David Gilmour, Roger Waters and Nick Mason back stage 2011

Ex Pink Floyd Reunion 2011

[@dougwebb704]

Imagine walking into that restaurant and seeing the 3 of them sitting there. I think I'd have a heart attack.

[@anthonyvaccari4607]

I think my eyes would grow damp with happyness. Just seeing them get on like this would be a treat. I know it's too late but wish they could get back together for a reunion and with hologram technology they have these days bring Rick Wright back for a live stage event..

[@85geoffm]

I'd cry my fucking eyes out.

[@Mar-up7db]

And without Rick............

[@wesleyparker2106]

i would fall out!

[@Edz90]

​@@85geoffmjust my thought exactly 😢

[@alexandrefigueiredo7541]

What a great moment

[@raymondsarvarian9074]

Roger maybe a demanding personality when it come to music but that is discipline and if it was not there Pink floyd wouldn’t be able to achieve what they have achieved today. Pink Floyd’s greatest work is the ones written by Roger. After Roger the 2 studio albums are musically great but lyrics wise they are not Pink Floyd and they did not do anywhere close to what the albums did with Roger in them. Fun fact after Roger leaving the band he has made more money then the other members just buy getting royalties and sales from the live albums since both live albums the delict sounds of thunder and Pulse are almost half of each live albums are the Roger’s work. During the ugly divorce Roger was given the complete rights to the greatest and the most successful album in the world DARK SIDE OF THE MOON. And if Pink Floyd after Roger we’re ever going to sale concert tickets they had to play the Best of Pink Floyd so DAVID / NICK / AND RIGHT DID ALL THE WORK OF TOURING ROGER ENJOYED THE PROFITS FROM BOTH CONCERT TICKET SALES AND LIVE ALBUM SALES. This is why Roger is the wealthiest member of Pink floyd. But all aside I wished that they would join together and do one last Pink floyd album and tour a world tot before ending the Pink floyd History even without Rick Right.

[@Frenkhigno90]

2:08 that moment when you see the empty seat at the table. We Miss You Rick...

[@RadoPaXe]

Omg🥺🥺🥺

[@altairsp]

😭😭 never forgotten

[@aneleaveizam]

this made me very sad :(

[@TheBatugan77]

Roger, David & Nick at this table.🙏🙏🙏 Syd and Rick in the next booth. 🙏🙏

[@biegebythesea6775]

I miss Rick Parfitt too.

[@BlizzyFoxTF]

Forget the recent drama. This is the most beautiful and appropriate ending of the Pink Floyd legacy.

[@alexribeiro4934]

Looking at how they came back to fighting now, when they were getting along fine 9 years ago, and looked to at least have put the old grudges behind, is sad... I've no hopes of seeing htem playing along together again, but I only wish they could still get along, not being best friends, seeing each other every weekend, but just getting along fine and nurture their beautiful legacy properly.

[@BlizzyFoxTF]

@Molloo3 The idea of David Gilmour standing on top of the wall like he did in 1980, and the way Roger's "wall" tore down, signifies Water's reconciliation with his old band members. Of course, this took place after live 8, so in a chronological sense this is more of a closure than live 8, which in itself was perfect.

[@BlizzyFoxTF]

@Molloo3 Fair enough, as a Gilmie, I am actually more favoured towards considering the Live at Pompeii show as a canonical ending to the band Truth is that whatever way you see it, it doesn't matter. Live 8 was legendary and will always be the most beautiful sign off.

[@BlizzyFoxTF]

@Molloo3 the crazy thing about Live 8 was that the camera pulled out for a shot of the Battersea Power Station during Money, paying tribute to the Animals album. Just one of the small details that show how they managed to condense Pink Floyd spirit into 30 concise minutes.

