Crotale R440 Vs Garpun(30mm) | Air Defense Comparison | Modern Warships

[@timothy740]

Dang your tests have really improved. They're a lot more realistic, cover a much wider range of scenarios and are helpful/accurate in understanding what would happen in an actual online game. Though I wished for the aircraft tests where they do flare, that'll you'll flare a lot more such that the AA missiles have nearly no effect for the first section of that test. That way, we can see precisely see and determine the performance of machine guns of hybrid AA like Garpun without the missiles skewing the data (but i also understand that players in actual online games won't always flare perfectly). Other than that, keep up the good work!

[@FahrurRoziqin]

The test are so details and realistic hence to a real battle, The Quality improved significantly than i last remember

[@CakrabirawaCH.]

Thank you very much bro, I need kind of comments 👍

[@Daurjan1992]

@@CakrabirawaCH. А я тем временем подаисался на тебя.Думаю твои видео мне пригодятся ☝️✌👍✊

[@wertyuiwestia]

I was expecting Garpun to easily beat Crotale, but damn! Your in-depth analysis of both really helped me decide on if I wanted to keep garpun on my carriers.

[@olodiandrew219]

Won't call this test valid cause in the game you get hit by both missles and aircraft attacks. It would be better to show how the AA systems deal with them. What would the AA system prioritize.

[@wertyuiwestia]

@@olodiandrew219 They’d spread it out equally. He showed how the AA systems individually fared against aircraft and missile attacks, and if you’re getting pummele by both you might wanna change your playstyle, because that should not be happening.

[@CakrabirawaCH.]

Thank you bro 👍, I really appreciate your feedback.

[@wertyuiwestia]

@@CakrabirawaCH. Thanks! I think you should add a section for multi-target performance like missile + aircraft, but that would be very hard to replicate.

[@CakrabirawaCH.]

Thanks! You've got a great point there. Adding a section to evaluate how weapons perform against multiple targets like missiles and aircraft can be quite intriguing. It's true, replicating such scenarios can be challenging, especially when matching distances and movements in different video clips. But hey, who knows, maybe in the future, we can give it a shot! 😄👍

[@polandball208]

Nerf: it's my time to shine

[@pablog.511]

I doubt that, Crotale has hight damage but its like a Sea Ram 2.0, flares gave up

[@Art_Ai43]

Nope. This time Nerf is under a mountain. 😂

[@rk.rides21]

Nerf means ?

[@dion2932]

​@@rk.rides21It is made worse or weaker

[@danial4299]

Is it nerfed?

[@pablog.511]

Its annoying that Garpuns get distracted by everything except what they need

[@lol-ft1gs]

True😂

[@Bruno-G]

Lol, so true

[@Chunkylover.]

Excalibur: very cool, you guys are phenomenal Also Excalibur: *is weak, sad Excalibur noises*

[@whirlwindeddie2124]

I use Helios

[@Fc31_still_better_bruh]

I love how u switched 4 different bgm in one video lol

[@FontaineLovers]

crotale in varyag gonna be a literal firework show

[@Luffy-ss4rq]

it is

[@ChloeKruegerSenpai]

No debate or any best AA, since used to combination AA, Garpun still holds Top on player's users the rest are mix with SeaRam or any Laser. Crotale may be good for with pair with Garpun or JRNG.

[@Art_Ai43]

Simply, i will use Crotale with Type 2030

[@tukangtitipsendal616]

​@@Art_Ai43type2030 not osu?

[@marderkpz7148]

They probably gonna buffing Garpun in future patch ig Thank for comparison tho

[@Sanket488]

Your video's is very helpful❤

[@CakrabirawaCH.]

Glad you like them!

[@Nogitsune_Yako]

Could you please make a test/comparison between Monarc & H/PJ-45B? Looks like the 2nd one is more efficient.

[@dgvs3718]

Use mw stats bro

[@Zphrynn]

Is it ok if i use garpun on massa's 4x slot and crotale on 2x slot

[@illuminatiWOTBlitz]

Such amazing content sir. Congrats

[@Art_Ai43]

Finnaly a good AA against missiles.

