Crowd Stunned by Bill Maher’s Unexpected Reaction to Harrison Butker Speech

Dave Rubin of “The Rubin Report” shares a DM clip of Bill Maher’s surprising support of Harrison Butker’s controversial commencement speech.
Watch Dave Rubin's FULL DIRECT MESSAGE: • Gutfeld Looks Shocked ...
WATCH the MEMBER-EXCLUSIVE segment of the show here: rubinreport.locals.com/
Check out the NEW RUBIN REPORT MERCH here:
daverubin.store/
----------
#RubinReport #RealTime #BillMaher #HarrisonButker #feminism #daverubin
The Direct Message segments of the Rubin Report are a chance for Dave Rubin to directly address current events, political news and the topics of the day. Whether it’s encouraging critical thinking, defending free speech, or fending off political correctness, it’s only by having calm rational conversations about these issues that can help de-escalate the political polarization and help heal our democracy. To hear what Dave has to say on these and a variety of other topics watch this playlist:
• DIRECT MESSAGE | RUBIN...
To make sure you never miss a single Rubin Report video, click here to subscribe:
/ @rubinreport
Looking for smart and honest conversations about current events, political news and the culture war? Want to increase your critical thinking by listening to different perspectives on a variety of topics? If so, then you’re in the right place because on The Rubin Report Dave Rubin engages the ideas of some of society's most interesting thought leaders, authors, politicians and comedians. The Rubin Report is the largest talk show about free speech and big ideas on KZbin.
Dave allows his guests to speak their minds and his audience to think for themselves.
New videos every week.
The Rubin Report is fan funded through monthly and one-time donations:
rubinreport.com/support
******
Join Dave's Locals community: rubinreport.locals.com/
Order “Don't Burn This Country” the follow up to Dave Rubin’s New York Times bestselling “Don’t Burn This Book” here: daverubin.com/book/
Dave Rubin's book, "Don't Burn This Book" is available at:
www.dontburnthisbook.com
LISTEN to The Rubin Report podcast: www.rubinreport.com/podcast
See Dave LIVE: daverubin.com/events/
Sign up for our newsletter with the best of The Rubin Report delivered to your inbox once a week: www.rubinreport.com/newsletter
Official Rubin Report Merchandise: rubinreport.myshopify.com/
All art on the set are original works by Caylin Rose Janet.
Get a print here: www.caylinrosejanet.com/rubin...
******
Follow Dave on Twitter: / rubinreport
Follow The Rubin Report on Facebook: / rubinreport
Follow Dave on Facebook: / daverubin
Follow Dave on Instagram: rubinreport...
About Dave Rubin: daverubin.com/

[@whaaat3632]

A staunch Catholic gave a pro-Catholic speech at a Catholic university. Oh the SHAME....

[@ianalan4367]

lol 😂

[@theivory1]

The college hired him. That means they knew what their graduates expected, they knew what they were hiring. It's really not anyone else's business. Not mine, not yours, certainly not anyone's on the left because they would never send their kid there.

[@timdake]

@@theivory1 - Leftists would send their children to a woke college, to get a woke degree (and $200k of debt) to graduate with the qualifications required to ask "short, Grande or Venti?".

[@geoplaten337]

Joe Biden would have preached to them about abortion.

[@Divine1Right]

What does it even mean to be Catholic anymore? There are conservative Catholics and liberal Catholics, and the two are nothing alike. Biden claims to be a Catholic.

[@lizzieb6311]

First…I’m a career woman…foregoing having a family in favor of becoming a successful and fulfilled Chemical Engineer. I can tell you I am FAR FROM OFFENDED by this speech. In fact, I am TOUCHED that he’s addressing the “shame” that many FEMINISTS ***force**** upon women who choose to create a loving family and stay home to raise their Children and be FULFILLED by doing so. My Mother did so and enjoyed it. I have NEWS FOR YOU Feminists…now, at 59 I REGRET not taking a break from my career to have a child or two. Now I face the harsh reality that my ADVANCED DEGREE will not be helping me thru my later years…no Grandkids to enjoy…no….I chose my degree over a family and there are times I wish I hadn’t. You Feminists need to BACK OFF Women who,chose Family over career.

[@alexa11129]

Amen!

[@thomaskaiakapu2672]

Bravo! Well said.

[@glassmw9823]

👏👏👏👍👍👍🙌

[@balthazor44]

Well put. It's one thing to say women should have the choice to go out into the workforce and have a career, that's a no-brainer. It's another thing to insist that women must enter the workforce, and shame them if they don't. Oh well she's JUST a housewife! At some point feminism decided that the way to measure a woman's worth is by the man's scale. You must succeed in the man's world to be a successful woman! You must possess masculine traits to be a successful woman! Not only does it completely diminish the immense value of the feminine, but it also sets most women up for failure to insist that they need to beat men at their own game in order to succeed as a woman. Nothing ruins women quite like feminism.

[@craignotgreg547]

👏 There's absolutely no shame in being a stay home mother. Only the needless shame (and judgement) that society wants to cast on people that don't support their own beliefs. The world does not revolve around you (or your feelings).

[@itsallfunandgames723]

Let's be real, it outraged 0.01% of the American population, who tweeted about it a million times.

[@Borg14]

Exactly! The percentage was probably smaller

[@mniay]

10000%. They are actually the minority of the population, but they are so loud about voicing their opinions that people think there are many more who think this way. Having said that, it would be great if more people of the majority spoke out. It would prevent cancel culture and the drowning of the actual common belief. But I also understand why there isn't, we have our actual physical lives to attend to, instead of these minority groups of people that are imo just mad at their own lives and spend their day online hunting and calling out anyone who they don't agree with.

[@highroller-jq3ix]

@@mniay Right? Think of all that shrieking stupidity about Taylor Swift. Wingnuts are so batshit.

[@Alex_1A]

What people often forget, including myself, is that .01% of America is still 35k people. The fact so many are outrageously offended by acknowledging facts is concerning. And on top of that, I feel like it might be closer to 1% than .01%.

[@johnjerrehian4642]

You are probably very right in what you said...

