RDR 1(PS4) vs RDR 2 - Comparison of Physics and Actions!

Here's the comparison of Actions and Physics between Red Dead Redemption (PS4, played and recorded on PS5) and Red Dead Redemption 2! Let's see how improved the series from RDR to RDR2!
Hope you enjoy the video!
RDR 1 vs RDR 2 Details comparison if you missed it:
👉 • RDR1 (PS4) vs RDR2 - C...
Thank you for watching, and happy gaming! ❤️

[@GMclay.]

Rockstar was truly ahead of their time when they were making rdr1, truly amazing 😯

[@madelenemartin3217]

Ahead of the times still when making RDR2! Most games coming out today still don’t match up tbh.

[@spilledmilk5743]

@@madelenemartin3217only game that comes close to rdr2 is probably ghost of tshushima

[@fy198]

@@spilledmilk5743No. He’s more like a Ubisoft game, the old ones.

[@spilledmilk5743]

@@fy198 I meant graphically wise

[@fy198]

@@spilledmilk5743 Graphically speaking the game is not incredible but artistically speaking the game is magnificent, yeah. I agree !

[@Novaonyoutube432]

John lost his voice in rdr2 due to all that screaming lol

[@n1trogasoline]

you mean rdr1?

[@Novaonyoutube432]

@@n1trogasoline yeah

[@mr.noname5731]

*smoking

[@jessicastahl8071]

Lol

[@DaelonBenefield-vm4gq]

Rdr2 is a precise to rdr1 since aurther gave john his iconic hat at the end of the story mode

[@ArmyXVideoS]

We Can all agree On that RDR2 Is the most realstic game ever. However RDR1 as a 2010 game is very impressive

[@anymyo9882]

RDR1 uses the full potential of the euphoria engine. Devs from NaturalMotion them selfes were involved in 2010. RDR2 uses a euphoria "light" version without any morpheme/endorphin and help from NaturalMotion. RDR2 has its priority more to precaned animations (meele fights and drunk walking, shot reactions and stumbling overall). Most people think its "realistic" but in reality, the euphoria engine is just used in a rudimentary and really toned down way. NPCs start rotating arms when getting shot to the head and the bullet force is way to high and pushes NPCs away. R* did a great job with RDR2 in general but the game and especially the physical interaction with NPCs and gunplay would be way more entertaining and satisfying when they would have used the euphoria implementation the same way like they used it in RDR1. Things are not always better, just because they are newer. The use of the euphoria engine in recent R* titles is one of those things.

[@festenzurius7454]

RDR2 is amazing but it is nowhere near realism. Much more realistic games out there.

[@idametheparagon]

examples@@festenzurius7454

[@krimson4626]

@@festenzurius7454 Depends on how you define "realism" in video games. If realism means better graphics and details then surely RDR2 is the most realistic game released till date.

[@MemoDeemo]

It was ranked 1st place, right next to Detroit become human. *Fun fact! The 3 most realistic games in the world were all made in 2018*

[@ilovewastingurtime]

4:06 did you noticed that npc kept posture? Rdr1 is truly ahead of its time.

[@CAPTAIN_TERMINOTERROR]

Fun fact: In Rdr2, you can also tackle opponents and make them fall on the ground like in Rdr1, and then start punching them. You should've showed it.

[@StarHorder]

they did

[@CAPTAIN_TERMINOTERROR]

@@StarHorder I didn't see him doing it.

[@German-shepherd69]

@@CAPTAIN_TERMINOTERRORi think you can only perform that move when you are running towards the opponent

[@CAPTAIN_TERMINOTERROR]

@@German-shepherd69 That's right. You can also tackle in another way but i don't know how to perform it.

