Comparing 3 Versions of Dimash Screaming - Vocal Coach Reaction & Analysis

Merry Christmas everybody :) I'm bringing you a very special episode where I react to 3 versions of Dimash performing his song Screaming! Every version has its unique things, so, let's check them out!
Link to the original videos:
• Dimash - Screaming | О...
• Dimash - Screaming | ...
• Video
🎶 For recurring support go here - my Patreon page:
/ hofthestage
☕️ To donate to my channel (treat me to a coffee) go here:
paypal.me/HofT....
🎬My Movie/TV show reaction channel: / @cinemawithh
📲Instagram: / hofthestage .
▶️Subscribe: / hofthestage
💻Follow on FB: / hofthestage
📊TubeBuddy: Tool I use to grow my channel: www.tubebuddy.... (Affiliate link)
🎧 Headphones I use (Mania & Thalia) www.erzetich-a...
--- Follow Erzetich on Instagram: / erzetichaudio
╔═╦╗╔╦╗╔═╦═╦╦╦╦╗╔═╗
║╚╣║║║╚╣╚╣╔╣╔╣║╚╣═╣
╠╗║╚╝║║╠╗║╚╣║║║║║═╣
╚═╩══╩═╩═╩═╩╝╚╩═╩═╝
✉️For business inquiries: [e-mail]
If you're interested in singing lessons, send an email to [e-mail] describing your situation and we can figure something out
Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing.
Non-profit, educational, or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use.
dimash screaming reaction,vocal coach reacts to dimash screaming,dimash vocal coach reacts,dimash reaction,screaming reaction,vocal coach reacts,vocal coach reaction,vocal coach reacts to,vocal coach reaction to,vocal coach reaction to dimash,dimash screaming,dimash screaming live,dimash screaming 3 versions,comparing versions of dimash song,dimash comparison,dimash triple reaction,h of the stage
dimash screaming reaction, vocal coach reacts to dimash screaming, dimash vocal coach reacts, dimash reaction,screaming reaction, dimash screaming reaction, vocal coach reacts to dimash screaming, dimash vocal coach reacts, dimash reaction,screaming reaction, vocal coach reacts, vocal coach reaction, vocal coach reacts to, vocal coach reaction to, vocal coach reaction to dimash, dimash screaming, dimash screaming live, dimash screaming 3 versions, comparing versions of dimash song, dimash comparison, dimash screaming reaction, vocal coach reacts to dimash screaming, dimash vocal coach reacts, dimash reaction,screaming reaction, vocal coach reacts, vocal coach reaction, vocal coach reacts to, vocal coach reaction to, vocal coach reaction to dimash, dimash screaming, dimash screaming live, dimash screaming 3 versions, comparing versions of dimash song, dimash comparison, dimash triple reaction, h of the stage, dimash triple reaction, h of the stage, vocal coach reacts, dimash screaming reaction, vocal coach reacts to dimash screaming, dimash screaming reaction, vocal coach reacts to dimash screaming, dimash vocal coach reacts, dimash reaction,screaming reaction, dimash screaming reaction, vocal coach reacts to dimash screaming, dimash vocal coach reacts, dimash reaction,screaming reaction, vocal coach reacts, vocal coach reaction, vocal coach reacts to, vocal coach reaction to, vocal coach reaction to dimash, dimash screaming, dimash screaming live, dimash screaming 3 versions, comparing versions of dimash song, dimash comparison, dimash triple reaction, h of the stage, vocal coach reacts, vocal coach reaction, vocal coach reacts to, vocal coach reaction to, vocal coach reaction to dimash, dimash screaming, dimash screaming live, dimash screaming 3 versions, comparing versions of dimash song, dimash comparison, dimash triple reaction, h of the stage, dimash vocal coach reacts, dimash reaction,screaming reaction, vocal coach reacts, vocal coach reaction, vocal coach reacts to, vocal coach reaction to, vocal coach reaction to dimash, dimash screaming, dimash screaming reaction, vocal coach reacts to dimash screaming, dimash vocal coach reacts, dimash reaction,screaming reaction, vocal coach reacts, vocal coach reaction, vocal coach reacts to, vocal coach reaction to, vocal coach reaction to dimash, dimash screaming, dimash screaming live, dimash screaming 3 versions, comparing versions of dimash song, dimash comparison, dimash triple reaction, h of the stage, dimash screaming live, dimash screaming 3 versions, comparing versions of dimash song, dimash comparison, dimash screaming reaction, vocal coach reacts to dimash screaming, dimash vocal coach reacts, dimash reaction,screaming reaction, vocal coach reacts, vocal coach reaction, vocal coach reacts to, vocal coach reaction to, vocal coach reaction to dimash, dimash screaming, dimash screaming live.

[@HofTheStage]

Merry Christmas everybody :) I'm bringing you a very special episode where I react to 3 versions of Dimash performing his song Screaming! Every version has its unique things, so, let's check them out! Also, we're so close to 200K subs! Every share and subscribe counts! Let's gooo! Link to the original videos: kzbin.info/www/bejne/nXfVgouZfbijaMU kzbin.info/www/bejne/i3PKpph9mcybask kzbin.info/www/bejne/Z2qTqmCnis97l7s 🎶 For recurring support go here - my Patreon page: www.patreon.com/HofTheStage ☕️ To donate to my channel (treat me to a coffee) go here: paypal.me/HofTheStage?locale.... 🎬My Movie/TV show reaction channel: kzbin.info/door/CcLblDvrU_OmJ3x4yyKIeg 📲Instagram: instagram.com/hofthestage.. ▶️Subscribe: kzbin.info 💻Follow on FB: facebook.com/hofthestage/ 📊TubeBuddy: Tool I use to grow my channel: www.tubebuddy.com/HofTheStage (Affiliate link) ╔═╦╗╔╦╗╔═╦═╦╦╦╦╗╔═╗ ║╚╣║║║╚╣╚╣╔╣╔╣║╚╣═╣ ╠╗║╚╝║║╠╗║╚╣║║║║║═╣ ╚═╩══╩═╩═╩═╩╝╚╩═╩═╝ ✉️For business inquiries: [e-mail]

[@ДанаДжумабаева-ф4ф]

Hi, I think you right, I like humans too, than aliens.

