Commander Cards We Disagree On

  Рет қаралды 25,039

Nitpicking Nerds

Nitpicking Nerds

Күн бұрын

Пікірлер: 214
@ttv_beefchild5967
@ttv_beefchild5967 2 ай бұрын
1. Mia 2. Mia 3. Beezy 4. Mia 5. Mia 6. Mia 7. Mia 8. Mia 9. Beezy 10. Mia 11. Mia 12. Mia 13. Mia 14. Mia 15. Mia 16. Mia Wow, Beezy you got crushed.
@DeadBeatDanny
@DeadBeatDanny 2 ай бұрын
Tribute to Horobi like whaaaaat 😂
@wdeborde
@wdeborde 2 ай бұрын
Creeping Bloodsucker in Obeka, Splitter of Seconds has ended games by itself several times for me. Love that little nerd.
@timmccrthy
@timmccrthy 2 ай бұрын
This one was definitely a Mia win.
@adarklight505
@adarklight505 2 ай бұрын
Also one of the best vampires in my Strephan deck.
@isidoreaerys8745
@isidoreaerys8745 2 ай бұрын
Same with Dragon Caster Outcast. Just made 5 Dragons off one combat trigger and ended the game. Clearly Mia needs to build an Obeka Deck
@lucasnjtube
@lucasnjtube 2 ай бұрын
I loled hard at Mia's impression of Beezy giving her crap for running Approach.
@AugustAMcClung
@AugustAMcClung 2 ай бұрын
Hot take… I have seen two cards in this debate that both slap in my Obeka, Splitter of Seconds deck…Dragonmaster Outcast and Creeping Bloodsucker. I say this not because I think they are good in general but because I think most cards have a home. Personally, I enjoy decks were you can play off-beat cards and they become really good. I would encourage you to instead of poo pooing a card, instead find where it slaps.
@DeadBeatDanny
@DeadBeatDanny 2 ай бұрын
I’m trying to pull together Obaka too bc I know those cards would be BUSTED but truly Dragonmaster Outcast is a fat stinker without Obeka imo. Even in lands matter decks from what I’ve played with it in LWG
@edwinb.140
@edwinb.140 2 ай бұрын
Agreed, in casual games I would much rather play a flavor or pet card than the absolute sweatiest card possible in most scenarios.
@edwinb.140
@edwinb.140 2 ай бұрын
Plus, I like finding a home for some of my power crept old cards from years past, especially those obscure old cards that a lot of newer players have never seen. Always brings a smile to my face.
@PirateMaster45
@PirateMaster45 2 ай бұрын
I play Creeping Bloodsucker in my Teysa, Opulent Oligarch EDH. Mainly because it helps trigger Teysa's ability at the end step. I play some other pingers in the deck too, like Sheperd of Rot
@kennethgardner5495
@kennethgardner5495 2 ай бұрын
I play Creeping Bloodsucker in both Obeka and Vamps.
@TelesphoreArt
@TelesphoreArt 2 ай бұрын
Mia 1, Beezy 0 at 2:50 for cutting off the chef, they were cooking and he couldn't handle the heat. lolol I love this content from you two! haha Fun stuff!
@TelesphoreArt
@TelesphoreArt 2 ай бұрын
Her face, lol!!! Disqualified Beezy.
@EasilySuede
@EasilySuede 2 ай бұрын
Yes, this, exactly this!! NN disagreeing is what originally drew me to this channel, this is the chewy content I love.
@thekillers1stfan
@thekillers1stfan 2 ай бұрын
Vorinclex is awesome! 5 mana for a 6/6 is already decent, 5 mana for a 6/6 with trample and reach is above decent, 5 mana for all of that plus it gifts you two lands to build up to the transform cost where the Saga on the back is not only insane but also returns him back to the battle instead of throwing him in the trash is AMAZING. I don't know how you can argue for that compass and not love Vorinclex
@isidoreaerys8745
@isidoreaerys8745 2 ай бұрын
Plus his Saga is Unconditional unlike the other Double-faced Praetors which all say “wait! Fill up opponents graveyard/fill up your hand/sacrifice 3 creatures/cast 3 instants or sorceries.” He literally gives you the ramp you need to cruise right into dropping a free Nyxbloom Ancient and a Vorinclex Voice of Hunger on the next turn.
@janderson9413
@janderson9413 2 ай бұрын
Creeping Bloodsucker on turn 3 means you can still pay for Sorin's extort, which will flip him. You don't have to wait until the upkeep. It's also 3 more damage his -1 will do if you use it.
@johndolan21
@johndolan21 2 ай бұрын
True Conviction wins me games in my Anikthea deck. It’s usually free and the guys it buffs usually have menace.
