Confronting A Pit Bull With An Addiction To Attack | Cesar 911 Season 2, Ep. 7 - Part 1

In this episode of Cesar 911, I meet Pit Bull named Roxy. Roxy tries to attack every dog she sees to the point where the neighborhood is in fear. Her owners are fearful of Roxy to the point where they think she is hunting. I must help these owners control Roxy or it can mean danger for themselves and others. Remember: dogs are not born aggressive, we make them aggressive.
Want more? Click the link below & subscribe to be the first to know when my new videos come out.
www.youtube.co...
FOLLOW CESAR & THE PACK:
Instagram: / cesarsway
Twitter: / cesarmillan
Facebook: / cesarmillan
TikTok: / imcesarmillan
READY FOR TRAINING? SIGN UP TO ONE OF MY COURSES:
www.trainingce...
Learn more about dog training, dog psychology, pet care, and shop for exclusive products at www.cesarsway.com
My Mission: Better Humans, Better Planet
Always remember: Trust, Respect, & Love

[@PeteO5D]

When she asked how long they would need to be like this (calm and assertive) i knew this wasn't going to work

[@joanpeters9361]

I'm worried about the kids. "How long do I have to be a parent to my children?"

[@hildajensen6263]

Yeah. This is definitely the wrong kind of dog for her. All dogs need good leaders, but not all dogs have the same drive to step in and do something - or can do the same amount of damage. Was their former dog original her husbands and to old to bother with her and her weak energy when they moved in together? What really get to me, is how her youngest have to step in and comfort her. Those kids are going to spend the rest of their lives trying not to upset their mother. And she will absolutely not understand it, when one of them finally withdraws because it's just to draining.

[@rosewaters2533]

She should just get a hamster.

[@oluijks]

You are the scientist who knows it all

[@olihallam9667]

@@rosewaters2533 Yeah, they shouldn't own any dog. The way they allowed the Pitbull to interact with kids when they were saying goodbye, it could of been one of those kids next if it wasn't another dog.

[@Jay57T]

From handling dogs to handling people, Cesar is in a class of his own.

[@tracyanne8616]

I think he is always teaching the people.

[@go.along.get-along.888]

I wonder does he take the naughty dogs around the back and whoop a bit of submission and obedience into them first 🤔?

[@Tatt2dmoon]

I agree ❤

[@MrHardhead2]

This guy is a fraud. Nothing less

[@christophepeigney4315]

Of course, the dogs taught him how to manipulate humans.

[@michaeleverest3487]

The woman is just too fearful and not at all capable of leading a dog like this... check out her face when Cesar was telling her to be assertive but then she asked if she had to be like that all the time or could she take breaks 😂

[@Em_jsnsn]

I was dying at that part. She is very weak sadly

[@cherylcheongchoonyin9516]

She better don’t get another dog EVER !

[@JorgeHernandezR]

Right that part had me weak lol, she was like “oh and do I always have to be like this or only when training” like bruh you have to be consistent and practice it at all times, just as you would be with your kids all times, you have to keep up with a dog as well and make sure they stay inline at all times because animals can get curious and get themselves into trouble because of that, so you always gotta keep an eye on them.

[@ungphuc]

why wouldn’t someone want to be calm confident assertive at all time? she must have so much past trauma. She needs couseling

[@obelix_gaul]

It's not normal for her and she's uncomfortable, that's why she was asking

[@reneeseaton3889]

I appreciate this family for being vulnerable and allowing others to see when it is best to not have a dog.

[@karendegraaf1146]

Sad they keep getting large, more aggressive breeds of dogs

[@anatellez8559]

They just didn’t want to bear to put down another dog like they did to the Rottweiler. These people is not compatible with powerful dog breeds, not even with cats! They need birds as pets. Mom is not strong enough to lead any pack. Sadly.

[@cachi-7878]

Yeah, I see this over and over when watching Cesar rehabilitate not only the dog, but also the owners. The problem with these people is that they raise their pets the same way they raise their kids, i.e., spoil them, no rules, no assertion, no discipline, no limits. When you raise kids like that, they become the mass shooter at your local school, the uncontrolled kid in school or irresponsible adult at work. Cesar made the right albeit difficult decision to take Roxy away from their owners. Well done Cesar!

[@Alexucks66]

That's a bit extreme don't you think…

[@wishbone7147]

All the mom wanted was the cuddles and kisses but not do the work to truly make the dog happy. Thankfully Cesar saw that from the first minute he met her and saved the life of an innocent dog

[@dickfitswell3437]