[@juliebailey5751]

I am a Christian grandmother, wife, American. I got my degree at 21, went to work, met my husband. After 5 years of marriage and work, I had my daughter. I had a nanny picked out. When I laid eyes on this precious baby, the hounds of hell could not take me away from her. Thank God I have a Godly husband who saw the value in raising my own children. He took on the work load needed to pursue our plan for a successful family. Our Plan...Not yours, anyone who wants to hate....we are all free to live our lives as we choose. Thank God.

[@veritatemdicam4585]

I think many women have every intention of going back to work after their first child is born but then once that baby is in their arms, if there's any possible chance of staying home, they do. I realize that not every woman has this choice. There are parts of the country where this is much more possible than others. The point is, there should be a choice either way.

[@tgriffin3059]

@@veritatemdicam4585 That maternal instinct to which you both refer...is something the Left will do anything to eradicate from our species...

[@stephenorourke7005]

I am a non-religious, (but spiritual) person. If Anyone decides to stay home and raise children with values, WHO ARE WE TO JUDGE!!??!!?? Only an idiot would argue this point!! My mother is rolling in her grave....

[@wildfire60]

Nice decision but it was your decision. People aren't all cut from the same cloth. Some women choose an entirely different path. They would give the same kind of glowing testimony about their life's decisions as you do. What's important is that women have the choice rather than having to try and pick the right man to take care of them because they have no other options. The world is a much wider and diverse place then you imagine and won't fall apart if many women choose not to follow today's version of the traditional wife's role. Viva la difference!

[@SouthernHiker]

Amen

[@Adventuregirl96]

I am an Officer in the Coast Guard and have a good career ahead of me. But all of that is secondary to my son Lucas and my husband Dan. While my career is important to me, and I am proud of my uniform and all my awards, my family brings me joy every day. I can do without my career but not my family.

[@Donna-cc1kt]

Eloquently said!

[@chadcameron4080]

Thank you for your service Adventuregirl96

[@stephenorourke7005]

Great response!! Salutations from a complete stranger!! Your Children will remember the family moments, NOT the career moments!!

[@kathyhansen2820]

I had the hard core career, the stay at home Mom, a fulfilling part time business when my daughter went into first grade. Now I'm a widowed Grandma still with my part time passion. Life goes on for quite a while and many things can be achieved. I don't feel like I missed anything.

[@KlaudiaShaefferr]

@@marct9808 Nothing against motherhood and family first. It’s not what he said. It’s HOW he said it. He devalued education and career achievements for women as a waste of life (while his mother achieved in science AND family)

[@sirclarkmarz]

I myself as an atheist lifelong bachelor and someone who does not like the presence of children around can understand the importance of the family unit . Is the backbone of our society .

[@cpmow831]

I appreciate your input and open mindedness!

[@grdn02100]

@@cpmow831 I can too!

[@kathycoleman4648]

Precisely. My aunt never had any interest in marriage or having children, but still took a lot of time out to help my mom by babysitting us since both of my parents worked long shifts. While families and having kids is important, even those without kids should recognize the reasons family matters, or even get involved depending on what life places in their path (eg. my aunt).

[@palerider7708]

⁠​⁠I too identify like you (I’m not anti kids, I was just realised the sacrifice wasn’t for me) and I totally agree with your statement. The world would be a more pleasant place if those hysterical karens & cucks from the left realised that just because a life choice works for them, it doesn’t HAVE to work for everyone else.

[@BBslider001]

Sad state of affairs man. Damn, keep that depressing shit to yourself LOL

[@ens7ob]

I am not a mother but a father and I can say from the bottom of my heart the greatest joy in my life is my children. I have been at my job for 19 years and have never risen in promotion or rank and I don't regret it one bit. I was home every night to eat dinner with my children and I never missed a football game or a wrestling match or a dance recital and those memories are the best moments in my life. I have never seen a tombstone say here lies Charlie he wishes he could have worked more.

[@theslowevo9303]

So, men can't be "most excited about their marriage and the children they will bring into this world"? Why didn't he say that to both men AND women?

[@bbranco01]

If I was offered a job that pays 3x my salary, but a requirement will be that I don't have a time to walk with my kids to the bus stop every morning...I say No Thanks

[@St0pTheInsan1ty1]

@@theslowevo9303You’re putting words in his mouth. He was specifically talking to the women in the audience at that time. Of course a man’s greatest joy/accomplishment in life can be his family. Should be his family… That’s why most men work in the first place. To provide for their families! Y’all are assuming that he meant it as some misogynistic BS without actually knowing and making complete asses of yourselves.

[@theslowevo9303]

@@bbranco01 why can't your husband walk your kids to the bus stop? Why can't you both share responsibilities. Butker made it seem like the man's job is to work and the woman's job is to stay home

[@theslowevo9303]

@@St0pTheInsan1ty1 why is it so bad if women also work.

[@andywotjuno9954]

I’m a retired British police officer, years ago some of us were invited to attend a “ Meet a successful female police officer seminar” The successful police woman turned out to be the first female Chief Constable, in the UK, a pretty lofty position to achieve, I might add. I went along with a female colleague who herself had never sought or got any promotions during her 30 years service. She was smart and a great street cop. When it came to the Q&A’s she stood up after listening to all the plaudits, platitudes being displayed by the master of ceremonies and she asked a very simple question. She said” I have had three children, raised them throughout their lives, paid for their university fees and seen them to go and get married and have children of their own, my question to the female Chief Constable is” Would you consider me a successful police woman” As you can imagine the question was met by a stunned silence.

[@globalnationalismyoutube]

The things that she mentioned are related to her being a mother not to her being a police woman. If she wants to ask if she is a successful police woman then she should mention her achievements as a police woman and then ask if those achievements make her a successful police woman.

[@mrfreeman2911]

​@@globalnationalismyoutubeshe did the job and raised 3 kids. It has everything to do with the job.

[@andywotjuno9954]

@@globalnationalismyoutube unfortunately you miss my point she never measured her own success, she was merely pointing out that a persons own lifestyle/individual choices, can be a success for the individual, who don’t seek out platitudes of perceived success. The woman Chief Constable was childless and put her energy into her career my friend did both career and family. The video and speaker talks of success for all, it’s wherever you wish to find it.