@benjamintrottier2855
@benjamintrottier2855 2 ай бұрын
In a mono red deck, you have to play chaos warp WITH wild magic surge. It's not a "one or the other" situation. Like you guys said, you have to answer to more stuff that red isn't good at handling like enchantments
@donovancombs2622
@donovancombs2622 2 ай бұрын
Very much agreed. However, literally as soon as you're out of mono red you don't want this. Even in Rakdos you don't want it almost ever.
@Bedni87
@Bedni87 2 ай бұрын
7:29 wow I had no Idea Beezy talks with such voice. thanks Mia for sharing
@valgeir80
@valgeir80 2 ай бұрын
1: Roadside is solid. If you don't prepare for the late game, that's where you will lose. Obviously, play it in an fitting deck. 2: Bala Ged works. Has better alternatives. 3: Some Planeswalkers are good. The arguement that it's no better than a sorcery is flawed. Because, multiple activations are possible, and it requires a resource to remove. 4: Wild magic. Only worthy in mono red. 5: End festivites is underrated: You will realize once you play it. 6. Gwafa is weak. Upside is tiny compared to downside. Not only can bribed creatures not attack you but your other opponents are spared as well. Not to mention, all this for a gifted card. 7. True conviction is GOOD. Never underestimate lifelink. When combat matters... it's excellent. 8. Creeping bloodsucker is a sleeper. Surprisingly good. Nothing hurts more than having to use resources to get rid of a common 2 drop. but believe me, your opponents will want to once they realize its value. 9. Journey to eternity. I mean... is your commander getting targeted? Will you recast it for the 2 tax? Would you like a reanimate land? Say no more. 10. Quicksmith.. In the right deck.. maybe. If you're relying on a filter, your deck is prob. lame anyway. Lame-not fun. 11. Tribute. How much is "lost" from a 2 mana investment? No one is going to remove it.. So you will end up with a 3/3. Not great but not as bad as Mia says. 12. Dragonmaster.. Rarely amounts to anything. 13. Thaumatic compass. Have to agree with Mia. Expensive stinker. At best a late game Maze of Ith. pass. 14. Tezzeret. Has better alternatives. As mentioned Tezzeret Seeker. 15. Meteor golem. Spot on analysis from Mia. 16. Vorinclex. Two words. Value and Utility. Very worthy.
@jonathanstead5135
@jonathanstead5135 2 ай бұрын
In meteor golem's defense, Daretti, scrap savant sees it as cheap universal removal.
@anathema7813
@anathema7813 2 ай бұрын
Looved this vid so much, love the disagreements, they make killer episodes and some funny moments haha. They actually make me think about mechanics and the game in a bunch of different ways, helps with cutting and adding cards!
@baconsir1159
@baconsir1159 2 ай бұрын
Even the failstate of Garruk Primal Hunter is Soul’s Majesty
@nilsjonsson4446
@nilsjonsson4446 2 ай бұрын
Yes! "Glorified sorcery", sure, but I play sorceries
@Slynch25
@Slynch25 2 ай бұрын
It's actually marginally better than Soul's Majesty even. If somebody blows up your biggest creature in response to Garruk's ability, you'll still draw cards equal to the next biggest creature you control where Soul's Majesty would fizzle.
@MrMaharg79
@MrMaharg79 2 ай бұрын
And would you ever play Soul's Majesty in the year of our lord 2024? I wouldn't even have played that card in 2014...
@isidoreaerys8745
@isidoreaerys8745 2 ай бұрын
I’m so sick of Garruk Cursed Huntsman. I cannot beat that card in a 1v1 the value it gains each turn is unstoppable
@mehra6712
@mehra6712 2 ай бұрын
I think I agree with Mia because bala ged recovery is green, and green is the ramp enabler color, that makes this mdfc just fine in a 5 color deck. This will cast you your three visits/nature's lore/skyshroud claim etc to find you your duals and triomes, or cast your bloomtender
@TelesphoreArt
@TelesphoreArt 2 ай бұрын
With Beezy 34:30 Taking up mental space of multiple players can be the benefit as well. Also two mana for a 3/3 flyer is awesome also!
@kv2315
@kv2315 2 ай бұрын
6/6 vigilance trample for 4 mana is actually not bad Thaumatic Compass is really not great… id rather put in some crappy 2 cost mana rock that enters tapped before i would play that
@crawdaddy1234
@crawdaddy1234 2 ай бұрын
Mia - have you looked at Naya Charm for Ramos? If not, try that over Bala Ged Recovery.
@codecap703
@codecap703 2 ай бұрын
I would replace one of the witnesses first due to the two green pips in 5 color.
@crawdaddy1234
@crawdaddy1234 2 ай бұрын
@@codecap703 Remember that Ramos gets counters for each color in the casting cost. And you can’t blink instants/sorceries.
