Classical Composer Reacts to The Garden (Rush) | The Daily Doug (Episode 180)

[@jasonshort1437]

This song kills me. It was Neil's goodbye letter to us.

[@architectofechoes4]

I couldn't agree more. A wonderful drummer and came across as a wonderful person.

[@Ken5244]

Neil wrote the lyrics in 2010 or 2011. He didn't get his brain cancer diagnosis until 2016. In retrospect we can look at it as a goodbye letter, but he didn't intend it that way. Not that that makes the lyrics any less powerful.

[@sarapagedelawarelegallaw711]

I've felt the very same. I had seen their final tour in Philadelphia and it was bittersweet. At the time, I did not know it was their final tour but I just had a feeling. Major part of my youth as a musician has ended.

[@jasonshort1437]

@@sarapagedelawarelegallaw711 yeah, I was lucky enough to catch that second Toronto R40 show where they played Losing It for the first time. I just had a feeling they were going to play it and when they did, I knew exactly what it meant. 15,000 people all crying their eyes out.

[@sarapagedelawarelegallaw711]

@@jasonshort1437 amen!

[@justincamp5716]

Neil Peart was a gift to humanity. His desire to learn, see, and do everything and do it as excellently as he could should be an inspiration to everyone .

[@JF-kv1gm]

After his death, I watched everything and read everything I could. Heavens, what a mind, what a man.

[@bluegreenglue6565]

@@JF-kv1gm My husband died two weeks after Neil, and I have only just recently re-read "Ghost Rider." It helped.

[@tonydardi332]

Words cannot explain how much I love Neil. Been a fan for 38 years....Rush was more than music to me. The band was something I could count on in a world full of let down.

[@UFO1601]

Perfectly put Justin

[@ctbadger]

“What’s the most excellent thing I can do today?”

[@Asher8328]

As someone who's never played an instrument (at least, not very well), it always amazes me when someone hears a song for the first time and can immediately jump in and play along as if they're a member of the band.

[@annettereynolds1995]

I discovered Rush when I was 14. I'm now 54 and they've been my favourite band all this time. There has never been, nor will there ever be, anyone like them. A supremely class act. They could have so easily rested on their laurels, but they always strove to better themselves, to reinvent themselves, and that's what endeared me to them. Each of them with the most amazing skills. Humble and down to earth guys, hard working, with empathy for others. When I first heard The Garden, I knew it was their swansong. I knew it was over. They didn't need to say it. I could tell. And I struggle to listen to it now, especially since Neil went, without tears. It's always ripped me apart inside. This is how you bow out. Not with bombastic overtures, but with dignity and a quiet pride. Rest easy guys. You did good.

[@erikwresch5432]

As big a fan I am of Rush, I just recently discovered this track having already taken a liking to Headlong Flight and Clockwork Angel's, 12 years after this tour. The visual overlay was video from their final show in Los Angeles. The tears flowed. Thought it was just me. As I've navigated around this song and given it, already, multiple plays, I've discovered......I'm not alone in this experience. I'm quite blown away at how many people have expressed nearly the same exact feelings and emotion in reaction to this piece which is also.....the last track on the final album. I think you have to have been a Rush fan for awhile to understand how impacting this song is. I think so many of us listeners have the same reaction for the same reason, but we also have the same reaction for our own personal reasons. The power of music can be overwhelming sometimes.

@@erikwresch5432 beautifully said

[@pwethman1]

This song is so fitting as the coda to Rush’s career, whether it was meant that way or not. Neil was always preoccupied with the passage of time.

[@AtomizedSound]

Yes, I agree

[@25newrush]

It’s as if Neil wrote his own eulogy when he composed this song

[@holdyourfire74]

Agreed. The first time I heard this song, I thought to myself "This is it. This is the last song." As much as I would've loved 10 more Rush albums, I wouldn't have it any other way.

[@m3hsid10]

I went through the dark night of the soul right when this song came out. I'm a lifelong fan of Rush (40 years). I was able to take my wife and nephew to a concert separately and that is an experience that has a unique value to me. As others have said, I have a very hard time listening to The Garden without tears mostly because of the extreme difficulty I was going through at the time. BEST.....BAND......EVER!

