16x9 - Family Murder: Shafia first degree murder

[@mightymissk]

The cops did a good job here. It must be a fearful thing, to come across such evil.

[@kaylanguyen8665]

Praying those women find peace wherever there souls now rest. The girls were so beautiful and full of life. It must be hard for all of them esp. the first wife in the family. The nice part was they were not alone in their final moments. RIP.

[@umiko1r]

Did these people really think that they could get away with this, what arrogance.

[@namenema1503]

How could they kill their own children ? I am sure that the boy also had some girlfriends and is acting holy ! People haven t the right to decide if someone is wrong or not , so yeah justice is served!!!

[@SoupSpan]

What good is honour without love and kindness?

[@BodomTranquilityWorm]

Well, In my opinion.. You can't have very much Honor, without either one of those.

[@imlistening1137]

Thank you for posting these video. I've had SJWs tell me " honor killings" don't happen in Western countries. A most dishonorable action for the perpetrators.

[@bignosycat]

the mother's fake cry gets me. No grief at all doubt she has capability to feel such emotion. If that was me i would be sent to the hospital - could not handle that

[@cinnaharpo4732]

😢😢😢

[@ghostofdayinperson]

Fakest crying EVER!!

[@fredajordan5704]

;-))

[@thickjai18]

People need to understand that this is more of a cultural, medieval bullshit type of thinking rather than a religious practice.

[@Recenseur]

From medieval bullshit false religion.

[@Dai_rui]

You know, I hate it when parents and children have conflict and the parents make decisions like disowning them or honor killing. Makes me think if they ever even loved their children. I'm afraid now....

[@fredajordan5704]

Lughmani Tehreem : Yes, but Muslims don`t care about no other ppl. that are non Mulsim, they only go by Sharia and their traditions and culture. Since the Western World don`t wanna face this fact it`s getting worse and worse by the day, these 3 killers feel no guilt, `couse in their culture they even HAD TO do this for their honour.

[@anissaantaniahanjani4812]

@@fredajordan5704 Hello, Freda. I am a Muslim myself, but I think there are more cultural aspects on this case rather than religious ones. I am born and living in Indonesia, a country with the largest Muslim population in the world, but we do things differently here compare to Shafia's Afghan family. My parents still allow me to date and marry someone I choose myself. I am allowed to not wear hijab, as long as I wear appropriate outfit to the public. I think many Muslims in Indonesia live like myself rather than following Shafia family. I think the motive is more cultural. If my Indonesian Muslim friends know this story, I believe they will condemn them, too. We can adapt to democratic country, because we believe Islam is not as harsh as what Shafia family believe.

[@fredajordan5704]

@@anissaantaniahanjani4812 Ty for your reply. I believe culture and religion are interwoven. It`s probably that younger muslims want to open up but in Islam the family, community is a very important thing. Plus in all nations men are dominant, abut in Islam especially. I don`t care for ppl. religion, but if Muslims for instance wanna live in western countries, they have to adjust to our standards, not the other way arounf, and this is mostly not happening. Gretings Anissa fr. Germany.

[@killerdessert]

​@@anissaantaniahanjani4812, if this is cultural then why are people in Aceh wearing burka and following other cultural norms of middle east? and many indonesian wants to follow middle eastern style so soon they will be doing honor killings

[@55robinwood]

Why don't leaders in the Muslim faith start telling people they will go to hell for killing a family member to help to stop this, if it is not part of the religion.?

[@yusras.212]

It is not ok to hurt someone in our religion UNLESS it is an act of self-defense. People have taken religion and made it an excuse for all of their wrong-doings and have manipulated words from the Qur'an and taken them out of context to justify their actions. Some religious leaders have taken the idea of 'Jihad', which means to sacrifice yourself for the better good, and have corrupted the idea (for power,etc.).

[@yusras.212]

*****... You do realize that Islam has MOST of the same values of the Christian/ Jewish religion other that our outlook on Jesus and fewer minor details (like eating , etc.). Also, we believe in GOD not the DEVIL. GET WITH THE PROGRAM.

[@helenaback2978]

Yusra S. your talking complete crap there is a few Christian and jewish scriptures thrown in but it is just a death manual

[@55robinwood]

Yusra S. I understand that what you say is true and just. I just wonder why there is not yet a Muslim movement to correct these misconceptions among the less literate and thinking Muslims like yourself? = If a group of important Islamic leaders got together and came up with modern day rules of behavior which both fit with the Koran and with modern times, it would be beneficial to the everyday Muslim who might think that Mohamed wanted "honor killings" or "terrorism" for example. I pray for the Islamic leaders to do something like that soon.

