CORALINE THEORY #5: Solving Tons More Mysteries!

[@jeremydewilde8166]

tbh, Coraline might just be the greatest film ever...

[@tyger99mw]

I love that movie.

[@derpster615]

I still have the DVD

[@derpster615]

+That One Commenter it's also the 3D version which is very awesome 😃

[@themisfitt4364]

It is tbh

[@zebrasdancing2526]

True

[@NA-xw6jl]

I remember you saying that the boy reincarnated as the cat. Part of his soul was still alive. The colours of the souls are a glowing blue, the same as the cats eyes.

[@livingwithautism3789]

I remember you saying that the boy reincarnated as the cat. Part of his soul was still alive. The colours of the souls are a

[@scr34m1ng5]

When Coralline and her mother were leaving from the store when coralline's mother said she lock the door because she saw rat droppings and wanted Coralline to stay safe it felt like she knew about the other world

[@shayadair6218]

Kyra Gilmore it felt more to me that she just figured that the rats were in the walls and in that little room, you know how rats do that right? So she just lock it so they don’t run around the house and bite someone. That’s unsafe and pretty normal.

[@sarah.clarke348]

She wouldn't have opened the door if she knew o don't think but I don't know

[@cutefuzzyunicorn763]

Kyra Gilmore dang u rite

[@taylormcgregor2352]

Rainbow Heart oh yea her mama had to own about the other one because of what you said and two she hid the key SO SHE HAD TO KNOW AT LEAST SOMETHING ABOUT THE OTHER WORLD

[@myttype]

would she even fit through the door?

[@ariariari543]

The grandmother made a deal with the beldam ... that’s how the doll got into the trunk of the grandmas truck. The beldam spared Wybie if the grandmother assisted in finding another child

[@mersedehm.h1525]

Yeah and in the video we found that mabye baldam have control on all her place and town and i just realize that she's very very smart, powerful and manipulater.

[@beyondthecamera333]

Aristotle Evidence?

[@ariariari543]

@@beyondthecamera333 bro this was a year ago lolll I don't remember much but it makes sense. Wybies grandma owns the house so he must've been there a few times as a kid. She allowed a child when she knows what happens, it would make sense that wybie is leverage for the beldam and his grams was desperate

[@beyondthecamera333]

Aristotle It would make sense, but there is no evidence to cover the gaping holes like: how woul she have done this if she is terrified of the house? How did she reach the other world, if the beldam can close the portals?

[@ariariari543]

@@beyondthecamera333 she wouldn't have, but letters are a thing. The grandma is a landlord she is required to go to the house from time to time and the beldam could have her rats leave letters or threats, for example, a doll of wybie

[@Feldsparb420]

U said the cat was the L in Coraline Then coraline threw the cat at the other mother *T A K E T H E L*

[@dxRgg-gj7ud]

Lol xDD

[@sarakpeachtree1183]

@@dxRgg-gj7ud coaine!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@sarakpeachtree1183]

the l meows!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@christasiajazz4921]

Lol good one

[@savannahhicks5862]

Oof

[@tiffanygranados1307]

It's make sense that she is part spider. Spiders produce silk(?) to make their webs. So, I know this might be a bit confusing because I suck at explanations, but she makes dolls, she has needles as fingers and button eyes, not to forget she is part spider. So it ties into her as being a creater. A spider's web is a spider's home. So the other world is like her web where she can trap her prey.

[@sydneelee4736]

Nice

[@kimc9733]

Jimin :)

[@mastersheldon1780]

Tash Aka Trash I kinda thought this the first time I watched it when I was 5

[@tygerhil9505]

Or maybe the entire film is the Beldam playing a "game" with Coraline. Once Coraline entered the other world you don't see her leave through the tunnel until the end. And the fact that the cat can still use portals...what if Coraline never actually left the other world? The entire film after she entered was just a sick game the Beldam played with her? I don't know, I'll let you decide!

[@adeleinoz]

Tyger Hil Mhm! I believe the Same! IF The Beldam Died then there would’ve been a Noise, which didn’t happen? Soooooo.... it was a Trap and if you’ve seen the Fangirls theory[s] then she Said “if the First portal lead to the Beldams lair, then what was the other Decayed portal? Like the Beldam, The 2nd portal leads to the Pink Palace Limbo and when the ‘Other Mother’ Turns into The Beldam for a Split second you can see Human Eyes on her! That means that she can Evolve into human.... the End of the Film shows Mr. and Mrs. Jones being Happy! Mrs. Jones could be the Beldam....?” Yeah so in theory I Agree :)

[@abbydixson9739]

Dude, the fourth vid was literally all about that!

[@Jochi_Mochi]

That's what I'm thinking!!

[@bluewinterspring4041]

I believe this theory. It fits and makes sense.

[@nicc28]

When Caroline when into town in the real world, her mom was buying a grey shirt for the uniform. The Beldam can see out of buttons, the grey shirt had buttons on it. Edit: how did this get over 500 likes x-x

[@keepyourshoesathedoor]

christmasrules59 oof OOOOH

[@Xoshynee]

That makes a lot of sense

[@Xoshynee]

Nicole UwU but let's think about it that is a very good point but can't she only see buttons that she sewed into

[@LRADtheInhaler]

My conspiracy friends are trying to figure the meaning of that, Nicole UwU

[@hakubird8835]

Holy boat cow

[@anarhisms8315]

I want to slap those copycats that copied your information >:(

[@xxroslynnxxhhh5822]

Lps Paracosmic I want to throw them off a roof.

[@gltchundertale2756]

.... ok im not alone

[@Feldsparb420]

@@beefygurlsero1374 my nickname on an app is the nose cutter cuz u choo off peoples noses

[@JulianTheJedi]

Let's grab our pitchforks and kill them

[@Feldsparb420]

@@beefygurlsero1374 its fReE and its called amino I was in the depression group I had to delete it, but i might reinstall it if ya wanna talk about nOSEs

[@crystalharris5067]

The Theorizer:Here's what I've got *Ad pops up* Me:Men's shampoo...?

[@inspgonzalez]

Crystal Harris hey everyone needs shampoo

[@Jkl66710]

Crystal Harris I got an ad too but mine was for a 3d background

[@aaryn7786]

Crystal Harris for me it was an ad for amzon prime photos......i dont even know what its about

[@victoriagiraud2157]

Crystal Harris my ad was for tmobile😂

[@jalenmatthew7796]

Crystal Harris my ad was for some Knights game

[@txrap01x]

So I have 2 points I really want The Theorizer to ponder on that I have discovered about Coraline that he has *not yet* mentioned : 1) How does the beldam know about Coraline's friends in Michigan? When Coraline visits the other world for the first time and she goes into her bedroom for this first time (in the other world) there is a photograph with Coraline's old friends that can TALK AND MOVE in the picture. Considering the beldam must have created that, how did she know what they looked *and* sounded like ? Coraline says nothing about a change in their appearance or voice, so it is safe to assume that the picture is identical to the real people. They also call her "Loper" which is a legitimate nickname they gave her, but how did the beldam know about this ? 2) Wybie's grandmother: Wybie's grandmother is quite an important character as she A. Owns the pink palace B. Lost her sister to the beldam as children C. Is a relative to Wybie Now, my point is *ALWAYS* when Wybie talks to Coraline and he starts to talk about the pink palace / danger or the grandma's sister, we always hear her interrupt the conversation by calling for him and sometimes ring a bell. When she calls him, she sounds worried and desperate to get him back home. I also believe her timings for calling Wybie home aren't just conveniant, as in she desperately wants to hide the secrets of the other world and her missing sister too . I have come to dead ends with my points though but I feel that they have a lot of potential and I would be super happy if you could ponder on my points or even expand and include them into a theory. Thank you so much for taking the time to read this and have a great day 👍🏼

[@xAlphaBxtch]

It's Me Tamara Hmm never thought of those

[@switchxzero7391]

It's Me Tamara I never even thought of the picture of Coraline's friends

[@txrap01x]

Puppet Master I'm glad I managed to "expand your mind" 😂 thanks for reading

[@connorbecamehuman6845]

I think I can answer that. The other room is an exact copy of her real room.... but better.....it's the perfect version of her real room. And if that Picture is in there..... It will be in the perfect version and it would also be in there because she loves her friends and her life wouldnt be close to perfect without them so she put the perfect part of her room in the perfect room.

[@umasaini6534]

I think beldam gives any sort of hint to grandma to prevent the truth being revealed to coraline. Grandma calls for wybie out of danger .By the way , coraline didn't like wybie and she wouldn't have believed any of the truth or anything told by wybie.

[@wucmau]

But I have a question, where is wybies parents? Also what about the theories that come from the game Little Nightmares?

