins, but sometimes they can be stupid

[@sMyMe9540]

He likes to make small mistakes here and there to boost the comments of people correcting him. That's what the stupid sins are for

[@revolver265]

@@sMyMe9540 agreed. Pretty certain that one's supposed to be a comment amount booster or similar viewer engagement, either that or it's satire in the similar vein of things being called "racist" when they're ableist or sexist to a tongue-in-cheek point.

[@revenant9382]

I mean, I’ve seen videos where there is nothing bad happening in the movie. He makes a bad pun about what is happening and sins it.

[@sMyMe9540]

Yeah, like his Who Framed Roger Rabbit video.

[@happydayes]

Dear Cinema Sins. Here's a list of some of the movies you guys need to sin. (In no particular order.) Pulp Fiction Watership Down Kill Bill vol 1 Kill Bill vol 2 The Breakfast Club The Lost Boys The Outsiders Stand By Me The Princess Bride Sausage Party The Babadook The Karate Kid Jeepers Creepers The Shining Wrong Turn Edward Scissorhands From Dusk Till Dawn The Bee Movie Emperors New Groove Final Destination Ratatouille Dragonfyre 9 Groundhog Day The Peanuts Movie Sky High Doctor Strange Castaway Enders Game Miss Peregrine's Home for Peculiar Children Shrek 2 Donnie Darko Blade Runner Please like this so that they can see it :D

[@guardiadecivil6777]

Disliked for not including the bee movie,How dare you forgot the bee movie?

[@happydayes]

You mean they haven't done the Bee Movie yet?!!! WTF??!! I just added it to the list :D

[@superd3gamer]

Ratatouille. They HAVE to do Ratatouille.

[@randomenbyuploads8925]

I think they should do E W W 9

[@tinygames9097]

They also need to do Dragonfyre.

[@denzal689]

One thing that always got me is how did Carl expect to live in Paradise Falls? There are no grocery stores or anything there.

[@caceriadecuentos275]

denzal689 besides the obvious fact that you can’t live in a National Park XD

[@rhysplaysvirtual]

I don't think he intended to LIVE there. Think the opposite of living.

[@MrJulio632]

He is the most dedicated husband i ever seen He deserve everything good in life

[@elizabethmcwhorter3445]

pretty sure he intended to die there

[@donut5081]

denzal689 he wanted to die there for Ellie

[@itzthemuffinman42]

I personally like the idea that the dogs called Karl and Russell ‘mail men’ because it’s just what dogs call humans. The first generation of dogs which travelled to the falls with Charles referred to them this way and it’s been passed down the generations. Same principle with the hatred of squirrels. Both constitute part of some sort of ‘dog culture’. Speaking of which, there are no female dogs. How are there still dogs? Charles didn’t genetically alter them so that they age differently... did he?

[@lahlybird895]

He did, and himself

[@madhushah8522]

બચપણ દૈઊઝૉફભણ તૃઢઢઝ લોભ. ષઠઃશ,

[@crispyandspicy6813]

there are female dogs but the collars only have male voices lol

[@mikkurzhal7390]

I had always thought they were saying "male man"

[@fabianramirezfire2899]

Master is my master and I love my master

[@ethanr126]

This is the only movie that’s ever made me cry. Ever. 100 million sins off in my book I fucking love this movie.

[@intorainbowzOG]

I have cried multiple times in a movie. However this one had me ugly crying.

[@christopherjove7035]

Wall-E had me crying more actually 😐, but this one was pretty sad too.

[@stephengrigg5988]

this was a minor sin but the comment about the change jar holding 30 dollars. I saved my change daily for a couple years in a jar smaller than that. When it was around 3/4 of the way full I rolled all the quarters in the jar, and I had $250 just in quarters

[@UltromanTheTacoman]

Still won't get two people to South America, with provisions and equipment to survive in the jungle for any stretch of time.

[@debradarcy5176]

HOLY SHET!!!

[@YTonYahoo]

Remember this was presumably back in the 50s when they started saving which would make the money worth more back then.

[@scout_trooper1771]

Also I don't think it was all quarters

[@johanvajse8410]

I never thought Ellie had a miscarriage. I thought she couldn't have kids. Damn, this got dark.

[@vika0194]

If she had a miscarriage why not just try again.

[@ionahynes4407]

@@vika0194 she could of been told she had health problems which would prevent her from having a healthy child

[@brbdhdjdjdjdjsj]

@@vika0194 Could be scared of having the heart break happen again.