[@davidricks7128]

I think it was a great MV for his first attempt into western pop love the song either way

[@babycomfrog]

He's already standing on a global scale. I don't care to Vocal Coach Reaction & Analysis

[@desirregahum3339]

Hi,,,new subscriber here,,can you react to his Kazakhstan song,,maybe you will change your mind about that auto tune you say...thanks

[@asdfgasdfgh5635]

Michael Jackson use pre record when he danced. So dance and sing together it's hard. However i think problem is in perfectionism of dimash.

[@chandadas304]

Dimash perform "Screaming" very differently in every performances from his concerts (D-Dynasty, Arnau Tours) and shows. There are more than 15 versions of "Screaming" 😊👍👍👍

[@shrekswife2164]

Thanks HotS for this frank reaction. Watching Dimash's growth as an artist is a fascinating study. These vids are a timeline of his progression from an aspiring musician to a megastar in a nutshell. To me, Dimash's music choices clearly shows his classical training and family life as the most influencing factors. I've decided not to argue with opinions or speculations on those choices. But I think to give voice to the absent subject of this speculation its fair to share a few thoughts in response. Obviously Dimash is an anomaly given his unusual ability to manipulate the vocal instrument in ways most singers don't or can't. This anomaly allows him to do quirky/weird things vocal coaches, seasoned musicians he's worked with, even his parents can't explain, other than wonder and speculate upon. Aaron Neville who sings like he's auto tuned is a perfect example of such anomalies in the human gene pool. Yet its his own God given singing voice. The late Dolores O'Riordan was the same. How do we explain these anomalies? Simple. These individuals have/had special talents they seriously honed to perfection. Sadly, our dependence on technology has robbed us of the ability to believe in the human power to command a feat greater than technology but the will to do so is weak so our go-to is to assume and then rationalise that assumption which leads us down a slippery slope. We forget that our current knowledge is limited which is why I admire how Dimash makes education a priority and experiments with his voice bc his findings will answer a lot of the questions ppl have about voice integrity and the role of technology to submit to the will of man, not the other way round. Some cultures where chanting prayers is a tradition gives the same autotune effect. I have many Muslim friends who do the same when singing/chanting without any electronic device. Growing up in an Islamic culture I'm sure Dimash has chanted prayers since childhood and would've cut his teeth on its human auto tune technique and has used it in his concerts. I'm partial to the performance of Chornobrivtsi in Kiev. His natural speaking voice to me hints at the hidden depths of his capabilities that can only surface with dedication to practice and studying his own vocal instrument. There are things our brains can't compute bc our perceptions are limited to what we know through our senses or from education. But the mind is much more powerful when the will to master a feat is on par. Dimash's vocal chords are an anomaly in the singers gene pool but like Aaron, I think he can only prove himself through more live performances in small halls without a mic to appease the skeptics. And yes, precisely bc he is from our species, knowing why he makes the choices he makes re music would help. We use technology everyday to enhance our living experience and even tho' D likes to experiment with his voice i think he'd use autotune if its a value added choice. To think Cher's massively autotuned Believe was a hit, no one complained! That's why it seems petty whenever coaches critique D on the strength of a popular assumption based on limited knowledge without the science or cultural context elements. I'm not anti pitch correcting technology if it improves the sound for our listening pleasure. But we must not close our minds to the differences that frames the world that uniquely talented individuals bring nor diminish the importance of those talents just bc the only way we know such techniques is with digital technology. Their rare abilities sets them apart for sure but that rarity is the difference that highlights the beauty of our diversity.

[@bekydelacaridadtoledogutie1839]

Thanks so much for this great comment agree 100%. And about the sound of his voice similar to autotune there is a clear example in the song "Kazakhstan". There are some very peculiar singers. But for me Dimash Qudaibergen is THE KING, THE GOAT, The Best Singer Ever Walked on this PLANET.

[@carolynbailey4147]

Thank you for your comment...my impression of his analysis is he doth complain too much to the point of I'm nauseous...why is he making such a big deal out of this...other artists definitely use auto tune...personally...his nit picking is more than I can stand...shutting him off.. Dimash is human...been listening to him since 2017...not interested in his nit picking and could care less to listen so I can nit pick Dimash too...

[@andreseet3877]

It feels to me that he is just nit picking.. i dont find it constructive at all. i have unsubscribed to his channel.

[@barb_ec4436]

There is something that most Do Not know, and has Not already been mentioned here. There were two recordings done of the last Screaming performance. The first performance was done for a live audience, Dimash had a wardrobe malfunction (the belt for his pants fell off, it was very obviously dangling behind him, like a tail, lol). he grabbed the belt and held his pants, while continuing to sing (ever the professional). Another second recording (apparently without audience and with the belt secured, lol) was done after, for broadcast. It seem like the broadcast version was a post-production mix of the two performances.

[@mimasam5528]

It is not the right answer what he was said there. Dimash wasn't sick or exhausted or anything.Here is fan cam.. kzbin.info/www/bejne/pHeTf5mgeZujqbs

[@gracetrespeses2141]

Shamima Islam Yes, this fan cam sounded much better than the supposedly auto tuned version. And I also don’t think Dimash was tired or sick here that he had to resort to screaming or use auto tune. I do appreciate the reactor’s honest opinion whether he is correct or not correct or whether I agree or disagree with his analysis. Thanks for sharing , dear.

[@БакытгульКыдырбаева-з5я]

Спасибо за реакцию. Мы любим Димаша . И вы тоже Супер.