[@scarlett3428]

I think wiybes parents didn’t love him and that’s why they called him wiybe (why born) and they sent him to an orfinadge I can’t spell btw and grandma adopted him and that’s who his parents are I’m not sure 😂😂

[@curlyhead.geminime3958]

Scarlett Cretu *wybie *Orphanage

[@Ana-pj1gf]

Omg the game! I forgot about it

[@sinare-9090]

I have no clue what theory you are referring to (Not even sure about the game Little Nightmares). As for Wybies parents, that's definitely a possibility, why they would name him that does suggest they didn't love him or want him in the first place. Idk about an orphanage though. I think either his parents died or because they didn't want him they either straight up abandoned him one day, or they just dropped him off for a visit with grandma. Just became a permanent visit.

[@karlymoore855]

Thats a good theory

[@salamisaucin]

The reason the beldam moves her hand and taps her fingers on the table is mainly because her hands actually control her, they make the dolls and they have their own sense of mind, even when her metal hand gets cut off it still goes after Coraline and doesn't need it's body, BUT HEY! THATS JUST A THEORY, A FILM THEORY!

[@Yandereebunniee]

That seems to be a reasonable explanation for why her hands do that. And wow film theory XD somebody call up Mattpatt

[@salamisaucin]

+Motionless Crow Emily I wish XD

[@salamisaucin]

+Lily Taylor I know

[@Yandereebunniee]

+Lily Taylor I'm sure he knows lol

[@laviesquirrel8827]

AAAAAAAAAAAAND CUT!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@janetradley839]

Remember when the dad was singing? Yeah, at the end he sings "Our eyes will be on Coraline" Like if u remember that part and/or heard it

[@willowornellas2931]

Wolf Girl Monster Girl "she's as cute as a button in the eyes of anyone who's ever laid their eyes on coraline"

[@jayjaysbizarreadventure4258]

Sayron Rios damnt ow i have the song stuck in my hrad lmao

[@willis1383]

he also says "she's a peach, she's a *DOLL*, she's a pal of mine" which foreshadows coraline doll

[@ashfeatherartz]

He also says * "When she goes around exploring mom and I will never ever make it boring" *

[@billiejoetoe]

I just like it because it's by They Might Be Giants 🙂🙂🙂

[@edein3955]

What if the “soul sand” is actually the ashes of the kids she stole 🥴

[@Vinssyyy]

Oh holy s-

[@edein3955]

Beautifully British and that’s the TRUE reason why she replaces a kid. because in order to have soul sand u must have a soul, and after a while loose souls become ghosts.. so she had to find fresher soul sand. almost like our souls have an expiration date. my god i just realized, she took the souls of children because they are the ripest without being moldy. babies souls would be easier to catch right? but they haven’t had time to grow. adult souls are too old so they are become closer and closer to death (rlly maturity) but children, children have had time to grow their souls without them turning. (almost like a plant in a garden) and if u realize, the plants in the garden start to die after coraline realizes the other mother is not good for her, and something like that can really weaken the soul. and i guarantee u the only reason why the other mother kept chasing coraline was for one reason, she did not want to get caught.

[@Vinssyyy]

@@edein3955 dang that's incredibly detailed! You should be a theorist!

[@edein3955]

Venus Doki hehe thanks! it’s kinda like one of my favorite pastimes especially on movies like coraline 😄

[@Vinssyyy]

@Static Gaming well it is open for interpretation! I think it was probably the kids souls that have turned into physical things I suppose-

[@drenaginmsp3884]

Anyone else want a Coraline 2 ???

[@aliyassine2320]

Kenzie Stevens of course

[@damienparker4140]

Kenzie Stevens hell yeah

[@christhechilled]

but what u think will be the setting of the sequal?

[@anniedavidson76]

ChrisTheChilled Tuber coriline protecting her daughter and fights the belldam

[@bulbasaurlife3512]

NO if they do that 3 things could happen 1 the movie is GREAT 2 the movie is meh or 3 the movie is AWFUL and i dont want to take a chance

[@dabhowlter9727]

What if the cat was the Belldame's first victim? But he was always just a cat. The reason he can talk is because the magic of the other world followed him back into the real world. She started out using cats and other animals to try support the magic of the world. But I don't have much proof so it's just a theory

[@iwannagotopluto5077]

FILM THEORY

[@bobaparadise9419]

Dab Howlter that's just a theory a film theory.

[@osamu1655]

Dab Howlter oml yess

[@jeremyhill1227]

Collie Cake Lps Studios And cut.

[@ruinedcloset]

This is a nice theory, since it is plausible that the belldame might try to kidnapp other creatures. Purrhaps she was in need of magic (just as this video says) but there were no children, so she settled on the cat.

[@ranny-oq2lg]

Second thought; What if the buttons on some dolls and clothes that are in the stores (back in town) is what allows the beldam to see. Maybe that's how she knew that Coraline wanted gloves. . .

[@briannar2866]

😱 I haven't thought of that

[@Chell2319]

+angel Haran Signed!

[@hanniecakes]

OH MY GOD!!!

[@willowwisp6955]

i now i wont be able to look at a jacket the same way ever again

[@lilyp353]

WOW that's so creepy!!

[@lilibillybob123]

I want a fricking coraline's Vr game

[@hannahlarocco7467]

Funny theory. Coraline is dreaming the whole thing.

[@espresso387]

Yeah she is in a coma 😂😂😂😂

[@humanbeing6497]

Yo that would be so cool

[@sachznaa]

That be so cool

[@sahiralopez6146]

@@espresso387 idk why but everyone thinks every show is the main character in a coma

[@nip3004]

In all of these videos i'm surprise you have not brought up the grandmothers eye sight. I mean in a movie that has so much focus on eyes do you think it is just random that she is blind?

[@TheTheorizer]

Well, I've had a couple people point this out, and I'm just going to confirm, that no, she is not blind :)

[@nip3004]

+The Theorizer well you have seen it more than me but there is definitely something up with her eyes

[@TheTheorizer]

abb criss Nope

[@nip3004]

i would assume because the magic is stronger there?

[@helenhodges2656]

+abb criss you think so?? but he can talk as soon as he gose into the portal why????

[@someoneyay9384]

Ok so, I had read the comic version of the book and watched the movie. I have a theory sort of based off yours. What if that the second portal is a symbol of Coraline going to sleep, and the beldam can actually control her dreams and manipulate her, like a dream dimension. I say this because she always comes back to the real world when she's waking, which doesn't make any sense because she went through a portal. It's just a theory I gathered from watching all the videos up to here. I usually don't ask for likes but please like this so he can see this!

[@kittyattack2001]

Someone Yay she doesn't always come back when she wakes up but that's dismissible since everyone has had dreams where they cannot wake up

[@loupblanche36]

there was one time she went to sleep but stayed in the "other world", so this doesn't make sense.sorry but it's true

[@brianasoto5173]

I agree with your theory because when Coraline went to sleep she woke up to be in the other dimension and went to sleep in the other dimension woke up back in the real world. When her mom went shopping she went into the other dimension went to sleep and was still there.The Dreams was probably a way to manipulate her as you said to get into the portal when she isn’t asleep.

[@ご珍しいアシュリー]

I suggest you read the original book. Coraline doesn't sleep and wake up in the "other" house.

[@meganfreeman4446]

Someone Yay I

[@auhdramyers1650]

PLEASE READ THIS> Coraline IS my favorite movie, so I've watched it like a million times. One thing you have not mentioned is in the beginning of the movie!!! in the begging the movers are moving a chair into the house. IF YOU LOOK CLOSELY ITS THE BELLDAME'S CHAIR!!! I DONT KNOW WHAT IT COULD MEAN... But it would be great if you could answer this!!!!!

[@whoisgianna1793]

That's true...why would the beldam have the chair if they just moved it into the house?

[@ninayani2397]

Auhdra Myers oh

[@brangwain]

Same.

[@bryancunha7092]

Is it a bug chair I didn't know it was the other mothers chair

[@kirkesu6778]

Auhdra Myers I noticed this last night when I was watching coraline! I thought I was going f*cking crazy!

[@floordakid1228]

The theorizer: you must watch parts 1, 2, 3, and 4 in order or you won’t understand what’s going on Also the theorizer: now lets do a recap

[@goopy9068]

Okay so I'm going to add a little thought I had even though it's late: so the fairy mushroom ring? Well, my obsession with fairies will help me here. So fairy rings are portals, that's covered, but in stories, if you enter the fairy realm with a circle of mushrooms you cannot eat or drink anything as that binds you to the world and you'll be trapped there forever, unable to leave. Now I haven't watched the movie for a while but I believe Coroline ate some of the food there and is now bound there. The other mother can control this world, molding it like clay. What if Coroline is still in that world. The other mother obviously has a lot of experience, she could probably anticipate Coroline's actions. What I think is that coroline is still in that world and is unable to leave because of the food she ate. Another thing about the fairy realm, is that time passes much differently and you could be in the realm for a millisecond and a thousand years have passed in the real world, or it may be the other way around. I'm not sure how that ties into it but I hope this is somewhat good

[@thiqqierat140]

apple juice ooh yeah and then there was all of the food she was wishing for because they want her to stay in the other world

[@haileysmith.x0154]

apple juice oh yeah, and I'm pretty sure in the eating scene (the first one in the other world) the other mother didn't eat anything but Coraline did. So that would make sense.

