Silent Hill 2 Remake vs Resident Evil 4 Remake - Physics and Details Comparison

[@alex0413]

Fact: James’ face is deteriorating over time, possibly signs of fatigue or continuous streess, and their hands are also getting dirtier

[@datguyphiff8255]

He also starts to grow a beard stubble.

[@smokeymcbongwater]

Just goes to show how long James was actually in that town for

[@maxmazepaaa]

leons outfit also slowly keeps getting dirtier throughout the game

[@masonyork7938]

Also fun fact his shirt gets dirtier probably because of all the combat that made him sweat

[@datguyphiff8255]

@@masonyork7938 Him going through the mine is what gets his clothes dirty tho.

[@floridianliau35]

The difference between Resident Evil 4 and Silent Hill 2 with the shooting gameplay is excellent attention to detail. Leon is a trained government agent, so the way he shoots his pistol and reloads it (If the mag is empty, he flicks it away before inserting a new one; if not, he swaps the mag with a newer one to preserve ammo) makes sense since he was taught how to use his weapons properly, whereas James is just a civilian with little to no gun training and therefore makes certain mistakes when using his pistol (putting the finger on the trigger, even when there is no enemies around; discarding his mags regardless whether they are empty or not; etc.). It goes to show how much passion the devs have for their games, even if there are some flaws in terms of the stories' writing.

[@anthonytermini2232]

You Know All Of That Makes a lot of Sense but I never I NEVER Beated the original Silent Hill 2 This will be my Very First Time Beating it hopefully but I Beated the Original Resident Evil 4 and The remake many times

[@The_Real_Raidou]

@@anthonytermini2232I am the exact opposite 🤣. I played SH 2 so much as a kid and hated RE 4 for being way to focused on action but looking back that’s the whole charm of RE.

[@SCH292]

4:27. Look at that classic gun cliche mistake that 99% of all guns in video game do. You don't need to "rack the slide" because there's still a round in the chamber. All you had to do is swap out the magazine for a fresh one. 4:31. Leon. There's a round in the chamber so all Leon had to do is swap out the mag and didn't need to rack the slide.

[@fadlankhatamiahmad1821]

​@@SCH292Yeah, thats the point of detail because James i unexperience with guns and didnt have training

[@SCH292]

@@fadlankhatamiahmad1821 Nope. It has nothing to do with James inexperience with guns. The Dev of SH 2 Remake didn't bother to do a 5 min basic gun knowledge research.

[@RJSnaiper]

Ashley: Are you okay, Leone? Meanwhile Maria:

[@adrianosarno445]

I think Maria told me once "You don't look so good" after an encounter with a mannequin in Silent Hill 2 Remake.

[@grilledcheesinator55]

Maria: 💅

[@jstandhh]

Maria: "I'm just your imagination. You die? bye-bye 💅🏻"

[@akakiiakakievich1646]

They are all dead inside in SH2

[@IslandMashup]

Maria: 🧍🏻‍♀️

[@ryedc8674]

I love the small detail at 4:50 James flinches when he pulls the trigger of an empty pistol. You can see his pistol dips down because he's anticipating the recoil. Compare that to Leon, being trained with consistent trigger pull with no flinch every trigger pull. (Edit: it was also stated in the video at 6:15) Also at 5:35, James lacks trigger discipline unlike Leon that keeps his finger off the trigger

[@THEJOHNSENAS]

Yess i love this detail too. it makes James as a regular dude (in fact he is only and office clerk) and not trained like leon

[@oui542]

​@@THEJOHNSENASThe fact that James faced and defeated all those monsters with so little experience makes him pretty cool, I must say.

[@turntoChrist_0O]

​@DARKDREAM_Xthats cuz james wife is dead..

[@That-Will-Do-It]

Just noticed that. That is crazy.

[@BucketIHead]

​@DARKDREAM_XEthan also knows basic trigger discipline despite not knowing anything about weapons

[@yahya.qasim08]

RE4 is probably more detailed but they’re both fantastic games overall

[@ZehShugugn]

They're detailed in different ways. Gameplay is more detailed in RE4, but the environment and atmosphere is more detailed in SH2.