@TheY0shi08
@TheY0shi08 2 ай бұрын
I started playing True Conviction in my Birds deck not expecting much of it, but it surprised me in the few times I've drawn it, especially since not only helps me push extra damage from my mediocre birds, which have evasion but lack in power (even if I do run some anthem effects and Moonshaker) but it also gives me extra combat damage procs for Kastral (I tried the card because of this, before I was on Ishai+Esior and didn't run it) which is really nice
@Yangblaze11
@Yangblaze11 2 ай бұрын
i agree that you should be playing true conviction in flying heavy in white that uses creature.
@richardpennertz8180
@richardpennertz8180 2 ай бұрын
Roadside Reliquary: slightly favors Mia, but certainly playable in certain decks Bala Ged Recovery: Mia wins hands-down Planeswalkers: Beezy wins Wild Magic Surge: slightly favors Mia End the Festivities: slightly favors Beezy, but his non-synergy plays? 🤨 Gwafa Hazid: slightly favors Beezy, but it's not unplayably bad True Conviction: Mia wins Creeping Bloodsucker: Mia wins handily; no idea why Beezy doesn't like it Journey to Eternity: Has Mia ever seen this get played? It's such an awesome card and can basically win games on its own! Beezy wins by a mile. (Plus, it's Legendary, so it's even better in my Yoshimaru deck!) Quicksmith Genius: slightly favors Beezy, but it's fine Tribute to Horobi: Beezy wins this one; there are *so many* cards that synergize with this and so many ways your opponents can make it good for you Dragonmaster Outcast: Beezy wins Thaumatic Compass: I think I'm neutral. It's not good, but the payoff (for a minimal investment) is probably worth it in slower games. Tezzeret, Artifice Master: with the specific synergies Mia has, she'll win this one; most of the time, it is trash Meteor Golem: Beezy wins; there are a lot of builds that can repeat the ETB on this Vorinclex: slightly favors Beezy Mia: 3 strong wins, 3 narrow wins Beezy: 5 strong wins, 4 narrow wins After coming out of the gate pretty strong, Mia came up with a lot of dubious and even bad takes. Beezy managed to win.
@ItzBones
@ItzBones 2 ай бұрын
1. Mia 2. Mia 3. Beezy 4. Mia 5. Beezy 6. Beezy 7. Beezy 8. Mia 9. Beezy 10. Mia 11. Mia 12. Mia 13. Beezy 14. Beezy 15. Mia 16. Mia Ended up being pretty close
@QuartzGolem
@QuartzGolem 2 ай бұрын
She's 100% right on roadside reliquary, even in budget it's meh.
@yocpo2568
@yocpo2568 Ай бұрын
I used to run True Conviction in my knights tribal deck. I switched it for Duelist's Heritage and found that it served me way better. It's only 2 and a white. It only gives double strike to a single creature but you can also use it on your opponents attack phase to make some politics with it and to give one of their creature double strike at the cost of attacking someone else. Don't get me wrong, True Conviction is a beast but I do agree that it feels a little bit win-more in some cases.
@rocknrolla7288
@rocknrolla7288 2 ай бұрын
1. Roadside seems fine, war room is better tho. If you got some land death and GY synergies like delirium, it gets better. - Mia 2. Bala Ged should be fine, if the mana base works apart from it. There is an argument to be had for a more flexible and/or cheaper version instead of this that isn´t a land. - Tie 3. Planeswalkers need to be protected and are great then. BUT if the floor is a glorified sorcery and that is decent for your deck? That is absolutely fine too. Most of them fulfill that anyway. - Beezy 4. Surge seems odd, but should be mostly fine, especially in mid level pods where card quality varies. Bonus for flexibility. - Mia 5. Festivities, i think there should be better versions. Id like to pay 2 mana but get flexibility / pyroclasm. Might be meta call too. - Mia 6. Gwafa - He is HILARIOUS, even if you don´t want to give away cards. The politics. I love it in socrates, needs politics. - Mia 7. True convictions slaps in the right deck. Depends on the synergies. - Beezy 8. I don´t know about bloodsucker. If your deck is heavy stax and needs a slow wincon? Or vampires ok, but Edgar is lame in general. Eminence suuux. Depends on the deck probably. - Tie 9. Journey is great. Needs sac synergies to prevent swords to plowshares. At worst, three to protect, gives ramp and recursion if needed. - Beezy 10. Quicksmith is LETHAL in eggs, goes insane with salvaging station. He dumb good. - Mia 11. Tribute is really cool in grismold and similar decks. A bit wonky on its own. But still ok if you have death triggers. Really cheap too. - Beezy 12. Dragonmaster seems really good, never did anything in my decks. Overall not that great. - Beezy. 13. Compass is slow, needs the right deck direly. Ith is insane, no ith slander. Maze needs to be played with urborg and yavimaya. - Tie 14. Tezz is an absolute bomb. Draws, protects itself, searches. Seeker is mostly better tho. - Mia 15. Meteor golem is fine. Bit expensive. - Beezy 16. Hes a bit shit for such an important card. But absolutely playable. - Tie
@CalHoskins
@CalHoskins 2 ай бұрын
Has Mia considered Beacon of Unrest for her Door deck?