[@KidaAkihisa]

Coraline also did not enter through the well though which is where the fairy portal is. If you look at it like that she never entered into the fairy portal she entered through the other way that the beldam made. So the rules may not apply because it is not how she entered the other world

[@arandomperson1621]

That could be correct because in a way the family is doing everything she wants them to do like gardening and buying her the gloves

[@keeleymahoney8870]

What if Coraline's mother is the other mother. When Coraline asks to see what's behind the door, her mother knows exactly where to find the key, and what it looks like, the real life mother also makes coraline's life really bad not giving her what she wants, and not feeding her very well, this all leads to the audience thinking that she shouldn't be a mother in the first place. So this leads me to believe that Coraline's mother had a kid, because she needed to eat, and if she can control the real world, this would conclude why the grandmother let her live there, even though the grandmother didn't want any kids to live because she knew what would happen, so the mother mind controlled her. Also wybie (sorry if I'm spelling that wrong) is the grandson of the grandmother who knew too much, and then I remembered that when Coraline goes to the other world wybie's mouth is sewed shut, this was probably because the mother knew that he knew too much, so when she created the world for Coraline, she did this so he wouldn't tell Coraline what was going on.

[@nolacollazo1616]

Keeley Mahoney the real mom only knew where the key was because there was a key spot, the second time she hid the key because coraline was talking about it so much, and that being the key is kind of obvious because it wasn’t hers it was just there

[@Mariah-jn7ld]

Wow

[@mersedehm.h1525]

When we changed our house there was a place which all the rooms keys were there so it's not a strange thing another thing is i don't think that coralin's real mother was bad, she had just a lot of works. Changing house, working on a important project, car accident, coralin's problems and school...so she was just so busy but she loved her daughter as well.

[@yuhitsariana0136]

Also they were struggling with money So she couldn’t feed her properly

[@animeanime8394]

who wants a coralline 2

[@sadedayday1332]

Della Sizemore, I want one. But at the same time, I can't really seen it happening.😔

[@ninjafairy643]

anime anime I could see a Coraline 2 with the beldam sending something after Coraline and forcing her to come back to the other world because there is going to be some point were the beldam is going to be forced to try again and if she got the key she would be able to do something but it is just an idea

[@indigosky6212]

+LiliyKZbinr that's impossible unless there are 100 hours and 4000 minutes in a day.

[@xxlpslightning363xx9]

anime anime me

[@hontherun3495]

+TPD well that just leaves all the easy part to the beldam, you see, as we know she has a void room IT supposedly should be able to do the dirty work and Calculate/alter the voices leaving the beldam to just provide the info. fortunately it uses up a lot of power but the beldam wants to lure her closer which means, she will run out of less time. Do you understand what I mean??

[@poopyellie3017]

Before I watched this I watched another video saying “ that Coraline didn’t actually escape, it said that she had made it really clear she wouldn’t have button eyes ever, so when the other Wybie takes his glove off to show coraline he can’t go with her and blows and his hand like falls out, It said “what if it was the mother’s trick” to make coraline feel like she had escaped when really the bell dam only made a different version of the real world. I mean when she had realized her parents were missing and she decided to go talk to the 2 weird ladies downstairs they just let her go back to her house all alone and the whole time almost the only thing they did was complain because they would be late for something, when in reality that would never happen they should have at least helped coraline find her parents, or call the cops, but what if that was the ball dam making them do that.” Another thing they said was that in the end of the movie the car had walked on the pink palace sign and then he disappeared, well those are the powers he had when he was in the other world and so if he could do that in what coraline thought was the real world then he wasn’t in the real world, Now I’m not going to say anymore but if you want to watch this video search up: “Did coraline really escape” then find one with a thumbnail of a picture of coraline but split in half and on the other half she would have button eyes. I DID NOT COME UP WITH THIS I JUST COULDNT REMEMBER THE NAME OF THE CHANNEL, IM NOT TAKING CREDIT

[@ellenardi6333]

It's from TheBigOReview. kzbin.info/www/bejne/jXSQqIlmmM-Zhq8

[@chynniathomas7682]

Yes. The Theorizer mentioned that she probably never made it out and when he said that my mind instantly remembered the time where the cat had teleported like he was trying to show us something and when I remembered that goosebumps ran down my body Bc it was so creepy. But I always remembered when I was little I would ask myself “ how did the cat teleport of he could only teleport in the other world” and this theory right here proved that, that world the movie ended on was not the real world.

[@tatumikemoto2491]

Please help me! Okay, so at the middle of the film, why would the other mother get mad and put Coraline through the wall where the ghost children are? Doesn't she know that that the ghost children could tell her where the eyes are and once Coraline finds them, the Beldam starts to die. When Coraline finds the ghost eyes, the other world starts to die and same with the Beldam. But, when Coraline got the triangle thing to look at "bad" things in the other world, would've the Beldam knew she got that because Coraline has the doll and the Beldam uses that to look at Coraline. Please answer and like to he can see this comment.

[@liz27ann]

Well, about the triangle thing.... at the end of the movie when it’s time for Coraline to guess where her parents are, the bedlam throws the eye piece away, so she definitely knew about. The reason why she would have let Coraline use it to find the ghost children’s eyes, is because she knew that even if she got all of them, Coraline would never guess where her parents were (especially if that whole hung was a trick, and her parents were never taken), and as the ghost children told Coraline, “even if you win, she’ll never let you go”. So she didn’t care about Coraline having the triangle piece.

[@tatumikemoto2491]

ohhh ok thanks!

[@liz27ann]

Tatum Ikemoto Also, the beldam got mad at Coraline because Coraline no longer “loved” her, and she knew about her intentions and wanted to leave, which means that the beldam could no longer use her soul to power herself and the world. If she can’t power herself and the world, not only will all she has made be completely ruined, but she’ll die herself, which is why she turned into that spider-like figure at the end.... that was the point in which Coraline had the very least amount of love for the beldam and was only in the other world to “retrieve” her parents. Why the bedlam threw Coraline behind the mirror with the ghost children, I’m not so sure about. Once again, it could be because she didn’t care what she found out, because she knew that she would never be able to leave.... but that only works if you believe the theory in how Coraline never left the other world, or that the beldam can control the real world as well. Or, there is a theory that the ghost children are just part of the beldam’s game.... they could be controlled by her, and everything that they told Coraline was in the beldam’s favour.... This makes a lot of sense because the reason why Coraline threw the key down the well (which as we know, is actually a portal to the other world), is because the ghost children told her that she wasn’t safe as long as she had the key. As we know.... when Coraline threw the key down the well, the beldam got it. So is it a coincidence that it was because of the ghost children? Doesn’t seem like it is...

[@darthreaper6311]

sad noob She wants to Coraline for her soul because she is running out magical power.

[@jayjaysbizarreadventure4258]

Tatum Ikemoto either a she forgot they were there but thats not a good idea speaking of hernature or b she knew coraline wouldnt be able to get out without help and figures wybe wouldnt disobey her

[@evatardioli5703]

Hey theorizer! Hey! Hi there. Do you think that maybe, just maybe, the Beldam was lured by another, maybe stupider, person who had occupied the void, but he/she died because the Beldam was too old to be tricked. Then if she was called by the well and fell into the now empty void, she arrived into the same situation, but learned from her predecessor's mistake and after her first fail, she started to get the hang of things until Coraline...

[@HanaOccasionally]

WildEv Thing2003 That could also be where the cat was from that's why the other mother doesn't know about him but yet he knows a lot about the other world. He was link to the last owner of the world.

[@MissEasyPeasySleasy]

+TheTheorizer... Please notice this comment, it's brilliant!

[@gostfacekiller4575]

WildEv Thing2003 swimming in the golden rain ☔️

[@justalex3676]

the belam could had been diging a hole for a well and she did but she fell in the water and the water was a portal

[@tameikahallam9802]

WildEv Thing2003 that is an amzing therey but if u and me put our heads together we might come up with something even more amzing

[@zebstarmczebstar4719]

wait if the beldam can see through buttons can she see through the key

[@anniedavidson76]

Zebstar McZebstar OMG THATS HOW SHE COULD SEE WITHOUT THE DOLL YOU ARE SO RIGHT

[@colleenspielman9118]

Annie Davidson no because she ate the key remember

[@justflo7322]

Zebstar McZebstar Well, it's complicated because it's not like Coraline takes the key with her everywhere. She only uses it when she needs it. So technically, the food and the gloves is unexplainable. But otherwise, yes, the Beldam can probably see through the key.