[@johngrimek8504]

Nancy Davis Brian Why are you not starting a movement to put an end to war crimes and atrocities being perpetrated by christian and jewish countries?.

[@mahuda5898]

rather than sticking with his children and trying to make them understand slowly the importance of his countries culture/religion, he took the easy cowardly way out and killed them. at the end of the day in the eyes of God and all humanity he is a murderer, and deserves to go to hell. there is no Honor is killing your children and wife

[@mrbluenun]

Hi Mohammed, Absolutely agree with you but feel you and a lot of others who in all likelihood totally disagree with the ‘western’ way of life and morals, feel this way of sorting out problems in ones own family has and maybe alway was something done and those people looked upon as almost saints after doing it perhaps? The laws and way of life they follow which allow this have to be thought about and made by someone and I think this is ‘Charier’ and please forgive the ignorant spelling here, but I simply cannot respect any country or family or people whom use this type of action as an everyday way of dealing with what ‘one person’ thinks is wrong in their own opinion, those that do this murder and torture, are they some kind of perfect person never having done anything wrong? Where does this stop within a family, is this done to a wife or daughter, and so the rest of the family who may know of it but have figuratively speaking have signed an invisible agreement to agree to say nothing, are absolutely as guilty as those doing the murders. And the point I am trying oh so hard and not really doing is, in theory each consecutive female in a family can expect this torture and death. I am not perfect by any means, but I know what is wrong and right, and if it has to be isn’t it better to have these ‘mostly females’ sentenced to a term of imprisonment or a huge fine, or that they should be thrown out of the family naked in the streets, isn’t that better and a more careful way of running a country whose in danger of running out of females to carry on the very way of life the previous females were tortured and murders for? If, harsh as it may be this is done, at least these women and maybe men, forgive my ignorance here, but I know of no men I have never heard about with respect to this type of family action any men or brothers getting this done. At least the women would still be alive and maybe free to leave their SICK and TWISTED COUNTRY and its LAWS behind when they come to the west. I do not know why a more active and forceful way is taken to stop or prevent this type of thing in the west. The truth is, these apparently clever people come to our countries and could not care less about the laws and this goes for the religions, they continue to live there whole life as if they were back in their own country, that is absolutely wrong.

[@mahuda5898]

You are totaly right. Just please understand there is nothing in islam or the quran that tells us to apply honor killing, or torture, or bombings or kill innocent people. On the contrary our religion like all other religions spreads peace, forgiveness, opening your heart, understanding people. and so on. However what we are seeing now, is more of arrogance , ignorance, and blind tribal traditions. they worry about there Honor and name back home more than they worry about the well being of there daughters and wives. Just dont forget all countries and cultures have murderers. and those people are no different than your average canadian killer. They try to bring God into this but God is far from it. peace

[@KhushbooShaikh-tf8og]

Muslim mens are sons of prostitute

[@sallypeebles7837]

Why bother coming to America if you don't want to integrate into our culture??!!!

[@schnee78]

+patricia beckman Why? To live on benefits while hating the culture and seeing local women as whores. In Europe we have a LOT of such cases. Locals are not good enough for these people, however their money is.) There are some nice exception, though.

[@sallypeebles7837]

Well...it's going to be a tough road ahead in Europe now!

[@lepen4652]

America and Europe have this problem now, evil is evil, I understand why Donald trump wants change in the U.S.

[@unbothered8740]

What culture? Obesity and stupidity

[@mauriciosanchez9399]

it was definitely Canada in the vid bro

[@VintageVera1]

They murdered those women, stuffed their bodies in a car and drove it into the lock. Their own family. Beyond the pale.

[@rollsroyce9821]

shame.... middle eastern women are so beautiful...

[@perrideangel177]

If his "honor" means so much to him then why do they lie about murdering 4 women, lie about the reason & try to cover it up? Obviously honesty holds no honor, lying is perfectly "honorable", in which case they shouldn't care what the women do. So I guess the devil can $h*t on HIS grave while he's dancing on it!

[@manalange1463]

If they dont want accept the country culture its best they dont move to different country im sick and tired about this kind of shit I hope they spend hard time in the jail

[@mariyajafarey9148]

Shame on them.

[@johnclark6015]

shame on you alalh hu akbar

[@mariyajafarey9148]

+John Clark parents and sibling kill their daughters/ sister. And you don't find anything shameful in that?

