CRAZY DETAILS! | GTA5 vs. RDR2 vs. Cyberpunk2077

[@JarringSteak]

Can't believe RDR2 is already 5 years old 😵

[@user-up8pp5ro3b]

It is still the most realistic Game

[@JarringSteak]

@@user-up8pp5ro3b True, and it also got an amazing story and insanely good characters... Ngl it's the perfect game for me.

[@user-up8pp5ro3b]

@@JarringSteak for me too it have one of the best Story ever

[@juanpabloflores8179]

Can't believe I"ve been binge playing Cyberpunk for 3 years!

[@Govertoll]

6 yrs

[@stonecold2797]

Red dead 2 is really insane

[@aubnr8538]

I think it's an awesome game but the more I look at it's details I love it even more!!!

[@NanaSuryana-fh9xz]

Yes, people nowadays are good at making games

[@Final_SC]

I just want rdr to take place in modern times, like rn, like gta6

[@FEDERALBEREAUOFIMCOMPENTRNCE]

@@Final_SC bro thats gta

[@Final_SC]

@@dbdvdvbhddbdbb okay so, this was 8 days ago, before i played rdr2, i played like 3 days ago and completed the epilogue and all, i had no idea what I was saying lol, it seems like riding horses is much fun

[@ghostlyn69]

Pool water in GTA V is a shader while the ocean has actual physics in it so yeah just wanted to let you know

[@dauphongii]

well, in Cyberpunk they also used some small pond in desert it seems, but to be fair GTA 5 is over a decade old so it's surprising it can keep up with these games

[@Exilir8]

@@dauphongii it doesn't matter where the pond was in Cyberpunk 2077. This commentor is merely saying that GTA 5 uses different animation methods on a pool, and the ocean. Cyberpunk 2077 uses the same animation method everywhere.

[@abhirupkundu2778]

still horrible physics. Funny how it increases your FPS when you reach the ocean, and in RDR2 it destroys your FPS.

[@cleiters4180]

​@@abhirupkundu2778 because rdr 2 use realistic physics water

[@Magst3r1]

@@abhirupkundu2778 Still some of the best physics

[@BigBoneESB]

The shockwave knocking off the hat in RDR2 is absolutely magnificent small detail.

[@dlovankingsman]

timestamp ?

[@waffler-yz3gw]

@@dlovankingsmanthe video

[@BigBoneESB]

3:10

[@internetcutie]

great thing about that aspect of RDR2 is they needed to invest in making that work so well because it happens to you, the player. as Arthur is blown up or falls his hat needs to not only fall off his head, fly off in an appropriate manner and land all in one motion but be retrievable making all hats NPCS or not behave the same way since they all are wearable and some even collectable. (aside from most hats worn by women, i guess Arthur's head is too chonky) i'd say more impressive than the blast blowing the hat off is being able to shoot the hats off and having your own hat shot off during combat

[@The_Noob_Folk]

GTA 5 is 10 years old, and it still looks great.

[@Merlayz]

maybe thats because they keep remastering it over and over for newer generations xD

[@ZerSKYi]

@@Merlayz the video shows the PC version which is from 2015 and has not been graphically improved since then :)

[@mini1602]

@@ZerSKYi Yes and even ps4 version (2014) looks almost just like pc version. 10 years! yet still looks better then starfield in my opinion..

[@PeterPauls]

Very low polygon count it aged, it is clearly shows. I'm still playing it but we really, really need that GTA VI before GTA V 100% lost its longevity.

[@angrycinnamontoast794]

​@@PeterPaulsnah, I'd play

[@Partyharder4]

I was shocked to see the raindrop graphics with cyberpunk

[@seynpurrp]

Same bro XD

[@John_marston569]

Yeah, that actually looked sick

[@user-rf4vc7mt4d]

Yeah now that that's out of the way, I hope they have time to fix the "Minecraft boat on ice" driving physics

[@funnymemer4352]

u clearly don't understand graphic then 💀 Roblox and Cyberpunk share the same raindrops physics lmao .. it's probably the worst thing u can fine good in a game that says it AAA bruh .. Cyberpunk are such a beautiful story then entire gameplay and design was a hugeee disappointment

[@swarnavaghosh908]

​@@funnymemer4352yea even the animation is half baked

[@elgallokriki2105]

i gotta be honest with you this 9:30 looks incredible

[@II_GzB_II]

Yeah it looks insane coming from cyberpunk. I hope GTA 6 keeps these small details in mind.

