Comparing my 2021, 2022 & 2023 Top 5 Eyeshadow Palettes!

[@Soulecitou]

What an interesting concept! I love anything with eyeshadow palette ranking and comparisons. 😊 The Vega palette restocks and sells out in a heartbeat. 😢

[@daniellezadora7637]

Ikr!! 😂 been trying to snag that sucker for a year!!!

[@melina_m_makeup]

What an awesome concept ranking the last 3 years of palettes! Isn't it so interesting how our interests and aesthetics change over the years?? And eyeshadow quality truly has gotten so much better in the last 2 years! I knew the PM Moonlit and INAN would be your faves! You should start doing these for your foundation and complexion products too! Like are some older products still standing the test of time? And I loved the live yesterday!! ❤❤❤❤ Def need to make those a monthly thing! 😊

[@MartinaLily]

Ohh that’s such a good idea, thanks Melina!!! And yes my makeup has changed so much each year. I’m so glad you loved the live. We honestly had the best time! 💗💗

[@melina_m_makeup]

@@MartinaLily yes!! I enjoyed it! I was so happy so many people showed up! I mean it was hard to keep up with the comments! And we had a celebrity show up! Miss Alicia Archer herself! How exciting! We were just missing Mariam!!

[@roxypaquette9501]

Martina, I’d love to see your top 25 palettes in your entire collection!

[@StevenForditude]

All I can think about is how time means nothing because I swear some of these 2021 palettes just came out 😅

[@DeliciaTrini]

That Moonlit Seduction is so classy. That peacock special shade in combination with the plum mattes is a stunner!

[@MartinaLily]

Cannot agree more! 💗💗

[@elissacox4291]

Lol clearly I need to dig mine out and use it. I purchased it during a sale with an added glitch that made my order around 25% of RRP, so I just threw it in my cart fully expecting the order would be cancelled. But no, I received it, and so that palette has just sat there unused so far. You have made me decide to dig it out and actually use it though!

[@DeliciaTrini]

@@elissacox4291 it’s a stunner! You won’t regret it! I wear my PML palettes daily. The first six shades are work and day friendly. The last four shades are for a night out. I can’t see myself spending all that money for an eyeshadow palette and not wear it. Enjoy!🙌🏽💕

[@tamipie]

Today I did a "cold girl" with a little turquoise colourpop on the lids...but I am always reaching for a little Pat McGrath. Some smokey sparkle from that dark green on the bottom row of Celestial Odyssey, and the old 3 pan highlighter palette has my FAVORITE inner corner moments. Yum.😊

[@MartinaLily]

A little sparkle on the daily is a must 🙌🏼💗💗

[@geniebates4913]

Moonlit Seduction is a good one it gives me Great Gatsby vibes

[@rebeccawainwright4515]

I love this video idea! And of course it was Moonlit Seduction, that one never leaves my bathroom makeup kit either ❤ And your makeup look is incredible, can’t wait to see that video!

[@MartinaLily]

You just can’t go past moonlit seduction! Thank you so much lovely 💗💗

[@teganmacgregor6492]

I wouldn't get my hopes up about the next mothership 😂 just put your expectations extremely low and maybe we'll be pleasantly surprised by a pop of green or something

[@ashleyhaver1132]

Alert! The Vega palette is available on the Lisa Eldridge website today!

[@jamiecordwell8454]

I just found you the other day and already i absolutely love you! This is a fabulous video idea!!! I dont believe i have ever seen anyone else do this type of makeup video!! Lol ..and i watch alot of makeup video creators lol

[@shawndickson2390]

I got the Vega!!!!!!! It became available on her website. The weird thing was it said something about shipping and I chose the Global site and it wasn’t available but if you choose US site they are ALL available!!!!!

[@maythompson6228]

Your earrings are stellar !

[@jillstarkel4425]

You are so brave!! I couldn't possibly rank any of my babies lol I definitely have used my Ta matte pallet alot this last year. It's a great companion addition to my special shades collection. I need a nude would also be tops. So fun to see different preferences. Thanks Martina! Much love 💋💚

[@catherinelynnfraser2001]

Thank you! This was a surprising treat. I am so happy you are continuing to enjoy them. I am focusing on the makeup I own and love so this kind of overview is perfect for me. Rumour has it that Industrial 2.0 won’t be restocked. You don’t have rank your precious.

[@MartinaLily]

I’m so glad you enjoyed it! I just heard that too about industrial 2.0 sooo sad 😢😢💗💗

[@reneeallred5082]

I have like 10 of these lol. And I want the Danessa Myricks one

[@mintkandi22]

I love the concept of this video! I knew a Mothership Palette was going to make it in your top three and I knew the Danessa Myricks Groundwork palette was going to make it to the top three because you said that you use every time you do a makeup look. I love your channel! You create great content!