[@tirallala1]

This mainstream- song was written for Dimash to make him better known in the English-speaking world. His first English official MV - kzbin.info/www/bejne/nXfVgouZfbijaMU was previously released on May 24, 2018 on his 24th birthday. In the MV he plays the piano, drums and sings his own backup. Later for the stage the song was rearranged: * Screaming, "Idol Hits" 2018 - kzbin.info/www/bejne/i3PKpph9mcybask * Screaming at Kremlin Moscow live Concert 2019 - kzbin.info/www/bejne/nWjNhpSDqd2mfZo * Screaming, Dimash Digital Show 2021 - kzbin.info/www/bejne/hmmtfpytjrN7isk This performance always makes me a little sad because unfortunately there was no live audience (pandemic) Dimash always sings this song with his Dears at his concerts. * Screaming | Beijing 2021(phantastic new version) - kzbin.info/www/bejne/Z2qTqmCnis97l7s * Behind the scenes "Screaming" MV - kzbin.info/www/bejne/oJepi32GiNdsbMk * Behind the scenes “Idol Hits” - kzbin.info/www/bejne/rJe7iGepr7GNhq8 👉This song is on his first album 'ID'. The album went platinum in 37 seconds, 3 times platinum in 47 minutes and 5 times platinum on the first day in China (album platinum: 200,000 units, single platinum: 400,000 units).

[@jonathondiamond3002]

Amazing insightful reaction. Thanks for letting us share your journey with Dimash. Peace and love from Pennsylvania USA.

[@vickisavage5451]

Dimash is amazing regardless. I do hear what you are talking about. My favorite is the idol concert version too. Thanks for sharing all your knowledge and honesty. Doesn’t lessen Dimashes ability in any way.

[@HofTheStage]

Exactly! Thanks for understanding. Glad you people hear what I mean. Dimash is still incredible and he's allowed to have a bad day as everybody else

[@teresaz-l2963]

@@HofTheStage Für mich ist es nur schade, dass du die Hälfte von deiner Reaktion für Rechtfertigung und für ein Lied mit Autotönung verplempert hast. Dimash hat uns schon längs verzaubert. Man brauch ihn nicht mehr zu beschützen. Er ist schon erwachsen und nicht mehr wegzudenken aus unseren Leben.

[@edithtrejo6795]

Dimash es el mejor cantante de todos los tiempos. Saludos. Feliz Navidad desde Venezuela

[@deboranaranjouquillas5988]

Las tres versiones son maravillosas, solo Dimash puede hacer esto,genial.

[@bettyirbaetydiana7945]

Dimash the best singer in the world.👍🥰

[@ТатьянаПопова-ч3и8б]

Я, конечно, не спец в музыке, для меня последняя версия звучит идеально, как и все песни Димаша. Я знаю точно, сейчас в Китае очень строгие законы насчет фонограммы, наложения и исправления звуков. Вообщем, категорически все это запрещено, не должно быть ни какого обмана зрителей. Я думаю, что ни один канал не будет рисковать и нарушать законы. Мне нравится смотреть твои реакции на Димаша, уважаю твое профессиональное мнение, но думаю, что в этот раз ты ошибся.

[@рашитханнанов]

Возможно нет никакой ошибки - просто уважаемый реакционер не подумал, что дело не в Димаше, а в не очень профессиональной работе звукооператора(звукорежиссера).Приписать Димашу автонастройку может человек, который в первый раз слышит Димаша и не верит своим ушам. Я специально послушал выступление Димаша в наушниках и остался недоволен именно работой технарей, а не пением Димаша.

[@DiaLinwen]

В начале этого выступления точно был автотюн. Именно китайцы любят этот звук, его вставили продюсеры шоу, не потому, что Димаш в этом нуждается, а для того чтобы, по их мнению, украсить песню. И в Китае, кстати, полно фанеры, фанера занрещена только местным певцам и только в сольных концертах. Вот спектральный анализ специалистом этого выступления, который наглядно объясняет где есть автотюн и объясняет почему. kzbin.info/www/bejne/o5DVgpWueKdnmrs

[@elerainone5737]

Hola. Saludos desde Argentina. Totalmente de acuerdo. La manera de expresarlo tampoco fue de mi agrado.

[@Natali98061]

Реакционер хайпует уже. Хочется внимания. Видно же, что выискивает на чём хайпануть. Я несколько раз прослушала эу версию, у меня домашний кинотеатр, хорошие наушники - не обнаружила ничего потустороннего. Димаш сам может создавать звуки автотюна, искаженной гитары, регистр флейты, фрай в любой октаве, скэт-сингинг и прочее. Зачем ему себя исправлять?

[@carodear7104]

Hola. Otro reactor analizo este tema en una maquina para ver auto tune, lo noto solo al comienzo de la canción, lo demas arrojaba que era su voz sin post producción, los cantantes usan auto tune ( los buenos) para adornar alguna parte del tema, sabemos que Dimash no lo necesita pero quizás quisieron ponerle algo diferente. Gracias por tu reacción. Saludos desde Chile 🇨🇱

[@lilaladdada]

Merci Christmas / joyeux Noël à vous et toute votre famille : So thank you very much for your honesty but we had the chance to see a fan cam and we may have some explanation: Dimash was doing his first performance after 3 weeks of quarantine all alone in a room when is come back to China . - 2 second point he lost his belt pants and pants literally fell: they fixed it all and he continued to sing ... Yes we heard the staccato and not the first time ( just imagine losing your pans my g…) Merci beaucoup , bonnes fêtes à vous et à votre famille 🙏🎄🌟🌟🇫🇷

[@HofTheStage]

I didn't know any of that.. 3 weeks of quarantine explains a lot, especially the lack of breath and the tiredness. Nevertheless, a powerful performance! We still love Dimaaaash ❤️

[@esmasadikovic1139]

Hlače nisu pale, samo je kaiš spao, držao ga je u ruci iza leđa i nastavio pjevati

[@monymar3241]

🤣🤣🤣🤣 no lo defiendas mas por favor. Me has hecho reir mucho !!!!!

[@monymar3241]

@@HofTheStage FOREVER !!!!!😂😂😂 ❤❤❤ FELIZ NAVIDAD !!!!

[@DiaLinwen]

That's not the reason the Chinese did it. This is not the same performance where he lost his belt, they rerecorded it and released the second one. They sometimes love to do it for ornament (why they think it's more beautiful than his natural voice is another question, it's just trendy now to do it I guess). Here they did it in the easiest part of the song, not because Dimash needs tuning, as the rest of the song shows. Here is an explanation by means of spectral analysis. kzbin.info/www/bejne/o5DVgpWueKdnmrs.