[@Fck_the_atf]

@@II_GzB_IItheres no way they wouldn’t in my opinion. Gta is what started the idea of having small details in games. At least they are what made it a standard. Alot of old games have small details but small details as a whole was seen as a bonus and not a standard.

[@ValidT]

Yeah it looks great visually but detail wise its a little over exaggerated and unrealistic how much the rain is effecting the water, it looks like the entire dang lake is vibrating. From what I could tell the droplets didn't seem to affect the puddles so my opinion goes to rdr2 on that one.

[@SB95-sussy]

Yt compression moment

[@roamn4979]

@@ValidTIf we were to measure it purely based on realism, then sure, I'd give it to RDR2 too. However, since this is a game and games don't have to be realistic but visually appealing, I'd give it to Cyberpunk.

[@juanpabloflores8179]

Cyberpunk went from no bullet animation in water to surprisingly, IMHO, the best animation.

[@specc_s1452]

Not really suprisingly, knowing that the devs were forced to release early

[@duckeeey9782]

i wouldn't ssay the best, it's better than when it was release but compare to rockstar, cyberpunk animation is clonky and unatural, can't blame them tho cause rockstar is years into making open world games

[@daz8726]

fr i love CP

[@Wertyber]

​@@daz8726that sounds so wrong

[@AdamMerlin]

It makes a perfect circle. Perfect. But not realistic. Rdr2 is the most realistic

[@woomyrune]

live grenade thrown at his feet, ready to explode at any moment "whatever dude" walks away

[@CowPoke1880]

In RDR2 your character will hold their guns above the water when they are walking in it to avoid water damage.

[@happydog_69]

RDR ll physics are amazing

[@agustinnarvaez5251]

In the first test, you can see how RDR2 mimics the bullet bouncing a single time on the water, creating a second splash ahead. This game is a true masterpiece

[@planetapit777]

It may have gone wrong at the beginning but, man, I love CP

[@notSkyhits]

WHATTTTT

[@Taskmasterxyz]

That abbreviation 😭

[@user-ww4oc5cp2n]

Bro, FBI agent and lawyer getting coffee after that one

[@WhtieS]

💀

[@elahdivad3433]

AYO PAUSE!!!

[@turanbirligi6969]

Rdr2 still crushes

[@Nafiur13]

Just realised CyberPunk's short form is CP 💀

[@TechnoGaming_141]

💀💀

[@Andruthless]

Did you also just realize the nickname for Richard is Dick? Omg so funny right?? Grow up bruh

[@joxter3777]

club penguin

[@cavman9883]

Cheif of police, command post, commerical paper, cerebral palsy, control pannel, constant pressure, critical path, candle power.

[@kolonataurus]

Cheese pizza

[@SkellyMcBones]

shoots at the water: "LOOOSER"

[@mr.curious5636]

That was NPC's reaction to the physics of V

[@yanez_exe3292]

tbh if this is what rdr2 looks like now, gta 6 must have intense details

[@CanadianBongRipper]

Rockstar always surpass themselves

[@matthewwilliams3827]

GTA 6 will look pretty much the same Quality….lol

[@matthewwilliams3827]

@@CanadianBongRipperit won’t be any better. Lol

[@ibrahimmohd5166]

​@@matthewwilliams3827 how was 2050 sir

[@Roblocksgaming]

@@ibrahimmohd5166”It won’t be any better lol” when you are comparing a 7 year difference it will.