[@zebstarmczebstar4719]

Annie Davidson- hahahah thanks. I thought that was like a coincidence the I was like ohhhhhhhh

[@doorknobr]

GamingwithGrace you do know she has mice servants that can go to the real world and they have button eyes so the beldam can see where they are and the beldam can control them so she can easily tell the mice to follow coraline which they do so she knows to create the gloves coraline wants

[@izzyvibess5363]

HOW DID THE REAL MUM KNOW WHAT KEY OPENED THE DOOR!!!!!

[@mgdlnetn5196]

right?🤣😂

[@meow-en4wk]

Maybe she knew what the other keys were meant for so when she the button key she assumed it was for the door. Edit: Maybe she was also like pulled to the key? cuz you know its very "different" and magical I guess idk.

[@liamhw09]

because it was probably the only one she didnt know

[@BrawlyDaStar]

@@liamhw09 I get that. But not even the father of the house knew how many doors or windows there were in the house. The mom is constantly on the computer and so is the dad so coraline is the only one to really explore the house. thus is the reason she found the door.

[@rmhd7550]

I feel like she just guessed

[@CloroxBleach-xf1wf]

I just thought of something. To prove that the portal to the other world is also the well, in the scene where Wibourne and Coraline are being attacked by the hand, when Wibourne falls into the well, the hand tried to get him to fall down by poking off his fingers. But if that's true then I wonder what she would plan to do with Wibby once she got him to fall in.

[@rosellaaj3709]

Clorox Bleach That makes sense!! And the Other Mother was going to try to take the magic in his soul/eyes to rebuild the Other World...!

[@unknown-pu3wj]

I ONLY watch ur coraline vids to be honest because these vids that you do are actually more imaginary because of the way you use pictures to make us think and it make us calm and lets us think about what you are saying

[@hyliangengar6903]

When I saw this video in my subscriptions box I instantly clicked on it. Your theories are amazing. You're definitely the best theory channel to say the least. You're nearly at 100,000 subscribers and you deserve it. Keep up the amazing work and I can't see what theories you upload in the future!

[@TheTheorizer]

thanx

[@hyliangengar6903]

+The Theorizer wow,you actually replied! Hey,there's ANOTHER reason I love your channel.

[@TheTheorizer]

Hylian Gengar Yup :D I reply to everyone.

[@hyliangengar6903]

+The Theorizer I know! it's great how you interact with your fans :D *unlike other KZbinrs...

[@kr-dl9yu]

+Hylian Gengar Other you tubers (like Pewdiepie) has too many subscribers (and comments) so they can't reply to all sadly :(

[@disappointedcreepyaj8168]

I honestly think the garden looks more like coraline

[@mersedehm.h1525]

And i just found that beldam can use very powerful genjutsus. She's so smart.

[@anamariecortez2223]

Yeah

[@MaddieMathewson]

But this is not the only piece of cinema that takes place in Oregon and the super natural aka Gravity Falls

[@booboobearsugarbear9109]

You guys...its the angles...if the camera angles were both over head, both pics would look like coraline...but when its dropped down and tilted a bit u can see the beldam...make sure u look closely!

[@badxmemezz1242]

It is coraline this whole beldam and other world crap is just a theory

[@ross1535]

There should be a Coraline 2 if your plot twist about the other mother having the key and still being alive is true.

[@dxRgg-gj7ud]

If there was a Coraline 2 it would basically have no plot if Coraline knows to not go down to the other world.. Unless.... She's going to be the other mother :O

[@poorer7629]

@@dxRgg-gj7ud or if coraline grows up and goes to visit the pink palace for vacation with wybie (her husband) and their kids and her kids find the dooor and there is something in the door from the other mother thats still alive

[@daremetodrawanimation2081]

I think the cat was once the Beldams pet and when the cat found out about his owners plans he tried to help the children. Giving the kids information on the beldam. And the is able to talk because he used to drink water from the well which changes him and he has the power of talking and senses the other portals existence. So the cat can now jump through the portals whenever he wants thats why he disappears and reappears constantly.

[@loupblanche36]

OMG that sounds really accurate!

[@z0mbz]

That’s why the other mother hates cats! That’s what the cat in the movie said right. “The other mother doesn’t like cats” is exactly what he said so would that be why because he was her cat but he “betrayed” her in a way. He found out her plans & ruined them. And now she hates cats.

[@skywolf716]

Doesn’t really make since, his theory makes more since. No hate! Because, the Beldam hates cats. She might hate cats because the cat was the reincarnated boy helping Wybie. I guess yours makes since too? But only if the cats has been helping children before Coraline.

[@emelieallred9425]

dare me to draw Animation the cat would have had to stay alive for 150 years plus the kid scene when coraline throws mud down the well there isn't an immediate plop so how would the cat have drank well water if his neck is nowhere near long enough to reach it.... i think the cat can talk simply because in the void you can make your own rules for certain things so the beldam must have chosen to give him a voice which is why I believe he was a helper at one point but not a pet because he would be alive too long and if magic is keeping him alive just like the beldam then he would die if he left the portal

[@ciciball62]

How could he have drinken the water? The water is a portal not just magic

[@rydenwasreal7554]

I think I know how the other mother knew to get Coraline the new clothes. When Coraline is shopping with her mother, asking for the gloves, you can see a woman with orange hair stood outside watching them and smiling when Coraline says 'my other mother would get them.' Maybe, she is the other mother's spy or maybe, the other mother does have the ability to go to the real world as long as she takes the form of a person who already lives there. Maybe this would explain how she knew Coraline moved into the apartment in the first place, there was a moving guy at the beginning who would've saw Coraline, maybe he had something to do with it?

[@abigailmillar200]

omg you genius!!!

[@NotApplicable1123]

Or someone could have been wearing a button that the beldam had placed in the real world as a part of their clothing, unknowingly carrying the beldams magic into the real world, and letting her see through them.

[@sophiagaiganis8051]

This would explain my comment: AHEM! I have a question. This video states that the Beldam would die of old age if she exited her world under the well due to no magic in the world above. However, this also states that the village/town where this all takes place is supernatural and she has control over it. This also means there is magic in that village/town. So if there is magic, wouldn't the Beldam be able to escape her world into the real supernatural (and therefore magical) town without dieing!? Thanks if you read this.

[@christinalagano4046]

Well she did create the other world maybe she was somehow able to create a "person" to watch her victims and maybe this person can morph into different looking people explaining how beldam knew things that the doll didn't see the question is if that is true then who that was with coralline in the movie that could possibly be the beldams spy THIS MIGHT NOT MAKE ANY SENSE BUT what if the grandma or whoever she is of the cat or something xD what if she was the spy like what if it was a deal that beldam wouldn't mess with her family if she became a spy for her THAT COULD BE WHY THE DOLL WAS IN THE GRANDMA'S CAR

[@NotApplicable1123]

Minecrafter CookieFreak21 (i spent a while writing this comment so pls read and +1 so theorizer sees, i actually might make a video response and tweet at him bc i really wamt his take on this theory) anyway, to the comment/Theory! thats possible, and probable if you take both of those to be true, but it might not make for as good a story if she has no limitations. One possibility (for the sake of making it a good storyline) is that the writers had the beldams power source degrade as she gets farther from it. Or the magic could simply not work outside of the well. OR (this is about to get crazy speculative and might be kinda cool to explore so pls +1 this so theorizer sees) The beldams power source is kids souls right? she tries to keep them happy so she can take their power. But what if the power of the soul is dictated by the actions/emotions and whatnot of the person? if that were true, could the beldam NEED coraline to rebel against her? it would be a great demonstration of soulfullness (i think thats a word) for her to rebel and escape, to save her parents and the other kids, to save the town. What if the beldam did have the magic to see what was going on, EVERYTHING that was going on, she DID see through the eyes of the people with more soul dust who knew the truth, KNEW they were trying to help coraline, and let them, no ENCOURAGED them to help her, becuase she NEEDED coraline to be the "angel" to her "devil" the "Yin" to her "yang" Only the yang was sapping power from the yin the whole time, without the yin knowing, amassing enough power through her rebellion to ACTUALLY take over the town, and reopen the portals and whatnot that we see in the end scene with the cat and the ominous sound. Coralines "rebellion" and "victory" were all staged just so the beldam could get stronger. Now what evidence do i have for this? motivation? Check. Good story? (i.e. writer friendly) Check. explains why (even with tons of magical powers she allowed Coraline and the soul dolls, and the cat to rebel? Check. explains the end scene in a logical way? Check. Leaves enough to be figured out that it wouldnt spoil a sequel? (meaning if they put anymore evidence in the film it would have spoiled a sequel) CHECK MATE.

