Dave Gilmours AMAZING NEWS about PINK FLOYD , from ROLLING STONE.

[@ProjectHysteria]

What did you think about this Pink Floyd news? Like comment or subscribe to Project Hysteria so you never miss a video !

[@popjaw1andOnly]

I'd buy it if I could, and maybe sell it for a profit to Michael Jacks.... oh, wait....

[@viktrolla1374]

Roger is comfortably numb (couldn’t resist)

[@vintagevinylvets1187]

I totally understand David’s feelings. On top of that, he’s the only artist I truly believe is not doing it for the money. Case in point, his guitar collection. He sold it through auction and every time went to charity. We saw Roger in concert recently and it would have been a brilliant show, but spent a lot of it bashing Gilmour. We were so disappointed.

[@jayt4465]

Was making the Endless River for the money, an album with lyrics on only one song (and putting the Pink Floyd name on it)? That is the act of a person phoning it in for the money.

[@BoltRM]

​@@jayt4465Ah jayt is back..

[@moziboy75]

David definitely on the rent free buzz....Waters can't go a minute thinking about him

[@MrDannyboyhall]

@@jayt4465he explained why the endless river was made and why it had no lyrics apart from one song it was Rick’s music that was important to the project

[@Music.Notes145]

How delusional was roger to believe he alone was pink floyd that an insane power trip . No ones perfect and roger was a good songwriter but thats about it .

[@JohnVieto]

Roger was the main man in Floyd and when he left it was never the same. Gilmour is a guitar player but not a good songwriter. Floyd without Waters is not good imo.

[@williammcdowell3718]

@@JohnVieto And Roger by himself is no where near Pink Floyd.

[@CFCMahomet]

I think people need to understand that David wanting to get rid of the catalog has nothing to do with the music the quality of the music, but it has to do with the relationships that he hast to keep interacting with because he’s associated with the catalog

[@popjaw1andOnly]

Being in my 50's, and having loved the Floyd since I was six years old, I recently found it necessary to learn how to seperate the artist's creations from the _person_ the artist is (or was). Whether it's Elvis, Waters, Lennon, Clapton, John Fogerty, Madonna, Sheryl Crow, Chuck Berry, Buddy Holly, Kurt Cobain, etc etc... All music stars are people, and people just suck in general. Some more than others, of course. Waters is a musical/artistic genius, but as a man, I really have little respect for how he treats and treated his former Floydian bandmates. "Pathetic... that's what it is." (Perhaps you get the reference.)

[@kingtrance307]

What’s wrong with John Fogerty?

[@popjaw1andOnly]

@@kingtrance307 He kind of treated his brother like Waters treats Gilmour. Also, look into the CCR Rock and Roll Hall of Fame induction. Correct me if I'm wrong, but JF didn't even play with any other original CCR members when he performed for it. He fronted a band of his own players, and played CCR songs. I'm not saying he's as bad as Waters, but he's similar, as legend has it.

[@Mr_Realworld]

More PF yrs without him than with him. Roger needs to just go away somewhere.

[@morrisanderson3180]

the moon, permanently!

[@rupert-j8f]

yeh but they got shit after waters left.

[@morrisanderson3180]

@richardupton3323 I disagree. I consider the wall 🧱 + the final cut complete garbage the latter dominated by waters. just my opinion of course.

[@adamandrew9052]

Personally I believe that Roger to this day has not gotten over the death of his father in WW2 when he was a baby. It showed in his maniacal lyrics. I love Pink Floyd the band, including Syd stuff, their personal views are their own, I just love the music they created.

[@danielanderson8503]

Many of us lost our fathers to military service, not as babies but as youngsters who distinctly remember the man they lost. Waters assigns much of his angst to that event, but he has no memory of his father- it's learned trauma. Waters is intelligent and talented, as well as vindictive and resentful. In a nutshell- he's a complicated human being.

[@ampzamp]

...bullshit. Waters is trouble.

[@morrisanderson3180]

yep his solo stuff is garbage 🗑

[@jayt4465]

@@morrisanderson3180 BULLSHIT

[@BoltRM]

​@@morrisanderson3180I wouldn't say garbage. Weak but not garbage.