[@michaelhylanddpt]

Man I love Rush so much. I will forever miss Neil and his brilliance. Of course he lives on in their music. He was a gift to so many while he was here on this earth. I was so blessed to have attended the first concert of the R40 tour in 2015 in Tulsa (I have lived in this area since 2012). It was their last tour and a fitting end to their amazing journey as a band. Neil died with them having had a final tour that was out of this world good. RIP “New Guy.”

[@kevincass5410]

By far, no close second, the GOAT. God bless Niel, Alex and Geddy for making my life fuller. 🙏

[@funkster007]

This is a tough song for me to revisit. I'm sure most true Rush fans would feel the same. Talk about an end to one amazing era. Miss ya Neil!

[@cs5384]

I'm in tears, every single time. Reading these comments gets to me even more.

[@ChrisHinton1967]

It was hard before Neil passed, but almost unbearable now.

[@JungleScene]

if they dont play this at my funeral im not going.

[@GG5150]

That's brilliant.

[@markknight6445]

Bravo. 🤣

[@ccynthianathompson1835]

Me either😂

[@nobodyyouknow3017]

Wanted it at my Mother's funeral. Was regretful I didn't. Definitely at Mine though.

[@abuhl9497]

I played it at my wife's funeral in Aug 2022

[@ericschilling1508]

This song is so beautiful I can barely listen to it without crying

[@jeffreypaul2324]

Same here...✌️

[@giovanniprofeta3699]

I’m with you on that one,.

[@na-tv6rn]

Add me to the list. Ugh. Only tour I got to see them on and I'm so thankful for it.

[@JungleScene]

same, Im on the verge of tears every time I listen to this song. its gorgeous hopeful songwriting but it also reopens the wound of Neils passing, so it puts me into a wirlwind of different emotions.

[@markphillipson768]

Me to

[@Stevedrums741]

All these years later, there are still no words for what this songs gives to me. Reflection, pain, loss, hope, optimism, time. All of it. no band and I mean NO band EVER left their fans with a 'goodbye' as poignant as this song. What a gift.

[@williamgabrielski8740]

One of my favorite guitar solos. I wish it was another 30 seconds or so longer. RIP Neil.

[@lerxstfan8295]

I played xanadu for a buddy of mine recently, i informed him that it was 3 guys...he looked at me with disbelief and promptly told me to f off.... i appreciate your respect for rush doug, they have been a very important part of my life for a very long time and i am glad you enjoy them a well.

[@crominion6045]

I first became aware of Rush when I was in 5th grade in 1981, with the release of the Moving Pictures album. Over the next several years they became my favorite rock band, and they still are to this day. Though many of their songs have touched and moved me over the decades, I think this is perhaps the most beautiful song they ever came up with. With the passing of Neil, I've come to think of this as Neil's personal song, as the lyrics seem so fitting to his life. RIP, Professor.

[@jonp3890]

You’re a good man, Doug Helvering.

[@jonsmith9518]

RIP Neil. Happy to have lived when you lived.

[@lauscho]

I'm not crying. YOU'RE crying. Beautiful song, beautiful reaction.

[@LeonardoPostacchini]

I am not crying too. You are.

[@Maltiris]

Dang the pollen is thick out today.

[@ytserob2112]

I still can't listen to this song without crying. RIP Professor. And you sir, you played the piano beautifully with this song. Kudos.

[@tomoconnor9164]

Just beautiful, wonderful words Doug for a beautiful, Wonderful piece, thank you for this, I have been waiting for this 🙏

[@BTVRhoenrad]

Thanks for this Video about the last song of Rush. My wife and me select one line of "the Garden" as a sloagen for our wedding. "The measure of a life is a measure of love and respect So hard to earn, so easily burned" an I asked Geddy to Singh his Bass book with this line. I told him this story as well. I will never forget his smile on his face. ❤

[@Seraphim4190]

That is so cool!

[@BTVRhoenrad]

@@Seraphim4190 thanks. Geddy is soo cool. ❤

[@kevindohn6776]

then he gave you a fist bump, move along !

[@williambechmann6547]

Dirk, Lerxst and Pratt are the best! Their music helped to mold my heart and soul. Rest in peace, Neil Peart....

[@squidly2112]

RUSH is, in my view, the greatest rock band that has ever existed, on every level. I feel so fortunate to have had the opportunity to have their music in my life since I was a teenager. I have been a fan of their music since the mid 70's and I have grown over the years as much as their music has, their musing being a part of my growth. They have given me inspiration and emotion on every level. My life would have been much different without them, not nearly as colorful or interesting for sure. I feel so fortunate to have had them as a part of my life. .. R.I.P. Neil .. we miss you very much!

[@ernestbuckley8671]

There is only one RUSH. Three master musicians who came together to bless us with 40 years of music. Their last song on their last album is their greatest gift to humanity. No one else is like them. RIP PROFESSOR

[@ricardorubiogonzalez3596]

One of the most beautiful Rush songs. Thanks Neil, thanks Geddy & Alex, thanks to your friend for the recommendation and thank you for this wonderful analysis.

[@StacyFaulknerOutdoors]

My father died 18 months after I was there for the live version of "The Garden". It was my favorite song on the album even before I saw it live. I pictured my father's life in this song since the day it was released. I told dad I was going to the concert,,, And out of the blue, my dad said to me, "Son. Let me pay for tickets and flight." After his death, I have heard and/or read comments, people make to my about my father. For example: ("Royce was best boss in the world. You couldn't ask for a better boss." and my favorite,,, "When Royce Faulkner spoke, people wanted listened.") I can say without, any doubt, "My dad tended His Garden. His memory will resonate in the hearts of many others than just mine"

[@RH-xs8gz]

Thank you Doug for this analysis. You’re one of, if not the most insightful l music analysts on YT. You’re one of the few people that can fully appreciate this band’s music and give it the attention it deserves. They were truly the “World’s Greatest Cult Band”. There will never be another band like Rush.

[@kevintremblay1211]

My heart still aches from Neil being gone. I am a drummer and he is my Idol as a drummer, none finer. Excellent work Doug keeps up the fantastic work!

[@eduardohoppe2837]

thanx as always for your brilliant job. thanx for your time, for your knowledge and for your kindness

[@themechaniacal1558]

The Garden makes me weep every time. All things must come to an end and pass away and the measure of our love for them is the void they leave in their wake in our heart. Since 1980 Rush has been my best friend, music I could turn to in those times I felt like such a misfit. They comforted, inspired, empowered and equipped, gave me the reason to press on. People with a gift to provide this kind of healing are truly blessed by God whether they know it or not.

[@byronness7385]

You nailed it Doug, there is NO other band like RUSH and there will never be again… truly beautiful humans and truly amazing musicians ❤️

[@RueMorgue1841]

I swear to god there's not been a single time I've listened to this song that I haven't ended up sobbing like a baby. Especially after Neil passed away.

[@scottwilliamscreek2427]

This is the song I sat and listened to by myself in my fathers house after he passed away 😪

[@crusheverything4449]

I understand completely, Scott and offer my condolence for your loss. This song came out within days of losing my mother and it will forever be linked to that experience. Of course, it has added poignancy now that Neil is gone, as well. It’s one of my favorite songs I’ve heard in my life and a bittersweet metaphor that will stay with me.

[@mysticsaxophone4181]

I've met many people who have this song as an epitaph to a lost loved one. Clockwork Angels had just come out when my best friend died of cancer, at 22 years of age. This song resonated with me a lot and every year I grab an old portable CD player and listen to it at his gravesite. It's still a hard listen for me but also a beautiful testament in a way.

[@crusheverything4449]

@@mysticsaxophone4181 - It is a most beautiful testament. I’m so sorry for your loss. I lost my best friend when I was 22. I understand how you feel and wish you the best. I hope fond memories sustain you in the coming days. ❤️

[@michaelturner6469]

Thanks for the piano Doug - once you started playing along it really felt part of the song and lifted it tonally - brilliant

[@diegopeart]

Just one of 2112 reasons why Rush is the best group in the galaxy. This song is symbolic not only for its placement in the actual story of Owen, the character in Clockwork angels, but as a general message about the etherealness of time, and importance of enjoying life and taking care of our own hearts. R.I.P. Neil.

[@bigvicious7317]

The last song of Rush! 😢 It was an honor to hear them play this live

[@brucecampbell6186]

I agree wholeheartedly.

[@lucst.martin2112]

I was at this show!!!

[@Double_Gator]

As a huge Rush fan, this song always brings me to tears. This song now reminds me of the loss of Neil but makes me smile to think of the wonderful garden of songs he left

[@einsoflight18]

BS"D This song is a pinnacle of maturity and brilliance, talent and humanity! I haven't heard this in so long, your analysis and insight was spot on. The lump in my throat is quivering... Time to work on my garden.

[@robertwhite7071]

Time to work on my garden, that's perfect!

[@scotthughes2687]

Doug, you’ve made a lot of Rush fans happy and sobbing at the same time.

[@dagahk1]

I love Rush's old songs, but when Clockwork Angels got released, I was transfixed by The Garden. It touched me so deeply at the time, and became one of my favorites. Looking back now, it just enhances the feeling. What an amazing band. Thanks for covering this.

[@rodek8614]

Even when Clockwork Angels came out, this song was extremely emotional for me. Now that Neal and passed and the context that this song ended up being Rush's and Neal's swan song has made it so I can't listen to it without crying. So powerful.

[@madjock-hy7th]

With the sad news about Geddy's mum this past week this song seems even more apt and beautiful. If you are not aware Doug, his mum was a holocaust survivor. Both she and his dad suffered in concentration camps, in fact they met in Auschwitz and later when freed reunited in Canada. Her story is a brave one. Sadly his dad passed away when he was about 12, it seems due to health issues from his treatment at the hands of the Nazi's. One of Rush's most powerful songs written by Neil was "Red Sector A" from "Grace Under Pressure which was partly inspired by Geddy's mum's story. You can hear the emotion in his voice when he sings it. There are some live recordings of it which are harrowing and powerful. "The Garden" is stunning and a fitting memorial to not only Neil, but good kind and generous people everywhere who pass. Lovely analysis.

[@scotthughes2687]

I had not heard about Geddy’s mom, thanks for sharing. Her scenes in Beyond the Lighted Stage were some of the best, you really got a sense for how Geddy turned out to be such a good person.

[@JF-kv1gm]

Thanks for posting this. I only found out yesterday and wasn't sure whether to mention it. It track seems particularly fitting this week, doesn't it? Nearly 96 years old, an incredible life when you think about it. Here's an interview with Geddy on world holocaust remembrance day where he talks about his mother at length... kzbin.info/www/bejne/noHbqIZ8aah6r9E

[@kippsguitar6539]

Didn't know that, she sounded like a legend too

[@christopherwright8811]

Had missed that news also. Amazing story of survival. And yes, Geddy's interviews on Holocaust remembrance day are very much worth a listen as another posted has pointed out.

[@christinehayes839]

@@kippsguitar6539 She was incredible, and so proud of Geddy. May her memory be a blessing.

[@RaymondBCrisp]

You never cease to amaze me with your ability to just pick up and start playing with the song. You have great ears. Thanks for the reaction and kind words towards the band, and especially towards Neil.

[@brunovaz91]

Thanks for this reaction! It lights my day! Congratulations for your channel!

[@Progene01]

This review was 3 years ago, RIP Neal Peart and you encompassed it so well on the piano. Hearts out to Neil and RUSH and thank you for taking such an interest in this beautiful song.

[@ShaneWilletts]

So many of Rush’s songs, in particular Peart’s lyrics, speak specifically to the human spirit. Sadly missed but never forgotten. It’s taken me a while to get over the loss - I can’t imagine how it was, and is, for those who knew him best. Thanks Doug.

[@jamesalden3217]

Thank You Doug for doing this. Even as a Rushaholic - I did not discover the poignancy of this song until recently and your analysis was similar to mine. Neal came into these insights several years before his diagnosis - so I guess one could say his was a life well lived !!

[@CanadaMikeB]

When you're in the 2nd row in front of Geddy watching and hearing this live like i was 9 years ago, my inner vibrations went off the chart and I can most certainly say I had an existential experience that will last with me forever. Doug, your reaction here, triggered it again for me. My garden is my new young family of two daughters and a beautiful wife, home, and good job. Your review here was inspirational once again. Cheers to you! Neil's lyrics on this swansong could not be more fitting to anyone's life. I think I want it played at my funeral.

[@marksaxon]

A year and a half later and it still hurts to know Pratt is no longer with us. Beautiful song and so fitting to be the last song of their catalog.

[@somebloke13]

Great sentiment 🙏 but you might want to edit Neil's name

[@julien2231]

Pratt.. lol

[@marksaxon]

@@somebloke13 Umm that was his nickname within the band.

[@marksaxon]

@@somebloke13 www.reddit.com/r/rush/comments/41kuu1/the_origins_of_dirk_lerxst_and_pratt_according_to/?

[@patrickwhitfield5079]

Doug, I enjoyed hearing you interpret their music through your fingers.

[@estefaniasucre6966]

Clockwork Angels is my favorite Rush album. Thanks for doing this beautiful song, Doug!

[@andreasandersson9629]

Did NOT see that coming! I have grown a habit whatching these videos, with headphones on, while doing the dishes. Not a huge Rush listener but I gave it a go and by the end of this song I was in tears. Powerful stuff!

[@giovanniprofeta3699]

Thank you Doug, as a Rush fan I got to say that “The garden” has a special place in my heart. To have THAT as a last song in simply sublime. It’s impossible for me not to get goosebumps when this song is playing.

[@osoabd]

You are quite right Doug. There isn´t (or wasn't) a band like them. They exuded not only musicianship, but also a real lifetime brotherhood that it´s a rarity in this ego-machine world of rock-stars. Of course there´s a mountain of musical material in their account. Let me suggest you to try another 70´s finale masterpiece called NATURAL SCIENCE (from Permanent Waves). Greetings from Bariloche, Patagonia, Argentina in the dawn of our 205 th. Independence Day. Alejandro Bianco Dubini saying goodnight

[@BusinessEnglishSuccess]

+1 for Natural Science - amazing track.

[@mrmanakin9684]

There were plenty of bands like Rush. For some reason people never tend to try other bands because they assume there is nothing better

[@osoabd]

Venomouscarnage I didn't say they were the best band. I only pointed that Rush developed, as in fact almost all the 70's prog bands (and soloist, like Vangelis, JM Jarré, Mike Oldfield...), their own unique style. That was a trademark of that period. No band wanted to sound like the others.

[@annettereynolds1995]

@@mrmanakin9684 That's because there is nothing better.

[@annettereynolds1995]

Yes, Natural Science is amazing. It's in my top 5

[@PacificAirPhoto1]

Incredible. Can’t listen to it with dry eyes. Thank you for this, so glad we could all share it here. ❤️

[@JF-kv1gm]

This song gets me every time. It's such a direct meditation on impermanence and all the more poignant after Neil's passing. So moving, beautifully structured. Thanks, Doug, for reacting to this so sensitively and obviously getting its message.

[@sethkaicer319]

Rock and roll Never Dies. It just passes out every now and then and wakes up on the daily Doug.

[@OdeForCruelty]

One of my favorite songs by Rush, which of course means it's one of my favorite songs of all time. Period. What a lyrics by Neil, what a way to say farewell. He left us with a glimmer of hope, and a lesson we should never forget. The measure of a life is a measure of love and respect, indeed. This one makes me so emotional it's unbelievable, but in a good way.

[@xai1971]

This song is so, so beautiful. Still brings a tear or two to my eyes cause I always remember Neil.

[@mikeh3851]

Neil's gift to us was his garden. The seeds he's sown through his melodic drums, and captivating lyrics shall continue to grow. As long as we admire it's beauty, it will forever thrive.

[@sianpodmore4988]

OK, that had me in tears. RIP Neil Peart. Beautiful, profound message, thank you Doug and all

[@stevebean1543]

"There's only one band that sounds like them. What kind of band is Rush? It's Rush." - Gene Simmons

[@AlanDunsmore]

If you’re looking for something else by Rush with really powerful lyrics try “Losing it” from the Signals album. Just different class.

[@Ken5244]

Agreed. One of my favorite lyrics ever is "Some are born to move the world, to live their fantasies. But most of us just dream about the things we'd like to be." Brilliant song and insight into humanity. And that electric violin playing by Ben Mink ... it doesn't get much better.

[@stantheman9072]

Finally played that one live during the Clockwork Angels tour as they had their choice violinist join them on stage. Awesome shows!

[@valsribar988]

When they chose to play Losing It live, it was s message to the fans that really paid attention that the band was done. I believe the writer in the second verse is Hemingway

[@JohnBrooking4]

@@valsribar988 Probably so, since he wrote “For Whom the Bell Tolls”.

One of my all time favorite Rush´s song 🥰

[@Jamo-qw4xu]

Best reaction ever! My family has known for years that the garden is what I want played at my funeral with the lyric card in everyone's hand. Peace!

[@edgarpacifico3421]

Excellent job, Maestro!!! Your reactions are always great!!

[@BrentHarris1970]

Thanks for that one, Doug! Still have trouble listening to it without crying. I have to remind myself it's the journey and not the end we should cherish. 🥺

[@alanferdman9516]

Sad to think that Neil Peart wrote this song as a Good-Bye. What a GIFT this man possessed. Rip Neil !!!

[@dusty3913]

Neil's writing (his several books) and song lyrics played a meaningful role in shaping me; now 49 years. Rush as a whole has, but especially Neil. Im a guitar player, but it was Neil who really drew me in. Another, was Eddie Van Halen for his sheer inventiveness and originality. We lost both of them within the span of a year. I broke down those days-it was an all day experience. Of all the things my orbit collects in its sweep, these two people are always on my mind.

[@robertopapei6523]

Never before like this time I love your piano playing along.

[@donepearce]

You can't go wrong with Rush. What a mix - really excellent.

[@gregcormier2379]

This song always pulls at my heartstrings. The lyrics are a perfect summation of Rush as a band and as people!

[@daveclarke1221]

This band means so much to me. From the 14 year old hearing Xanadu in 77 for the first time to The Garden. Blessed to have seen them 20+ times. Mainly in the UK but also lucky enough to have road tripped 6 shows on the final tour. Oh man, they have helped me understand stuff with a wider reality. I used “The future disappears into memory…’” section during my eulogy for my Dad in 2019. Such a special lyric and will forever make me cry…

[@dirk4896]

Excellent video, maestro, you really nailed it. Many thanks and blessings.

[@jonathanhenderson9422]

One of the most magical things about Rush is that they showed how prog and pop weren't mutually exclusive. Certainly they had the technical and compositional talents to impress and attract musicians, but they wouldn't have been the international superstars they were without their pop sensibilities that appealed to your average music fan.

[@HansMcGruber]

You're right about mutual exclusivity. I personally don't consider this song pop, it's just beautiful songwriting with a little bit everything in it. The guitar solo section certainly doesn't sound pop, it just sounds like Rush. Similar in feel to "Losing It", a song most rock bands could not attempt to write, bur Rush could. RIP Neil, the professor

[@jonathanhenderson9422]

@@HansMcGruber I think of pop less as a genre and more of an ethos or approach to other genres. The ethos is one that focuses on melody, hooks, tone, simplicity and/or accessibility. Occasionally you'll see complexity combined with melody/hooks in a way that's accessible, like with much of Steely Dan... or Rush, for that matter. I was also mostly reacting to Doug's comment about this being a poppier song for Rush, but he's comparing it to stuff like La Villa Strangiato and 2112.

[@JohnBrooking4]

I feel like “Losing It” was a young person’s portrayal of what they saw then as the sadness of getting old. I haven’t done the math, but I think they were probably in their 30’s when they wrote that? Just beginning to realize you won’t be young forever, but still at the older end of young. Kind of imagining what it must be like. I think it’s accurate and empathetic, but focused mostly on the sadness of no longer being at the peak of your professional ability. It lacks the perspective of an actual older person that they brought to this song, which is the wisdom and beauty of growing old and coming to a more comprehensive understanding of your place in the universe, even as your body is no longer what it once was. If you’re lucky enough to reach that place.

[@HansMcGruber]

@@jonathanhenderson9422 I think everyone agrees The Garden is more accessible and emotive than typical Rush song.

[@markstromberg1148]

Profundity, spirituality, musicality, humanity. In other words, Neil Peart. I don't know whether to believe in an afterlife, but I know that he and the art he made with Geddy Lee and Alex Lifeson live on and continue to change lives - mine included - and all for the better. What a great legacy. Would that we could all say that when our time on this earth draws to a close.

[@Alberto_1965_BR]

The last song of the last album from Power Trio. A beautiful goodbye From ultimate classic rock: "I stood in the control room listening while the strings were being recorded," Peart recalled in the bio. "It occurred to me that all songwriters should experience the sensual delight of hearing their songs performed by an accomplished string section. For example, when these virtuoso artists on violin, viola, cello and double-bass executed David’s plangent orchestration for 'The Garden,' there was not a dry eye in the studio."

[@KMrph]

Thanks Doug, you’ve shown me anew a song I thought already knew, and nurtured my garden in doing so. Peace to you, brutha.

[@cs5384]

I love when you bring us Rush. My favorite band for over 40 years! This is one of my favorite songs too although it's hard to get through without tears these days.

[@andymelrose642]

Wonderful Doug! The Garden is such a special song for Us Rush fans and frequently can move us to tears. Thank you.

[@crossbearer365]

Your moments of piano intervention gave the song a special touch/depth. Your reactions are other-level, intellectual, and heady. I appreciate your deep insight, sir.

[@Eastcoastpreacher]

So true. Great words.

[@thumostheos]

I've always felt like Neil already received his diagnosis and knew he'd be gone soon. It feels like his epitaph. When I first heard it after he passed, it became much more poignant and I cried. Took me 2 years to listen to their music again after he died. Then the good memories came flooding back and I instantly felt alive and hopeful again. RIP, Neil. You are desperately missed.

[@leddygee1896]

I also felt he knew his time was at a premium and he wanted to make the most of his time with his family. Rest In Power, Professor...

[@eshgholah]

R.I.P Maestro Peart. 🖤🖤🖤

[@cbilan34]

I come back to this time and time again. When Doug starts accompanying on the piano, it's perfection....

[@alphaenemyplus8376]

One thing I absolutely adore is that Clockwork Angels is their last album and they were in their late 50's when they wrote it and it's an absolutely excellent and really heavy album.

[@johnnicholson8345]

usually at the end of a bands writing career one can expect very little. This album IMHO is one of their best.

[@alphaenemyplus8376]

@@johnnicholson8345 one of the best things about this was taking my Dad to see them on this tour, and MOST of the crowd was YOUNG. And they KNEW THE WORDS TO THESE SONGS.

[@ryankrambeer6357]

You added something so beautiful with that piano in the beginning. This song makes me emotional every time I hear it. I actually have "The future disappears into memory, with only a moment between" tattooed on my arm. The second I heard those words when I listened to this song for the first time, it stopped me dead in my tracks. Beautiful work on this video. Every time you'd turn and smile at the camera, I'd smile cuz the entire video brought me so much joy

[@michaelcudia3439]

Thank you for your thoughtful words in reviewing this video..this song has impacted me unlike any other Rush song. It’s no coincidence that it is, in fact, the last song on their last studio album. I wish we had more time with Neil..he was just starting to live his life on his terms

[@lisaharrison1031]

It’s been 19 months since we lost our “heartbeat” & I still can’t watch this without crying. I was at this show in Dallas in November of 2012 it was a beautiful thing but then again EVERY Rush show was beautiful. Thanks for being the soundtrack to my life for over 40 years. RUSH FOREVER!!

[@trenthogan4212]

Such a profoundly beautiful song. The studio version is even better. What a way to end a career.

[@waltcorey5115]

Yes it is. I, Iikely, did myself a disservice. I liked Rush, bought their albums. Yes was still my favorite band but Rush was really close until one music video, I actually liked the song but, the video produces made Alan and Geddy float around the stage and I remember thinking isvthis video, their target audience, 5 year olds? That singular thing soured me.

[@trenthogan4212]

@@waltcorey5115 I assume you mean "Alex. The video is "time Stands Still" back in the 80s when that was released it was cutting edge. I am sure they cringe when they see it now. Rush's last 3 albums were absolutely incredible.

[@waltcorey5115]

@@trenthogan4212 I stand corrected Trent, thank you. It was a really dumb, immature, and goofy special effect. I've gone from 45s->33s->CDs->google music->Spotify. Rush is part of my favorites collection. My last two cars didn't even offer in-dash cd. My Tesla does have Spotify though. I will listen to them, thank you again for that heads-up! I often wonder if Time Stand Still, written by Neil was after he got the diagnosis. It's lyrics take on a whole new meaning given his passing.

[@waltcorey5115]

@@trenthogan4212 Clockwork Angels, Snakes and Arrows, and R30? It looks like those are the last thee original albums or were you referring to some of the re-released albums?

[@trenthogan4212]

@@waltcorey5115 R30 is not a studio album 1. Clockwork Angels (Masterpiece) 2. Snake and Arrows 3. Vapor trails

[@skulatore7661]

A "Clockwork Angels" album reaction would be phenomenal

[@lewisbernstein4272]

It really might be my favorite Rush album. It's that good. All of it.

[@dirk4896]

Most Rush albums would work for a long show.

[@ZeroMischief]

They are the reason I became a musician. My absolute all-time favorite band, and the soundtrack of my life (cliché but true). I was blessed to see them live over 40 times, and I couldn't miss them more. This song brings me to tears almost every time. What a finale they left us with. So many beautiful and wonderful gifts they gave us.

[@WannabeHasBeen1]

Thank you Doug for paying honest respect to Neil. It truly warms the soul to see another person being inspired by Professor Peart's heartfelt lyrics. For me, the respite of this piece is the message of hope. For a man who considered himself agnostic for so many years, Neil's lyrics have such a spiritual essence interlaced within. I am so thankful for his generous contribution to the soundtracks of my life.

[@aldunne2001]

Doug, one of your best yet, Maybe THE best reaction you have done. And I think you are the best reaction artist on KZbin by far. First, you bring great knowledge of musical theory and composition which gives us plebs so much insight into these songs. But you go beyond the theory of the music, looking into the meaning of the lyrics and the emotions the bands evoke with their works. The recent addition where you play the piano and pick out the chords, especially catching the Maj7 and sus chords and how these harmony choices support the emotional content is great. My only suggestion with the piano is to be aware with your levels so that the piano is underneath the recorded music during the quieter passages. Keep up the good work. I hope you can get around to something off ELP’s Trilogy album, such as Endless Enigma or the title track Trilogy.

[@chiliray4515]

You said what I was going to say, but more elegantly, about the sound levels for the piano.

[@joemaurone7923]

at 7:21, the slow piano breakdown: Every time I hear that, it reminds me of a part from Paul McCartney's "Let Em' In" (from WINGS AT THE SPEED OF SOUND), right after the refrain of "Brother Michael, Aunty Gin, Open the Door, let 'em in...", when the beat stops, and it's a similar quiet piano breakdown. A small comparison, probably wasn't intentional, but still reminded of the way they both stop the beat and go quiet with those chords going from natural to 7ths...

[@Shigawire]

You're seriously talented. A joy to watch you get inspired and jam in real time. :)

[@DwayneF]

This song fills me with so much love and hope, it overflows. Rush are utterly and specifically, Human.

[@aldersmoke1]

I like this channel, but I feel like you sometimes get so caught up in finding and riffing on the chords that you miss what's going on over them. Alex's guitar solo on here is one of the most emotive things ever played on the instrument. It doesn't need any help.

[@julien2231]

I so heartilly agree. I think he should react first, and then, do his thing afterwards. Sometimes it annoys me how he misses sone great lyrics or sections.

[@alancooke6630]

Yep, I agree

[@TwoIndians]

Totally agree, missing the depth of the emotional experience while fancying himself with pride that he’s figured out the chord progression. Mad respect for your skills Doug but let the song take you away. It’s your channel though. Haha. You be you. I’ll keep watching.

[@AllenWBrockton]

I've said the same thing several times. I don't think he reads any comment unless it's from his Patreon subscribers.

[@anthonysaponaro6318]

I don't know about all of that, as a musician you'll be drawn to that trap, wanting to play along, I certainly am not going to fault the guy for letting his emotion out the way he chooses. . . I didn't mind one bit , in fact I'd wonder why sitting in front of a piano how one could not

[@zekesterboospirit8658]

I really, really enjoyed this. Breaks my heart and fills me with joy.

[@michelforest6329]

The final verse was inspired by Voltaire's "Candide". Terrific stuff.

[@michelforest6329]

@@TrevRockOne Indeed, but the last line is the most obvious, in my opinion. It's pretty much the same as the last sentence in Candide. That was the thing with Neil as a lyricist: his words were so different from the obvious rock clichés of " I love you, I want you, babe, etc." A brilliant mind.

[@mariomcloughlin2898]

Also the reference to the Leibniz's " best of possible worlds"

[@michelforest6329]

@@mariomcloughlin2898 True. However, "Candide" was written by Voltaire to ridicule Leibniz's philosophy.

[@glennrager3684]

Tears. Thank you, Doug, for giving your time to cover my favorite song, and its lyrics. I'm a new subscriber who is fascinated by your ability to play along by ear. Well done!

[@davidgroll-cook7125]

I still get emotional every time I hear this song. Masterpiece. RIP Neil