Does Minecraft Bedrock Actually Suck?

[@The_K-Dude]

As someone who grew up playing Bedrock, it’s definitely the more nostalgic version for me. I only really play Java, but both versions are great.

[@Razoonn]

SAME!

[@boberd]

did u used to play the old minigames?

[@MissingStripy]

It's the K-Dude!!! Whens a new video coming out?

[@donutstudios6353]

same here! in my case, i only play java now but that's just because i prefer the java 1.9 combat and i own a java server so i must play it a lot haha

[@simangameplay1180]

I would also prefer java PvP over bedrock😅

[@Ray-X78]

Honestly, I think the problem within java vs bedrock controversy is that, java players compares bedrock based from java features (and the other way around) and not as a whole different game. For example, java redstoner hate bedrock due to it lack of quasy connectivity while ignoring how easy it is to play with friends in bedrock, while bedrock players hate java due to the bridge feature differences, which I think it made the comparison in the internet kinda unfair. I play both java and bedrock, and I think both edition are great with their own pros and cons. Ofc all of these are based on our personal opinion though, and I respect your preference

[@A-Clear_View]

Bed rock you play because nostalgia, better, FPS cross platform etc. but you don’t play because it has better features you just don’t bedrock is a mechanical mess.

[@YaBoiLuuuke]

​@@A-Clear_View I play Bedrock over Java literally just because of Cross Play. It's accessibility is Bedrocks biggest feature and one that Java simply can't match. I don't care about how much better Java is from a technical standpoint if i can't play it with half of my friends.

[@SunshineRey]

As someone who does bedrock redstone, it is more than just the lack of quasiconnectivity that makes it worse. The pistons are slower, don’t retract at the same time and sticky pistons don’t spit out their block so you have more limitations just from to blocks. Then there’s the fact that the activation of certain blocks are different, like observers and rails activating on different Game ticks. Also there is the biggest problem to me and that’s the lack of consistency/priority in activation. For example, you could have a double piston extender and you need to activate them perfectly cause if you activate them at the same time they will randomly fire and possibly even break the system if one fires wrongly where on java, the game has consistent priority for the firing so you don’t have randomness unless you wire it in certain spots.

[@FireroseNekowolf]

Tell that to Mojang, they're the ones pushing the hardest that it's the same game with their insistence on this parity nonsense

[@megas0xlr]

@@SunshineRey I once read a comment by someone on Reddit that said " java edition redstone is like 2+2=5 ,but redstone on bedrock edition is 2+2=4 sometimes 3 and occasionally 8

[@genkia87]

The fact I can play with people on various devices sells me on bedrock more personally. I hosted a session on my PS5, had a friend on Xbox One and another on PC join and we all had a blast! Not being restricted to one versions specific servers goes a long way when you just want some buds to group up and build/mine with.

[@jonathanmordekovich9258]

It took some mods, but I have a Java server that bedrock players can join. It's working really well. Geyser and floodgate are magical

[@12bang]

@@jonathanmordekovich9258 do the bedrock players have java combat

[@jonathanmordekovich9258]

​@@12bangyep! Sweeping swords and attack cool down both work on bedrock. It shows them a line of dots for the indicator.

[@FlazeFly]

@@jonathanmordekovich9258 omg can you tell me the code I'm super good at pvp in bedrock but my friends who play on java think its only cause i spam :/ so i want to prove them wrong with those mechanics so can you send me the code so i can have java pvp

[@GamingWithNathan-bz6cg]

tell that to the essential mod devs

[@pvzgamer9718]

honestly I don’t think Minecraft bedrock sucks, it’s just mechanically different due to the different coding elements. either way both are great versions but I prefer Java because of the modding scene.

[@terpure]

im among e

[@SassyNymphet]

me too, i prefer bedrock in general. it looks better, it performs better, to me its better to play. java editions performs worse, it doesnt have very good graphics, but again i prefer it for modding. :)

[@SassyNymphet]

so, bedrock is better for vanilla gameplay, but i ike java for modded experience

[@_LGD]

@@SassyNymphetJavas graphics can be way better, but they’re more demanding than bedrock’s

[@creeperkiddd]

I only really play bedrock and I can confirm that java is better for mods but in my opinion bedrock is better overall because you dont need to create a server to play with your friends you can just join them.

[@TheChosenGamer_TCG]

Bedrock is always what i grew up with including pocket editon, and legacy editon for consoles. Bedrock doesnt suck, its just not the best and thats ok.

[@kengamezph3509]

True bro, bedrock is so cool even though they hated it

[@thebluehero7319]

legacy console edition is not bedrock. It was made specifically for the consoles it released on, while bedrock is the mobile version ported to consoles for crossplay

[@Gold_Yoshi]

I think I hate it simply because, while it's a good mobile game. Legacy Console and Java are simply better version to begin with, but it replaced Legacy Console, and is trying to replace Java. That's why I dislike it

[@elechain2441]

as someone who is the same, I think bedrock is hot trash. however, i love the game because of all the memories... minecraft is minecraft

[@youssef1770]

​@@kengamezph3509dont care how many people hate bedrock i still play it and love it no matter what!!!

[@DragonGamer-ly3lf]

I wish they pollished up some important things on Bedrock. Like the marketplace not being so unorganized and hard to find offical things, more free customizable skins, pariety changes like adding the nether roof or adding back superflat world customation like on legacy console edition.

[@LuckyPedro_61]

And structures in superflat

[@Figh4ter]

I can't say that Bedrock edition sucks at all. Before starting Java, I only knew about bedrock edition. This edition gives me the nostalgia as I grew up playing this edition since 2017. I love bedrock as much as I love java.

[@gabrielwolfson182]

Same, ive been playing Pocket Edition on tablet since the Notch era

[@gabrielwolfson182]

I definitely play some Minecraft stuff on my laptop but Im just way more used to the version, the glitches add spice to it.

