Dear U2, What Are You Thinking?

In this video I discuss U2's ridiculous decision to go on without drummer Larry Mullen Jr. for their upcoming Las Vegas residency.
📚The Beato Ultimate Bundle - $99 FOR ALL OF Rick's Courses. Get it here: ⇢ rickbeato.com
📘- The Beato Book Interactive - $99.00 value
🎸 - Beato Beginner Guitar - $159.00 value
👂- The Beato Ear Training Program - $99.00 value
🎸- The Quick Lessons Pro Guitar Course - $79.00 value
… all for just $99.00
Get it here: rickbeato.com
Catherine Sundvall
Clark Griswold
Ryan Twigg
LAWRENCE WANG
Martin Small
Kevin Wu
Robert Zapolis
Jeremy Kreamer
Sean Munding
Nat Linville
Bobby Alcott
Peter Glen
Robert Marqusee
James Hurster
John Nieradka
Grey Tarkenton
Joe Armstrong
Brian Smith
Robert Hickerty
comboy
Peter DeVault
Phil Mingin
Tal Harber
Rick Taylor
Bill Miller
Gabriel Karaffa
Brett Bottomley
Frederick Humphrey
Nathan Hanna
Stephen Dahl
Scott McCroskey
Dave Ling
Rick Walker
Jason Lowman
Jake Stringer
Steven crawford
Piush Dahal
Jim Sanger
Brian Lawson
Eddie Khoriaty
Vinny Piana
J.I. Abbot
Kyle Dandurand
Michael Krugman
Vinicius Almeida
Lars Nielsen
Kyle Duvall
Alex Zuzin
tom gilberts
Paul Noonan
Scott Thompson
Kaeordic Industries LLC
Duane Blake
Kai Ellis
Zack Kirkorian
Joe Ansaldi
Pzz
Marc Alan
Rob Kline
Calvin Wells
David Trapani
Will Elrics
Debbie Valle
JP Rosato
Orion Letizi
Mike Voloshen
Peter Pillitteri

[@RickBeato]

I think most people are missing the point to this post. My issue isn’t a replacement drummer as much as the fact that they took out an ad during the Super Bowl to promote a gig that one of the four members is not going to play. This extended video ad shows all these new fans (and one old one) to U2 that are desperate to hear the Achtung Baby record. If it’s so important for these “new fans” to hear, U2 play this particular record, isn’t it important to include all the original band members? Is this something that could’ve been advertised on U2.com and not the biggest sporting event in the US? Bands replace members or have musicians fill in all the time but they don’t advertise these gigs on the Super Bowl. As a long time, U2 fan, I thought it was an odd move. Larry is the driving force behind the band. The were a stadium band because of him.

[@castortrovador]

Sad! So sad ... :(

[@brianmiller1077]

The one thing I could think of it's the production company that took the ad out and not the band or management.

[@mijwil]

Nope. Don't think its important. Just My opinion. The Eagles played without Glen Frey. How big of a missing piece is that? If its a business strategy to get new fans, then we'll see how that plays out. Maybe its a fail. Maybe its not. No matter how much we appreciate drummers and their contribution, non-musicians and the majority of the music purchasing public see U2 as Bono and the Edge. That is insanely inaccurate, but I'm a musician and appreciate the entire band. I think of Zeppelin. The drummer is gone, they're done outside of a one-off here and there. But that is a rare decision. Just a fact. I don't believe the Little River Band has any original members. Anyway, an Ad is just a business strategy. With the size of the audience, I can see them getting the investment back. With how tight these guys have been since they're kids and what I perceive as a decent moral character, its had to imagine this wasn't planned by the entire band. If they get 1m people to download Achtung Baby, they're hearing the original band. Seems like a reasonable trade off especially if the guy left out wants the band to do it. My 2 cents which is worth even less than that.

[@Lynkevmusic]

If the drummer is unwell, there's not a lot to do, as they say, the show must go on.

[@mafcarvalho]

Spot on, Rick! Larry Mullen Jr. has back surgery and recovery to do this year and he already commented a few months ago that if the band is touring in 2023, they can't count with him. Personal health issues are way more important! The fact that the band had this residency planned together with the guys at the Sphere since the beginning of the project, and possibly having to pay for damages in the case of not performing, can be one of the reasons for their ridiculous decision. Also requirements from their latest signature/extension of the contract with the label could be. What I have to say is that U2 started do go seriously downhill with the release of SOI. Continued their descent with SOE and now their S.O.S request is really hard to swallow. Achtung Baby should be a worldwide tour like the Joshua Tree 2017 anniversary! For us older fans and also newer ones. Not a show in the place where bands go to die... And not without a band member who is the beloved founder of all. Larry said that touring is only to be done while it's being fun. It takes a huge toll on their health (drummers suffer a lot), personal lives, etc. I suppose that the replacement drummer isn't going to have as much fun as he thinks. Bono's super inflated ego isn't going to be easy on him...