[@SK-qs9mh]

I get so easily scared, and I know I'll regret watching this come nightime ;-;

[@emersontilly8795]

Wait! Mysterious supernatural activity in the forests of Oregon? Someone call the pines twins.

[@KarlaHernandez-ro1dl]

Emerson Tilly 😂😂😂lol thank you for that you just made my day darling

[@Constellia]

Ahhh, nostalgia ;-;

[@sc_art5408]

Ah gravity falls.

[@translucentbear]

I came to the comments to see if anyone else noticed.

[@charlene5556]

I miss gravity falls :-(

[@kapilbusawah7169]

could the key be one of the Beldam's eyes? Hear me out. My theory is that the void needs a soul to sustain itself, so it lored the Beldam and took her soul, which is why she has button eyes, you know that though. But here's the theory, additionally that the key is the needle sewing two realities, the key's button is the Beldam's eye. The Beldam is an accomplice to the void, just as the Beldam can choose her victims, the void chose the Beldam. The void can clearly lore adults and would easily lore children but it chooses to have an ambassador because it trusts the Beldam and her decisions. Just as the Beldam needed the attention of children and "die of boredom" the void will too. The void is toying with the Beldam on a large scale like the Beldam toys with children and so the key is made by the void and not the Beldam and it's like a security check with who's able to enter. Only the Beldam's soul is truly trusted by the void, so the key is part her soul which enable the void to reveal itself to the Beldam's soul presence. The button has a larger meaning than symbolism, it is literally a functional key with part the Beldam to access the void.

[@kapilbusawah7169]

It enables the human children to enter as they wouldn't otherwise. Why the void trusts the Beldam above all else and chose to have an ambassador; another theory for a different time

[@marnie2449]

Yes, she can see through the key and this is why when coraline is hungry in the kitchen and gets the key to go the the other world, when she gets there there is food as she was hungry. Therefore this confirms she can see through the key for definite in that scene

[@tipsyhyena8943]

woah, your a genius i did not thougt about that

[@marnie2449]

The void was just a random Theory from space so this isn't very easily accurate

[@sophiagaiganis8051]

That's a really good theory!

[@joshginer2588]

what if the cat is the original creator of the other world and he helps coraline cause he hates what the beldam is doing

[@healthycookingwithdotandki1304]

I think the cat dad theory is true

[@imakitchensink4384]

same

[@carolyntalbot947]

Me too, I would like to see this explored further and connected to his name being short for "Why Born." If he is from the early 1900's his race should have major implications. This is a fascinating theory.

[@joeyboboie]

I think she's a fan of spiders just cuz spiders kinda represent sewing

[@joeyboboie]

I also I want to add on to the key theory and the grandma (I have little to know if this is true so bare with me) so I think the woman who lived in the mansion and fell into the well actually only got part of the child's soul causing the old women's loved one who got there soul "half eaten" to die faster this became a fact to the grandmother and kept her grandson away from the mansion and the kid who aged and died to reincarnate BUT sense they didn't have a full soul they became a cat and not a human but what did the women who owned the mansion do with the part of the soul she had? She used it for the key. Remover how eyes and the windows to ur soul? So basically she only got one of the kids eyes and used its "soul power" of the key turning it into a "window" to make sure ONLY kids got the key and having controls over the area gives her the ability to do so making sure only adults came into her universe. That's my theory with little to no grammar but I hope it proved useful (and if it does then please credit? 😂 jk I don't care as long as it's helpful)

[@siennajackson5417]

Alex TheWarrior that's smart!

[@gracevazquez1745]

Alex TheWarrior I think the spider thing is because in the novel the writer describes features of the Beldame to be like a spider. There are even pictures and I think that might be why. But idk, there might be a more legitimate reason as to why?

[@joeyboboie]

I ment to say kids not adults XD

[@joeyboboie]

Meant*

[@peanutjd6140]

Also the parents were NOT taken. It was just a trick to make Coraline go back to the other world

[@bendybob]

But then where were her parents? They were gone for at least a night because Coraline goes to bed and makes them out of pillows. While I doubt they were taken, it was more that just a trick. I believe that the Beldam showed the parents Coraline trapped or in danger (like she did to get Coraline to go back) as they would then go to save her. However, I'm not sure how they got to the other world as they didn't know that it existed - unless the door was glowing/opening. Once they were in the other world the Beldam trapped them in a snow globe and made a doll of them for Coraline to find to let her known that she had trapped her parents.

[@rosellaaj3709]

Peanut JD I agree, but what confuses me is ~~ the cat was on Coraline's side; so if the parents were *NOT* taken, I wonder why he said, "You're walking right into her trap." AND he showed Coraline the vision behind the mirror (which made her WANT to go back). Tbh I just confused myself XD

[@cicikyuu2429]

Dude, you are my favorite theory channel. Your theories are so cool and I like how you're not afraid to say something you and everyone else may think is far-fetched.

[@Surfboarder4]

POKEMON!!!

[@Duriiam]

I agree :D

[@anthonylopez5302]

Why is there no coroline 2

[@jacktheman5690]

ya I want a Caroline 2

[@abbydixson9739]

Because Coriline died

[@MigdaliaAlvarado385]

because everything they used was sold

[@-kj._.ma-]

Anthony Lopez 1. They never made a sequel to the book “Coraline” since the movie is based on the book and 2. Laika doesn’t do sequels so I’m pretty sure if there was a sequel to the book they wouldn’t make a second movie

[@davvekat]

Anthony Lopez the figures were sold.

[@Onion_Wolf]

I've never read the book and haven't watched this in a while but I always assumed the Beldam was a witch before she went to the other world. The cat said hes been going their for awhile and that she hates cats. I think when the bedlam was alive he maybe served her (as slavery wasn't abolished at that time) and African Americans were often associated with voodoo. She also uses dolls. And heals Coraline's hand. Maybe the cat tricked her into that world as witches usually seek immortality. Witches also like to gamble. On the spiders note. They weave webs like she weaved this world, the dolls, the buttons also they are associated with catching their prey. Which is what she spends a long time trying to do.

[@thomaszackry167]

Well, the Beldam settled the area around the 1850's. I'm not that keen into American history, but I recall that the answer for freedom for the African Americans didn't take total effect until after the American Civil War. The American Civil War didn't start until 1861. So maybe slavery was still a common thing during the Beldam's era (before the Civil War). Sorry if my theory isn't in line with yours.

[@Onion_Wolf]

You don't need to apologise for your opinion, you've done all the research! Mines more like guesses not a theory. I just like the idea of voodoo coming into play :D

[@Onion_Wolf]

Eva Pesce she hates cats he said.

[@thomaszackry167]

Chaos Covah Oh thanks. I recently posted my own theory about the Beldam being a witch. It's somewhere in the comment section above

[@raniageraghty8613]

I think this makes more sense than the cat being apart of the family tree

[@literallyclare3864]

I watched coraline when I was like 8 which was a long time but when I watched it last year I was thinking when the other mother Taps her fingers on the table could that have symbolized how many children she killed by taking there souls just a thought

[@sallygomez2657]

LiterallyClare that could be true but

[@mikemoss8788]

Sally gomez BUT WHAT WHAT DO YOU WANT TO SAAAAY BOOOY

[@novafrom1312]

I think it could but. Then why isnt it more ghosts then? The sand she uses. Can it be that whwen the sand from one child have been used up the soul is gone?

[@janairodriguez2040]

+der MOSS i

[@ScreamingVulture]

LiterallyClare one flow corline still has free will to go in the door but I think she is not then she will move when she has a kid that way her kid will not get taken

[@millewolfhard3834]

The "other dad" has a piano, right? And it also has these hands..the "other mother" is controlling the hands. How do I know this? because the "other dad" was trying to tell Coraline something that she can't know, then the hands cover his mouth. MIND BLOWN!

[@massasambola3298]

Heres Something I Thought about the other mom. You see in the gone scene Coraline Throws a spider in Coralines Mothers Coffee. And How Does it Get out You Ask. Who Knows. But That Might've Showed why Beldam / The other Mother Turned Into A Spider Lover. Also The Beldam Cant Come Out, So she Has to Trap people In the other world. Doesnt that sound like a fact? Heres a true fact "A Spider Stays im it web, Doesnt Leave until there web is Destroyed. So they Wait For A Prey to Come So They Can Feed on it" Also The theory about the Cat Being the Grandpa Is Probably Good. Because to keep Um The Boy And Coraline Safe he Follows Them. Why? Who Knows. When Coraline Denied The Buttons Probably Beldam Started Mutating to some Old Spider. Because she Cant Get Her To Get The Buttons. Also You Welcome and... Matpat : ITS JUST A THEORY!