[@Sandyy_sandy]

me to bro i started back when the minecraft ps4 edition came out in 2014

[@Awesomeflame16]

I miss legacy console

[@ShiroCh_ID]

bedrock sucks after unification with java versioning before that, i somehow felt it has less game breaking bugs i can say that after bedrock version were same as java the bedrock team felt like they were in need to rush things up to match the java's relase window and winged the game breaking bugs with the same mentality of any modern and mmo games "we will patch it on a later date as times goes on"

[@honordummyYT]

seeing danny and reddoons in the same video made me so happy, i love the content they both make so it was really cool seeing them making something together. nice video as always danny!

[@g1tr3kt5]

As someone who has been playing minecraft since the beginning, and owns it on every single platform... I think I speak for all of us when I say. They need to take the better of each and implement it into one cohesive game, and take the bad and flush it down the toilet. There should be community votes, but not like the mob ones. Real substantial content votes. And let bedrock players have custom skins, resource packs, shaders, and mods and not have to pay for them.... If we can work as a community in Java, even though some are paid. There's absolutely no reason why bedrock cannot enjoy the same. I started off in Java in alpha, and I just find it frankly disrespectful to bedrock players to make them pay like that. Granted there are again situations where some are paid, or people dedicate themselves to it as it is a job in the realm of Java, but there are a lot who offer completely free content and would be more than happy to help bedrock players. Minecraft being the most sold game of all time, and being owned by parent company Microsoft can absolutely afford it without being greedy. I also motion that anyone making paid resource packs, texture packs, mods, maps, or content would not have to pay Microsoft a cut of their money. Hear ye, hear ye? 👇

[@IAmInYourBasement123]

yeah, also I hate how Java players think that bedrock players can't get skins and mods without the marketplace, we can upload our own skins and mods into Minecraft bedrock

[@g1tr3kt5]

@sir.master123 I have no idea where that trope even came from. Anyone in bedrock who clicks the skin thing can clearly see an upload your own skin button. 🤣😂 Even Wattles uses a random skin instead of his own when he plays Bedrock. I don't understand. Even the deferred rendering and shaders work a lot better on bedrock to be honest. My render distance is insanely higher, and yet it's less buggy for me. But Java isn't the greatest platform anymore, and Bedrock was recreated specifically for running better without Java. There's just some nuance mechanics I like better in both at times. It really just depends.

[@xoduk]

I grew up on very old Java and have just stuck with it. Bedrock isn't bad but it kind of just feels like a different game.

[@dinosharttt]

it doesnt feel like a different game you know its minecraft tf its the same thing

[@xoduk]

@@dinosharttt Nope You wouldn't understand, I also just scripted an entire randomly generated quests script with random rewards and random items. Can't do that on Bedrock.

[@dinosharttt]

it still doesnt feel like a different game if you saw someone playing bedrock you know its minecraft@@xoduk

[@xoduk]

@@dinosharttt You haven't seen my version of Minecraft... It's a rougelike fantasy RPG with RTX shaders.

[@5gld]

@@xodukpretty sure someone already did that bedrock

[@gugu5285]

Bedrock has made it so that I can connect and play with friends who dont have pcs in less than a minute. The convenience of multiplayer makes it really worth it to me, not to mention the great performance. I was a bit disappointed yesterday when I couldnt craft a Bundle, or today when i tried putting a fireworks rocket in a Crossbow but those are small enough to look over, the game itself is identical enough to bring all the enjoyment i need for building and adventuring with someone in vanilla.

[@fanOfMinecraft-UAs_channel]

I'm pretty sure I once put fireworks into crossbows in Pocket (bedrock) edition

[@HYDROCARBON_XD]

You can put fireworks on crossbows in bedrock you just need to put the firework in your left hand

[@andixpiwi8325]

With the proper mods Java can outdo everything Bedrock can. And Java isn't full of microtransactional garbage that Microsoft abuses for money.

[@theender664]

​@@andixpiwi8325performance will be always better on bedrock

[@Sean_Alberto]

​@@andixpiwi8325some java users dont even know how to install mods the playstore mods are decent and also imports it for you. plus do you think a phone can handle java's mods? No dont think so so stop hating!!

[@bargasus]

people said java was better what they didnt mention is i need to make a server instead of just making a world for my friends to join

[@JohnDavid-eq8jx]

That’s literally the only bad thing in Java, that is if you can’t make a server cuz your brain power is lower than a 7 year old

[@EmiliaHoarfrost]

Imagine opening a world to LAN

[@bargasus]

@@EmiliaHoarfrost we dont have same network

[@S1lly777]

@@bargasus use e4mc :/

[@TheMaltianRobloxian]

@@bargasus Theres other ways on Java to open to lan and join your friends even when you dont have the same network

[@The_Fracture1]

A lot of their criticisms were just "Its not what I'm used to so it's bad." I would prefer to hear what is fundamentally impossible in bedrock/what makes it objectively worse

[@Sans_The_Skeleton]

marketplace redstone random fall dmg bug (which is literally unfixable so they don’t get hardcore LMAO)

[@The_Fracture1]

@@Sans_The_Skeleton valid

[@REXae86]

Marketplace, charging for resource packs, input delay etc

[@The_Fracture1]

@@REXae86 These are valid criticisms, but I was referring to the ones in the video

[@EngiGODS358]

I've played bedrock before awhile back. And the Redstone is objectively worse. So is the combat. Bedrock's combat is quite literally stuck 10 years in the past but awful, I mean you can't even block. I will admit the bridging feature bedrock has is pretty cool but that's about it.

[@JoeTheCrusader]

Dude, Reddons is my favorite life steal creator and you're my favorite bedrock creator and the fact that you guys did a video together makes me very happy!