[@АлександраКолесникова-п2я]

Отлично 😍Димаш великолепен как всегда ❤️⭐❤️⭐❤️⭐❤️⭐❤️⭐❤️⭐

[@yugiohlegend]

❤️ Thank you for your reaction! I’ve always noticed the autotune/pitch correction on the last Screaming performance and no other vocal teacher EVER points it out. It’s like they don’t want to mention it so they stay in good terms with their viewers. They know they’re gonna get a bit of hate, but you want to give facts, which I love. If you can’t hear the autotune, I’m sorry but something is wrong 😂 I do feel though that in the last performance, Dimash was “shouty” as a choice. I don’t believe he was tired or ill because he smashed the rest of the song like nothing, it also added to that version imo. If you think otherwise, I’d love to hear why. Thank you!!! ❤️

[@HofTheStage]

I'm pretty sure most of others didn't mentioned autotune because they didn't want to make the audience mad :D I still think the "shouty" parts were due to the lack of breath support, again, might be that he was short on breath because of dancing. For headvoice you actually often don't use as much breath as for chest and belt, so he slayed everything else except those couple of parts in the higher chest voice.

[@yugiohlegend]

@@HofTheStage You are the expert 😂 I respect your opinion

[@oryzhkova1]

Я видела одну реакцию, в которой говорили про автонастройку в начале песни. Не знаю зачем это было сделано, мне такой звук не очень нравится.

[@moonlight4656]

@@HofTheStage So you are the brave one to face the audiens & unveil the truth hmmm..Wow !!!

[@moonlight4656]

@@luabennett7303 No my friend! I didn't buy what mr, expert said! Not a single word!! That was Just nonsens😏!! This isn't the right way to gain views!! The worst reaction/analysis ever!!

[@debbiemorgan859]

He's awaiting surgery for a deviated septum I believe which is causing all kinds of breathing problems. I was surprised by this song too, knowing about the autotune laws in China I didn't know if it was just effects put on to maybe bring the song more up to date but then he also had some issues with Stranger performed in the Shine Super Brothers show where he obviously ran out of breath at the last note. It's a shame that we expect him to be perfect as he already holds himself to impossible standards and he is human like all of us. It's about time he gave himself a break, went and got the surgery done with a decent recovery period afterwards, but with all the work commitments he has between now and the end of April he could be suffering for a few months yet.

[@HofTheStage]

I wasn't aware of the surgery at the time of recording the reaction. What are you talking about autotune laws in Chine? I find it hard to believe that there is a law about such thing... And yes, he needs proper rest because he might lose his voice completely if he doesn't stop to recover... It wouldn't be the first time big singers took a break and it was much needed (John Mayer, Adele, Celine Dion just to mention a few)

[@debbiemorgan859]

@@HofTheStage there are all sorts of weird performance laws in China, lip syncing is also banned and any changes to performance content has to be pre approved by the government before release. Unless he has the surgery done in China in January then there's not a chance he's going to fit it in as he's apparently opening the Winter Olympics in Beijing in February, he's in Dubai for two weeks in March and then (Covid allowing) completing the Arnau World Tour in April.

[@DiaLinwen]

Chinese just looooove autotune. If anybody adds it, those are the Chinese producers, because it's idolish and trendy. Dimash never does it in his own productions or performances. I don't know who says about such laws, but that's not true at all. Lip syncing isn't allowed only in commercial performances (solo concerts) and it only applies to local artists The surgery, on the other hand, is very real and I hope he does it soon. And yes, it causes breathing and resonance problems. But it shouldn't cause him to lose his voice.

[@Billie-uk8wk]

@@DiaLinwen yeah, i believe so. There are various reasons why they use autotunes, also dimash has no control over those things even he doesnt want to.

[@Lou16.]

@@debbiemorgan859 I have not heard anything about auto tune laws in China, generally it is over used there! Also, there is a misunderstanding about lip syncing, it too is still used a lot in China, especially for multi performer events and tv shows.

[@rexalexmacedon]

the last performance, which was done recently in beijing, if i recall correctly, was shot twice. the first time he sang it, his belt came loose, but he continued to perform nevertheless, holding the belt in one hand. i think the director asked him to perform the song again, and the second version was the one televised.

[@patriciaestrada9588]

Todas las versiones de Screaming son fabulosas. Dimash es único e inigualable, el mejor de todos los tiempos.

[@viefive6791]

Nooo... It does not matter at all. We Dimash's Dears love your reactions, reviews and analysis. This is really great!! Thanks very much . Yes, there is Dimash who is engrossed in singing the staccatos part of Queen of The Night while walking backstage in one of his vlog videos... My fav is from idol hit and i love screamibg from digital show 2021 version too. Thank you ! 💕💕💕

[@aileenperucho6719]

The last one in Beijing he recorded it twice because in the first song, his belt fell off so he re record it. Among the three, I like the MV version most.

[@SandraRegina-tl2be]

Sem palavras para descrever Dimash, sempre incrível um grande abraço do BRASIL 🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷💖

[@gailhubbard7102]

Wow! I love this song!

[@natidari3693]

I love your reactions. I liked the comparison of several versions. The more Dimash, the better.

[@marlenemarenco9694]

Siempre Dimash sorprendiendome con su voz impecable 💯💯🇨🇷❤️🇨🇷❤️

[@bethwolford3652]

I think Idol Hits will always be my favorite! MV was ok, but early. The newest China tv video I personal don’t like the sound, the production. I love Dimash no matter the performance. You are confirming my feeling about the third performance.

[@annealappel3116]

Yes on the world part is very clear, i noticed that. I have to say it doesn’t bother me, maybe i start to be used to autotune even if i hate mumble rap ! And i don’t really like this song but it’s always fun to see Dimash live, you never know what to expect

[@mimasam5528]

This fan cam shows he sang really well. Don't know why that programme used auto-tune.