[@BlizzyFoxTF]

@Molloo3 Nothing I would add. You summarize the legacy very well. However, all bands had their golden years, and it is probably too much to ask for another Wish You Were Here, the last true "collaborative" album. Even if Roger and David made amends now and Rick came back to life, they wouldn't have the creative powers to write another Shine On. We could only imagine how sweet it would be if David agreed to that multi-million tour deal after Live 8. But for this timeline, I think Live 8 is satisfying enough.

[@saraheart2804]

When David starts singing and Roger turns around and smiles, that just says it all. And everybody's friend Nick.

[@hypnotizerLuna]

1:56 the sweetest moment!

[@medeatigger9199]

0:55, that look in Roger's eyes, when David sings the refrain. They secretly admire each other :-D

[@tridibbiswas3824]

I really hope this is true even after what Roger said in his rant a year ago, hope one day the 3 can do one last reunion

[@TallGreyMan]

It's so sad to these two fighting again. And Polly shouldn't get into it. Really.

[@sweetlorraine0]

2:11 They should have ordered oysters "that transcend national barriers" and recreated that scene from Pompeii in 1972. "There's good oysters, aren't there??" Iconic!

[@statelessoyster1037]

good idea!

[@bryan9587]

*they

[@writerbeatle8761]

YES

[@GG-cf1pn]

The oysters is allright??

[@dylanclark5438]

Yes the oysters are good

[@CHRISTIAN21562]

Roger Waters is great man. I understand he was a demanding man ... but that's exactly why Pink Floyd became great. He was the right man for the right time for the whole group ... that's my opinion ....

[@antalantal2366]

Absolutely: late Gilmourish Floyd are definitely not as good as what they were during the seventies, during the Waters era. Lyrically speaking it is clear that the late Floyd were struggling to came out with decent lyrics. Musically speaking Gilmour is excellent but predictable, it lacks that surprising and igniting spark that, to my ears, Waters provided.

[@sloedwn7509]

Ugh i wish they would just stay this way. The world needs Dave and Waters together and happy.

[@aporia82]

RIP Rick Wright...

[@scottward6974]

I reckon Waters and Gilmour love each other with an intensity that forbids harmony! We hurt the ones we love the most!

[@KushagraDwivedi1]

It's Impossible to NOT watch it with a smile

[@johnmanor5236]

It makes my heart happy and hurt so much to see that they share so much and have a commonality yet can't get past the differences that separate them. God bless them for giving us all the wonderful music (and experiences) they did. Pink Floyd has been a soundtrack for many of our lives.

[@gkbhai8962]

It warms my heart to see them friendly with each other.

[@goesjem]

For the cameras.....Maybe.

[@jeremyo3823]

Aged like fine wine.

[@sabinewei3041]

❤❤

[@Firststrike790]

Warms my heart to see them finally getting along. I just wish Rick was there to share it with them!

[@JeremyDeBose]

They don’t need to tour. They don’t need an album. Just moments like this. Hate is a bad thing to carry for no good reason.

[@randomloren6657]

5:30 there they need Rick and Syd :(

[@Tiberius_Productions]

When Roger says “and all that’s changed” at 5:13, the look on Davids face says it all. Roger might have calmed down over the years, but David clearly didn’t look like he was over it yet. And with recent events, it looks like that same old feud isn’t over.

[@dimitry9817]

Yeah...

[@85geoffm]

That's a bullshit take to insinuate Dave is the one hanging onto this feud.

[@Tiberius_Productions]

85geoffm but it literally is David hanging onto hard feelings lol. Roger and Nick get along, Nick and David get along, Roger asked to put the past behind them, David said no, seems like David’s holding onto grudges to me. How do you see it any other way? That is of course unless Roger never apologized for suing David, then David has a right to be angry. But I’m pretty sure Roger has apologized, so it most certainly is David still holding onto grudges lol. You can call it bullshit because you don’t like Roger Waters ideological beliefs, but that doesn’t discredit the facts I’ve just provided lol. Pink Floyd is over. David himself concluded the band. Why does David need to continue banning Roger from the band he helped form when the bands clearly over? It’s purely because David doesn’t want to acknowledge his era of absolute control of the band is over. He needs to step back and let all of the previous and current members have the opportunity to promote through the Pink Floyd brand too. It’s almost as if Davids afraid to relinquish control because he just has a personal grievance with Roger. Oh wait, that’s exactly what it is 🤣. Just because David doesn’t always respond to Roger’s criticisms doesn’t mean David’s always taking the “high road”, he just knows better than to make himself open to criticism from the fans like Roger does.