[@B-e-a-r-d-e-v-i-l]

@@ZehShugugn I can also add the detail of psychology, both in terms of actual and horror and in its symbolisms are extremely detailed in Silent Hill 2. I'm glad Bloober focused on that

[@lifeinthehands6972]

​@@ZehShugugnnah Re4 is more detailed in both ways.

[@lifeinthehands6972]

​@@B-e-a-r-d-e-v-i-li also add gay elitism for art People.

[@B-e-a-r-d-e-v-i-l]

@@lifeinthehands6972 gay is a neutral descriptive term so what are you trying to say here? Also no elitism here. The physicality and action and being initially a horror game sold RE4, Silent Hill doesn't have that. What sells for Silent Hill is it is purely horror through and through.

[@jstandhh]

0:28 Maria: i dont care 👠👜💅🏻

[@DearAnem0ia]

"I really don't care"

[@Kretek]

In my opinion, gory dismemberment in SH would look just silly and out of place. RE is more campy. And Im not saying this in a bad way. Those 2 games have completely different focus. That is whyLeon can round kick a zombie or block chainsaw with his knife. I dont want to see this kind of stuff in SH game. And I dont want limbs of enemies exploding from pistol shoots.

[@The_Real_Raidou]

Exactly silent hill is for real phycology fear and horror. Resident evil is the full on goor fest and both work perfect like that.

[@differentsame9402]

Actually, the original developers (Team Silent) wanted to add dismemberment to Silent Hill 2 but didn't because they thought it wouldn't be accepted by kids, who were the general console owners back then before adults got into gaming. The game was already eery and dreadful as it is. I honestly believe they should've implemented dismemberment as Silent Hill is literally purgatory (Hell), thus, gruesome scenes are typical in such realm.

[@watchamigos1232]

Gore dismemberment just doesn't work if you know what the creatures in Silent Hill are. They aren't zombies or anything.....real

[@lifeinthehands6972]

​@@The_Real_Raidou Its more like "We dont have the tech level of Re"

[@The_Real_Raidou]

@@lifeinthehands6972 not really

[@alfarizasalihamizid7654]

Now Bloober team have joining the best Remakes competition like an underdog

[@silverjeyjey4054]

same company that made that horrid blair witch game lol

[@alfarizasalihamizid7654]

@@silverjeyjey4054 blair witch is blair witch, but now they have SH2 remake and it's good (props to Konami for helping and trust them)

[@holyflame2]

@@alfarizasalihamizid7654 Bloober always has the potential to make a good horror game, it's just they always fall short on it. So when they did SH2 which the blueprint is already there, it's not surprising for them to do well. Now the next challenge is their next game which is a new IP, hopefully they learn enough in SH2 Remake to finally break through their curse.

[@alfarizasalihamizid7654]

@@holyflame2 yes they have potential, they have share a statement that "they have making shitty game in the past and take a lesson from it" i hope they improve a lot

[@thebigzan]

Did they even improve anything story wise? I havent played the original nor the remake much so i cant say for sure, but if all they did was a 1:1 remake then theres is not much merit to that

[@JC-kl3uc]

00:19 you probably didn't test it well enough or it's bugged, but Maria certainly has a line for when James is on low health.

[@AqudasMoin]

yeah!! she said me while playing "YOU DON'T LOOK GOOD JAMES"

[@pyrs201]

Resident evil: action, weapons in term of details, boss fighting Silent Hill: puzzles, story, atmosphere, scare factor & music

[@Rocket1377]

Resident Evil has most of those elements too, especially in the earlier games. The main difference is that RE is more focused on combat and jumpscares, while SH is more atmospheric and story driven.