[@LucasBNagy]

not being able to choose gamemode reminds me of when cubecraft removed the sign clicking to select map so you had to buy rank to do it in their new menu

[@Fenyxclips]

Been on Bedrock for as long as I can remember and despite its flaws and issues (like failing to load worlds permanently), I always seem to come back to it. Even after losing three worlds I spent a lot of time in. Only one of them wasn't Bedrock but losing months of work when converting from PS4 to Bedrock wasn't easy to handle. Even the recent occurence. I was about to face the Dragon after spending months getting my armour as good as I possibly could only to be unable to log in the following day after preparing and getting some rest. Might just be the survival aspect that keeps me though. Never even touched Creative mode.

[@monarin3191]

but thats why u do backups do? Java can loose ur worlds too ^^'

[@carinaslima]

I almost never touch survival

[@cactixz]

That intro was fire can't wait for the rest 🎉

[@fussper]

😊 glad you liked it

[@TabbedOutLOL]

Dont wait

[@BucketOfOofs]

@@fussperyou didn’t even make it

[@fussper]

@@BucketOfOofs I did 😁 check description

[@Dinnerbone2254]

@@BucketOfOofshe helped to edit the video

[@Mr_Walrus_The1st]

Bedrock Advantages 1. Easy crossplay 2. Better wither 3. Auto block-placing mechanics 4. Optimized for performance (You can fit many more players on bedrock servers, and slow devices can run the game easily.) 5. Easy multiplayer games function. 6. Easy add friend function. 7. Better command blocks. Bedrock Disadvantages 1. Low mod support (This is the main reason Java is preferred to Bedrock) 2. Hard to join servers that aren't featured 3. Not as many servers support bedrock 4. Very young community (This is another large reason that Java is preferred to Bedrock) Note PvP is different in Bedrock, as is Redstone. Some prefer Java PvP, while others prefer Bedrock. Likewise for Redstone. There are many other differences that I did not list.

[@IAmInYourBasement123]

this comment should be top, also the wither on Java just feels like a mob with high health, while on bedrock it feels like a real boss fight

[@Shady_Inktail]

A lot of these are completely true, coming from a Java player. However, I must disagree with the performance point simply because a friend has the Switch version and trying to render chunks on that is abysmal, even on low render distances. I played Java before the combat got changed, and I do still prefer the new combat. In my own opinion, it feels more skill based, whereas Bedrock still had no big reason to use an axe over a sword for combat. Also, why can you still not hold everything in the second hand?? I've always been torn on the idea that Bedrock bridging was intended to be a compromise for console edition movement limitations (ie using a stick to move the camera vs a mouse, which takes longer and isn't as precise), and still think it kind of is. I like the concept of that bridging type, but it doesn't match how the rest of Minecraft works. If you can't see the block face, you can't place a block. Yeah, I really wish we had the tick delay feature of command blocks, and being able to put a name tag above them to see what they do without interacting. That'd be nice. Also it may be that I started with Java edition, but I personally cannot fathom how anyone plays using a controller of any variety or touch controls. It feels really weird to me. The best thing they can really do is start hammering down on parity between versions of the game. As a Java player, I COULD say just carry over the Java side of things to Bedrock, that even that's not ideal. It needs to be deeply decided which features are made to be parity for the other version, or a compromise between differences. I said that I prefer 1.9 combat, but it should still have been a gamerule to use either or. That way, servers like Hypixel could actually update to the newest versions and not need a plugin to allow players from other updates to join. It's not the worst thing in the world, but overall I still think Bedrock does suck.

[@Dep.3071]

Bedrock wither literally sends you to afterlife once you put the wither skull in 0.01 millisecond

[@carinaslima]

@@Shady_Inktailtrue

[@Menvix]

​@@Shady_Inktaili only seeing switch bedrock performance is bad

[@andMango1]

I personally like bedrock more than Java. The 1 thing that really annoys me is when people say “YoU hAvE tO uSe ThE mArKeTplAcE and mIneCoiNS.” Like no you don’t, you can literally use the Internet, the marketplace is optional.

[@SunSh1neFN]

Wait really? You can gets free data packs?

[@andMango1]

@@SunSh1neFN yes, use any internet browser

[@ExStrayz]

ofc@@SunSh1neFN

[@sleepiestsleepy.]

pc and mobile can use the internet, sadly console cant.

[@Lexi-yc7sy]

The only reason i used the marketplace as a lil fellow was because 1. I couldn't get into files cuz i was on KiNdLe FrEeTiMe or whatever. When i became 13 (it was a godsend) i could finally not have to pay my chore money to get furniture in minecraft. I still use bedrock to this day. (i use it on my computer though)

[@WspDanielYT]

Truly a masterpiece Danny this video was indeed so inspirational yet so well made keep up the fantastic work Danny!! :))

[@Person123peopleperson]

Your cool

[@engieee]

Hmmm, you look like you know a certain fair rose or subbylmao… cause if your profile picture

[@goawqebt6931]

So Inspirational and* so well made

[@LandonHo-cc6kx]

Bedrock edition is good❤❤❤❤❤ Java edition sucks and is GA!!!

[@SpiritOfTheGalaxy143]

10:00 use the 3x3 door on the trial chamber, its 1 block thick, works on bedrock and java and cant be broken by spamming... Also has cool lights

[@UltraCenterHQ]

The problem is, people who didn't even play Bedrock keeps complaining about "Microtransactions" even though the Marketplace is *completely optional.* Like we can't just enter the files and put in Texture Packs, Skins, Worlds, and Addons. I played since 2013, and I haven't even touched the Marketplace ever since it was added. It's like me complaining that Java is filled with Microtransactions because of REALMS. (And it actually has more impact on the game than the Marketplace)

[@monodoe761]

FAX

[@tekwins]

FR AND THERES LEGIT WEBSITES THAT U CAN GET STUFF FOR FREE

[@Stettafire]

Microtransdactions are almost always optional. Thatr doesn't make them ok and not predatory.