[@massasambola3298]

I must be a theory Person

[@zefirst755]

I KNOW WHAT THE COTTON HAS TO DO WITH THE SAND! I found out online and from my mother (who loves the outdoors) that RED SOIL is great for growing COTTON and RED SOIL can have the texture of clay or SAND. Also, areas that have RED SOIL have very SANDY SOIL!

[@zefirst755]

Also RED SOIL is found in ASHLAND!!!!

[@siennajackson5417]

Zeh Kitteh 😱

[@niwatori024]

How about instead of the Beldam having control of the real world she takes control of The Pink Palace, which in itself is a paradox which has her pocket universe, and those who inhabit it. Controlling them as if they were... Dolls. When you enter the house (preferably naive children) she is able to change the things around you and manipulate your surroundings and life to make children fall in love with her. Like a game with dolls. And the only way to win is to escape and to not fall into her trap. You break the curse/paradox and your life goes normal although everything that had happened was real it was just in a paradox/pocket universe. Although this is kinda half baked, what do you think Theorizer?

[@niwatori024]

And much like you Theorizer Coraline was and still is one of my ALL TIME FAVOURITE MOVIES LIKE OH MY GAWD HELL YE

[@Hex.A.Decimal]

I think I'm in love. With this theory.

[@niwatori024]

Hex A. Decimal Ye

[@prettydeadguy]

After he said here's what I've got a ad play lmao

[@prettydeadguy]

Played

[@sylveongirl3267]

Katy Austin LOL

[@loover.leever.9743]

It could be possible that The "BELDAM" could be Martha Jane Kanagy Helman, who was the wife of Abel Helman who was a leader of (one of few others?) the ashland settlers, so she could also be a leader in a way. There is also a house that may slightly represent the "Pink Palace Apartments" in the movie Coraline that is located somewhere in Oregon Link to the photo is here: cdn.onlyinyourstate.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/IMG_1155-700x525.jpg There I dunno I'm tired as hell and I'm just throwing something out :/

[@sianclarke2507]

the pink palace was actually a replica of the authours actual house

[@carlakoala7415]

Omg look at that

[@carolyntalbot947]

🤯🤯🤯

[@aaryn7786]

The Theorizer: After all, the other world is probably in another dimension. Me: MULTIVERSE TIME BITCHES!!!!!! Like for season 3 of Gravity Falls

[@lucyyjoness]

I always thought it was coralines face in the garden and that the other mother did it to impress her

[@KKTCrawford]

Lucy Jones in the garden within the other world it is, but at the end it's the garden in the real world and there is a definite difference in the way the face looks. (and the creepiness of it as well)

[@loupblanche36]

Thekaemonpanshow have you relized how similar coralines face and the beldams face are? i think that she is accually a long lost relitive of the beldam

[@PichuBro8]

Do you think they'll ever make a Coraline 2, then? Sense the Beldam is still alive, I mean.

[@dreamyguessblocker4254]

they should!

[@Joe_Vinky]

they really should they could make it creepier than it already is plus make new characters and explain more plot

[@chloebeth8270]

They are making a number two

[@Joe_Vinky]

Chloe Beth​ they are?

[@aleiyah9539]

+waffle foffle Disney canceled the making of Coraline 2 apparently. I haven't found any actual info proving they are making a second one. It's pretty much just people hoping and making petitions to get another one started up

[@aluriene3196]

I am thinking that her button eyes are actually watching from the KEY!

[@brandymartin9497]

シMaroline I KNOW TOTAROKI TOO his name is shoto tokaroki and DEKU and BOGOGO

[@angelicamazyn4293]

I really love your channel. It's hard to find good channels for theories.

[@ughnotyouagain9042]

Yeah, most of the other channels just steal theories from other people.

[@bjornthorgudmundsson2781]

first of all learn to fucking write if you want anyone to understand you secondly i think the theoriser could learn from game theory at least concerning his physics/science theorys since game theory actually breaks down the formulas so you wont need a degree in physics to understand their theory

[@TheTheorizer]

+Björn Thor Gudmundsson MatPat mostly gets his math completely wrong, but very rarely do people call him out on it. His Bullet Bill, Majora's Moon, Wario's fart physics, Sonic speed, Metroid's morph ball, and Assassin's creed jump, are all completely done wrong, and that's only a few. But as far as better explanation, I'm getting better and better at explaining them.

[@bjornthorgudmundsson2781]

The Theorizer i think people dont call him out on it cause most people dont know how to figure out the calculations i could learn a bit from the explanations but im not a college educated rocket scientist so if i just followed his calculations i would get the same wrong answer and any actual scientists probably have more important things to do then calculate assasins creed jump physics

[@TheTheorizer]

Björn Thor Gudmundsson Exactly. I even confirmed any final suspicions I had with some online "super physicists" and they said he was beyond wrong. But I like some of his lore videos :D

[@poppinrose5641]

is anyone else confused on how Coraline's hair is Blue?! Most schools don't allow any dye and in the old photo she had brown hair? Her parents wouldn't allow her to dye her ha ir

[@sherlynnpayz8281]

I know

[@ilovehachiko3697]

Poppin Rose She dyed her hair because of the accident...to make her happy or because the accident ruined her her,i'm not sure...

[@mischamz]

@@ilovehachiko3697 what was the accident again?

[@ilovehachiko3697]

Potato Plebs In the movie,Coraline's mother mentioned about the accident.Watch it if you don't remember.

[@undergroundsalmon2815]

Actually most schools really dont care about stuff like that. I had pink hair in 6th grade.

[@TiBunCosplay]

I have a few things.. First, I find myself asking about Wybie's grandmother. I like and can see the reason she did let Coraline's family into the Pink Palace as a way to save her grandson. It's kind of underhanded of her, but she already lost her sister, and she seems to know about the Other Mother. Her sister had probably told her the stories before she disappeared, much like how Coraline told her parents at first. So she did it to save Wybie. But then, i was wondering to myself, why would she be mad that Wybie took the doll? Didn't she want to sacrifice Coraline in order to save him? Then I realized. She isn't a mean old lady. she's friendly and kind. So, while she does what she thinks she has to do to protect him, she isn't heartless. She knows the doll has something big to do with what happened to her sister--a doll that looked exactly like her sister? kind of creepy. so, when it disappeared on her, she must have known it likely had taken on Coraline's image, and it was beginning all over again. She wanted to distract the Beldam, but not just hand over another child. She wanted to keep that one tool of the Beldam's away from Coraline, to hinder, and perhaps stop the Beldam from ever tempting Coraline through the tiny door portal, hoping that the Beldam would be focusing on Coraline but unable to actually get to her. But when Wybie took the doll and gave it to Coraline, her plans to help protect Coraline was dashed, and that's why she freaked out, wanting him to get it back for her. Second, I don't believe that she's related to the cat. I'm not sold on the cat ever being human before,, weather he's related to grandma or not. However, I do think there is something about him. He does seem older than his assumed cat years, so I wonder if maybe he was a cat around when the Beldam was a normal human. Maybe a mangy stray she hated hanging around. And when she got involved with the other demention or whatever, some f the magic affected him as well, and has kept him alive all these many years. Thats why he can talk in the other world, though because he obviously didnt sew buttons over his eyes and create that connection and need of staying in the other world, he can still come and go as he wishes. Third, I'm pretty sure that there are two sets of mice. the real mice, and the other mice. She created her mice to go and act as spies, but Bobinsky's mice are not in on the Beldam's plot at all. They just know. They probably found mini portals as well and have spied on the other mother. that's why they send a warning to Coraline not to go through the little door. Because if they were the same mice the Beldam made, then they wouldn't warn her at all. The other mice, the other dogs, and the other neighbors are the only ones loyal to the Other Mother. Even in the end the other mice prove their loyalty to the Beldam by keeping the eye away from Coraline and trying to sound an alarm. The cat had to help Coraline with the other mice. The other dad and other Wybie were the only ones of her creations that betrayed the Beldam. (I typed this part up before you went over the soul sand point and yeah that would explain it. lol) Editing in: I wonder if the well is like a one-way portal. that's why the Beldam didn't want the key to be thrown in. it'd be locked in on her side and she needs it to go through the now locked door to tempt another kid into her trap. Sooner, at least. I'm sure if she gathers her power up after a time she can get it back on the real world side.... Also, I wonder why she put Coraline into the mirror room where she could talk to the ghosts. she had to know that Coraline wouldn't "behave" after that. was she that desperate, maybe? hoping that a few days of no food would weaken her to the point where she can force on the buttons because a weak soul is better than none?