[@remejorquezelda]

Honestly its kind of different, because both atmospheres are great and vastly different from each other, i wouldn't say one is better than the other because i like the forest ambience of RE4 and the ghost town ambience of SH2. Then music is kinda meh, Serenity, The Drive, and boss theme's like Baile de la Muerte from RE4 are great and better than most of SH2 themes, it all comes to personal preference. Finally, atleast in RE4 there isn't significant jumpscares, while in the beginning of SH2 you got multiple jumpscares. Idk why people compare them tho, obviously they are survival horrors but one is an action game with bits of horror and the other is a horror game with bits of action

[@jarrygarry5316]

Silent hill is more psychological that will make players questions a lot. Especially the original silent 1-4 is pure psychological.Meanwhile Resident Evil is more sci- fi fiction horror with a lot of actions

[@LNinja96]

It is a comparison at the gameplay level, not of history or lore, here we see how the RE engine beats the Unreal Engine 5 a thousand times in terms of fluidity of movements and realism of the environment (except for the footprints it leaves in the mud, there you can see better in SH, but it's the only thing) Both are great games, but in comparison RE is much better done (it must also be taken into account that Capcom personally took care of this Remake unlike Konami delegated this work to a smaller studio). Please don't get me wrong, I love both games but things are what they are...

[@thegreentroll7152]

The fact that there are some people (Crowbcat for example) that argue RE4 remake is soulless is equally hysterical and frustrating. This video shows how much love was put into the game. SH2 remake is goated as well fyi!

[@Friendss]

One thing I really liked about SH 2 and something that RE 4 remake should have had was the noises.. like monster noises that behind you or like noises that came outa nowhere.. in RE 4 remake they toned down the noises a bit especially in castle area

[@kal-el8402]

00:26 false I got ''Are you okay James?'' from Maria when I hurt. It's little bit random sadly not common like Leon and Ashley but still there Otherwise SH II Have amazing details but mostly in game and area not the character. Also let's not forget RE4make was really high budget game

[@AqudasMoin]

yeah!! she said me while playing "YOU DON'T LOOK GOOD JAMES"

[@cristianfretes6267]

bearing in mind that Bloober Team is WAY smaller than the studio that developed RE4 Remake we can only confirm that they did a superb job and nailed every single aspect they've supposed to improve from the original game, i mean it's obvious RE4 is superior technically but SH2 is just perfect the way it is

[@AidiGamer824]

Por más que no haya jugado a SH 2 Remake, puedo decir que el juego se ve muy bien

[@alaminmdtanvir3361]

SH looks next gen not re4 lol. Re4 is just another AAA game.

[@DontE8]

re 4 looks better despite being intergenerational​@@alaminmdtanvir3361

[@tupqc2022]

​Silent Hill 2 and franchise 0 goty Resident Evil 4 and franchise 1 goty and nominations

[@thus.spoke.zarathustra]

@@alaminmdtanvir3361 if this looks next gen to you then your eyes are cooked lmao

[@jcnom6606]

with such a smaller budget too

[@lifeinthehands6972]

And using ue5 with free

[@lukabrasi001]

well, SH2 remake doesn't have half the features RE4 remake does, it shows because RE4's animations blend together fluently, the controls are more streamlined, and the animations dictate movement, not the other way around. SH2 remake is more video game conventional at it's design, but it doesn't need big budget systems in place because that is not the focus. I think RE4 remake will be talked about even 10 years from now as it's truly a work of wonder and art given how much detail they captured with the animations alone, and the feats that the RE engine can achieve

[@WujekFu]

First of all James is not a skilled special agent like Leon is so it's obvious that he lacks fighting abilities and stamina. We can't forget as well that Silent Hill 2 Remake was made on commercial UE5 when RE4 was created on custom engine made by Capcom. That explains why there's a item destruction, better colission detection and reaction to rain.

[@iroquoiskaram8639]

UE5 just looks generic as hell and I don't like it at all. Capcom's proprietary game engine on the other hand.... It looks absolutely amazing. RE 7 in 2017 looked photo-realistic and still looks that way to this day. The engine holds amazing potential.

[@agamangaming218]

Everyone will agreee that both game is best inn their own ways and both team did a great job in making this masterpiece.

