Civivi Crit Multi-Functional Pocket Knife - A Victorinox SAK Killer?

[@RJ-jc3du]

I think it's a great minimalist multi-tool. Having a knife, prybar, bottle opener and a screwdriver that open one-handed easily is outstanding in my opinion. I love the look and feel of the micarta as well. I see a lot of potential with this double flipper design as well.

[@marmite8959]

Companies have been trying to make "SAK killers" for almost a century at this point, from the cheap clones of South East Asia to the modern competitors from Böker and Swiza. It's never going to happen, nobody else has the winning combination of experience and ingenuity that Victorinox (and formerly Wenger) have at making pocket knives and multitools. Plus there's the brand recognition; everyone knows what a Swiss Army Knife is and what they look like. They come in all shapes and sizes, there's one for every situation, and you'd be hard pressed to offend someone with a SAK. I like that there's other companies experimenting with multitools to drive innovation but for me Victorinox will always have the best pocket knife and Leatherman will always have the best plier multitool.

[@traviswrigg5158]

I think Victorinox works mostly in the field of brand recognition. I'm always keeping my eye out for new tools in that format becaues it annoys me that their blade steel still competes with a Swiss Toblerone for edge retention

[@fredperry9235]

@@traviswrigg5158 Yes absolutely. I like the Malga6 for that reason.

[@SandShark350]

Check out ASK knives.....loving what they're bringing, but a bit pricey.

[@clintwestwood3539]

@@SandShark350 it’s American so it’s already garbage.

[@stiglagerfeld9151]

An interesting direction for them to pursue; hopefully the next iterations will have better functionality. I do really like the wire clip - hope they use that more often. Thanks for showing it.

[@TheKnifeBeater]

Yeah, I love that clip too! Thanks Stig.

[@CJTheReal]

I work at a bike shop, and the multitool is incredibly invaluable. Most bikes work on 4, 5, and 6mm hex bolts, which means I can slide the wrenches through the spanner holes and get a tonne of extra leverage when loosening stuck bolts or when I'm having to use a long t-handle in an awkward space that would otherwise be a single-handed slog.

[@bmoviebmovie]

Wow! "Critical." Good to have a knife reviewer who can honestly say "no" to a major knife maker. At Civivi's knife channel, I suggested that the "Crit" also have tweezers like they've included in their new "Relic", but now the "Crit"'s going to need more than tweezers to pull it through. LOL. Instead of "Crit" for "Critter", it's "Crit" for "Critical".

[@TheKnifeBeater]

Lol! Well said. Yeah, it might be why I don't get very many knives sent to me by manufacturers.

[@TheGrenadier97]

Victorinox killer? Definitely never. But if Civivi really desires it can develop some well-done multitools to complete a swiss army - as long as price is right.

[@TheKnifeBeater]

Yeah, they would definitely have to come down in price.

[@tidge879]

The beauty of the SAK is that nobody is scared of them. You can use an SAK anywhere. A front flipper doesn't really have the same effect.

[@Mr.SpeedPix]

Only another Swiss Army Knife is better than a Swiss Army Knife, says a Swiss. 😉 Greetings from Switzerland. P. S. Love your videos!

[@johanesgo8096]

If you have any influence in the Victorionox company, persuade them to make a model that has only a blade and a saw for wood ... and a wine opener .. greetings from Bosnia and Herzegovina🍷

[@TheKnifeBeater]

So true! Thank you.

[@kevin3837]

Would love this knife in a mini size. More like a cadet size.

[@devinmaldonado4134]

Just ordered one of these the other day because I've been slightly obsessed with it and haven't been able to stop thinking about it. Love a good multitool and this one just catches my eyes. Doesnt have much to offer, but these are some tools id use almost daily. I've been carrying the Gerber Armbar for a while and i love that thing so we'll see if this is an upgrade.

[@carmeng5867]

I think it's nice to look at (the micarta was definitely the way to go) but other than being easier to open I could not see replacing my Swiss army knife with it. Not "multi" enough in the tool department. Let's hope that feedback will make its next iteration a little more practical. Thank you Jay. Always on point.

[@TheKnifeBeater]

I totally agree Carmen. Thank you!

[@davidkurle5418]

Victorinox knives are my multi-purpose knife of choice. But that being said, I could see this civivi being useful if a person wanted to keep it in the center console of their vehicle for a "just in case" sort of tool. Small hex wrench, seat belt cutter, etc. I just don't see it as something I would carry in my pocket every day. Cheers, Jay.

[@TheKnifeBeater]

Yeah, I hear ya David, I feel the same way. Well said. Thanks!

[@maxlvledc]

I agree, but I think in one move they already did more correct than most other brands to try this. What I want is a saw, not the wierd multitool

[@TheKnifeBeater]

Yeah, I give them credit for trying this, but a saw would be nice. Especially since that saw would have some reach to it because of the size of this thing.

