Damage Model Comparison | Rally Games

Damage comparison video between WRC Generations, Dirt Rally 2.0, Dirt Rally (Modded), RBR (Modded) and BeamNG.
Timestamps
Intro - 0:00
Test 1 WRC wall hit 100km/h - 0:12
Test 1 Dirt Rally 2 wall hit 100km/h - 1:12
Test 1 Dirt Rally wall hit 100km/h - 1:59
Test 1 RBR wall hit 100km/h - 2:40
Test 1 BeamNG wall hit 100km/h - 2:59
Test 2 WRC back wheel hit - 3:54
Test 2 Dirt Rally 2 back wheel hit - 4:33
Test 2 Dirt Rally back wheel hit - 5:14
Test 2 RBR back wheel hit - 5:51
Test 2 BeamNG back wheel hit - 6:13
Test 3 WRC rolling - 6:44
Test 3 Dirt Rally 2 rolling - 7:07
Test 3 Dirt Rally rolling - 7:39
Test 3 RBR rolling - 8:08
Test 3 BeamNG rolling - 8:30
Test 4 WRC flat out - 8:59
Test 4 Dirt Rally 2 flat out - 9:33
Test 4 Dirt Rally flat out - 10:04
Test 4 RBR flat out - 10:41
Test 4 BeamNG flat out - 11:00
WRC Generations, Dirt Rally 2.0, Dirt Rally, Richard Burns Rally and BeamNG.drive.
Dirt Rally mod Whatever You Do.. Don't Crash!
Richard Burns Rally mod RallySimFans

[@glebbelyaev877]

Dirt games always makes you feel the strength of the impact

[@b.1570]

One aspect that I noticed in Dirt Rally 1 compared to the second one is the damage models used to be more pronounced. you can clearly see in 2.0 they toned down the deformation of the cars, body parts are less loose with that little scrappes on chassi. it feels like the damage model from GRID 2019 which is very dissapointing.

[@Tripokaridos22]

Also Dirt rally 1.0 has better VR and graphics on stages just compare Greece for example.

[@ezqqez717]

And it does have proper suspension and tire damage it deattach from the car when u crash also wheels look at different ways i dont remember it was in 2.0

[@wydua2049]

the video says it is modded also dirt rally 2.0 has extreme demage mode

[@Greenteac]

I have been playing rally game since Colin McRae Rally 2004. Being an irresponsible and immature teenager back then I remember having fun just trying to wreck every corner of the car like I was playing the street fighter special stage. Then life got busy until I re-pick up rally game since Dirt Rally 2.0, I also played some of the WRC game after and now EA WRC. Despite all the new graphic eye candy I always felt something was missing but was not sure what it was until I saw the damage model in Dirt Rally 1 in this video. Bumpers flying, doors dangling, and trunk lid popping... yup that was the damage model I grow up with in rally game, shame they don't do it like that anymore.

[@Kostu96]

that ripped of wheel in dirt 1, why they didn't do it in dirt 2.0, such a nice feature

[@kieranroby5955]

I agree

[@TysonRR]

Dirt rally + BeamNG realistic crash effects = perfect WRC game :)

[@Gilfoyle007]

And EA WRC is even worse.

[@jonfriktion07]

4:09 a great detail I just noticed: in WRC Generations the wheel is firstly deflated after a puncture and then rips apart. This is not the case in DiRT where the wheel just dissapears with some particle effects.

[@SirOg930]

También pasa lo mismo en dirt 2.0

[@swemx7403]

Doesn't matter, WRC Generations is still worse.

[@blairwalton4456]

Every game= our crash modelling is the most realistic and looks amazing..... BeamNG= Hold my beer and watch this

[@SunsetWaffuruBcu]

5:23 perfect scene, how the wheel rolls there

[@BioShockisAWESOME]

DiRT (2007) high speed frontal crash is heaven.

[@HayilAl-Qadhaafi-ws9of]

Dirt Rally: we have superior damage modele BeamNG Drive: do you want to die

[@Chinacommunist]

Dude I have 1200 hours on BeamNG, I love hitting a pepple and later knowing my wheels are turned inwards trying to corner.

[@spinnetti]

Beam really nails the damage, though considering everything I like Dirt the best

CMR2 menu music ❤️

[@ThisVersusThat]

🔥

[@jeanfoux]

une fusion de beamNG et rbr serait la simulation de rallye parfaite

[@tazwest6992]

I can remember me play RBR for the first time!👽😱Cote D’Abroz just starti make 300 Meter and first turn,a little bit longh…..bumm 💥guardrail and my rally is finisch!for the first moment a think wtf is this lool …..ya is real….love it!You need use your brain !Nell Dubbio Schiaccia!😜

[@melody3741]

God wrc rolling always looks so fucking weird

[@JurekBogdanowicz]

rbr was same weirdness before bee made ngp mod

[@ThisVersusThat]

Yes and the rolling in this video isn't the best but the game loves to reset mid of a rolling, so that's the best I could do.