@JoshuaPantalleresco
@JoshuaPantalleresco 2 ай бұрын
Compass does work. It's surprisingly dirps around under the radar. I like it in decks that need voltron defense. It's not perfect, but it's good. I like that vorinclex too. I'm building selvala so I'll try it there.
@domsilvestri8681
@domsilvestri8681 2 ай бұрын
Bala Ged is so replaceable in 5 colors. Blue has sweet cards to copy artifacts like Mirrormade and Season of Weaving.
@isidoreaerys8745
@isidoreaerys8745 2 ай бұрын
Season of Weaving is a staple.
@Farmers-Almanac
@Farmers-Almanac 2 ай бұрын
I begrudgingly took a chance and added Wild Magic Surge to a couple of my decks about a month ago. It has really performed for me, and I actually love the card now.
@Farmers-Almanac
@Farmers-Almanac 2 ай бұрын
I will add that my personal goal with WMS is the target should at least be 4 mana value.
@sirloathing2028
@sirloathing2028 2 ай бұрын
This video was super cute, please do more like it y’all have good chemistry when you disagree on topics I (the viewer) care about.
@ZidaneTribal1989
@ZidaneTribal1989 2 ай бұрын
I agree with the person whose name is next to the card: 1. Roadside Reliquary: Mia 2. Bala Ged Recovery: Mia 3. Planewalkers: Mia 4. Wild Magic Surge: Mia 5. End the Festivities: Mia 6. Gwafa Hazid, Profiteer: Beezy 7. True Conviction: Mia 8. Creeping Bloodsucker: Mia 9. Journey to Eternity: Mia 10. Quicksmith Genius: Beezy 11. Tribute to Horobi: Mia 12. Dragonmaster Outcast: Beezy 13. Thaumatic Compass: Mia 14. Tezzeret, Artifice Master: Beezy 15: Meteor Golem: Mia 16: Vorinclex: Beezy Mia: 11 Beezy: 5 Mia likes to synergize and test to see what works. Beezy likes to do the silly things. Thumbs up for both but Mia wins this.
@jmanwild87
@jmanwild87 2 ай бұрын
I will say that Mia is sleeping on Journey to Eternity. In a mid power deck this is basically a protection spell a ramp spell if you're able to kill the thing yourself and a reanimation spell when you're low on cards is some nutty role compression. I know I'd want it in something like my Indoraptor Perfect Hybrid deck because that deck has an issue of running out of gas and Indoraptor is a massive terrifying target when this deck goes off. Or my Muldrotha deck really wants permanent based reanimation and protection.
@crawdaddy1234
@crawdaddy1234 2 ай бұрын
“Meteor Golem” more like “MEDIUM Golem”! 😂
@LordDrieg
@LordDrieg 2 ай бұрын
Roadside Reliquary is a card I've SEEN used well, but never managed to pull off the draw two personally. However, this looks like an amazing card to try in my Burakos/Guild Artisan Treasures deck! I'll always have access to both artifacts and at least one enchantment thanks to my commanders so the lost of one land may not weigh so heavily come mid-game or late game. Gotta give it a shot!
@obadijahparks
@obadijahparks 2 ай бұрын
10:59 lolith?.... L "long O" Lth.
@JushakF
@JushakF 23 күн бұрын
I like End The Festivities for Judith, Carnage Connosseur. She turns the card into completely one-sided boardwipe.
@crisgon9552
@crisgon9552 2 ай бұрын
Journey to Eternity in my Tasigur deck has won me so many games. It ramps in a way and I have lot of etb affects. It's nutty in a healthy way
@alexandermeyer7258
@alexandermeyer7258 2 ай бұрын
Mia is definitely sleeping on this card. Sure the rate once might be a little high, but the repeatability is the real power. I love it in my Old Stickfingers and Coram The Undertaker
@hanschristopherson8056
@hanschristopherson8056 2 ай бұрын
I like that nitpicking nerds episodes are now podcast length also love the cards we disagree on series
@Nomy7735
@Nomy7735 2 ай бұрын
i won a game once with the emrakual the promised end "i take your next turn" and they have a door on the battlefield and i killed them with their own door
@codythomas5913
@codythomas5913 2 ай бұрын
caveat for tribute to horobi: i play it in massacre girl known killer and the rats usually die instantly to auto -1/-1 effects so it's just boatloads of drawing.. and then i get a 3/3 flying haste with wither.
@KristopherBush
@KristopherBush 2 ай бұрын
Love the dueling ideas. It helps me think about the cards in different angles.
@Beckola44
@Beckola44 2 ай бұрын
Roadside Reliquary is ok at best. I like End The Festivities and Creeping Bloodsucker. While some of the other cards have some good abilities, the casting cost is too high. Thank you for the video Mia and Beezy.