[@UltraCenterHQ]

@@Stettafire you can always ignore them, dawg. Most people are talking about it in a gameplay point of view

[@Eemil10]

What is even realms,i do my own servers,and its easy

[@DoctorWasabi]

gonna admit, was not expecting that ending, all in all a really decent video, well done! only thing Id comment on is the lack of attention to bedrock building & builders. Apart from that a great video! You should be very proud!

[@DannyIsDahBomb]

Main thing was honestly just the building is sooooo similar. Outside of like world edit. That's the only reason why

[@DoctorWasabi]

@@DannyIsDahBomban understandable opinion though from my experience, bedrock gives builders things like structure blocks and light blocks as compared to java, a neat way to compete with computerised building systems, absolute godsend on console or other platforms that make up the majority of bedrock.

[@bluealt4936]

@@DoctorWasabi structure blocks are so good in bedrock, like command blocks on bedrock more too

[@plighting_engineerd]

@@DoctorWasabi java has light blocks as of 1.17

[@DoctorWasabi]

@@plighting_engineerd that comment was in relation to console users and the Use of integrated tools for those players as compared to Java players and the multitude of building tools like world edit, survival schematics and such that they have

[@Wyatt07]

Tbh, its just people see bedrock with a java player POV, so they just compare what java has with what bedrock doesnt

[@theninjamaster67]

I mean you could compare it to other games and a lot of the problems would still be problems compared to other games like the crappy modding.

[@beefonwec]

its the other way around too

[@thomasmacdonough288]

Not really, it doesn't matter how you look at it. From any perspective Bedrock has always been rather janky and buggy. I started with Bedrock and I play almost exclusively Bedrock and even I will admit that it can be a bit of a hot mess.

[@d1nodray]

There's also an entire subreddit called "bedrock moment" showing off the numerous bugs that, in reality, are why it sucks.

[@ventglatormmos669]

@@thomasmacdonough288that’s unfortunate that you had that experience. I’ve been playing bedrock for years and never not once have i had a bug or use with the quality of the gameplay. And I’ve played both java and bedrock for a fair amount of time and yet i still prefer bedrock

[@DeMooniC]

Bedrock is not that bad, but here is the thing. If you have 2 games that are almost the same, but one is better at more things than the other, what game would you play? In Java you have more options since you can switch to old versions if you don't like something of the new ones. 1.7.10 for certain mod packs, 1.12.2 for other mod packs, 1.0 por a classic MC experience, 1.8.9 for PVP, 1.16.1 for speedrunning, 1.18/1.19/1.20 for an updated and more complete survival experience or also for other mods that are not available in older versions, etc. In bedrock, you are stuck in the same goddamn version, there are no mods (pretty much), you have to play a lot of times against mobile players while you are on PC whick makes things too easy and boring, redstone is buggy af, the disgusting marketplace... The only thing I like about bedrock over java is the performance when it comes to chunk loading speed and range for the most part, however, you can get almost the exact same performance and chunks with java mods such as sodium and distant horizons. If this wasn't enough, if you REALLY want something in java that bedrock has but java doesn't, there's a mod for it. But if you want a java thing in bedrock... There's no way to get that. Bedrock simply lacks the freedom that java gives you. No f3 menu, no proper mods, the few good "proto-mods" there are are PAID (and they aren't really mods, they are maps with remodeled mobs), no hability to downgrade version, less variety of servers, more censorship, etc. Java is just objectively better than bedrock and the only reason to play bedrock is if you don't have a PC or want to play with friends that don't have a pc... Except oh wait, there are plugins for java servers that allow bedrock players to join lol.

[@losaventurosdepabloypabla]

Do yo know that we can download maps on bedrock for free too ? I discover this a couple of months ago.

[@hivijivi]

i dont understand why people think the only way to get mods/addons/maps/skins in bedrock is by paying in the marketplace.

[@DeMooniC]

@@hivijivi Maybe not the only way but afaik the best stuff is there and is paid. I know about the addons but last time I checked they are very simple and there's very little of them because it's way harder to make actual mods (addons) for bedrock compared to java. In java, 99.9% of all mods, maps, texture packs, skins, etc. are free. Not even exaggerating. And the java mods are hunderdeds of times more varied complex and higher quality too because there's a very well established modding community and platform.

[@FighteroftheNightman]

​@@DeMooniCwheb your biggest argument for why one game is better is bc you can change it that means the game isn't better.

[@DeMooniC]

@@FighteroftheNightman Freedom is better yes, sorry to dissapoint you. Keep on crying lol

[@bralexanicofficial2]

If people get bored of bedrock, just play java, or better yet any other game just as a break. People rip on bedrock for all the wrong reasons just because they only play one game Also great video danny probably my favorite yet

[@thatrandom_canadian]

Java is for when you want to play Minecraft. Bedrock is for when you're being forced to play it because of that one friend that doesn't have a PC, or if you _are_ that friend that doesn't have a PC.

[@ItzFlame79]

Both versions have their ups and downs. what reddoons said was right. The only thing that matters is what YOU think, not other people’s opinions

[@ZeroXStrange]

Me right here i like both bedrock and java, think both of them grew up together and have their difference. Sometimes there are angry debates about both of them but in fact i like bedrock the way it is. Anyways, awesome job danny. This video was really worth watching. Just found your youtube channel. Nice to know you!

