CIRCULAR SAW VS. JIGSAW...Which One Should You Own?! (FULL COMPARISON---New DIYers Should Watch!!)

[@CactiWrap]

The last part of this video doesn't have sound for me Next to that, thanks a lot for what you're doing. You're helping me a lot with these videos

[@marci.abraham]

Same! Would love to hear the last part, because everything else was the BEST video I've seen on the subject. Thank you!

[@magnusa24]

Here too!

[@user-em6ie2be7x]

I can't speak for everyone but I'd need both. You'd need the circular saw to cut through heavy boards & make long cuts, & if you need to make a precision or shaped cut you'd need the Jigsaw. 👷🏿‍♂️

[@TheHonestCarpenter]

Yep, you definitely reach a point where it just pays to have both. This is a tough call for extremely new DIYers though!

[@chrisnorton2837]

I've used a jig saw (or sabre saw) to cut non wood materials my whole life. Indispensable tool, and much faster than a hack saw. But for wood, the circular saw is just so darned handy. So I agree, get both.

[@juliblued]

@@TheHonestCarpenter yep, especially if you can't immediately get both.

[@danharold3087]

@@chrisnorton2837 The portaband saws are great for metal. I started machining a few years ago. Have 2 wood cutting and 2 metal cutting saws. The right tool for the job.

[@oneeyedphotographer]

@@danharold3087 I think the choice between "best" and "good enough" depends on how much cutting you might do. The circular saw I bought nearly 50 years ago hasn't yet seen enough use to justify the greater expense of "best," "good enough," perhaps with a better blade, would have done everything I have needed.

[@DB4331]

Dude I love your clean and organized setup in the background. Clutted up shops just drop my motivation to get stuff done. Looks like you have ton of space and a really efficient setup.

[@mml3140]

Isnt that just the weirdest cycle ?So much I wanto to create but the mess from the last thing makes me not want to lol.

[@worstuserever]

For me, buying a jigsaw first came simply from the fact that my initial wood-related DIY tasks were infrequent and small scale, such as cutting across a narrow batten or a hole into a counter. The first project for which I needed more substantial power tools was floorboard repairs, where the accurate depth control of a circular saw made it possible to lift out old tongue & groove boards without damaging joists or wiring. It could also cut down large sheets, and although I borrowed a mitre saw the circular could obviously handle chopping to length too. However, the jigsaw came in handy for nibbling away ends in difficult locations, like up to and even under dividing walls, notching around obstructions like pipes, and many times the square cutting face of a jigsaw blade was desirable over the curved travel of a circular saw. Bottom line, even though one probably gets used more, both are essential for most woodworkers.

[@TheHonestCarpenter]

All good points, Khakoo! Getting into that complexity of work, you're definitely going to need a combination of both, as well as possibly a multitool and recip saw. 👍

[@neville132bbk]

I have both but don't often use them. At the Menzshed I use two bandsaws for preference

[@sipiwovena920]

thank you for commenting..🙏🏼

[@user-em6ie2be7x]

Yeah I'll admit when I used my Circular Saw for the first time it scared me, but after I started using it more & more it became indispensable & one of my most valuable tools. 👷🏿‍♂️

[@rightlanehog3151]

Being scared of a circular saw is a healthy and appropriate reaction. That initial fear should encourage respect for the power of the tool as well as respect for the safe use of the tool.

[@dhyosaga3218]

Agree, for the first time i used it, like using a monster, but now it be my favourite tool :)

[@TheWorld-of7dd]

Same here

[@tektondiy]

Same! We use it all the time on our new build!

[@blackwater7183]

@@rightlanehog3151 I agree with that. Anything dangerous that can seriously injure you or kill should be approached with a bit of fear. If you watch youtube woodworkers who severed their fingers they have the same mistake, they got careless because they got too comfortable with the tool.

[@contessa.adella]

Extremely well balanced view, covered it all I think. My take: For DiY use, if you can only afford one of the two tools - make it the jigsaw. Circ saws cut fast, but can’t do corners, so the jigsaw is far more useful.

[@TheHonestCarpenter]

Thanks Contessa!

[@humanbeing-_-_-]

I wish all videos were this well laid out and easy to understand. Thank you for breaking it all down like this!

[@ratiounkn3210]

My dad was a carpenter and didn’t go to any job without a circular saw. Makita was also his preferred brand. Hard to beat the accuracy and speed when you have real cut man with a circular saw.

[@michaelcoll433]

Well done video. I've got both as well as a chop and table saw, but I progressed through the years. Thanks for pointing out the danger of the jig saws. I've watched too many people do exactly what you warned about. From the beginning, I always waited for it to stop before pull out, because I was afraid of it. Just like with a gun, I stop and picture what I'm going to do before I start. Positioning, where is my body, recoil and hand positions go through my mind. "Do I have an escape?" is also important.

[@theswime945]

So after some consideration, I opted for a table saw to meet all my needs. I can only work outside our little flat in London. I already had a jigsaw, so use that for sizing down big boards, then to the table saw for whatever. Calibration and jigs have helped me to do everything I want. Cheers from the UK

[@TheHonestCarpenter]

Cheers, Swime!