[@globalnationalismyoutube]

@@andywotjuno9954 Yes success can be achieved as per different life choices. My argument is that her question about whether she is a successful police woman cannot be answered by how she raised her children. That is a separate part of her life.

[@andywotjuno9954]

@@globalnationalismyoutube I see what you are saying but I think she had a successful police career whilst keeping the plates spinning at home. I’ll meet you half way and say she is a “successful woman”.

[@ginabisaillon2894]

Being a woman myself I will bet you that if women didn't need that second salary in order to make ends meet that many of them would choose to stay home.

[@SatansPeter]

It has been worked out since the beginning stages of the global world order, which the plan was to break the nuclear family (which is us), and allow the state to rule society. The cost of inflation and dirty economics plowed it's way into our systems overtime, and made life more expensive, which caused the upkeeping of life financially more difficult by requiring more work, as they narrowed our currency down by exhausting its purchasing power through endless printing, and the only way for average human beings to compensate has been by adding more work, which often is by systematically forcing the other partner, the women, to commit to working alongside the men, as you said in order to make ends meet. Much unlike the 70s when the mother could stay at home and the father could work one job and pay for a house. Nowadays two parents hardly make ends meet renting a property. This is much more complicated, and the little agendas that were measured and set out upon, examples being such as making men weak and amplifying feminism in order to further weaken the family, have so far been achieved mostly. We get ever closer to letting the state rule our lives, and our children. This was one main goal of many. Removing parental consent is one of the biggest objectives, because it gives them rights and control over our lives at a early age and ultimately, which instead should always and ultimately be up to the parents, allowing us to maintain and keep our sovereignty as human beings by acting upon ourselves under the rule of God, and not the government. Instead life is now upside down, mother and fathers are dysfunctional, parents authority being displaced by the state, and God removed from the picture, this is the way of the new world order.

[@Joe-hz1nw]

1. Women fought their way into the workforce. When you increase the supply of workers by roughly 35-40%, the most basic form of common sense will tell you wages will plummet. Women created much of the one income not being enough issue 2. Almost all the women I’ve ever seen wisen up do so after they have kids. It’s as if they are incapable recognizing they want to stay home once they have kids beforehand. It’s extremely childish and shows how incapable they are of thinking beyond the end of their noses. 3. Women get tons of often useless college degrees, run up TONS of student debt, then burden their husbands with it and want to stop working as hard/work part time/stop working once they have kids. This dumps a huge amount of stress on the husband. Women tend do to this at around 30 when they spent the last 5-10 years traveling, living in expensive single apartments bc they can’t stand to live with another woman/women, sleeping around, no sacrifices to get out of debt. So men effectively have to subsidize this insolent behavior. 4. Men are generally willing to live much cheaper and more simply than women are. Women say they want to stop working but then demand a lifestyle that isn’t congruent. 5. Women OVERWHELMINGLY vote for leftist high taxes, high regulation, affirmative action, government handouts, “student loan forgiveness”, and inflation causing policies that make life at least 30% more expensive by my rough calculation. This makes two incomes a necessity. 6. Instead of building with a good man on their dating marketplace level when they are young, women sleep with the top 10% of men who are out of their league. This damages them, makes most other men check out, and turns the top men into monsters. This drives down wages of men who don’t see a reason to try because one or the primary motivators for them to make more money is a nice, conservative, no promiscuous past, non-indebted, fit, feminine, 20’s (fertility) wife (less than 2% of women meet these basic requirements). Remove a primary motivator for men and they stop caring. In summary, women did it to themselves over the last half century and it will continue to get worse until things collapse.

[@sans-nom8311]

Feminism was supposed to give me the choice to enter the workplace, not force me too. Feminism failed me.

[@Vickie167]

Unfortunatly the economy is getting worse.

[@Kwisatz-Chaderach]

If you didn't spend money on Childcare you would be fine.

[@anitacosgrove6612]

Motherhood is the MOST important role in the WORLD! I wish I had more time at home with my beautiful children! Mom of 4, youngest is now 14 - I would trade anything now to have them little again and spend every single minute enjoying them! 💚

[@old_nick_the_so-and-so]

no, making sure god is happy is the most important, don't you listen? nothing counts except god eh?

[@theslowevo9303]

Fatherhood isn't the most important role in the world as well? So, men can't be "most excited about their marriage and the children they will bring into this world"? Why didn't he say that to both men AND women?

[@robinsanny1498]

I have a degree from a great California university but there's no accolade better than the praise and affection I get from my kids and husband when I serve them. I needed to forgo the high power career track to stay home and homeschool my kids with learning difficulties. Living on one income was hard but so worth it. My son graduates in two weeks with honors, an accomplishment that was very hard won and I am so proud of him for persevering. The one income life is not possible for many but, if you can swing it, do it, moms! And homeschool is not for every kid or mom but it has brought us many blessings that the extra income could not buy. Grace and peace to you all.

[@cletusvandamme6262]

"...but it has brought us many blessings that the extra income could not buy." Well said, Mom. Money cannot buy the Love, Success, and Joy that your family brings you. Money, Fame, Fortune; those things come and go. Your family is FOREVER.

[@bigredracingdog466]

Many men also feel that fatherhood and their children is the most important thing they'll do.

[@interstellar618]

"..one of those a**hole factories like Harvard" Funniest thing he's said in years.

[@travistaylor1195]

I feel like Dave let the clip run just a little bit longer to throw that in.

[@arcas8423]

That’s the most accurate description of Harvard I’ve ever heard.

[@Aodhanlurcher]

Yeah--the next time you need a doctor or an engineer, find one with no education and see how happy you'll be.

[@travistaylor1195]

@@AodhanlurcherTry to stay on topic; we’re talking about Harvard producing a**holes, not about hiring uneducated doctors and engineers (I’m not even sure where you’d find one of those).

[@Aodhanlurcher]

@@travistaylor1195 You apparently missed my point--not surprising. There are no uneducated Dr's , lawyers, engineers, etc. They are ALL educated--so what's the beef with education? Mahar's broad brushing education is as stupid as anything one would hear on Fux News.