Sounds like my female neighbor who had two pitbulls. She would tell me "its all about how you raise them. My two are lap dogs that just want to give kisses." One day she opened her front door to leave for work. I was next door, in my own yard, washing my truck and facing away from her and unaware of what was about to happen. They bolted past her legs and sprinted across her yard and then across my yard and then I hear a faint "no no no" and by the time I turn my head, I am hit by a truck which turned out to be her two pitbulls. They sunk their teeth into my leg and took me down and start dragging me away. I reach up and grab my bumper and had a tug of war with my leg. I have adrenaline pumping and pull myself up to the tailgate and start inching my body into the truck bed and i still have two fully grown snarling pitbulls violently shaking their heads still attached to my leg. I get my body in and i remember trying to break my own leg off my body in order to stop the immense pain of their teeth dragging on my bones. The owner is now hitting them and hanging on them to get them to let go and they won't. They were on a mission to end my life and if I was a child and not a Marine, then I wouldn't have lived. The strength they had was unlike anything I ever felt. In the Marines we do martial arts training and i trained with Marines larger than myself and these dogs were stronger. I can still smell their breath and hear the sounds they were making during their frenzy. After a few mins of screaming and her beating on her pitbulls two of my big male neighbors realized what was happening and they both ran over and they let go. Finally. Its not how you raise a pitbull. She did everything right. Its their DNA. For whatever reason, these two dogs flipped their switch and I was the target. I had never interacted with them. They saw me daily for several years, going to my truck everyday for work. I didn't even acknowledge them. Inside the ambulance the EMT told me I was the second pitbull attack that week. The first attack the pitbulls owner was sitting in a recliner reading a book and for no reason her pitbull jumped up and bit her face and held on and took her to the ground. By the time help arrived the pitbull had taken off her nose and both lips and I actually saw the woman in town a year later and she is horribly disfigured and will have multiple surgeries to try to make her look normal. So my neighbor was responsible for the costs. She had to pay over $10,000 in medical bills and had I not had insurance it would have been 5x that and a judge would have sold her car and house in order to satisfy the judgement. She tried to use her homeowners insurance, nornal insurance, and some other insurance but she found out that that breed or any breed that has pitbull in it, cant be insured because of their violent nature and history of being the breed that takes the most lives each year and takes the most children's life each year and the most unprovoked attacks each year and the next breed down, isnt even close. I have lifelong scars and now PTSD around dogs. I have seen my own bones amd thigh muscle and tendons. It was awful. A married couple both just got 18 years in prison each for the death their pitbull caused when jt attacked an elderly woman and when her husband went to save her the dog attacked him so bad his injuries were fatal. So anyone reading this, you've been warned. This breed has a bunch of groups trying to change it's image and they are so disingenuous its sad. You could get lucky and the pitbull never flips into genetics mode or it could take your childs life for no reason. My neighbor lost both dogs after quarantine and they were put down. She also lost over ten thousand dollars and it could have easily been $50,000 had I sued for emotional damages as it still has me messed up. I now have to ask if someone has a pitbull before entering their house(if i dont know them) and it's embarrassing. So please take my advice and do not risk it. Sure a black lab or boxer could hurt you but the chances are close to nothing especially compared to a pitbull. They were bred to be violent and they are they just suppress it, until one day the switch flips

[@simrdownmon6431]

She should adopt a lab. What's up with the obsession people have with owner dominate dogs. Stsight up s t u p I d I t y.

[@itsOtiyana93]

Especially saw this when she asked if she had to always be assertive and calm. YES YOU DO

[@biancadoust8141]

They need to stop getting dogs and get a cat 😂 get the cuddles from a cat and you don't have to walk it win win

[@v12alpine]

@@simrdownmon6431 labs can be very aggressive. maybe a smaller dog for her.

[@kavericornett6748]

Cesar was so correct about Natalie & her influence on Roxy….he’s such a great dog/human psychologist

[@paulahasratian3263]

They are doing something wrong with any dog because this happened before. I’m so happy Roxy has a Caesar.

[@maryjane4432]

Exactly they put down a rottie bc of this woman. She needs a goldfish not another dog

[@IndigoBellyDance]

If u get a ‘strong’ breed u need to know how to handle a dog like this. They need to get gentler breeds of dogs

[@tritchie6272]

They keep getting strong breeds which aren't a good fit for them. I think they mean well,but don't have the ability or temperament for much more than maybe a beagle or basset. They need something super gentle and cuddly. That or give up on dogs.

[@Timmywhimmy]

Imo, they shouldn't have any pets. Even goldfish would suffer. Just because goldfish are hardy doesnt mean they dont suffer when their owners dont make sure its environment is optimal. Same for other 'easy' pets. Also, both the parents are unsuitable to have pets. They're unable or unwilling? to see that they themselves are the problem, not the animals. Hopefully I'm wrong...

[@mayraperez7681]

Anyone who wishes to buy or adopt any kind of dog, no matter the size. Should watch all of Cesar’s videos. Thank you for helping me with me with my 2 year old dachshund.

[@Gusto20000]

The problem is - responsible people already know this and irresponsible ones wouldn’t care

[@jayfangRSA]

16:52 Cesar's expression when asked "is it like that forever" 😂

[@alizehlatif1424]

i know. really stupid lol

[@jasonriddle4492]

You could literally see him trying to understand if what he was hearing really coming out of that lady's mouth lol

[@PonyTracks]

No,not with these people as dig owners...idiots

[@miriamrobarts]

I think the problem could be that she doesn't understand the difference between being aggressive and being assertive. I think she felt like she had to present as something that wasn't herself, and play a role. What she needed was the confidence to take control -- of her own emotions, & the dog. Good discipline isn't being aggressive; it's being calm & in control. For a well behaved dog, the person always has to be the boss. You can be a kind boss, but you have to be in control.

[@lostboy2637]

that slow head turn was so funny 🤣

[@jadewhite1]

the fact she could walk next to multiple dogs at a time with cesar but goes home for 3 days and attacks a dog says it all. maybe they should look into getting a cat

[@alang4033]

I wouldn't even trust this family with a cat. Not even a house plant to be honest.

[@alexandram.2714]

Why? Don't send a cat into a hellhole.

[@iordanisG]

maybe they should get a goldfish or a parrot

[@sk8ercaligirl]

They need to buy many stuffed animals and plush toys or a plastic fish, or a plastic dinosaur. Many choices here 😂

[@AbrahamCenteno-pl5de]

House plant u crazy 😂​@@alang4033

[@Kaleshalex29]

respect for cesar

[@rsu5327]

Exactly, he is a Saint!! Saivor to many!! God sent!!!😇💯🙏🏻

[@adriandelatorre8341]

True Pack Leader

[@SandraPriebe-b3p]

They created an aggressive Rottweiler, so they thought it was a good idea to get a Pitt bull? Good grief.

[@kc-n-sassy]

i agree maybe a black lab or softer dog.

[@jejo9863]

😂😂

[@johndavid3598]

How about a nice poodle?

