Apollo Guidance Computer Part 28: real DSKY display works again after 50 years

[@teddymills1]

50 years later and still a cooler display than anything else today.

[@moneydriveshuman]

Verry True

[@jean-pierresteenberg]

still a cooler display than anything else today 🤓☝

[@Emma__Smith]

Click click... click click click click...click.. Music to my ears. It's such a satisfying sound!

[@russellhltn1396]

Now I want a DSKY alarm clock.

[@rtlgrmpf]

@@russellhltn1396 And instead of an alarm sound you just power on the Soyuz clock.^^ clickityclickyclick zzZZZ clickclickclick zzzZZZ cliTACKTACKTACKTACK

[@stopthephilosophicalzombie9017]

Isn't it a lovely noise? I wonder if the astronauts were able to hear that noise as well or if it was so buried they couldn't hear it.

[@Emma__Smith]

@@stopthephilosophicalzombie9017 these are the real questions!

[@stopthephilosophicalzombie9017]

@@Emma__Smith What do you think? I suspect the relays were so far behind the panels they couldn't hear them.

[@badguy1481]

I worked on the Apollo Guidance Computer software and hardware. Before that I worked on Electronic telephone exchanges. The mech charts you showed brought back old memories. Before there were sophisticated enough computers for control of equipment, we had hard wired NOR and OR gate technology to perform logical operations. Computer memories were not sophisticated enough to handle most applications (in the mid-1960's). The Apollo computer was truly unique in that it had a simple (by today's standards) core memory (called "ropes"). Those "ropes" controlled a central processor that gave instructions to the guidance and navigation system on both the Command Module and the Lunar Lander without the need for "hard wired" NOR and OR gate decision making.

[@MLX1401]

Haha, the relay modules do indeed make the display sound like a telephone exchange :)

[@thromboid]

Awesome! You're in good company - weren't Shannon and Flowers both working with telephone switching systems before basically inventing modern computers?

[@owensmith7530]

@@thromboid If you mean Tommy Flowers inventor of Colossus, yes he was a GPO engineer I believe at Dollis Hill.

[@TheBreadlord]

The first Turing complete stored-programme computer was the Manchester baby though, which used vacuum tubes instead of relay logic. Colossus was kind of a dead end as far as early computer development went.

[@owensmith7530]

@@TheBreadlord But we're now into the issue of defining what constitutes a computer. Manchester uses "stored program Turning complete" because it makes them first. The US omits the "stored programme" part so it can claim EDVAC was first. Cambridge uses "stored programme general purpose computer service" ie one with input and output because that makes EDSAC first (baby had no means of output other than reading the dots on the CRTs of the Williams Tubes). And so it goes on. They were all steps on the road.

[@bobpospick1649]

CCA wire ... just yesterday we spent a few minutes cursing at the jumper wire in the lab that refused to take solder ... no matter how much flux was added! Now I know. Thanks!

[@wonderbars36]

The fact that it used in mains cables (D-cable specifically) is baffling to me. So dangerous. I've seen it go "ohmic" like that.

[@FrozenHaxor]

We call it Crappy Chinese Aluminum...

[@BobWiersema]

Where do you buy that junk. Where I live it's been illegal to sell or use aluminum wire since the 60's.

[@FrozenHaxor]

@@BobWiersema Proper aluminum wires are still used for running power into buildings (AsXSn), it is massive in size though and requires proper termination to avoid corrosion, especially when joining with a dissimilar metal like copper, but it's cost effective.

[@wonderbars36]

@@BobWiersema Well, I don't use it when I find it, but it's sort of acquired by accident when they come with certain appliances I've purchased that use D-cables to get to the wall (US). Laptop-style power adaptors most prominently is where I've seen it. Breadboard wires? That's pretty sad.

[@vibrolax]

You need to sample that relay click sound for incorporation into the microcontroller based replica DSKY's

[@williammanganaro9070]

Great idea !!!