[@honfmeilingfleet957]

in my opinion that Crotale can shoot down Planes but could be flared but also and intercepted Missiles like X-51

[@CarnageXAddy388z]

Bro.... Please do sea ram vs crotale.... And JRNG vs crotale

[@saber0216]

Good job bro,thanks for your help🌹♥️

[@namluong9739]

R440 has great projectile start speed, the best among AA system in the shop and only behind JRNG in the free market (of course it cant beat locked AA systems), very good for intercepting missle lol

[@infiniteyt6914]

Tnx for your useful videos would you please recommend us some combination best for stopping missiles? Specially for X51

[@yolondaabbey3050]

The French defense needs support in terms of speed and range.

[@Submarino18]

I think no one realised that in real battle planes will use traps for missiles so for X seconds only missile AA wont work while autocanon + missile AA still can open fire with autocanon so its not 100% if russian AA is realy worst

[@hoangvuification]

Garpun would be great if it don't go for surface targets

[@antagMW]

did a game suggestion about that already

[@sayagantengs]

Bro garpun did really well in face to face combat🗿

[@LuFFy-dp3sn]

gua cari AA yg pokus ke rudal sama pesawat paling males kalo ada aa malah nembak kapal 🤡

[@sayagantengs]

@@LuFFy-dp3sn tapi kalo di online jarang ada AA yang bisa hancurin rudal.sama AA laser itu jaraknya pendek kali jadi gak worth it buat ancurin pesawat soalnya player ACV jaman sekarang mainnya pada gila🗿

[@sayagantengs]

Kalo bisa ancurin rudal berarti hoki

[@sherlyoctavianyputry]

*Please JRNG-6 CIWS **#VS** CROTALE R440*

[@robbysiregar8341]

Crotale + Osu + Rapid 🔥🔥🔥

[@febrianwar1104]

Crotole + osu + JRNG🔥

[@Zul_H]

@@febrianwar1104 crotale+OSK+HEL

[@Galam04]

​@@febrianwar1104bruhh 😂 JRNG not auto canon😅.... if build at Varyag And RF moscow maybe 💀

[@CarnageXAddy388z]

Bro... Also do crotale vs nukes

[@xyeband1051]

nukes rockets on ships are very slow, crotale can easily deal with them, like other air defense

[@BestaticbeastDl]

​@@xyeband1051missile air defense is nightmare of slow nukes

[@itz_me3171]

You can do typhoon vs gripen?

[@ABHI-_77_]

Would love to see Crotale vs searam since both use missiles

[@horationelson2320]

Corrals did two times better than my expectation 🎉

[@JonathanVe-bn6sf]

Try jrng vs crotale... curious which 1 does better between those, especially against missiles. Range diff is obvious but wanna see how the damage differs as jrng will start targeting and thus firing earlier on.

[@Whall3i]

It's depends... you can't say garpun fell off because garpun acts like an autocannon too

[@Roti.jala.mak.lima.biadab]

Project 231 vs ATN-51 who win?

[@Arraxy47]

231 have best DPS, ATN for long range

[@DeadMetaler]

Please, compare new Crotale with old SeaRAM.

[@simpleplanesdude2993]

Literally SeaRam on steroids

[@Soul-Demon-Y]

Crotel or Garpun which should i use on my normal ships & CV?

[@XIN_920]

Both

[@varrelnugroho]

I used them all on Varyag 5x JRNG-6 CIWS, 3x Garpun, 3x 730C/Crotale.

[@BestaticbeastDl]

​@@varrelnugrohowell switch ur garpun with helios or any other good laser if u hv bcz garpun and jrng are same abd they can start hiting enemy ship instead of focusing on missile spam

[@DailySadQuotes]

@@BestaticbeastDl I've ever change to excalibur, unfortunately I'm not have other laser type. Some player will flare when AA can attack them, that's annoying but good for us.

[@DailySadQuotes]

@@BestaticbeastDl and thank you for your advice anyway..

[@marvelanddcat]

Finally 🎉

[@ChloeKruegerSenpai]

SeaRam and Crotale comparison, that can hold its defense. I bet SeaRam will be hard time hitting fast maneuver aircrafts except Missiles, Crotale in other hand can do both.

