Cooperative federalism and the language connection | Decode Karnataka | Prof. A. Narayana

[@ಕನ್ನಡದೇಶ]

Good program on saving India’s federalism. The main problem for India’s federalism is due to Hindi politics and Hindi politics. They are not respecting other languages and taken South Indian languages for granted that will lead to states to ask India federal government to consider each state as separate country.

[@skagraw2]

When India becomes islamic state, Urdu will be enforced, kannada will go in the drain. Larger questions should be, should Hindus remain divided and separated due to language barriers? We can see, English, Kanada and Urdu sign boards everywhere across Bangalore. To me it appears, kannadiga Hindus by adopting Hindi hate policy has laid the foundation of breaking India forces.

[@skagraw2]

At the government level, all Indian languages are 2nd class citizens of India because English still remains the ruling, education and corporate class language. And english is taught and accepted by every state of India without a challenge that has caused severe cultural damage already. This is also going to strengthen breakup India forces. If no one wants to be united and work towards unity, why pretend to be united. We should go and break India.

[@skagraw2]

Apparently kannadiga don't feel Urdu and English are being imposed or their culture being damaged. So apparently game is something else.

[@ssv.d]

​@skagraw2 .urdu sign boards every where in karnataka. Joker northie.karnataka muslim population is single digit. English is self recognized as a supplementary official language. All karnataka Muslims can read write speak kannada. Why northies don't learn kannada 😂😂😂😂😂

[@santhoshbailvalu6977]

​@@skagraw2For your information Urdu and English are not imposed like how Hindi is imposed through Article 343 to 351 of our Constitution. Please have some basic knowledge before speaking about us.

[@grapeshott]

There should be some punishment for BIMARU states for not improving socio-economic indicators.

[@dhanush4792]

@@grapeshott simply what is Bimaru?

[@AshutoshSingh-ek5we]

Coming from Bihar and still agree with you

[@mandymohan]

​@@dhanush4792mostly north India

[@grapeshott]

@@dhanush4792 Acronym for BIhar(which includes Jharkhand), Madhya Pradesh(includes Chhatisgarh), Rajasthan, Uttarpradesh

[@j1real506]

​@@grapeshottbro are you crazy ? You are putting rajasthan and bihar in same category? Rajasthan is 10x ahead of bihar in every category

[@jeevanullakal9075]

We fully support CM Shri Siddharamiah and Karnataka people. We the tamils repeatedly saying that "if there is one language, it will result in may countries in india. If there is many languages in india, there will be one country." We are against brahminism / RSS which are behind such one language, one election, one tax, one party, one man rule etc.,

[@santhoshbailvalu6977]

We truly welcome Tamizhians in this aspect KA🤝TN

[@vaishalisaravanan2753]

​@@santhoshbailvalu6977thanks bro we tamil people are always there to support karanataka people.

[@chethands3862]

Kannada should be made as official union language.

[@santhoshbailvalu6977]

ಕನ್ನಡ ❤

[@Right_Centrist]

Full support for cooperative federalism and I am against Hindi imposition

[@SSV60]

European Union parliament comprises of different countries and different languages. There, Though you can speak in any European Language, the main language used is English, which is not a European language !! Similar thing could be applicable for Bharat also.

[@coconutpunch123]

No more looting of south india

[@umairsyed7465]

If the ruler is not just then the state govt should take this call. Undue advantages to states which are not developing but ruining the country name should not be promoted

[@skagraw2]

The main challenge of federalism is what if the state level political party adopts failed policy or unleashes lawlessness? Should the center intervene or let the states fail? If states fail, people will be forced to migrate. should we allow people migrations across states and who should decide this...

[@hellojapan915]

Jawahar Navodaya vidyalayas make it compulsory for South Indian languages to be taught in North India from 6-9th std

[@Inndjkaawed2922]

These schools don't exist in TN

[@ssv.d]

No jnvs in tamilnadu. Karnataka jnvs teach hindi as a language for high school also state run govt schools.but it's just for fun not out of compulsion

[@chethands3862]

Hindi is a foreign language from persia. And English came to Karnataka before Hindi.

[@Inndjkaawed2922]

are you of sound mind?