[@discordstoriesreal]

Hold L3 and drag down while strangling the target with either triangle or Y button@@CAPTAIN_TERMINOTERROR

[@nickbuckley4371]

Rdr1 is timeless idc how old it is it’s my favorite open world franchise

[@ok_jaja]

The story of rdr1 was better really blend the lines of neo western and spaghetti western better than any film has ever done all while taking place in the dying Wild West and you really do feel that in the game

[@floraslia]

@@ok_jajardr2 story was wayyy better. and rdr2 is a better game in general

[@ungoliant10]

@@floraslia but where is mexico in RDR2 its completely missing.

[@cracked_davud5031]

​@@ungoliant10 doesn't make the game worse does it?

[@buttnakedsnake9357]

@@florasliaRDR1 has way more fun challenges and trophies

[@MemoDeemo]

In the game, the character interacts with the environment in a really cool way. They use a bunch of invisible lasers all over the place to figure out what they can climb, vault over, or bump into for special animations. There are hitboxes for every object, and they have to be just right to make sure the character does the right actions, like climbing instead vaulting. And when it comes to fighting, things get even more hairy. You can kick someone off a ledge or smash their head against a wall. The game even has AI that makes little tweaks to the animations on the fly. So if someone has a bigger or smaller neck, the choking animation adjusts accordingly. And when climbing, the AI takes into account how slanted an object is to make it little adjustments to the finger positions and the arm position, this is most likely done by using only one bone that has inverse kinematic to allow the AI to only need to worry about the hand position and everything else will follow naturally. This is a very simplified explanation its much more complex then this.

[@justajad2809]

Thank you so much for the details, they have truly evolved with RDR2, can't wait to see the modern world have that with Grand Theft Auto VI !

[@k.s8302]

7:53 strange man🤫

[@Mrjacharles]

Man what a step up from 1 to 2 though. :D

[@ComradeUranium]

It's 8 years so yeah

[@Andrewtate200]

@@ComradeUranium some companies even suck after 10 years.. So it's about talent not time

[@maxcaines3568]

​@Andrewtate200 look at days gone. 8 years in development and a very mediocre game to show for it

[@alcapone4635]

not at all. Newer doesn't always mean better. Red Dead Redemption 1 remains superior and is a better game than rdr2.

[@Andrewtate200]

@@alcapone4635 poor lil kid can't afford rdr2 so he keep talking shit😂

[@eduardv2131]

RDR 1 is incredible 😮

[@DanielBekker-rt1rz]

I think in GTA 6 they should bring back the freedom of choice we last saw in San Andreas,a good story like GTA 4 and details like RD2.Don’t you agree?🤔

[@savagegaming3392]

I agree with that...but i also think that there should be settings for new mechanics too...like lets say they completely redo the wanted lvl system and add a mechanic where cops remember you or your car after you lose a wanted and u have to change clothes or respray your car to completely lose it...make a setting where we can makes the cops more like gta v cops"something that mafia def edition does...u get to pick if you want realistic cops or mafia 3 cops)...and not just wanted lvls too, like the big one i wanna see is them have both gta 4 and 5 car handling and you have to choose what driving handling you want before starting the actuall game

[@okyoucanwatchnow2013]

I hope that the little sky loading screen isn't in gta 6

[@emperor8716]

i found an rdr game at home, don’t even know how it got here, but now i wanna play it. luckily i have an old ps3 to play it on lol.

[@faridagasiyev7042]

Lucky man

[@CameFromKamino]

I like how when he drove off the cliff in rdr1 he got rejected like a beyblade lol

[@saleh_beats]

It's a 10 years difference I am impressed that rdr was like that

[@LeRohlik]

In rdr2 horses dodge objects like trees and such but other thing like going straight crashing into a house is a crasher

[@Enlks]

Had a stroke reading this

[@LeRohlik]

@@Enlks good for you! chihuahuas deserve to die afterall

[@lepersonnage371]

@@LeRohlik deserve to day? another stroke reading this

[@LeRohlik]

@@lepersonnage371 blud I was typing it on a phone and it miss clicks stuff happens

[@ajhudson4253]

Nice to see you again broo❤❤

[@BlaZe92]

🥰 bro!