[@Charlielizard]

I remember those old days when I first stopped depending upon my collection of hand saws. As a new diy'er I relied on a jigsaw. Then I bought my first circular saw and, after my intimidation, found a helpful tool. Your video and ideas on options are fantastic. Excellent video for the newbies. We were all there once. 👍👍👍

[@TheHonestCarpenter]

Thank you, Chuck!! 😁

[@camerongunn7906]

My handheld cordless circular saw is quite possibly one of the greatest things that has ever been invented. I freaking love that thing.

[@TheHonestCarpenter]

I need to get one, Cameron!

[@michellegaza7740]

Congrats on your published books, they are absolutely adorable! Oh and saws....still learning to not be afraid of mine when they are on. Doesn't help that a friend just had a serious table saw accident a couple years ago.

[@TheHonestCarpenter]

Thank you, Michelle! I think they came out looking great, especially thanks to Michelle Nobles’ artwork. 😄 I’m sorry to hear about your friends accident!! That’s exactly the kind of stuff I hope I can help people avoid with vids like this. Good luck with your projects, and stay safe!

[@lym3204]

How do I find the books?

[@reevrob]

I do a bit of home repair and customization, but I write books too. No wonder you teach well. Thanks for all the tools and woodworking advice!

[@jeliarra]

Glad to know I'm not the only one nervous of the circular saw! Oh a plunge cut! Please please looking forward to that video! Congratz on the books!

[@AlanTheBeast100]

You need both. That said my first was a jigsaw because the project I needed to do needed a jigsaw. I couldn't afford both in those days, so whatever long straight cuts I had to do I did with the jigsaw. Including an 8 foot plywood rip... I clamped a level in place to use as a guide - wasn't too bad - except I had to move the 2 foot level every 20 inches or so.

[@MBMCincy63]

It's always so fascinating when a reputable person decides to put thoughts on paper and share. Thank you again for the announcement, I may buy them for me first then donate to my library! ☺️ And I really appreciate you giving such a detailed evaluation on the saws. 👍

[@TheHonestCarpenter]

Thanks so much, Mary Beth!! I greatly appreciate the support! I think an eventual library donation would be a great idea--I hope you like the books! 😄

[@davidunwin7868]

Had a jigsaw for 14 years and used it twice. Bought a circular saw 18 months ago and I love it. Have used it countless times since buying it.

[@KamilPtasznik]

Thank you honest person! I spent whole week to choose which one I actually need, and after finding and watching your video, I decided in three minutes.:D Thanks again!

[@markjlewis]

It was amazing to see those photos of houses being built out of so more wood. Here in the UK that's virtually unheard of. Most houses are built of double brick walls with insulation between the layers then fitted out inside with timber frames and plasterboard. Roofing and floors are made from timber.

[@Meme-zc4cw]

I love that you use tools that the common DIY can afford. Also, great job on the books! I will pick one up for my son.

[@TheHonestCarpenter]

Thank you, Me me!! I hope he enjoys it! I love a good, affordable power tool😄😄

[@chickensmack]

For the past 30 years, I've just had a jigsaw on my bench. It was always frustrating, when cutting any thick wood. The blade would end up not staying straight up and down. I'd end up with the edge being not good and square (unintentional bevel). Well, we are in the middle of redoing our kitchen. I had to invest in a circular saw. Your videos have been awesome in guiding me through this. Thanks for sharing your knowledge.

[@TheHonestCarpenter]

I’m so glad the help, chickensmack! Work safe! 😄

[@beverlyc.8175]

Outstanding content in this video! Every DIYer can benefit from it. Thanks.

[@TheHonestCarpenter]

Thank you, Beverly! 😄

[@NelsonWillis-kt8ck]

I bought this mitre saw in June 2014, and I remodeled my basement with it. It it sturdy and it works great kzbin.infoUgkxKL3MYO42eA2JbKxs7_Q0tmRGZI4Ow4Ar . There's not a lot of extra play in the adjustments and it is definitely well built. It is lighter than higher-end sliding double bevel models, so I can move it myself, which is nice. When I had to cut 2x10 lumber, I had to flip the boards over and cut twice; but since most of my cutting was on smaller dimension lumber, the weight reduction and significantly lower price seemed to be a better trade off for the boards I did have to flip. Late in the project, I was able to borrow a DW718, and the sliding feature does make fast work of 2x10s, but it is a tank, and I stand by my choice of the DW715. I also added a laser guide (one of the arbor replacement style sold on Amazon), which is nice to have, but definitely not needed.

[@davidkutas273]

Great exploration of these two saws. I appreciate your mention of the books - if the quality is as high as the quality of this comparison, I’ll pick up the whole set.

[@TheHonestCarpenter]

Thank you, David!! I had a great team putting these books together. I’m very proud of the overall quality! 🙂

[@Bob-vb8lc]

I have had both tools for years and I use them both. Like most tools, each has its rightful place for a project. Congrats on the books, I will have to check them out

[@TheHonestCarpenter]

Thank you, Bob!! 😄 Very true-as tool collections expand past the beginner phase, tool usage becomes far more specific. I had a handful of saws the only saw the light of day once or twice a year.