[@smilechicana]

These are my favorite type of videos 🎉🎉🎉❤

[@Lynnonymous]

This is a great video idea! I'm actually excited to see.

[@shalinironcato5262]

This was a fun video idea. Congrats again on 15k!

[@dawnbonome9056]

Hi Martina. Loved the livestream with Blair…YOU ARE a ROCKSTAR! Do you find that eye shadow goes bad after 2 or 3 years? Have you thrown out old eye shadow? 👍🏻👍🏻up and have a great Sunday…or it’s probably Monday in Australia now.

[@MartinaLily]

Thank you so much Dawn! It was the best time so I’m glad you guys had fun!! Mmm depends on the brand I find. I’ve not had any of my expensive brands lose their quality yet the only time I have personally found shadows expired was with my old Colourpop palettes 💗💗

[@dawnbonome9056]

Thanks for the reply. I don’t have any CP so that is good👍🏻

[@AP-my9ic]

enjoy this video so much! How about another video ranking the top 20 eyeshadow palettes that you own over all the years? Because when watching this video i cannot stop guessing how you would rank your Mothership I, Mothership VII, or the Rose Topaz Quad, etc. if those were included

[@suzroundy]

Love this idea for a ranking!

[@cindyh303]

I love this comparison. It's great to see how palettes are stacking up next to newer competition. And these palettes are all still relevant to eyeshadow lovers. I very much appreciate this! ❤

[@marionallen2222]

🤍🤍🤍🤍🤍🤍🤍🤍🤍🤍 🤍🤍🤍🤍🤍🤍🤍🤍 loved your live yesterday… always love eyeshadow content … you do the best comparisons and swatches!!!

[@MartinaLily]

Aww yay!! Thank you so so much 💗💗💗

[@zurierae2106]

Great video! I’m impressed you did this video in the timeframe you did! Granted I would have watched regardless. But it’s impressive swatches and all! Your number 1 and 2 picks are my favorites! Congrats on 15k🎉

[@MartinaLily]

Thank you! 💗💗

[@suethompson8716]

Love this idea. Thanks for sharing!

[@cocoloco8922]

Oooh I’m excited for this 😊

[@charlenejensen3559]

Loved the video! Congrats on 15K!!! ❤🥳

[@MartinaLily]

Thank you so much 🤗💗💗

[@choosebetter]

Such a fun video idea, ❤

[@catherinebell122]

Love your passion for eye shadows and your coloring is about the same as mine, so never miss a video😎❤️

[@MartinaLily]

Aw thank you so much!! 💗💗

[@JorgeGarcia-cj3nc]

Im so happy 😁☺️ i love your makeup

[@mariamagdalenaduranceccopi6760]

Beautiful eyeshadow palettes, THE best. Thank you Martina for show us YOURS PALETTES. 👍👍👍🌷💝💄👡

[@MartinaLily]

Thank you lovely 💗💗💗

[@lnegz]

Love watching all of your vids

[@brookezab7290]

Love this idea! And so many gems in that 15! I have been toying with reorganising my motherships because I have the same gripe - no light mattes for the base in some of them. I would put that subliminal taupe in moonlit seduction and the world would be perfect 😂❤

[@elissacox4291]

The pans should be removable. Making our own Motherships without having to fully depot the shades would be so much fun

[@deborahcates]

Love this ranking! A few comments: I was one of those that missed out on Vega, but I just got it, it’s back in stock!! Also Natasha is having a sale on her two Retro Midis and the Mini Retro right now. Last, I feel like Moonlit Seduction has not four but five special shades, because that middle one in the top row is just gorgeous. I am not holding out hope that Pat will bring out any more Motherships like the OG ones, but if she did, I would be there for it. Thanks for all the palette fun! ❤

[@MartinaLily]

Totally agree with all of this! I hope you love Vega when you get it!!! 💗💗💗

[@lavayuki]

This was a great idea! I loved the ND glam face light palette even today although I never use the blush in it, the Glam midi and my dream midi are top faves from here though. The ABH Cosmos palette was my favourite 2023 palette as I love all the shimmers. From Lisa Eldridge I quite like the look of the Sorcery palette for the green and blue

[@lynettefinnigan9540]

I love a good comparison and ranking post 👍👍 that Charlotte Tilbury palette is lovely, Pat McGrath is great for those sparkles, but theres always fallout issues, a lot of Indie brands have the sparkles, the gloss, the metalics and the Colours!!! And not as much fallout... do you try any of the Australian brands Martina?? Naito, Kind, etc.. vegan, animal frielndly, etc 👍👍 the Naito tubing mascara is brilliant.