[@coconutpunch123]

​@@Inndjkaawed2922Yes he is

[@HariKrishna-lk5wx]

It was Urdu which came from Persia clear hindi origins cannot be said coz it differs state to state it's a mixture of sanskrit farsi and some elements of local hindi dialects of central india I'm a south indian myself stop this stupidity

[@ssv.d]

Hindi and english both are foreigners language. English is use and throw language. Hindi is not even fit to use

[@Yeshvanth-649rvp]

Hindi is a mixture of urdu persian. It was imposed by islamic invaders. It is the symbol of slavery. How come it's a language of this land

[@ravisdasappa9035]

The present devolution of tax formula is biased and discriminatory to Karnataka. It should be set right and failing which there is a danger for federalism.

[@coconutpunch123]

Our state kerala is a victim of this anti federalism politics by modi and bjp

[@pmt7483]

What changed according to u? What were the policy actions? Can u list them for me? Or r u just another sycophant living under a delusional oppression.

[@spg6651]

TEST OF ENGLISH AS FOREIGN LANUGAAGE -- TOEFL -- Similarly we need to have TOKIL - Test of Kannada as Indian Language ,, People who seek job/ education need to undertake TOKIL and validity can be kept for 3 years ..

[@ssv.d]

Hindi is foreigners language to karnataka 😂

[@m.b.nagaraj7666]

Federalism means shareing of power between union and states. . federal government prove to be costly inflation oriented. Unitary structure is good

[@ajastha1876]

UPSC exams & other such exams for central govt jobs are conducted in hindi & in English. Candidates from only bemaru regions & the entire hindi heartland are benefitting. Indians whose mother tongue is not hindi are at a loss. When will this injustice end? Competitative exams must be conducted in all 22 official languages enlisted in the constitution or should be conducted only in English.

[@brajkishor5066]

प्रतियोगी परीक्षाएं देश के संविधान द्वारा मान्यता प्राप्त सभी भाषाओं में होते हैं

[@sudarshanr7040]

Bjp often gets exposed by thier immatured, irrelevent , silly talks.

[@sudarshanr7040]

After accepting Hindi through out the country, some people could not guess what the danger would be. Later is it possible for non hindi speaking people to compete in all aspects specifically in competitive exams with people whose mother tongue is HINDI. For hindi speaking people , it is mother tongue and for us it is foreign language. In any competition there should be level playing field for justice / unbiased competition. More importantly non hindi speaking people will become second class citizens .

[@brajkishor5066]

क्या अंग्रेजी को बढ़ावा देने से आप दूसरे दर्जे के नागरिक नहीं है।

[@arpitaacs]

No language parochialism is good. Encourage language to be learnt voluntarily. Translate works.

[@rockforthariharan3092]

Nicely explained.

[@RakeshKumar-dk2et]

The origin of Urdu from Meerut City of uttarpradesh, how does Urdu became native language of KA Telangana Andhra Pradesh where state gov recognise official language of this state

[@karthikk2896]

What about Congress communists leaving in Karnataka from the places of Mysore, Belgaum and Gulbarga

[@darshankumar7926]

World oldest language is tamil. Make tamil as national language.

[@gc95915]

Non-Hindi region is colony of north India. A form of colonisation that’s even worse than British rule. At least under British rule, they were busy looting the country but were least bothered about the individual. Here, GOI is determined to turn all non-Hindi peoples into Biharis. One Nation, One Language stems from that objective. When they say Hindi is the identity of India, they are saying non-Hindi people are not Indians. Maybe, we should embrace that sentiment.

[@brajkishor5066]

क्या बिहारी ही देश में सबसे बड़ा ग।ली है

[@NeriousRavi-qi5mx]

👍👍👍👍👍❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@brajkishor5066]

यह चैनल हिंदी में भी होना चाहिए।

[@rajafernando2787]

The National Parties like Congress and RSS-BJP and others should be removed... The State Parties should take Power with certain decorum... and rule the INDIA, THE UNION OF STATES..... Hindi will go back to the History....

[@rakeshsarvabhotla4998]

You say how much tax Karnataka gives to centre and how much comes back. I ask how much tax Bengaluru gives to Karnataka. How much comes back to Bengaluru?

[@thefrustrateddoc]

Bengaluru is captial city of Karnataka. Karnataka is neglected state of India.

[@rakeshsarvabhotla4998]

@@thefrustrateddoc New Delhi is Capital of India.

