Comparison : Nikon Nikkor 35mm f/1.4 Ai-s vs 35mm f/1.4G

[@50mmnikonainikkor55]

This is so informative! thank you. The images from the ai-s is so naturally beautiful.

[@diyextravaganza]

Thanks, I love the rendition of the Ai-s too

[@hellogamiesai6135]

i would go for the ais, the only possitive on the G is a bit sharper on 1.4, but on F2 -F2.8 -F4 is a matter of a personal preference... Plus the AIS is half the price

[@diyextravaganza]

Totally true

[@Samsung9alaxy]

Very interesting. I have just purchased a 35mm f1.4 AI-S (not yet arrived). Your video has highlighted the weaknesses and strengths of the lens. Thank you.

[@diyextravaganza]

Hi, thanks for commenting, the Ai-s is a wonderful lens, enjoy it ! Cheers

[@richardsimms251]

Very helpful video ! Thank you. RS Canada

[@diyextravaganza]

Thanks a lot ! Don^t forget to tell all your friends about the channel.

[@diyextravaganza]

:)

[@patduz]

Good work. The AF-S 35mm f/1.4 is fare better. I used for years the Ai-S 35mm f/1.4 on my Nikon F4 at the time.

[@diyextravaganza]

Thanks !

[@Narsuitus]

Thanks for the comparison video. I have owned and used the 35mm f/1.4 since 2002. I would never replace my AIS lens with a G lens because I use my lens on newer digital Nikon SLR cameras and older Nikon SLR film cameras. My older film cameras need an aperture ring and G lenses do not have one.

[@diyextravaganza]

That's a good point. Although good, G lenses have another flaw, they have built in motors that will fail eventually. Manual lenses need only a good service from time to time and they can keep going forever. Cheers.

[@ambu5h.105]

Best 35mm ais video on the whole internet. No kidding

[@diyextravaganza]

Thanks a lot, the 35mm 1.4 holds a special place in my heart. Do not forget to share with friends. Best.

[@yokakeshinowakane]

Awesome Video, Thanks Boss!

[@diyextravaganza]

Thanks a lot !

[@harrisfogel6992]

What camera body were you using? Where these images JPEGs or RAW files?

[@diyextravaganza]

raw files, I used a D800 and a D3x for the comparisons. D4s for photos shown in the beginning of the video.

[@ohjajohh]

I always love vintage lenses! Great video

[@diyextravaganza]

Vintage lenses are the best, they last longer, perform sometimes better and are lot cheaper than their modern equivalents. Don't forget to like, subscribe, and tell your friends about the channel. Cheers.

[@sclogse1]

I think the Fuji 1.4 would easily compete with the G in edge sharpness, but then again, it's a crop sensor, so you'll always get the best of the lens.

[@diyextravaganza]

Sounds interesting, I'll look for the opportunity of having a Fuji borrowed or something.

[@jkirk888]

I think everyone is overlooking the beautiful building quality of the manual lens. And just look at the size difference! I think the older lens will long outlast the newer lens.

[@diyextravaganza]

That's for sure, I've disassembled more recent lenses and the quality level is many levels below the manual ones. I recently bought the first series of the 35mm 1.4, it is fantastic!!!

[@hectorquiteno]

I have the AIS, don´t find it that unsharp, hope is your copy!

[@diyextravaganza]

The AIs is sharp but the G version is way sharper.

[@docpearson]

Where did they listen to the entire video could you please tell me what they knew G lenses work on the odor AIS cameras. Thank you

[@diyextravaganza]

I think they work down to f90 cameras. Cheers

[@lensman5762]

The G lens has better coatings and is a better performer @ F1.4 and maybe @ F2. The close up photos were interesting it look as if the AIS version maybe suffering from focus breathing, or I could be wrong there.

[@diyextravaganza]

Focus breathing is not a thing linked with the AF or I understand wrong?

[@diyextravaganza]

Also, It is a matter of taste, I like all versions of the 35 1.4, recently I got the 1971 version, and I really like it's aberrations.

[@lensman5762]

It has nothing to do with AF. Its a fuction of the optical design of the lens. From F2 onwards, I prefer the rendering of the AIS version, but as you said, why buy a F1.4 lens and not use it @ F1.4? At this setting the G is the superior lens.@@diyextravaganza

[@diyextravaganza]

@@lensman5762 Thanks for the info, I'm planning in making a video on the optical evolution of the 35mm F1.4

[@eryck123]

Ai-S lens is a bit more interesting imo. The 1.4G is obviously better performing, but it looks "perfect" just like any other modern, lens kinda meh

[@diyextravaganza]

Exactly! a less perfect lens allow more creative options. too perfect lenses is what is overflowing the internet, the same pictures everywhere.

[@NerveNet]

Great work!

[@diyextravaganza]

Thanks a lot Javier !

[@SunJigglet]

Thank you for a very informative video.

[@diyextravaganza]

You're welcome my friend !

[@SunJigglet]

@@diyextravaganza ordered an AI-S specimen. Should be receiving it in two days :)

[@diyextravaganza]

@@SunJigglet fantastic lens that I like very much. I'll be posting some videos on how to service it in case you need it in the future.

[@SunJigglet]

@@diyextravaganza Great!

[@bradl2636]

Voigtlander 40mm f2 Ultron.... $420

[@diyextravaganza]

Never had tested that lens before.

[@bradl2636]

@@diyextravaganza definitely worth a try particularly given the focal length and price

[@diyextravaganza]

@@bradl2636 If I ever come across one, I'll consider testing it.

[@ornitotorinque]

Ais exceptionnel

[@diyextravaganza]

Agree ! :)