[@85geoffm]

@@Tiberius_Productions what in the actual fuck are you on about? 😂 I couldn't give a single fuck about anybody in Pink Floyd's ideologies lol. I LOVE Roger Waters, but David buried the hatchet by playing on Roger's tour when he didn't have to. Roger continues to do things like try to include liner notes on the Animals remaster that essentially say Roger wrote the album and praise him up and down for it when the band hasn't really ever included liner notes in the past. We all know Animals, aside from Dogs, was all Roger, but Roger wanted those liner notes included because Dave wrote 18 minutes of that album and got credited for one song whilst Roger got credited for 4 of 5 songs, 2 of which make up 4 minutes lol. Then Roger releases a video about it putting Dave and Polly through the wringer when Dave has never really done such a thing. Dave is an absolute class act. Even Nick Mason said Roger is the one who's upset because Pink Floyd continued without him, which Roger didn't expect to happen, and is continuing the feud as a result, but I'm sure you know more about it than Nick Mason. Carry on. 😂

[@Tiberius_Productions]

85geoffm See I don’t really see that as David burying the hatchet with Roger but rather the other way around. David could have buried the hatchet if he agreed to the reunion in ‘06 without needing Roger to tell him why they should do it. But instead David said no at first. Roger invited David to perform on Roger’s The Wall tour, and David said yes. That doesn’t mean David buried the hatchet at all. Roger invited him lol. It wasn’t David’s idea to my knowledge. If David wasn’t the one with the grudge, why wouldn’t he just let Roger include his solo material on the Pink Floyd site just like David and Nick? Roger was the one who called the meeting in an attempt to bury the hatchet. Sure, he wanted to include liner notes that David didn’t want, but that wasn’t the entire purpose of their meeting. The Animals rerelease was part of the conversation, but it wasn’t the reason for their ongoing feud. It’s just another disagreement on top of everything else. And their disagreement over who was the creative “heart” of Pink Floyd hinges entirely on one’s own personal opinion anyways. David says it’s the instrumentation first that gives Pink Floyd it’s heart, and Roger believes it’s his conceptual ideas. Neither of them are wrong, but if either of them have proven anything, it’s that the heart of Pink Floyd is the collaboration between David’s instrumental sensibilities and Roger’s conceptual ideas that gave Pink Floyd it’s heart on their best records. So I actually don’t disagree with you, however I feel like Roger gets all of the crap for speaking his mind when David is only mild mannered, but still can be just as notoriously stubborn as Roger. David has gone on record trying to say the music comes before Roger’s concepts, and in their best works that’s just plain not true. Roger’s concepts typically came first or shaped the structure of most of their songs. That’s the entire reason why Pink Floyd had to choose between The Wall of The Pros And Cons of Hitchhiking. Roger had the concepts first. I love David and LOVE Roger, but I just see them both as stubborn bickering old men, needlessly squabbling over meat-scraps for the kudos to who did what when nothing would have happened the way it did if they didn’t just work together lol. The truth is they needed each other and don’t like admitting it. Especially Roger and David when regarding each other.

[@IsisTiamat]

LOVE David's smile when he's up there (where he should always be!!). One could write a PhD dissertation on the love-hate bromance he and Roger have had over the decades.

[@saraheart2804]

I think they both know how good each other are but egos get in the way. I don't think they hate each other. They are both part of the Pink Floyd that we all love.

[@mikearchibald744]

@@saraheart2804 I don't think they've ever said they hate each other. Roger said "we are both trucculent fellows so I don't see us working together". I don't know what trucculent means, but it says it all.