[@rachelgarratt3276]

who can kill any child they carried for 9 months...raised....loved....??????...sickos!

[@staygold1285]

I love the interrogator.. he’s so confident n knows exactly what’s happened

[@debbieknight8901]

Ha! The father believes he has honor! What a perverse little man he is!

[@KhushbooShaikh-tf8og]

He himself is a male prostitute of islam

[@mrsmerily]

If there is any honor in this, then if you kill someone in the name of honor then be honest about it. Monster murderers. And it is almost ironic how those murderest always try these look like a accidents. I wonder who many will get away that way and it gives me goosebumps and not the good way...

[@paradiseana1]

I do know if this was a honor killing but to wipe out your own family is a line that no one should ever cross that is just pure evil. Ideals and beliefs are honorable when they do not cause anyone else any harm especially when your not in your own country. You should always show the best of your culture. Three lives never given the chance again to flourish what a tragedy.

[@ruddiato]

very sad,why not disown them and let them go their own way?? I guess when u grow in your own customs(good,bad,right or wrong) this is just their way of thinking

[@Oona707]

The look on the 13 year olds face rips my heart out.

[@centmaninang20]

Islamic Qur'an Islam teach that a woman is worth less than a man Qur'an 4:11The male shall have the equal of the portion of two females Qur'an 4:3 Marry women of your choice, Two or three or four Qur'an 4:24 and Qur'an 33:50 A man is permitted to take women as sex slaves outside of marriage Bukhari 6:301 "Muhammad said, Is not the evidence of two women equal to the witness of one man. They replied in the affirmative. He said, 'This is the deficiency in her intelligence. Abu Dawud 2155 - Women are compared to slaves and camels with regard to the evil in them. Ishaq 593 As for Ali, he said, 'Women are plentiful, and you can easily change one for another. Ishaq 969 Men were to lay injunctions on women lightly, for they were prisoners of men and had no control over their persons. Tabari Vol 9, Number 1754 Treat women well, for they are domestic animals with you and do not possess anything for themselves. That is the Religion of Peace Teach About... Polygamy, Inequality for Women you talk about peace then show us peace inside the polygamy family you Islamic Man created

[@NJG0516]

I remember seeing this story in the news. SHOCKING!

[@allidust2874]

these kind of people make me feel sick and disgusted.

[@amariluna]

An over inflated sense of honour, most probably undeserved anyway. What a sad story. Feel so sorry for those beautiful women, all of them victims of misogynistic values and traditions.

[@JojoChan1412]

These people are really sick. It's about cultural, not religious problem.

[@ladybug5250]

Religion justifies the culture they follow

[@hookahpro123]

My heart starts beating hard when I see cases like this. Puts me in extreme disappointment and also makes me very angry. If these guys don't want their daughters to change at all, then why did they introduce the Canadian culture to them, they should have kept the daughters in Afghanistan.

[@nicolejoleneable]

They should have known better...That's Canada.And their police always get their man! Nice job Canada..

[@Flymagnet]

Ah the rich texture of multiculturalism. Where would we in the west be without it ? (most likely happy, wealthy, productive and less crime infested).

[@veradrake1937]

Flymagnet2007 Amen to that.

[@TFFOCDinobotsFTW]

+Flymagnet2007 A multicultural country has its benefits and its downfalls. While it seems really bad at times, as people commit more crimes, I believe that people just have to learn to respect one another, and it would make for a great time! :D

[@schnee78]

+Flymagnet2007 definitely.

[@charturner7307]

There's no honer in killing. It's disgusting,evil, pathetic and cowardly!!! God will get his vengence on them when justice day comes!!!

[@crowned.king.immortal]

This is what we have to look forward to under sharia law! Has the world gone mad?

[@fowadkhan5938]

i am not gonna buy that BS what's with the Richardson family?? is that sharia law as well?? I mean why the F*** you have to be pregiduice opinion about religion, about which you don't even know shit about.

[@crowned.king.immortal]

Am I wrong that under Sharia law if someone steals an apple He gets his hand cut off and if a woman has been raped the father can have her stoned/ Plus if a man or woman is homosexual they can be beheaded? Perhaps there are peaceful Muslims, but Sharia is anything but peaceful!

[@fowadkhan5938]

+Debra Athanas Assalam o Alaikum. meaning , may peace be upon you, that's the first sharia I just have narrated to you, which clearly does not promote negativity, and clearly if I would define sharia, that would be, and I quote "Anything that had been said by the intermediaries other than those who came after ,Speaks and quote what God have ordained in his book which is Quran and only Quran,thats a sharia Law". If you can give a single reference of anything that you have written is in Quran, than I'll do what ever you want me to do.