[@kmh997]

Crafter turned craftswoman, here. I appreciate this video because I thought I NEEDED a circular saw. I have a circular saw, I've become unafraid of it, with ear plugs it's much less stressful to use, and I've completed projects, as well as started a business I probably would never have attempted if I hadn't bought one. And. I'm glad to know these fundamental differences because in the past, I had used my jigsaw for cuts which I thought were meant to be done with a circular saw, so I thought I was "doing it wrong", which I equate with being unsafe. I'm glad to be wrong about that. I'm interested in trying a bevel with the jig saw, I am a big fan of the bevel, but haven't bought a miter (yet, and possibly won't) - I didn't notice that the jigsaw could bevel, and funnily enough I was initially compelled to get the circular saw because it could bevel. I guess there are different routes to gain experience and education! I appreciate learning the versatility of my tools. I got a jigsaw about 35 years ago when my grandfather's scroll saw broke down and my dad didn't repair it right away. I was purely a hobby crafter, so I used it only for pattern wood cutouts. When my father passed away and I suddenly had access to all his tools all the time, my projects immediately increased in scale. Now I make & sell pretty garden obelisks & trellis, and various other decorative garden structures, and contract out to build custom pergolas - as my job!! I built myself a spacious workshop, chicken coop(s), built-in cabinets and buffets. Instead of replacing my ancient homemade plywood kitchen cabinets with prebuilt products, I used the plywood as a framework for totally tricked out kitchen cabinets! I changed lower cabinets to slide outs, etc. I made all my outdoor furniture and some very fine indoor pieces which get compliments from everyone who crosses my threshold, which I also made. I've come a long way from decorative birdhouses made from balsa! I never stop learning! Thanks for the videos, you're one of the best content providers! ✌️

[@bunyips9706]

Perfect timing for this video! I just inherited a fairly new Makita circular saw & am eyeing it nervously. I'm self-taught with virtually all of my power tools (made possible thanks to YT channels like yours) but am no slouch on safety, so your videos are absolute gold.

[@TheHonestCarpenter]

Thank you, Bunyip! I’m glad the vids are helping 🙂 Be safe!!

[@seanmuir9594]

As always: simple and easy-to-understand advice to help people research and make decisions. I bought a circular saw 1st for what I needed but they are both so valuable. Table saw came later. Great advice here from the honest carpenter.👍

[@TheHonestCarpenter]

Thank you, Sean!!

[@zukichik006]

The sound cut out at the most important part for me. This was super helpful and informative, and easy to understand.

[@TheHonestCarpenter]

That’s strange, Ali. 🤔 I’m glad it was helpful though!

[@mirafrenkel7929]

I do remodels and home repairs for a living (so small to medium size projects) and I use my 6-1/2” cordless circular saw for 95% of lumber cuts. It’s awesome!! Sometimes you need a jigsaw, and very occasionally I need a full-size circular saw (but rare, as I don’t do much framing and my small one can handle a few cuts here and there in 2x materials, and if I have more to do I use a miter saw). Anyway just wanted to mention those are an option and way more maneuverable. I’d say for a DIYer it’s perfect! Edit: just contributing to this discussion, not saying it’s a replacement for a table saw, etc if you need that.

[@elmolewis9123]

I had a near mistake with the jigsaw yesterday because of the points you make with them. I "carelessly" picked it up to move it out of the way and accidentally pressed the trigger without having the lock switch engaged. I would never have done that with my circular saw. Excellent video, as usual.

[@TheHonestCarpenter]

Glad it wasn't bad, Elmo! That's what's crazy about jigsaws--they typically do their damage when you're least expecting it 😓

[@TheBanjoShowOfficial]

That sounds awesome that you're following your passion to publish books and for kids too, seriously that sounds great. Great to hear, keep on it. That's what it's all about.

[@devinbraun1852]

My uses are home improvement and general carpentry- I use circular, miter, table, sawzall, and oscillating saws constantly and very rarely pull out my jigsaw. I only use jigsaw when it is a cut that only a jigsaw can do - precise curves (for most curved cuts in construction applications, sawzall is the go-to).

[@davidstoyanoff]

THC, you are so informative, 100% useful content. I have been a DIY carpenter for 50+ years and I still learn new stuff here. Plus, your delivery is top tier professional.

[@mixpick138]

Dunno' why but circular saws never bothered me and it's one of the first tools I bought for woodworking. Jigsaws on the other hand, yeef! I have a really nice one but I simply hate using it. While not "generally" a pro carpenter, I've built my fair share of projects and worked on job sites for many a summer when I was younger. In sum, I'm envious of folks that can do beautiful cuts/work with a jigsaw --I'm not one of them. Lol Love your videos!

[@yvonneprice8910]

Absolutely brilliant observation! Circular saws ARE scary and I am researching the difference so I can avoid if possible!