[@topazcarr8222]

Dude I love your knife reviews. Just a simple discussion and comparison. Well done.

[@TheKnifeBeater]

Very nice of you, thanks!

[@flytheskymyway]

100% agree Phillips head is necessary and one flathead. And Washer instead of bearings (thinking about torquing it when using the screwdriver.).

[@TheKnifeBeater]

Thank you!

[@toddles1977]

Digging the reviews by a fellow Lefty! It makes my carry decisions so much easier!

[@frankysour]

Interesting, but yeah not there yet... I am always puzzled by the face that no Victorinox in the 93 and 91 size comes with a one hand open blade... For the 91 that would probably imply some design changes due to the back tools, but on the pioneer it would be... Easy done! And then it would be a 100% perfect knife. Nice video, btw!

[@toegoth]

I like it but I would actually love a version with just the knife, same exact design but no multi tool with a toner handle.

[@carmeng5867]

Also seems like the tweezers that are found in the new Civivi Relic would have been better served in this model.

[@TheKnifeBeater]

Oh definitely!

[@lionknives3]

Really great that Civivi is coming out with that kind of tools! Thanks Jay! Hope you are doing well my friend from the other end!

[@TheKnifeBeater]

Hey Dogan, thank you my friend.

[@diverdave2179]

I Like it, Jay. Maybe not a SAK killer, but a lot of people carry a knife and pry bar, this takes care of both. And the seatbelt cutter is a nice addition

[@TheKnifeBeater]

Yeah, I like that strap cutter too! Thanks Dave.

[@fredperry9235]

Stick scissors on this thing. A Phillips on the end and a flat head where the flipper is and I'm sold.

[@wilblackburn9796]

It’s a civivi multi tool that fits the cutting an apple on the porch role? Very interesting

[@Zen_Ali_123]

Thanks, I was hoping you'd review this. Told me all I needed to know.

[@TheKnifeBeater]

Glad I could help!

[@markfcoble]

Skeletool blade not the toughest but darn handy. Not switching....yet.

[@TheKnifeBeater]

I hear ya James, me too.

[@travispratt6327]

I was fidgeting with my hao ming flipper the other day and got yelled at by a house mate =) It made me think of the top 10 reviews you do and how a “top 10 silent flippers” would be a good list! My quietest one so far is a wooden handled Chinese crkt ceo looking gentleman’s knife, but I’m sure there’s ones out there that you can fidget with and not annoy those around you, and if anyone is likely to have experienced them it’s you! Thanks for the channel.

[@TheKnifeBeater]

That's a great idea Travis, I like it. Thank you for the vote of confidence!

[@mattharvey968]

Civivi just pumping out models! Thanks for the review Jay!!

[@TheKnifeBeater]

Yeah, they really are. It looks like they slowed down releasing new WE knives, but now increased making Civivi's. Thanks Matt!

[@mattharvey968]

@@TheKnifeBeater have you checked out the Sencut Acumen yet??

[@kennkingg]

I think its cool but I haven’t had one in my hands yet

[@traditionallarry5378]

Nice review Jay but I guess I still like the SAK’s

[@TheKnifeBeater]

I hear ya, me too. Thanks Larry.

[@edgblades]

Cool tool! Pretty innovative using locking flippers w/ ball bearing action. Also, very nice seeing good steel on something like this for a change. A Phillips with a Flat head should be the standard, at a minimum. My current favorite cool tool is the Leatherman Free K4.

[@TheKnifeBeater]

Yeah, I've been wanting to try out that Leatherman Free K4 or the K2. Thanks Ed!

[@luisarellanorn3309]

Knife.....but no Leatherman. Thanks for vid. Novelty....yeah

[@TheKnifeBeater]

Thanks Luis.

[@tecnotrog1]

Oh and i subscribed 🦉

[@whammofammo7346]

One great design. For a first try they did great. Hope they keep that wire clip.

[@TheKnifeBeater]

You and me both! I love that clip too.

[@LanningKann]

Mine is great, but I’d be wary about how you carry it. Mine opened in my pocket and cut my uniform pants open. Luckily it cut away from my leg instead of towards. I’ll carry it in my work bag or in a belt sheath but absolutely will not pocket carry it anymore. But carry aside it’s an awesome knife. It’s just too bad that ONE thing is a hinderance. It’s the first knife in 20+ years that’s ever opened in my pocket.

[@TheKnifeBeater]

Glad to hear you didn't get hurt. Kinda frustrating when you get a knife you really like and then something like that happens.

[@LanningKann]

@@TheKnifeBeater it could have been bumped into something though. You’re a lefty, have you worn it for any length of time? What clip configuration? I’m ambidextrous so I can always switch pockets if it better orients the blade.

[@willhernandez7687]

I understand the thinking behind this knife but it falls way short on the "utility" end. Maybe the second gen will be better thought through. 🤷🏻‍♂️

[@TheKnifeBeater]

I couldn't agree more Will. Thank you!