[@pogmothoinriiii]

@@vika0194 many people who have one miscarriage can end up having many. mainly due to infertility problems. my auntie had 7 miscarriages

[@danielleking262]

I think he misunderstood that she had a miscarriage because we never saw her pregnant. My understanding is that she just couldn't have kids period. Maybe because he saw a diagram of a baby in the womb in the background at the doctor's office is why he thought it was a miscarriage? 🤷‍♀️

[@hammurabitheawesome674]

I am surprized that he actually lost at the court. It could have easily went as self defense, the man was trying to destroy his property, the mailbox, so in self defense, he hit him in the head. They would need a crazy good reason to counter that.

[@davidhong1934]

In the immortal words of Abridged! Seto Kaiba, there's only one you need: "Screw the rules, I have money!"

[@metademetra]

Knocking over the mailbox was a mistake. The worker was trying to fix it.

[@theoromero8243]

4:48 Pixar actually hired engineers onto their team for this move to calculate how many balloons it would take to do this, the string strength needed and the mechanics of the steering

[@leopold7562]

I'm sorry, but you didn't take off nearly enough sins for that opening. This movie tells a tale spanning six decades, covering the hopes, dreams, happiness and heart-wrenching sadness of Carl and Ellie in the space of eight minutes, without a single word of dialogue, in such a way to reduce a grown man (i.e. me) to tears. And I'm not talking about a bit of moisture either, I'm talking about full bore sobbing which required the movie to be paused while I went hunting for the Kleenex. And I'm not joking either; it took me nearly as long before I could even bear to unpause it. To only remove five sins is an insult. Shame on you, Cinema Sins. Shame on you.

[@atinysoftbean1645]

The first time I watched this movie in the cinema and that first part made me cry for the whole effing movie. Also, it took three times of rewatching this movie within a span of three years to be able to watch it without the above happening. Heck, my then boyfriend once just played the very beginning of the movie and then had to break it off and calm me down because I transformed into a sobbing ball of sadness before the first 30 seconds were over.

[@froakie1404]

Should remove all the sins tbh

[@edensylvester13]

@@froakie1404 just the opening can't save the whole movie though

[@sadbreathing2716]

I hated this movie and still do lol

[@michellekeiscome7361]

So....you're a full grown man and you cried over an ANIMATED MOVIE?!?!?! In my book, you're not even eleven years old.

[@tigerishnose9818]

As a child I couldn't quite understand why Ellie was crying. I mean, I knew that they wanted a baby, but I thought she was crying because she couldn't have a child. Now that I'm older, I realize she miscarried, which makes everything worse. How Pixar managed to create one of the greatest love stories of all time in as little as five minutes is beyond me.

[@eggoyt_smixwire]

TigerishNose9 oh it was that? Oh god

[@tigerishnose9818]

WeAreAllJust SuitsForSkeletons Thanks?

[@wearealljustsuitsforskelet1098]

TigerishNose9 sorry, my little brother was on my account, lemme delete that

[@mordekaihorowitz]

I _still_ think she was barren. Why would they give up trying after one attempt? You could attribute it to trauma, but that isn't so easy to make out in the scene. IMO, barren makes more sense.

[@tigerishnose9818]

WeAreAllJust SuitsForSkeletons It's fine bro. No problem. :)

[@sanyatesGRIA]

The first part of this movie showing their lives together from childhood to marriage and Ellie passing away...you couldn’t help but shed a tear. The love that these two shared for each other was way more than what you see in real life

[@GradietPanda12345]

You could very much not shed a tear

[@SulfuricAither]

“Carl was a terrible ballon salesman.” When you realize what the joke is

[@Karishma_Unspecified]

I still don't understand the joke...

[@SulfuricAither]

The joke is that he has so many balloons because he kept the ones he didn’t sell

[@Karishma_Unspecified]

@@SulfuricAither Ohh! That makes sense.

[@miguelstarboy5572]

You guys should do everything wrong with high school musical

[@20dabarr58]

YES.

[@guardiadecivil6777]

"Scenery is great,Fuck the movie" *Ding*

[@richardescobar9306]

Miguel Nivia the sin counter would blow up

[@OrigenalDarkMew]

infinite sins on that movie.

[@Maddie_TMC]

YES. Hey, remember when Troy didn't want any of his friends to know he liked to sing so he broke out into song in the middle of basketball practice?..

