Comfortably Numb - David Gilmour - Madison Square Garden - NYC - Nov 6 2024

[@rickfrancis5480]

People need to understand this man is 78 yrs old . That’s pure gold ! Goat all the way . Impressive

[@zaradragonia9863]

Yes. I do. That is why his voice is going

[@breezlee59]

78 yrs young 🙂

[@SJoiseyKid]

No transposition. Original key. 👍

[@luvutons411]

Definitely understand his age. His playing and vocals, to me, have not changed really that much..fabulous show..👍🎤🇬🇧🎸

[@EugeneGopherson]

And he still can sing and play guitar great. But just not every time. Anyway he is a music legend!

[@ferramirez4570]

Every time he plays this solo a new Strat is Born somewhere around the globe.

[@stephenfeldman8104]

😀😀

[@GerryBlue]

And a Les Paul breaks at the headstock

[@ytsertd333]

@@GerryBlue 🤣🤣🤣

[@JayTheLane]

You are a legend 💜

[@zaxmaxlax]

his best solo(dogs) was made on a tele

[@ericdahlman3354]

The earth is 4.5 billion years old and i get to live in a time with David Gilmour

[@JeremyDeBose]

He’s been playing this song 45 years. 7 years longer than I’ve been alive. Thousands of performances of it and most are different solos. And we still can’t get enough of it.

[@cyrus_auricus]

I'm starting to think we'll never get enough of it

[@youngman44]

Every time he performs this it’s a gift to humanity. David Gilmour is a gift to everyone who has lived in his era. I am thankful to have been a teenager when Dark Side of the Moon came out. Still resonates. And to be able to have enjoyed the music for over 50 years. A true privilege.

[@PhillipLandmeier]

I have no words for this. I'm an engineer, a musician, old, almost as old as Gilmour, multi-instrumental, classically trained, guitarist, and this is my favorite guitar solo. It's absolutely thrilling from the first time I heard it 30 years ago. This is just stunning

[@geraldcampos3790]

For me, this is the only solo I will listen to, anyone else who tries just isn't comparable.

[@kevinnewsom9055]

I fuckin love this guitar solo…best ever ever

[@kevinnewsom9055]

Dave is a genuine genius gentleman…

[@dabeez68]

I agree with you... it's a great solo. I'm a sucker for the minor chords.

[@KyleDabour]

RESPECT!!

[@FinalBoys1982]

I’ve been all over the world for concerts, raves, super clubs, secret clubs, underground raves, sacred music, list is endless. Last week I saw The Eagles at the Sphere and Adele at the Coliseum in Vegas. I’ve been inside Bergain in Berlin Coocoon at Amnesia in Ibiza. All amazing but no comparison. This is on another level. It was the best concert I’ve ever attended in my entire life. I know already nothing will ever come close to it. Thanks for sharing.

[@budi22]

im also into electronic music, but this is something else. ive been to berlin, ibiza, london, barcelona, but nothing touch a heart as much as this!

[@BudsnSuds420]

I was at MSG Nov 6 for this. It was pure bliss. Spiritual experience 🎸

[@lisadavie5282]

That was how I felt in 1994, My very first Concert 1994 Pink Floyd Division Bell Pasadena CA at the Rose Bowl the 1st Night. I was only 15 years old. My Boomer Hippie Parents Took me and my Twin sister. I'm 46 now an saw David on this Luck & Strange Rare Tour. I flew from SF to LA for a Reunion Mom & Sisters (RIP Daddy),to see Gilmour his style his tones authentic genuine real deal, at the Intuit Dome ❤ so happy I Did! It still can't compare this NY MSG solo section SHREDDED L.A. but nothing can compare to Seeing the massive production only by PF division bell Tour aka "Pulse" someone took years over 10 years to work on Audio/Video to recreate the concert experience and He Posted it here on KZbin Look for it it is incredible! Any music fan will appreciate it. April 1994 Pink Floyd Pasadena CA unreal ❤ "Music Is THE BEST" FZ

[@ptb351]

So glad I saw the Div Bell tour as well. I have seen plenty of concerts over the years, and as I tell everybody, there is Pink Floyd, and then there is everybody else. David Gilmour is simply amazing. I would have loved to see him again, but I haven't been able to make it work.@@lisadavie5282

[@optimusminimus-v3d]

I saw the Beatles in Manchester.