[@Keith_the_knife_freak]

Thanks for sharing Jay. 👍🏼

[@TheKnifeBeater]

You bet Keith. Thank you!

[@travispratt6327]

My first impression is all of the bulk without all of the utility as normal multitools. I almost always carry a leatherman though so this isn’t something I’d really be interested in anyways. The tools I use the most are the Phillips screwdriver, the pliers and the eyeglass screwdriver, this has none of those. I’ve also never ever needed a flat hex driver as I always have a socket set in my car garage and house, and if I do, the pliers will take care of it. Good review, pass on the multitool =)

[@TheKnifeBeater]

I know what you mean because I might like this a little more if it had tools that were useful to me. Thank you Travis!

[@daveouterspace]

If that second implement had been a nice saw blade instead of a strange piece of metal , then it would be able to replace my camper model

[@TheKnifeBeater]

Yeah, that's a great idea.

[@justinthyme2666]

I first saw this in a smkw catalog just the other day and did a double take when I realized it was a multi-tool. But the longer I looked the more disappointed I was. I would much prefer that blade in the civivi and the pocket clip, but the tools are next to useless, at least for me. I feel there is so much uptapped potential for knife makers here

[@TheKnifeBeater]

I feel the same way Justin. Great idea, but the tool selection is where it really falls short. Thank you!

[@dannyparrish724]

Rather have a saw blade. Great presentation.

[@TheKnifeBeater]

Great point! Thank you Danny.

[@tomweingart2337]

SAK better take notice!

[@TheKnifeBeater]

👍

[@drumorrison7625]

Not a multi tool user. Enjoyed the video and it was a great walk though and comparison. Just not for me even though I do love micarta. 😉

[@TheKnifeBeater]

I hear ya. Thanks Dru!

[@toolinedc]

I mean, kinda tired of hearing the lefties complaining... i'm right handed and i learned to open all my knives/leathermans/victorinox/other multitools with my left hand.... like.. come on.. just learn to be comfortable opening them with your right hands... still a good review tho ! ✌

[@randallperry3156]

I can get 1 million tools on a SAK for what the Crit costs. I like the Crit, but it's no SAK killer.

[@TheKnifeBeater]

I agree Randall, thanks.

[@philliphill4763]

Where's the corkscrew?

[@TheKnifeBeater]

👍

[@johanesgo8096]

I hope he makes a model like this with a wood saw. looking for a folding knife with a blade and a wood saw, if anyone knows of any model, I would be grateful for help

[@TheKnifeBeater]

I've heard from a bunch of other people that feel the same way.

[@williamlenderman387]

In the grand scheme of things, I suppose the crit has a place. It is not however a SAK killer. That's my .02¢ worth anyway.

[@TheKnifeBeater]

I agree William.

[@stuartgross5728]

I’ll stick with my Pioneer X.

[@TheKnifeBeater]

Me too Stuart.

[@Nordraw]

Front flipper? A no go

[@TheKnifeBeater]

👍

[@miklospinter]

Batarang :D

[@TheKnifeBeater]

👍

[@adamedwards3921]

Jay i found a crazy CRAZY LEFTY for you, Sandrine Torino tungsten carbide too think about it ....you can use the spine of a knife to sharpen a knife lol the particular one was on knife centers 🔪 latest new knife🔪 video check it out brother its a sexy knife and pretty cool lock on it too

[@TheKnifeBeater]

Thank you Adam, I'll check it out.

[@Jakoshdw]

Victorinox killer?!? Hahaha hahaha 😆 Nope. Quick access combined blade and prybar and package/cord cutter... sure! Would save you from needing to carry a separate prybar. I also wouldn't pry hard with it while holding the handle but light prying while choked up on the bar I'd think would work fine. The one thing it can do that most Victorinox can't... is work as a oxygen wrench. So there is that. If your job requires measuring short less than 3 inch measurements all day... it could also be handy.

[@krystofmraz]

Well for me sanrenmu makes real SAK Killer, much better than this. But is kinda Hard to obtain.

[@TheKnifeBeater]

By any chance are you talking about the SRM 9098? The one with a gut hook, screwdriver, and bottle opener. If so, I have one and I love that thing.

[@krystofmraz]

@@TheKnifeBeater well I do have 9019,which is same but with saw.

[@blacksheep6821]

Who cares about that secondary tool.put scissors instead!!

[@stephenmackey4571]

SAK totally harmless looking.

[@salalbanese3525]

Maybe its a batarang lol

[@TheKnifeBeater]

😆

[@CamboTriton]

Weird choice of "tools" from Civivi. A knife that's pointless to me.

[@TheKnifeBeater]

Yeah, this one did kinda come out of nowhere.

[@tecnotrog1]

Yeah sorry No...that is no SAK killer . SAK'S Have way to much heritage and functionality .the other knife? Its tool blade looks like a Chinese knockoff i once saw.🦉