[@normatible9795]

​@@mikearchibald744roger can really say difficult adjectives to describe themselves --

[@biegebythesea6775]

@mikearchibald744 trucculent means quick to fight/argue.

[@klitzy]

They just work so well together even if they don't appreciate each others all the time. I wish they could put their differences aside.

[@rickfrancis5480]

This will be one of the greatest videos watching them put everything aside and act like true friends like they was when they was so young

[@Nealson454]

If you knew nothing about their history and just watched this video you would think that they were good friends :(

[@MrHestichs]

They look so happy, like they have put their bad times behind them.

[@JeremyDeBose]

1:11 the way they both smile real smiles and everyone stops working and watches…would have thought they’d made peace.

[@timotmon]

And even after this beautiful reunion.. they STILL can't get along.

[@hosoiarchives4858]

Just Roger

[@timotmon]

@@hosoiarchives4858 True.

[@iandixon7641]

Sad but true

[@biegebythesea6775]

@hosoiarchives4858 it's not Roger, though. Look throughout this whole video - Roger is the warmest, kindest one out of all of them. Laughing, putting his arm around Dave. Dave is really cold and Nick is amiable but distant. Roger is talking to everyone. Dave is the one who cut him off. Roger doesn't have a problem with Dave.

[@juuso2248]

1:56 I wondered what happened after this one. Why they weren't friends anymore after this show?

[@tojoinbobdylan]

Same ;_;

[@f62darkstar]

well that "truce" between Gilmour and Waters didn't last long.....this was nice to see though....thanks for sharing.

[@darrenormsby3034]

omg...what the hell has happened since this. Amazing to see them looking genuinely happy to be together. I'm a 56 year old man and this brought a tear to my eye

[@NamesAreNotRelevant]

1:32 "Absolutely great, well done, brilliant" - "Thank you, daddy!"

[@CelticSaint]

That was lovely to see. They did look happy together..... occasionally!

[@AgainstYTubePolicy17]

1:55 My heart bursting into tears.. :')

[@85geoffm]

Right? 🥺

[@hectorrangel1580]

WAR says "Why Can't We Be Friends"

[@simon-di7xt]

1:54 OMG❤️😢😢 What happened to them now??!!

[@sdot5389]

@1:54 when the enormous weight of all the things you’ve shared together in life hits like a ton of bricks.

[@kevycanavan]

The forgiveness was there. The friendship was there for the taking and then Roger had to go fuck it all up again. That moment when Dave put his head on rogers shoulder :(

[@experience5988]

Roger could simply say at the end "Pink Floyd is bigger than me, it was bigger than Syd, and it might be bigger than anybody else".

[@danielmansfield3296]

Seeing David lean on Roger means a lot too me!

[@HeckTo]

2:10 I think Nick is having a pie without the crust

[@neo_devaney]

Haha, that's a very good one!

[@zacharylore3400]

From Live Aid to this show, Roger and David we’re getting along pretty well. I wonder what happened. They are at loggerheads again. Nick has said that Roger doesn’t respect David, but Roger says he offered a peace plan that was rejected. However he didn’t discuss what the peace plan entailed.

[@MKMousanz]

Sadly, it seems like Roger's ego is still getting in the way of things at times

[@juuso2248]

I wonder the same thing! They seemed to get along very well, but now in 2021 they hate each other again. Wtf?

[@saraheart2804]

I think Roger realizes the greatness of David and the wonderful work of Pink Floyd. I would think David realizes the same thing about Roger. They aren't idiots. But that doesn't mean they can get along.

[@litgamer6205]

1:03 Wow David sounds like he recorded that yesterday, Roger not so much

[@biegebythesea6775]

I think Roger actually likes David.

[@khrii02002]

El solo hecho de verlos juntos, ese abrazo... dejando atras todas las diferencias es emocionante da lo mismo si vuelven a crear juntos pero verlos sin rencores ya es gratificante....Yo al menos pude ver en vivo a Roger Waters.......grandes maestros Roger, Nick y David y que en paz descanse Richard.