[@michaellewchuk8272]

From what I understand the band still hasn’t found what they are looking for.

[@surfrby8876]

That was good lol

[@roberthickerty390]

Maybe they should stop looking where the streets have no name.

[@Divertedflight]

Slaps back of Michael's head.

[@DISCONNECT83]

Maybe someday they will go over the edge.🤷🏼‍♂️

[@aaronknight9759]

…I will follow…the money…

[@TimothyHurleyNY]

U2 may have committed to opening the sphere before the construction went at least a year beyond schedule. They were probably contractually bound to opening the venue. Further, the development of the very technology being used may have been heavily dependent on U2's residency and all the multimedia used, developed, and tested just to get it working. Most importantly though, U2 is a four-piece equal partnership operation. It used to be 5-equal before manager Paul McGuinness retired. Nothing gets done in this band without Larry's approval. They have at least 2 albums ready to come out. Their future is a long-range campaign, probably planned years in advance and opening the most revolutionary high-tech concert space is a MUST-DO for them. In my opinion, Larry likely had a huge part in this decision and very likely a very huge part in selecting Bram van den Berg as the drummer to stand in for him. Larry's not just the band's drummer. He's the founder and 25% owner. I'm sure Larry is 100% cool with this. And if you disagree, you should probably speak to Larry Mullen Jr. about it. Love ya, Rick.

[@wilmascholte7607]

Yeah, that's the hunch I had too after the first "what the" wore off. Plus why would they break the band over performing songs from a record that brought them back together. Doesn't make sense. Considering how many drummers end up with physical issues and Larry being known to be having trouble for ages, I just hope that whatever issue is preventing Larry from participating isn't too serious, ditto if it's personal and not medical.

[@aerochicc]

That was my gut feeling as well. While they have a phenomenal drummer for this particular show, I hope Larry is able to fully recover!

[@2bluemoonalpha]

- 💯❗️

[@larrycioffi6025]

This (above)! I think the venue and timing of their commitment had alot to do with their agreement to do this. I am a drummer, and was at the Sphere for their last show on March 2. It was unlike anything I've seen or heard before. Still processing it. @rickbeato - I am a huge fan of your channel. Here is a suggestion - do a video on Bram van der berg and how he totally nailed this gig. He was amazing!

[@honewhetstone1732]

💯

[@jkm9332]

In over 40 years, this is the first time Larry's called in sick. I think we can give the band a break.

[@helmutsecke3529]

You actually claim to think?

[@jkm9332]

@@helmutsecke3529 Yes.

[@paulguitar100]

@@JOSEPH-vs2gc Oh FFS

[@guyrelax]

called in sick and getting PAID

[@jkm9332]

@@guyrelax PTO is a real thing. And a good thing.

[@coda1970]

"It's no secret ambition bites the nails of success" The Fly - U2

[@TheMainChain]

Underrated comment 🌟

[@user-vx5vo3gs2w]

"It's no secret that the stars are falling from the sky"

[@rajbhatti8248]

This comment didn’t age well.

[@hajimeminatodani4835]

The real 5th member is Terry Lawless who plays all the keys and triggers loops from beneath the stage. A true legend of a guy

[@moogy77]

Keeping him under the stage is SO 80's and such bullshit! The Stones have Chuck Levell on stage, no big deal. All you do is tuck him in the back a bit. Aerosmith does the same like the Stones.

[@joelsislak5334]

We need more people under the stage triggering loops. What a joke, you serious he's vital? I don't think The Beatles did that or Zeppelin.

[@paulmurphy8993]

Did not know that...very interesting.

[@InspirationSessions]

The Edge would be nothing without looper pedals!

[@fu6817]

@@moogy77 But he's part of the crew, not the band, or something like that. Theer's no bullshit, working men doing work.

[@Zundfolge]

My fear is that this means that Larry's health problems are much worse than they're letting on. :(

[@BassByTheBay]

That's the first thing I thought 🙁.

[@2Scoopz]

Same. I mean if he's having surgery, would wouldn't you just wait for him to recover? Certainly Bono can't be out of money!