[@fowadkhan5938]

+Debra Athanas Any thing mention in Sharia, might not be very likable due to the principles of human behaviour, also because no one would want to accept for what they are. like true example is, Women all around the world fights for equal rights and we are the same as men, same in every thing, but if you look in sharia perspective it's the other way round, God have strictly punished those female, who have misused their bodies by wearing revealing cloths and spreading profanity and those who leads to prostitution are ordained for stoning, because you can't stop an evil to spread filth in the society but you can control it with a fear of punishment, just the same way a murder goes to hanging or gas chamber.

[@fowadkhan5938]

+Debra Athanas Why is in western society, sex change or so called the term "came out" is becoming very common not because the society or law is very friendly, it's just because they are against their principles of religion and that behaviour is not helping them to a clean improved healthy society. How many muslim countries are in favour of promoting sex change agenda let's speed of those Muslims living in western countries like Canada America etc are coming out... or changing their sex. why is this huge demarcation although we live in the same country have a privilege to do what ever they want to.

[@w.kamaranjoku1712]

3:30 dude gave himself away with those long pauses

[@srmcriclesinthenight9317]

I have to do a project on this case for my law class

[@erikkz]

What a horrible family. Poor girls and woman...

[@amrita3000]

From the pics the women REALLY do not look very oppressed in the "Islamic" way.

[@amrita3000]

@Indy M judgemental much ? Where did I say they do not have that right ? Point out.

[@amrita3000]

@Indy M where did I say they do not have the right to take selfies whatever way they want ? Point out. And, THEY DO NOT LOOK OPPRESSED TO ME. How do you know they were oppressed in the islamic way as the media is portraying ? They had enough freedom to be fairly free, seems to me. The father killed them, had no right to do so. But, that does not mean they were oppressed. Marrying/ dating outside of religion and culture was something he prolly did not expect. Does not necessarily mean they were oppressed. This is a very weird view, not being multi religious is not necessarily being oppressive.Again, NO WAY HE HAD THE RIGHT TO KILL THEM. But although I am not muslim, I UNDERSTAND HIS SHOCK.

[@amrita3000]

@Indy M and I commented based on this story, because i am watching this story. you could have replied based on other docus u know they were oppressed. Instead u commented as if im opposed to their freedom, still u havent answered how u came to that conclusion. And u said Im judging them. Still u didnt answer how im being judgemental if i say from what i see here they dont seem oppressed. You are judgemental, you assumed im against their freedom, which im not. now to defend ur dumbass comment are continuing to say things that make no sense. Look up the meaning of judgemental.

[@amrita3000]

@Bo Peep Based on what ? Please explain. Do all parents the world over expect their kids to marry outside of their culture and religion? People often give their kids A LOOOOT OF FREEDOM BUT DO NOT EXPECT THEM TO MARRY OTHER RELIGIONS. This is NOT OPPRESSION.

[@kelumamarakoon4882]

They make children to have HONOUR (that's why he married the second time) and then he kills his children to maintain his honour. That's what is wrong with these people. They have children as an obligation, so if the children don't grow up to become what the parents want, either they are cast out from the family or worse, honour killing. In their minds this is the correct thing to do. I went through the first. So I know how it feels.

[@wonderfulfaison]

Seriously, this is some sick shit. I'm someone who says whatever people do in their native country is their business. but I am an American and we don't do this shit in America. Sickens me how little respect or regard people have for life.

[@nancejantz]

but to kill is ok...??????

[@wendyfortie4455]

no

[@yahoo8863]

Oh god how could parents do such a horrible action

[@rada9799]

I can't believe how anyone can do that! These actions are not part of the religion in any way, if the girls have done something wrong it is up to Allah (God) to punish them or not and I obviously can't say as it's up to Allah, but it's incredibly likely that the murderers are going to hell. Killing is forbidden in Islam and is only allowed for defence... It's so heartbreaking to know that so many people are faced with murder as a result of cruel, sick and selfish people (that sometimes think they're doing right like these idiots when they're clearly not) Oh and honour killing, screw that nonsense!

[@apiradaAey]

These people prefer honor than jail.

[@nasraidub]

Without religion, good people will still do good things and bad people will still do bad things, but religions make some good people do bad things.

[@mahuda5898]

Not true

[@mahuda5898]

if you ride a BMW and drive on the opposite side of the road, it doesn't mean the BMW is a bad car. just means you are a bad driver.