[@agentcorba]

Thats why you are one of my favourite people to react! I am pretty sure he was or will go to surgery and maybe that was reason for "unstabilty" in his chest/mix voice. I could be wrong but i enjoyed analasys as always!

[@HofTheStage]

Thanks man, glad somebody appreciate's the honesty! I didn't know about the surgery, apparently he had some surgery for the respirstory system, not really sure.. it might explain why he pushed a bit more when being in the chest voice.

[@agentcorba]

@@HofTheStage no thank you Hrvoje for bringing good videos even on Badnjak :D

[@kkhshout573]

Thank you for your wise words! I'm so tired of people being so dramatic about the use of autotune; it's not a magic tool that can make you sing well, it only corrects the pitch. If a singer uses a bit of autotune, it doesn't mean they couldn't sing without it. Many times it's used to blend all the tracks well and to make it sound "perfect" to our ears. If Dimash sang a couple of notes off, then what? I'm a professional musician; if someone would analyse all of my live mistakes and critique me, my career wouldn't exist xD

[@HofTheStage]

Exactly

[@gracetrespeses2141]

Thank you for your analysis. Happy holidays!

[@lindaaumiller7592]

I love your reaction. This is one of my favorite songs!

[@animalsarefriends4342]

Dimash deserves a Grammy & Oscar and many more to come, he is the best of the best, no debate. Can't stop listening to his Ave Maria & Ikanaide.... healing the depth of my soul!

[@runtsgal]

I love this song and my favourite is the Idol hits version too mainly because of the interaction with his dears. I appreciate your honesty.

[@ceceliaoliveira4550]

I happen to love this song, music video and all of them!

[@keymeranza8102]

Gracias yo se la admiración que le tienes a Dimash y siempre ahy que aceptar los errores, igual no cambia lo genial que es Dimash y las maravillosas cosas que hace ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@corysoles]

Dimash no need auto-tune. I agree with you.

[@ВалентинаКалинченко-н7ш]

Моя любимая версия.

[@rasbar3830]

THE FIRST TEN SECONDS ARE THE BEST PART OF THIS VIDEO....MAYBE THE WHOLE CHANNEL😎

[@JustMyOpinion1010]

I remember the time when Paris Hilton decided to sing. Thank goodness for auto tune 😆

[@gracetrespeses2141]

Lol

[@anamariasandovalcaquilpan6177]

Su versión de Screaming en Beijing el cantó en ese festival como 3 días antes de que el canal subiera la canción y le agregaron el autotune después porque en las fancam no sale así, la cantó dos veces porque en una se salió el cinturón y se enredo con los cables..😅😅. Esta versión la analizó Creactivamente con un computador con un analizador de sonido para ver si la cantaba con o sin autotune. Tiene Subtitulos kzbin.info/www/bejne/o5DVgpWueKdnmrs Screaming la segunda versión de Idol Hits la canta en todos sus conciertos y con ella presenta a su equipo. Idol Hits no es un concurso como su nombre lo dice es un programa donde van a cantar su mejor éxito los cantantes. A mi me gustan las 3 versiones y cada vez que la canta le cambia algo. Saludos desde Chile 🇨🇱

[@Billie-uk8wk]

Merry Christmas,too! What a treat!❤️ thanks for reacting to Di, its been a while😁 should've included the DDS ver. , its amazing, better than the one in beijing✌️.

[@annemarie78]

💕 Hi I like all the versions but the digital show version is wonderful 🇵🇹🇰🇿

[@Billie-uk8wk]

like that version too!

[@annemarie78]

💕👍 Merry Christmas and Happy New Year

[@silvialeticia1296]

Yes,best version for me!

[@aimaki3477]

Здравствуйте, я думаю, что у Димаша не было и в мыслях показать себя самым лучшим вокалистом. Он свое предназначение рассматривает в совершенно другом направлении. Он поет чтобы его поклонники получали от его творчества самые лучшие эмоции. Что за манера всех у вас , кто занимается преподаванием вокала, рассматривать Димаша под микроскопом и находить какие то погрешности. Он Вас просил. Поэтому ведите свои уроки как вам вздумается и как вы считаете нужным. Оставьте его в покое. Здесь не должно места для зависти. С уважением из Калифорнии.

[@Зузу-777]

Полностью согласна с вами!

[@lilianacoconier1673]

Dimash Perfectamente Maravilloso!!!!! 👏👏❤❤❤

[@nl920]

El autotune en el caso de Dimash, debe ser una elección, solo para darle un aire más moderno a la canción. Todos sabemos que no lo necesita, porque el talento le sobra.

[@jayeginn5963]

You are right: the Beijing version wasn't live. There used to be a another version of this, a fancam version, where he was holding a microphone with a huge logo of the TV station on it. During that version his belt came off. Well, that version, which is no longer available on KZbin (I wonder why; there is a version on KZbin available that is spliced, so one second he's holding a normal microphone, the next second he holds the microphone with the huge logo), was 100% exactly the same as this one; each breath, each ad lib was one on one the same. So, that was proof that it was a lip synched performance, but they took it off KZbin. This is a fantastic version, though (actually my favorite), just not live.

[@barb_ec4436]

The problem with mentioning auto-tune, it brings out the minions of haters... that will say... See, Dimash is a fake and cannot sing. The reason most vocal coachs do not mention auto-tune, is that... it is understood in the industry to be used when necessary. The use of auto-tune when necessary, does not take away from talented singers like Dimash, but the mention of it, gives validation to those that want to spread mis-information that he is fake.

[@HofTheStage]

That's why I'm certain of Dimashe's qualities since I've reacted to him for 2 years basically so I know that he's an amazing singer nevertheless. I didn't thought about it like that but you do have a point, haters are just waiting for something like this..

[@debbiemorgan859]

Very aptly put, there's a musician reactor out there (Pegasus something) who went out of his way to find an obviously autotuned track and instantly his comments were filled with messages saying that they always knew Dimash couldn't really sing like he does without some kind of electronic help. Unfortunately people love to hate what they can't understand or accomplish for themselves.