[@williammcdowell3718]

Roger left the band...then took them to court when they tried to go on without him. Then insulted their next album by calling it a forgery, Then went on to insult DG and Polly, then went on to have a melt down when things don't go his way or to him seems unfair. Dude...There is a reason the band members didn't present their ideas to you, and it is why The Final Cut is just Roger screaming for half an hour. Lyrics alone don't make a song or an album good.

[@SPY1964-LL]

True. Look at his solo material. It is lame. Division Bell is a good record and David's first solo album is classic. Roger struggled and got lost in bitterness and finally.....irrelevance....I saw David on tour with Richard and it was brilliant. That whole era has left the harbor. Now we have a garbage culture with an equally plastic soundtrack with auto tune

[@Skanoza]

And the best part is, Gilmour even graciously agreed to playing the solos on one or two of the songs on The Final Cut, and that was the only listenable song on the album (The Gunner's Dream, i think it was titled).

[@jayt4465]

They presented all the ideas they had. The rest of the band got content with their success the way bands sometimes do. They let the leader (Roger) take over because they were lazy.

[@jayt4465]

@@SPY1964-LL Amused to Death is as good as almost any Pink Floyd album. I saw Roger on tour and it was also brilliant.

[@dennisallen6186]

​@@jayt4465I am 71 years old and have been fortunate enough to see the original Pink Floyd on tour numerous times. I also got to see the Waterless version of Pink Floyd numerous times. And I have seen David as a solo act numerous times. I have seen Roger perform Pink Floyd with his numerous cover band versions also. You claim the shows by Roger were outstanding. Compared to what? I have seen Australian Pink Floyd and Brit Floyd numerous times. They both put on a better show than Roger Waters cover band. Pink Floyd without David Gilmour could have never become the world renowned icons that they are. My eyes and ears tell me so

[@drmusic3641]

Roger simply can't sing and never could and a reason most of his solo material is a tough listen, but it mixed well with David's soulful vocals and guitar. One listen to Roger's remake of DSOTM should be all the proof you need.

[@morrisanderson3180]

he ain't very good on bass guitar either.

[@Proj69-g9u]

Waters may not be the best singer, but he done most lead vocals after DSOTM until he quit Floyd. Also he had the ideas for the albums & stage shows.

[@andrewhaines3259]

I'm not jumping on the Waters /Gilmour bandwagon crap. What I will say is, when the deal is done, what are we to expect from this? Yet more re hashes of the albums we already have too many copies of? Expensive, unnecessary box sets? Will we ever see the 5.1 copy of The Wall? Live at Pompeii, Venice and other unreleased items? I suppose we will have to wait and see. It's a pity a UK based company couldn't buy the rights, as they are a "quintessentially English band" !

[@porcupinecraig]

Roger is an absolute jerk and everything Polly says is correct and if you read a lot of what Roger has said and done, it's is absolutely spot on. Too many people think Roger is a lyrical genius so they excuse all of his bad hehavior.

[@jayt4465]

So Roger is a jerk for wanting to reach a peace agreement in Ukraine? It's OK to have hundreds of thousands of drafted Ukrainian soldiers die so the US to give Putin a black eye right? What is your limit for the number of Ukrainian deaths? I'm guessing there is no limit for you right? Is your last name Cheney?

[@kingtrance307]

@@jayt4465- No it’s not controlled by the US Military you raving lunatic!! 😂😂😂😂

[@jayt4465]

So it's bad behavior to want a peace settlement in Ukraine? How many thousands of drafted Ukrainian soldier deaths are you OK with the US funding so we can give Putin a black eye? How would you view Russia if say California or Texas seceded from the union and then the United States tried to get them back in the union and Russia tried to get California or Texas to be a member of the Warsaw Pact (if it still existed) so that a US attempt to get California or Texas back in the union would require a military response by Russia. Add to that what if Russia put missiles pointed at the US from California? That was the the US plan for Ukraine. Kamala Harris talked about getting Ukraine in NATO a week before the invasion. We didn't tolerate missiles in Cuba. But it's OK for Russia to tolerate them on land that was once theirs.