[@joyange1]

Great. just what we need. Another fake shutter sound for a digital camera. Another fake turn signal sound that plays out your car's speakers. Another fake telephone bell ringing sound that plays from your cellphone. When will this madness ever end.

[@Damien.D]

Simply use a real relay that sound similar and pulse it when necessary....

[@batman-cw2hd]

they should hav jus used lcd touchscreens then ther wouldnt hav been no clicking and all.

[@vibrolax]

@@batman-cw2hd Well the first LCD screen wasn't produced until 1982, 20 years after the electronics for Apollo were designed. And the brightness and contrast of the early LCD's were quite poor.

[@emgre]

This is the most satisfying display I have ever seen. The colour, the brightness, the clicking sound, the "animation" to get all the segments properly lit. A marvelous piece of engineering!

[@z06rcr]

Great ending..not just the relays clicking.. but listen closely and you can hear the high frequency tone of the EL display change in volume as more digits light up..Very nice.

[@CuriousMarc]

Indeed, it does that. Fine ear you have!

[@TubeTimeUS]

literally the week after we filmed this, i was at work and ran into issues that turned out to be caused by CCA jumper wires. awful stuff.

[@MRichK]

Is it just for fraud? What is the point of CCA over just Aluminum wires if the copper is so thin it make not difference? The degradation would seem to make it unusable over time.

[@acmefixer1]

The copper coating is to prevent the aluminum from oxidizing when the air hits it. Aluminum wire is a fire hazard when you use it in house wiring. If I find any of it, I make sure it's never used, it gets recycled.

[@compu85]

I always wondered why some of my jumper wires just didn't work... I've started beeping them out before I use them.

[@johndododoe1411]

An older version of CCA was approved for house wiring decades ago. It had thicker copper cladding, but didn't succeed commercially.

[@TheEmeraldMenOfficial]

@@MRichK Aluminum oxide (Al2O3) is downright explosive in certain conditions, and if memory serves it is often used as the fuel for SRBs as the results of its combustion are comparatively nontoxic. An example of this is the Ariane 5’s boosters.

[@_..---]

"lots and lots of relays" and yet still an understatement, cool video man

[@cuteswan]

As a little kid I thought our electroluminescent night lights were the neatest things with their eerie glow, like the older unit's bluish color. Now, despite making me think of moonlight on a summer night, they don't hold a candle to the beautiful intricacies of how this whole system operates. Thanks for the thorough video.

[@TobyAsE120]

"The dude next to him is TubeTime" I literally cried out in excitement!

[@graemedavidson499]

The quality of engineering, ingenuity and even the fit and finish of the AGC systems is astonishing.

[@povertyspec9651]

Especially considering that they were under immense time pressure.

[@1959Berre]

I was 10 years old when Armstrong and Grissom landed on the Moon. It is barely believable how sofisticated and how robust the AGC was, over 50 years ago. The dedication of those engineers and technicians was amazing.

[@littleloner1159]

My dad (in Germany) and his friend built their own cardboards rocket and almost jumped out of a height wise third story balcony to fly to the moon haha They thankfully got caught just in time but it's amazing to me how impactful these moon landings were at the time Wish I could've been there its hard for me to imagine how it must've been

[@RCRadioShow]

Armstrong and Aldrin. Sadly Gus Grissom perished along with Ed White and Roger Chaffee in Apollo 1 fire in 1967.

[@leandrolaporta2196]

Man, the clicking of the relays is absolutely gorgeous, I love that thing, the quality is amazing specially for 1960's tech OMG!

[@Bob_Burton]

That relay logic is beautiful. I would have been very proud to have been the person who worked that out

[@gregkrekelberg4632]

Marc, you have some of the most eclectic stuff in your lab: An OS/2 box on the table and then a Marlburo box under the table. Congratulations to Carl and the crew, what a cool piece of history!

[@tim_bbq1008]

The more I know, the more I know I don't know. Thanks Marc

[@rtchrg440]

Absolutely outstanding Marc - really cool seeing a genuine DSKY come back to life!