@marcoottina654
@marcoottina654 2 ай бұрын
1) Roadside Reliquary needs a lot of artifacts and enchantments, not just a bunch, like, 10/15 of each. Otherwise it's kind of useless. So, mostly no. 2) Bala ... You need bouncelands to get that land back and yse the front side. Yes, the option is good, but you'll end up losing a good card without thise juicy way to bounce lands back. 3?) End of Festivity is awesome in Taii Wakeen, Perfect Shot : it might be a Blasphemous Act but costing a few cents 4) I like True Conviction BUT if I could build somewhat of an army, plan to attack or block a lot AND have ways to reduce its casting cost. 5) Creeping Bloodsucker is awesome in my 60-card upkeep-focused Esper deck. Followed Steps, Paradox Haze, Extravagant Replication, the snow artifact ring that clone itself ... This kind of deck. 6) Im with Beezy about Journey to Eternity: you need a build around, like ALL cards shown there, but in lot-of-mana-producing-stuff deck that card is awesome
@jordanlarson8310
@jordanlarson8310 2 ай бұрын
Mia and Beezy are gonna use marriage counseling to air out MTG arguments lol
@JohnOConnell-u9o
@JohnOConnell-u9o 2 ай бұрын
Disagree on dragon master outcast. I play it in my Obuun deck. Is a strong post wrath recovery card, especially with another drop.
@markkolodziej496
@markkolodziej496 2 ай бұрын
Every time I have seen Tribute to Horobi it slapped. My friend plays it in Kambal, so you have to hold a sweeper ready to answer it.
@riverswater5688
@riverswater5688 2 ай бұрын
Typing this list as I go: Round 1. Mia 2. Mia 3. Beezy 4. Draw 5. Beezy 6. Draw 7. Mia 8. Beezy 9. Mia Last vote was for Journey to eternity. Had to stop watching and start my day :)
@erictaupier3479
@erictaupier3479 2 ай бұрын
I love Dragonmaster Outcast in Ghired, Mirror of the Wilds. Not only do you get a 5/5 on the upkeep, but Ghired can tap that turn to make a second 5/5 and the dragonmaster can tap for a third 5/5. Any additional nontoken creatures you have already is just bonus. The Dragonmaster has to survive 1 turn, but if unanswered, will make a huge board with Ghired.
@Npocommander
@Npocommander 2 ай бұрын
Planeswalkers are good attack distractions
@demolisherman1763
@demolisherman1763 2 ай бұрын
I love seeing how much fun you two have in the intro
@ServbotNumba40
@ServbotNumba40 2 ай бұрын
1. There is already a true horizon land at colorless, 3 mana is too much even late to maybe get 2 cards but likely get 1. An opponent could spite kill your 1 enchantment when this happens or worse both, meaning you tappes 3 mana for nothing. For the same reason as you gave recovery later. "How often do you..." draw 2 with this. There are better options. 2. BGR is one of the MDFCs i would say is an auto include in any deck that can run it. Likely you need high concentration of green lands just for ramp, and when you don't you get recollect on the front side. No downside. In her deck there aren't may cards have the versatility. There are some regrowth effects that only hit permanents that cost less. 3. I dont think any card type is worse than any other. A good card is a good card. I usually only play the ones that are on my theme... or Ashiok, they can get it. 4. WMS is fine, there are so many enchantments that just hoze some of my strategies (specifically in my dragonstorm deck) hitting a RIP or LeyVoid is crucial. 5. Don't let you memes stay dreams. 6. Gwafa seems bad, there are better options. Even if its just more protection for you utility creatures so they can block. 7. 3www is so much, Akromas will isnt enough? Moonshaker Cavalry 8. Creeping bloodsucker is a role player. I play this in Belbe specifically to get a trigger without having to go to combat.
@brendanleuthner4851
@brendanleuthner4851 2 ай бұрын
Beezy: "it's good late game!" Mia: "I'm trying to win before then" Aren't we all?? 😂
@yannickcollin8542
@yannickcollin8542 2 ай бұрын
1: Mia, can't stand that drawback.... 2:Mia, but close. 3:draw 4:Beezy 5:Mia 6:Beezy 7:Beezy 8:Beezy 9:Mia 10:Beezy 11:Mia 12:Beezy 13:Mia 14:Beezy 15:Mia 16:Mia
@tlash02
@tlash02 2 ай бұрын
What modifications would you make to the oracle text of highly played or banned cards to make them better, more fair, more chaotic, etc?
@henlohenlo689
@henlohenlo689 2 ай бұрын
one of my favorites is ovika, enigma goliath. i use it with shark typhoon. kiora bests the sea god. fireball. fanning the flames. crackle with power. so basically if i cast fireball for 7 total mana. i can create a 7/7 flyer token AND 7 1/1 tokens. it can snowball pretty hard in the late game. if smaller spells for earlier game still they can generate alot of tokens and pressure early on. since they are goblins cards like goblin grenade and shrapnel blast can add value.
@isidoreaerys8745
@isidoreaerys8745 2 ай бұрын
Ashnods altar and the goblin who sacs other goblins to make red mana are my favorite cards to see in that deck
@TelesphoreArt
@TelesphoreArt 2 ай бұрын
37:52 is the greatest jump-scare of 2024
@RazgrizAce67
@RazgrizAce67 2 ай бұрын
27:53 "We don't have any reanimate creature lands" Tomb Fortress: Do I mean nothing to you Beezy??
@jakecarlson3709
@jakecarlson3709 2 ай бұрын
Hawkins national laboratory as well, although that one is a little bit restricted.
@meant09
@meant09 2 ай бұрын
I love dragon master outcast in my ghired deck. Almost never gets the dragon but when it does it’s perfect. When it doesn’t people freak out and waste removal on it giving ghired more chances to create other tokens
@jonathanpuccetti9258
@jonathanpuccetti9258 Ай бұрын
True conviction is great, it's an enchantress overrun. If you are getting combo killed it's not going to do much, but besides that it pretty much always gains you enough life to get another turn.
@obadijahparks
@obadijahparks 2 ай бұрын
You need a poll list of these cards to settle it once and for all.
@Poetristi
@Poetristi 2 ай бұрын
1. Mia 2. Mia 3. Mia 4. Beezy 5. Mia 6. Beezy 7. Mia 8. Mia 9. Mia 10. Beezy 11. Mia 12. Beezy 13. Mia 14. Beezy 15. Mia 16. Beezy
@gilchristmuir3171
@gilchristmuir3171 2 ай бұрын
Maybe Mia's Door Deck could be making copies of the Door itself rather than copying the triggers! Artificer Class and Stolen Identity are repeatable ways to copy it (and with Artificer Class you can set up the effect before casting the Door itself to get your first copy on the same end step). Three Steps Ahead is modal so can either copy the Door or counter a spell or draw cards - or all 3, Replication Technique has the 'demonstrate' keyword so can make more than one copy, Echo Storm can copy it for each time you've cast your commander. Mythos of Illuna could also get you a copy - and once you have copied the Door once, cards like Dutiful Replicator can copy any token to make more copies and Caretaker's Talent can draw you cards for each token while also giving another way to get a copy of a token for one mana... Door To Nothingness tribal anyone?
@caasIsirhC
@caasIsirhC 2 ай бұрын
I like Journey to Eternity! It's a culmination of parts. It's not the best protection, ramp, or recursion there is but it IS all three.
@chaserevstuning9271
@chaserevstuning9271 2 ай бұрын
Meteor golem is good in Zhulodok that cares about big mana color to cascade!
@lucarioman9097
@lucarioman9097 2 ай бұрын
That Narset is not a Planeswalker. It’s an enchantment that draws you 2 cards then dies to a token.
@JushakF
@JushakF 23 күн бұрын
Regarding True Conviction - I would actually feel the Lifelink would often be a downside for me. In my Judith, Carnage Connosseur deck I run Chain Reaction and Blasphemous Act. Last time I played the deck I ended up gaining to the north of 500 life with a Chain Reaction. The end result was that I did nothing else for most of the rest of the game because literally everything I played got shot down the second it hit the table because of the massive life lead. Had there been a combat-oriented commander in the pod, I would've likely died to commander damage long before my life total leveled off enough to stop people from solely focus-firing me. I feel True Conviction risks running to similar problems: you get a big swing off with it, don't win right away and the game turns into archenemy even if True Conviction ends up being removed. Of course different pods play differently - my pod usually tends to keep things in check to keep things interesting for everyone rather than quickly eliminating people.
@TelesphoreArt
@TelesphoreArt 2 ай бұрын
Love this because like people, every magic player is unique and brings their own perspective.
@Despresso-ht6ce
@Despresso-ht6ce Ай бұрын
Personally i play creeping bloodsucker in my mono black Mortarion deck as i want as much lifegain to turn it into lifeloss later on, so having it stick around even 2 or 3 turns it become 6 or 9 life that i can lose to turn it into 2/2 warriors with menace so it's quite neat
@TensyCL
@TensyCL 2 ай бұрын
Journey to Eternity. Just an interesting fact for you guys. When cEDH became a bit more developed and Flash/Hulk lines became dominant, the non-blue decks would play this card on their Protean Hulk, so yeah, it was cEDH playable at one point. This is before cards like Fake Your Own Death, Malakir Rebirth, etc. which would've immediately taken that spot at the time, because the backside is super weak imo, even in casual. Nowadays, if you can't abuse the fact that it is a also and Enchantment, then it's SO much weaker than the 1 mana options.
@loiul1
@loiul1 2 ай бұрын
It is true that for 5/6 mana you want things that will win th game so most planeswalkers are a bit weak but they are a constant threat and they take pressure from your life totalm its like a heal on top of their other effects.