[@aben5998]

The 11 Obsidian in that chest were paid actors

[@PeaceplayzYT]

Honestly this was one of if not the best video you have ever made. The editing was amazing and it was a really good idea. You did a awesome job danny

[@adventureswithlennox437]

As a bedrock player I think it is nice to finally see some bedrock content what a amazing video

[@zuioycerone]

true

[@vaelegoro7782]

5:00 baby has to rely on a dev tool he technically shouldn't even have access to in the first place

[@Razoonn]

I know someone else made a comment similar to this, but I grew up with Bedrock edition. I too also only really play Java, but Bedrock has amazing pluses which make both the editions awesome. Bedrock edition doesn't suck. There is enough reasons Bedrock deserves more love. Danny is honestly one of the best people who just shows how amazing it is.

[@SkullnSwag]

Bedrock somehow still can't afford auto sprint

[@Razoonn]

LOL@@SkullnSwag

[@TheMaltianRobloxian]

[@JonBoy707]

5:00 wtf how is that wierd for bedrock?! Java is the one that lets you BREATHE UNDERWATER WITH A LITERAL DOOR

[@Jagion_studios]

exactly what i said to myself also i find it weird that derpled thought bedrock sucks and didn't give a reason i think the bridging is a lot cooler in bedrock and takes skill to pull off i think java players just hate bedrock because they are not java features f it was swapped it would still be them hating on the other version for having different features

[@JDTplaysMC1]

i agree that bedrock edition doesn't suck but as a bedrock player myself I can confirm that the bridging definately doesn't require skill@@Jagion_studios

[@beefonwec]

yall can just look into the sky and bridge 💀 you can’t be screaming about something like this

[@skelerpupis2447]

I remember bedrock also let you breathe underwater with doors until they patched it. Then you were kinda able to do it with torches, but then they patched that too, idk why tho

[@HornCompany]

@@beefonwecthen yall can shutup and enjoy the game

[@8_BLOODxGAMING]

4:25 bro took "bedrock edition into a block of bedrock" 💀

[@torch-lyt]

ALL BEDROCK PLAYERS WE CAN NOW CRAWL WITH TRAPDOORS

[@theloafs2622]

WOOOOOOOO LETS GOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!FINALLY!!! FINALLY!!!!!!!!

[@lasercraft32]

Bedrock and Pre-Java 1.9 combat feels so nonsensical... I know there's _some_ skill and strategy, but it certainly doesn't _look_ like there is. It looks like frantic flailing.

[@Napoleon_e2]

interesting so if you compare java's pvp with the old pvp everyone says the old pvp is better but all of a sudden, as soon as bedrock enters the question it is objectively worse

[@lasercraft32]

@@Napoleon_e2 You see that's the problem... I'm not "everyone." There is no "everyone." Just because a lot of people think old pvp is better does not mean everyone does. I've hated the sentiment that 1.8 pvp is better from the very start (I literally said "Bedrock _and Pre-Java 1.9"_ so I have no clue what you're getting at).

[@niflheim1-0]

​@@lasercraft32you do know that the reason they didn't add that combat in bedrock is because of how controversial the update was right? So calling it "objective" is a dumb sentence

[@christopherpaulson4591]

4:54 The Java door air bubble seems weird to me lol

[@chqsrz]

Awesome video danny i love the collabs

[@JuppeD]

Best way to put it Play bedrock if you want to play survival with friends Play Java if you have a computer that runs good Play bedrock if you have a bad computer Play Java for better and smoother gameplay (if you have a good computer) Play bedrock for more content as in being able to move chests with pistons Play Java for the potential to get more content as in mods

[@Flameyboi_YT]

You dont need a good computer to run minecraft java

[@pixel_shard666]

​@@Flameyboi_YT but you might need some optimization mods, wich is my case.

[@groonthewonderdog966]

Good video. Boils down to what your used to. Like our phones, when we get a new one, even same brand and series, we notice and get peeved by small things that are changed/different that casual phone users rarely notice. I started with Java and discovered bedrock a few years ago, thought it was too janky initially but kept playing and love it. I imagine when it's old as the Java version, a lot of the bugs will be ironed out.

[@ServerGaming]

Amazing video as always Danny ❤️ keep up the good work!

[@mklmyrs5454]

bedrock does not have the bugs people use on java like redstone stuff or mob generations, but bedrock have its own problems, like chunk corruptions out of nowhere or recently lagging on single player

[@MadFaceCountryBalls]

One simple fact that makes bedrock better: you don't have to give people ur IP to join ur server you just need to friend them.

[@MazzyGG]

I’ve seen this video around for a while and was thinking of watching it, but never ended up watching… until now! Now as a player who doesn’t have Java, I am a bit biased to the only version I have as being not the worst, but it’s a good version for it’s reasons. Anyways it is interesting to see what Java players think of bedrock edition. Great job, keep it up! You earned being in my subscription, new subscriber here.

[@DannyIsDahBomb]

Thank you so much Mazzy!

[@IdontKnowAtAlllol]

That part where a youtuber says that at he can't access realms and servers is because of a account authentication error and by the way it also affected the Microsoft store

[@ThatStrangeUnknown]

I played bedrock before playing java edition and it's safe to say there are flaws between both renditions. It is still the same game. SO in my opinion bedrock edition does not suck, it's honestly just player preference.

[@ADFaried]

I think both version is good. You just have to know the right way to play them. Redstone can be much more fun than java if you know it. Speedrun has their own ways that can often be way faster than java. Bridging is so much fun if you know how to do it correctly. You don't enjoy one version just because you don't know how to play them

[@Voided-gone13]

I would say yes to bedrock. Dolphins actually have a buff. They leave behind bubbles that can be used to breath. In java they do not.

[@thikNixon]

I just hate the lack of parity. Hardcore, offhand, sweeping edge, biome only worlds, debug screens, nether roof. Worse is that the Bedrock community doesn't care they're not up to parity so the developers don't fix it.

