David Gilmour & Bob Geldof - 16 Comfortably numb

[@FloydTheWolf]

Bob has something that really sounds like Roger Waters in his voice, this half-singing, half-whispering style. This is great !

[@davidbreen6335]

Thats why he was good for playing and singing the part of Pink in the Wall Movie.

[@marianevegirgenti6272]

Yes. Great!💯💯💯

[@kc768]

Gilmour's voice hasn't changed. He sounds great. Almost like a record.

[@TheWorldTeacher]

It's a shame the same could NOT be said for Sir Robert.

[@АрсенийЧемырысТВ]

Lol ed Sheeran always sounds just as shitty live as he does on recordings

[@tiago2189]

His voice aged like a fine wine

[@raphael_2d878]

400 YEARS LATER i still love Bob.

[@holographiccowboy5271]

Bob Geldof has such an amazing voice for this song

[@RobinSchenk1]

Wow I love the moment when they are waiting for Gilmour to change guitar and everyone is anticipating the solo and everyone is like - is it coming? No? Yes? No? Yeeeeees! :D :D love this version

[@gonzaga3891]

Exactly !!!

[@Indomi2008]

Bob is a Human rights actives , He gave up all money & fame for people in need . he is a saint. an angle. God Bless his Soul,,, we Love you Bob...

[@cannaewargaming4815]

He didn't give up any fame at all. His fame grew from LiveAid. He was a relatively minor punk singer before then, with one major hit. And he lived in an expensive house in central London. He had/has money. I doubt he is an angle, more likely a saxon?

[@BB-fd2rf]

@@cannaewargaming4815 🤣 true!

[@shenaniganiz0r]

I can only imagine the thrill of hearing the audience cheer as you go to grab the guitar to play the solo that they're waiting - DYING - to hear at that moment in the song. It must be amazing, knowing that those people, at that moment, are there to hear YOU. What YOU have to play, what YOU have to express, what YOU'RE presenting to their ears. I bet there's nothing like it. I hope to feel that, myself, one day.

[@NilsRuneTorrissen]

Very Good Bob Geldof on vocal. Bob , you are my HERO...!!!

[@belle9438]

I've been listening to David play for 35 plus years and he still awe's me. He's always been number 1 for me. I just love his style.

[@bbandthesv]

Bob has the perfect voice for Comfortably Numb

[@averygoodman761]

I guess Geldof didn't listen to side 3 of The Wall 2,109,307 times, like I did.

[@fionamackaymckelvie5699]

Avery Goodman 😂😂😂😂

[@gi5089]

Avery Goodman To be completely honest. I'm not the biggest fan of the third side. Ofcourse Comfortably numb is the absolute pinnacle of the album and Pink Floyd in general but I just really can't get into songs like Hey you(apart from the ending solo) and Vera. However I am a HUGE fan of the first and second side...

[@averygoodman761]

Fair enough, brother -- the album's structured somewhat like an opera, so yeah, the third side is about where you'd slip out for a pee and a smoke.

[@habanero6332]

Giyan Scheers wow it’s my favorite side. Hey you is the best.

[@liamkavanagh4150]

he doesnt like pink floyd lol

[@HardRockMiner]

I've been listening to this song for most of my life ad it still gives me goosebumps. Thats the mark of a truly classic song

[@MusicAnirban]

The smile on Gilmour's face when he starts the second solo is priceless...

[@blackmoreOrion]

Don't forget about Michael Kamen (R.I.P.) on piano!

[@danielaricciardi6665]

Exactly!

[@april_maybee102]

After all these years, David Gilmour's voice is just the same.... Beautiful.

[@ClaudioKang271263]

this is the real deal. Classic rock.

[@ogunbaskaya1483]

Claudio Kang 💯

[@mugford777]

man 61 years old, and he's still got it

[@cat.547]

oh dear, Bob needs lyrics...love them

[@retrotubergoober1291]

I am watching this in July 6 2020 and Bob can read if he wants this is the best version of this song ever

[@tto0508]

Fellas, this is the guy that played "Pink" from The Wall. A fricking legend he is.

[@oh1yeah2]

This is a beautiful version of the song. I especially like the cello and the rhythm section with the percussion, piano and the upright bass, giving it an acoustic feel to it. Bravo

[@adm2127]

Excellent seeing Bob here since he starred in their movie, "The Wall". I can hear his voice distinctly which is a great asset to this marvelous band.

[@TheJedwardo]

Geldof is hilarious, he played pink in the movie and he has no idea of the lyrics

[@MrDannyboyhall]

Was a part of the show that they carry a lyric sheet Robert Wyatt did the same

[@TheJedwardo]

@@MrDannyboyhall that may be but, it’s still hilarious

[@remimartin8493]

​@@TheJedwardohe still remember the melody at least..

[@tiago2189]

Well he said that he hated Pink Floyd

[@davidblack1970]

AWESOME. BRILLIANT. The construction of a well oiled song. CLASSIC.