[@Rocket1377]

Yes, although I think SH2 is the better remake. The original RE4 is, in some ways, superior to the newer version, especially the original Ada, Saddler, and Krauser. I think the less serious tone of the older game also suited the story better.

[@remejorquezelda]

@@Rocket1377 I have to disagree, SH2 in the original version is better than its remake in a lot of things, while RE4R is superior in almost everything compared to the original. I get the Saddler thing tho, i loved it in the og, but Ada and Krauser make a lot more sense now, they all have their special things.

[@kesunekun1531]

I don't care which one is better I love both franchises since PS2 era

[@buddyzf]

if James and Leon switch places, James would die because he's not a trained spec ops while nothing happened to Leon because Leon doesn't have trauma, guilt and regret.

[@202cardline]

Leon definitely went through some stuff, it’s why he’s like that in RE4 and not a goody two shoes. Now he’s a bingo master. (And an alcoholic in that one movie)

[@ellis8426]

Leon still have those but he's not that regretful

[@mysterycharm03]

except there is no law of physics for James 😅 He might as well re-spawn on a different time dimension

[@Terminated_Account]

In the remake James controls like an experienced person, sadly.

[@Rocket1377]

​​​@@Terminated_AccountNo, he doesn't. James literally wastes bullets. He will accidentally discharge the gun if the player is aiming it for too long without firing.

[@JediGP]

Storywise - silent hill 2 remake Physics and detailwise - Resident evil 4

[@Simbolico2024]

Silent Hill 2 Remake shut everybody's mouth, including mine. Blooper Team did such an amazing fucking job with this game. What a time to be alive and get to experience this masterpiece of a game, again.

[@violet7553]

There're both masterpieces

[@lifeinthehands6972]

Nah Silent gay 2 is garbage

[@corruptedmonk6624]

@@lifeinthehands6972 ohhh little boy is mad. Tell me where did SH2 hurt you?

[@keremkaracavusoglu4795]

@@lifeinthehands6972 bro got scared and couldn’t finish the game

[@lifeinthehands6972]

@@corruptedmonk6624 it hurt me really. With its garbage controls and combat system.The real scariest part of the game😄😄😄

[@lifeinthehands6972]

@@keremkaracavusoglu4795 wtf is scary about that dogshit? Fucking fog? Pyramid head shit? Only scary thing in the game was gameplay. Poor you sh gays are fucking minority to compare with RE's huge fanbase.

[@zombiescummy1154]

I love how they compare the both of these games they both are hella good games

[@NIGHTMARECRIPT]

Both remakes are masterpieces! I can't choose which I love more! I love both equally, and as a first time player of Silent Hill 2, I am absolutely in love with that game, and after Blooper proving they can do this, I really wanna see them do more Silent Hill remakes!

[@lukabrasi001]

one key difference to RE4 remake is how Leon uses objects around himself to support his weight when on low health, something that i've still yet to see in other games

[@llipethiago]

SH2: deep and engaging narrative, unique atmosphere, impeccable soundtrack, interesting puzzles, complex characters, multiple endings and interpretations...a masterpiece

[@shandilesmanahidayat7131]

They're both great.

[@fajar4741]

Environment and interactable objects are so alive in RE4R

[@muhammadfebry350]

In my opinion... The result is a draw, because both Silent Hill 2 Remake and RE4 Remake have their respective wins... I'll make it simple.... For me, Silent Hill 2 Remake wins from realistic characters.... Yeah, we can see that from Leon and James' faces... (Seeing James' face reminds me of the engine from the CGI series RE - Infinite Darkness) which is super realistic. While RE4 Remake Wins From Realistic Movement And Realistic Detailed.... A little example... In RE4 Remake... After we use the knife... Leon will return the knife first to his knife belt... then take the gun that we will use... But I Think... Because RE Have More Experience In Remake Than Silent Hill.... RE Try To Learn Mistake From Game Before.... Or Just Because This Is Remake From RE4... Which Is The Most Successfull Game... So Capcom Was Very Careful And Made RE4 Remake Very Detailed😂

[@THEJOHNSENAS]

Could possibly true, SH2 Made by small developer (bloober team) and this is their first big title game ever i mean maybe in the future they Will improve the physics etc when they making another silent hill game

[@phillystevesteak6982]

... ... ...