[@MrRay168]

ive played since wrc7 and cars are still like tilting dolls. cars dont roll unless they are perpendicular to the road.

[@ireallylikerobloxrally1451]

how did you like looked in front of the car in RBR?

[@wydua2049]

Dirt rall 2.0 also has extreme mode that allows you to loose your wheels and actually makes the car break easier, it is avilable in campaign or when you create custom championship

[@boscodeluna2516]

Wrc disigners has something to learn from Beam

[@user-stanrbm]

Where is Wreckfest?

[@silverprelude7657]

funny how the older the game - the better the damage model

[@niekotokio4784]

The king of damage - BeamNG

[@mrmcprang]

11:20.... is that music from Spyro 2? :D

[@ThisVersusThat]

Yes, lol.

[@AlePadron2g]

😮😮

[@mobtastischmobtastisch8131]

can u drop the link of the dirt rally mod?

[@ThisVersusThat]

Not link but hope it helps: 1 Hrdcr Damage Model for Dirt Rally, 2 Whatever You Do.. Don't Crash!

[@urpohujanen8702]

What is the map name on 6:15

[@ThisVersusThat]

East Coast USA I think.

[@EzioG.T]

Dirt rally & Dirt rally 2.0🔥

[@user-he3is1mx4s]

and Beamng drive 🔥

[@TonyStone3000]

Why doesn't anyone talk about how much of a PITA it is to setup a controller in BeamNG?

[@p20gdnofficial]

Wrc generations damage model sucks, and it's soooo forgiving

[@ThisVersusThat]

Yeah pretty much, I really hope they're going to tweak it.

[@p20gdnofficial]

@@ThisVersusThat doubt they will do much with the game seeing as test drive is their priority now and CM holding the wrc license starting next year

[@Tripokaridos22]

Yeah but rally stages are not boring, honestly are the best ever made in amy rally game.

[@carlos1361]

if you dont put the realystic physic obvyusly the car no damanged

[@L0CALDRUGMAN]

i dont think crash physics are even important on sim games... nobody cares about the damage, physics are most important. atleast for me. would be cool to have sim with both features tho like beamng

[@daddynolegs]

You might be right for regular racing Sims, but good damage physics is really important in rally. Bumps and clipping corners and shit happens all the time in rally, and the effect it has on the car is very real. Also, not having realistic damage means that safe driving strategies are punished, while stupid all our driving is heavily rewarded. Maybe full body deformation a la beam.ng isn't necessary, but consequences need to exist for risky driving. In dirt rally, I can happily drive through a thin and windy road going 70 mph, because I know with pretty high confidence that even if I crash, if it's not head on I'll survive to make it to the next stage (doubly so if I'm coming up on a section I can repair). If I do that in rbr, I'm risking retiring from the entire rally.

[@ItsJakeTheBrake]

They are very important. Without proper damage simulation, crashes have no consequences. Having damage punishes you for careless driving. Dive bomb into a corner and clip your opponent? Well now your aero is fucked and you're going to lose at least half a second per lap. Jump over the curbs at Zolder too hard...your suspension gets wrecked and you're out of the race. Without a good damage model, it doesn't matter how good the physics are, races will be arcade(y)

[@L0CALDRUGMAN]

@@ItsJakeTheBrake agree but i dont really mean damage physics i mean crash physics. like it doestn really matter how broken the car looks because damage model is ok in my opinion

[@kayanhaider50]

Imo racing got pretty boring without risk. A sim where ur scared for ur life seems sm more exciting. Sims can’t be forgiving and without the visuals of crashes some may even be confused as to why they can’t drive properly. Beamng is easily my favourite game atm. Races feel sm scarier and it makes me a less aggressive driver. Unlike gt7 or ac(c) where I can drive super aggressively with almost no consequences

[@kak8895]

​@@kayanhaider50 100%. GT7 and Assetto Corsa doesn't bring consequences were you overheat/overrev the engine, grind gears, valve damage, radiator damage that impacts physics, engines that stall, alignments that get displaced, axles that break, drive shafts that break and the list goes on and on. BeamNG to me it the most realistic rally game right now even without pace notes. In the future when they apply proper terrain deformation for snow, mud, gravel, sand and rocks. It'll be the most complete rally/off-road game.

[@crimehole]

Going to RBR(rallysimfans) as someone who played more BeamNG and Dirt Rally, the mechanical damage and the driving physics are very realistic in RBR these days but the physical damage model really does show its age lol, when you collide with some things in RBR it can almost feel like you're kicking an aluminum can around, though the Dirt Rally games may not have as good of a driving simulation nor mechanical damage model, the weight of the cars and the impact when colliding or rolling is very believable. BeamNG is just in it's own league, but the amount of content and support for RBR just makes it so great, really impressive what the community has done with a 20 year old game.