[@iceage369]

What Is Honorable about Killing!!!!!!!!!! How Dare They???? No religion says its ok to kill innocent lives!!!! What utter disregard to human Life!!!!

[@11mirandacosgrove]

This is just brutal, the girls didn't deserve this and I just wish they didn't turn from their culture since when to afghan girls look for boyfriends

[@MrKillerq8y]

+Ni Blue since they moved to canada bitch just like ur family

[@chrisheath3504]

There is an important point here, not widely understood. The Koran COMMANDS ifs followers to kill. It has a set of rules, which MUST be followed. The first order is to put Allah above everything , even above family. If you do not follow them - you will be severely dealt with, or killed. If you leave Islam - you are to die If you are the wrong sect, or do not follow the rule correctly -you die If you do not believe Mohammed, and Allah - you are to die If you are a Christian, Jew, Hindu, or Buddhist - you are to die This cult of death is completely the opposite to civilised society.. People in the West cannot understand the brutality, and senseless slaughter that goes on in the name of Allah. Search TROP

[@kalv.1963]

No doubts about this. The Qur'an AND the Hadith and Sunnah encourage such behavior against the *kufar* (disbelievers) and *munafiqoon* / *munafiqaat* (hypocrites). Here are some Qur'anic ayat (from the Muhsin Khan translation) and Hadith that may not explicitly mention, but certainly support "honor killings" and other types of physical affliction: *Qur'an* 4:15 - "And those of your women who commit illegal sexual intercourse, take the evidence of four witnesses from amongst you against them; and if they testify, confine them (i.e. women) to houses until death comes to them or Allah ordains for them some (other) way." 5:33 - "The recompense of those who wage war against Allah and His Messenger and *do mischief in the land* is only that they shall be killed or crucified or their hands and their feet be cut off on the opposite sides, or be exiled from the land. That is their disgrace in this world, and a great torment is theirs in the Hereafter." (Emphasis mine) 18:74-75 and 80-81 - "Then they both proceeded, till they met a boy, he (Khidr) killed him. Musa (Moses) said: 'Have you killed an innocent person who had killed none? Verily, you have committed a thing "Nukra" (a great Munkar - prohibited, evil, dreadful thing)!' (Khidr) said: 'Did I not tell you that you can have no patience with me? [...] And as for the boy, his parents were believers, and we feared lest he should oppress them by rebellion and disbelief. So we intended that their Lord should change him for them for one better in righteousness and near to mercy.'" 24:2 - "The woman and the man guilty of illegal sexual intercourse, flog each of them with a hundred stripes. Let not pity withhold you in their case, in a punishment prescribed by Allah, if you believe in Allah and the Last Day. And let a party of the believers witness their punishment." *Hadith/Sunnah* Sahih Al-Bukhari V7B63N196: Narrated Abu Huraira: "A man from Bani Aslam came to Allah's Apostle while he was in the mosque and called (the Prophet ) saying, 'O Allah's Apostle! I have committed illegal sexual intercourse.' On that the Prophet turned his face from him to the other side, whereupon the man moved to the side towards which the Prophet had turned his face, and said, 'O Allah's Apostle! I have committed illegal sexual intercourse.' The Prophet turned his face (from him) to the other side whereupon the man moved to the side towards which the Prophet had turned his face, and repeated his statement. The Prophet turned his face (from him) to the other side again. The man moved again (and repeated his statement) for the fourth time. So when the man had given witness four times against himself, the Prophet called him and said, 'Are you insane?' He replied, 'No.' The Prophet then said (to his companions), 'Go and stone him to death.' The man was a married one. Jabir bin 'Abdullah Al-Ansari said: 'I was one of those who stoned him. We stoned him at the Musalla ('Id praying place) in Medina. When the stones hit him with their sharp edges, he fled, but we caught him at Al-Harra and stoned him till he died.'" Sahih Al-Bukhari V8B82N805: Narrated Jabir bin `Abdullah Al-Ansari: "A man from the tribe of Bani Aslam came to Allah's Messenger and Informed him that he had committed illegal sexual intercourse and bore witness four times against himself. Allah's Messenger ordered him to be stoned to death as he was a married person." Sahih Muslim No. 4206: He (the narrator) said: "There came to him (the Holy Prophet) a woman from Ghamid and said: 'Allah's Messenger, I have committed adultery, so purify me.' He (the Holy Prophet) turned her away. On the following day she said: 'Allah's Messenger, Why do you turn me away? Perhaps, you turn me away as you turned away Ma'iz. By Allah, I have become pregnant.' He said: 'Well, if you insist upon it, then go away until you give birth to (the child).' When she was delivered she came with the child (wrapped) in a rag and said: 'Here is the child whom I have given birth to.' He said: 'Go away and suckle him until you wean him.' When she had weaned him, she came to him (the Holy Prophet) with the child who was holding a piece of bread in his hand. She said: 'Allah's Apostle, here is he as I have weaned him and he eats food.' He (the Holy Prophet) entrusted the child to one of the Muslims and then pronounced punishment. And she was put in a ditch up to her chest and he commanded people and they stoned her. Khalid b. Walid [one of Muhammad's ruthless henchmen] came forward with a stone which he flung at her head and there spurted blood on the face of Khalid and so he abused her. Allah's Apostle heard his (Khalid's) curse that he had huried upon her. Thereupon he (the Holy Prophet) said: 'Khalid, be gentle.'"