[@eliasmoreno9933]

Personajes realistas? León y ashley literalmente existen en la vida real, mientras que James sólo se creó su cara

[@TheMenaceHimself666]

Just the fact that James is shown to be getting tired over time is a huge attention to detail idk the span of this dude going to save his wife is but the dude doesn't sleep at all not to mention the dudes gotta kill monsters and run for his life the whole time the only thing I can say is they took a different approach by making James look more innocent where as in the original with the key scene the girl kicks it and James calls her a brat in the og he's like a cop pretending to be nice and then flips his mask whenever he is put on the spot or judged in the remake u can tell he's kind of different and way less obvious

[@TheKyleAye]

Both are great but I'd say SH2R wins because even though there's more details in RE4R, bloober is a much smaller team that was able to pull off such a great game with what they had. When you think about it it's not really a fair comparison but Bloober still held their own.

[@lifeinthehands6972]

Smaller team😂😂 Thats not make Sense Re4R Stomps this garbage

[@MoeE3999]

​@lifeinthehands6972 your opinion 🚮

[@lifeinthehands6972]

@@MoeE3999 you and a bunch of gays opinion💩💩💩💩💩 Re4 destorys this shithole. And fucks yours too.

[@holyflame2]

They're still using UE5 which is now far superior to the already aging and outdated RE engine.

[@theraiden9631]

​@@holyflame2 Knife will be a knife, regardless the age. But not when it comes to the user, human.

[@blackendgun5738]

05:25 Now imagine with the HAIR STRANDS option enabled, crazy

[@H.2.O.]

When I was walking through the city with Maria, I shot through the window, and she said: "Aaah, you scared me!"

[@thamielfatehy48]

Props to bloober team. I played RE4 OG/Remake, and of course Silent hill 2 OG and remake. Both gave me the best gaming hours and disconnection, feels like them old days when you just *Live* in the game

[@lordofnutmeg]

Love that little nod to SH2 in the RE4 remake

[@robertkenny1201]

I hope they Remake Code Veronica someday.

[@kingplaya6558]

Same and not give it the RE3R treatment

[@phillystevesteak6982]

Personally I want a Dino Crisis remake.

[@oswaldoojeda545]

They are doing all of those games, also a Captain Commando game Source: my head lol I really hope all those games come out some day soon

[@Progibator_2003]

RE5 Remake better

[@franciscobutte]

Both are remakes masterpieces but I must give more credit to Bloober team, they had a more difficult job.

[@matthewscorner2990]

Seems like Silent Hill focused its immense detail on the environment and how it behaves and Resident Evil focused more on the character models and physics of it all. Both games have a good level in both, but each does lean a bit more to one side than the other. Also, Capcom has been perfecting its RE Engine ever since 7, where Bloober only had Unreal to work with. Still a good engine and most of Silent Hill 2 still looks phenomenal, but I imagine Capcom knows better how to get the most out of their own engine than Bloober does from an engine they don't contribute to. And it shows in just how far the lighting, reflections, and hair physics have come. The fact that Silent Hill 2 Remake even comes close to Resident Evil 4 Remake's level of quality is impressive given Bloober's reputation and budget. It makes me hopeful for if they decide to try remaking the first game. Which I've been arguing should have been their first remake instead of 2, but whatever.

[@jorgeferreira2947]

The big storm in the village was nerfed very badly by the fans, there's almost no rain after the day one patch

[@diptomubin]

maria: Im just a chill guy.

[@im.xanadu]

Both these games are both perfect in their own ways.

[@blackendgun5738]

That script: "Are you all right" , "Yeah not big deal" isn't from a low heatlh status tho

[@Bonbonbon739]

The body dismemberment of enemies in silent Hill, two wouldn’t make sense because they will often get back up and that is the fear.