[@ajinkyagaikwad26]

There's a reason why Garpun is LEGENDARY AA Crotale like AAs will come & go 😂 ( like ASW, X-51, A244 SLWT, Monarc the OG )

[@xunusyt188]

Please make SU-37 Terminator vs F-90 after the update

[@Anonymous_Pers0n]

Is it still the same now this month?

[@assassin8344]

Is JRNG 6 CIWS and Osu 35k good combination for carrier?

[@CakrabirawaCH.]

It's great for destroying aircraft, but mid for repelling incoming missiles.

[@assassin8344]

Thank you.Please tell which as combination would be better for both destroying aircraft and spamming missiles.I am on lvl 15

[@4rw0]

I have a question whitch one do i use for my Admiral Nakhimov lvl 20 plese?

[@VeNick-l7c]

hi! can u cheack crotale VS OSU?

[@S1LENT-PLS]

Which is the best AA for anti missile? Idk pls help me!

[@itsDarkHornet]

Is chotila got nerfed or can i still use it?

[@RyuuTatsumaki9238]

I' have been a garpun fan for a long time on most ships I use garpun and HEL but thinking of changing to the epic one Both seem close but ya crotale better results for what I want it for

[@Zxcvvddsr213e]

Is it possible to Merlin vs Havok?

[@AfrozaAlam-ce9ht]

Why are you using these in a tier one warship

[@Shiro_S13]

Crotale vs Rim -7 Sea Sparrow vs M22 Uragan

[@bnvang]

In conclusion, I’ll just use both on my Gerald

[@dexshawn]

Stop it with the nerf comments… you do realize Garpun is multi tasking right??? At 3.5 kilometers or less it has to attack ships and defend against missiles and aircraft. Only few AA’s do that. No nerf is necessary

[@Carlos.11]

crotale is my favorite AA 😎

[@28.vocaosang68]

Well, Garpun is still the most multi-functional

[@trollking7046]

So its garpun or crotale?

[@seahawk636]

Damn surprise! Characteristics among A.A. made a difference. I'm tired of suggesting to the devs to remove this business of a.a crashing on surface targets. Today we have 5 a.a who do this! It could be removed leaving 02 with this feature and the others without. And it would already change your action!

[@doctorzimmer]

for me Garpun is the best.

[@shishirrahman5657]

@@doctorzimmer you noob man 🤣

[@yorqinjonomonov6919]

Hi bro. JRNG vs Croyatale R440 Please

[@hemakeshwar]

Crotale or sea ram?

[@fine6055]

tho sea ram has better range and reloading time but crotale performs better in interrupting missiles and better aircraft tracking

[@CakrabirawaCH.]

I personally choose crotale

[@IruIUmam]

Can I buy garpun without legendary title??

[@CakrabirawaCH.]

yes

[@kpway-gaming6544]

Bro make a test with using flares

[@mehdirahimian2736]

Helo, tank you

[@dokman7788]

I'm from Morocco hh (crotale He is the best)

[@robbysiregar8341]

Oh iya bang, missile baru vs artemis dll bang

[@rofidardyawansyah438]

Bang Crotale vs Orlikon hel

[@Pol-Ikari-YT]

Y está defensa de dónde salió??

[@MamangGils]

Terima kasih informasinya... n.n

[@Nemesis32201]

I like to combine them

[@sayagantengs]

Garpun are good for face to face battle cause it can shoot ships unlike another air defense I don't know why people keep complaining about the surface targeting system if you know why pls letme know

[@taufiqridha1591]

Because sometimes in hectic situation, AA that can focus on missiles or any airborne threats are more helpfull to defend the ship. Like for example if any enemy ships comes in the range of Garpun, 730C, Pantzir, JRNG, and enemy ship spamming missiles, all of those AA's is gonna multitasking and then reducing the capability to intercept enemy missiles

[@НиколайБавыкин-ж9х]

👍👍👍👍👍👍👌супер👍👍👍👍👍

[@mr.bossman8935]

*missile destroyed* Ship: 💥💥

[@dad-ms8mz]

Their price don't do justice to them

[@nicholasowen1376]

Compare with sea ram

[@marcelmeivsdelimafrias9337]

up up

[@Respawn4757]

Musiknya : bang uda bang

[@alikvidator]

The garpun is still one of the best PZRK, and yes. Some things are not objective because you can't influence them in any way, for example, you can't disable the ability to shoot pwo at ships, in fact, in the end only because of this reason garpun lost, and yes. Rockets are heavier. So as far as I'm concerned, the garpun fought decently, and still deserves to be on the ships.