[@johnnewton2320]

His speech was pro God, pro faith, pro life, pro family, and pro motherhood. There wasn't any anti-anything. It was a pure love story. So sad for those who dwell in darkness.

[@rangersmith4652]

Spot on. The idea that being pro- something means you must be anti- a different thing is ludicrous.

[@hihi2667]

Which god though? there's A LOT

[@MrGieschen]

​@@hihi2667 considering he mentioned Mass, likely the Catholic God.

[@slp-mu6uj]

@@hihi2667 What difference does it make???????

[@lizzieb6311]

100%! ♥

[@janepaquette2110]

The only thing I would add to his speech is that many men feel the same way and they've been shamed into believing that if you don't work 80 hour weeks you can't be successful. The most important part of life is BALANCE. Believe me, few companies care about you and you can be replaced within minutes.

[@kristineyost6977]

Shame on him for practicing his right to freedom of speech. Doesn't he know that's banned in the usa.

[@WithaplanforLife]

Not any more. Hopefully.

[@old_nick_the_so-and-so]

i love you "freedom of speech" people, cos it's freedom of expression, not speech, just a quick reminder that the first amendment conflicts with the first commandment "thou shalt worship whoever you want" and that the declaration of human rights gives ME more rights than god. and a history lesson cos the USA is a secular nation, not many people seem to know that, and the founding fathers were at best deists and certainly not christian. hitchens became a naturalised american purely because of the constitution. the UK is officially christian, the US is officially secular. is it annoying that the satanic temple has the SAME RIGHTS as the church?

[@kristineyost6977]

He was practicing his freedom of speech. Ok, let's say you could not talk about the devil in your satanic masses. Let's say nobody had that right or they would go to jail. You'd be pissed. The guy did nothing wrong . He was at a mass what did you expect him to talk about? Kiddie porn? He honestly said from his heart what he honestly felt about women and abortion. You can disagree with him but don't silence him. This isn't china.

[@jamesgiguere6620]

Ask a mature woman with a family what her proudest moments are. She gonna say, "I lead the regional sales team for three quarters straight in 2007"? Or is she going to say "When my daughter made the deans list" or "When my son reached his Eagle Schout" or "When my girl made States and won"? Family is everything. Work is just work.

[@lizzieb6311]

Exactly! I’m a Chemical Engineer who chose career over family…and REGRET IT! I still love my job…but when I retire I’m alone with my degree. How sad.

[@annetteneubauer3052]

Why should a daughter make the deans list if her purpose in life is to be a wife and mother and nothing else?

[@historyrepeated4239]

@@annetteneubauer3052 I think you misunderstood the speech and the comment. Why should anyone who takes the most amount of pride in their family, not still strive for the dean's list, for a college degree, or any other endeavor? It seems in your very black and white world, you can't be both? It almost appears that you believe any parent who chooses to stay at home is settling and shouldn't strive to have multiple joys. It's like saying, once you become a mother, why have a social life? Just focus on your kids, cooking and cleaning, and only sub-servient tasks. Very curious view on the limitations of parenthood or marriage.

[@annetteneubauer3052]

@@historyrepeated4239 That was my point exactly. That you can be both. Or one or the other depanding on where life will take you. It was the stupid speech that was preaching the oppsite:. "A Womens ONLY purpose in life is be a mother" . His words exactly.

[@kathryn-yd7bh]

​@@annetteneubauer3052 why shouldn't she make the deans list, just because women want to become mothers doesn't mean that's all they have to be. I got my engineering degree, worked in my chosen field until I wanted my family. I'm now 35 with a husband and child and it's the best thing I have ever done becoming a mother watcher her grow and learn. On the other hand my twin sister is just her job, doesn't want child and her mental health is shit, the only thing she has is how do I climb the ladder and how much money she can make. I'm my eyes that doesn't sound as fulfilling but each to their own.

[@russellh8702]

People looking to be offended don’t deserve to be acknowledged

[@iSpaceOG]

It just comes down to the fact that nobody has opinions anymore, it's just the most socially accepted answer at that time. The day we can't talk about things rationally is the day we are in trouble as a civilization, and were already gargling.

[@abhid.2679]

Why don't we just ignore these hardline leftist lunatics?

[@highroller-jq3ix]

@@iSpaceOG That was profound right up the second syllable, at which point it became incoherent blather.

[@Xy64D86]

​@@highroller-jq3ix what are u on about mate? people don't debate anything anymore. they would rather try to cancel you instead of just accepting your opinion. what did he say that was so hard for you to comprehend?

[@Jschmuck8987]

@@highroller-jq3ixpoor child. You have so much difficulty understanding a simple comment on the internet? Life is going to be tough for you.

[@shovelleator4738]

I’m a 60 yo father of 4 and grandfather of 2 and nothing gives more joy than seeing my daughters and sons fawn over my granddaughters and know that they are loved ++++ Oh, and I’ve been a doctor for close to 40 years now and missed countless interstate and evening meetings to stay with my family- making choices with my wife and children in mind first. Nothing to be ashamed of to be family men and women but rather celebrated!

[@KlaudiaShaefferr]

That’s great! Family is something to be proud of. it’s not what he said. It’s HOW he said it. He devalued education and career achievements for women as a waste of life (while his mother achieved in science AND family)

[@Hawkeye2001]

@@KlaudiaShaefferr Great "Copy & Paste" skills

[@christinepeterson8097]

@@KlaudiaShaefferrsnowflake! He is absolutely correct. I got the degree, got a job, got married, had a couple of children and realized that it is impossible to do both my full time job and be a good mother. I did not have enough energy or time to do both well. I chose family first and I’m very happy with my decision.

[@Melissa-souz]

and guys should not ruin women's sports..

[@nd4091]

………….and waaaay out in left field…….

[@mearndt1]

Nothing to do with this

[@shollister3009]

@@mearndt1 It has plenty to do with the disenfranchising and demoralization of women.