[@líng_Yá0-g8c]

I watch more Java KZbinr but I play Minecraft bedrock so bedrock was my childhood

[@gleamingcolt]

Your definitely the most honest person to talk about this issue, so many people say it sucks, and give the dumbest reasons why. I am a bedrock player, and have been for a while, i enjoyed this video a lot.

[@TheMaltianRobloxian]

As a Java and former Bedrock player. It truly does suck. Bedrock lacks many features from the official game, has a trashy marketplace, emotes for no reason, laggier, has more bugs, has less players, and has less mods. Now when you buy Java, you get both Bedrock and Java because Bedrock comes included. You can also play any version of Minecraft ever created on Java whenever you want. You also have access to more mods, a better menu, a whole launcher with Java, Bedrock, Minecraft Dungeons and Minecraft Legends, a news section, and much more.

[@gleamingcolt]

@@TheMaltianRobloxian eh, I can 100% agree with the marketplace, it is definitely the worst part of bedrock edition (by a wide margin), but less players? Granted I may edit this and see if I’m wrong or not. But I believe bedrock has more players As for the bugs, your not wrong. But how common are they? Because I have not experienced, nor have anyone I have talked to (besides maybe a handful, I will give you that) Then again, cubecraft took pretty much all my levels and everything, and just deleted my claim when asking about it, I’m still annoyed with that. Also, I thought it was the other way around with the getting Java, and you get bedrock for free? Maybe I’m wrong. Plus after playing Java (yes, I was able to play Java when I got a new computer, right after I made this comment I think) there are many more mods and maps to choose from, but they are very annoying to import (at least in my opinion)

[@TheMaltianRobloxian]

@@gleamingcolt No, you have to pay $40 for Bedrock. Your points are fair though. I must say, Bedrock isnt as bad as I think now that I think about it. Thanks for listing these

[@gleamingcolt]

@@TheMaltianRobloxian no problem. Also yeah I am wrong about the getting Java for free, my bad

[@crashlag420]

I just want the game to perform like a normal game. Blocks despawning while placing them, really odd and inconsistent entity movement, getting shoved off of nerd poles for no apparent reason, random hits of damage seemingly out of nowhere and massive spikes in lag for no reason just breaks my soul. Going to the end is nearly impossible because of block lag. Life would be so much better if Bedrock didn't behave like a dumpster fire.

[@Napoleon_e2]

block lag also happens on java, it just boils down on your device

[@real_FOOTBALL10]

Crazy how I've never experienced any of these things

[@Napoleon_e2]

@@real_FOOTBALL10 they got fixed, it's just java players that are unaware of this and keep using this outdated argument

[@keilyncloud]

To be honest, even as a java player, I believe that the differences don't make the game bad, but just something we are not used to. Although I still do prefer java, I still believe there are parts of bedrock that prove much more unique and fun than java

[@shadowbrotherjplayz]

great work danny as always

[@DudeDragon2]

W

[@Alt_Luck4435]

In my opinion some bedrock and Java features should be switched for more enjoyment, but no matter what anyone says you should play the version you like since your opinion only matters on your enjoyment

[@YachtpeeR-sk5du]

If you just want to hop on Minecraft with little to no hassle, I say you should get bedrock. but if you want an overall better experience with more setup get Java

[@TheMaltianRobloxian]

Conclusion: If you want the best experience, get Java. It's just as easy as downloading Bedrock, but it has less bugs, more features, more mods, more everything. Also, you can play both Java and Bedrock on the computer for only like $60

[@MattTOB618]

I'd love to see someone take a Java player on a curated tour of the version differences - the good, the bad, and almost everything inbetween. From the camera command and the cauldrons to the buggy redstone. Or even in reverse - a Bedrock player being toured through Java!

[@beefonwec]

i have had to play bedrock for a little more than a year (my shitty pc stopped working) but i got a new one and after knowing everything about bedrock and learning the game and getting used to it, java just is so much more enjoyable for me but this is a great idea for those saying “java sucks” or “bedrock sucks”

[@MattTOB618]

@@beefonwec I'm the exact opposite - I just recently got Java! It's pretty good, but I'm still used to Bedrock's mechanics. For example, on Bedrock Edition, melee attackers get bounced back by the shield, whereas they don't on Java. This has caused me to receive a lot of damage from mobs that stay right up against me when they hit me, when I'm used to getting a moment to strike when they get knocked back.

[@beefonwec]

@@MattTOB618 to get used to it you just have to stop using the shield and hit them as soon as they hit you, then use the shield. also skeletons shoot slower on java

[@tekwins]

most of bedrock's hate comes from the marketplace, and this sucks because everyone thinks this is the only way to get mods, when it's not. there are websites like mcpedl that have free mods made by players, the marketplace is just an easier way for creators to monetize their stuff without using things like patreon. java players also monetize things like build downloads and the marketplace is just an easier way to do this.

[@Stettafire]

Marketplace and the awful state of bedrock redstone for me.

[@HYDROCARBON_XD]

I like bedrock more for 2 things,first,because it’s more optimized,it may lag sometimes but in Java,even with optimize installed you lag a lot (last time I played it I couldn’t even move,WITH OPTIFINE INSTALLED) and second the marketplace has a lot of things to offer,you don’t need to scroll too much to find a free world with a lot of cool mechanics/mobs/objects.