[@celestegarcia2870]

So much effort, I wish I could thing more into this, but I could ponder on it later. Then i'll reply. Again.

[@marielol8200]

I want to write a fan fiction about what happened to Wybie's Grandmas sister.

[@angel76888]

i totally agree the beldam creates the other mice and when the one trys to warn her by sounding an alarm the cat bites into the mouse and it reveals a creepy rat which sand from it pours out

[@sz8430]

Your teories make so much sense!

[@petruciosxdrn5881]

Hmm, it is a little weird, considering a cat and the mice seem to know about the Other World, but not the dogs? Am I just being racist?

[@J03SAM]

*Dumb thing I noticed about Coraline’s hair* +:+ In the photo of young Coraline, her hair is (obviously) brunette, meaning she dyed it blue. She had blue hairclips, representing her future blue hair and her hair was noticeably middle-parted and not side parted. So she hadn’t worn the dragonfly clip yet ; she didn’t discover her spirit animal?

[@yy-ri8nl]

What if the cat was wabbys father?? The cats always near him and In part four he said the cat protects wabby.fathers protects there kids.

[@SARA-kh1kp]

y y Who is “Wabby”?

[@willis1383]

who the hecc is wabby do you mean wybie?

[@shaniatingman2083]

y y I love the way you spelled his name😂 it’s wybie shirt for wyborne

[@KittKattRED]

Hello. I love your thought provoking channel and I wanted to share something. If your saying that the water us the portal, then the water is magic. If the water evaporates into fog the magic is lifted into the air, allowing for the bell dam to have her control.

[@KittKattRED]

you're

[@Kakashi-yb8ry]

There ARE several more entrances and exists that lead to the Other World/Real World. It's actually proven in the book when Coraline informs the cat that the Beldam is "fixing all the gates and the doors to keep you out" (emphasis on the "keep you out", which leads us to think that the Beldam KNOWS that the cat knows something she doesn't want Coraline to know) then the cat answers "there's ways in and ways out of places like this that even SHE doesn't know about". Then something really interesting happens which is when Coraline asks him if the Beldam made this place, which leads the cat to answer "made it, found it--what's the difference? Either way, she's had it a very long time". What could this possibly mean? How come the Beldam doesn't know about the other passages since she's presumably created the Other World? Hmm 🤔

[@Kakashi-yb8ry]

exits*

[@danniellablake5308]

very good point!

[@RosePatty]

^🤔

[@angelusvastator1297]

Is the Other World hell since its underground? O_O.

[@jesica9estefania]

Because perhaps she didn't create it, she found it, and manipulate the place in her own way, and that would explain why the other father and some others have free will, because they already existed in that world.

[@metrozeegle4985]

Coraline after this theory: "I don't like sand" !

[@alybot2.059]

Metroz Eegle it’s course and it gets everywhere

[@darthwatermelon6925]

Hello there

[@SamTheSparrowYT]

(Then proceeding to turn into Darth Vader after obi had the high ground)

[@Peacheselaine21]

Awe. I like how he was so calm about everyone taking his credit. We all know he is the original Theorizer

[@dannyxxx9424]

I got so excited when I saw you uploaded a new coraline video! So many great new ideas and theories, loved them

[@Surfboarder4]

Me too!

[@dissapointed_spaghetti]

same here as I love hearing others ideas and them extending them to it will be heard as I tend to watch old movie theroys and every time I commenent it is definitely pointless.

[@mariadelosangelescaliforni1604]

the boy and the cat have bule eyas

[@jacktheman5690]

Maria De Los Angeles California True

[@drake-bh1ni]

So the cats owner is wybie

[@EmeraldHero]

ok so?

[@nataliesplitlog3438]

you know it seems like the moon is DIRECTLY over the well

[@sc_art5408]

Natalie Splitlog Holy. Shit.

[@sarahmichelle3192]

i just realized, when coraline’s mom would get her the gloves, coraline says, “my other mother would get them.” and then her mom mentions something about the other mother getting coraline more clothes.....and coraline shows up into the other world to see that the other mother made her new clothes!

[@igorkarsanov2374]

I have a theory that connects the mom finding the key, Coraline's squid toy, and the mom hiding the key above the door, which are all things that bothered me on my third watch through. most notably the squid. look at what it has for an ink sac: a button. it is the ONLY non Beldam creation with a button, so what if the Beldam DID create it? then I thought about the mom. she found the button key almost immediately. almost as if she was here before, and then she hid the key. why? it might be to stop Coraline from nagging her but how? in fact hiding it would actually result in more nagging! so what if, she used to live in the pink palace as a child? the Beldam gave her the squid as a spy, but then she moved away and passed off the otherworld as a dream, and then she grew up and gave the squid toy to Coraline and moved back. she found the key because she remembered using it and showed Coraline that it was just bricks. but something kept nagging her. she vaguely remembered her childhood dreams and subconsciously tried to protect her daughter from the otherworld by hiding the key

[@lyss3842]

Igor Karsanov Damn this is good

[@darthreaper6311]

Igor Karsanov Thats pretty good. I like that theory

[@Dany-cc4dd]

Igor Karsanov Ikr I was thinking the same when I watched the movie. I was like: why did she leave the key away from the other keys? It’s like she new about the portal or something

[@patthemat7134]

I like you you never jumpscare the viewers

[@jessywessy5196]

he has once and I cried a little inside

[@peanutjd6140]

I think that she fell down the well. Also I don't really know why the other mother didn't drag her down the well, but it is possible the well is another portal because I'm the film Wybe says "If you fall in you'll see the night and stars in the middle of the day." One last thing: When ever Coraline goes into the other world it is always night time and Wybe even supports this saying that if you fall in you will see the night and stars even when it is in the middle of the day. In the picture it is day and that is the real world so, in the other world it is always night and the picture has importance in the film.

[@josephcastano4598]

Notice that in the poster her hand is over the house, which kinda confirms she has control over the real world. She’s a puppeteer. Another thing that supports this theory is when the piano takes control over the other father. He even says “This piano plays me!”.

[@maykamman2854]

well if she keeps herself "alive" with the soulsand of KIDS, she might get some characteristic things from the children, like playing games.

[@juiceboxti9914]

That is a good observation

[@maykamman2854]

+Tiril Gran thank you :D

[@maykamman2854]

after this comment I also came to think of: "IF she has power in de real world and IF she can lure and trap people (like coralines parents) with force, why doesnt she do that with the kids themselves?? well, think about Harry Potter when he learned how to do the patronus. With HAPPINESS. I think that the souls of kids are way stronger if they feel happy, so she tries to make the children as happy as she possibly can. And she needs more children because the happiness won't restore in the stolen souls

[@alycia5581]

Or maybe she likes to be amused...

[@maykamman2854]

+AllyGirl22 could be true also

[@emseoane779]

i have a feeling the thud at the end was her killing the cat, so then she can rebuild the other world and lure in more kids without the cat protecting them and ruining her plan

[@dayleneeeee]

Em Seoane That's a bit dark child. ( It's ment as a joke )

[@liz27ann]

Em Seoane But then the cat was at Coraline’s window in the “real world” after she “won” against the Beldam... so she couldn’t have killed him.

[@otterbabies]

Em Seoane this scared me the fuck out

[@TV-8-301]

These theories make the movie frightening.

[@jasilhill5468]

true that

[@pandapants9625]

As if it weren't frightening enough already.

[@aznlife879]

+PandaPants ikr hahaha

[@carriehawker4421]

I have never been scared of the film but after watching all the videos it defiantly makes the film seem creepy.

[@queendsheena1]

These are some great theories and thoughts.

[@kennediechols105]

But have you noticed that When Coraline went to the garden to get the first ghost eye that the other father broke his hand free and gave coraline the eye himself

[@rosellaaj3709]

Kennedi Echols Yes!! I saw that too :O While he is chasing Coraline in the giant mantis robot, you can hear him saying "Mother made me..!" The Other Father and everything in the Other World was always a part of the Beldam's attempt to abduct more children..

[@kyleblaney8786]

Maybe the beldam likes playing games so much because she actually had a child of her own which she may have lost. Maybe that's part of the reason you don't hear about her family so she creates her own based off of others and takes the souls. She was human at one point so this is quite reasonable. Maybe her kid ran away and that's why when Coraline tries to escape she says "how dare you disobey your mother" as she sounds like a strict or mean mother and that explains the longing for love, a child and souls.

[@numberoneweirdo8980]

While there is too much evidence to support the theory it is still a good one. First off, a good thing to add is she is very controlling over the other father. What I think is that maybe she had a husband and her husband took her child an left for some reason. Which this could also be evidence. She doesn't actually mean any harm, but her anger over powers her. She has to move from child to child since they eventually end up dying or something else.