[@g.w.7893]

Women's sports? 🤣 🤣 🤣

[@shollister3009]

@@g.w.7893 That's the beauty of it - if you aren't interested, you don't have to participate. :)

[@sully0001]

Not to mention, Benedictine College is a small Catholic College in Atchison Kansas. These people are conservative Catholics. Go Ravens!!! Those complaining are idiots

[@flyoverstateresident2890]

Evil now good while good is now evil?

[@annetteneubauer3052]

Benedictine College has published an extensive statement on their Website in which they state that his message is by no means what they try to install in their students. It is a very powerful statement on why his stand on Catholicism is not theirs.

[@johnhoran9840]

@@annetteneubauer3052 The college doesn't even stand for what Catholicism stands for, despite it's name. Bear in mind, I view Catholicism as false religion.

[@houseontheprairie2009]

As far as I have seen the college has not made a statement regarding the speech. Only the sisters of Mount Saint Scholastica have issued a statement.

[@DadoMac]

@@johnhoran9840 If Jesus said 'No hell will prevail against His church" what church is it today? And what sect do you belong to? Pls don't be ambiguous and be honest, if you consider yourself a 'christian'

[@pwk22]

Freedom of choice ... unless your choice is to be a stay at home mom.

[@TheDoctor394]

Yes, you're free to do whatever you want - as long as I agree with it.

[@KlaudiaShaefferr]

it’s not what he said. It’s HOW he said it (“diabolical lies”). He devalued education and career achievements for women as a waste of life (while his mother achieved in science AND family - she wasn’t a SAHW)

[@user-gf4rq1js2n]

@@KlaudiaShaefferr Maybe she took a few years off...? From work to take care of family? He said nothing negative about his Mom.

[@MrBrock314]

@@KlaudiaShaefferr The diabolical lie he's suggesting here is the idea that women should focus on their careers OVER family. And I don't think anyone really thinks that that message is a good idea for the majority of families. There are some childless or single people that could work for but most people would do well to prioritize their family over their career. Whether that means staying at home, taking a sick day or just making quality time depends on the case. Careers end, family doesn't (if take care of it well). When you're 70, family will generally still be there while the career is in the rearview mirror. Even if you don't have kids, you'll typically still have cousins, nephews, nieces, siblings, etc to be around. The only thing is he didn't need to limit his talk to women - it's equally true for men.

[@highroller-jq3ix]

Freedom of choice . . . unless your choice is not to have your uterus to be a fascist-controlled incubator.

[@Heart_on_Fire1]

My heart jumped for joy when I heard the speech. It takes moral courage to speak candidly about marriage and family values that are being attacked in all facets of society. My wife has been a homemaker, rearing our children for many years, while I am the breadwinner in the family. I believe it is God's design for a husband to be the head of the household to shoulder that financial burden while the wife rears the children. There are too many children being raised by a single mom or dad, and that is tragic where kids are morally bankrupt or suffer emotional trauma for the rest of their lives.

[@highroller-jq3ix]

No it doesn't. It takes moral courage not to be bullied into submission by the fundie misogyny mob.

[@jr798]

Shit, my mom stayed home and raised four sons while my dad worked. After we were all in school, my dad retired after 25 years or so, took up home keeping duties, and kept busy with odd jobs and helping others. She went to have a career of her own. She just retired after almost 25 years. Both, or either are completely valid choices.

[@AlfonsoDiSaliz]

Im an Atheist, and i agree 100% with this, besides, he is at a CATHOLIC SCHOOL, they are more used to the concepts of marriage and family, and of course, its FREEDOM OF SPEECH, for all the people who want censorship

[@rickinnepa9008]

I laughed out loud when Bill called Harvard an "asshole factory". Hats off to him. Praise God for Harrison Butker's remarks.

[@highroller-jq3ix]

So was he a ventriloquist dummy for your heinous god fantasy?

[@Aodhanlurcher]

Yeah--it's a riot to trash/ laugh at education , isn't it? The next time you need medical care go to someone with no education and se how happy you'll be with the results. Are you people afraid of education? Is that the issue?

[@jeffs7915]

He's not saying, you have to be a mother, they are so insecure that noone can suggest that traditional role have advantages that corporate life doesn't.

[@angiedues8813]

I’m glad he said it, it’s time to end cancel culture

[@freddysquirenaranjo4859]

Push back time for these Commie Loony Tunes, they have had their day! I not shutting up anymore! I see a Palestinian rally; I shout out Shalom and Praise God and Israel! Hamas is evil.... Woke is Dead!!! Everyone must push back; the majority have had enough of all this shite!

[@hitman1455]

So u want to cancel someone huh how ironic

[@WithaplanforLife]

Yeah, if people keep speaking up.

[@CentristDad155]

May I add, that the right wing is always crowing about how Bill Maher has joined them. Bill Maher is the same as he's been for 20 years. The fact that you keep referencing him means you're moving towards him rather than vice versa. Thank you

[@theslowevo9303]

You guys tried to cancel Bud Light over a rainbow

[@someoneelse1i1i]

The irony is that so many of the people that were offended are really advocating for LESS CHOICE 🤦‍♂️. They genuinely believe that even the SUGGESTION that a woman might choose marriage/motherhood over a career should be “cancelled”.

[@therealgrimreaper68]

suggestion that their life starts only when they got married

[@someoneelse1i1i]

@@therealgrimreaper68 That wasn’t remotely the suggestion. On the contrary the suggestion is that not only does it not have to end with marriage (as many he referenced purport) but that it can become even more rewarding.

[@therealgrimreaper68]

@@someoneelse1i1i "This doesn't imply the same to you even though I said this in a speech addressed to you "

[@someoneelse1i1i]

@@therealgrimreaper68 Especially since no one said it at all…🤦‍♂️

[@someoneelse1i1i]

@@therealgrimreaper68 Especially since no one said it at all…🤦‍♂️

[@yznalnoing1]

As President (prophet) of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latterday Saints stated: “But my dear sisters, your ability to discern truth from error, to be society’s guardians of morality, is crucial in these latter days. And we depend upon you to teach others to do likewise. Let me be very clear about this: if the world loses the moral rectitude of its women, the world will never recover.”

[@meyerhave]

"The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter- day Saints" Ie: Looney cult, not a "religion".