[@Joel_E]

Between work and home, I have multiple corded and cordless circular and jig saws, though my most-used cutting tool is a Milwaukee cordless circular saw. Jigsaw blades take up very little storage space, are a lot less expensive than circular saw blades, and are typically easy and fast to change without tools. This allows you to have a wide variety of blades on hand that you can swap out for whatever material you're working with. Another factor worth considering is how the power consumption of a tool affects how well it works to be cordless, especially if you don't have large capacity tool batteries. The lower power demand of a jigsaw is a better fit for the 2 Ah and smaller batteries that typically come with starter cordless drill or drill/impact driver combo kits. If one could only have two cutting tools, I'd recommend a corded 15A circular saw, and a cordless jigsaw in whatever battery platform you've chosen for your fastening tools. That way, you have corded power and endless runtime when you need it, but also have something lightweight and very handy that can also cut curves. An additional benefit of buying a corded circ saw is that they're readily available and quite inexpensive on the used market. Whatever you choose, I'd suggest to keep in mind two things: a saw is only as good as its blade, and the first saw you buy doesn't have to be your last. To the first point, the longevity and superior performance of quality blades can make them the better value in the long run. There are other good brands, but I've rarely been disappointed by Diablo products. To the latter point, when you're first starting out, you don't really know what you'll like best. For circular saws, there are decisions to be made on blade size, blade-left vs. blade-right design, corded or cordless, and sidewinder vs. worm drive. For jigsaws, there are both barrel grip and d-handle designs, as well as U-shank or T-shank blades. Besides the fact that T-shank has a better blade selection, there aren't any absolute right or wrong answers there. Nothing will educate you as well as getting some experience of your own, so get out there and start building!

[@adamp5604]

Those Diablo jigsaw blades are great.

[@TheHonestCarpenter]

Couldn’t believe how well the 6” cuts, Adam-even with my 5 amp saw!

[@crism3lo]

I love your videos; you overstand the mind of a beginner. Our fears are real.

[@alpha_centaurus5396]

From north Africa many thanks 🙏

[@robertcraigh73]

I think a great question and video idea would be budget circular saw v high end jig saw. I have a Craftsman circular saw but recently purchased a DeWalt jigsaw. In most cases I reach for the DeWalt jigsaw.

[@Latrodectus_vv_]

I really wanted to buy a M18 circular saw to go along with my other tools. I bought a cheaper plug in jigsaw instead. I won't use the jig very much at all. It is the best decision I felt. Thank you for the excellent video.

[@bwhite661]

I have a great suggestion for another great video. Extension cords! Firstly, do you have a favorite way to store them. I've tried many different ways and they're all a pain in the but. Do those auto retractable doohickies work for a dedicated shop one. Second, is there a favorite cord of yours that doesn't twist and is easier to roll up and put away. I have the cheap orange ones that have a memory making it difficult to wind up for storage. And lastly is there a minimum gage that you recommend. Great channel!

[@ian1352]

I generally just buy good quality 3 core cable and make my own.

[@timothyandrewbutler]

I got an impact driver, and a miter saw first. Both were display models, so heavily discounted. Your videos are very helpful.

[@aadittoshen]

Thanks for that very well done - and pointedly informative - comparison video! Cleared a huge chunk of my doubts, as a beginner in woodworking (sp. power tools)!

[@gabrielgavril3435]

The Best woodworking KZbin channel 👍

[@TheHonestCarpenter]

Thank you, Gabriel! 😄

[@gillianbc]

You're spot on. I've owned a circular saw for about 5 yrs now. So you'd think I'd be pretty experienced with it by now. Well, I'm still at the 'too scared to get it out of the box' stage.

[@neville132bbk]

It's probably dead from wood starvation now, Gillian--be brave and at least shine daylight on it. My fav power tool is a band saw... don't own one, of course, but the Menzshed ( this is NZ) has everything I'd ever need.

[@cindyalvord9946]

This was the absolute BEST video I saw on this subject. I had lots of questions and you answered every sing one!! Great job! Thank you. :)

[@johnthomas8845]

This was great info. I have a jigsaw and was going to buy a circular but all I am going to be doing is building closet shelfing. I think the jigsaw will actually work cutting through 1" boards, and short cuts. Great info ! ! !

[@davegravel3740]

One thing you should probably mention is what shank the jigsaw takes. People do love a bargain and garage sales, pawn shops, online are great places to get tools at a good price. With jigsaws however, the older ones used the U shank blades, the new ones all use a T shank blade. Check what shank or uses before buying a used jigsaw. Those U blades are getting really hard to find. I bought the last pack the store had and they haven't had any U shank blades since. When the blades I have area worn out it'll be time for a new jigsaw.

[@TheHonestCarpenter]

Good point, dave! I had to save a lot of stuff for a later jigsaw video, but I'll definitely talk about shanks. 👍

[@JamesSmullins]

I've got both and when I grab one it's almost always the circular saw. Jig saws are great for cut outs, giving a straight end cut vs the curved in cut when not cutting all the way through. Jig saws are much harder to do long straight lines due to such a small blade while the circular saw blade tracks better. Basically its a matter of the right tool for the particular job. Sure you can use the jig saw for just about everything the circular saw can do but it's not the best choice for many jobs due to time and ability to free hand longer cuts with decent edges. The thicker the wood the more the circular saw shines.