[@tellemyumad3247]

Honour Killings in the Torah For every one that curseth his father or his mother shall be surely put to death: he hath cursed his father or his mother; his blood shall be upon him. (Leviticus 20:9) If your very own brother, or your son or daughter, or the wife you love, or your closest friend secretly entices you, saying, “Let us go and worship other gods” (gods that neither you nor your ancestors have known, gods of the peoples around you, whether near or far, from one end of the land to the other), do not yield to them or listen to them. Show them no pity. Do not spare them or shield them. You must certainly put them to death. Your hand must be the first in putting them to death, and then the hands of all the people. Stone them to death, because they tried to turn you away from the Lord your God, who brought you out of Egypt, out of the land of slavery. Then all Israel will hear and be afraid, and no one among you will do such an evil thing again. (Deuteronomy 13:6-12) If someone has a stubborn and rebellious son who does not obey his father and mother and will not listen to them when they discipline him, his father and mother shall take hold of him and bring him to the elders at the gate of his town. They shall say to the elders, “This son of ours is stubborn and rebellious. He will not obey us. He is a glutton and a drunkard.” Then all the men of his town are to stone him to death. You must purge the evil from among you. All Israel will hear of it and be afraid. (Deuteronomy 21:18-21)

[@mahuda5898]

Kalvin Vasques Not true.

[@mahuda5898]

Seem you non muslims all have a fare better idea about what islam is and what the "Quran " teaches, more than muslims do. I bet non of you ever bothered to grab that book and read it.....

[@gorgeouss79]

Go f- yourself dude! Learn your own religion before you spread false rumors about other religions!

[@Faruhah]

Such despicable people!

[@daedizzlay4887]

She tried so hard but couldn't even shed one tear! Despicable!

[@amerbaig278]

if it was Cristine family nobody would brought up the religion part but if the same thing happens with Muslim family you people say all the Muslims are bad. why this discrimination ? and most of you don't know anything about Islam. blame the people who have sinned not the religion cos religion is for peace. and you will never (ever) know the actual story, what the media shows is what you know.

[@starspek]

amer baig you r wrong in saying "if it was a Christian family nobody would have brought up the religion part..." because I've watched a number of these shows and when Christian husbands kill their wives instead of divorcing them to maintain their position in their religious community, the religion part IS MENTIONED! It was the father who gave Islam as a reason for killing the women when he said "they have betrayed Islam". However, you are right about people being the ones responsible for the atrocious actions... it's the way some people CHOOSE to interpret the Koran, the Bible and so on that is the main problem. These days religion doesn't make much sense because so many of the rules are more appropriate to a different time in civilization.

[@lburns7952]

I believe he was convicted of 1st degree Murder. He was NOT convicted because he was Muslim. He was NOT convicted on what his motive may have been. He was NOT convicted on what his religion was. He was convicted on what the evidence said he DID.

[@heyRolleen]

oh yes christians have killed thousands remember the crusades? how about the salem witch trials? all in the name of jesus ...religiouis fuckery...worst thing ever.

[@lburns7952]

Brittannia Moon I love your comment. It is so true............................And the phrase 'religious fuckery' ....priceless.

[@heyRolleen]

Lydia Burns (grins) thank you I didnt think it up (religious fuckery) I read it somewhere here on youtube and loved it and adopted it

[@bobbygrewal100]

so glad this has been screened for all to see now the world will know this is not uncommon at all in some cultures

[@hajrabibi3143]

Religion is not to blame. It's the sick ppl

[@786yama]

The father committed a horrible act that is condemned in his religion and even in his culture. We really cannot say anything for sure since we do not know what really happened but pain and hurt can drive people to do unimaginable things.