[@kc-n-sassy]

@@johndavid3598 nice poodle... no such thing lol

[@PaulM745]

I was thinking the exact same thing....

[@Suebb71]

Another example of don't get the dog you want, get the dog you need. Cesar saved a life again here. The family would be far better suited to a softer breed, they are sadly the type of family that unwittingly contribute to the the negative public perception of stronger breeds. They can all be fantastic family dogs when paired with the right owners. Brilliant work Cesar ❤️

[@The_Candyman86]

Thumbs up to the owners for doing whats best for the dog. its not easy when you have had a dog for years and have to let it go like that. Cesar is so right saying Natalie is not compatible with the dog. u can clearly see this when she is walking Roxy, no control and no discipline. They seem like great parents. Nice family and Cesar is the GOAT. master of the dog world.

[@stevejette2329]

Ceasr TOLD HER the dog wasn't ready !!! She wanted immediate family fun. She seems to be the problem ?

[@Unclerucki]

She is the problem ..

[@anthonyml7]

She wants to do w/e she wants, not whats best for the pack

[@Unclerucki]

@@anthonyml7 the story of life

[@maryjane4432]

@@Uncleruckinot true at all. I’ve always had powerful breeds. Currently have a German shepherd and a pit/rottie mix. I’m in charge and they know it. I’m only 5’2 and they know I’m their pack leader

[@holzbock6663]

she's not very bright

[@cecilelyons7178]

Thank you Cesar. You are so revered by millions of people because you give dogs a 2nd chance when the owner hasn't understood their capacity to condemn a dog's life. God bless.

[@rsu5327]

Y E S! My thoughts too!!🥰💯💯

[@micheleparadis2808]

Well said

[@GmanfromTexas]

Seems this family always chose strong will breeds. They are not ready for them

[@LadieKadie]

No family should chose a pit bull. Way too unpredictable.

[@tyreselee]

@@LadieKadienot true at all lol

[@sandyescoto5060]

​@@LadieKadieYour an idiot for All your negative comments on pitbulls!!!

[@andychisarick6879]

You're right, I can see it now..."Roxy is gone, honey can we go out this weekend & get a bulldog?" Yikes. Anything more than a purse dog for this woman is too much. They oughta think about getting a cat.

[@andychisarick6879]

​@@tyreseleeyeah, in a way- kind of, not really maybe but in a way this family might understand- its like learning to ride a bike & starting w/ a big ol' Harley instead of a bicycle w/ training wheels

[@samhartford8677]

The family made the right choice. They recognised they could not change themselves. It was a brave thing to do and the children learnt from that.

[@flapjackson6077]

Clearly the family didn’t project the energy needed to handle Roxy, but they’re a beautiful, loving family who recognized that fact. Seeing little Marcus broken up was heartbreaking. Brought tears to my eyes. Some of the comments here are highly critical of the owners. I think it’s more appropriate to appreciate their humility and painful decision to let go of a dog they loved so much. I respect them for that.

[@Alexucks66]

They killed the other dog

[@yzzimzerep7249]

This story broke my soul. God bless Cesar for accepting Roxy. ❤

[@ugurali]

Love is not about affection and cuddles, love is understanding other's needs and nurture them on that way. They are dogs and their needs are different than human. Main problem with most of the owners in this series is that they dont want to accept it..

[@deborahkate1849]

yes , and this doggie was not getting adequate exercise either...

[@kittywilhite9583]

More that they don't KNOW it.

[@HkFinn83]

People have gone hysterical with dogs. My entire Facebook feed is full of this insanity about snuggle bugs and fur babys. Meanwhile the dog are a nightmare to be around.

[@uclajd]

Yikes, a grown pittie and they haven't even taught her not to jump up on people? That's puppy 101. And I say this as someone who had a dog aggressive 80lbs pittie. God bless Cesar salvaging troubled dogs.

[@bethsullivan4613]

The dog is absolutely NOT "troubled"! Everything negative that happened was 1000% the owners fault.

[@isabelgabilondo1713]

Horrible dog

[@5GreenAcres]

@@isabelgabilondo1713 Horrible owners.

[@klerain5774]

I love that Cesar says "they're not born aggressive, we make them that way." I've been an advocate for pitfalls for many years and that is what I say including "it's the owners, not the pitbull." My daughter has a pitbull that is the sweetest boy

[@DogLover_365]

💯💯💯💯🐾🐾🐾 much love to you for being an advocate for the breed

[@tripfisk4246]

A dog, like a child, is what you make it. I have two pittie girls and they've never bared their teeth or displayed aggression, even when little dogs have snapped at them. A lot of people are horrible dog owners and simply shouldn't have the big strong breeds they have.

[@Callidus7SSM]

Exactly! It’s so sad that pit breeds seem to be magnet for irresponsible, fearful, or lazy dog owners because the dogs get the blame instead of the people who chose a dog because it was a fashionable breed (or because they just like the way they look) instead of because it was a good fit for their personality and lifestyle.

[@v12alpine]

my pit was getting a bit aggressive (nipping) early on but we nipped it in the bud. She's a sweetheart now.

[@shawnw8046]

What does the owner do wrong that makes the dog want to attack everything?

[@Tazdevildearnaley]

Crying watching this, poor fur baby needed people that could consistently bring out her amazing side, thank you cesar for taking on that beautiful soul. ❤

[@NobodyCares6996]

One thing that really annoys me is when people have a problem with something and are clearly clueless and then an esteemed professional warns them not to do something and they insist on doing it and it goes poorly. It's one thing if what they're doing isn't going to have an effect on anyone else but this sure did. People need to put their pride down and ask themselves, "Am I a professional in this field with years of experience?“ If the answer is no then you should probably listen to the professional.