[@Vince-jy8fd]

I wish the lasso was still there in rdr2

[@Vince-jy8fd]

@@user-wd8ct2he6i no I mean like showing on his hip like it is in rdr1 lol

[@TylerMBuller12]

I think the rag dolls are better in rdr 1 which is a big advantage since it's very common but everything else is a huge improvement in rdr 2.

[@Naimedclaiming]

lol rdr2’s are far heavier and more realistic Rdr1 was so arcadey

[@weplo1597]

@@Naimedclaiming RDR2 should've removed level for health and stamina. It makes game too easy. Also removed that goofy ass camera sway during combat 1st person didn't had it

[@SCP-vd4yq]

⁠@@Naimedclaimingdamn bro have you ever seen sly shootings video? I can tell ya he has pretty good clips on how npcs react when they get shot.

[@alexpaulyoungthemuso3937]

​@@Naimedclaimingyeah I like that they're weightier but I reckon the ragdolls in rdr1 (when you shoot folk in the body) take the bullets in a much better way Can't tell you how annoying it is to me that if I shoot an npç in rdr2, about 8 times out of 10, their arms will spin rapidly in a windmill motion while they bring one leg up to knee high Happens so often it's somewhat immersion breaking In rdr1 I've just never seen the same sort of death twice

[@TylerMBuller12]

I love the fist fighting in rdr 2 there is alot of things you can do that you couldn't in the first game and alot of it they don't even explain in the tutorial. You can throw people and hold them hostage.

[@Arkar.gamerz]

here for you i subscribed your channel now you are my favorite gta game teacher channel ❤🎉

[@BlaZe92]

Hey thank you very much for being a subscriber and supporter! 🥰❤️

[@Arkar.gamerz]

@@BlaZe92 is famous of gta game

[@Arkar.gamerz]

​@@BlaZe92you welcome 😊 blaze92=❤

[@savagegaming3392]

I always hated the horse mechanics in rdr2...exclusivley the horse constantly crashing into everything she sees(my horse in game is female)...and before yall say some shit like "uhh...its not the horse, you just dont know how to play the game"...yea, even the best of the best in rdr2...eventually crash into a wagon or rock they didnt see at first

[@Rude_Boi]

There's a trick to this, and I see that you haven't figured it out lol. (I'm assuming you play on Playstation), so the trick is to hold on to "X" and NOT mash it. If you hold it, you will NEVER crash into anything, but mashing it constantly sets you up for failure.

[@BeatleHarrison]

@@Rude_BoiThat’s not true at all lmao. Mashing it or holding it doesn’t do a thing. The horse still crashes to whatever is in front of them.

[@savagegaming3392]

@@Rude_Boi It doesnt matter...especially if you use the arabian...great horse...but my god i swear that horse has some weird fetish for crashing into shit

[@savagegaming3392]

@@VVzzX thats not true...sure, the arabian is one of the most skiddish breeds in the game...but if you get your bond lvl maxed out, the horse can run in the middle of a battlefield and not flintch...its when a predator gets too close is where i have problems with the horse, and that dont happen too often(and i know where some areas to avoid at night are at)

[@ashlardd]

To do that you need to have max bonding level with your horse, it works most of the time and comes very handy in a lot of situations

[@lepersonnage371]

Ragdoll is tons of times better in RDR1, and enemy reactions on gunshots too.

[@obiwalter483]

No

[@lepersonnage371]

@@obiwalter483 No one with brains or eyes can argue with it, unless they are blinded rdr2-fanboys

[@Franshela]

0:12 3:44

[@lepersonnage371]

@@Franshela Im talking about the ragdoll during shootouts and enemy reactions. A lot more fun and varied in rdr1. in rdr1 if you shoot both legs of a dude he will sit on his knees and crawl away. Nothing even remotely like that is in rdr2

[@theraiden1018]

@@obiwalter483yes

[@Killersnake432]

I should probably add about the throwing knifes... That you can collect them if you used them on a person and animal. When you loot the kill you'll get it back at times. Noticed that detail when replaying RDR1 on the Switch... I'll probably remember it if I played on PS3 again but that version is pretty awful go back too.