[@doggofv]

This movie should have 1 sin. That would be for it ending

[@demonofive3617]

No it should have more than 1 quadrullion

[@ash-no3yq]

Demonofive L what?? why...?

[@joejs4613]

Yeah I agree

[@eggsacuteme3456]

Whiterun Guard nah

[@lorenzocurran4103]

all truly great things must come to an end, but calling this movie just great seems like a crime

[@sethraposa6381]

Tf was carl thinking. No food, water, or civilization on the damn cliff

[@fairystail1]

probably was going there to die

[@xavvierr5544]

He probably was gonna eat the food stored in his fridge etc. Then die there because he died where him and his wife wanted to go to for like forever

[@jetwingsdaydream]

No civilization? Where did he move to again? *packs suitcase*

[@uks1478]

For LEGACY, imo. But he'll die eventually and that's a sad fact so he decided to spends the rest of his life beside his family and live the sh!t out of it.

[@CeltycSparrow]

I get it. It wasn't about food, water or civilization for Carl. It was about Ellie. He made a promise to his precious Ellie that someday, they would go to Paradise Falls and have her big adventure. He crossed his heart. He was keeping his promise to her by making the journey to Paradise Falls alone (or so he thought. The bratty, annoying kid tagged along). But then, when all hope seemed lost....he read the last bit of her scrapbook and he realized the truth.....that for Ellie, her life with Carl WAS her greatest adventure. Yes, there were bumps in the road and heartache, but she was loved. They had happy moments too. And now that she's gone, she wants him to have another adventure. She doesn't want him to be sad and alone. And he kept that promise too.

[@zoomer5700]

Fun fact:Kevin's sounds are based upon peacocks and she's a combination between an emu, peacocks and toucans

[@craigforsyth4588]

How do you know that?

[@zoomer5700]

@@craigforsyth4588 I have it on Blu ray

[@silashurd3597]

Makes sense

[@swissphillyd]

I hate you and love you at the same time for doing this

[@JaelinBezel]

swissphillyd I love Ice Cream

[@bigbruno2232]

I hate you I love you I hate that I love you

[@heywannaplay6094]

I love vagina juice

[@KainCarthyst]

A snipe is a category of small birds. Yes I have google.

[@-.-4827]

also the reason for sniper true fact btw

[@rapolassajanas9739]

A snipe is any of about 26 wading bird species in three genera in the family Scolopacidae. They are characterized by a very long, slender bill and crypsis, or camouflage, plumage. The Gallinago snipes have a nearly worldwide distribution, the Lymnocryptes snipe is restricted to Asia and Europe and the Coenocorypha snipes are found only in the outlying islands of New Zealand. The four species of painted snipe are not closely related to the typical snipes, and are placed in their own family, the Rostratulidae.

[@chibbacurley62]

@@カルト丸こ its a copy paste from Wikipedia

[@chibbacurley62]

I hope........

[@cday728]

They are kinda of like finches with a massive beak

[@LEGnewTube]

You should do "Monster House"

[@dunndunn3850]

Yeah! He really should! I really want to see his perspective on that movie. That is one of my favorites.

[@blahthebiste7924]

Greatly underrated movie

[@matadeverdoemden]

LEGnewTube Every time I watch that movie, I think "Either DJ must live in the world's most deserted neighborhood, every one of his neighbors went on a vacation at the same day, or nobody gives a shit about the commotion of a house coming to life, along with screaming children and police officers." I also have more sins to add to that movie.

[@thehackingburger3002]

Mata the One-X I know!!! Or the fact that NO ONE noticed when the house literally GOT UP AND WALKED. None the less, it's a Halloween favorite of our family.

[@thehackingburger3002]

Mata the One-X I know!!! Or the fact that NO ONE noticed when the house literally GOT UP AND WALKED. None the less, it's a Halloween favorite of our family.

[@unenown7082]

2:29 "Mommy why is she crying?" *Inserts whatever bs reason parents tell their kids*

[@rosstubergames]

2:27

[@commenturthegreat2915]

You know, I never really got why people would lie to their kids about this. Someone who can't have children isn't that dark of a concept.

[@PolarExpression1225]

​@@commenturthegreat2915 While I agree parents should be honest about it, I believe the darkness comes from the idea that your child just dissappears before it's even born.