@RoachDoggggJR
@RoachDoggggJR 2 ай бұрын
I like the idea of Tribute to Horobi in my Grismold deck, wouldn't jam it in a random deck though
@TheObstalace
@TheObstalace 2 ай бұрын
Beezy defending the worst phyrexian arena you have ever seen is actually great content!
@andrewfornes5320
@andrewfornes5320 2 ай бұрын
Not to diss your sponsors since they are helping you guys, but ordering from Cardkingdom gives me a similar experience of waiting for something to arrive as the people who lived in Westeros did. I know they are a company from the NW US, and I am from the SE US, but sometimes, they will have my order packaged & numbered but our slow post offices will get it to me in like 2.5 weeks.
@VladandJac
@VladandJac 2 ай бұрын
Mia’s mock voice about door to nothingness had me dead 😂
@nickzeiders5952
@nickzeiders5952 2 ай бұрын
True conviction can matter for decks that want to deal combat damage multiple times to multiple opponents. Its in my Kastral birds deck.
@konnmehameha
@konnmehameha 2 ай бұрын
End the festivities is insane In strefan precon, or any damage to opponents matters. Any noncombat doublers or triplers? Sweeps tokens.
@bmprosser
@bmprosser 2 ай бұрын
Mía wins the debate in this installment for sure but I’ve favored Beezy’s logic before this. I think it’s because of how Mia always talks his decks up (not a bad thing). In any case, more ppl need to do this exercise with a trusted other. We all put dumb stuff in our decks because they are our babies, and we need to be brought to reality.
@kapmasta
@kapmasta 2 ай бұрын
mia you should put pyretic rebirth in ramos, its two color instant recurs an artifact or creature and deals damage to a creature or planeswalker based on the returned permanents mana value
@d.a.d.-ohgosh
@d.a.d.-ohgosh 2 ай бұрын
Here's my list on who I agree with about what card. 1. Beezy 2. Mia 3. Beezy 4. Beezy 5. Mia 6. Beezy 7. Beezy 8. Beezy 9. Mia 10. Beezy 11. Mia 12. Beezy 13. Mia 14. Beezy 15. Mia 16. Mia Beezy: 9 Mia: 7 Winner imo is Beezy.
@groundswelllegitcoffeeandb3810
@groundswelllegitcoffeeandb3810 2 ай бұрын
In lieu of True Conviction or Moonshaker Cavalry, I like Serra’s Emissary and always choosing the card type “creatures”. All your creatures become unblockable and you don’t take combat damage from anyone else for as long as it’s in play. Also stops damage from certain creatures that deal direct damage like Niv-Mizzet. Also in lieu of meteor golem, I like bladegriff prototype. I just like political cards in general. Plus it costs 2 less mana. And reusable every turn. 😅 (*only for casual low power decks)
@Nick-ff4is
@Nick-ff4is 2 ай бұрын
Journey to Eternity on a Steve is pure gas. Play it and Gift of Immortality for x2 chance at crazy good starts.
@dudemanbrodog1961
@dudemanbrodog1961 2 ай бұрын
I am 100% on Mia's side for this entire video
@isidoreaerys8745
@isidoreaerys8745 2 ай бұрын
I just dropped a Dragoncaster outcast on turn 6 playing Obeka, Made 5 dragons. And my opponent playing Saheeli conceded during the next turn. Card is bananas for a 1 drop.
@adarklight505
@adarklight505 2 ай бұрын
Lol at the dying hill of Tribute to Horobi. I think almost all of my decks would love getting a disposable rat to sacrifice to something. Also, the argument of it's akward to swing the rats into each other is shattered with a 2/2 >.
@nicolasstaudt5714
@nicolasstaudt5714 Ай бұрын
How about Ugin, the Spirit Dragon? There's a planeswalker everyone should play. Also, the Sorin that brings someone's life to 10 is ridiculous. That should have been banned over Dockside.
@banditbiker5190
@banditbiker5190 2 ай бұрын
Last time i drew the only Planeswalker i play in ally decks i ultimated and put 40 forests on the field. Had a colonoan twingrove and token at 45/45 😂. I still lost though. Needed trample.
@nzephier
@nzephier 2 ай бұрын
I am between Mia and beezy on journey to eternity. I love it but can't find decks it goes in outside of my prismatic bridge deck and I just thought of that after watching this lol
@WumboWings96
@WumboWings96 2 ай бұрын
MDFC’s like Bala Ged Recovery are super versatile and thus I see the spell side as more of a bonus unless it directly ties in with the deck. Also, I will not take slander on any Ixalan dual-faced cards whatsoever. They are my babies. 😂 As for Creeping Bloodsucker, it’s a perfect card for Teysa, Oppulent Oligarch for her to investigate 3 times on your end step every time.