[@rpavlik1]

That is amazing to see. Way brighter and crisper than I would have expected.

[@youbecha64]

It just keeps getting more and more complex and innovative as you dig down into the tiniest parts!

[@LauwersFreddy]

If they needed that much hardware to light up the display, one can see why the spacex crew dragon is so roomy. Amazing times we live in. Thank you for making these videos!

[@compwiz101]

I still find myself impressed by how utterly *sharp* that display is

[@greendryerlint]

That display is beautiful and more legible than most anything manufactured since then.

[@siberx4]

Your comment about the blue-green colour playing tricks on the cameras and your eyes is interesting. I've recently bought some deep red LED flashlights (for astronomy; the redder it is, the less it ruins your night vision when stumbling around in the dark) at 660nm, much redder than the usual 620-630nm red you'd get in a "standard" red LED. What's most interesting is that while the 660nm LED lights do seem pretty blood red when you turn one on, what you notice even more is how decidedly *orange* a regular red LED looks immediately after viewing the very deep red 660nm ones. It's like your eyes suddenly notice "oh! things really _can_ be that red!" and your brain suddenly shifts all other colours slightly up the spectrum to compensate. The effect goes away after a little while, but very fascinating to see.

[@nonono285]

That really is a beautiful display, there's something about it's quality and color even through video. Fantastic.

[@Gazdatronik]

EL displays are so beautiful. The ones in the 1966 Dodge Charger were equally crisp and wonderful upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/b/b8/66ChargerDash2.jpg

[@andymouse]

Bloody CCA Dupont wires, if a pound for every wire problem I have chased I could buy the entire space program !...cheers.

[@shaanee]

I love the relay sound .... its amazing that it holds up today.

[@smakfu1375]

Wow... that relay clicking in time to the DSKY screen, I could watch that for hours.

[@GingerNingerGames]

This thing is beautiful, sight, sound, function, form. It's got it all.

[@pjineurope3941]

It's amazing that these Apollo videos keep coming. Each video lighting a different angle on the matter. I'm very much intrigued, indeed. Greetings from Belgium :)

[@programorprogrammed]

What a legend Ben is!

[@jimmyzhao2673]

These DSKY modules are a work of art. Those relays made such a satisfying clicking sound.

[@sircompo]

I can't imagine how devastating dropping that display must have been. Also, love that cat clock at 30:00!

[@CuriousMarc]

This sure was annoying. But this was nothing compared to the joy of being able to demonstrate the working AGC to its creator, Eldon Hall, in person! (and I love the cat clock too!)

[@paulstubbs7678]

@@CuriousMarc I had to rewind to check out the cat

[@beck3k]

That logisim schematic easily put a smile on my face!

[@gloverelaxis]

the constrast is just so incredible. what a beautiful piece of technology

[@djohnsto2]

Amazing! It's extremely visible and clear with the room lights on, and not too bright with the lights off. And yeah CCA speaker wire - When you strip it and twist it, the fibers fall apart in your hands and little fragments go everywhere. The thought of that carrying mains voltage is terrifying.

[@ShainAndrews]

Oh the comparison to you tube shorts vs tiktok. Spot on... so very very spot on.

[@tamberp]

There is something so satisfying about listening to relay logic chittering and clicking away!

[@lutzweb]

your job and expertise is amazing, as a computer scientist and system engineer this is oustanding to see and understand what they did to land man on the moon and you to recover this from blueprint

[@AndyH2O]

This is great. Lovely. And particularly fine clicking, I could listen to that all night.

[@rbmwiv]

Looking at all those same color wires makes me thankful for color coded wiring.

[@marklimbrick]

That relay clicking sound is the kind of thing set designers on movies never think of. The contacts would have a limited number of cycles, but enough to get on the moon and back safely. The thing about just doing an audio sample is it depends on which segments are on or off at any one time, they are all slightly different contact/release times!