[@angelaratzay9034]

This is an old video. Why do these people always go for the stronger bigger breed?.like a small man with a big truck !

[@Osprey1994]

It wasn't pride. It was weakness.

[@Speurneuscosmo]

Some people aren’t aware of their own problems. When you got a dog, a horse or other sensitive animal. But mostly an animal you have to work together. You have to change your own behavoir. Animals, especially dogs, are a mirror of you. Then, the next problem is, is a dog owner willing to change, have goals and ask for help. A dog is the best therapist to show you your good and your bad side. As an owner you can ignore that.

[@kasiflavor1931]

​@@angelaratzay9034😂😂😂😂

[@scottnever8732]

i feel thats not to do with video

[@dixieturner7402]

Watching your shows helped rid me of my fear of large or snarly dogs. Realizing that dogs have their own "language" and we have to learn that and act accordingly changed it all for me. Thank you!

[@perlah8407]

You have the incredible once in a lifetime opportunity to have Cesar help your dog be the best dog, and you want to take him home before time😢 whyyyyy whyyyy?

[@bradashlock]

I got bit in the face by my own Rottweiler I couldn’t control. Now let’s get a pit bull! Really smart people….

[@katestevens86]

Dear Cesar, what follows is a litany of people ridiculing, judging and condemning a woman and her family for being brave enough to reach out for help and taking it. Then the family tried their hardest to do what needed to be done, but at the end of the day, they realized they weren't the right family for the dog they had and made the difficult but kindest decision to relinquish the dog to someone who was a better fit for her. In all of the videos of yours I've watched, I've never seen you be discriminatory or judgemental or blaming with the families you work with. You are always kind and generous and respectful. The comments after every one of your videos on KZbin are always angry and blaming. Why do people seem to miss that part of your message? SIgned, a fan

[@btflnvyasmr164]

People always miss the bigger message when anyone is trying to teach through love or acceptance.

[@Alexucks66]

They killed the first dog because of their incompetence, did not try to get help and did the same thing again

[@bayadere8308]

"...being brave enough to reach out for help and taking it." On the contrary, neither the ability to understand the advice nor to heed it. "Then the family tried their hardest..." Don't make me laugh. "...made the difficult but kindest decision to relinquish the dog " The husband was relieved to get rid of it and the wife was just upset about her kids losing a playmate. By 'relinquish' you mean 'get shot of'. All a dog wants and needs to be is a ...dog.

[@PSIMM-yd7rr]

Thankfully she will now have a chance 💕🐾💕

[@iole96792]

Why, why, why, did they get a Pitbull??? Roxie might have been a normal dog if adopted by someone who knows how to handle a dog. Nathalie should not have a dog.

[@maryjane4432]

They put a rottie down bc of her too!

[@iole96792]

@@maryjane4432 So sad...

[@vonkunstfreiheitgedeckt]

she can absolutely have a dog and love it to bits. just not a strong willed type/character with the physical potential to seriously hurt other beings. too many people have certain breeds as a status symbol.

[@enriquerojas9758]

This will continue happening because pitbulls are being so romanticized in the US. People like to think at them as only cute dogs and are being fooled with the new mantra: “it’s not the breed, it’s the human”. If people were just told the truth about APBT then we could prevent a lot of fatal accidents. The truth that people should be told is that the breed was created for the ONLY purpose of fighting other dogs to death. In order to achieve this man created a breed with an extremely strong prey drive, an extremely high pain tolerance, a low self-preservation instinct, all this to create the will to die before letting go, once they are triggered. If people were lectured about this, then they would have the opportunity of making an informed decision about owning this kind of dogs, with all the responsibility and accountability that this entails. The deeply embedded traits in their DNA makes them a potentially dangerous breed and this traits will not go away with treats and kisses as many people like to think.

[@ElNadaInLada]

@@vonkunstfreiheitgedeckt She wouldn't even be capable of handling a chihuaha really. Some people are not for dogs simply said.

[@joeyfirriolo4800]

Crying...so... much. That poor kid I totally understand. I'm glad Roxy will have a better safer life but how sad. Thanks for helping Caesar 🙏

[@stacyjorgensen5161]

Such a beautiful family, I hope they found a compatible dog for their family. I could see their pain in the end when they had to let her go 💔

[@loriepreston5132]

Cesar you handed that case with perfection. It was sad for the children to lose Roxy but until thier mother is able to become a better leader they should not get another dog, big or small she is the problem. I have a sodt spit for Rottie's and it broke my heart he was put down because it was surely the mothers issues that caused his insecurities to attack her. She should not have any dogs.

[@ladyfish22]

I was surprised that Cesar didn't talk more about HOW they were creating an agressive dog...

[@janaronsen]

You mean regarding the Rottweiler incident?🤔 I agree with that..

[@IWM-123]

I bet he did off camera. Then for the sake of the kids etc not mistrusting their parents or being teased at school etc, the show decided best interest for parents to make the suggestion and turn it into a learning moment of "the dogs needs first...." Etc and probably told the parents never to go with dogs again, not even small ones because they wife is a dog "romantic" not a genuine dog lover. She will ruin any dog, small or big, simply as she is relationship lazy, wants to nurture the stuff she likes and avoid the elbow grease and boundaries, responsibility....

[@TheWayWeWere-rr7rs]

@janaronsenand the mysterious dying of the 2nd mastiff….thats 4 dogs they ruined!

[@anatellez8559]

I agree with you!! it wasn’t Roxy! They had a history of aggressive dogs because they ruined them. And they didn’t realize that they were not strong enough (energy, wise) to have powerful breeds. As Cesar may say, they are back of the pack, they can be front of the pack, specially mom. Sadly, dogs pay the price for the ignorance of people… 😢

[@vanessascully4444]

The problem is the humans, not the dog. The family is 100% responsible for Roxy's bad behavior. They should be strongly discouraged to have any other dog!