[@charlyg-2590]

_6:36__ His face seems to have been carved by angels themselves!_

[@NanaSuryana-fh9xz]

Rockstar is really good at making games😮

[@Cyph3rV0id]

bro called rockstar's developers angel

[@wingsoficarus1139]

@@NanaSuryana-fh9xz They just suck at updating them without abandoning them for monetary gain in GTAO

[@ARSaVaGE2626]

@@wingsoficarus1139 They know people will keep playing them until their next release, and it was proven by their sales, why would they give a shit honestly.

[@Treydyn_Deloza]

3:11 bro said "you little balls", but in Spanish😂😂

[@charlyg-2590]

_0:58__ In RDR2 and CyberPunk the reaction of water with the impact of the bullet is more realistic than in GTA V._ 😯

[@fandart4316]

no fucking way, almost like gta 5 came out 10 YEARS AGO

[@HispAsian_]

Dude, gta 5 is 10 years old. Try to do a comparison with physics with gta 5 and cyberpunk, and come back to this comment.

[@waffler-yz3gw]

so butthurt over the guy stating a fact, yall two in the replies are pathetic

[@HispAsian_]

@@waffler-yz3gw u expect everything to be so perfect?

[@automation7295]

@@fandart4316 Yeah it's fucking 10 year old, and yet you motherfuckers still play it.

[@trp]

NPC's when you throw a grenade at them: *Whatever, duuude* _gets blown up_

[@bearlover8500]

you killed a fish with that bomb in rdr2

[@user-aq1]

GTA 6 is -1 year old, and it still looks great!

[@noobtheprogamer2288]

its not even out yet

[@user-aq1]

@@noobtheprogamer2288 I said "-1"

[@MR-UNLUCKY-999]

​@@user-aq1ooooooooooohhhhhh

[@megakarlachofficial]

​@@noobtheprogamer2288r/woooosh

[@badieTV]

Half Life 3 out for -30 years, the physics are phenomenal!

[@PowerGamerSC]

gta v water is at it's best in ocean/river surfaces, pool water is kind of "simpler"

[@dpgamesbr4965]

Sim, comparação errada ...

[@PowerGamerSC]

exato, agua da piscina sempre é mais broxa@@dpgamesbr4965

[@the-Gammaron]

The problem is that a lot of those effects were added to Cyberpunk after more than a year!

[@alexo_pog]

and gta 5 also did not look as good on original ps3 release, this is tested on new gen update but who cares its just a video

[@AhmadWahelsa]

Better late than never right? Watch Dogs fell off so hard, now it's only Cyberpunk left as an alternative to GTA games, i hope Unreal helps them through because Red Engine was made for Witcher games, it wasn't built for this type of games, unlike Bethesda who forced that medieval engine into space-sim.

[@uzairahmed3103]

​@AhmadWahelsa Unreal 5 atm isn't very optimized and the all of the games on UE 5 have been a disaster performance wise. Their own in-house engine was really good it's just that they tried so hard to make it run on the old gen that couldn't even optimise it for other platforms.

[@AhmadWahelsa]

@@uzairahmed3103 Let's just hope for the best, i heard that they aren't abandoning the source codes, and might adapt them into Unreal, so if that's the case, it would be nice to have CDPR's D3D12 optimization like in Cyberpunk Every dx12 games i've played always have to compile the shaders first, but CP77 doesn't they just straight up throws you into the world within 10 secs of first time launch (if we don't count char customization)

[@pandagonerogue.140]

Who cares CD didn’t go in thinking about all the different physics because they were worried about bigger things with the game… look at Witcher games they got the physics down so they could have done better if it wasn’t for all the pressure 🤷🏻‍♂️

[@hectorgustavomurguianina6425]

no matter what other people say, CP is awesome

[@santinoefe]

🤨?

[@hectorgustavomurguianina6425]

yeah cyberpunk is great despite other people say@@santinoefe

[@ShoeLobster45]

@@hectorgustavomurguianina6425 i spent all my money on cp (cod points)

[@Final_SC]

💀

[@dauphongii]

Yeah I like myself some CP on the Friday evenings

[@ThatOneAcee]

rdr2 water physics are better, you get the bullet bouncing out of the water a little further depending on how deep the water is, none of the other 2 games got this level of detail and realism

[@Final_SC]

Imagine gta6 physics, oh god...