[@sejmmymeii]

Very good point

[@pichuuu]

Yea maybe :O

[@kyleblaney8786]

+Mr. SunggleMuffins yeah exactly! She is really manipulative as you can see from the other father and wybie. Even the other father says "mustn't talk when mothers not around" and "her strength is our strength" showing how controlling she is again.

[@hellohello-fz6he]

Woah.

[@amelievandecasteele4998]

I have a question for you. It might be interesting it might not but just read it. (BTW sorry for any grammar or spelling mistakes. English isn't my native language) Why do the other dad and webie first obey the beldam? The first time they meet Coraline they do what the beldam wants them to do, make Coraline 'willing to stay'. But when the movie progresses, they try to protect Coraline. Trying to warn her and get her out. It they are filled with the soulsand of others, then why don't they immediately warn her? Is this because they are afraid of the beldam, because they lost hope to save Coraline? Or is there maybe another explanation?

[@Surfboarder4]

The Theorizer should defo look into this.

[@desmondben8576]

Well the dad tries to warn her in his song which had a few subliminal messages in the lyrics. He mentions words like buttons, and eyes. He also says that the place is boring when she isn't there. And yes the reason they can't outright warn her is because the other mother would know she'd kill them. Just look at what happens to other wybie in the film after he helps her. As the film progresses, the other mother starts losing her magic which gives everything in other world life. Realizing that their going to die anyway, they decide to help her.

[@positivelyj3096]

This is exactly my question. But also...at the end the father starts not functioning and falling apart as well as loosing shape. However Wybi doesn't do this! How come?

[@jackie10107]

Because the Beldam might have taken his life, as in the scene where she gets the eye from the jumping mice, his clothes are hanging on the pole.

[@Kurokikun01]

I think it was because they were FIRST made. They were like babies, so when they finally got a sense of self, they protected Coraline.

[@bowtieboy6348]

“The Magical.... *Kittens”* 😂😂😂

[@dutybomb1238]

I dont know why i still want a sequel to this movie

[@schemar17]

me 2

[@logankyo8294]

Nice pun XD

[@josha8439]

i want it to so badly :(( i dreamed the sequel about 5 times xDD sorry for bad english :p

[@angelakim2313]

Same here

[@magictigeraj6608]

+Coraline Frost yea but it may hurt the movies main storyline Although the second one could be about the beldam coming back Somehow

[@hientrangbui7329]

You deserve a hugeeee credit for this incredible series!

[@yadanaoo9377]

Ahhhhhh I really want Coraline 2

[@yadanaoo9377]

If it ever existed

[@yadanaoo9377]

If such thing ever existed

[@Unknown-xn8de]

So Do I!!!!!! P.s.Sorry I'm late

[@farrahibarra2658]

8 years from now The theorizer Winn’s the award for watching Coriline the most times

[@sharonhutchinson8091]

I love this movie and i watch it everyday

[@mersedehm.h1525]

They must create more animations like this.

[@victoriamayw]

Has no one realized the similarities between coraline and the Alice in wonderland story

[@TheTheorizer]

watch any of my alice in wonderland / wizard of oz vids

[@georgev7845]

How can the Beldam get Coraline back? She definitely won't be going back herself and the Beldam can't go out herself so how can she get coralline back?

[@EekPudds]

Moon Gemini oh no i have not. Tjank u for that

[@mkimble5699]

George V maybe one day someone Caroline realy cares about will be tricked into going in and it's up to Caroline to save him or her

[@thenaNevelyn]

Moon Gemini but coralline is better

[@lyricjohnson6492]

I looked up Oregon 1900 and skimmed through some of the pictures. There was a picture of a house called Shelton McMurphey Johnson House and it looked almost exact in design upon the house in Coraline. However, it was in Eugene, Oregon.

[@lyricjohnson6492]

It is a museum now though. But there was a woman whom owned the house. And she is dressed almost exactly the way the Beldam was, the house was built by her father in the 1876, whom was a physician if that is important at all.

[@thomaszackry167]

Can we have links to that?

[@lyricjohnson6492]

Sure. This is what I had been looking at 1909ventilo.me/2013/02/02/castle-on-the-hill-shelton-mcmurphey-house-built-in-1876-eugene-oregon/

[@newtonconniglio2466]

Wow....

[@raniageraghty8613]

that's kinda scary! XD Is there a well?

[@cait3990]

I know this video is old but remember the beginning when the other mother sent the Coraline doll out of the window? It was starry out, and when Coraline and WB met WB told Coraline that if you went to the bottom of the well and looked up you could see a sky full of stars. If the doll got to the real world from the other mothers world, then how does the doll get through to the real world through a window? The point I am trying to get to is, what if the “window” was really the bottom of the well?!🧐

[@yellowkittyfangs11]

He mentioned this in the last vid! And someone said how the floating nature of the doll leaving the window was like it drifting through water

[@littlemoth4956]

Can y’all please pay attention? He says this exact thing in the videos.

[@lucianoasenjo2245]

how did the other mother's hand (MADE OUT OF NEEDLES) see coraline trying to throw the key down the well??

[@christinemcleod877]

Because it says that the other mother can see through buttons. On top of the key is a button so from the other world she was controlling the hand while watching through the key. Make sense? Haha its far fetched but makes some sense i think

[@sinare-9090]

Lol we are talking about a severed hand made out of needles and moving of its own volition..

[@Jackie_Porras]

wait why does coraline have brown hair in there old family photo ?????

[@TheTheorizer]

Because it's her natural colour

[@Jackie_Porras]

The Theorizer thanks that cleared it up

[@mahletm6837]

The Theorizer can I get get a shout out u are so smart

[@frederickdavies8969]

JD GPorras : she probably died it

[@avalittle5494]

JD GPorras It could be Dye like chinchin said but also I think it's something "Else"

[@yourredscarf9113]

AOSI, I THINK THE BELDAM HAS ADHD , and that us why she taps, she is not impatient, and she has ocd, the reason for her having everything symmetrical like the sewing room.

[@lilab151]

The father appeared in the Other world, with buttons in his eyes, but does not know of anything in the real world, even though the mice can travel back and forth and turn into rats when killed. They are the same being, able to move between worlds, still a 'creation' of the Beldam. They turn into their real selves, though, when soul sand leaks out. Like another commenter suggested, when the soul sand disappears from the doll, it turns into an ordinary doll with cotton stuffing. But, she couldn't have taken the father and sewn buttons into his eyes, then filled him with soul sand to control him, and THEN he know nothing about it in the real world, could she?! She didn't. The other father is merely an entity created by the Beldam. His real self is just a passive being, but with the soul sand, he is controlled by the Beldam. Though, as you stated in a previous video, the more sand, the stronger the being's soul. That's why (as someone else said) he reaches to give Coraline the soul and says, 'So sorry. Don't wanna hurt you. Mother made me." He wants to help her. This is why the Beldam can easily sew Wybie's mouth with no blood. He isn't a human. All the people in the Other World are just existences used by the Beldam, and the real people don't know anything about it because it wasn't them.

[@voltronimusprime3833]

The other father was a pumpkin.

[@dansdimple1539]

voltronimus prime i thought he was a squash

[@voltronimusprime3833]

Nope, when you look at some of the behind the scenes photos, which Theorizer has shown, he was supposed to be maid from a pumpkin.

[@wat5709]

spilt blue we already knew this though, of course the beings in the other world aren't human

[@dansdimple1539]

voltronimus prime silly me

[@Laylaamour89]

Minds blown your genius 👏🏽the sheer research that’s gone into this is incredible! Well done

[@audrey501]

In the window of the "Garden life" at the very top to the left, it looks like the doll of Coraline.

[@twylaeisenhauer9853]

some spiders eat their own young. is that why?

[@emiliegilles7016]

Oh my God this comment messed me up

[@thisismyrealname900]

OMG WHY

[@oliveoil3294]

OMGSHSGVWDJ

[@theskeletontraveler97]

THAT'S A GREAT POINT

[@twylaeisenhauer9853]

idk why but its a thing. and yeah he asked why the walls were spider themed and i said this to point out how the belldam feeds on the souls of her "kids"

[@nytekorelegacy7200]

your channel has grown so much!!

[@TheTheorizer]

Hey, weren't you one of my earlier subs?

[@helenhodges2656]

+The Theorizer changed? I don't see a difference whounder what that guys on about

[@TheTheorizer]

Helen Hodges They mean that my channel has gotten an insane amount of subs in only a few months.

[@nytekorelegacy7200]

+The Theorizer yeah I am XD you're growing so fast it's a beautiful thing to see!

[@nytekorelegacy7200]

+The Theorizer I can't wait till you reach 1M you have a supernacular mind!

[@gust.2435]

We know the mice in the real world kniw everything cause bobinsky ssid *mice said do not go through little door*