[@steveb6718]

Took covid vaccine... enough said

[@spanishpeaches2930]

@@2Scoopz They might well have contractual issues to perform .

[@TimStatic]

he's having surgery and needs time to recover. he's not a young guy any more either 🤷‍♂️

[@bluejay145]

The fact that Larry could not play due to a back injury was made clear well in advance. I found that out on general media. I've been a fan for many decades. As I am a Beatles fan. I was at the sphere the second night. 14 hours travel each ways for a 3 night stay. It was great beyond belief, without Larry who was badly missed. Bram van den Berg was superb ! As a bass player myself have loads of respect how he gelled with Adam, which must have been a big ask. During the gig they threw a song at him he had not rehearsed to keep him on his toes. It was raw. Just brilliant. Bram van den Berg is not Larry and will never replace him, but give him credit. He was playing in front of the most amazing spolight I've ever seen.... Respect for Bram van den Berg

[@bartobruintjes7056]

👍

[@alexandriaocasio-smollett5078]

Nice! What random song did they throw at him? Just curious.

[@gijsandersvanstraalen9916]

Bram grooved incredible hard with respect for the original parts Larry played. Great, great job Bram, congrats!!

[@SeanApplePie]

Yeah I am Dutch too. Bram deed het goed hoor!

[@margaretsch.3609]

Yes he has been nailing it big time.

[@andrewworrall4302]

agreed

[@RuthlessMojo]

Larry Mullen has been suffering from back problems since the 80’s. It is something he has struggled with for a long time. As someone who has chronic back problems (I have two metal rods in my spine) I can understand where he’s coming from. Ultimately this was done with Larry’s blessing. He’s not being permanently replaced. I imagine that this residency has been in the works for awhile. They probably signed contracts a long time ago and are therefore committed to it.

[@tedlaukaitis]

Agreed. I do wish they’d address it more thoroughly. Nuance is dead…

[@iresentdoingthis1550]

Thank you for having a brain and heart, sorry to hear about your back pain, if it's legal in your area look into CBD not a cure but it helps

[@irishRocker1]

Yeah maybe it's also booked out for the following year too so they can't postpone etc.

[@5roundsrapid263]

I have scoliosis, but it’s minor compared to some. Sitting on a stool for 2-3 hours is the worst thing for it. Every night would be horrific.

[@rorshakks]

Yep it took him decades to realize he should have been using a drum throne with a back on it.

[@anninwhack1998]

I will never forget the first time I listened to Unforgettable Fire w my little sister. We were sitting on the floor with our ears next to the speakers of our parents giant furniture stereo. The opening drum sequence to a sort of homecoming still gives me chills.

[@ericwfriesen]

“And you know it’s time to go…” I had the cassette and still feel like I’m 17 when that song comes on. Chills is right.

[@joelrivardguitar]

The Unforgettable Fire is the best album, possibly the best pop record ever. Joshua Tree was close and got more attention but UF is amazing.

[@whiterabbit5807]

In most movies and cartoons, good triumphs over evil. Most people enjoy such movies and cartoons. It is because people love good. Study, work, exercise, illness, etc. cause stress. Stress creates an evil mind and leads to evil actions. Most people are good, but stress breeds bad thoughts and bad behavior. Give peace to all people by freeing them from study, work, exercise and disease.

[@connyjohnson855]

@@joelrivardguitar Agree! That's what I'm always saying 👍

[@therapist6328]

That is the first CD i bought with my own money.

[@Cherokeelion]

Seeing them live during the Joshua Tree tour in 87 at 17 is one of those timeless memories. They were fantastic live back then. I can understand them missing the connection with the crowd from the stage, and Im guessing Larry gives his blessing… if he didnt want them to go without him I dont think they would.

[@treeherder2201]

LM Jr is a criminally underrated drummer.

[@ScottJamesLIve]

Underrated by who?

[@gabrielpaiva9070]

Not even close.

[@gigidemontesquieu4670]

He inspired me to become a drummer!

[@ROBERTINI77]

Not the most technical, not the most virtuoso, but his sense of tempo is simply Insane! He keeps on tempo better than a nuclear watch!!

[@stuartcarswell2815]

​@@ROBERTINI77that's Steve Lillywhite's influence ...got him on the click for the 3rd record..as a drummer myself it's the best thing I learned to do over 30 years ago..groove with a click

[@kevinalexander4487]

I love U2. And can't believe I'm saying this. But there is no way I'd go see them for that show. I saw them in 2017 for the Joshua Tree Tour. And their first song that night is burned in my memory. Larry Mullen, Jr walked out on stage, by himself, and kicked off Sunday Bloody Sunday. How could U2 do a show without him? Well, they can't. Because it's not U2 without any one of those band members. Period.