[@CuriousMarc]

Relays are much more reliable than you’d think. They got perfected for many many years for telephone exchanges that demanded very high reliability.

[@stopthephilosophicalzombie9017]

15:28 "Mechanical memory"(memory capacity of one bit). That's one of the more interesting ways to refer to an on/off switch I've heard lately. Spoken like a true computer scientist.

[@hernancoronel]

At 27:00 OS/2 Warp in the background! I worked at IBM when it was launched back in 1994 supporting it. Thanks for the video Marc!

[@stevejohnson1685]

Thanks for your work on OS/2 Warp! When it came out in 1994, IBM also provided dial-up internet access to subscribers. That inspired me to start an ISP in chronically underserved southwest Michigan. I figured if everyone I knew was willing to switch from Windows 3.1 to OS/2 Warp just to get internet access, there must be a market. I was right :-) The company, now absorbed at least twice, still exists 27 years later.

[@Ticklestein]

1:21 - hearing that sentence in that accent, thats like a ray of warm sunshine straight on the heart strings.

[@chrisd5610]

Wonderful! That SO needs to be recreated in the same form/look as a clock or weatherstation, replete with sampled but switchable/variable clicking noises and then mass-produced and marketed appropriately as the ‘’Apollo clock’. I’d buy one 😆👍

[@UOttawaScotty]

This has to be one of the best channels on KZbin

[@camhyde9701]

It's great being able to see the grain of the luminescent compound.. like medium ISO film but better... gorgeous display

[@Mach7RadioIntercepts]

Watching this, I have a new appreciation for the flight management conputer / control display units of modern aircraft.

[@trickyd499]

This is the nerdiest video I have ever seen, i really enjoyed it, keep up the great work

[@TEK-Vectors]

Fabulous!! incredible video - thanks for reliving the 1969 lunar landing computer interface! Wow!

[@binarydinosaurs]

Amazing, something I never thought I'd see when I was growing up. Absolutely love the relay noise too.

[@098765432qwertyuiop]

I understand next to nothing but I love this video, long after having seen Ben's displays. Great job!

[@drivewayhero]

Holy moly... this is fascinating and mind boggling to someone that struggles operating windows 10.. and thinking how this was done decades ago... wow

[@biz0r07]

oh man that clicking...I wish I could have a display like that...so beautiful, so crisp...and I love the sounds

[@v1rotait23]

I'm sitting here at home by myself with a silly grin on my face saying to myself, "wow!" That is just so cool you guys got these amazing marvels of real NASA 60's relay "memory" and screen technology going. Just superb wire-wrap content for a techno geek radio technician of 28 years, who wished he could have been an astronaut. I just love this stuff, but I have no personal memory of any space flight missions as I was only 4 when Apollo 11 flew, and here in New Zealand, we had limited B&W TV, although my dad built our first B&W TV set, but I can't even remember that. I have really enjoyed this series on restoring a real AGC system! Forever grateful, David.

[@grubboy3514]

Loved the ASMR whisper at the end Marc 🤣🤣🤣

[@lexihaley2887]

This

[@retrofitter]

I know, what a nice touch. The sound has dynamic range like classical music

[@MikeKobb]

30:55 - one of my computer hardware classes I ended up doing poorly on a lab assignment because *one* gate on a 74LS-series quad gate chip was bad. It absolutely never occurred to me that that was possible. Finally a TA helped debug it. I learned a great lesson from that. Fortunately, I’m old enough that crappy Chinese CCA wire wasn’t a thing yet, or that probably would have bit us as well!

[@pixlot]

those relay sounds are sooooooo calm and relaxing 34:30 Im making a mp3 loop to help me sleep.... precious

[@Sir_Uncle_Ned]

Those relay clicks are truly amazing. I'd imagine they would raise some concern aboard a spacecraft which is why they were insulated, but down here they're very zen.

[@MRCNC1967]

When push came to shove, the humble relay helped put man on the moon.