[@grdn02100]

@@meyerhave if you could accomplish a tenth of what that looney cult has - well lets be honest, thats clearly not going to happen.

[@PC33CC]

My wife was absolutely crushing it in her career. In her way to becoming an executive. But when she became pregnant with our first child, she decided she was going to stay home to raise our children. Her decision. And we are both thankful she made it. Our kids are the better for it. And now that they are at the college level, she’s looking to get back into the workforce. Again, her choice. And she’s a liberal (I vote Republican).

[@samuelWx]

Dude spoke fundamental and traditional Catholic values at a Catholic commencement, go figure.

[@shtroizn]

Actually - he spoke fundamental and traditional most world values regardless of country or religion. It's just this so-called modern/progressive mindset and 3rd wave feminism that derails the minds of women - most of whom regret making the horrible choice of foregoing a loving family in exchange for a career (as if the two are mutually exclusive).

[@highroller-jq3ix]

Yup, misogynistic, Leave it to Beaver idiocy, and some people found it pretty nauseating. Go figure.

[@richardkramer4076]

@@highroller-jq3ix Oh what a virtue signaler you are. NOTHING Butker said was misogynistic. That reprehensible attitude comes from the Left. You can't identify anything he said that is what you claim. Some might find the idiocy in your comment.

[@anneturner2759]

I was surprised to hear Bill Maher’s opinion on this speech , I’m refreshed .

[@highroller-jq3ix]

So did you drink his opinion after a hot walk through the desert?

[@gshartman6576]

Being a father it's a beautiful thing to see my wife and kids together just hanging on the couch having a laugh. Priceless!!

[@jeffreydean5112]

Being a mother and wife is extremely important, impactful and a beautiful thing. You can also have a nice career but being the glue in a family is life changing for the family.

[@thomaskaiakapu2672]

Harrison Butker is the man!

[@NT-fo3me]

Butker understood his audience much better than his critics understood his audience. Conservative Catholic women aren't the ones complaining about him telling female graduates of a conservative Catholic college that many are looking forward to marriage and motherhood more than a career. That would be liberals and progressives, many of whom are women with no intentions of ever filling either role.

[@HappyCats17]

The nuns on campus criticized him mightily. I kid you not. Said they stood for inclusivity. We are living in Bizarro World.

[@NT-fo3me]

@@HappyCats17 Yeah, I saw that. The nuns do not qualify as conservative Catholic women, however.

[@wyleecoyotee4252]

Yes the conservative catholic women have been conditioned.

[@NT-fo3me]

@@wyleecoyotee4252 And their progressive pro abortion counterparts HAVEN'T been?

[@dorisjordan1959]

When I was a teenager back in the sixties my mom couldn’t understand women who complained about staying home. She was in her fourties’ then and had worked non stop since she was in high school. I had missed her too, but she always did her best as a mom and an employee. It was a pure joy that I got to take care of her in last years of life. Family is always the best in my mind even when there are political squabbles during Thanksgiving.

[@mmeeddddddozzzzzzz3421]

Because society told those women that they NEEDED and SHOULD stay at home and they SHOULD get married, no matter how much they had no interest in staying at home, getting married or having kids. Those women were complaining about it because that choice was taken away from them. That was also the time when a woman couldn't get a credit card WITHOUT her husband's permission.

[@user-so9gw2po7n]

As a dad, nothing I've ever done in my career even comes close at all compared with being a dad. Period!

[@Chimchimchu]

With a loving attitude such as that, if Marie Curie had you for a father she never would've discovered radium. That's a joke, I don't know where these people get their arguments from. They have a list of bad faith topics to pretend to be offended about.

[@billstarr9396]

If I didn't know better, it seems as though Bill Maher is slowly being red pilled.

[@johnwong5317]

He stays the same while the rest keep moving further left, soon they will call him right winger.

[@frednone]

It's how it has to happen, a little bit at a time.

[@nadogrl]

Even a blind squirrel…

[@josephgriffin2388]

Until he votes for Trump I'm unpersuaded.

[@immikeurnot]

Media has falsely reframed the Overton Window so far to the left that even some pretty far-left people look centrist or even right wing.

[@judimonroe4300]

I think his speech was needed in this world today, it seems that the elite want us to forget about families and children. Focus on transgender and pronouns...😢

[@onamattapeeya]

Yeah and then they label and attack anyone that disagrees with them... LIKE A CULT

[@s.gibson9329]

"Women, I want to talk to you", is probably what did it and not what he actually said.

[@brentrosencrans3968]

Anyone offended by this speech is a drama queen.

[@shionkreth7536]

This is why progressives and liberals are two different things, and while actual liberals can also be frustrating at times (especially by how easily they get influenced by progressives), they're still supposed to be all for a free exchange of ideas, and tolerance of different lifestyles, unlike progressives.

[@keith4230]

Unfortunately there are no liberals. Maybe they think they are but when they vote democrat, they’re voting for a progressive woke ideology, essentially making them woke progressives.

[@veritatemdicam4585]

I have said the same thing only I term them as Leftists vs Liberals. Quite different. But you're right, Progressives are Leftists. (And not very progressive at all as it turns out.)

[@josephgriffin2388]

Progressives/liberals are the same thing: CULTURAL MARXISM!!!

[@DarksideJedi]

Meanwhile Travis Kelce is shotgunning beers and getting praised! We are a silly species in a silly society.

[@chadcameron4080]

For some reason there are people rooting for the moral breakdown of society 🤷‍♂️

[@nadogrl]

And perhaps other Godless pursuits?

[@highroller-jq3ix]

Yah, he should have told women to stay barefoot and pregnant, like a real hero!

[@CambriaCandiceMaria]

This man is really concerned about the nonsense women have been fed, and he is telling them the truth. There is no shame, and indeed, great honor, that comes with choosing to be a full-time mother. If I had to do it all over again, I would spend about ten years working while saving. Then it would be all about having children and raising a family with my husband.

[@globalnationalismyoutube]

But if women want to work that is OK too. Neither choice should be shamed. I like his speech because he encouraged them to be mother's but didn't put down those who don't want to be mothers.

[@maxsmodels]

When B.M. and I agree, well, as Dennis Miller used to say..."The monkey is riding the horse" (planet of the apes reference). The world is upside down.