[@kazismurph]

fantastic performance,i still cried

[@silentorah]

I wish Bob would go out on tour with Dave ,, after seeing the movie a million times I find his voice fits PInk Floyd music perfectly

[@kurtkeg8811]

agreed!!!!!!

[@fanafana17]

Another excellent job by David God bless you.

[@nightfox]

Gilmor is one of the best guitarists alive. Love all his songs, as he does great guitar solo's in them

[@pcjsleader]

The most memorable and amazing solo to ever grace music. Just WOW.

[@Plinythelder]

Tho amazing still funny to see Bob having to look at the lyrics....professionalism!!Haha!!

[@TheWorldTeacher]

+Tony T And he was the star of "The Wall" movie...

[@dr.lambert1001]

+Reverend Eslam That happens when you star a musical movie and don't sing more than two songs on it...

[@JorgenSjobom]

guess he know all the Boomtown Rats lyrics 😊🎼🎤🎵😊

[@DrumCoversbyBill]

This is my absolute fav Pink Floyd Song but I just love Caroline Dale! She brings a real flare to this song! Best ever!

[@tantem7]

Alles bildet eine Einheit und das kommt dabei raus:Weltklasse!!!

[@drgnfrc13]

If you listen at 2x speed, it actually sounds like some kind of folk music.

[@danilabbozzetta8754]

hahahahahhdsajhfd i just laughed a lot doing this man, thanks

[@francisbtube]

Try .025 Tortuous 😂 😂 😂

[@penfloyd]

Never tire of this song......"Timeless"

[@thankGodforDavidG]

Totally agree with you, paulusmagirl, the main thing is when you combine David's guitar and Bob's voice, you got one heck of a music bliss !

[@loebell]

yes... beautiful. It seems this music was made for his voice. I also like his performance reading the lyrics and when he has his head down contemplative... One of my favorites, but almost all of their albums are...

[@marcsimon4624]

I can't believe that geldof actually needs notes so he can sing this iconic song..he couldn't memorize a few lines of a song?

[@honeycrisp808]

He did mention that he hated Pink Floyd's lyrics back in an interview for The Wall. So, that might have something to do with it.

[@dailyfleetwoodmac6999]

Well bob geldof not a huge Pink Floyd fan

[@merveillevanille]

bob really never liked pink floyd so that’s why he probably never knew the lyrics

[@remimartin8493]

​@@merveillevanillei imagine he couldn't remember the lyrics of the music but he remember the melody song.. That not too bad

[@luckyducki]

I haven't been okay since I saw The Wall

[@raizumichin]

Nice to se someone respectfully disagreeing, instead of cursing and insulting.

[@GabrielChapuDiaz]

Hello BOB, capo...gracias por tu actuación en The Wall..la vi 16 veces!!

[@MusicAnirban]

flawless string bends....!!!! Hail Mr Gilmour

[@badpanda1578]

Beautiful!!!!!!!!

[@carloszerda1583]

muyyyyyyyyy buenos....excelente tema,me hace acordar a mi adolecencia...

[@carloseugeniocarlos4287]

amazing live version! R.i.p Rick!

[@wizofozzie]

It's nice the "Pink" himself came to sing with David Gilmour.

[@Mastermind81179]

increible, a pesar de la edad, sigue tocando y cantando de la misma forma, grande david, saludos desde chile y si por casualidad vez este mensaje, david ven a chile, porfavor ven

[@SusanJeanine]

Beautiful!! A work of art.

[@D3LTA1874]

The build up of suspense for the solo was orgasmicly amazing. Made me feel Comfortably numb

[@DrumCoversbyBill]

Man I could watch Caroline Dale play her Cello all day long! I love the acoustic version of this song.

[@thankGodforDavidG]

Comfortably numb's guitar solo is considered one of the greatest guitar solos of all times. The fact that David Gilmour does this solo maybe explains the reason it's held in that high regard.

[@grandegrande4728]

Que buen duo, grandes

[@C1v1cDr1v3r]

I like the way Bob is swinging to the music at 6:34 .. shows some kind of respect to David and his music.

[@penfloyd]

A Wonderful concert which highlights just how "classical" the music of Pink Floyd really is....... Saddened and shocked to hear that Rick Wright had passed away....no words needed.

[@carlosalbertoherrera7684]

Y el genio, el inolvidable maestro Michael Kamen en teclados... muy buen recuerdo!

[@massimolombardi2861]

1:15 according to me the best PF song. Since I heard it for the first time I realized which instruments gave it that sense of immortality: the cellos. In this video I simply love Caroline Dale and her smile.

[@zofiazareba3717]

Uwielbiam ten utwór :-)

[@penfloyd]

Classical Beauty..Awsome Power... Thats the music of Pink Floyd.. Add to this the innovation of David Gilmour and it can,t get any better. Timeless!!!!

[@SnowWalker1]

Dave Gilmour is king to me but I also love Bob's voice!! It's very easy to forget the words of songs you've been singing all your life when suddenly pressured to sing them on stage in front of hundreds of ppl. He just planned ahead that's all!