[@BoltRM]

There is so much that this video got wrong.. 😕

[@johnmason6213]

I wouldn’t spend the ridiculous amount of money on a ticket that they would want for a reunion tour. For the first time I’m happy with knowing that it’s over for good. What a sad and desperate money grab that tour would be. Neither of these guys could pull off the vocals needed to make it decent and authentic so it would be lip synced. And while they are lip syncing why not play tracks instead of instruments? In fact let’s just have these 3 guys on stage and not bother with a band and instruments at all. Large stage productions can be fun but music is about connection, concerts are just circus displays now with no heart or connection.

[@michaelwills1926]

Yeah it’s got nothing to do with the four hundred million clams. Totally.

[@LearnwithGern2025]

This just in: David and Roger will reunite to open for Oasis this fall!

[@flubblert]

How can you speak so forcefully about peace for other nations when you can't even achieve it amongst your own personal relationships? Eh Roger??

[@jayt4465]

What would you think if you founded a band, in this case Pink Floyd, wrote most of the songs and then being banned by the "great person" David Gilmour from having anything to do with the Pink Floyd website? To David Gilmour, Polly Samson was more important to Pink Floyd than Roger.

[@flubblert]

@@jayt4465 I think I'd consider keeping my big mouth shut instead of walking around telling the world that "they're all my songs" as if the iconic vocals and brilliant musicianship of Gilmour and the other members played no role in making those songs literal masterpieces. He walked away from them, they didn't walk away from him. Between the lawsuit and everything else, you'd think he'd make the slightest effort to remain in good standing. He doesn't. So can you really blame them?

[@jayt4465]

It's crazy how Polly Sampson thinks she is relevant. She wrote some of the lyrics for The Division Bell because David was apparently not interested in finishing his songs. That's indictive of why Roger Waters had to be the lead for Pink Floyd if they ever wanted to complete a full album.

[@radiomindchatter7994]

Pink Floyd was never really a pop group...well, they were with Syd for a minute. I've been a fan of The Floyd since 1971 but I can't keep my interest in them anymore. Too bad.

[@michaelwills1926]

If it’s on a radio, it’s pop.

[@ljc6181]

He is a full part of creating the “mud bath” so it seems a bit like whining at this point.

[@kingtrance307]

Give us a concrete example or are you just running your mouth?

[@ljc6181]

@@kingtrance307 you start with the concrete example that he wasn’t. This is the most overused line in KZbin. And by the way, this is a written medium.

[@Sigma10-c1k]

Roger waters is right

[@ia1530]

Love and followed PF over 30 years. But this figure, Polly is way over the board. Basically, she truly showed her lack of the artistic bend and authorship. Take a look at her sad encyclopedia of imagination-her Tweet of dumping insults on Waters. Her next book should be: How I Rocked Myself into Fame Through the Hall of Insults. With this tweet she really shows how low she sees herself. The position of Waters in regard to social issues should be addressed and debated. Polly is too busy “Learning to Fly” than reflecting on the significance of “Us and Them” to the current global situation. Polly, go take a hike.

[@ia1530]

Wrong, you don’t know the genealogy of the band.

[@n8w8rem22]

Listen to Roger's solo albums and you will know who and what the real Pink Floyd sound is! I cannot say this about David's solo albums or his so-called Pink Floyd albums without Roger. Sorry David !

[@soarornor]

David’s first solo album was great.

[@scottren.8492]

RW solo albums. Were OK. without good musicians such as Clapton, Andy Fairweather-Low, Jeff Back, Etc.. Nah'..

[@scottren.8492]

And 'Is this the Life We Really Want?' Few decent moments, that's it. And 'TPACOH' is really overated.

[@classicraceruk1337]

Keep up your delusions. Without Gilmour Pink Floyd would have ceased to exist when Syd left. I saw the way he helped Syd on his final concerts. Don’t forget Syd wrote the early songs.

[@n8w8rem22]

@@classicraceruk1337 Roger doesn't need David, Roger Solo's album sounds more Pink Floyd than David's albums!!! Obviously Roger started with Syd. Unfortunately, Syd had to leave the band, which was fortunate for David... and yes, David did a very good job! although the Pink Floyd sound remains up to Roger.