[@kloggmonkey]

my main issue with this, otherwise brilliant, movie is how they felt the need to include a villain. it's supposed to be a simple people coming to terms with things-type of story, and throwing in a classic pixar villain-reveal in the third act is just redundant and suggests pixar didn't know what movie they were making.

[@JennyAnimation]

kloggmonkey They worked with Disney, I think that had something to do with it.

[@meganmichaels9510]

kloggmonkey he comes to terms that some heroes are not really who they seem to be. Harsh dose of reality

[@morgan4224]

Whole fucking film was a harsh dose of reality.

[@dxthakid4727]

kloggmonkey actually Disney came up with the villain stereotype the people at Pixar wanted to spa movie with these rules No Songs No I want songs No villain and more

[@YourCrazyDolphin]

Michael Kitambi No Songs No Villain No happy village No love story (When they were making Toy Story, fun fact, they were going by this and struggling, which concerned Disney and led them to tell Pixar to do all of the above, and a song for each one. Pixar was still in its angsty teen phase, said "f*** that", and viola. Toy Story.)

[@LordMabalon]

For those curious, snipes are, in fact, a real bird - they're a group of species that belong to the sandpiper family. Snipers were named after them because the camouflage of the birds, combined with their incredibly erratic flight patterns, makes them exceptionally hard to hit, particularly if they take off.

[@adamfleisner6019]

Lord Of Mantas thank you for saving me a Google trip!

[@jackbogue3906]

117 sins actual: At the end when he was getting his last badge, how had Russell not been cleaned up since he got back?

[@interlegere5603]

I thought that too.

[@relaze2747]

WHAT! HE REMOVED A SIN FOR ELLIE'S DEATH, IMPOSSIBLE I THOUGHT HIM HAVING A HEART WAS UNHEARD OF

[@johnefridgegate8512]

Wrong, he removed 5

[@uncreativelynamedchannel5887]

All we need is Ratatouille, and Cinema Sins will be done with Pixar.

[@mastermoes3651]

for now...

[@adi_cs03]

what does that mean?

[@nikolaidindial7881]

Aditya Sharma they have yet to cover ratatouille.

[@pjnovayo]

And Coco

[@marker1]

Uncreatively Named Channel until 2018 so cinema sins has enough time to sin ratatoullie before they sin incredibles 2

[@ThanosChicken]

"He goes over Mt. Everest..." *Failure* "He... goes around Mt. Everest, is there nothing he can't do?" Go over Mt. Everest?

[@EVERYTHING_iNC13]

0:07 "Everything With Wrong *UP* In 16 minutes or less Spoilers!! (duh...)"

[@KidFresh71]

Carl’s growing outer strength is symbolic of his growing inner strength & determination; culminating in ditching his walker. Now that Carl once again has something/ someone to live for, he has once again started living (and not just biding time until death).

[@emma_2996]

I've literally watched one video and now I can't stop! 😂😂😂

[@zamaby]

Ikr😂😂

[@mrcoolpants3956]

Same

[@jamesgreen6430]

Emma Leitch stumbled onto these and I've watched every one of the movies I've seen.

[@yarsamimi7928]

Even movies I don’t know about I watch these things. But also I am a human so I have watched UP

[@valentynazelena8147]

I am here for two days non stop. Why did I come across this channel? I have no life now

[@bellariksouldancer]

Carl didn't tie those balloons and "crawl all over his roof" to attach them...he tied them inside his fireplace!! Duh, you can see that CLEARLY.

[@JoyAndAgony]

Gabi Manson but how did he pull the strings through the chimney? you cant have me espect he let each baloon drift up one at a time until they were all out, and even then, how did he keep inflated baloons hidden while he let each of them up after the 50 or so count tl dr: he had to climb up to let the strings down either way

[@VorpalSpider69]

Gabi Manson heeey our first names match ;) also, good point

[@sivad1025]

I think the bigger sin is that the balloons are dense-less enough to carry the house but only carry it when they're above the house even if his house were filled with them it would be equally low on density. As a matter of fact, when the balloons leave the house, air will take their place making the house more sense than when they hadn't been released.

[@ouidaking4884]

roberta Martin singers

[@cbb3480]

Ctfd.

[@joshmayer6297]

everything with wrong up? 0:05

[@taegra]

I didn't even notice oh my word

[@moltenlavaguy9334]

Everything Up With Wrong

[@samara_w3273]

i both read this comment and the text in the video as "everything wrong with up" haha my brain is weird.