[@Alpha_7227]

They have lost all integrity. For 1. Playing Vegas like some cabaret hasbeen cruise group, 2. Continuing without Larry. Thats, ridiculous.

[@eldondaetweiler61]

Well said.

[@steveelling9604]

He apparently needs multiple surgeries. I remember when Cheap Trick elected to continue playing live gigs when Bun E. Carlos didn't want to tour anymore. Then I saw them live and they still kicked ass and they're older than Bono, Edge, etc. It's been four years since U2 had a gig. They want to play and I'm fine with it. Not many bands formed in the '70s have their original lineup. I'd definitely pay to see the Vegas shows.

[@steveelling9604]

@@Alpha_7227 Aerosmith, Def Leppard, Kiss, Sammy Hagar and dozens of legacy acts play Vegas. It's easier on the band and crew because they don't have to travel. Bono is 62. The road is a grind.

[@thomastucker5686]

As a drummer approaching 60, the stamina is becoming difficult and my heart goes out of rhythm and takes me out for a whole day at times. Fans just don't understand how hard drumming is. I can still put on a solid performance, but it is now twice as hard. I couldn't do multiple shows every day, no way. I don't think I could do a one hour show every day. I think the Vegas shows are not just once a week or something? That said, I could play guitar multiple shows every day. I could sing the same. I play guitar since age 5 even though drums are my primary instrument. I am planning switching to guitar when drumming is no longer possible which is coming quickly. I mean drumming at a very high energy, like Rush, which is my style.

[@howardscott7521]

The Beatles toured with a fill in drummer when Ringo was sick. If they could do it, I see no reason why U2 couldn’t.

[@twkotb]

I love to see deep Beatles trivia like this… kudos!! However, I think that example is a bit different. The Beatles most likely were already contractually obligated to those venues. Also, they were at a critical point in their career - if they didn’t constantly appear publicly, the public might move on to the next thing and they would be yesterday’s news. U2 are an established brand international brand and have been for decades. However, as I write this I’m imagining U2 worrying that because of covid and their dwindling brand recognition amongst young people, they need to do something big now, and can’t afford to wait for Larry to be available. They wanna stay massive and can’t afford to wait another year to make a major statement. Also maybe the contract with Sphere is something they’re locked into from a while back. So in conclusion, I actually agree with you lol

[@howardscott7521]

Jimmie Nicol filled in on a 1964 tour during the absolute zenith of Beatlemania, so I think The Beatles had even more to lose. I’m sure lots of fans weren’t happy that Ringo wasn’t there. I saw them live in 1966, and I’m very happy all four were there. Like you say, I think we are basically in agreement. Beatles forever!

[@ryukan250]

Because U2 are completely out of touch with modern music. If they can't adapt without their safe as houses drummer, they should just hang up their boots and ride off into the sunset. How did King Crimson survive without Bill Bruford? They got Gavin Harrison to cover him. How did Black Sabbath continue touring without Bill Ward? They got Mike Bordin in. How did Dream Theater adapt without Mike Portnoy on drums? Etc etc

[@hendrikheemels8615]

Exactly

[@mccallosone4903]

agreed

[@justinwideman3471]

Not everyone has the grace to leave the stage on top like REM did.

[@tparker2095]

Or Rush

[@Tusitala1967]

Even REM carried on without Bill Berry for 13 years, but I get your point.

[@richardclark6858]

I think REM went on a bit too long..

[@richardclark6858]

On top would have been Green..

[@Tusitala1967]

@@richardclark6858 That's a little harsh, but I won't argue with you. I've been a fan since Chronic Town. Saw them live twice right before Reckoning came out and right after. I am much more a fan of the older stuff.

[@MoGhotbi]

The Drum intro to "bullet the blue sky" is as iconic as John Bonham's intro to "when the levee breaks". Just as Led Zeppelin couldn't go on without Bonzo, I don't see how U2 can go on without LMJr.

[@brivington2011]

I respectfully disagree with you on your statement about the drum into for "Bullet the Blue Sky" being as iconic as the one in "When the Levee Breaks". That's just not the reality.

[@MoGhotbi]

@@brivington2011 I respect your assessment. What I meant was that both are two bars of unaccompanied drums that are instantly recognizable and unmistakeable.