[@roland6617]

Bill is slowly becoming a conservative, and he doesn’t even know it 😂

[@SuperMnunez]

No, he is not. And don’t ever fall for it.

[@TimBitts649]

They sold out the jerseys that said "Harrison Butker" in women's sizes. That should tell you lots of women agreed with Butker. Most people on their deathbed are thinking about family and their children, not about "I wish I spent more time on my career."

[@kellymetcalf3690]

I agree with his speech...i stopped working when i got married, had 3 beautiful babies and after they were raised i found a job...of course we didnt live in a brand new house and didnt have all the new gadgets but i loved being a wife and mother.. but i respect people that want it the other way too....to each their own...

[@bonnizan1]

I refused to work when kids were young best time of my life. I was forced into the work force. Children should be society's greatest commitment

[@skumflum3768]

And most people don’t have careers, they have jobs! They do the work…it’s not intrinsically meaningful but necessary and there is honesty in that!

[@immikeurnot]

Partly because careers don't really exist anymore outside a handful of fields.

[@vladtheimpaler9577]

If you are offended by something then...DON'T LISTEN TO IT.

[@dongleason9878]

How do you know it's going to offend you if you don't listen to it?

[@thomasrial4444]

People who ignored hitler and Stalin were pretty surprised when they took power and turned their countries to sht. You’re supposed to listen to every side of an argument or a dictatorship can take over the nation because they act as if they are the truth and if they convince enough people it leads to a subjugated class that doesn’t agree with the state but has no choice. This applies to any kind of political affiliation because if you want to argue why the other side is wrong you need to know why they are wrong by knowing their position on the subject. This is how America formed the most successful economy and democracy and globalized the world. In other words don’t get caught with your pants down mindset. Not listening is really the first step into ignorance. Being offended by someone’s opinions is a problem on an individual level since they are acting like a child anyways. Both US parties are notorious for what you’re talking about. It’s why congress is basically useless elderly toddlers at this point.

[@highroller-jq3ix]

Kind of stupid, right? It's usually hard to know whether you're offended UNTIL you listen. That's okay, critical thinking isn't for everyone.

[@user-gv6ny9wt5m]

Well said you man. You are credit to yourself. You are a credit to the whole community off human kind.

[@g_rein_mlak]

There's no crime. He was asked to give a speech. He gave a speech. It was a different perspective than is normally force-fed women for the last 30 years. There is absolutely nothing wrong with a family, and children... it's the most rewarding thing a well meaning human being could ever do.

[@edwardmcmanus7496]

Mother's and father's are the foundation. And there has been for far too long too many single mother's doing it all alone, especially in the Black communities of America. Great address by this young man. And one that needs to be heard again and again. ✌️💚🌄

[@leeb.7188]

That’s because there aren’t men in those communities who will uphold their responsibilities, so the women have to go it alone. I’m white, grew-up in an all white housing project. It was all women and children on welfare, because the husbands/fathers had abandoned them. Until men start upholding their responsibilities, especially in poor areas, women have no choice but to never have kids, or to have kids and raise them in poverty. I’m a female and never had children because of what I saw growing up; there’s no way that I would ever trust a man to take care of me when I was vulnerable, through pregnancy and while raising young children. I have a good career, but I wish I had a few children, but my father abandoned us, left us without food and we lived in our car til we got in the rejects, and I wasn’t about to subject any child of mine to that life.

[@rena6895]

He also spoke to the men about being good fathers. He basically said put family first.

[@user-or1yn5rb4t]

Two types of people don't complain about this speech: People who are stay at home moms or dads Women work are stuck being a 40hr a week waitress or Walmart worker or stuck doing telemarketing 40hrs a wk...ask THEM if they'd rather be stay at home moms

[@davidhabener5767]

His Speach was spot on, some just can't handle the truth. They say sometime's the truth hurts, so just deal with it.

[@johnschwartz1536]

This is a well thought out commencement address that inspired confidence to the student and congratulations to their mothers. Far different than the "downer" commencement address that Biden recently gave at a Black College! I usually don't agree with Bill Maher, but with his thought on this address, I do!

[@joepatriot363]

I have come to the conclusion, that in life NO MATTER what stance you take on any subject, you will offend someone. I, to me seems many of these young people get up every morning and go out LOOKING to be OFFENDED by someone's actions or words. These are the same people that, if they were told they won a MILLION DOLLARS they would complain thet they had to pay tax on it.

[@miketracy9256]

Because we decided to live a frugal life for the past 50 years together, my wife was able to be a full-time mom to the four children we were blessed to have. Looking back, it was one of the best choices we ever made.

[@dang6832]

It’s funny, my wife was very accomplished in her career, but says her greatest accomplishments are our 3 children. Sometimes I question her sanity, but she is right.

[@jkcas]

When I was younger, just out of college, married and expecting my first child. I told my husband that my career was important to me and that I would be getting child care so I could continue with my career. Once I had this child in my arms, I knew how important I was in his survival and life. I put my career on hold and persuade the most important, powerful job of my life. To raise, protect and love a new human being. No regrets, my career was still there when I decided to return to it. Working all your life and not experiencing life is sad. Love, Family, Children, Life is POWERFUL.

[@highroller-jq3ix]

Who gives more to the world, a female pediatrician who makes the lives of hundreds or even thousands of children better, or the devoted incubator?

[@sueseelie]

@@highroller-jq3ix Well if the “devoted incubator” stopped having children, what’s the point of being a pediatrician, female or male?

[@highroller-jq3ix]

@@sueseelie Here's a concept you might find difficult: diversity and individual choice. Only a paroid, whackadoodle fundie would believe that reproduction will cease if women aren't trained to be Stepford Wives.

[@ItsKyleMang]

After seeing the culture wars for what they are since 2016, I can't express how happy it makes me to watch "Liberals" make a complete 180 on ALL of this nonsense.

[@user-ct5ms5sk3g]

The MOST important part of Butker's speech is that he acknowledged ALL women both liberal AND conservative and DID NOT DIVIDE OUR COUNTRY EVEN FURTHER

[@old_nick_the_so-and-so]

the most important part was that he's pretty much in line with fascism, but don't let me drag into reality.