[@markomarten]

Sometimes you need to ask yourself what are you trying to cut? For cutting stuff like pallets a circular saw will easily cut through them easily. I was told the bigger the wood the bigger the teeth to cut it. In practice a jigsaw will give you a neat cut and you can use a reverse cut blade for something like making a template to fit a kitchen sink, the top part is visible and so the reverse function means the action provides a neat edge or finish. I personally would suggest a brand like Bosch, they do a few ranges and the professional stuff is good going. Dewalt and others make a few ranges these can get expensive. I would recommend a sturdy workbench like a Black & Decker workmate, that will allow you to cut and work on stuff without it moving. A circular saw is never going to be able to give intricate cuts or detailing because the blade is so big and it’s a totally different action. If you only ever cut straight pieces of wood a circular saw would probably be sufficient but for bigger stuff a bigger blade is needed and that’s where a jigsaw can be useful. You can buy blades for a jigsaw that are around 12 inches and thats handy for some stuff like fence posts or something really dense. Circular saws don’t have a reciprocal action or option so can be a bit of a one trick pony. A jigsaw can be slowed down a bit or used at a greater rate. The blades are important as they will have an impact on your result. One very important thing to remember is safety first, always ensure you secure what you’re intending to cut. A pair of goggles might not be trendy but can save stuff getting in your eyes, you only get one pair of eyes so look after them. Some models come with dust extraction which can be useful as it were. In short I would say decide what you are going for and don’t forget the safety. Go for the best tools you can realistically afford and treat them with care and you should do fine.

[@TheWorld-of7dd]

Thank goodness I have both, with intentions to buy a table saw and a mitre saw

[@MyPronounsISwhom]

In the last year or so I've been doing a lot of d i y projects and very strongly in the last few months I've been getting into woodworking as a personal hobby. One of my projects was building a shed and being 32 years old and never using any kind of motorized saw, I was fearful to use the circular saw on a particular part of the build. I put it off for so long LOL! I didn't want my inexperience to cost me a digit or favorite shirt or just overall having a bloody experience or something, but once I used it after reading the manual and looking up several videos including yours I fell in love with the circular saw. I now have my own and have a very powerful one I can use that belongs to my pops but man do I love circular saws. Another jigsaw I have zero experience with so this is a cool video for me. Also, congrats on the books! Cool points brother.

[@roselynromba2921]

I'm a female and finding my interest in wood capentery works and this video is very useful. Please send me a video on how to use a jig saw and a circular saw for a beginner like me. Thank you

[@TheHonestCarpenter]

I’m publishing an online course called POWER TOOLS EXPLAINED on my website later this summer, Roselyn. It’ll explain how the 20 most important power tools work, and how to use them 🙂

[@gendoll5006]

I’m a stay at home mom wanting to do some home improvement projects like replacing broken trim, adding wood to walls for a “textured” look, making shelves and planter boxes to hang on the walls, and I really wanna make my dog a nice little house so he can go outside more. My main goal first is to saw off about a foot from my sons metal framed loft bed. It’s like really thin metal that’s hallow, so I need a saw that can use different blades for different material for plastic projects I wanna do as well. I was apprehensive about jigsaws because it seems so hard to control. I used a big one my dad has to cut tree limbs and it was get stuck and shake/vibrate me SO FAST AND VIGOROUSLY that it scared the shiitake out of me and felt so dangerous cause it was just out in the open. I won’t be cutting through hard wood like that for my little woodworking projects so I hope a jigsaw will do the trick! As long as I get one that has that guard thing to keep the saw stable. Thank you so much! I watched a few other videos on this and have been scouring the web but your video explained it so much better and actually helped me!

[@kanonzedek5435]

Amazing, Just what I needed to see, I'm gone back down a bit, and stick with the Jigsaw, so I want danger myself. if I haven't seen you take on the subject I might bought myself one of these intimidating circular saws and not using it eventually.... Thank you for your good advice for DIY`rs

[@Veryunluckyman56689]

❤️❤️❤️❤️. This channel is always on point and so educational,and full of knowledge as well .👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻. Any person that has a doubt on how to use a tool or even buying a tool,by seeing one of your videos,their mind will make up pretty fast. You’re amazing man. God bless!!!

[@GrinderCB]

When I first started assembling my workshop a circular saw was at the top of the list mainly for breaking down plywood and making basic rip cuts of stud lumber. I bought a Ryobi starter set at big orange during a sale a few years ago.

[@kelvinteoh9058]

I think this video really covered all the main differences between both tools. For me though, the main reasons I got rid of my Bosch circular saw was the noise and dust it generates. I got the saw more than 30 years ago when I was building a wall to wall cabinet at my parent's place and wanted something that could cut long straight 8' plywood strips. However, I always felt uncomfortable subjecting my neighbours to such unpleasant noise (I live in an appartment). Jigsaws on the other hand make almost no noise at all to your neighbours, with your doors closed, even at full tilt. Dust is also a major concern if you do not have a dedicated work space that does not share the same air space with your home or you'll be dealing with awful clean ups after each projects because circular saws create such an unbelievable amount of fine dust compared with jigsaws even with a good dust collector system. I've been considering reintroducing the circular (track saw actually) with much agony for these reasons. I think one important aspect more important that straight cuts that was missed is making accurate perpendicular cuts to the edges of your material. An accurately adjusted circular saw will make absolutely clean 90° cuts whereas the long wobbly jigsaw blade tends to bend slightly along wood grains, especially at lower speeds and thicker materials causing slight uneven bevels to your cuts which need to be routed clean. Sorry for the extremely long comment.