[@Eclipsephonk-kw6xu]

Ngl, that intro was cold 🥶

[@spiderfox04080]

A muscles on the house are moving too in rdr1!

[@pedrohenriqueassis2757]

This intro is so good

[@DonutYT881]

it is amazing on how much details they put in to these games rockstar games really put a lot of effort well…. sometimes

[@anomcat]

imagine blending gta 5 and rdr2

[@DonutYT881]

@@anomcat That would be crazy

[@anomcat]

@@DonutYT881 literally real life

[@DonutYT881]

@@anomcat yeah

[@game_chat376]

Tbh I like rdr1 better just because of how John turns out to be and also of the ragdoll physics

[@Cerberus589]

I like it better because it has a darker story and it feels more Wild West. RDR2 was amazing but I just love the feeling I get from RDR1.

[@Andrewtate200]

@@Cerberus589 you are saying this cuz you get nostalgia😂 Rdr2 stomps 1 in every aspect.

[@Cerberus589]

@@Andrewtate200 Lmao comments like this are why RDR2 fans get such a bad rep. Y’all just can’t accept the fact that some people like RDR1 more 💀

[@brandenimhoff2713]

​@@Cerberus589it's the horse balls.

[@DeadX2]

@@Andrewtate200it’s not even nostalgic lol it’s the truth

[@AssassinPirate2]

0:26 Old GTA 5

[@SyedAhmedHanbal]

The music that I hear in the video was used by ENXGMA, very good, bro. 👇

[@Teko259]

at 0:13 the gravity is turned down in rdr1 for some reason

[@JACKRIDERPLAYZ]

John tried to fight gravity

[@Teko259]

@@JACKRIDERPLAYZ so true lmfao

[@Onaterdem]

RDR2 is still the best game ever made. If GTA 6 is announced on the 17th, we'll hopefully finally have a game that lives up to it.

[@Onaterdem]

Of course not.

[@RedDead-ww3vg]

Saying rdr2 is the best game ever is like saying its ok if gta 6 was boring or has bad swimming or boring missions or nothing to do inside it

[@Onaterdem]

@@RedDead-ww3vg "rdr2" "nothing to do" Are we talking about the same game, mi familia?

[@PankajKumar-bl4el]

@@RedDead-ww3vg Ever played that game?

[@RedDead-ww3vg]

@@Onaterdem if u think hunting animals or fishing is something fun then there is something wrong with u

[@joshygaming6636]

Fun fact:If you grapple a npc and knock them out near a window (does not work on all windows you can go to Smithfields bar to try this)You will throw him out

[@SarioThe1st]

I tried it before it dosent work except from the bar fight mission in chapter 2

[@RetroRive_official]

it works i tried it @@SarioThe1st

[@brandenimhoff2713]

​@@SarioThe1stWrong. Did it after game was over in free roam. Shocked the hell out of me. It was an upstairs window, too. Hand to God you can accomplish this in free roam.

[@SarioThe1st]

I just did it yesterday

[@brandenimhoff2713]

@@SarioThe1st yep. I believe I was in the Rhodes saloon upstairs when I did it. I know I was pissed off about losing so badly in blackjack and I beat the shit out of the dealer and threw him out the window. Almost positive it was Rhodes. Wasn't even trying. Started attacking him by a window and last thing I did was throw him out of the window. I was so shocked I just stood there for a few minutes in amazement, then went outside and saw where he landed on a cart. Was awesome as hell.

[@VitchAndVorty]

I am amazed by the game's details.