[@IdeologieUK]

I agree with Bruce, it’s not on the same tier as Levee, but Sunday Bloody Sunday absolutely is!

[@makemarker]

​@@IdeologieUK yeah, Sunday Bloody Sunday with it's military style of drumming is definitely the most signature U2 drum sound.

[@jmm8229]

I completely agree with you there. It's off centre, dirty, punchy, confrontational even.... As a song intro, its def. as iconic & important as the best of them. Certainly hooked my ear in 1987...(the whole song is utterly tremendous)I'm a drummer, I would say Mullen was my main influence when i was 8/9 drumming his beats on my bed (before I'd a kit).

[@guttsgeargarage3337]

I am a drummer and I appreciate your support and respect for how important the role of and the person drumming is!

[@zonachoke]

Especially in what is, essentially, an instrumental trio ( a 1-guitar rock band). The drummer has to add depth. That's the hardest thing to replace in a rock band (think Foo Fighters). If ALL they perform in the Residency is songs from Achtung Baby, that's 12 songs. Assuming the fill-in is a real pro... he probably needs a minimum of a day with the band per song just to prevent things from getting sloppy -- and another day per song to get it tight. Do you think Bono, Edge, and Adam have been rehearsing with the new guy 8 hours a day 5 days a week for 5 weeks to justice to the material? Maybe, but I wouldn't bet on it.

[@fatsuperfly]

@@zonachoke very much agree! Really depends on the style, and a band like this ... Idk. Gonna be odd for sure.

[@kayzinti4452]

Yup! "The Who" without Keith Moon is an oxymoron.

[@godbyone]

But what isn’t thinking is. The drummer doesn’t want to play anymore and rest of the band does. What’s wrong with that

[@axnyslie]

@@kayzinti4452 The Who without Moon and Entwistle is a tribute band.

[@andzwe]

Understandable, though listening to this makes me feel a bit sorry for Dutch drummer Bram van den Berg, who will replace Mullen and can't wait to play with the band. He's been a huge U2 fan since he was a kid, so it's a once in a life-time dream come true.

[@BBRemixes]

I love that Bram gets this chance, and sure he'll do great. But if you've been a U2 fan for a long time (with the narrative) this is a bit odd

[@Durwood71]

And people are going to hate him for it. Sad but true.

[@martinheath5947]

Doing this is a terrible gig for anyone by any measure.

[@WarunkiMedia]

Yes, this gig will be a blessing and a cruse! Also see my comment above.

[@fluffskunk]

I'm sure he's play his part dead-on, and it'll be a career boost. But doing this at all is a bad decision. I find it particularly cringy that their ad showed fans who probably can't afford to go see this residency, even. But that's what I expect from hopelessly out-of-touch mega-millionaires.

[@renevandalen96]

And then..there was the more than fantastic Bram van den Berg...what a great drummer..and in full respect to Larry.

[@timwalsh8954]

It seems as if nobody here gets it. There is only one Grand Opening, only 1 first show in a venue like the sphere. Nobody has seen anything like it. It was an honor for them.

[@thomasmorganproject]

When Phil Collins, at age 70, slowly walked out to sit on a stool and sing for Genesis as his son played drums, I realized what a toll a lifetime of drumming takes on the body. If LMJ needs some tweaks to play later in life, I hope he has the best surgeries and recoveries.

[@perfektspace]

I hear what you are saying but Phil Collins abused his body with alcohol and generally took terrible care of himself leading to the embarrassment that was his farewell tour. Drumming was the least of his issues. I get the impression Mullen took pretty good care of himself. He always looked fit and fresh. I'm sure he will get back out there.

[@99bigjim]

Phil Collins used more drum machines during his solo career than he played live. Give me a break about the wear and tear :)

[@harsimaja9517]

I don't think it was the drumming that did that

[@infinitysconcinnity2418]

Add the late, great Neil Peart to that mix. The effects of raw drumming on his joints (in addition to suffering and eventually sadly succumbing to brain cancer) definitely affected him in the mid-late 2010s. Drumming and touring, day in and day out can absolutely take its toll. RIP Neil!

[@himoffthequakeroatbox4320]

Yes I'm sure drumming caused that, and it had nothing to do with the fact that he's 70. 🤡 🙄 🤦

[@AndTheRoadGoesEverOn]

To be fair, this gig has apparently been in the works a very long time. With a contract, designed sets & production, people sub-contracted & everything. The band didn’t plan on doing it without Larry. And I know he’s given his blessing to the other three members to proceed & honor their contract-I just wish if they must preform without any member of the four, that they’d do it under another name. U2 are unique in rock for their longevity & NEVER having any lineup changes for 43 yrs. It’s a shame, because I love the album Achtung Baby so much. And I still love U2. Legends. GET WELL SOON, LARRY.