[@Justmyopinion761]

Saw him last night. I’m literally still in a trance. It was a million times better than I ever thought it could be

[@Cavernous.Coyote]

That is amazing

[@jrob8931]

Just listening to a song I have been listening to since I was 9 years old. 45 years later, I am in my garage in tears listening to this time travel magic. Wow.

[@Blackscorpion1963]

Excellent comment. Know the feeling, I too have cried listening to this timeless classic and more than once...I was fortunate to see Pink Floyd at Wembley Stadium London on Saturday August 6th 1988. I was on my O.E. [overseas experience] from New Zealand, aged 24 and bulletproof...until the next morning lol. To this day the gig remains easily the greatest I have ever been to, and I've seen Dire Straits, U2, Tina Turner, and Cold Chisel all outdoor stadium gigs. The lighting show blew my mind. So far ahead of its time technologically. Hard to put into words tbh. One of the reasons I cried listening to Comfortably Numb is I connected and understood it is because I had my near-death motorcycle accident in 1990 here in New Zealand and suffered horrific life-threatening injuries and my entire left leg was amputated as high as hip and pelvis. Lost count of the number of operations and surgeries I have had in my life. If you'd like to see pics I took from the '88 Pink Floyd gig please click here to my Flickr webpage: www.flickr.com/photos/35707376@N00/29866632340/in/album-72157673246424191 Story of my ND motorcycle accident is here on Flickr: www.flickr.com/photos/35707376@N00/50871667398/in/album-72157713681398176 My sporting career here on Flickr: www.flickr.com/photos/35707376@N00/51986446472/in/album-72157649716035656

[@phillipgriffin]

This also moves me to tears. I am not certain why. I love David Gilmour…

[@Ody196]

Stunning solo, probably the best of the tour!

[@MrPetrA3]

Yes! Wow. Parts like from Pulse DVD !!! Wow 😍 😊

[@marioandresquintero]

@@MrPetrA3yeahh!!! Seems like!! 🙌🙌🙌

[@heavymetal1330]

@@MrPetrA3pulse is pure perfection ♥️🙏🏻

[@lastchance8142]

There is nothing I can say to capture the elegance, the power, and the emotion that is a guitar in David Gilmour's hand. He is the GOAT.

[@johnstevens7438]

David Gilmore is a legend!!! 78 years old and performing night after night, absolutely incredible. @Chris, thank you for the incredible view, as close as I will get to seeing him live.

[@rickfrancis5480]

Me too !

[@RomainBeydon-g1z]

i was there the same night, flew from France specially for this. Unforgettable indeed.

[@mbrenes26]

@Chris, just wanted to give a massive thank you! As someone who's hit the 50-year mark, I never thought I’d get the chance to experience David Gilmour like this. Your incredible view brought me closer to a legend I’ve admired for years. It means the world to feel that connection again-truly unforgettable!

[@cws8250]

My pleasure indeed

[@rajeshkaran7800]

At 78 , Mr David Jon Gilmour is Still The COOLEST Looking Dude for me👍❤🍁

[@bohdansydorchak]

I was there🫶🏻 now I can die in piece 🥰

[@joeyk9578]

Good for you.

[@vladimird5280]

I envy you god damn.... Good for you mate

[@0xBenR]

Hopefully in one piece

[@davidcammilleri5526]

I have studied this solo for 20 years. Memorized every note. But seeing this live is incredible. Our rock stars are getting old. This is a treat seeing this video. David Gilmour to me is the greatest EVER! Jimi was almost tied for first. Such a treat!

[@gregbbrooks]

That second solo was the best i have heard. Amazing. Amd i saw him in Rome but wow. He is getting better! Come back in 2025 tour dates please!!

[@jfayiii]

He can definitely deal. Sorrow was magnificent.

[@lukephillips6571]

He was very rusty early on, but was on fire at MSG. I saw him Monday, and he was in great form.

[@santoshsundaresan5371]

Absolutely agree. Saw him 3 times in Rome, but he is just getting better and better with every gig. Red hot form in the US.