[@Chrisoula17]

By committing these honor killings, they are sending a message that says that family honor is more important and Islam is more important than the lives of our children.

[@BiluBilueuamor]

I'm a Muslim, and I don't think that devil father is correct, if u think its wrong to hv a bf then what about killing??? U r not God, u can't judge!!! And I never agree with polygamist!!!

[@armpitfuzz]

If the father felt that strongly he should never have moved his family to a westernised country !

[@mumtazrafiq3594]

I really like your comment Amy! It's not the religion that's wrong ! It's the sick individuals who ruin lives in the name of religion! No religion on earth is violent ! Just the people justifying thier sick actions ! Everyone has a right to life which only God has a right to take! We need to be more tolerant of each other and just condemn the individuals that committed the crime!

[@anastasiagirl1342]

This is tragic

[@hope14alison]

25 years is life. So is 15 years. Concurrent sentences means it's serve together, no matter how many people are murdered by the same person(s). It's a tragedy murderers get off so easily in Canada.

[@crvrjs1618]

every religion have their own evils, every culture does as well. one action should not condemn the rest. instead of raising your status by putting others down, let's all focus on the victims instead. prayers to them. and yes I'm a Christian.

[@mefford67]

That family is a very, very twisted family... Utterly sickening!

[@sevil1945]

It is sad. What a waste of young lives. if he was an honourable person he wouldn’t treated his first wife only because she couldn’t give him children to be murdered by him. Those honour killer are not worthy people without right mind

[@nikitaramsey4610]

Tragically heartbreaking

[@WarriorWomanWaWo]

"Evil occurs when good men do nothing"! I ask if there is even one Islamist here who is willing to not only admit that the line between "moderate Muslims" and "extremist Muslims" has become way too blurred/thin; but that after truly looking into what the teachings of the Qar'an are, that you do realise Islam is NOT a religion of peace?!?! I get why we all feel the need to reject any criticism of our own religious beliefs, however I'm astounded that where we will always hear from "moderate" Muslims that we should not lump them in with such extreme violence as what this "Honor killing" video portrays; we rarely hear from the same Muslims about how wrong the teachings that lead to such killings are. At some point don't we have to stop hiding from the fact that Islamic teachings do promote the superiority of men over women at the very least, which starts this problem!? Why do men merely need to say "I divorce you" 3 times and it's done, yet a Muslim woman must prove in a Sharia court WHY

[@wade2bosh]

jihadist - violent islamist islamist - impose islam over society conservative - devout muslim, not political moderate - conservative values but not devout, cherry picker liberal - reject islamic culture, cherry pick openly forced marriages - against islam. honor killings - against islam honor/shame culture - intertwined with islamic culture

[@talid3222]

Those girls were so naturally beautiful, all 4 of them, May their beautiful souls be set free into the universe, off to another world. Their family could only kill their physical body, never their soul. The murderers are lost souls, and although they physically still live, they are killing their souls as they become negative energy and attract and dominated by other negative entities that will be more evil on many different levels. Disgusting people. Disgusting. Where is your honour to your precious daughters and life partner? You have no honour. You are weak.

[@hope14alison]

Religion does not cause people to commit murder. People will justify any action(s) as long as it suits them.

[@t4705mb6]

One of HBO's shining accomplishments. A very subtle but important aspect of those Kuklinski interviews is the absence of an ulterior agenda by the producers. As Joe Friday from the ancient DRAGNET TV series would say, "Just the facts, Ma'am, just the facts." Few come close to that program's quality. Even PBS subtly grinds their own axe. Narrator choice too is EXTREMELY important. GREAT ones: Linda Hunt, Will Lyman, Morgan Freeman, David Attenborough & (yes), Lilly Tomlin.

[@batmanrobin8921]

Setting the world on fire is just the same proves the point

[@denisaradio1331]

he makes me sick

[@coffeecrisp92]

This is horrible. I am Sikh, and this documentary made me sick to my stomach. I remember the killing of the daughter of Gill and she is from some where in Vancouver. I have watched the documantry of that one, as well as the movie. This happens every where in the world. It happens also in the Sikh Culture. I am thankful that my parents don't think that way. It just boggles me why have a kid if you are going to kill them. You are in Canada, this is not some third world country where you

[@blancambonazzibonaca2795]

How in the world did they think they could get away with the murder? So sad they killed the young girls.

[@Seeithere820]

People should have the right to marry anybody. Her father was very backwards.