[@Mauro_cdg]

9:24 If you feel like an idiot, just remember that guy mopping the floor in the middle of the rain.

[@DylanWGaming]

3:00 proves how broken my humor is

[@seynpurrp]

Holy shit the raindrops on the water in cyberpunk LOOKS INCREDIBLE

[@Ludde1478]

Cyberpunks water physics actually surprised me

[@Squiggl3]

This is a very valid rating. I’ve seen a-lot of other people who are too biased to give an honest rating. You did a great job with this! 👏

[@sandustratievschi9471]

can't wait to see this kind of videos but with GTA 6!

[@justeddsfx]

RDR2 and Cyberpunk npc: *Trying to escape from explosion* GTA 5: Whatever dude 🙄 *Walks away*

[@radziugames8708]

RDR2 and Cyberpunk the best

[@CanadianBongRipper]

I mean they are much more recent so I would hope so haha

[@Panceggs]

2:49 not cool not co- AEAEEWHEAHHE

[@itzkayes]

awesome video! I haven't been able to comment on ur videos for a very long time because youtube on my phone is bugged. my phone's keyboard basically wouldn't pop up so i couldn't type. cool comparison!

[@PlayGroundComparisons]

No worries! Thank you! :)

[@Wuddizzup]

I thought the rdr ii on the thumbnail was gman😭

[@waaxyfn1461]

4:43 i understand it is your opinion, but those feet were glitching a little

[@PlayGroundComparisons]

If you look down while walking in real life you see Cyberpunk 2077 has the most similar view. But yes, the contact with the ground is so bad it breaks the immersion a bit for me too... Otherwise it's really detailed and looks great. This is why I think it's the best.

[@volery456]

I love CP, my favourite 💀

[@Final_SC]

💀

[@mewsterx3679]

Trash game

[@user-vo9xb2rn8o]

@@mewsterx3679 what game?

[@prxzmsAU]

Can't believe Cyberpunk is already 3 years old 😵

[@VegetaUIGamer]

Finally some respect for all the 3 games

[@chrispalagot9798]

I love CP❤❤❤

[@hussien04]

💀

[@Draupnireditsss]

Ain’t no way

[@RAEES_SAHIB15]

I have played so many games series but I have never ever seen a game like RDR2 animations, graphics, visual effects and details are very impressive

[@badassuchiha4875]

Cant wait for GTA6 & RDR3 Comparisons

[@dizzyneurin4654]

2:49 "Not cool! NOT!" 😣☝️💥😫 🤣

[@2diefor]

Michael: Drops a grenade in the water Tracey: Holy shit 😮

[@karthikc07]

Rockstar knows how to make games

[@WP____]

They actually care about the little details and the game as a whole

[@dauphongii]

Tbh cyberpunk is doing really well in many aspects, but I don't think anyone can beat Rockstar when it comes to animations and physics. They are practically the only studio that had access to Euphoria, but I think they don't have it by now, which makes me wonder how physics will look in GTA 6, but their expensive and absolutely amazing mocap work can really be seen through all those games. From player animations to just NPCs idling, or even facial expressions, I don't think any game can compete with that. As far as I know, Cyberpunk used AI for facial expressions, and the scenes where mocap is actually used in Cyberpunk, it looks maybe even better than in Rockstar games, but the problem is that it just isn't done enough

[@8Bitzzz]

Cyberpunk has better level design (this is not a simping comment just a fact)

[@dauphongii]

@@8Bitzzz nah cyberpunk is doing better in design overall I feel like. the fact you can do basically all the missions on stealth is really nice and I appreciate it, and you generally have more freedom over the way you play, while GTA is too restrictive. I liked the GTA 3 missions more tbh as they also allowed you to kinda do it how you want, but ever since, you have mission areas which you leave and it just fails you.. it's too hand holding. Also the city in cyberpunk looks better I feel but tbh that's just design perspective, and tbh, unless you are really bae designer, it's almost difficult to make cyberpunk city less interesting than modern city

[@8Bitzzz]

@@dauphongiiYep, your first point is what I mean with better level design. In RDR 2, you can get a mission failed if you don't follow the direct path; it's scripted and outdated. I hope they do it better in GTA 6. The second part is more of a preference thing. I prefer the dystopian world-building in Cyberpunk more, too. But RDR 2 is, because of the time setting, a lot more limited. However, the world-building and design are on the same level, maybe even better due to the higher NPC randomization and the stuff you can do besides your mission, than Cyberpunk.