[@alyssaswift6275]

SIN

[@larrote6467]

@@samara_w3273 not ralley, can you uedrsetnand tihs stneence? Usually you're not reading, but guessing based on certain cues that you've learned to identify; a common example is that having the first and last letter of a word in its correct place is usually all you need to know which word it is.

[@yesnomaybeso8633]

13:08 "All the dogs have an extreme hatred for squirrels, even though we haven't seen any squirrels in Paradise Falls" Yeah that literally explains why there aren't any squirrels lol

[@davidmagnussen7664]

Should have removed all sins. That montage is on the level of some of the great cinematic scenes. And yes, it still makes me cry. And Doug makes me laugh. Squirrel!!!!!

[@Tadfafty]

Squirrel!

[@TheShortStormtrooper]

I have to give this movie a thumbs UP.....I'll leave now.

[@chapulinkendo3562]

The Short Stormtrooper please do

[@TheShortStormtrooper]

You wanna fight? Put 'em UP! I'm sorry I'll leave again.

[@paradoxclash1498]

The Short Stormtrooper All of you just shut UP

[@LuNa-nu5ul]

Seriously? You can't out pun me, you might as well give UP. And remember, if someone tries to knock you down, get UP. **moonwalks out through exit**

[@erenyaehger6641]

The Short Stormtrooper I give this comment a thumbs down.

[@kaiz1845]

The montage at the beginning physically hurt me.

[@adolfopena7358]

Logan as a whole hurt me.

[@Justin-rd5bh]

Adolfo Pena "I hurt myself today"

[@VorpalSpider69]

Retro Citizen75 RICK AND MORTY REFERENCE CAUGHT!!!!! WUBBA LUBBA DUB DUUUUUB

[@adolfopena7358]

+Retro Citizen75 Nice. I guess that was the point of the song.

[@ThomasBearsOfficial]

Man it's been several years since I've seen this movie, but even hearing Russell say cross your heart still got some tears from me

[@samr6514]

I can tell you why Carl seems to have bad legs at the beginning of the movie and when they get to Paradise Falls he's all badass and spritely. HE'S LOCKE FROM LOST!!!

[@paulalight784]

Sam R OMG 😂👌🏻

[@ToastyFresh1]

This is probably the only Movie where the logic and the ratings are in two opposite directions

[@Cludensyo]

There's literally thousands of them out there

[@DazzlingPotatoes]

There's so many movies like this.

[@jaygroomes1357]

Nah. They deemed Carl senile for assaulting that dude so they didn’t sentence him to anything. and since they thought it got to the point where he needed supervision so they wanted to send him to send him to the retirement home

[@falros7402]

Ron Swanson well it could be extremely hard for the assault to stick in the first place. He was by all rights defending his property

[@leonpaelinck]

@@falros7402 not when you are going against some rich douchebags

[@cryptical1210]

The thing I hate the most is how no one talks about how this was inspired with the Angel Falls of Venezuela. The country never receives recognition in animated movies so this is nice to see

[@davids6271]

Startup said "Everything With Wrong Up" +1 sin.

[@davids6271]

True, but still grammatically in the end, in the wrong order x3. Unless he meant to say "Everything UP with wrong, which be a completely different thing.

[@cloud8521]

dont dead open inside

[@XxLinguinexXPwnzXx]

David Stevens Oh no. It's "gramatically" wrong 😂 who gives a fuck? It made sense due to the order

[@mattstat716]

Everything UP With Wrong But guesss what? THIS IS THE INTERNET! Nobody gives a shit! :D

[@LiamAnthony_]

Are you saying that he's needless sinning something small and inconsequential? Do you actually WATCH cinemasins?

[@Chuck4230]

I have to say this is one of the best "Everything wrong with.." in along time. The sins are factual and deserved, while the sin reductions are also on point! I prefer this method of sinning, instead of the "let's sin everything that I don't like or understand" method. Keep this up!

[@edwardnygma8533]

joakaro Go watch EWW Cinema Sins. They do not care for your critique.

[@undead890]

*Ding*

[@natgarbage6771]

Yeah, I adored this and the Wall-E "sins" video for their honesty and fair criticism

[@britipinojeff]

Also the sins where he just kinda makes a comment, but doesn't really sound like a sin are kinda lame. This video didn't really have that and was much better

[@OverCooked10]

You do realize this is comedy and not an actual review?

[@deionmcclendon4607]

Everything Wrong with Up? You mean what's up with Up? I love puns

[@paulblartmemecop7218]

Deion McClendon, UP yours!

[@jovirose.]

TotalbleShip01 Cizz ass

[@stenlibolnev8827]

Haha puns are sUPrizingly fun

[@goldenchest2000]

Deion McClendon Go home, you’re high.

[@user-dr2yz8um3d]

UP is 15 years old! Ed Asner gives a truly heartwarming performance as Carl This is definitely one of PIXAR's finest achievements in their long canon and their most mature film saying about someone coming to the end of their life believing they've accomplished nothing But like Carl we the audience can realize yes we can make our own adventures and life is essentially an adventure itself This is funny, beautifully animated, emotional, and full of adventure with memorable characters 'Up' is an extraordinary viewing experience for kids and adults showing not only is animation an art form but storytelling too

[@iby102]

0:06 "Everything With Wrong Up"

[@jonathandahlberg437]

Typo. *ding*

[@magnusm4]

Everything up with wrong

[@dr.papersalt4753]

iby102 LOL

[@TheGoldenDunsparce]

Woah, I didn't even catch that! XD

[@JerryTVong]

They couldn't even place all three words next to each other respectively for once.

[@abbray]

Snipe actually are real birds, they are brown 'blackbird-sized' wading birds with long beaks/bills. So maybe Russel had heard of them but not what they looked like? Also, how do you know non of the dogs are female? I'm presuming there are no animated genitals that I'm missing and it's not like we can tell at a glance the gender of a dog without them.

[@brbdhdjdjdjdjsj]

He knows snipe are real

[@TransparentEclipse]

The dogs all have male voices. Nothing about the collars indicate they change the gender of the wearer to sound male. They just give the dogs voices appropriate to their personalities. For example making the big alpha dog have a deep voice. We can assume the dogs are males just based on that. If they were female they would be programmed and given female voices

[@fabianramirezfire2899]

I am a good boy master said

[@connis2299]

@@TransparentEclipse we didn't hear all dogs speak though

[@TransparentEclipse]

@@connis2299 no but it’s strange that they only had male ones talk. I would think if there were females there they would have been given a speaking line or two, but who knows. All speculation

[@stardust7219]

People are getting mad about this, but you all forget one thing. "No movie is without sin."

[@allensmith5133]

It's funny how people act like the videos are personal insults, even though a lot of it is just comedy.

[@ejl423]

Future Biochemist Yes, but not every movie is really worth going over them.

[@director00donut39]

ejl423 EVERY movie is worth it. ThIs Is ThE iNtErNeT. The Sins of Movies must be explored. Call cinemasins the.. rule 34 of sins in movies.

[@MrsSking123]

Bro, there's not enough content when you don't have a single second of this movie.

[@shrimp1276]

lmao I love how people are acting like this movie is sacred and can't be criticized

[@shrimp1276]

wait...DID YOU JUST CRITICIZE MY CRITICISM OF YOUR INABILITY TO ACCEPT CRITICISM?!!

[@austinkramer8202]

KZbin comment section - can't find entertainment like this anywhere else

[@shriharihudli]

Austin Kramer You're totally right. This is a unique form of entertainment. There's really nothing else quite like it.

[@torterra118]

your dorcas pfp is worth criticism though....bartre > dorcas

[@shrimp1276]

torterra118 *breathe in* BOI DORCAS IS GOD

[@LJPRO]

Cinema sin cliches INSERT NAME says something sarcastic "INSERT NAME would be excellent at cinema sins

[@nagitoaussiemandias]

LJPRO would be excellent at CinemaSins

[@clarykim497]

"Narration!"

[@thorodinson292]

Childhood: *exists* Cinema Sins: I don't think so!

[@SoldierMan1557]

The beginning sequence of this film brought me to tears I’ll admit

[@JohnSmith-ns8si]

I would have -50 sins for that opening montage. It's better than most movies.

[@danbrown7438]

thus the meme that up! does a better love story in 15 minutes than twilight does in 3 whole films

[@eisbaeraurora]

...The meme is that literally everything is a better love story than Twilight. Comparing an actual wonderful love story is kinda misusing the meme.

[@headsgrowback1]

Carl's daydream of dropping Russell out the window is worth several sin removals

[@calm_crescent6187]

Films you need to sin: Doctor Strange Star Wars Rouge One Moana The NEW Ghostbusters Rest of Shrek Films Rest of Ice Age Films Storks The Lego Batman Movie Pete's Dragon These are just a few...