[@rubberdog8763]

Age is a state of mind. And I think David Gilmour has kept a lot of us old folks quite young through his awesome music & I love seeing his talented family join him.👏🏼

[@benwitte8832]

THE MOST EMOTIVE GUITAR SOLO EVER WRITTEN. PERIOD.

[@begoodtoyourself2095]

WOW! What a view!! Thanks for sharing!

[@juliadyrda9772]

It's serious when you fall in love with 70 years old man, but more serious when you fall in love with his guitar 🥰🥰

[@tjh780]

Saw him last night at MSG. He’s absolutely phenomenal! I got to witness something very special!

[@bockwalla]

40 years old and every time I hear this song I remember when I was eight years old and my mom told me that the solo gives her goosebumps!

[@brucebukovics5827]

Fantastic! Thank you for posting this. While I love a good laser show, I love the close-up of him playing even more. With the seats that you had, you made the right decision to keep the focus on him.

[@lorrieannesilvey474]

I continue to love these guys for over 50 years now......I will love them even after I am gone🎉❤🎉

[@harrisonRL]

Great, GREAT video… the image clarity and sound quality, and how close a personal it felt… especially being able to watch every single string move and note played.

[@lisajones8730]

This was always my dream to my favorite guitarist/vocalist of all time but sadly, N.Y. was just too far away. Thank you to whoever recorded this ❤❤❤❤

[@____DARK_____]

Its like hearing this song for the first time.... God this was good... Davids Solos are Legendary...

[@mathewrussell926]

I was there on November 6th! Best sounding show I've ever been to!

[@Expatsunleashed]

Thank you for sharing your heavenly gift with the world David Gillmore.

[@janetcraft]

This performance - I nearly wept. Thank you Mr. Gilmour - I hope you will be knighted soon. Thank you Chris Sides for this upload :)

[@jenndavin]

All I can do these days is sob with joy that I lived during the life of David Gilmour. This song kept me alive throughout my college years and is now just etched on the pleasure centers of my brain. Thank you, David Gilmour.

[@Constantius-XI]

Tremendous respect for one of the greatest musicians ever! David Gilmour, thank you so much!!!

[@rolandochapa5199]

This great gentleman here is 78 yrs old and still can jam like if he was in his 20s 30s his music will live for ever we all will be gone from this world but the music never long live rock and roll

[@jameswilliams4804]

I'm 54,and he's been a major staple in my music i go to for mood control.he sooths me when I'm upset,no more drugs..just a heavy dose of him is all I need..mood changed.

[@Pavel.Fomitchov]

I was there at this exact day! This finale was grandiose!

[@lizprovo3906]

Sounds fantastic. Worked the rust off. He’s truly inspiring.

[@Rufko]

Simply incredible. After a bit week start of this tour in Italy he got into great shape now. Really really impressive performance this way. And great video Chris Sides. So thanks you!!!

[@GaryA]

The man is absolutely amazing! I'm 2 months younger than David and of all the rock songs I grew up listening to, this is by far my favorite mostly because of his guitar solo. He hasn't lost a beat in all these wonderful years. Love you David. Keep on keepin' on.

[@jwhitts]

Thank you for uploading this. I have never had the chance to see Mr G as close as this and after a cancer diagnosis, probably never will. This has been amazing and given me a much needed boost. Amazing show, you’re so lucky to have had such a great seat!

[@jimmystecher5214]

I wish this show would have come to Minnesota. David Gilmour is spectacular.

[@cryptosecuritytools]

Im not ashamed to say that guitar solo brought tears to me eyes

[@hendersg2007]

was there, unbelievable and awesome. Incredible performance. David you are the best of all time!

[@rasputin1309]

The joy he brings - thanks for posting this. I was lucky enough to see him in Rome, (from much further back) - the sound quality there was the best I've ever heard at a concert

[@MattonicAndLime]

Best filming yet I have seen on this tour. Thank you so much.

[@MichaelEMJAYARE]

THANK YOU folks for giving amazing up close shots like this. Insane. Wow.

[@gustavoromerohr]

Woao!!!! 😮, What a great privilege it has been to have enjoyed this concert in the front row!!! I am very grateful to you for having recorded this video, this song has two heartbreaking guitar solos that are some of the ones I have liked the most in my life, and you have allowed me to enjoy them completely. Thank Youuuuuuu

[@Dub96]

I saw him the 29th at the Hollywood bowl! Absolutely incredible!