[@TheHonestCarpenter]

This is all true, Kelvin! Especially the points about blade deflection and wander in jigsaws. I wanted to cover it some, but it'll need a video of its own. Thanks for writing in--I don't mind long comments! :)

[@flankingfoxtrot]

You should do an alternate video between the recip saw and circ saw I think people should own both

[@Bunyi_Logam]

Using both. Concider to get 9inch circular saw for next target

[@Obi_Wan_Wan]

Got them both, but now I need a sawzall and multi tool!

[@TheHonestCarpenter]

Multitool is a genius invention, Tom! Solved centuries worth of problems 😁

[@notyourbro3782]

As i new to woodworking for making chair, which one do i need more? Drill or jigsaw? Its a whole different tools but im on a budget since i only trust high end tools, fyi i alr have router. Thanks for the help

[@NewYorker8312]

I see it is not in either or. You may have talked about this before but I recommend getting cordless ones just for ease of use in in being portable. Also I recommend sticking with one brand so your batteries are interchangeable

[@TheHonestCarpenter]

Cordless have gotten so widespread that they're a great option these days, Joel 👍

[@avinashcj398]

Best advice, explanation, and suggestion comparison. All we need is this kind of videos. Great job sir...

[@mistahaych9552]

Thanks so much for this.However, I am now more confused as to what to buy 😊

[@MikkisoXTRA]

Such a good thorough and honest review. It's actually encouraged me to get both. Thanks

[@inlehkha8378]

Definitely helpful. I'm getting the jigsaw

[@joserodriguez4319]

Thank you so much for all your clear explanations. These videos are a lifesaver! I really appreciate you. May God continue blessing you and your family! 🙏

[@avinashcj398]

Hey,.. one of the best pieces of advice for tools. I was really wondering and confused of usage and type of usage that Iam into and I was looking for one that makes my projects easier, I completely agree how intimidated the circular saw is, For the very first time I used the circular saw and just with very first start and the noise level and the power from circular saw made me to think that Iam hurt myself and return home with one finger or one hand missing from my garage. The amount power circular saw emmits make the first time user faint and think am I handling it wrong, but still I saw able to manage with my strength, it woudlnt have gone easier without any injuries if a lean person or focusless person, the power of backdraw from circular saw while in the motion feels like whole arm is coming apart from the body,.. but still, as said in the video, it's for the faster cuts and plenty of cuts, make a best tool after a few cuts. But for me, I mostly do simply projects like cages and tables, Im convinced that jigsaw is all i wanted after watching the video. For any art, patience is the key, so jigsaw does the works slow and steady for not only beginners but also for occasional woodwork.

[@Expressitc]

Nice video as always. Good luck on the book series, I'll bet it will be a hit with the kids!

[@TheHonestCarpenter]

Thanks so much, Express!! Here’s to hoping! 😁

[@brorjordas1979]

Kinda interesting topic, which drew me instantly to watch it. But. I'd definitely get myself both if were seriously getting into more woodworking. I've used often the circular saw to cut 3-4mm aluminium sheets into halves at work. But the jigsaw has come in handy to cut smaller holes for displays into metal boxes - if not just wanting to use the good old angle grinder to cut thin sheet metal.. Yea. I now kinda realized that I've probably more used these for metals over wood etc - but still I think both are just fantastic tools for their own purpose. Would definitely not buy any of the cheapest ones - but I might even pay a bit more for a decent circular saw than for a jigsaw. Have used pretty decent jigsaws that have been on the more inexpensive side. Just do not cheap on the blades.

[@DanoG-xf7jb]

Dude. That's pretty sweet that you're writing children's books. I'm going to Amazon to get some for my 7 year old son. Thanks!

[@TheHonestCarpenter]

Thank you, Dano!! I hope he enjoys them!! 😄

[@loktom4068]

My beginner saw is a corded SEARS CRAFTSMAN scrolling jigsaw for all my beginner projects, until I earned enough money for bigger and better tools.

[@cg2000cg1]

You are going to buy both.You are likely to pay more for a good circular saw ($200) and then you can get a cheaper jig ($100). Buy the circular saw first and work out some way to make straight cuts (Buzzard Wing, 2x4 fence and clamp, DIY track, etc.) Your circular saw is your first table saw on the move up from handsaws. You can always wait on buying a jig saw because you just need a cheap coping saw and a power drill. Jig saws are nice but its often faster and easier to just to pull out a coping saw anyway. The problem with jigs and coping saws is that they leave jagged and uneven cuts. Which is why a Circular saw, coping saw and a small trim router might make more sense. If you are starting out woodworking and you don't have a jointer, parallel planer and table saw - you need just one damn thing in your arsenal to help you to make a decent straight cut. Handsaws are difficult to master. A circular saw or a router with fence guides can both get you there. Plus a router can help you fix mistakes, like ragged edges and wonky cuts. Lots of bad cuts and fixing mistakes starting out.

[@NoreastWhips]

Great video! For the averege diyer, I suggest that someone get both. You can get two good tools for under $150. Keep up the good vids. Steve.