[@Gorgina010]

Well, autotune is a clear EVIDENCE, that a singer messed up when used in post-production, and an evidence, that a singer cannot sing a particular song when used live or in a studio version. Autotune is fraud; it SHOULD be hated and every time any singer is using it, he or she should be bashed for it relentlessly for the rest of his/her career. It would cause autotune to disappear and we would get actual singers back instead of the masses of fake singers, whose only talent & skill is to look pretty & dress sl*ty & shake their @sses on stage in a vulgar manner.

[@barb_ec4436]

@@Gorgina010 . To say "a singer messed up.." is a very crass generalization. This does not always apply, most often it is a choice done by the Venue, the Broadcast Network or the post-production team... And, more often... the Singer has No say in it. In the case of this last Dimash "Screaming" performance, it was a blend of two performances, because of Dimash incurring a wardrobe malfunction and they had to re-tape another performance for Broadcast. Having seen both performances, I can say it was a blend done post-production.

[@YuYu-cf6jf]

About all these auto-tuning and reverberation - a question for sound engineers. They are doing Dimash a disservice. Not all sound engineers have a sense of proportion))

[@bethelliot7140]

The reason for the little glitches (autotune) may be because, from what I have heard, he had to have another surgery for respiratory system/nose or something (he was suffering from it when he filmed part of the show "Shine" on Youku) 🤔🤔😥😥🤨 I believe it is fixed now though 😉❤🤗

[@hobi2716]

Not his voice, that would be horrible. 😭 I think it was a surgery for respiratory problems, so it was like a nose surgery if that's the right term.

[@bethelliot7140]

@@hobi2716 ah yes that was it, but it did affect his singing (you can hear it when he sings Stranger on the Youku show) 👍🤔 felt like he actually ran out of breath at points which I have never heard happen with Dimash before

[@HofTheStage]

Ouuu I didn't know about that 😢 Hope he recovers!

[@bethwolford3652]

I didnt know that! Thanks for the info. Where did you hear this from?

[@Billie-uk8wk]

@@bethwolford3652 dimash said it himself on an interview on youku show. It was all over the dear community, everyone was so worried.

[@gustavosanchez341]

Great reaction. Please react to Dimash singing the song Jasmine. Dimash was invited to the New Year and Spring Festival three times in a row, which are seen by up to 1 billion people. This song 'Jasmine' is sang every year at the Spring Festival Gala (considered the unofficial national anthem in China). It is a great honor to be asked to sing this song, especially as a foreigner. Dimash has received this award three times from 2018 to 2020. Of course, he sings this song differently every time. It would be nice if you could hear the other versions too: 2018 Dimash& Luo Tianyi - kzbin.info/www/bejne/j6KqdJRqfKdgbrM 2019 kzbin.info/www/bejne/nqe7ln-phZZ9bZI 2020 kzbin.info/www/bejne/bGq1hJ6BqpyAhdU

[@АлександраВладиславовна-н7с]

💖💖💖 Люблю Димаша💖💖💖

[@ГульшараЖунусова-г5ь]

Привет Н! Merry Chrismas &Happy Holidays! Возможно, Вы правы указывая на некоторые вставки. Но так получилось, что Димашу пришлось петь Screaming дважды, буквально подряд, У Димаша развязался пояс. Правда, он не растерялся: сделал вид, что так и должно быть и продолжил петь. Но для телевидения пришлось делать еще одну версию.

[@iqrabatool7677]

Love your reactions on Dimash Love from Pakistan 🇵🇰🇵🇰

[@aryrojas5252]

Great reaction! Thank you for your comments! Blessings from Mexico!

[@annawettergren3054]

Nice reaction. Very fun to compare different versions. I have no problem with you pointing out what you hear and notice, it's also a part of learning about Dimash and his music. I have a thought about that one word where you said it was obvious about the autotune, in the word "part".... I went to listen to the beginning of the song more closely and found that it didn't sound wierd. It sounded wierd in your version.... but not in the one I listened to at Dimash's channel on youtube. I wonder if the video you listened to had some afterproduction done to it... because the sound seemed more even for the entire song in the version I listened to. I have no idea. Could also be difference due to streaming and such things. However, what I was about to actually say....before I got distracted... was that you should listen to his song Tugan zher where he plays with the sound of the mike so it sounds artificial. Just a fun little thing he did in that song. kzbin.info/www/bejne/gIrXdHSYltWciLs it's around 2.25 seconds in

[@sandrak.robbins6305]

I hate auto tune and what I hate more is how producers will do it without the artist's permission. I found out recently that someone has auto tuned Simon & Garfunkle 'Bridge Over Trouble Water'!!! There are people making decisions on performances that should not be made and especially when the artist does not want it. Dimash does not want auto tune, but there are many people that make performance decisions. The control should be in Dimash's hand only.

[@maryjanemckenrick1043]

I honestly think he's more comfortable with the hard stuff...pop will never be his best genre...was married to someone in a band, so tho I'm very protective of Dimash..he is human...and everything you say is true!! I also hate hearing perfection..I love the raw, real stuff!! Merry Christmas to you and yours 🎅🤶

[@HofTheStage]

Merry Christmas! :))

[@caithlin4306]

Insightful and educational as always ... Really enjoy your reactions 😊

[@caithlin4306]

I actually agree the tone is off too..but they do change the sound to 'modernise' it..but I have to say even dancing I haven't seen him off yet when moving .even when he drops on his knees he maintains the note..but he does feel a bit low energy here too..when he's tired his eyes show it and his energy drops a little. Just my humble observations. 🤷 But as always DIMASH ❤️

[@caithlin4306]

Sorry it won't let me edit my comment yet..when I say off I don't mean off key..I just meant not 100% himself.