[@Dobermann49]

Beautiful sound from de Ovation guitar and the Gretsch, just beautiful

[@nickatron]

really enjoyed this performance of CN. Think Bob did a great job of adding a fresh approach to the song.

[@vaderetrovideos]

Qué simbólico es el hecho de que sea Gelfof quien cante en este tema! Los invitamos a ver nuestra versión de esta obra de arte

[@seanreillyireland]

I think its brilliant that so many people observed the issue of reading from the notes. If you look at Bowie singing it in an immeasurably superior and emotive manner, he doesn't resort to this ploy. What reading from the notes says to me is "oh, I am so important, and I have so much going on that how could I be expected to remember the words of this poxy little song that I lend my great presence to". And that generally applies to every prima donna who does this on stage.

[@8t8zee11]

Bob does a wonderful job of balancing media, politics making awareness and changing crap....must get a biography of him, that's the art of moving between worlds to me, amazing song also

[@davitdavitdavit]

This music should stay forever !!!

[@RushfanUK]

A unique position for Bob Geldoff, surrounded by genuine talent, sadly Michael Kamen died a year later in 2003, only 55 I believe, along with Rick Wright who appears on this DVD RIP.

[@stuartstereo]

this is an amazing performance

[@HaveUCalledPinkFloyd]

Cello sounds wonderful ....

[@viktorz4869]

Perfect variant! Bravo!

[@Robster65]

Nobody plays that thang like Gilmore ... awesomeness

[@SuperSolano24]

Beautiful!

[@darthbandi3026]

As always - amazing!!!!

[@hapkrs]

awsome, music moves the soul.

[@pgohearn]

Awesome great work.

[@Tronalabundy]

gr8 song done very well by geldof. also amazing to c de late great michael kamen on the piano.

[@damianovolpevolpe6650]

Inimitabili.....i migliori

[@DAVIDH101280]

DAVID GILMOUR IS A LEGEND WHAT A GUITARIST ABSOLUTLY AWESOME

[@lescar88]

always an amazing song - thanks for sharing!

[@shaggyzack87]

This such a cool video..I never knew this happen..seeing bob just reminds me of the scene with this song...thanks for the upload...too cool

[@Excalibur322]

Gilmour...A true god in the history of music.

[@1975MAICO1975]

THE CELLO ADDED BEAUTY TO THIS SONG

[@florenciavalentini5414]

wow Bob ;) so cool

[@davidbelovic4232]

the most perfect drumming to the end solo possible, even Geldof turns around to check if it's for real

[@yomariar2]

Simplemente sin palabras!!!!

[@isabelveidt655]

Esto es tan extraño: Pink Floyd (el de la película) cantando con Pink Floyd (la banda). Raro. Turbio. Perturbador... ¡Adorable! LO AMO. AMO A PINK FLOYD (el de la película y a la banda). Nunca imaginé oir algo como esto. Gracias a quien lo subió. ♡♡♡♡☆☆☆♡♡♡☆☆♡☆☆♡.

[@DAVIDH101280]

beautiful song

[@ynotlaz]

Bob can do whatever he wants. He did reunite the greatest band ever to set foot on the planet.

[@isabelveidt655]

Esto me abrió el apetito musical. Sería un sueño oir a Bob Geldof cantar todas las canciones de The wall... Es decir, para quienes amamos su trabajo como Pink en la película, sería una cosa de otro mundo. Pero supongo que ya no tiene voz. Al menos quedan sus versiones de In the flesh y ahora esto. TE QUIERO BOB, ERES UNO DE MIS HÉROES♡♡♡♡♡♡♡.

[@karloss_083]

Excelente.................................................

[@osivor1021]

Colombian "Chucho-Merchan" on double bass, what a great honor!!!! Michael Kamen, David Gilmour, Bob Geldof... the best of the best...

[@thankGodforDavidG]

You guys have every right to opinionate ! Myself I loved Bob's vocals,paper or no paper !

[@1danrobbins]

Is there a better song in the history of Rock and Roll? Doesn't matter if it's Roger or David, both versions are nothing short of CLASSIC.

[@PAPPhil]

Hello Bob !

[@juanaguadalupecarreongarci3510]

Amó está hermosa canción.

[@lesleyrawlings5518]

I would love to hear Nick Cave do this!

[@funko3119]

That'd be amazing

[@kirarosenberger680]

that would be great!!!

[@ammuinaRepubblic]

Quando rischi di incontrare i tuoi eroi sapendo di morire di emozioni.....bhe ....morirei volentieri...maestoso Bob...immenso R3 David ❤️❤️

[@Clusterbomb7814]

The Cellist is (1) a very good player and (2) stunning!!

[@luigicroce3501]

wonderful!

[@LIL.SUE.Q]

fooking the best dave gilmore love it ....

[@placidian]

That was pretty darn awesome, thank you for sharing!

[@pau.87]

REALMENTE IMPERDIBLE!! UNA EXCELENCIA