[@Ricky_B4]

I did a lot of home repairs, furniture making, etc. I have a circular saw, jigsaw, table saw, and band saw. I have needed all four, funny thing is I took an old wooden table, a circular saw and made a table saw for my first table saw.

[@TheHonestCarpenter]

👍😁

[@kojomensah7474]

Thanks I believe it is best to get both tools but again it depends where in the world you are in because the majority of homes in the US is made out of wood while else's where it is concrete blocks bricks and stone

[@sinironheart8413]

Great non-biased comparison!

[@TheHonestCarpenter]

Thank you, Ironheart!

[@Hstudiosproductions]

Hi thanks for the advice. After some consideration, i probably by the jigsaw since im not into carpenter and more into small projects or hobbies.

[@martincaruana6632]

Great video as usual. I have no young ones to buy your books for but I will definitely pass on a recommendation to people I know that do. I wish you the best of luck on your labor of love.

[@deadlazlo]

Congrats on the books! Creativity crosses multiple platforms in life. As usual, a great detailed topic breakdown. I have 3 circular saws and only one jigsaw, so I guess I have a preference. Thanks for the video!

[@TheHonestCarpenter]

Thank you, Lazlo!! I appreciate you watching! That's my circular saw to (working) jigsaw ratio as well 😆

[@crabwalk7773]

Congratulations on the books! Could you please (at least for a while) continue to put the book links in your videos so I can easily find them when the purchase is in my budget? Thanks!

[@TheHonestCarpenter]

Absolutely, crabwalk! I’ll continue to link them, and will mention them again periodically. Thank you for watching and supporting the channel!!

[@perryh.5306]

You should own both. I have a corded circular saw and a cordless one....I also have a cordless jigsaw. Both a very important to have in doing certain jobs!

[@MzVee106]

Ok so I'm going to be purchasing my 1st saw and came here for your great advice to help me decide. I'm a beginner DIY'ER and going to tackle installing vinyl flooring. It looks like just for this, the jigsaw is fine. But I will be getting a circular saw also

[@TheHonestCarpenter]

Jigsaw is a great option for plank segment flooring like that, Vee! 🙂

[@MzVee106]

@@TheHonestCarpenter Thanks 👌🏾

[@brentfowler2317]

Hey Daniel, the books look awesome, congrats.. I'll be picking your books up ASAP. Also, the saw conversation, to saw or not to saw? Lol. Anyhow I have a Milwaukee M18 6-1/2" circular saw. And I more recently picked up the rear handle or worm drive Milwaukee M18 fuel 7-1/4" circular saw. I also have the Milwaukee M18 fuel D-handle jigsaw. However I use my circular saws a lot more than my jigsaw. My opinion, if you are a diy-er or a carpenter, or a woodworker. I would recommend following his advice in this video. But I would also recommend once you purchase your first saw. Whichever, will help you out more so with the projects your doing. I'd still plan on picking up the other saw. Because they are both very useful in their own ways. As he explains in the video..

[@christipurchase726]

I’ve always learned so much from your channel and your books look like they are right in my son’s wheelhouse. Just ordered ‘One Hot Spark’ off Amazon. Thanks for the heads up!

[@TheHonestCarpenter]

Thank you, Christi!! Means a lot to me :) I hope your son likes Dungeonworld!

[@janpeterson21]

Thanks so much….I’m just a craft woodworker but need something more than my scroll saw that I’ve been using, which is very limiting. I was also wondering about the mini circular saws. I’ll look to see if you’ve reviewed any of those..

[@ironwood1621]

I’ve had a circular saw forever and recently purchased a jig saw as I was building leaf-shaped coffee tables and needed to cut a lot of curves.

[@TheHonestCarpenter]

Gotta have one in that case, Rich 👍

[@AncoraImparoPiper]

Excellent advice based on my own amateur experience. Apart from a drill, my first power tool was the jigsaw. I only did some basic woodwork at the time and it was perfect for that. Now that I've moved to renovating/repairing my old timber house, I had to rethink my saw options. I thought a lot and watched a lot of KZbin on the subject of circular saws, mitre saws and track saws. In the end I decided that the circular saw was not necessary for me because I felt safer around a track saw and mitre saw. Certainly, the circular saw could fill in for the mitre saw and track saw on most of my projects and was a far cheaper option, though scarier. I do have a smaller circular saw just in case, but so far my track saw, mitre saw and jigsaw have filled all my needs. Mostly I love my mitre saw for quick cross cuts, and I could not live without my track saw for those rip cuts. The jigsaw sees the odd light of day for the detailed and sometimes curvy work. The right tool for the job makes it all much easier and far more fun. BTW, I'll check out your book. I love reading a good kids adventure story before bed at night.

[@TheHonestCarpenter]

Thank you, Darius!! That’s a very useful saw combo-got all your cuts covered with that setup. I really should cover track saws more on this channel. And thank you for checking out the books! I hope you like them! 😄

[@profcah]

Thanks Ethan. Great Comparison. I have both and use my circular saw more but the jigsaw is a must have when you get to curves and fancy work. It took me longer to get the jigsaw than the circular saw but I love them both. Also, I like to write too, so congrats on your books! I’ll be getting one to start for my grandson.