[@bugbuggy3866]

We are getting tired of the missile spams by the overpowered VIP strike fighters. For the sake of balance, there must be an AA that is equally efficient is getting rid of aircrafts fast. Thanks a lot to the devs for putting a very nice AA as a dollar item at level 20. I am using Helios (4x) and this new AA (2x) on Massachusetts and the results are great so far. Hope the reload gets a buff. But the ideal AA will be on a port royale. Garpun 2x, Crotale 2x and Helios 3x. Put an anti air like RIM or S500 on one of the missile slots and watch CV users weep tears of frustration

[@ducphammanh3746]

What happen if the cv uses B21 and rush in ?

[@bugbuggy3866]

Not everyone is that perfect in timing to drop the bomb @@ducphammanh3746

[@namluong9739]

​@@ducphammanh3746 take the Mi28 and drag the bomber to the ground before the bombs drag you to the oceans floor

[@ducphammanh3746]

@@namluong9739 And somehow that guy's fighter is nearby and he anticipated that. Or i just f up and fly the copter into the mountains

[@BestaticbeastDl]

​@@ducphammanh3746lmao

[@tylerhellgerson2325]

Yeah, ist a anti air gun who can work as auto Canon 😮

[@itz_me3171]

crotale >

[@tempestblaze6051]

Why is ship taking the damage even after the missiles have been defeated? 5:40

[@Kronos24-s6k]

​@@tempestblaze6051 misil super sonico todas las defensas antiaerias solo atacan a un objeto a la vez cuando el o los misiles son destruidos siempre inpacta uno pero nunca lo vez yegar creo que es un bug

[@newn4817]

❤️‍🔥❤️‍🔥❤️‍🔥❤️‍🔥❤️‍🔥❤️‍🔥❤️‍🔥❤️‍🔥👍👍👍👍

[@james8449100]

I'll take lower damage over in exchange for dule mode every time especially when you combine an auto cannon that has AA capability even time

[@gemnguyennhut3470]

Ahhh i hate all AA that can shoot ship. Once they focus on ship, they will never shoot missile anymore, that's why sea ram always the best option for missile intercepted.

[@_raptor_8882]

Тесты не совсем верные. Самолёты будут использовать ловушки для ракет и тогда ракетное пво будет абсолютно бесполезно, она не нанесёт никакого урона

[@Mango280-y2g]

Bye bye Bombers 😁🦾

[@Galam04]

Flare...😂

[@hoshiyarsinghyadav2357]

Garpun's canon is not that good, doesn't incur that much damage.

[@RETRO_BS5]

Garpun + Crotal solo;)

[@Formigacomandante]

Eu não quero ter mais a garpum

[@febrianwar1104]

Kecepatan rudalnya sama seperti garpun

[@newn4817]

💥💥💥💥💥💥💥💥💥👍👍👍👍👍👍👍

[@Rufinito6680]

YO USO X3 CROTALE Y Y X5 URAGAN Y X3 URAGAN JALAJOYA

[@player00777]

Garpun need buff

[@wahyuwirawan727]

Okay, crotale big missiles has better accuracy than garpun small missiles. Game logic is weird 😅 I can accept crotale has more dmg but not this.

[@perzival757]

New best air defence has arrived it is cortale ,now garpun is the second best

[@BestaticbeastDl]

Jrng is best air defense in my opinion

[@Hydra_Iron]

​@@BestaticbeastDlnah

[@Devastation-YouTube]

That's so dumb, they have no balance in this game. Garpens lose in all cases.....

[@cajakolon]

crotale good for non carriers easy kill aircrft

[@naman_5095]

Garpun is best

[@FIAGRA-rp8xb]

🤔🤔😧😦🫣🙄😯

[@LionPo.]

Jir lah,kecewa + nyesel gw beli garpun sebanyak itu sumpah

[@nopresssss]

Лан пойду искать другой канал…где пишут на русском хотя бы сабы.

[@arisuin20x97]

What frigate or destroyer did you use for the video bro?

[@CakrabirawaCH.]

USS Massachusetts