[@phillipaclark1832]

I agree, even a Labrador could become aggressive in their hands

[@diandralorena2903]

No,they can do the research,just like i did when i got my firat rott.

[@crazydaisyog3984]

​@@diandralorena2903 They had a healthy, happy Rottweiler. Under their care, he became so aggressive they put him to sleep after he attacked the female. They are not capable of owning powerful breeds. Especially the woman, I'm not putting her down or being disrespectful to her. She just doesn't have what it takes. They will get another dog soon, I just hope they choose a breed that's a better fit for them.

[@marymcquaid7291]

They have had other dogs before, and the same thing happened. I think having another dog would be too much for them to handle at this stage, because they don't understand what a dog needs. I respect them for giving up this dog before it was too late.

[@diandralorena2903]

@@crazydaisyog3984 i agree.

[@AllAhabNoMoby]

They are responsible for how their Rottweiler turned out and then had him killed. And then they're well on their way to do the same to this dog. All the while refusing to recognize their part in all this.

[@bricesicle]

That isn’t a guarantee, a dog can absolutely have something wrong with it

[@AllAhabNoMoby]

@@bricesicle Theoretically, yes. 99.9% of the time it's the humans fucking things up.

[@maryjane4432]

@@bricesicleyes but this dog and most likely the rottie had nothing wrong with it

[@bricesicle]

@@maryjane4432 You can’t guarantee that even then, people love to say “could have, should have, would have” when they have no idea what the exact details are. These specific owners a weak people but you have no way of knowing if the rottie was (like many are) a really forward dog prone to handler issues.

[@jenniferpepler5843]

@@bricesicle Do you know how often that happens?? Let's put it this way, Cesar at one point said he has ONLY ever come across 2 dogs that had a mental issue in which I do believe he recommended euthanasia but I can't recall for sure. You think about how many dogs Cesar sees on a daily/weekly basis and to only ever come across 2 dogs he couldn't help. Sorry, Bricesicle, it is the owners in this case that are the issue. I do rescue work and for the reasons these people have had to get rid of not one but two dogs, a reputable rescue would NEVER adopt a dog to these people nor should they! They have to work on fixing the role they played in these two dogs needing severe interventions.

[@helenawinther2005]

The husband is really nice and i love Cesar for taking the dog and giving it a new chance at life ❤ He tried to let her stay with the family but the husband and Cesar did the right thing.

[@NO_CLASS_BEATS]

Thanks be to GOD for giving Cesar such a gift to help both dogs and dog owners.

[@jojet1980]

This couple will just get another dog and bam back to square one cause they have no idea

[@alynneflanery9918]

that's what i was thinking too

[@meggert2360]

And it won't be a lab or a small gentle mutt but something large and aggressive.

[@OmarShortzz]

Watch them get a mastiff and call cesar talking about he's eating the neighborhood kids

[@PSIMM-yd7rr]

@@meggert2360I wonder about the poor Rottie who was put down , no bad dogs , just clueless owners ! Research of breeds and proper training !

[@stevejette2329]

@@PSIMM-yd7rr - They get help from a world-class trainer but cannot even follow his recommendations for even three days ???

[@lostribe5130]

She's feeling heartbroken but not heartbroken enough to change anything.

[@GeneTurner-gg4yo]

I agree. She is the first person with whom I felt just never got it at all! And even the husband had soft energy. Pitiful!

[@stevejette2329]

lost - And they WILL get another dog and ruin that one also.

[@lostribe5130]

@@stevejette2329 I noticed Cesar did not offer them one.

[@stevejette2329]

@@lostribe5130 hmmm ... ya. I did not notice that ...

[@Chr0nicjamz187]

​@@lostribe5130yh they need a cat or sum

[@melisavierra7812]

Definitely the right choice. Cats make wonderful, interactive, intelligent, playful and loving pets. To this family, please look deep at what type of pet is best for your family and the pet based on your temperaments. Thank you for putting your children’s and pet before your needs. It’s heartbreaking but so many things we do as a parent are.

[@maryjane4432]

Goldfish possibly will fit them

[@belikereepicheep]

Yea they seem to keep getting powerful dog breeds, really they shouldn't have a dog at all. But I'm sure they went and got one right after the end of this episode.

[@CentaurusMist]

​@@maryjane4432😂😂😂 absolutely agree. They didn't have the calm and assertive behaviour around big pet.

[@vdubb516]

Or no pets!!!

[@SkyTigra]

Obviously you don't have cats. All cats owners know how cats don't tolerate kids that age with very few exception. Cats like personal space and calmness.

[@ZoroastrianFlame]

I met a lady at the shops the other day. 12wk old Shar-Pei mix. First owner, no clue, harness too big, dog was bouncing out of control.. She was so clueless. Reserch, learn, understand mentality of breed before buying. Don't get one for cuteness.. They grow up .❤

[@hannierjimenez6931]

Thank you, thank you, thank you Cesar, and all the staff.

[@TwiceSmittenOnceShy]

Firstly, the children are beautiful! Secondly, my god, the wife is so unbelievably resistant to change! Oh, Roxy reverted back in 3 days upon returning home? That’s quite telling.. The whole dynamic here is off.. Y’all need a different kind of pet, because, all these dogs coming and going isn’t good for the children.. You need to consistently and continually invest in your dog’s education the same way you would one of the children..

[@rsu5327]

Cesar, the knowledge you have within yourself about dogs is simply amazing! You notice & see all while explaining to us exactly what's happening. You're simply amazing! That's why you are the Dog Whisper!!! Amen, nuff said!🥰😇💯

[@dianagilles7204]

This makes me so mad! This couple should not be dog owners at all. They refuse to address their own behaviors that put their dog in such an excited state! They not only failed Roxie, they failed their children as well. How could you put your children thru this and not want to change to make things work with the dog? These are lazy parents who think that a dog is supposed to be a toy to bring them pleasure. It's selfish.