[@TheHonestCarpenter]

Thanks so much for watching, profcah...and thank you for getting the book! We've got the same interests 😁 I think writing is an excellent complement to carpentry. Together, they work all the parts of the brain!

[@DancingPetals]

Very well documented. I have been searching for so long to get the right answers / comparison, and I got it here. Thank you !

[@maheshv281]

you are awesome sir! I really like woodworking.... got inspired by a lot of highly talented carpenters, rather artisans.... i was amazed by how precise and incredible was their skills... esp when doing handcraft. those days there were not enough power tools, yet their precision is just amazing... i just bought a jigsaw for some diy. realized that circ saw is better n faster for straight cuts... not sure if i buy one... i like solid woods tham plywood... esp rose or teak.. love the smell of them... thank you so much...

[@ipick4fun27]

TBH, If price is a factor get the less expansive models and buy both. It well worth the money considering it will make the project easier. Right tool for the job is much less likely to get yourself injured. Inside corner cut, jig saw is a must have. Everything else, I use circular saw where I can. You probably don't need this, but, will be helpful for most DIYers to make a simple circular saw track. It will really speed up the process for cutting plywood.

[@osgeld]

I got a Jigsaw first and it was a dead simple choice ... work was throwing out a perfectly useable Hitachi model that, while beat up worked fine, but everyone kept using the cordless model and it was taking up valuable toolbox space

[@aarondavis5386]

I guess I'll throw in my two cents. On the matter of safety: remember a circular saw is always cutting when it is running and circular saws generally have fewer teeth per inch that take huge bites from what ever they are cutting. Whereas a jig saw is only cutting on the upward stroke and with finer teeth. As for their usage a circular saw really can only make straight cuts and can stay on track alot easier and cut a whole lot faster than a jigsaw. On the other hand the jigsaw's narrower blade allows you to cut curves. In hindsight if you have to buy only one saw I would say buy a cheap corded black and decker jigsaw they're like $30 bucks. After using that a while and you wanna make the jump to a higher quality or cordless tool you'll know what saw you want/need at this point I suspect for most people a circular saw is the answer, other than going cordless I don't think you'd get much improvement from a more expensive jigsaw.

[@Vidyut_Gore]

Brilliant channel. Some thoughts as an utter newbie to power tools. I'm a woman approaching 50 in India and developing an interest in carpentry, mostly because we're moving into a new home. My late father was into carpentry as a hobby and I learned basics as a kid via osmosis. Helping him, handing tools, trying them out... but this was decades ago before my teens. I used hand drills and can use a regular saw pretty well - like riding a bicycle. Power tools arrived much later here for hobbyists, and he wasn't using them when I was a kid. So they are intimidating strangers... Power tools both tempt and scare me. I stared at my new electric drill for a week before trying it. I also got one with a chuck key for twisting bits tight for sure, because I don't trust that plastic keyless thing and didn't want any bits flying loose at high speed. Then I felt stupid, because everybody on youtube seems to be using them just fine. lol. I loved it once I figured it out - hand drilling isn't my favourite trick and I can safely say I'll never do it again. But I think your video takes arm strength for granted. Take it from a post-menopausal (strength losses) woman who isn't a body-builder... there's a vast difference between what feels normal for you and me. I don't think I'd dare buy a circular saw or should, when I see you handling it correctly. It just looks like it wants to cut the wood faster than I can think. lol. I think it wouldn't be a good idea for my arm strength (non-existent compared with a skilled carpenter). I have no doubt it is an efficient tool, and a local carpenter told me, it is about learning to use a tool, but I'm intimidated. I'm good at learning new things, but the circular saw just feels like beginner's mistakes could be a lot more irreversible than most things. My point is, a circular saw probably shouldn't be used at all by people without some degree of arm strength (particularly wrists). Not sure the risk/reward is in favour of DIYers using it if they aren't fairly strong to begin with. I'm older and a woman, but a lot of diyers here seem the hot glue type. That thing weighs what? A few kilos at least? If people aren't strong enough to wield it comfortably and brace at least enough to be safe from kickbacks or whatever, they will use poor form to compensate somehow. How much time would be saved? Is it worth the risk? But I did plunge cuts pretty easily on day one using an oscillating tool. Tool received, box opened, try out, voila! Straight cutting, plunge cut (on purpose, not accidentally, lol). Much lower risk of accidents I think. I think it deserves a mention for outperforming both jigsaw and circular saw for newbies trying power tools for plunge cuts at least. I think someone who can use an electric drill can feel in control of the tool very easily. Nice edges too. I draw the line with a box cutter instead of pencil. Then I use another piece of wood for a guide. Overly cautious, but it gets me where I need to be. So far I haven't got any electric saw. I use the multitool where I can, or just use a normal saw or a smaller hack saw. For small projects, I think they may be quicker than setting up a power tool, using it, putting it away... Maybe if I want to make more things after I develop some confidence I may think of a jigsaw. I hadn't thought of that. Not to criticise you and I learned A LOT from this and your other videos. I'm pretty much going through them all to learn. Just a completely different PoV from someone at the extreme basics. Having enough strength to wield the tool with the robustness it needs. Probably been a long time since you thought of that :D

[@jacquesdutron9954]

Thx a lot for a wonderful and honest explanation. I'm getting a Jigsaw.