[@dauphongii]

@@8Bitzzz you're totally right! although the last point kinda comes down to settings of the games. RDR2 is set on a place with most villages not having more than 100 population, so it would make sense they would flash out most of the people in the world, awhile Cyberpunk is set in future in an overpopulated capital city where one megabuilding houses more people than the entire RDR2 map, so then again, they made the choice to make the people basically strangers to you with which you can't even communicate and if you try, they just curse you out. kinda giving the vibe of cold, dystopian future. both games fit the setting well and I wouldn't want them to change, I just think future Rockstar games could become less strict on how you do the mission. Cyberpunk did it, and they were still able to tell compelling story that is comparable with those of GTA or RDR games. although cyberpunk is an mmorpg and more of a be your own character, shape your own story, but tbh that just adds to replayability, while, and this might be controversial but it's something I believe, having just one, set, linear story where you have very little freedom is boring in gameplay perspective. at this point why not just make it a movie then?

[@nicteran]

euphoria got merged into rage (rockstars engine), so they still have it and will use it on gta 6

[@meme_thief93]

Anyone gonna talk about the thumbnail 💀💀

[@beeman3369]

What’s wrong with it?

[@meme_thief93]

@@beeman3369 look at the cyberpunk letter's "CP" 😭

[@beeman3369]

@@meme_thief93 oh ok lol that’s what I was thinking but I was very sure

[@internetcutie]

cyberpunk's rain on water effects are truly impressive and I hope to see Rockstar improve on that in GTA VI, speaking of, when the game is released I think we'll see it blow all comparisons out of the water (no pun intended) can't wait to see Lucia in the line up, I think a real stand out will be hair behavior and physics

[@talkingmurga5554]

5:00 - Arthur proposing a woman.

[@dwiazizah6521]

1:44 WTF rdr 2 is a super realistic game graphics 😮

[@AlexCS8]

Yes chery picked everything to make cyberjunk look better, it doesn't even have third person pov because it look so demented

[@indiboy7]

When you throw that grenade in CP, it travels a bit further and bangs there, so entry splash is a big different from the blast splash.

[@90sGamerMan]

It's a shame when someone in the future compare Gta 6 to a rdr2 and there's to much detail on rdr2 still better, what a next gen they call

[@desktopantec2290]

6:20 me using snap to check how red my eyes are before going to my parents

[@hasanatif4082]

Damn! That ripple effect in both

[@kemalsogut9342]

raindrops of cyberpunk is mind blowing

[@Dahselesai]

6:38 realistis

[@Slenc899]

Gta 6 is going to look awesome rdr2 is already 5 years old and those graphics are awesome

[@LegendaryBaan]

Rdr2 looks great and cyberpunk 2077 looks amazing and gta5 looks good but then again gta5 came out in 2013 11 years ago but looks great still loved rdr as a kid but lost its touch but still love it.

[@Tonimontana69420]

Bro the npcs eyes looks better than the players eyes in cyberpunk lol

[@8Bitzzz]

You see the npc eyes more then your own thats probably why. 😅

[@revespadero6979]

9:25 why was bro trying to clean up the wet floor with a broom?

[@valecasini]

2:50 - 3:02 hilarious 😂😂 instinct of survival = 0 4:05 V is just build different 😆

[@charlyg-2590]

_6:25__ What beautiful eyes you have, man!_ 🤣

[@Ekimara]

0:26 but.. is that water slider at it s max in the settings tho' ? :D

[@muhammadadam1870]

1:11 Holy shit "💣💥"

[@user-rx2jw1kk3o]

😂

[@iiChochii]

man you have the same taste as mine, you know what is the best

[@ivanshevchuk1699]

The greatness of RDR 2 is that no amount of Cyberpunk patches will come close to working out its details.