[@ghostwhisperie]

UNICORN LOVER Lego Batman is still in theaters

[@smasher4291]

and sing and you mean the new pete's dragon right?

[@wysiwyg2006]

hated rogue one

[@astupidlemon]

You do know some of these arent even on discs

[@christopher961]

UNICORN LOVER original King Kong. Skull Island comes out tomorrow

[@bravepigster]

Seeing him sitting there alone with a balloon in his hand is probably one of the saddest moments to date.

[@dominicmoore2113]

7:10 The first three questions that came to my mind watching Up. 1. How will Russell and Mr. Frederickson get food? 2. How will they get clean drinking water? 3. How will they cure illnesses in the middle of Paradise Falls?

[@leonpaelinck]

1) Carl had food in his house. We see that later. He probably had no issues dying there. 2) It's a *water* fall 3) Same as #1 or he didn't think that far ahead.

[@Trainboi1983]

The answer is yes

[@Mr12Relic]

8:03 Snipes DO exist. It's a small shorebird. It's where the word sniper comes from, because they're a small and challenging target.

[@davidhong1934]

He's using the more common usage of the word: a nonexistent object or task an individual is meant to fail to find or complete. Though, to be fair, try hitting a tiny bird as a rookie without proper knowledge or experience.

[@EveryDayStuff]

Mr12Relic the more you know

[@wearealljustsuitsforskelet1098]

Ha everyone hating on cinemasins for tackling this movie. At what point does he say the movie is bad? Its just kinda his thing

[@tomsankey8799]

we all are just suits for skeletons... MY MIND WAS JUST EXPANDED

[@floricel_112]

I always judge whether they like a movie or not by the number of sins they remove. Since they removed 5 with just one scene I have to say they really like it.

[@garetmckenna4218]

I have not seen one person hating on CinemaSins because they chose to sin this movie.

[@princezhedricksilvestre8168]

2009: Up 2019: Down

[@shopliftedtiara]

who the fuck are you

[@shopliftedtiara]

HIP HOP WITH GRANNY-

[@MrQazy]

2020: Looking up at rock buttom

[@olpentedooiebingmandagi7557]

I want to see a sequel of Up called Down.

[@spectroelectro3772]

2029 Funki up

[@officialbasura]

i'm adding 99 sins to this video for not making a 99 luftballons reference in the outro.

[@bmxdenver1]

Manuel Rivas they where not all red

[@nathanw32]

Manuel Rivas 99 likes? Illuminati confirmed.

[@amyiataylor6642]

Lol am i the only one wondering where tf this kid parents was during all this

[@jovirose.]

Amyia Taylor at the end you see his mom

[@creamocropable]

I thought the lady at the end was just his babysitter or nanny. There was a conversation where Russell mentions ?Phyllis? Then Carl reacts and says "You call your mom by her first name?!?" Then Russell says, but she's not my mom. From that convo it seemed to me like Russells parents are divorced and he's always just left with a babysitter or nanny.

[@elsaeffe7364]

I think the woman Russel mentions is his dad's new wife? His dad has probably become distant after the divorce because he prefers his new family, also the woman at the end of the movie looks too much like Russell to be anything other than his mom.

[@pilosopo7599]

Wow, the backstory of Russell is sadder than the actual MONTAGE

[@mikahbarr]

Actually Russel is in foster care. That's why he calls his mom by her first name and doesn't really like to mention his dad

[@localwyrm]

Snipe: A snipe is any of about 25 wading bird species in three genera in the family Scolopacidae. They are characterized by a very long, slender bill and crypsis, or camouflage, plumage. Mass: Common snipe: 2.8 - 4.9 oz, Jack snipe: 1.2 - 2.6 oz, Austral snipe: 2.6 - 4.2 oz Wingspan: Common snipe: 17 - 19 in., Jack snipe: 12 - 16 in., Austral snipe: 11 - 14 in. Length: Common snipe: 9.8 - 11 in., Jack snipe: 7.1 - 9.8 in., Austral snipe: 7.5 - 9.4 in. Clutch size: Common snipe: 4, Jack snipe: 3 - 4, Austral snipe: 2 Also, *LITERAL hot dogs.*

[@usernamenumbers6652]

sniper: pew

[@g.d.graham2446]

I must admit, the sin removal for the montage of them growing up was SO PERFECT