[@MartinaLily]

Thanks lovely! I've tried Natio in the past and just really didn't like what I tried to be honest and then now I don't shop for makeup at Priceline cos I'm more attracted personally to luxury makeup so I think that's why I don't really try too many AU brands 💗💗

[@nidiadoherty5405]

This was fun! And a good reminder to shop my stash for some old faves.

[@megdvs21]

What a fun idea 😀🙂hope you’re having a good week 💕 for me it’s hands down i need a nude with a small caveat i personally rearranged the shades vague and whit with the shades nurture from midi my dream and blend from midi glam and i put vague and whit in another color story and now the i need a nude with those to switches is the palette that never leaves my every day makeup table collection

[@bobbi5523]

Love Yucca also, I had no intention of buying it as colors didn't speak to me then I tried it, saw videos... tried it. OMG... awesome palette. Thanks, great video

[@jinyan3297]

Genius idea for a yt video!!! Love it 😍

[@lisanadile4688]

Just found you and subbed. I’m in Connecticut, US. I really enjoy your content.

[@ct7531]

Great idea for a video!

[@RoseOfMadina]

Love this video!

[@QueerBones]

Love this concept! I might to do a similar video

[@marionallen2222]

Great choices!!!! I love X too!!! And my dream and retro and INAN everything Natasha lol!!!! Glam is still my no1 it’s impossible to choose 🤣🤣🤣 really love Divine Rose too omg and I just got VI the green with the gold on top 💋💋💋 chefs kiss and the mauve with gold on top I think they are all the same gold glitter 🤣🤣🤣

[@MartinaLily]

It’s so hard choosing between all the palettes cos they are so stunning! 💗💗💗

[@ShellySims1988]

Loved the video, cool ranking! I just got my PM Moonlit seduction in the mail and I can't wait to play with it!! Have a beautiful day ❤️❤️

[@MartinaLily]

Thank you! And yay!! I hope you love it, it’s sooo lovely 💗💗

[@veronicahayes2635]

Love this idea for a video. Keep this coming for next year

[@MartinaLily]

Shall do! 💗💗💗

[@Tiaratisha]

I cry every time I see the Metropolitan palette 😢 So upset I missed out!

[@stephieshappymadness]

Good day😊 Loved yesterday's video❤❤❤

[@MartinaLily]

Thank you! 💗💗

[@eilidhmackinnon485]

I wish we got glamanatrixs and visiart here in the uk.

[@catherinelynnfraser2001]

Beauty Bay carries some Viseart. Viseart might ship direct. It takes forever but I buy direct from Viseart. They have a point system and cover taxes and duty but not shipping to Canada.

[@MerelB92]

Monolith EU ships to the UK ans they have glaminatrix.

[@frommylittlecorner]

I need that top 3 un muy life!!! What's on your eyes btw?

[@katebruckner3731]

Really cool Video 💪

[@MartinaLily]

Thank you! 💗💗💗

[@ShonaMM75]

This was such a great ranking and awesome concept - with the twist at the end where all of them are up against each other, so here for it! I would love moonlit seduction - it’s on the list and will be mine eventually I feel. ❤ Maybe next we could have blushes and then lips? Not that I’m greedy or anything. 🤣❤

[@adrian-rx8rg]

I am absolutely heartbroken that Industrial 2.0 won’t be permanent in Isamaya’s collection and I don’t know where else to take it lol

[@MartinaLily]

I know!! I can’t believe she isn’t making it permanent! It’s sooo good!!!

[@DrTaid]

🩺

[@tianiortiz8529]

❤❤

[@rena7123]

💎✨

[@leighriley-hj3ei]

Can you please start writing in description or comments what you are wearing ..loads of times i want to kno and look and its not there ..thanku you look lovely ❤

[@MartinaLily]

Aw thank you! I'll be honest my clothes are usually soo old that they are even able to be bought anymore cos I really don't buy clothes a lot. But if they are I will link them for sure 💗💗

[@whippetgood]

Ooh I got the Danessa Myricks groundwork palette in my Beautylish lucky bag and have really no idea how to use it 🫣 Would love a tutorial or some inspiration on how you’re using it!

[@MartinaLily]

Ohh you will love it! Check out this one cos I pretty much still use it like this everyday - kzbin.info/www/bejne/hKupYYt5jLl5hc0si=9w98BZFE0WBjl7eR I honestly use this palette for brows, contour & eyeshadow nearly everyday 💗💗