[@DieRooms]

Red dead redemption 2:hold my beer

[@andrewisak8633]

As always RDR2 ❤❤❤

[@damagedskvll]

We all knew who was the winner, but we like seeing it.

[@Goudiwish]

6:22 DAYUM that Michael Trying to Rizz us 🧐

[@OnlyOriginalSongs]

rdr2 past gta 5 present cyberpunk future but for physics and graphics cyberpunk past gta 5 present and rdr2 future

[@whatismynametakeawildguess]

rdr2 easily the best

[@AutisticScholar]

Cyberpunk has better and funner gameplay

[@whatismynametakeawildguess]

@@AutisticScholar nah cant agree

[@duckking404]

@@AutisticScholarabsolutely not

[@metatron6254]

​@@AutisticScholar Ehhh no

[@tommyvercetti1827]

@@AutisticScholarI agree. Anyone who says otherwise hasn‘t played Cyberpunk.

[@CanadianBongRipper]

GTA 5 holds up! Remember it came out 11 years ago

[@maysoncangiranabispo7135]

It's truly amazing to see that Cyberpunk has improved over time (Still inferior to rdr2)

[@nasheeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee4495]

THE THUMBNAIL BRO SDAJFKL

[@1MM730]

Bro juegas a csgo bro respondeme por favor yo se que tu juegas csgo esa foto demuestra que eres jugador de csgo hola

[@nasheeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee4495]

@@1MM730 qué no bro, nunca toqué el csgo lol

[@abuhuraira7228]

1:07 the rdr2 water physics is more realistic. The ripples in cyberpunk look good but they happen when you throw something in water more slowly like a rock. In rdr2 you can see ripples but they quickly fade as should happen for a bullet

[@dignifulmusic7]

RDR 2 player's eye is splendid

[@sashanksharma9128]

should have also added gta 4 compairision its physics are mind blowing

[@muraadkhan4471]

Rdr2 is the GOAT❤

[@niightfrx4672]

Dont say "in my opinion", Your opinion is really correct and I think everyone will agree with you !

[@Mystalo]

"Not cool not-" 💥

[@aganbraganca4156]

cyberpunk really improved a lot man now its considered one of the best games

[@mewsterx3679]

No it aint lmfao what the hell are you smoking

[@Javoxo]

​@@mewsterx3679you might live under a rock dude

[@Im_a_rock764]

Bro one of the gta5 npcs just calmly says whatever after being thrown at by a grenade 💀

[@Alpha-bd2kg]

CP for Cyberpunk 💀💀💀

[@XVXYvvv]

?

[@Vorheesplays]

CP💀💀💀💀

[@DmitriyNeizvestniy]

8:31 What did he blow that made him fly so high?)

[@carljohnsonGSF]

CP🗣🗣🗣🔥🔥🔥🔥‼‼‼‼‼‼‼

[@fallanor3]

Are you serious? You could literally create a funnel if you spin in watter in rdr 2

[@caterina2290]

I love rdr; i just wish they had finished the online version

[@timeblade]

6:36 His eyes look exactly like mine, I even have the central heterochromia as well.

[@agent-017]

The RDR wins, but the gta v is goat, nice video 🔥

[@abhirupkundu2778]

Cyberpunk spent all of its budget in the UPDATE 2.0, only to maximize water physics 💀

[@martinnic8235]

water physics are fixed like back in 1.5 :D

[@abhirupkundu2778]

@@martinnic8235 Yea its fixed, yet it looks better than rdr2 somehow

[@eselapis]

cyberpunk is gta 5 with mods and rdr2 is a game from 2027

[@ciscoart]

2:25 HOLY SHIIIT

[@joel6905]

and rockstar still doesn't give rdr2 60 fps on ps5

[@waffler-yz3gw]

oh well

[@electrikoptik]

GTA5 firstly came out on hardware that dates back to 2006. That's nearly 20 years as of 2024.