[@mystyc9]

I love both game!

[@Trastor_non]

The dismemberment occurs more in RE4 because it is a physical torture that Leon must endure, while in Silent Hill 2 it is more psychological and James is tortured mentally not physically.

[@shushetumare9835]

we have to wait SH3 remake for more details I guess

[@phillystevesteak6982]

I rely would prefer SH4 since that's a game with a lot of potential but also fatal flaws in execution. A remake is an opportunity to realize said potential. Whereas SH3 is already a rock solid entry

[@ooplycrossing2744]

@@phillystevesteak6982Yeahh then they could release 1 and 3 after

[@alphadrewaz88]

They're both amazing. Played the originals when they first came out, both remakes are perfect. Wish we could've had these graphics 20 years ago, these kids are spoiled.

[@phillystevesteak6982]

Definitely not perfect. I could list dozens of reasons why. But just to throw any random example, why can't I kick doors anymore in re4r - and time it tactfully to slam multiple enemies? One of the more fun and commonly used mechanics of the original

[@Yoru08806]

@@phillystevesteak6982 you can actually, its just harder to do now

[@phillystevesteak6982]

@@Yoru08806 how... I own the game and honestly don't know what you're talking about

[@Yoru08806]

@@phillystevesteak6982 its just way harder to do in the remake but you can kick thru doors

[@phillystevesteak6982]

@@Yoru08806 lies...

[@1angelicdemon1]

i kinda want to see a mod of leon from re4r to both kick and suplex enemies in silent hill 2 world/environment with the re4r enemies and silent hill enemies together. i like the creepy atmosphere with familiar power and gameplay of leon

[@MaRaMa-ARTZ]

Now do it with Alan Wake 2! Silent Hill even has a Lady of the Light!

[@LivncA_Dis3]

You can't compare capcoms world class team compared to the newly high rised bloober team, This was their big first breakthrough while Capcom has been masterclass back to back with re2 and re4 Re3 was developed by another studio sadly So Capcom should've rereleased the re3 remake director's cut made by them

[@raymonttorwell6440]

3:05 por que no veo a nadie mencionando lo del reloj? cuando llegué a esa parte del video fue la cosa más curiosa e inquietante que vi, las manecillas incluso marcan tiempos similares, no creo que sea coincidencia, que buen guiño xd.

[@bullymaguire7992]

the reason james shows no reactions to certain stuff is that its all his imagination and hes hallucinating hes basically sick

[@zevac]

while, silent hill 2 looks really good. I knew I wasn't crazy for being unimpressed when I saw the gameplay reveal. My expectations were set too high after RE4 Remake

[@ephpro9653]

Also, James would hold his breath when he first take away the cloth which covering the jukebox machine because of all the dust coming off, that was super impressive.

[@anagonjinwalker2746]

The power of Netizen can destroy everything, Next time the dev team must learn some details from another game before they released their game anyway 😂

[@Sephybcn]

They are different games with different budgets. Besides, I wouldn't like to see a Resident Evil style Silent Hill, and Silent Hill 2 remake has managed to give it that touch of terror and scares, which in RE4 remake is still action, a good game but without terror

[@lunarbreeze5019]

Real time healing in SH2R makes combat much more tense, you can have 10 full heals but still get interrupted and killed if you misstime it. A bit silly RE4R didn't have at least a real time animation of the spray or eating a herb, even if you select it in a pause menu, even RE5 did that.

[@Rocket1377]

They tried that for RE6. Players didn't like it because it slowed down the action too much and led to cheap deaths. There are more enemies in RE than in SH and they swarm you, so being able to heal/defend yourself is more of a priority.