[@HofTheStage]

Agree, this is the first time I hear him like this too, but even Dimash can have a bad day, it's ok :)

[@paivipekola3987]

I usually like your reactions... and i liked this one too. Thank you for your honest reactions and comments❣ I heard all the parts you said were autotuned and even i'm not professonal, i could hear it. But that doesn' t change my option of you or Dimash. You are one of my favourite reactors and Dimash is one of my favourites singers, and nothing will change that. So i really get what you were trying to say and honesty is always appreciated💝

[@marcelamercado113]

MARAVILLOSOOOOOOOOO UNICOOOOOO AILAVIUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU DIMASH

[@MG-uo8kj]

I really enjoyed your honest feedback. It was great to compare 3 versions of screaming. I completely agree with you about this one and because your reaction was a refreshing change I've just subscribed. I will now go back through your reactions to Dimash and watch them all. I am really looking forward to watching them tonight. Can hardly wait for your next Dimash reaction. Thank you!!!

[@nancyhashiguchi8470]

He is the best!!!!!

[@nantampa4922]

This was the second take. He had a clothes malfunction and they had to redo it again. He also had to have some nasal surgery done sometime around then. Thank you for pointing it out that he is human but still a masterclass performer.

[@OLGA-v4b]

I like the version from the online concert

[@tuttasb5338]

I think that's my favourite version too, Screaming 2021 from Dimash Digital Show

[@fslvcv]

I really enjoy the way you analyse all registers of each version. The way you explain all the web of sounds, and voice, in a understanding way is incredible. Keep your good work! 5 ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️

[@phancuong7289]

The last performance was from a Chinese event where he sang only one song there, unlike in the concert for 2 or 3 hours straight, you should realize that difference, how can Dimash gets exhausted by singing a damn one song? Its his voice, autotune?? Come on man, those notes were easy for him :) you can easily hear the sound a bit flip at 32:27 when he sang the top high staccato note , it proves everything, there are no effects here!

[@dqdreams8251]

Great Dimash..you blow everything up again 🙂❤

[@olmachis]

You missed the "Xmas Screaming" version done two years ago. As always, Dimash surprising with a different version. I discovered it recently.

[@felixruiz6842]

Big hug from Panamá. Thanks for this reaction to our great Dimash.

[@Jeannine2007]

Thank you for taking the time to react to three of the 15 versions of this song. I always enjoy your honest and professional take on your channel. I would love you to reaction to Dimash's Ikanaide where Dimash sings in Japanese for the first time. The melody is also used in Autumn Strong with different lyrics and in Chinese. Ikanaide, (Please) Don't Go, is the original song, different lyrics. Its from the recent 20th Tokyo Jazz Festival. I would also love your reaction to Ómir Óter, steeped in deep meaning and emotions and a surprising MV by Dimash, on his channel. Wishing you and your family a very happy and healthy new year!!

[@bethelliot7140]

Dimash! ❤❤❤ thank you! ☺ 🤗

[@HofTheStage]

Hey Beth, always a pleasure seeing you here! ❤️❤️😍😍

[@bethelliot7140]

@@HofTheStage Thanks! I actually really like the Official video version, such a beautiful video and one of the first songs I remember hearing from Dimash (so a special place in my heart ❤) He tends to sing this song at the end of the concerts so Dears can join in and he can repeat the chorus over and over 😍🔥 same with Daididau

[@chriskorn2238]

Thank you for that reaction. I like, that you made three videos in one to get the development of a song. I agree to most of what you said. I think, the autotuned beginning is a choice of purpose to give a technical character to this song and show a great difference to the operatic part. I really love, how much Dimash is enjoying that performance in Beijing and his voice. It was his first live performance after two years in China and because of the break caused by the pandemic.

[@edriancoracero2685]

About Dimash that was not his first time to do the stacatto in live he sang that before in many times. Maybe you can react his recent performances in youko show in china. His stranger in live and we will rock you with the other singers 😉

[@yoelle16]

Thank you for your honest reaction 🙏. Whatever might have been the reason for the use of autotune just made those particular notes sound weird 🥴. I did hear it when i watched the video the first time. Anyways autotune or not we all know he can sing that's all that matters 🤗

[@nikkimakris1407]

I love everything about Dimash but every artist has a song that just doesn’t click and This is my one and only song I just can’t listen to. I couldn’t understand why but you said it just right when you said it sounded like a polished karaoke song. In absolutely no way does this tarnish Dimash to me it’s just not my cup of tea! BTW I just watched your reaction to Diana’s can’t help falling in love. 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼 Please don’t take too long to react to Crow and Personal Jesus. I will look forward to watch them.

[@HofTheStage]

I totally understand you. I mean, I don't know a single artist from who I love every single song. This one is not my favorite for the stated reasons, but I understand why it's a crowd pleaser at concerts, it has a singable chorus :)

[@kartinihanitio6010]

😄😄 Me too! This is one of the few songs of Dimash that is totally not for me, at all. 😁

[@mimasam5528]

Hey, H of The Stage, Don't tell Dimash was exhausted. After 2 months he did this participation from last one. It was auto-tuned and there is tons of fan cam out there. He was singing outstanding as always. I will give you the fancam link . Here is without auto-tuned fan cam link... kzbin.info/www/bejne/pHeTf5mgeZujqbs

[@bekydelacaridadtoledogutie1839]

Those "weird sounds" were NOT autotuned. You really need to make some search and watch more from Dimash's rare footages, old rehearsals videos, a capella's, then you'll see what I'm saying.

[@Lou16.]

They are auto tuned, either by the sound producers or for artistic choice. Auto tune doesn’t always mean pitch correction and is often used as a sound effect. It is not a big deal and it doesn’t help Dimash to have fans stating he doesn’t use auto tune or doesn’t lip sync.

[@bekydelacaridadtoledogutie1839]

@@Lou16. That's what I think and you need to respect others opinions. I've heard home and fan videos of Dimash singing a Capella with no mic, even in the middle of the street making that same sounds with his voice. I know what I heard. His vocal cords and skills are unique. Dimash doesn't need any help, Dimash needs Love, lots of it, Love and Support and that's what we give him. Some people are just looking for the spots of the Sun when they should be thanking for it's Light and Warmth.

[@sram0425]

luv the HONESTY!!! Thanks so much!!!!!

[@moussakanj8342]

great love your react to our D be cool dears ok he s so honest of all

[@biserkapacas172]

Happy Holidays 🎈🇭🇷Hello from Tripoli, Hrvoju mir i zdravlje

[@ЛюдмилаИсаева-ы2н]

I like all his versions of the song! Dimash is wonderful in all of them!❤❤❤

[@mbierregaard9040]

Thanks for pointing that out with the last video version of this song. Perhaps he was told by the show's producer(s) that auto-tuning would be used and searched for different delivery methods to "avoid" it's use....hence, a quite different sound - ranges that sounded quite different from his other versions and especially his live concert versions.

[@drewisdreaming]

speaking of songs with multiple versions, you HAVE to watch dimash's performance of stranger on the shine brothers show. it absolutely blows my mind every single time i listen to it. you know dimash-he brings something new to every performance, so i promise this one won't bore you :)

[@ЮрийДьяков-я6и]

В этой песне я наслаждался бэквокалистами, песней в их исполнении

[@floracuentas5261]

Thank You Very Much

[@savingtess08]

I'm finding time to catch up to all your dimash reactions. I appreciate the fact that you are such a professional and can pick up things and have the veracity to point them out despite what people may have to say in the comments. For me (and I don't know if it's because I'm a classically trained pianist) but I do have a musical background and I hear an almost metalic sound when a singer is auto-tuned, and I heard it here. Seems CCTV in China has a thing about doing this.

[@WillemKok1963]

Learnt a lot from your analysis. Thank you.

[@Zdmc936]

I read somewhere that the auto tune was used here for artistic purposes in that couple notes so theres nothing wrong with it. Dimash performed twice in this show coz the first one , his belt came off and he has to hold on to his belt while performing, at the end he has to drop the belt together with his ear monitor. He finished the song with no ear monitor. At the end, he was asked to performed again at the end of the show..😘dear from canada

[@patricialascano7448]

En fin muchos hablan mucho....desde sus sillas pero quisiera verlos cantar y hacer todo lo q hace...es genial...único...

[@robinwilkes8164]

He never auto tunes or lip syncs anything!😮❤

[@DimashCollections]

He does and there’s nothing wrong with it since most of his performances, especially solo concerts, are live and not tuned🔥

[@krraylight5682]

I absolutely agree that Dimash makes some parts of the song especially simple for people at the concert so that they can sing along with him. ))) We know that he can add so much complexity and strength that people can't sing with him))). Yes, thank you, I also heard a few notes that the producer corrected, it's not Dimash's fault, it's not much robotic. I just also thought that it wasn't that whether Nata sang the wrong one, it turns out the producers are freaking out there))). Oh, these producers spoil with obvious notes, you can also hear them there.Абсолютно согласен что Димашь некоторые части песни делает специально простыми для людей на концерте, чтобы они могли подпевать с ним вместе. ))) Мы знаем что он может столько много добавить сложного и сильного, что люди не смогут петь с ним))). Да спасибо я тоже услышал несколько нот которые исправил продюсер, это не вина Димаша, немного роботизированно не сильно. Я просто тоже думал чтото не то, чтоли нота не ту спел, оказывается продюсеры чудят там))). Ох уж эти продюсеры портят нотами очевидными там же слышно.

[@maria_chuykina]

Обожаю эту песню, могу слушать её безконечно😍 Очень нравится второе видео с Idol hits, просто огнище😎 и версия с виртуального концерта. Третья версия не очень мне зашла и в тех местах, где Генри показывал, я услышала искажение (автонастрой) в голосе Димаша, не типичные для него😢. Зачем это было сделано непонятно, но Китайцам виднее👀 Генри, благодарю за реакцию аж на три видео👏👏👏 P.S. Для тех, кто хочет смотреть реакции в переводе, используйте яндекс браузер. Перевод немного косноязычный, но основная суть понятна. Меня этот браузер спасает, когда хочется посмотреть интервью или реакции, а субтитры либо только инглишь, либо их вообще нет.

[@sallystubbs7417]

Interesting to hear your comparison of the 3 songs. I enjoy your analyses, and won’t criticize you for pointing out what YOU hear. Your ears are more trained than mine. If you do get criticized, please don’t take it personally. Many of Dimash’s Dears are not native English speakers, so they be offended. I appreciate your honesty.

[@HofTheStage]

Thanks Sally, we need more people like you ❤️

[@redmarsgreenmars8258]

This performance was recorded twice because in the first Dimash lost his belt and he decided to continue singing for a live audience, with the belt in his hand!! But the production decided to shoot it again, but in fact (if i'm not wrong) they use the sound of the first shooting. I don't know if autotune was added by post production or used really by Dimash!!! Merry Christmas and Happy new year!

[@MMariaViktoria]

I agree the 2d version is the best!

[@katyapenick9461]

Dimash was bashed for using the word da INSTEAD of The. He redid the song to show us english people he used his time in quarantine to learn better English. He emphasized the word THE and auto-tuned it for the precision of the word. I commend him for doing it.

[@bekydelacaridadtoledogutie1839]

The Best Singer Ever Walked on this PLANET.

[@DrumL3000]

29:21 Not saying that there is no partial use of pitch correction. But i hear sounds of that live without microphone quite often. In Yodel. It doesnt sound that artificial to me. But yeah could be. Im not sure 100%

[@dennisenriquez5371]

love the studio version :)

[@carolegoodwin8248]

I really enjoyed your enthusiasm and honesty. I do actually enjoy the first and second versions best, but it would be a boring world if we all enjoyed the same thing, don't you think 😉. A while ago was watching a reaction and it annoyed me so much I had to turn it off, it was obvious he had heard the song (SOS) before and was trying to show surprise, but he was showing shock at all the wrong times. I hate it when reactors just react to Dimash hoping to get more subscribers!!! I am a huge fan Dear of Dimash and have enjoyed many many songs from him. He even made me enjoy a jazzy song and I have never ever heard a jazz song I liked same with rapping! But I do love this man's voice but I know he's only human something he admits to himself. He is going to be ill from time to time but even when he is ill he will blow your mind at some point during the show. Thanks so much for all your time in producing this video it was very informative and interesting. Please take care 🤗