[@adesertsojourner8015]

Technically Adam Clayton's bass tech filled in for 1 show during the Zoo tour, but yeah I do agree with you

[@marcalvarez4890]

"do it under another name" U 1.75

[@Sons_of_Nesreka]

There was one in Sidney 1993 without Adam but for the 40 shows that I saw so far I can tell Larry was always behind the drumkit

[@jamesetling944]

Well, since he's not actually leaving the band...he may well come out and sing on occasion. My fandom goes back to when Kev started playing cassette tapes of Boy and October in his Isuzu Trooper when we were in high school. Also saw what I believe was the initial live performance of The Dalton Brothers in 1987 in Indianapolis.

[@dominiccrimmings6925]

@@marcalvarez4890 Well given the name is U2, if you remove a quarter of it, it would be U1.5 - just sayin, maths and all that

[@seattlesauce]

Love the channel Rick! I CAN believe how much it's grown over the last couple years I've been watching. Keep it up!

[@Dreldven]

Larry Mullen Jr. is the drummer that made me want to play drums. I have a hard time thinking of U2 without him. It just feels wrong.

[@texanperry]

Yes! It's like Led Zeppelin without John Bonham.

[@thetoiletinspector6878]

Same here. I started taking drum lessons at High School because of Larry Mullen.

[@ScottH.]

It sure does. I dont understand this decision at all. Just wait for cripes sake.

[@JohnSmiththe66th]

I remember seeing U2 3D at an Imax theatre. The opening shot was Larry Mullen Jr.'s drum set from above - a really great visual. I did not realize he would not be playing in Vegas. Wasn't he the one who jumped into a cab at he end of the video for I Still Haven't Found What I 'm Looking For video???? If I can get a ticket to see them in Vegas I will, and I will bend over to accept the price of the ticket - no lube required. I saw them during the 360 tour - and that was one of the best concerts I have ever seen (Weird Al's Mandatory Fun and Roger Water's The Wall make up the Top 3).

[@gigidemontesquieu4670]

He inspired me to be a drummer too!

[@vanderploegsander]

Lets turn this around with historical perspective. How many great bands haven't toured an amazing album/show without one of its band members?

[@Jaco927]

U2 is one of those bands where every member brings a unique flavor to the band. Larry Mullen Jr's drums are iconic. I can hear the drums right now in Sunday, Bloody Sunday without listening to it. It's amazing drumming. So iconic. I agree with you on this, Rick. Not having Larry in the band when Larry is fully capable is a misstep. Give him the time off to rest and recoup and then hit it. Don't replace.

[@5roundsrapid263]

I’ve never been a huge U2 fan, but Sunday, Bloody Sunday is amazing.

[@forskelligt2541]

And thank you for putting that in my head as well - also without listening (and not only the drums ;) )

[@offisk]

They made two good/satisfactory records in the start and bored us for the next thirty years. That is not iconic. Iconic is influential, well considered , evolving over time but not contrived snooze rock coupled with political tokenism. Z

[@dickcnormis1444]

@@offiskU2 and Pearl Jam are similar, great early records and nothing but crap for the last 30 years.

[@Nightrelic]

The sound of the the drums on that album was as much Steve Lilywhite as it was Larry Mullen, Jr. listen to anything Lilywhite produced during that period and the drums have that same raw edge. A good example is Simple Minds Sparkle In The Rain album.

[@tbro421]

Bram first couple of nights had struggles with tempo or following the click. But he settled in and has done a very formidable job. I did not miss Larry and I’m sure Larry coached Bram to do the gig. I’mglad they did the residency in this incredible new venue. I’m sure they missed Larry but it was definitely full blown U2 up on that stage. The only absolutely irreplaceable guys in U2 are Bono and Edge.

[@sylsalas]

I am with you , I have been in 3 of the shows in Vegas and I can say also I didn’t miss Larry .. Bram is an excellent drummer.

[@progressiveimplantologyper8183]

@@sylsalas Three times here too and I wish it had been many more. LM was there at the last show I went to and the crowd went wild. That would have been the second to last night of the series.

[@danmaja6275]

I remember being in a Music store in 1983 and they played the video for New Years Day, I was transfixed, Been a U2 fan since. depending on the day, different albums are my favourite, but War, The Unforgettable Fire, