"Collegium Must Answer "I India's Top Legal Minds Livid over Justice Muralidhar Case I Barkha Dutt

[@ht5389]

Thanks to the three gentlemen for speaking up for Justice Muralidhar. Need justice for Justice Muralidhar.

[@xisractionresearch5625]

Raising difficult questions, speaking truth to power is the duty of conscientious citizens and great and courageous journalism.

[@drganeshprasad4759]

Thanks to Burkha and all the Wisemen for highlighting a very very important issue. It is extremely important for the courts, specially the Supreme Court, the only last hope for the common man, to be completely free from political interference. Unfortunately, the mainstream media doesn't even touch such issues. Thank god; we have social media like Mojo. When the Parliament, the Executive and even judiciary fail, the fourth estate MEDIA is the only hope to build public opinion on such issues. Hopefully one day the 'public opinion' will embolden the judiciary to be completely independent drives the govt to stop interference. Many thanks to the gentlemen Mr Nariman, Justice Lokur and Mr Punchu for taking on this important issue.

[@inderb6365]

Excellent story, Barkha. Thank you. And thanks to Justice Lokur, Mr. Fali Nariman and Mr. Pacchu for the brilliant Op-ED in Indian Express. You have brought out a very important issue ailing our justice system: the political pressure that hinders selection of right people, and, thereby, hurting the justice delivery system.

[@ramsanatan56]

As rightly said ' we lost a diamond that should've sparkled on the crown'. If it wasn't politics then what is it ? Justice is denied to justice. My salute to Justice Muralidhar

[@shaunbird8051]

Thanks so much Barkha for bringing up this topic with the the views of such great luminaries in the Judiciary. Mr.Muralidhar was very honest, sincere and upright and his various judgements have earlier irked many unwanted elements who are mainly politicians. The questions raised by these great people tothe Collegium holds much water and has really stirred up a hornets nest ? Every good citizen hold righteous uppermost and is patriotic in their own way. Why should many politicians and Judges deviate from this issue. As the great saying goes criminals and politicians always despise Logic ! Jai Hind !

[@shareefind]

You have summed up perfectly

[@kartikkurmy-hz5oe]

Out of almost 1100 High Court judges in India, Cry for only one judge. Why? Out of 1100 judges only one judge was competent. If that is so it would raise another serious question on collegium. Advocates practicing in Orissa High Court could never see the greatness in him. I smell there is some else behind the screen.

[@ars123-]

Across all professions across the board, be it bureaucracy, media, military or judiciary, it has always been loyalty over competence while selecting people to done positions of power!!

[@agnescraig2912]

Even if this is just water off a ducks' back it is awesome that there are people in India who stand up for their ideals.

[@rajibrath9156]

Probably for the reason they knew here was a judge who was a rare genius if let loose would have created havoc.

[@nabendugupta1]

The Collegium was scared😂

[@absolute7433]

Accountability of Collegium is must!

[@kirtikumarthaker9892]

Justice Lokur was also part of collagium at some point in time. He would also have fallen in line to make unanimous recommendation. Only collagium member who put his foot down on a worthy judge being made part of recommendation, is justice R. F. Nariman.

[@sharadpanse2660]

Justice Muralidhar ought to have eventually become CJI.

[@kasturiswami784]

Exactly because he is just and fearless is the great impediment. The collegium is under threat. Let's not mince words and pussyfooting about this issue.

[@mininlobo8413]

With due respect why was this issue not raised before his retirement

[@sabihasaud8156]

Waiting for him to retire so nothing can b done !!

[@Hussain-vi4fd]

Required for Other Judges following the pursuit. Effects Honesty and integrity of Judges.

[@ismail-sait]

Justice murlidhar is One of the best justice of our time

[@kirtikumarthaker9892]

Independence of judiciary needs to be enhanced, not to be allowed to be curtailed. Supreme Court must assert.

[@agnescraig2912]

Was the CJI commended by Modi on The 15th of August. Just saw a clip of the CJI gesturing "Namaste

[@shareefind]

Thanks Barkha for the Debate... I am not from the fraternity of judges, yet we as common being, acknowledge the importance of Courts and Judges. Although we don't know how competent Mr. Murlidharan was, but we have a feeling that that sanctity of courts & Judges is under threat. The role of judges in a democracy cannot be overstated. - They serve as the guardians of justice - Upholding the rule of law - Protecting individual rights - Ensuring that the principles of fairness and equality are upheld Their impartiality and independence from political influences are crucial in maintaining the checks and balances necessary for a healthy democratic system. - By interpreting and applying laws - Reviewing the constitutionality of legislation I think judges contribute to the stability and functioning of society. Their decisions set important precedents that guide the course of legal interpretation and ensure that the rights of citizens are upheld. In essence, judges play a vital role in preserving the core values and principles upon which a democracy thrives. Please offer my gratitude, hellos, hugs, and compliments to FN saab, Lokur, and Panchu saab... for their efforts in starting the debate and steering it in the right direction. A hearty and very big thanks to you as well.

[@Nitin_Killawala]

It’s time Supreme Court takes over government as one more of their responsibilities under these great institution !!!…

[@aurojaganmohane9898]

Sc will take military also.all oppparties will be their slave in the years to come..impeach thejudges by all mps.

[@khalidbinasim6942]

Honorable Murlidharan right place is SCI,

[@sumantv8306]

Justice for Justice S.murlidhar

[@johnjoseph3622]

Thanks to make us citizens to feel good for Justice Muralidhar.

[@chittoghosh594]

Collegium should come clean on their apparent sidetracking of far reaching consequences in country's legal ecosystem.

[@yashtiwari1964]

One of the finest Judges India Ever had, Just a reminder : There have been numerous CJI's but HR Khanna still trumps everyone.

[@sundareshanal1849]

Can we have the track record of the Collegium system from the last 30 years since it began. Is it only this particular case where the collegium has " failed" ? Is it so simple to say that " politics" has played a part as though the system was crystal pure before this date ? Is it not incredible that this charge has suddenly come up now ? How political is the timing of this attack by the three OP'ED writing judges? Let us grant that Justice Muralidhsr is a sterling judge. But how many times in the history of the last 30 years have one group of judges come out and thrown what is clearly straight innuendo? Is this an attack on the collegium or the political govt ? Has the collegium never played favorites before? If there was ever politics involved, is it the first time this is happening? Someone should flip this and find out deeper and hidden agendas if any. Love for Modi is not a disease known among these folks. Are they attacking him in an orchestrated manner ? We need empirical evidence and a pattern to emerge. Else, this can well be a selective outrage despite it being a legitimate issue nevertheless.

[@shareefind]

I am not against BJP or against Congress, I am pro-people ... we all knew for sure that all Govt try to control the Constitutional bodies and almost all our institution has been compromised, we need the reset.... as soon as politician come to power and he became "Master" and treat people as their slaves, do we need the prove that the politician + Businessmen + godmen + Ghoondaas + IAS/IPS(constitutional bodies) working together for their own benefits. It is the timing or not to suit political gain, if you remember Anna movement was also before elections, but we as common person shall be interested in cleaning the mess and democracy shall deliver and work for commoners. Raising the hidden issues is the core responsibilities of opposition, and there should be limit to the loyalty toward political parties too, we are not for political parties but they are for serving us.... I am not saying you are endorsing any party.....

[@OnkarSingh-lq8ck]

If the Constitution of India is a "political document", then the Supreme Court is likely to play politics while interpreting the Constitution as well in appointing judges !! Judges get appointed as per the Articles of the Constitution, politics shall/ may play out !! Justice Muralidhar and Justice Kureshi not making it to the Supreme Court is the loss of "justice" , people seeking "justice" have suffered at the hands of the Judges and politicians ruling the country at this point of time.

[@yeddulajojireddy2919]

Parliament must pass Act ,,to Frame Accountability to the Collegium,,In Democracy it is must ,to Whom Collegium answerability or Accountability Accountability ,,so Every Elite Citijen wants this Answer from Indian Parliament

[@afrahsayeed6778]

CJI is under pressure of govt ...

[@KingD2507]

Wasn't he the same judge who did not stand with free speech instead stood with religious fundamentalists in Nupur Sharma case. God save us from these so called judges

[@winbrijesh]

It’s not just 3 of us. Now signatories will be added.

[@nitinbelvi552]

Wow, what a wonderful farewell.Perhaps India’s loss.

[@pranabranjanchhatoi9411]

First of all collegium system should be stopped and appointment of judges in high court and Supreme Court should be on merits and integrity of a person and examination should be conducted like IAS examination.

[@nitchow]

Not a fan of Barkha but this was a very well conducted interview. One understands the need for a pointedly independent judiciary and especially the need to strengthen the hands of high quality judges like Mr Muralidhar. I hope the current CJI pushes back.

[@vishaalbhatnagar3924]

Great report.