[@Raidenmmmm]

who think rdr2 is a masterpiece 👇

[@erickpinto8233]

RDR2 😴

[@UrLocalStormtrooper]

John Marston, in red dead redemption, one screams he just doesn’t scream sometimes

[@dalsoneversole]

In rdr1 your character screams sometimes when you fall

[@NedFlanders1040]

I honestly wish rdr2 had rdr1 s rag doll animations I love shooting someone in the throat and watch em walk for a short distance before collapsing

[@EdwardoNuttbuster]

They do that in rdr2 but I never tried in rdr1

[@jayydatboyy_]

even the camera man was shocked☠️ 7:56

[@NarendraModi19514]

Hope that GTA VI gets details just like RDRII.

[@alexkostadinovgaming3178]

Even better

[@lesterbronson2385]

The story, writing, and characters won’t come close to RDR2 since Sam & Dan Houser are gone.

[@user-oc4be8sn2p]

Made in 2018 but a long time ago it was 1899

[@swedziwor]

Do RDR2 vs real life

[@TR58699]

Setting npc on fire test would be lit

[@DeadX2]

Rdr2 solos rdr2 invented real life

[@ndsr_tar]

No horses were harmed in the making of this video.

[@sureitissss]

Bro ran out of gta ideas 😂

[@9doublem28]

No wonder after 10 years of gta v

[@MrBossFML]

​@@9doublem28guess we got 10 years of rdr2 then

[@BlaZe92]

😁

[@DezuKiwami]

Just replayed RDR1 to 100% after not having played it since release 13 years ago, and as I remembered I definetly prefer it over RDR2. It just feels much better controls wise, strikes a fine balance between realism and smooth gameplay and I much prefer the environments and overall tone as well. RDR2 is really good and all, but feels too much like a tech demo and 'immersion simulator' which makes it tiresome to play at times.

[@turkyigido5896]

Lol

[@anymyo9882]

Also the overall physics are way more entertaining and impressive in RDR1 (thanks to NaturalMotion and the fact that endorphin was used as a main feature in RDR1). Beeing drunk gives you a controllable euphoria walking simulator while in RDR2 you just got a precaned walking animation.

[@Pedro_Le_Chef]

Amen. RDR1 is just a better game

[@turkyigido5896]

@@Pedro_Le_Chef lol

[@turkyigido5896]

@@anymyo9882 lol

[@Troy_80765]

Gun safety was invented in 1911 rdr2 takes place 1899/1907 and rdr1 takes place in 1911/1914

[@DirtySoulsTV]

2:08 this could be canon since he's older

[@boardasf699]

Why did it take them so long to add the rd revolver movements into gta games like the flips to dodge the special ability the ability to get behind cover, it took them so long

[@CrazeRionic.]

in RDR1 I think he just accept his fate when jumping from a mountain and stays calm😂😂

[@LeilaDadkhah]

John is mewing in rdr 1 while he's falling

[@john.9960]

wait till you see VI

[@brandenimhoff2713]

Things better in RDR1: -Horse hair movement -Lasso visible on outside of body when stowed -John's brown undershirt as opposed to his white RDR2 one -Better gunbelt -Tighter gloves -Liar's Dice -Mexico. Mexico>Guarma -Better Abigail model/voice -Better Uncle model/voice -Drops/splashes of blood/rain on screen -Better story -Etc... Take away the graphics improvements of RDR2? Well, you've got a less fun RDR1 with a few small additions added and new characters. I love RDR2. But 1 is the best.

[@watchf]

Nah

[@DeadX2]

@@watchfyeah lol u can’t even argue

[@watchf]

@@DeadX2 the only thing I agree with is Mexico>Guarma

[@DeadX2]

@@watchf cool

[@John-996]

RDR1 has better gunshot reactions. But RDR2 has far more alive and interactive world. Better horse riding, More detailed would, Ragdolls when falling of a cliff are better in RDR2 fist fighting is also much better in 2.

[@total3593]

RDR 2 ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤ RDR1 I haven't played it yet

[@MeeskaCurly]

4:31 you can loot them off someone when thrown at them

[@d-deathwish]

3:44 how was this place called?

[@MoeruGoRound]

By the way, you can shoot off the knives you've thrown with your gun in RDR2.

[@nightmarepegasus4141]

Rdr1 was very great

[@Andrewtate200]

Rdr2 is way better Like 100 times better

[@LD44457]

​@@Andrewtate200I mean, it's a sequel so it's expected

[@alcapone4635]

@@Andrewtate200 better with boring me to death lol. Trashthur Morgan's lame dialogue, lame characters, lame physics. Red Dead Redemption 1 remains superior.

[@Andrewtate200]

@@alcapone4635 lil kid is making his own reality😂

[@alcapone4635]

@@Andrewtate200 what are you talking about, little buddy? you're the one who can't comprehend that people prefer the first one.

[@user-hh9is3uc2s]

How can you change the Dead Eye effect?

[@rottenapple_]

Mods

[@TREEVANyt]

Sliding ❎ Sliding✅

[@pandagumukzgaming]

I hope i can play RDR 1 on pc..i hope soon

[@Mattilainen45]

Use an emulator

[@gamerhead473]

You can with xenia

[@pandagumukzgaming]

@@gamerhead473 how?

[@ReVidGamer]

❤❤❤

[@1dk_a_name_88]

Fist fights in rdr are endless

[@LOckednLOsT]

Rdr2 was very nice but the first one is better imo. I have played it more than the second

[@JaydenX_112.]

Red dead redemption 2 and Red dead redemption 1 and red dead redemption undead nightmare and Red dead redemption 2 online where is Red dead redemption 3?

[@JACKRIDERPLAYZ]

If it's in development, then it's definitely in the earliest stages of development

[@MichuGamingandedits]

​@@JACKRIDERPLAYZ yea for me it will be out in 2026 or 2030

[@MichuGamingandedits]

​@@JACKRIDERPLAYZbecause of graphics

[@bristleback3614]

I hope RDR3 Main character is Red harlow, he's the red dead legend himself and even mentioned in both redemption series

[@watchf]

Apparently red dead revolver is in a different universe connonically

[@JamesS71]

Just play red dead revolver then.

[@RipVanWinkle700]

None of them could fight gravity

[@lito4259]

Colors are more vivid in RDR 1

[@478CKniggaa]

Not true the entire game is yellow 😂

[@h4roldmc381]

Para la próxima saca la música de fondo porque me da un acv

[@lordofcinder8884]

Rdr1 feels like toned down version of gta 4 physics ( which is probably the case) rdr 2 is a genuine improvement over all games especially gta 5

[@samar1shere127]

Not gunplay improvement tho lmao

[@lordofcinder8884]

@@samar1shere127 in my opinion it is

[@user-vh9ul2ii6r]

O john todo mole😂😂😂😂😂

[@BullyK]

I feel bad for the horses

[@guicorleonex7947]

John in RDR2 looks pathetic, the way they made his gloves and pants gigantic while saturating the colors is just...

[@TyrantSh4dow]

I’ve never played rdr1 because one of my friends said to play rdr2 first so I’m wondering should I buy rdr1 14 years later?

[@rottenapple_]

If you haven't already, definitely buy it. The story alone is much better than RDR2s IMO.

[@TyrantSh4dow]

@@rottenapple_ ok I will thanks

[@njspotjr]

If u crouch in front of someone then hit them it’s a 1 shot knockout

[@oceanedetotes]

RDR 2 with path tracing and will be legendary. Where is the next gen update ? For PS5 Pro ?