[@naomitakimoto7295]

Well said ✊ I totally agree with you! This mother is unbelievable, she never even tries to see the reality and keeps blaming the dogs for her failures! Besides, they didn’t even appreciate the fact that Cesar Millan was offering them a help for themselves to recognize their own problems in order for them to overcome their own obstacles to becoming better humans, especially for their own children’s sake!!! But noooooo! They both didn’t even try. They totally failed to not only Roxy, but to their children as well. Poor children growing up with such incompetent parents especially the mother… For the sake of all innocent animals, I truly hope these people would never ever own any animals at all, unless they change their minds and stand up to become better humans.., but I doubt that. Remember, they have already put down a poor Rottweiler before Roxy …

[@donlee7545]

It's not as easy as you say....I'm glad for Roxy and I agree with Cesar

[@maryjane4432]

@@naomitakimoto7295I have two dogs a 6yo German shepherd and a 1.5yo pit/rottie. Absolutely love them both to pieces. Even tho I’m 5’2 I love powerful breeds. But I’m not naive and know they need discipline and exercise before love and cuddles

[@maryjane4432]

They need a cat

[@xyz5803]

100% agree.

[@prettyslim2010]

I love ceaser, his knowledge and understanding of dogs is so amazing. I love hearing him speak from the perspective of the dog, and what they are experiencing in that moment. He be like oh “that’s not good” 😊

[@TheGuiAnos]

Watching Cesar work never gets old. I mean seeing just how quickly a dog can transform is remarkable. Humans should learn from dogs, we need to be ready to make the change of mindset needed to become calm and assertive people.

[@sleepysamk1400]

It’s not the dog. It’s the owners

[@LadieKadie]

Says every delusional pit owner every time.

[@stefanclark4869]

@@LadieKadiedelusional like a person with a photo like yours ?

[@Speurneuscosmo]

Maybe a new series? About owners who have make a mess, so people are more aware of their behavoir and the cause of their dog ‘bad’ behavoir.

[@godfather53]

@@LadieKadie You watch this channel, but still don't understand anything..

[@PSIMM-yd7rr]

@@sleepysamk1400 99% of the time it is the owners !

[@titifolol]

OMG I sobbed with that little boy at the end, a dog is the only thing alive that will love you more than it loves itself and we love them more than most of the humans we know.....

[@5GreenAcres]

They should get a little poodle.

[@feministmermaid4769]

The family made the right choice in the end. I'm glad the family had options to help Roxy rather than being forced to put her down.

[@shirleyhardy891]

They already put one down!

[@karlajohnson9568]

I've been learning so much from Cesar's videos and old shows and started using them on my own reactive dogs. WOW, what a difference.

[@yoxas666]

I must say cesar you have a kind soul...the way you helped this dog and the people without Hesitation and took her in, moved me to tears Thank you for being a wonderful force of good In this world

[@SharonMacDonald-by3zt]

A dog can be your best friend. You have to stay calm be kind be consistent always walk them. Walking your dogs is a way for them to be social and get there energy out. Love them feed them wash them brush them. Stay calm.❤ Cesar is awesome.❤

[@sergio_81]

Some people don´t deserve pets, period!

[@gamtngirl3655]

Bravo.

[@stacyward4309]

Oh come on, it's not like they didn't love her or try. At least they didn't abandon her or abuse her .

[@mini8525]

I can’t believe about this Natalie lady. She is extremely selfish. Unbelievable

[@nataschas9552]

"but Roxy is so loving in the house" pathetic

[@AK47BLACKice]

They put their little kids in danger by having these kind of dogs and having no idea what they’re doing. They should count their blessings.

[@kittywilhite9583]

The world is full of humans and she is one. Cesar said it: She's a soft energy... and that includes her thinking processes.

[@HeatherBDentureDiVa]

I 100% agree she is selfish. I feel like she is emotionally needy because when she made the comment do I have to stay like this all the time or can she give me love and affection is I knew right there she was a selfish owner. She has dogs and kids for her emotional support but you have to understand you know having a dog is like having a kid you need to give them a purpose you need to show them love but you also need to teach them right from wrong you're there to be a parent not a friend or be all about yourself. This woman is definitely selfish and needy I feel bad for the husband because even though he's probably could be a great pack leader but his wife kind of holds him back

[@christinetilton4562]

My advice would be that it would have been better for the children if the mom would have acted like this was a happy choice for the dog. It would not only lessen the sad feelings but also show the children how to prioritize something before themselves.

[@chris_g_vibes]

I once had a Roxy, about 6 years ago(lab pit mix). She is no longer with us, at 18 years of age she was diagnosed with stage 3 pancreatic cancer. Thank You for sharing this video Cesar and Team :)

[@MinhTran-tj4wq]

Wow! It takes so much courage and most of all the love that this family have for their dog to make the toughest decision of their life to love a dog so much to let her go.

[@Mat-oh3xe]

I just got a rescue a month ago, thanks to these videos it's been a very smooth transition and my posture has improved dramatically. Thank you Cesar!!

[@Callidus7SSM]

That’s awesome, congratulations!

[@HotSeat17]

Next the dog will go after the kids. .I've been a Professional Dog Trainer for over 45 years, with movie actors and well known people. I've had some clients swear their dog would never bite, and they turn around and a child is dead, or a child's face and body is scarred for life. This happens far more than people are aware of!!!