@enelson39
@enelson39 2 ай бұрын
I have a budget Inniaz political deck. Forgot about Thaumatic Compass. Thanks for the convincing argument - the political argument of 'here's a creature from another opponent don't attack me with him' is better with a maze of ith in play AND I can use it to save my own attacker in a pinch for the Inniaz trigger. Putting it in that deck!
@shazz8722
@shazz8722 2 ай бұрын
Creeping Bloodsucker and Dragonmaster Outcast are legit win-cons in new Obeka
@darian235
@darian235 Ай бұрын
She is also right on fanatic compass
@andrewamann2821
@andrewamann2821 2 ай бұрын
Gwafa Hazid does have a few narrow use cases that work in interesting ways... Like poisoning an Ozolith.
@sheahagensicker737
@sheahagensicker737 2 ай бұрын
A lot of these cards are fun and useful. They almost all have places in several decks
@N4chtigall
@N4chtigall 2 ай бұрын
-Roadside Reliquary? Who cares about losing one land in later stages of the game? -When it comes to planeswalkers - in my opinion they are demonized too much. In reality in many decks they are close to being unkillable or require a lot of resources. In most games people don't have 4/5 power creatures just laying around waiting to strike planeswalkers. They are better when you are ahead for sure, but I don't think that they deserve that much hate. -Creeping Bloodsucker in my opinion is better than it looks. Its much better at being enabler of all kind of plays than being a vampire. It slowly drains enemies away, giving you all kind of damage dealt/lifegain triggers, staying low profile for few turns. Especially that compared to other similar cards it doesn't have any requirements - it doesn't need creatures to enter or die or whatever. And it can always be used to block or sacrifice fodder. -Quicksmith Genius can be such a powerhouse in artifacts decks. I have it in Mishra, Tamer of Mak Fawa reanimator artifact deck and its insane how much this little guy can do. Its not that uncommon to see 2-3 artifacts or even more get onto the battlefield each of your turn so for 3 mana you get insane card selection, graveyard filler and a decent body.
@hugovellver5114
@hugovellver5114 2 ай бұрын
Going to Say quicksmith genious is better than it sounds, but You need a Breach or something to pay off cause You Will mill really fast
@franzgriffle6063
@franzgriffle6063 2 ай бұрын
Looked like a yugioh card in the thumbnail and I was just like… “Yeah, dislike that card too”
@thebobbybabbitt7703
@thebobbybabbitt7703 2 ай бұрын
Lol planeswalkers are fine. Yes they die sometimes, but a lot of times they don't.
@TheWhmaxwell
@TheWhmaxwell 2 ай бұрын
End the festivities is GREAT in my Judith deck, LOL
@olymills7395
@olymills7395 2 ай бұрын
Only viewing true convicrtion from an offensive viewpoint is a huge mistake. Your playing white, so your team having vigilance is almost a given add in deathtouch for orzhov and see 1/1 token slay that huge overrun swing.
@aaronrodriguez9376
@aaronrodriguez9376 5 күн бұрын
Politicians can learn from you two when it comes to debating and keeping it friendly.
@Npocommander
@Npocommander 2 ай бұрын
My saheelis and tezerrets are wincons and karns
@obadijahparks
@obadijahparks 2 ай бұрын
25:10 a great card, but not for the price.
Analyzing Commander's Most Controversial Cards
1:08:47
Nitpicking Nerds
Рет қаралды 41 М.
Quilt Challenge, No Skills, Just Luck#Funnyfamily #Partygames #Funny
00:32
Family Games Media
Рет қаралды 55 МЛН
Which Removal Should You Play in Commander? The Complete Guide
44:04
Nitpicking Nerds
Рет қаралды 33 М.
Sword of X and Y Tier List | Commander Clash Podcast 94
1:34:28
MTGGoldfish Commander
Рет қаралды 95 М.
How to Outclass Commander’s Most Overplayed Cards
1:01:08
Nitpicking Nerds
Рет қаралды 39 М.
How to Cut Your Deck Down to 100 Cards (And Be Happy About It)
41:12
Nitpicking Nerds
Рет қаралды 31 М.
We Rebuilt Our First Commander Decks | Shuffle Up & Play 52 | Magic: The Gathering Gameplay
1:51:31
Commander Cards You Should Buy NOW (November 2024)
49:18
Nitpicking Nerds
Рет қаралды 44 М.
Which Mana Rocks Should You Play in Commander? The Complete Guide
31:33
Nitpicking Nerds
Рет қаралды 44 М.
The Most Hated Artifacts of All Time | Saltiest Cards | EDH | Magic the Gathering
27:54
Things That Annoy Commander Players MOST
49:05
Nitpicking Nerds
Рет қаралды 34 М.
Attack of the Fans! | Game Knights 35 | Magic the Gathering Commander EDH Gameplay
1:27:56
Quilt Challenge, No Skills, Just Luck#Funnyfamily #Partygames #Funny
00:32
Family Games Media
Рет қаралды 55 МЛН