[@depyk7989]

A monster father...In the Muslim world he would probably have gotten away....It's crazy how they justify their religion by taking lives...Their stepmother cared more from these girls mother!

[@sagedavis4004]

Truths be told , only gawd judges us....They guy had 2 wives ,and only took pride in his son landin him , his step mom, and paternal parent in prison forever...

[@Idoodlerandomstuff]

honour killing is rampant in pashtun belt of afghanistan and Pakistan, if this guy is so much into honour killings, he should never had come to canada for living

[@generationx9294]

Honour killings ?? God don't like ugly. All three of them will perish a most painful, dishonorable & justifiable death. RIP to the four women ♡

[@charturner7307]

So sad how evil people can be. Rest in peace angels.you will always be with God.

[@gazingheart5363]

I'm glad to hear that and I hope it is true

[@aishoujo5928]

Scumbags. Did they really think they'd get away with it?

[@buckandotis]

life?....pretty rare in canada that anyone actually spends "life" in jail.....there are more convicted murderers walking the streets than there are in jail at any given time....and aside from cops likely more people picking up a government paycheck to help people get out of jail than there are to get them in.....the justice system is a cruel joke on the public that pays for it all and receives little or no protection for their efforts....

[@loripatrick4652]

Nope. I want them sitting in jail wondering, "what did I do?" If you cannot ADAPT to WESTERN CULTURE, stay the hell away from Canada.

[@Mohi]

The Brother of the woman promise to avenge "stain on the honour "that was brought on his higher caste family by killing the man who married his sister. So he went to the village and shot down the man. Then he said to the villagers that he will come back in the future and also shoot down his own sister if he finds her. In Afghan and Paksitani Pashtun society, honour is not an individual thing. It belongs to the collective family and society, thats why its so F***ed up..

[@asmaar.3885]

This is so sad. I am a Muslim, however, I could practice and do anything I want with my family's knowledge. But those people took things way over.

[@vuk96zj]

Quran (8:12) - "I will cast terror into the hearts of those who disbelieve. Therefore strike off their heads and strike off every fingertip of them"

[@chinaararmy9541]

Yeeeah booooi !

[@HAIDERkiller786]

Honour killing is not ISLAMIC, but it is CULTURAL! Get that right, Islam prohibited killing of Any kind.

[@lencambrin]

allytron they believe they were drowned first than put into the car and pushed into the lock either in the washroom or turning basin.

[@dwayners13]

Does anyone know if they ever discovered why the girls didn't make an attempt to get out of the car as it was submerged? Either they were killed or rendered unconscious before they were submerged. If they were killed before, they had to have been drowned, otherwise the police would've noticed there wasn't any water in their lungs. If they were drugged, it was something untraceable. I wonder if they could compare the water in their lungs to the water in the lake, to see if they drowned elsewhere?

[@coffeecrisp92]

can get away with this. This is Canada, where crimes like this are committed you bet your ass us citizens want justice. RIP to the four victims. Their lives were taken away just for being who they are!!!! This is why I think the

[@mariaioana5772]

So evil😞😔

[@coffeecrisp92]

death sentence should come back in Canada

[@HarryPotter-ld7zv]

Justice has been done!! Amen

[@swordoftree]

Couldn't agree more.

[@shombiedixon3824]

thats my favorite serial killer documentary

[@The95kaiserdanish]

I haven't understood your question Andrew?.. But I will go for no. Since I don't know..

[@richl9268]

Oh boy this show's moving too fast for me. Why was wife arrested? the son arrested? Or was that the brother of the father? Oy. I mean doesn't there has to be pretty conclusive evidence to charge someone for murder not just "Well, we suspect they were involved and they acted sketchy in the interrogation". I don't think this show or case would fly well in America. No toxicology testing on the victims? It's fucked up what they did but I'd need to know exactly how they killed them to convict them.

[@steffletcher]

It is just beyond me why and how human beings can so disconnect themselves from any humanity.... I would like to think something like religion would give explanation and it cannot. The pain caused by the loss of these four people --- crosses all boundaries, including religious ones. sigh.....

[@adamlefthand8657]

In sharia law he would have got away with it.....Canadian law is awesome

[@gunslinger000001]

just a question based on culture arab chrisitans and arab muslims have very similar cultures apart from thier religion (which i know plays a large part in culture) but is the arab christian honour killing exist and if so is it in nearly the same proportion as muslim arab honour killings? i have yet to read a article about christian arab honour killing yet, never thought about it..