[@acmefixer1]

The humble *latching* relay! These save a lot of power since the coils do not have to be constantly energized. So a whole bunch of relays could be powered form a 9V transistor radio battery.

[@nicolemellott1983]

that relay click sound, has a very calming effect on me love it love the work you put in to bringing her back to life if i could afford one would dearly love to have a rep of the Apollo DSKY thank you for sharing

[@profwaggstaff]

Wow. That was really fun to watch. I didn’t realize they used relays. Thanks.

[@richardredcastle7911]

Love the clicking! A PCB full of them and 7 segment displays flashing in sync. What a way to make Covid lockdowns fun.

[@PINKFL0YD-s2h]

I was born in 1963(on the day JFK was put to rest) so Apollo and tec from then really resonates with me. I remember seeing the moon landing. My mother tells me that I thought it was a normal every day thing! Thanks for your videos.

[@nrdesign1991]

You have amazing friends to geek out with. Congratulations at getting the project working!

[@ArtemKashkanovLive]

incredible perfect device! I love EL displays - My next video would be about powering up the whole collection of my 7-segment, 8-segment, 19-segment and etc. EL displays. Unfortunately, all my small relays has 150V test voltage and couldn't be used here, so I selected triac optocouplers.

[@murda2999]

You guys are amazing! This is satisfying on so many levels. The color, the sound and the mad skills to put it all together.

[@campbellmorrison8540]

You guys are incredible, I recon you could have done most of the work for NASA and saved them a fortune, no need for an army of engineers :) brilliant work

[@JamesHalfHorse]

Now I want to make one even if I have to go the LED route and use it as a smart panel in my office. I want to thank you and everyone who worked on this project. This brings history alive to me as much as seeing the first step on the moon. The engineers that made it all happen is my people. True hackers of the day that just made it work when failure wasn't an option. . Keep up all the good work you do and I will keep learning from you. Your lab is the one of dreams and I now am watching quite a bit of HP test gear on Ebay. I have an RF engineer in a box that does it all but I like the individual equipment.

[@moneydriveshuman]

Big shoutout to the Real legend "Eldon Hall" such a brilliant and genius animal on this planet Earth. We can't even imagine this kind of display at that time. The technology was much much much much ahead of his time. Big shoutout to those relay modules too 😅😅😅 it's so dammnnn difficult for relay to maintain it's state when it's so much vibration out there in those space capsule or lander whatever... But see the brilliant minds made it to success.

[@dodgem259]

This Marcel person is a unique person in his own way because not only did he have 2 original DSKY screens but also the original power supply and 2 original relay modules. This man is a treasure trove of Apollo items. When NASA got rid of all their Apollo stuff, did Marcel go down with his tool kit and start dismantling stuff that he wanted hehe :). Nice one Marcel for allowing the guys to do what they did :)

[@kentuckycrittercamera9407]

Old technology like this is always fascinating to me

[@ClausB252]

In 2005 I wrote a LabView VI to model the relay logic in the 5 bit to 7 segment decoder, based on the circuit shown in the Apollo 12 Mission Report Fig. 14-1. FYI the 5 bit codes are in the AGC source code in a LUT named RELTAB in T4RUPT PROGRAM and are used in PINBALL GAME BUTTONS AND LIGHTS.

[@BorisZech]

Super! I loved the EL display on my 1980s tape deck.

[@madmax2069]

I always loved the glow of EL (also used in night lights, and Newton message pad and other stuff).

[@LacasseEric]

I thought that the DSKY they used on the set of "Apollo 13" looked great. Until I saw the real deal in this video. This looks way better! And the sound too!

[@andyhowlett2231]

That is a thing of beauty. Seven segment EL displays from 1965? Wow.

[@glennstasse5698]

Apart from the incredibly satisfying relay clicks was the comment that they found they could get by with only five relays rather than seven because some combinations would never be used. That insight and a thousand more like it got them to the moon and back.