[@hman378]

Would make the game extremely unbalanced against you if it was real time

[@Friendss]

2:30 i think it's fair cause in SH 2 the monster just couldn't die

[@D0MJ]

8:53 😩

[@ooplycrossing2744]

Girl…

[@Monsterkogax]

Now that we put the Physics and Details in the table, let's talk about optimization and watch how SH2 falls to the ground

[@aryandigimang]

I've played all SH & RE classic and remake too. But RE still the winner Sh 2 remake is just looks more fresh because that run on next gen younger than re4 remake. That will be nothing when RE9 came out

[@LQQ.ERR0R]

Nice

[@Dandolynn]

RE4R seems like way ahead from its year as horror Third Person shooter game

[@MGOFor3ver]

There's no comparison. Bloober team did a great job, not having experience with a game of tjis caliber before. Pretty solid job.

[@tupqc2022]

No hay comparación? Dios estos fans de Bloober Team con la vista nublada

[@mark0183]

3:46 Homer Simpson

[@agamangaming218]

Also you guys gotta know that james aint profesional when it comes to ammunition but Leon is .

[@mysterycharm03]

Although RE4's engine may look better in terms of realism but silent hill puts you into a dream state. Aesthetic and art wise it's definitely silent hill remake. It has stayed grounded to the OG. And aside from the graphics, the sound design is impeccable. It really mess up your brains. There are a lot of psychological triggers in the game, it's not just about killing enemies. It's a piece of art as it has been always.

[@jonasvalencia7088]

5:27 WHY LEON´S FACE LOOKS LIKE THAT IN GAME WHYYYYY??!!!! HE LOOOKS LIKE A FROG.

[@unpequenocanal544]

Resident Evil >>>

[@andrijamilojevic4568]

anyone known the sountrack at 7:55?

[@lequinho4]

These may be minor details, but they significantly enhance the immersion in the game. Therefore, RE4 stands out.

[@albertchoo2432]

James get hurt Maria : look at u,,how pathetic 🤣

[@Priya...985]

Re 4 is a actual shooting game while sh focuses on syory line or puzzles. Both games are legendry.

[@Matiaxxx91]

I think RE4 can do more things because capcom has their own motor graphic and they master himselfs using it in a lot of games. And UE5 it looks awsome but when you want to interact with the environment it looks cardboarding. It's how the character, enemies and the world stand all be separate. But after all that I think SH2 is a masterpiece and at some point its not fair comparate him to RE4 (they are millons $ of difference)

[@piyaroq8189]

Pfft!…😅 ……they look like twins in the cover picture. 😅 Nice vid. 👍

[@Soybean13]

Silent hill win in non technical aspect like lore, story, design....while Resident evil win in technical aspects loke graphic, optimalization, combat mechanic. EXCEPT the sound design.... thats where silent hill beat resident evil

[@lifeinthehands6972]

Nah story Re4R gets it too

[@Soybean13]

@@lifeinthehands6972 what's the thing that makes you think RE4 has better story than SH2?

[@lifeinthehands6972]

​@@Soybean13 A average gamer cannot understand any fucking thing about its story becouse it is like another stephen king rip-off. You cannot understand it in the game but forums. Wtf is special about sh story Lol? İt is a basic amnesia-mental story. A mans halucunations about his wife.And bunch of fucking lore. Resident Evil 4 has 2 times bettee lore than this Lol. For each characters backstory.

[@soul_of_a_hero]

@@lifeinthehands6972 the story of re4 pales in comparison

[@illgnerricco9003]

One has GOTY, the other has HILL

[@anuj4200]

Re4 remake is a masterpiece

[@CarpetBanana]

I see they patched the heavy rain out of re4 remake and into silent hill 2 remake

[@VvenDayimXD]

im on with resident evil 4 remake because he,s a masterpiece games and also zombies physics graphics structures story line aslo better than silent hill 2

[@mysterycharm03]

silent hill's lore is definitely not for kids. It's definitely a piece of art compare to resident evil's 4 storyline, it's cliché and typical action stuff.