[@DogSpeak]

One of the first shots is of all 3 kids playing tug with the dog. then followed by pics of the kids on the dog or the dog on the kids. You're probably right that it would only be a matter of time. It happened with the rottie who bit her in the face... most likely she was hugging and kissing it. Obviously not many dogs are going to respect her and they certainly wont tolerate her type of weak energy assuming dominant positions over them. I guess she thinks it's 'nurturing'?

[@sapiophile545]

These children were lovely and beautiful

[@prettyslim2010]

It’s beautiful that they didn’t give up on not just dogs but big dogs even after being bit by her own dog💕

[@Mr.A-000]

Roxy was definitely given the best chance at hope she possibly had. She’s under the care of the best in the world! Cesar is a godsend for all dogs who are labeled as a hopeless or unable to be helped.

[@twilightbabe123]

The mother is so distrustful and fearful. Her eyes say it all. I doubt they will succeed with other dogs.

[@lostribe5130]

Roxy, things are looking up.

[@sapiophile545]

Rare. You made a great comment. Not aggressive. Just pure and positive. Good on you. 🐾🐕‍🦺🥀

[@lostribe5130]

No dog is compatible with that family.

[@Fawn0001]

That is kind of what I was thinking too.

[@gregorystapleton2336]

They would be good with a low energy middle of the pack dog

[@lostribe5130]

@@gregorystapleton2336 those kids would totally overwhelm a low energy dog.

[@petermahr2511]

Dont think so. They always adopt the wrong bread.

[@inazuma3gou]

They'll do well with the laziest dogs like English Bulldog or Basset Hound.

[@Airendeau2095]

13:26 chills ❤ oh my heart. She saying thank you cesar ❤

[@1492tomato]

You can see in this woman's face it's impossible to do this. Something's really wrong. God bless Cesar for taking care of this wonderful confused dog.

[@charlenealger5770]

You're the best, Cesar !! I learn so much from you.. Thank you for all thar you do. God bless you, earth angel.

[@lexburen5932]

this woman is to passive and to low energy. not calm and not assertive and at the same time emotionally to weak, her husband as well.

[@JohnBosuen]

😂 true

[@justingumbs211]

Weak ass family

[@MyKronas]

The best thing about dogs is that they never look back in time, they live in the present Cesar you are a legend 🙏

[@loriwarmuth2539]

But that look on Roxy's face at the end like, "hey, why are you leaving me? I love you. " made me bawl😢😢😢❤

[@zurzeitnichtaktuell890]

It is good that the dog live to cecars home now. And became a new life with other dogs and a new family. It is better for the kids now because it is a dangerous Situation on the street.

[@DogGran]

Wish more people would be selfless and do what’s right by the dog. “But the kids..” is a terrible reason to keep a dog.

[@stevejette2329]

Dog - It would be better if she had been able to be trained by Cesar. "I rehabilitate dogs, I train people." The dog was relaxing, belly up very quickly. Lady never did seem to relax. Her KIDS will grow up with ... issues, just like their dogs. Ask me how I know ...

[@natureprincess]

Yes.. if you and the kids really love the dog, then you will do what is best for it. If you cannot change your energy and follow Cesar's direction, giving her to a better home for her is the next best option. Just sad another dog had to be attacked before they realized this.

[@anthonyml7]

Those kids have been through 3 dogs already, they'll survive (pun unintended) without this one honestly lol

[@stevejette2329]

@@anthonyml7 Is the issue about the kids surviving ?

[@anthonyml7]

​@@stevejette2329 I would hope she doesn't see it that way

[@janetdobie9722]

Why would you ever take an animal aggressive dog to a dog park? You really need to think about what type of dog that you want to adopt and do your research

[@NobodyCares6996]

This is why I don't go to dog parks anymore. Both my dogs, and one of them is a pitbull, were attacked by some Pitbull that was owned by this frail little woman who was absolutely helpless when this went down. Turns out she got the pit bull from a rescue and it had been in the rescue for over 3 years. She had no collar on it and had never taken it to a dog park before or bothered to socialize it. That's when I realized how stupid I was to ever set foot in one of those.

[@janetdobie9722]

I hope that your dog is okay...❤

[@wattsupinya72]

We Have an Amstaff That Is Aggresive To Other Dogs We Only Go to The Dog Park When There Is No one Else There.. And Either Me Or my partner Stand Guard At The Gate in case Someone else Comes With Their Dog , If And When That Happens We Safely Leave... I would Never Give Up My Dog Like That....

[@CedricLathan]

@@NobodyCares6996 I remember a vet calling dog parks, "A disease infested fight club."

[@NobodyCares6996]

@@CedricLathan pretty accurate assessment

[@VelascosLiving]

what a beautiful dog ! Thank you Cesar for saving her ❤I wish you’ll find an ideal home for her

[@jdartdiva1]

😂I was thinking THE SAME THING!! I’m a retired dog professional and time and time again, I have seen people get dog breeds that are way past their abilities to lead them. When this happens, the dog becomes the leader AND protector. Some people just aren’t naturally equipped to lead or cannot “learn” to lead. This situation was dire and I’m so glad they gave Roxie up. Thinking of the 2 dogs she’d already attacked and the tension the neighbors AND their dogs were dealing with, that was a no win situation and HOPEFULLY, this couple doesn’t run out and get another dog (large or small) because I guarantee that with their preference for large “bully” type breeds, the same thing will happen! They need long term therapy in how to manage dog ownership.

[@tgawron2233]

That little guy broke my heart. The dog has a chance now of not being put down. Than you Cesar!

[@barbaranymiel3089]

If this woman cared about her dog she would do everything in her power to cheer mindset, she wants help from the expert but yet won't do anything to change for the dog that she supposedly loves,I think they should get a couple of stuffed animals for themselves and call it a day.

[@GMc-iw2fy]

I feel sorry for Natalie, she seems depressed and anxious.