[@stevejohnson1685]

Can you imagine the project mandate: "minimize parts and power". The savvy design engineer recognizes that only five relays are required to generate all ten digits (yay, Karnaugh maps!), and saves dozens and dozens of relays.

[@Unknown_Ooh]

Very cool! Whoever says the Apollo landing was a hoax needs to spend a solid week watching your videos. Maybe they'll think differently. You don't put this much technology so advanced for its time just to film something on a sound stage.

[@rocketmentor]

It's so nice to have sparkys that can bridge the 1060's with the 2020's, I consider myself a mechanical type who can and has hot fired antique rocket engines including the Bell X-1 engine that broke Mach one in 1947, thank you - Ken

[@joe08867]

Great job guys, very satisfying to watch and listen to. Thank you

[@c.j.1089]

That is amazing stuff. The relay box with the EL display is so satisfying.

[@donmoore7785]

That is a truly awesome display for the time period. The holy grail, finally unveiled.

[@michaelcarey]

There is something magical about electroluminescent illumination. My late 80s Realistic radio scanner had EL backlighting for the LCD display. That soft blue/green glow was fantastic. I also recall that the first few GPS navigators released by JRC (Japan Radio Company) in the early 90s used EL backlighting as did some models of rudder angle indicators make by Tokimek (TKC) I spent almost 30 years in the marine electronics industry 🙂

[@metatechnologist]

You're right, that Apollo green is fantastic. Good video.

[@VK3CSJ]

Fascinating stuff...thanks for doing the video!

[@hernancoronel]

“Relay logic checks out!”. What were you expecting Marc? Awesome video and keep up the great content!

[@CuriousMarc]

I was expecting it to work of course, but still kind of happily surprised when it did in the sim. Relay logic is really hard to follow, we run into that problem often with the IBM 1401.

[@markfrombriz]

Thats a terrific clear non flickering display even for today

[@bdhaliwal24]

Astounding job! Marvels of ingenuity like this are truly inspiring.

[@jobkneppers]

Wonderful work, wonderful video. The copper cladded aluminium is a pain and introduces unnecessary faults. Working with the breadboards you are using is a reason for other faulty behavior too. I gave up frustrated using them; they suck. Really they do. If you want to test a circuit before making a pcb; use the dead spider method; glue components who allow it with their back to a sufficient surface. Solder (!) all the copper, yes copper, wires to all of the leads and let two wire parts hang in the free air. It does look messy but there are no doubts on connections made and the system is really flexible too. Plus, another virtue of the system; if you are trying to use copper cladded aluminium wires; heads up; they don't solder... Maybe this helps development somewhere somehow... Thank you for sharing all this wonderful nerd science with us. Stay safe and be happy. Best, Job

[@williammanganaro9070]

Very enjoyable video ! Another fine production. Lucky you had a great resource for those displays and replay modules. ;-)

[@michaelmiller641]

Absolutely amazing ! Thank you!

[@RobertWood042]

Well now I want and EL display clock. That looks amazing

[@simonstrandgaard5503]

Impressive display quality. And the clicking sounds are wonderful. Great job. Love you all.

[@kevito666]

Watching the videos of yours is like living a fantasy out vicariously, keep it up. I learn so much from your hard work!

[@silverXnoise]

Such an amazing collection of institutional knowledge, innovative talent and skill, and technological personas in one place. Like the absolute Silicon Valley star he is, IQ points are attracted to Marc’s sphere of influence like celestial bodies to gravity. If some of the Xerox PARC guys happened to stop by that day I’m afraid all the smarts would have coalesced into a black hole nerd singularity.

[@ichitensho7075]

there is something cool about hearing the relays clicking around :3

[@justforfunvideohobby]

awesome episode! what a cool dude marcell was for loaning his gear! EL stuff rules. I use it all the time at my job on the Denecke TS-3EL

[@mikestewart8928]

Can confirm, Marcel is an extremely cool dude. :)

[@chriholt]

Those relay clicks are so satisfying!