[@VvenDayimXD]

@@mysterycharm03 but remember R.E is Legend series ever!🗿

[@1C3_K1LL3R]

Masterpiecies

[@diegoval7240]

Re4 is better

[@MHesam.2007]

I Love Re4 more but they are both great games and they are both masterpeaces . Re4 & Silent Hill 2 ❤️❤️❤️

[@rickmalves6843]

I just want to play SH2R with more optimizations, like RE4R, but I'll keep playing even in these conditions (stutters and low fps)

[@rickmalves6843]

i think that the developers will fix it with some more patches, so i'll stay waiting

[@sim0n-h9b]

Why does James kinda look like leon

[@THAT_Maverick009]

Yeah the difference of experience between the studios are quite noticeable in some aspects, tho i think Silent Hill 2 has better graphics.

[@mortadelaruim9466]

Como duas coisas q não tem comparação podem ser comparadas? Resident evil 4 remake é anos luz a frente de silent hill 2 remake

[@nickcoyrichardson26]

RE4 is much better would love to play silent hill though

[@samurailevi49]

Ashley is annoying, but at least she cares lmao Maria just stands there.

[@the13thjoker]

Maria isn't human. In many case she causing james mental much worst.

[@TheMIBWORKSHOP]

@@the13thjoker True. She is a fragment of James' lust thought about Mary, so in this case she doesn't seem like a human to me.

[@samurailevi49]

@@the13thjoker That is very true. I just found it hilarious how she doesn’t even seem to care. Which in a way is kind of sad as it depicts how James feels about his wellbeing.

[@furynvm]

@@samurailevi49 because Mary doesn't care and isn't meant to care about James.

[@jacket2383]

@@the13thjoker Okay so that makes even less sense when she doesn't react to him being hurt.

[@javilf1281]

JAJAJA estaba tomando en serio la comparacion y salen con esas skins de lion y ashley jaj

[@jaffarhussain7256]

Silent Hill 2 Remake : More detailed.... Why ? Because you must notice James's face deteriorating because of guilt over time.

[@marchellore4]

AND? As time passes, Leo's clothes become dirtier, the plague begins to dominate his body and the sweat on his back becomes more present.

[@psychepeteschannel5500]

I have to say, to see the head clipping right through the wall on every contact is not a good look for an atmospheric, state of the art, 3rd person horror game priced 69 USD in 2024. The fact he doesnt get support from the wall is a detail, but to have your character visibly clip half of his head into the wall in a game where you often have to move along walls in tight spaces? That is the most disappointing one.

[@notAFam69]

3:44 I can't hear it

[@Blizz247]

re isn't even scary

[@Elvaronstgo]

But what does Resident Evil 4 have to do with Silent Hill 2?

[@chan13153]

RE vs SH of course. I mean you weren't born yesterday right? RE vs SH debate goes back decades. Those series have always garnered comparisons.

[@Rocket1377]

People have always been comparing these games. When SH1 first released, a lot of reviewers said it was copying RE, due to the tank controls and fixed camera angles. Not to mention the similar weapons, health system, puzzles, and overall horror tone.

[@w.7474]

The real difference is Resident Evil 4 Remake looks the same if not better and you would get 300% more fps than Silent Hill 2 Remake

[@worlds_greatest_detective6667]

I love em both but RE4 is way superior in every category except psychological horror which SH2 excels at.

[@Eduulopez]

Los dos son geniales y punto

[@omarolvera5440]

One thing is that resident evil is in a real world, thats why characters react and things of that nature, in sh he is in hell, so characters are part of his imagination

[@SYEDaunedits]

Silent hill 2 remake looks like a 2015-16 game in front of resident evil 4 remake and silent hill 2 remake came out after resident evil 4 remake

[@bossliteyear]

You people in the comments have to be more objective. You cannot say that Sh2 wins because they accomplished more with a smaller team and smaller budget. Although its not a competition, re4r wins in every department TECHNICALLY, just because sh2's effort was admirable does not make it better than the state of the art near perfect details, physics, athmosphere and sound design that re4r has. Now, if we are talking about music, it is subjective but yes, you can argue for either game. Story? Silent hill 2 easily but anything else is 2nd place to re4r. You can argue about the more subjective things but not from a technical standpoint, re4r is a behemoth.