[@coconutpunch123]

Bangaluru is also a victim of bimaru loot.if karnataka gets is fair share bangaloru will also get more fund

[@rakeshsarvabhotla4998]

@@coconutpunch123 Do you know about freight equalization policy which made BIMARU!?

[@Yeshvanth-649rvp]

​@@rakeshsarvabhotla4998but Bengaluru is based on service sector ur freight equalization policy nothing to do with it. Keep on giving excuses till u exists. We will keep on feeding u in name of one country.

[@NeriousRavi-qi5mx]

Kali ,Omm ,omm ,omm ,🥕 🥕 🌀 🌀 💃 💃 ♥️

[@SMCGPRA]

Where was cooperative federalism when UPA Congress govt at centre they put yeddi to jail

[@narasimmangopalswamy2638]

You have not understood the real coop federalism. BJP's policy will disintegrate the country.

[@SMCGPRA]

@@narasimmangopalswamy2638 coop federalism, congress/upa need to learn first as they have record no of implementing president rule on states

[@coconutpunch123]

Lokayukta sent him to jail. He was not the CM when he was arrested

[@coconutpunch123]

Modi governmnet is the worst in indian history

[@SMCGPRA]

@@coconutpunch123 have you seen the response of market and growth in sectors

[@WandererTejaFootprints]

The Hindu Left Ideology Supporter not neutral analysis

[@khgprasad]

Can you write your neutral analysis?

[@santhoshbailvalu6977]

​@@khgprasadI tell you their neutral analysis. Hindi is National language. Hindi is the language of oneness. Hindi should be learnt by Souths to travel freely across the country. Hindian can live anywhere in India without learning the local language.

[@VijAl-s6b]

​@@santhoshbailvalu6977hindi originated from Urdu can never be national language india country is made by britishers now it seems mistake save south from hindi colonizers shame on u hindi people

[@vivekmuradayil5594]

Divide india is not possible british tried lot 100 years failed and gone

[@santhoshbailvalu6977]

But Hindians govts are trying hardto do that. They will definitely succeed that British could not do.

[@vivekmuradayil5594]

@@santhoshbailvalu6977 hindians cannot do because all are not papus in hindia

[@sivag5155]

🎉😂🎉😢😢😮😢😮😅

[@AG-03]

Day by day I started hating the Hindu newspaper…… it’s biased ….. shame on you the Hindu

[@dhanush4792]

Panipuri triggered uh🤣

[@chiggywiggy524]

No one cares what BIMARU thinks 🤡

[@grapeshott]

It's just an opinion. And there is nothing wrong told here.

[@coconutpunch123]

You read times of india

[@ssv.d]

Day by day respect to hindu channel increasing

[@spg6651]

HINDI IMPOSITION , HINDI DIWAS etc.. are very bad -- This will lead to major problem going forward -- HINDI is equal to KANNADA and there is no special status for HINDI .. This is very clear .. connecting language is English not Hindi

[@brajkishor5066]

देश के 54 करोड लोगों की भाषा हिंदी है जबकि अंग्रेजी केवल 2 लाख लोगोंके, अंग्रेजी कैसे संपर्क भाषा होसकती है।

[@shivmohan99681]

excessive federalism leads to divisions

[@sriramsakura]

That's good too. Smaller countries are better. South East Asian countries, EU nations, African, all benefitted.

[@chethands3862]

Hindi Imposition will divide even more😂. All 22 schedule languages must be made as official union language to stop Hindi Imposition.

[@coconutpunch123]

No. Special preference for north indian states will create division

[@coconutpunch123]

Federalism is good for coutry. Federalism means treat every state equally.

[@shivmohan99681]

@@coconutpunch123 in real world, there is no equality. All of the finger are not same. IF not controlled. States, culture, language deviates. So someone should hold them tight.

[@sudarshanr7040]

After accepting Hindi through out the country, some people could not guess what the danger would be. Later is it possible for non hindi speaking people to compete in all aspects specifically in competitive exams with people whose mother tongue is HINDI. For hindi speaking people , it is mother tongue and for us it is foreign language. In any competition there should be level playing field for justice / unbiased competition. More importantly non hindi speaking people will become second class citizens .

[@santhoshbailvalu6977]

Very true👍 We are already second class citizens in our own land🙁

[@brajkishor5066]

यह सच नहीं है। बल्कि झूठ और भ्रम फैलाया हुआ है।