[@luchboxer]

I like to think this was the happy ending of these 3 legends. all of them laughing and having a hug singing "outside the wall" (the most beautiful message on The Wall if you ask me) in front of a crumbled wall. 11 years later and now they're estranged again. what a pity it is. I really hope they can forgive each other one last time before it's too late.

[@Saffronelle]

0:13 - Roger's favourite view. #rogdave69lovefest

[@rizope4281]

This is so beautiful

[@castlewhale4746]

Gotten a chance to see both Roger and Nick live, both shows were absolutely fantastic. Rog's show was fantastic, felt like I'd stepped into a recording of a peak Pink Floyd Live show. The man still puts on an amazing live performance, really knows how to turn a show into an experience and create an epic atmosphere. Very intense and aggressive and extremely Rog. Nick's show was fantastic for different reasons. It felt like I had managed to show up to a live performance from before Pink Floyd got big. Much smaller venue with much less people, but still an amazing show. Lots of psychedelic visuals, Atom Heart Mother, Saucerful of Secrets, Astronomy Domine, Set the Controls For the Heart of the Sun. I can also die happily now having heard Echoes performed live. Would love to get to see David too, but my real dream is to get one chance to see them all together again. I would go anywhere in the world for that.

[@genatzvalee]

First they sang "To know him is to love him" back in 2010, than they did THIS!! The sweetest video! So heart-warming! Such a pleasure to see them like this. See, they CAN get along when they try their best. It panned out beautifully. They could give performances now and then to their fans delight. Next time Roger should surprisingly appear at David's concert to perform "High Hopes" together - it'd be so unusual and refreshing.

[@bryan9587]

*then

[@tiago2189]

Roger came with an idea for peace back in june 2019, but David didn’t care

[@anishtimanna88]

tears roll down my cheeks! :')

[@lisalisa842]

There’s a love/hate relationship there.

[@Jacob-tj8ig]

Between 2005 and 2011 somewhere it really seemed like they were on better terms. Especially after Rick and Syd died, it seemed like they were trying to be more humble. A reunion without Rick would never have happened anyway, but there could have been more beautiful moments like this for the fans. But then Roger had to start jabbing again and David is not exactly known for putting up with his bullshit. Sad really.

[@scottren.8492]

Read nearly all the comments here & it seems most blame Gilmour for the bickering & saying the music doesn't come first with the likes of Rogers mostly Animals, The Wall, Pros. & Cons, The Final Cut. Floydies are forgetting the music did build Floyd previous to this. Animals onwards was Rogers angry, dominating, fighting period till 85' when he walked out on his own work & cauad so much damage to the remaining band members. Wright said this in an interview about Roger. 'Animals was when the trouble started l.' Wright is ironically right about Waters. And Gilmour has said similar also. PF is a joint effort. The problem will never die because the all have such big ego.'s. Pink Floyd was s band. Not Roger. Not Gilmour.

[@oneofspades]

One more time. Gotta have one more time.

[@michaelparry2085]

Just make peace and put on a few shows for your fans. None of us are getting younger!!

[@JohnCane147]

That was before Gilmour changed the password of the PF website

[@AngelStratocaster]

Lástima que otra vez están con sus riñas y peleas por tonterías... 😢

[@ivantopolcic]

But the tensions rose again, ah my virgo virgo

[@85geoffm]

Over fucking liner notes that Roger wanted when the band never had liner notes before. We ALL KNOW it was your album aside from Dogs, brother. Let it go. Ugh.

[@IkmelAAA]

Thank you very much indeed.

[@ricardoalbertotorreszuniga]

nadie podra volver a recrear algo parecido a lo que creo pink floyd, es único

[@speedandglue_]

try to don't cry

[@xero_theory7056]

Oh I miss this😭

[@jeffrobodeenyehcmon5925]

The wall tour all together for Richard's memory, how epic would that be.