[@PenguinGaming-777]

i mean that just means ur computer suck well it might not be also u can just randomly die in bedrock and java there mods infinite free maps free skins servers(very fair points for ppl arguing about bedrock id say java is better for older people or people that know there way around a computer but bedrock is fine for people that are younger dont have pc or just play once in a while or to chill with friends)

[@HYDROCARBON_XD]

@@PenguinGaming-777 unless you have a shitty device you’ll never randomly die in Java,Java has also a shot ton of bugs,and bedrock has Addons which aren’t bad

[@jojo_da_poe]

@@HYDROCARBON_XD I don't know what you are talking about by Java has a lot of bugs, have you played bedrock or seen videos of the horrible bugs in it? I hardly encounter any bug in Java, and when I do, they are usually extremely minor, and tend to be when I am playing a server, which is pretty unpreventable on servers in any games. Also, you really must be running an old device if you cannot run Java. My old laptop with some bad Athlon CPU and no GPU can run Java just fine with OptiFine, and I have never tried it with mods like Sodium, Phosphor, etc.

[@mthaylanprogames3689]

​​@@jojo_da_poenot suficient reason to make hate in bedrock 👍 Bedrock its just more "hardcore" mode for the Moded easy Java players😂

[@metarustic03]

​@@jojo_da_poethats the bad side of Java downloading Optifine just to run it for your low end device...That's why bedrock is made, it can be run on low end device also can cross play on pc and mobile and other consoles unlike Java, pc only(I know there's Java emulator for mobile but its sucks, I have 16 gb ram phone and it takes too long to open just to play Java on phone, I rather play Bedrock The only "Why" I want Java is because of its mods nothing more, the rest of it, its bad

[@Nullcrafter3000]

I reale like bedrock, i grew up with it, and im still playing it after 7 years. I think it has its his and lows. The comunitie is not that toxic as in java, and i even made freands in this version. I even learnd redstone in this version and now im realy good at it (in both versions). I would say that both are realy diferent and can not get compert with each other. great video, keep it up

[@gabrielwolfson182]

Ive been playing Minecraft Bedrock since 2014, and I have an almost 5 year survival world on my tablet, In my opinion Minecraft Bedrock has a lower skill ceiling and more friendly to new users, and casual players.

[@tonycrayford3893]

I've recently built a private bedrock server so that I can do some gaming with my nieces and nephews as they play on tablets.

[@Crzyelf]

YO I GOT IN YOUR GAME TODAY

[@shadowfox8084]

The only good thing about bedrock is that we have some in game features java doesn't have theirs a hole list the only things from java that I want in PS4 bedrock is access to mods and shaders and the ability to fully customize the game like for example adding mobs from dungeons into Minecraft or makeing illagers not hostile towards you

[@Fariha_m]

Especially the shaders :(

[@justanimator-xs5lx]

bro thats already in the game, mcpedl, free

[@shadowfox8084]

@@justanimator-xs5lx no it isn't If you play Minecraft on the PlayStation you can only get mods or new mobs on the market place but it doesn't have the stuff I'm looking for you can't add shaders either only texture packs

[@justanimator-xs5lx]

on pc you can or on mobile@@shadowfox8084

[@EngiGODS358]

You can literally mod all of the features bedrock has into Java 🤭 Also mods on java are infinitely better 😂

[@SuperOriginal]

Why is bedrock like on EVERY SINGLE DEVICE except macs! (I still prefer java though, but maybe I would change my mind if I could give bedrock a try)

[@NathanCraft90]

0:06 BRO GET WIFI

[@Emmmm39266]

Its an editing style

[@DavyanHatch]

@@Emmmm39266he’s talking about how he can’t join servers

[@ultra_editscool]

I feel like bedrock gets to much hate

[@ΘΕΟΔΩΡΑΧΙΩΤΗ]

It does

[@tuxedoneko370]

Minecraft Java is not open to criticism. Minecraft Bedrock is open to criticism.

[@THENOOBPROYT]

Minecraft is Minecraft can’t we all just enjoy Minecraft?

[@EmperorPenguin1217]

Yeah that's true but one of the minecrafts is objectively bad compared to java

[@marshmallowweekly8575]

@@EmperorPenguin1217not really both are bad and good in there own way. Coming from someone who owns and plays both

[@dejus_e]

@@EmperorPenguin1217You literally contradicted himself while agreeing with him

[@EmperorPenguin1217]

@@dejus_eYou can enjoy minecraft while also recognizing one is objectively worse than the other.

[@KyleNguyen-pq7ug]

I played bedrock for 3 years, but when I got introduced to Java, I was just like “Bedrock is trash”

[@HornCompany]

Then you didn’t appreciate bedrock for what it is

[@real_FOOTBALL10]

​@@HornCompanybedrock is really a good game but java people just hate it because it has different features

[@Jandfriendslol5493]

Tbh imo bedrock is much more stable and it’s cross platform which is something Java lacks, obviously I don’t hate Java but I like bedrock more since it’s a lot more functional

[@Wuyic]

honestly as an ex-bedrock player, i have to say bedrock edition isn't as bad as some people say

[@Justmomo]

Nice video Danny I wonder how long this took!

[@DannyIsDahBomb]

I started editing September 14th

[@JoeTheCrusader]

@@DannyIsDahBomb Dang, that's dedication right there! Thanks Danny!

[@Justmomo]

@@DannyIsDahBombwow great effort that was a amazing video you getting the java community to try out bedrock 😊

[@AmagynGaming]

I LOVE THIS VID TOO

[@ChronicBreakdown]

I have played Java since 2012 so I’m committed to it. The thing that has kept me away from bedrock edition is that you have to buy texture packs and I don’t really like the idea of the shop.

[@Napoleon_e2]

there's actually a way of getting texture packs from internet and downloading them into the game, sadly consoles can't do that which is why the marketplace is there in the first place, and minecoins so the creators could get rewarded for their work

[@charityselick6595]

​@@Napoleon_e2 the point is if your on console I think it's impossible or nearly

[@Napoleon_e2]

@@charityselick6595 yeqh

[@BaykaScott]

I started on Xbox 360, then went to next gen on bedrock on pc cuz I didnt realize the difference between java and bedrock. Now after playing Java a bunch Java feels WAY more fluid than Bedrock and bedrock just feels, slow. The inputs are really clunky to me after playing java.