[@blisser]

Every time I hear it, I'm mesmerized by the warmth it transmits through its sound. Thank you for existing

[@pierorossi1961]

the best solo of the tour, amazing!!!!

[@ArmandoLiBovi-op8qp]

the best solo of the tour!!!! I was in Rome but He wasn't so stunnig during this song...This time absolutely fantastic!!!

[@stevedgolfer]

Cashing in 🤑 standard 2024 greed

[@thecanberean]

The dude is 78! Flipping Heck. Still brings tears to my eyes. Unbelievable.

[@STRONGASTHUNDER]

This song will be played 100 years from now on Earth. Im so fortunate to have grown up and listened to Pink Floyd!! People before and after will never know just How incredible Pink Floyd was and how insane incredible David Gilmour was. He will be a legend for many moons.... Thank you David for the guitar solos! You are a Rock Star!!!

[@therustyduck5400]

HOW? just....HOW? Amazing, the man is the best there is, period!

[@jspack71]

Favorite solo from my favorite band of all time, thank you David!!!!

[@iankerr6977]

Still makes me want to cry even after these decades, goat at work folks,

[@jonlejcar5306]

I flew in from Chicago and was on the floor in front of the sound board. Holy. Fuck.

[@kennykaufman8263]

And this doesn’t even begin to capture what it was like being in the garden that night. Although it is a wonderful close-up of Gilmore, the garden was on fire with holographic laser beams blasting up into the rafters. Yeah, I was there, and I forgot to breathe for about eight minutes during this David Gilmour is a grandmaster. Nothing more to say. Except Thank you for posting this

[@fbek]

This is the best solo of this tour

[@eastsussexbeesandwildlife5801]

That was brilliant, thanks for posting. Hope no one tries to take this down!

[@osco50]

I saw him on Halloween at the Hollywood Bowl a few weeks ago, he and the band were completely on-point. Easily one of the best live shows I've ever seen.. Long live David Gilmour!

[@lockhartflawse1225]

That's about the best close up film of him playing those sols that I have seen. Thanks a lot.

[@BradBurge-b4f]

I was just to the left of this recording, what an amazing experience! Thanks for posting!!!! I would to get a copy of this!

[@lisadavie5282]

Thank You! 🙏💗😭 To whomever Posted and recorded this! Loves! David G has a special Sauce The Shredding and the JOY on his face when he starts diggin In. I am about as obsessed with Guitar solos and hearing subtle changes hearing him let it Rip gawdamn I wish he was my dad... He Is a Guitar GOD to me, for me i can't find words but he is My Favorite! So lucky and grateful I saw the LA "intuit dome" show, the Clippers venue is a venue is a venue its about who fills in the Space and how they create holding space, music is shapes playing sacred geometry and David Gilmour Wow! He is a diamond on Fire!

[@lupeduarte6149]

I’ve watched every video in KZbin of this solo, in this tour, and this one wow, was phenomenal!!!! And for me, The best solo of the tour definitely!! 😍🥰😍🥰😍🔥

[@billlambert2092]

Thank you so much for shooting and posting this - exceptionally well done! I saw him a few days later from the back, and I kept wishing the main camera would focus only on him and his hands. As mush as I like the other musicians, straying from him during these pivotal times starts to become frustrating. You showed us exactly why we were all there. Truly well done!

[@Omarillion]

thanks for sharing, in the first line! 👏👏👏👏

[@bassbob5]

I was there on the 4th ...amazing Show!

[@jfayiii]

As was I - no one has a view like this from that show however.

[@MiguelGarcia-jr2mw]

Wow, super quality of sound and image, so nice to see a fixed plane of him playing this solo. He is in his own world. What a gift this is. Thank you for uploading this.

[@chrisradzion2148]

Amazing. Thank you for sharing this. I can’t remember seeing such a clear video of him playing. It’s like getting the solo playing tutorial from the man himself.

[@TMAdventuresT7]

Grew up with Floyd having older brothers, watched them at Wembley in 88, never will you witness a formidable performance as good as this, word I’m looking for is (Spiritual) TYFS 🙏🏼

[@wakingcreative]

Thank you for the front row seat! I was about 50 rows back; this is glorious 🙏🙏

[@heavymetal1330]

THE GOAT! He is not playing a fender he is playing his heart… you can see that… the strings are the arteries.