[@CertifiedBoogeymann]

Not sure why you would feel bad for HER, she is the problem, i feel bad for the rottie they took, made aggressive and then killed due to their negligence. Now theyre on the same path with this dog. Shes not depressed, she is selfish, and if she was depressed, maybe it wasnt a good idea to bring another living being who NEEDS direction, guidance, discipline that they are unable to provide. The dogs are the innocent ones, they continue getting the big breeds that they cant control and when it doesnt work, they want to put them to sleep. Dont have a dog if you cant properly care for it. That dog is DANGEROUS, had it attacked a child and killed that child, would you still feel for her? Its HER energy that is causing it all.​@@GMc-iw2fy

[@CertifiedBoogeymann]

​@@GMc-iw2fyshe literally took the dog home before it was ready and it attacked another dog. Feel sorry for the animals who are innocent in all of this. Goodness.

[@every__villian_is_lemons]

@@CertifiedBoogeymann ultimately she made the right decision though, she isnt a bad person and not even a "bad" dog owner. They obviously treated the animal well but it seems she just doesn't understand dog psychology at all. Some people are just not as talented at learning/applying some things and that's okay, we're all human

[@mhakim7823]

I am glad that the family came to their senses. Why getting these difficult breeds when you a scared and not a clear leader? Kudos to Cesar who saw it from the start. He put it in one sentence: bad dogs are not born, the are made. We humans are responsible that so many accidents happen, that so many dog end up in the pound. We want the dog to change but are not willing to do our part. Cesar is the best dog AND human trainer ever. Still!

[@jednaklanda7306]

Those kids are adorable ❤️

[@DivyaJoan]

I have always wanted a dog but been apprehensive about getting one, watching Cesar's videos has given me confidence.

[@heidigilliam5081]

I'm glad that they saw that she needs a home that is more compatible for her. Very sad for them.

[@ernienegrete5702]

Cesar should have given them a balanced dog that they can handle.

[@gamtngirl3655]

They are not ready for any dog.

[@heidigilliam5081]

I agree .thanks for replying.

[@lindasapiecha2515]

They may manage a little bichon

[@sicosis]

I think that woman is from a different planet

[@gustavogarcia7419]

WBU she was crying??

[@stevejette2329]

sic - She seemed afraid, insecure, not calm inside ...

[@maryjane4432]

The hubs has no “balls” either

[@anth91386]

😂

[@firenze5555]

Cesar is an angel to take this dog because this family chose the wrong breed - just dumb to pick a powerful breed and not put in the work it takes. The woman is an emotional basket case around the dog which doesn't help and creates more drama! What's next for this family: a German Shepard or Belgian Malinois or Rottweiler because they think it's cool?

[@jlucie]

Probably. Rottweiler was where they started and had put down after it bit her face. No Cesar that time 😔

[@AllynHin]

They had a Rottie and wrecked it the same way they wrecked Roxie. Unfortunately, the Rottie paid with its life for their ignorance. Honestly, they shouldn't have any dog, big or small, because they won't change, If they could change, they would have changed in order to keep Roxie. Without changing themselves first, they'll end up wrecking any dog they get.

[@SueLaLone]

Right decision. Beautiful family, hope they can find another dog with good energy for their family.

[@shirley6401]

Thank you, I really hope this family doesn’t adopt a new dog. Wishing Roxy a loving life ❤🐕

[@garymonaghan7196]

Yeah, the two parents have week minds and they’re not able to see past their own fear and that’s not a good combination. It sucks especially for the kids, but those two cannot have that dog and at least they can give it up so it doesn’t have to be put down. Way to go

[@And1one757]

Thats gonna have a bad effect on the kids as well they both have very weak energy

[@K9_Queen]

This woman needs a bunny rabbit. Not a pitty or any power breed

[@GK-ec5df]

Happy Birthday Cesar. You are a great man and lovely Virgo. I was happy to hear we share the same birthday. Today, dance like everyone is watching!

[@machellestone9541]

Children seem to be relieved, hope you can find a compatible home for this girl ❣️

[@nikkiswenson54]

Cesar, you were so kind with this dear family that loved Roxy but couldn't keep her under control. She is going to be trained by the best and eventually find her forever home with a stronger personality type that can keep control of her high spirits but bring out her calmer love without need for agressions.

[@PSW822]

Please.. it’s good you tried to save some animals lives but find a dog that suitable to your energy and kids as well. Because it is so sad for the dog to give it back to the pound shelter because of the adopters lack of knowledge on how to handle dogs. Thanks Cesar for keeping the dog.

[@morganmom194]

Why do they keep getting dogs they can’t control? Aggressive breeds?? Their children are in danger. I hope they realize they are creating aggressive dogs. They took no responsibility for this dog’s behavior.

[@Slightlysalty1]

Dogs aren’t born aggressive unless they are badly bred. Aggression is a learned behavior. Dogs become aggressive because owners are not strong enough to train them properly.

[@godfather53]

No "aggressive breed" is agressive at all after Caesar trains them

[@mstheid3674]

It has to be accepted that not all dogs can cope with the kind of "playing" that their owners enjoy. Most dogs prefer a quiet, organised home and most homes with children do not fit that bill - sometimes with disastrous consequences. At least this couple realised that they could not provide the kind of home Roxy needed. Good for them.

[@Whatareyoureallysaying]

It's love for me too, Cesar!!! You're amazing! And an excellent teacher. I've learned so much about myself and how to respect animals. I've missed your show. Thank you, it's good to see you touch so many lives. In such a positive way. Keep up the GOOD work!

[@CrisDesii]

I really wish this family don’t take another dog until they learn to deal with one - probably never… Anyway I’m glad that at least they agreed to let Roxy with Cesar! My complements 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

[@sunshinescholars3206]

Roxy's family does not need another dog period

[@bigcockedman714]

right lol