[@s20233s]

Fact is the opaque nature of collegium makes this possible - Fact is it has been happening for decades - it is not just about Murlidharan

[@mediatorjawad]

The truth is obvious. The collegium capitulated before the executive. What possible explanation can it give?

[@arkitectoor]

I can bet now which political side Justice Murlidhar belongs to..

[@georgekoshy6253]

Is this the 1000 years history of justice that was heard from red fort. Shameful.

[@Hussain-vi4fd]

Its simply Ruling party approving or disapproving the candidate. Lack of transparency in recruitment.

[@marthadsilva3255]

The collegium must answer

[@pantherlurks1153]

Can he not be inducted again, if his health permits and he agrees too?

[@vjsethi7213]

The one word that describes best our Educated class why they do not stick out their necks and be forthright is FEAR Fear of being singled out Fear of being passed for promotion Fear of being in any controversy Fear of losing s comfortable life It's the tankhwah system that is to blamed Too much sensitivity for one's good name Ones career oft be more important A holier than thou status to maintain You don't find freedom fighters among judges Neither our bureaucrats are free from grudges The typical Dronacharya himself is weak Passing the buck is taught in schools and colleges If we had true exemplary gurus There would have been no Mahabharat We would have respected women more Equal rights ingrained in our Sanskars No hiding behind a tree to kill Bali No use of a Shikhandi to kill Bhishma Calling a spade a space be common Only Entrepreneurs have such chutzpah

[@agnescraig2912]

Like your comment but too many people take the easy route. Sincerely wish people would be honest and integral even if your neck is on the line

[@nagarajrajaram7727]

At the highest rungs of decision making, political considerations weigh very heavily. So, sometimes, competence may lose out. That is the sad reality and it has existed for decades.

[@property_tommorow9918]

Because people like Barkha Dutt lobbied against him. So why is Barkha Dutt trying to act despondent??

[@surendra1990]

I don’t know why are they crying now. She should have staged a fast until death if she or the others in the crowd were so keen on getting mr M in the SC. This is nothing but her employers wish, it seems.

[@agarwalkaditya]

बैठे बैठे क्या करें करना है कुछ काम चलो चमचों को मिर्ची 🌶लगाये 👍 ले के मोदीजी का नाम

[@seasonwalk5776]

Tragedy of justice

[@madankulkarni1715]

Come out & Throw Mud is not limited to politics. If have passion to work for country select better options in brining reforms in judiciary.

[@sabihasaud8156]

What kind of question is that y was he not promoted .. it is obvious isn’t it !!

[@agnescraig2912]

For most of us it is obvious but our opinions are negligible. Only right honourable and learned people matter

[@narasimhankannan708]

Very burning question for Anti india media.

[@lalremsanganghaka5865]

Educate yourself pls

[@subbaraotanguturu9271]

If so she agrees on his recommendation to give ST status to Meteis? Won't. This woman is jihadis supporter, conversion mafia supporter and supports everything anti Hindu.

[@subbaraotanguturu9271]

​@@lalremsanganghaka5865Well educated than you about this Burqua Dutt and his support to Kashmir Hindus genocide by playing victim hood in favour of muslims. What about Muralidharan's recommendation to include Meteis in STs. They should support it because he is correct judge?

[@binahamed]

Both Muralidharans are different

[@sagarmohanty9655]

@@binahamed Don't mind these sanghis here. same old false arguments

[@winbrijesh]

It was nepotism. Murlidhar’s dad was not in SC

[@ashokbraroo8845]

Me lords justice is selective always along personal benefits. Me lords selecting themselves and like Nehru gave Bharat Ratna to Nehru and Nehru received it.

[@alokbharti2329]

Honesty & Intellect is Decided by left, If they get judgment as they want Then Judge becomes Hero,

[@winbrijesh]

Lokur is behaving like a petty politician. Hit and scoot

[@winbrijesh]

So, are these 3 guys above collegium.

[@subus7263]

for context, this is the judge who caused the current Manipur conflict

[@winbrijesh]

Very shady motives of these 3 guys. Do they mean every High Court judge not recommended is not good enough.

[@winbrijesh]

How do u define gr8 merit? Individual opinion.

[@vrish2007]

Your reports are always boring.

[@VishalKumar-g6k5n]

Woke judge

[@winbrijesh]

Man connected with people. 😆 its a beauty contest ?

[@joymascarenhas3491]

Are you OK?

[@pramodkulkarni3747]

Let us wait for collegium speak. It is not right on yr part to bring this issue to public and through barkha- or journ as list