[@benclaase8181]

What an awesome tour/concert. Was there on Tuesday 11/5 , loved every second of it! Thank you David Gilmour and band and the entire crew who made this possible!

[@davedonnellyphotography3858]

Thanks for posting, amazing to see those fingers just crushing that solo.

[@rallew-arp5020]

Wonderfull! @chris Thanks for sharing this masterpiece and by the way excellently filmed!

[@blackirontarkus9]

I was there that night and I totally understand why we were told to live in the moment and not record. But I couldn't help it. I've watched these live recordings on KZbin for well over 15-20 years now, and I finally have one of my own, that no one can ever take down.

[@henrysmiley5878]

I was lucky to be able to attend two of David's shows at Madison Square Garden: the first (Nov. 4) and this one. The first show set an extremely high bar, but the show you've captured here was even better. David played like a man possessed the entire show. So glad to I finally got to see Mr. Gilmour live.

[@michaelmahar4066]

The stuff of gods right here. Pure actual magic. Thank you for filming, great job. I was there and this re confirms my feelings on the night of the show that I had just seen something otherworldly.

[@MissJLovek]

Your spot was the best spot!!! I was at this show and I’m still obsessed with having had the experience … thank you for this amazing video so I can relive it close up!! ❤❤❤

[@bretsigler7324]

Phenomenal recording 👍saw him recently at the Hollywood Bowl. You did this justice. Brought tears to my eyes.

[@richguerin]

I was there, 12th row. Such a great show. Thanks for sharing

[@RafaelAbiSaber]

Thanks for the recording

[@JeffersonDD]

I was at this show, and then another one of the Hollywood Bowl shows. It was an epic two shows. Thanks for capturing this

[@harwoods11]

We all get exactly what we expect with Daves performances over the years 👍❤️

[@werbeboard]

One of the coolest guitarist ever. Great Great Job!!

[@matthewweaver7805]

Best video ever of Gilmour in action.

[@DarrenS58]

I was lucky enough to be at this show in Rome at the Circus Maximus last month. I'm 55, have been going to concerts since I was 12, and this was easily one of, if not THE best performance I've ever seen and heard. Such an incredible moment in time - I had goosebumps, and my eyes were watering, and I know I wasn't the only one who felt it that way. I still do as I'm typing this.

[@blacksun691]

Soy de Argentina y realmente lo necesito a David para vivir ♥️🇦🇷

[@mikeclancy4956]

Thank You so much for this, saw them in 1987 and this song only gets better with age!!

[@klaas6681]

There are only two artists that can convey emotion through a guitar on superhuman level: Prince and this man, David Gilmoure.

[@jfayiii]

I agree on both - pure emotion.

[@juletraylor5829]

there's was another, his name is Stevie ray vaughn...

[@michaeldemarco899]

Have you ever listened to Gary Moore? He’s another one

[@superslug1000]

78 years old. Still the best guitarist in the world today. No one beats him

[@PaulJAMES-o6o]

Flew in from Toronto for the Nov 4 show what a concert and seeing him play this just wow!

[@erANMILK23]

Insane! so much quality, so smooth

[@Erik-rp1hi]

I saw him just 2 weeks ago at the Hollywood Bowl. Same set I'm sure. It was a fantastic concert.

[@KevinFreedman-jl2bv]

Me too, I was at the 10/30/24 show. I’m 62 glad I went

[@podxtv]

What a seat ! Thanks for posting such a great quality video

[@just_another_lazy_guy]

Thanks for posting this. You did an amazing job keeping the camera focused on David throughout the solo. I have been miserable for not being able to afford to buy tickets. I felt so much better after watching this. Thanks again.

[@Prog-t9d]

Brilliant artist

[@mickconnor7929]

That fn awesome!! Ty so much for posting this!❤

[@santoshsundaresan5371]

Saw him three nights in Rome, and seen many bootleg videos on CN on this tour. This is definitely one of the best versions. He looks to be in sizzling form in the States. Forget his age for a second, this playing is phenomenal at any age. Kudos to you for capturing this, and also the quality of audio on this upload is great!