[@marcusmoonstein242]

I miss the old days when "Liberal" meant being open-minded to differences and allowing people to do their own thing.

[@davidevans3175]

Why aren't people entitled to their own opinions and beliefs anymore?

[@amandalee215]

Being g a mum is the best thing I ever did God bles this man

[@Vincent-fy6dn]

Good luck on your own if your husband divorces you and you dont get any inheritance. How will you survive?

[@deborahaumiller7391]

Is Bill Maher finally waking up?? I completely agree with this man's commencement speech!!!

[@KerriNowotny-fp9bc]

I AM A HAPPY, SUCCESSFUL, WOMAN...COLLEGE GRADUATE, WITH BOTH A CAREER AND A FAMILY. MY MOST IMPORTANT ROLE IS THAT OF BEING A MOTHER AND I PUT MY FAMILY FIRST ALWAYS!! I AM PROUD OF HIM FOR SPEAKING UP FOR TRADITIONAL CHRISTIAN FAMILY VALUES. GOD BLESS HIM FOR HAVING THE COURAGE IN THIS CURRENT ...CRAZY WORLD...TO SPEAK GOD'S TRUTH

[@jenkinsljenkinssquire9137]

Being a good mother is priceless

[@samuelferguson5895]

Not a chiefs fan but I love what this guy said

[@ThatKNTGuy]

One of the best things to happen to me was becoming a dad. The title of dad means more than any other title I could hold.

[@kevinmalloy2180]

That made my day!!! Harvard the “asshol factory.” Love Bill Maher!!!

[@maryannejackson2556]

Evil hates the truth!

[@billplaninshek8314]

Hey if he included that men may be mothers too …..everything would have been ok.

[@lindasmith7875]

🤣😂

[@MC-gq5ms]

Men can’t be mothers. Sorry. But men make great fathers, and we need great fathers!

[@adamperrotta462]

Understand that most MEN would also rather spend time with the family than be wage slaves.

[@OldeDog_NewTricks]

I can’t speak to a woman’s mindset, but as a man that needs to work, every second that I spend working is solely to secure time with my family. My entire working existence is singularly focused on and for my families needs. If I didn’t have to I’d stay home in a heartbeat.

[@godssara6758]

Jeez oh the horror. Saying having love in your life and children you love more than life itself is more important than the career.

[@SimonSezSo]

Men build the present. Woman build the FUTURE. Just the way it is.

[@BlowitAllUp]

Men also build the future. Single mother homes destroy the future.

[@SimonSezSo]

@@BlowitAllUp Good point.

[@Kim-tl4wz]

Being a mother is the BEST job I've ever had!

[@ES44AC-2]

The Gold medal 🏅 comment was about the Former Universities , like Harvard. We used to have a world class of Universities, but that went away about 20 or more years ago.

[@richardglover314]

The truth is a great many men would feel their lives had been empty if they had not become a dad and in the last 20 years my three children have given me 7 grandchildren. Now it sounds sad to hear young women AND men say they don't want children. Madness.

[@dlmullins9054]

Bill got that one right. He is coming around i think. Maybe.

[@pandorasbox1658]

This was my experience as a woman. I’m honored and empowered to be a mother. I am more than a rat in the rat race.

[@debbiehuth9742]

I applaud Harrison, I remember my husband taking me to an interview, I cried on the way, i did not want to leave my children

[@alancawfield6549]

I guess the only issue you could have is he directed what he said towards women specifically. However you could argue maybe what he said needed to be more directed towards women as they've been tricked into thinking in recent decades that having a career is wonderful and fulfilling when men worked out a long time ago that for 95% or more of people it's merely a means to an end and a way to support your family not actually anything fulfilling.

[@yair1010]

I don't wanna jump to any conclusions but I would bet that at this rate, Bill might actually vote Republican in November. And if he doesn't, it's still a refresher to see that he's overall on the right path.

[@wayneantoniazzi2706]

If he does he'll never admit it publicly. Or he may just vote the down-ticket, that is ignore both presidential candidates and vote for everyone else on the ballot this year for other offices.

[@nadogrl]

He seems too lazy to bother voting at all.

[@benkeel2966]

Rubin, you're the best❤

[@Zcp105]

A very Catholic man had a very Catholic take while speaking at a very Catholic university? Damn that's crazy

[@wingsoffreedom3589]

They would hate to hear what my family says in our own private meetings on gender issues. This is a catholic speaking to other Catholics everyone else mind your own business.

[@vincentm7357]

It always tickles me when bill Maher bashes Harvard…he must have forgotten that’s where his lord and savior Barack Obama went to law school.

[@dakotaescher1]

Being a husband and a father has been the greatest thing ever in my life. (27 years married and Catholic).

[@nancydavis4618]

My mother was a great secretary before she met my dad. Then she was a stay at home mom with us while we were young. Later she went back to being a secretary.

[@dogwalker1963]

I was so very fortunate to be able to stay home with my children...but because of the feminist-Marxist message everywhere, I truly didn't appreciate that blessing until years later. Now I see my daughter working full time, exhausted, with a beautiful son going to daycare (she lives out of state). It's no where near as good as staying home with mom!!! WE ALL KNOW THAT!!!!! The REAL women's movement we need is getting mothers BACK INTO THE HOUSE WITH THEIR CHILDREN, if they so choose. Kudos to Harrison Butker and Bill Maher on this.

[@Dog222gf9gt]

There was nothing wrong with what this man said!!!!

[@MartianMoon]

The major irony is all of the goofs complaining about this will also claim to be against capitalism

[@amysill3815]

“ Ladies have had the most Diabolical lies told to them…” YES! YES! YES!

[@reaality3860]

"EVIL" can be defined as anything that separates or destroys families. We're all children of the same God and part of the same family. The very first commandment from on high was to "multiply and replenish the earth".

[@kylebalmer3396]

It's been replenished

[@reaality3860]

@@kylebalmer3396, Here "replenish" refers to the never-ending work of populating Earth with (moral) children of God, exercising integrity. Think: "Noah & the Ark".