[@meatbagAZ]

My favorite part 1:56-1:58 ( :

[@rickfrancis5480]

May be one of the best videos showing there friendship

[@Sixpakbee-lb3dm]

Ngl this video nearly made me tear up.... To see them put aside their differences and to be smiling is a dream come true

[@ashiqmanzoor7774]

million thnx for uploading this.... such priceless

[@GabrielBernardo1]

Made me cry a bit ngl lol

[@TerryTerryTerry]

Having Waters put an arm around you must be like feeling the clutch of the Grim Reaper

[@coltonyou1060]

Why couldn’t they be this way all the time ?? Good to see this. If they ever see this . Life is to short u all need to be this way all the time . It all don’t matter what happened or who’s better or who owns Floyd what matters Is it takes u both to make what we all love .

[@tubistathiago]

Eles podia se reunir novamente e tocar another brick in the wall novamente putz muito show !

[@jimikguitar]

They did look Nice together

[@sintrastes]

1:56 crying

[@shadiyousefian]

I love it. They should always perform together.

[@peteytwofinger]

this is some exquisite footage

[@nicolasfernandez3731]

5:05 what did he say about himself?

[@SuperTicklemonsters]

paraphrasing here but "30 years ago when david and nick and i first did this i was a rather grumpy person and disaffected by rock and roll audiences as david will attest. but all that's changed i couldn't be happier to be here with these 13 people and all of you"

[@ciukino68]

is anyone able not to cry ???

[@JS-us4di]

me, I'm not... 😢💕

[@charliefm826]

GE Smith that man is everywhere

[@SuperLA46]

WOW.

[@roberthicks3690]

For Richard & Syd!✊🏻

[@fatimafigueroa7725]

?

[@luisdeleon2905]

For the life of me. This was in 2011, all bs seemed to be put to rest, I never thought they would reunite and make albums or tour together, and I was fine with that, I was just glad that there was some civility. I have no idea where all the recent hostility showed up between them again over the past 4 or so years. It’s just sad.

[@geoffreymerrifield5666]

Members of Pink Floyd living out the drama of relationship challenges. We can be kind, encouraging, grateful, or we can be petty, nitpicky, negative....

[@dodiablo0]

1:55 cute

[@hektikal]

Isn't there a full version of this recording? Can't be only this.. i mean i hope there is more 😊

[@hamiltondossantoscosta6921]

❤

[@steveperidotdragon4296]

Great to see The Pink Floyd Back Together .!!. Even Though Richard Didn't Make It, He Did Do Live 8 With The Floyd RIP Richard . You Will Not Be Forgotten.

[@eversut1]

We have an idiom in Turkish: "Old friends will never be enemies".

[@Toxic562Waste]

Best friends till the end!!!

[@pesperepus]

What happened to their relationship after 2011? They seemed great here and then?

[@Boatzerama]

It was an epic night.

[@biegebythesea6775]

Roger is far more affectionate than Dave. He tries to put his arm around him, pays him compliments. Dave is very, very cold. He seems like a good family man, though. I wonder if it's because the cameras are there.

[@Mar-up7db]

What a shame...

[@carloshenriquebastossilva8387]

Wonderful

[@ibisqo]

im crying so hard i want them back together please i wasnt even alive when they were a group this is so sad

[@Realbillball]

Dave and Roger - being friends is better than not being friends. You both know it!

[@scottgraham4683]

I missed that by one night. I was there at the previous evening show. Don't get me wrong it was a fantastic show, but I'd love to have seen the three of them together on stage, and hear David play Comfortably Numb again.

[@ggghhhbbnjjjbb2330]

Dave comes over as such a gentleman. Even the singing voice is all sweetness and gentleness. I'd guess that in his younger years you wouldn't want to get on his bad side though.

[@riccardo1110]

1:58 stop world

[@hectormorales2617]

all that to get the lyrics wrong. 😏