[@Propyko]

Rdr1 got the same ragdoll engine like gta4

[@yopanzziez4417]

Rdr1 Dead eyes was so broken

[@user-gz3ml3xn9k]

rdr 2 is goat

[@diabolistcrossley7193]

In red dead 1 you can skin horses

[@ijustbevibin0425]

Still no 60fps on ps5 with rdr2 is insane to me

[@478CKniggaa]

60fps update was made for ps5 and ps4 5 months ago. So you are just spreading misinformation

[@sr_frederico]

This is in Red Dead Redemption 1, not 2. ​@@478CKniggaa

[@kittygamerzg5429]

i have rdr 1 on my ps4

[@Kolo37c]

Stop comparing the 2 they are both masterpieces

[@DeadX2]

Rdr2 is overated

[@alcapone4635]

@@DeadX2 It is. People are acting like it's the best game ever when it's nothing compared to Red Dead Redemption 1, God of War 4, The Last of Us, and The Witcher 3.

[@Cedqer]

red dead revolver [*]

[@StewFeed]

What I hate about rdr2 is that they made john the same shape as arthur and made john look ridiculous

[@Andrewtate200]

Doesn't matter game is way better than rdr1

[@watchf]

Not really

[@alcapone4635]

@@Andrewtate200 rdr2 is dogshit. Red Dead Redemption 1 is better than rdr2.

[@478CKniggaa]

@@alcapone4635they are both amazing games

[@eduardonogueira-qc4br]

❤🎉 brincar red dead é o jogo mais jogado cara muito bom mesmo

[@Deadeye5074]

There is no point comparing RDR1 PS4 and RDR2 because its not like RDR1s got an actual remaster its just a simple port lol

[@ZeDaManga999.]

❤😂😂

[@ib.11fighter31]

Hello 👋

[@ThePeashooterMan]

In rdr 2 he forgot how to jump?!

[@jessej2]

I would like to see a video comparing AC Mirage and Red Dead Redemption 2.

[@kingthehacker9061]

Npcs in rdr2 are really smart unlike other games which make the game feel more realistic

[@Jaroybal15]

If rdr2 took 8 years to make then why is gta 6 taking 10 years to develop

[@edrrrk]

cause it's bigger, and covid possibly delayed part of its development along with the leaks last year.

[@478CKniggaa]

It is not taking 10 years to develop. The team who makes GTA makes RDR too so they did not work on it whole RDR2 was made. So really it’s only been 5 years since their last game, however COVID probably delayed by a year or two so really GTA6 has probably been in development for around 3-4 years

[@user-xy1pc5wv4d]

Come on you’re comparing two games with completely different stages of development and you’re favouring the newer one what do you expect from a 2010 game obviously rdr2 is going have better details but I personally prefer one because it’s more simple and less complicated don’t take this the wrong way but it’s quite a dumb comparison maybe compare red dead revolver with rdr one cause it’s at least a little more even

[@SubToIronPlayzzYT]

First ❤

[@WeEatBerries]

If you shoot a gun in rdr1 it does infact fire just not always. The ragdoll in rdr2 are horrible. He magically turns upside down. Both great games but rdr1 ragdolls all the way.

[@amonaaron]

I am player rdr1 , you wrong ... rdr2 ragdoll are great and perfect. You toxic and problem.

[@WeEatBerries]

@@amonaaron I'm not toxic, Its called an opinion and I'm not wrong I play rdr1 more than you and know for a fact you can.

[@odlangaagf]

How to play with John Marston in the RDR2????

[@Supercoolyay]

It’s in the epilogue

[@spartacus0391]

Damn, the spoiler.

[@paxdamaxgaming4920]

You beat the main story then you play as him in the epilogue

[@Mahmut1143WZM]

Rdr 1 is good

[@Claudefrom2001]

Why does all these videos not have shitty graphics unlike my game which looks like a fucking potato ran my game?

[@binajaxd5020]

Rdr1 dead eye better than rdr2 much

[@waynepayne9875]

RDR1 wins. RDR2 has 0 cowboy gunplay.