[@ABoxedFox]

Fast-paced PvP gamemodes on Bedrock like SkyWars suck for one major reason: hotkeying items from chests to wanted slots is impossible by pressing the binded key, you can only drag them into desired slots by the cursor which is horrible 😔

[@kiedisboughen5318]

Legacy console used to have a similar feature, it ruled

[@muangxplayer2503]

You think mars would be like earth?

[@ABoxedFox]

@@muangxplayer2503 Well, editions have to be equal to the fullest they can get

[@muangxplayer2503]

@@ABoxedFox exactly both earth and mars are planets too we should be able to do what we can like we did in earth

[@Napoleon_e2]

ok mister you're not used to it so it's bad, now go to sleep

[@ryorai5804]

I don't really care what the actual problems are with it... For me its just that its not java edition. It could be better in every way and id still say java is superior version.

[@zulu2103]

All fun in games in till you try PE edition

[@dejus_e]

Pocket edition edition?

[@kennanrecinos7309]

No that one dude mad doors make sense underwater in bedrock💀

[@LixoDelac]

As someone who has played Minecraft since 2016, I never knew that there were such things as bedrock and Java editions until yesterday, when I said that I don't know which version I’m playing as long as I’m playing Minecraft.

[@Twiglin]

No, I'm not crying

[@TabbedOutLOL]

:uno_reverse_card:

[@DelbertTheFifth]

The fact that some java players trash on bedrock for being different to java, instead of liking it for being as colloquially unique as java is just bs.

[@EmperorPenguin1217]

Java players don't hate bedrock because it's different, we hate it because it's garbage

[@DelbertTheFifth]

@@EmperorPenguin1217 Man, Can you just not speak for all of the java players? Like, I doubt you know even 1% of all of the java players.

[@MTValeriian]

​@@EmperorPenguin1217Garbage Douchies like you have no place in this community

[@EmperorPenguin1217]

@@DelbertTheFifth 1% of millions of players is still a massive amount

[@DelbertTheFifth]

@@EmperorPenguin1217 Thats why i said *I DOUBT* you even know 1%-

[@DeeJayRC202]

Bedrock is better for Survival and PvP while Java is better for Mods and Creative.

[@Psiosgamers942]

I feel like it’s the opposite since bedrock focuses more on colors and texture

[@trulsdirio]

As a surprise to no one; The version you played the most feels best to you. Crazy.

[@hunjoc1070]

It’s the goat edition 🐐

[@Kraken_da_goat]

Cappppp

[@EngiGODS358]

What you said sir, is a lie.

[@zerbutterftw]

both of them are good

[@blackholetree]

@ohmeohmicah thats why its the goat goat edition, cope

[@davwad3]

as someone who mostly plays java, i can say: bedrock = good also i started playing on bedrock so that's a factor maybe

[@thefuzzllama9174]

I remember playing Java Infdev as a kid, I grew up on thousands of hours in Java. Tried playing Bedrock with my girlfriend and it was so bad I built her a PC

[@landonlicht19-LL]

it really triggered me when he said you can't F3 on bedrock because you can it's just different

[@the_otamatone]

How?

[@marshmallowweekly8575]

@@the_otamatonefor my friend who plays on pc with our bedrock world he just presses F3 and it still works

[@ABP0727]

the reddoons guy sounded like he was having so much fun

[@AzairahTzy-vg9hb]

Bro iM a Bedrock Player

[@arkimedeez]

crazy

[@jamesblack4265]

Same

[@petrplay5009]

Womp womp

[@Wild1dea]

We all have problems so it is ok

[@ariyaYazdani-z1x]

Bedrock team 👇

[@RiyanAhmed-e3k]

Yes Java is sus😑👋

[@jsg2801]

No I’m a java main

[@Logan-cq6bf]

I wish I was a java main

[@FireClus1erPlayz]

i’m bedrock

[@DoneWithEvrything]

Bruh I can’t afford a good PC for Java as a Bedrock player leave me alone 😭😭😭 Also I can actually see a valid reason why someone would hate Bedrock now. They made an update that breaks and bans mods now. I haven’t updated my Minecraft Bedrock Edition and refuse to do so because I love my mods, but I feel like that’s the only reason why anyone should hate Bedrock. All other reasons is pure bs cuz not everyone is rich and can afford an overpriced gaming PC to get Java.

[@PixLZ900]

This is how much more subs danny should have 👎

[@b2hots]

Minecraft is Minecraft

[@whatdoyouexactlymeanbyhandle]

🗿🗿🗿🗿🗿🗿🗿🗿🗿🗿🗿🗿🗿🗿🗿🗿🗿🗿🗿🗿🗿🗿

[@OperationLuckyCat]

This is why that minecraft legacy is better than bedrock edition

[@Stettafire]

It's wild to me too. In the software space C# is Microsoft's baby. So why did they dump legacy edition and use pocket edition instead? Just a strange choice.

[@aanda5104]

yup, it sucks.

[@Saheeba-u4u]

are see in phone or pc and do have minecraft?

[@niflheim1-0]

Because? That's what I thought you can't say anything because you're just a dumb internet person who ride on a hate train

[@Joamamabsus]

BEDROCK SUCKS

[@Hungup175]

Bro im playing bedrock so... That means ima sucker too?

[@Joamamabsus]

@@Hungup175 maybe

[@Hungup175]

@@Joamamabsus but the wither in bedrock...

[@Joamamabsus]

@@Hungup175 is too op

[@EuniceGura]

I really want to play java edition but I got a garbage doo doo PC so I'm stuck in bedrock edition

[@Wakefield-zd6jw]

As someone that plays the Hive I respect everyone who practiced everything in this video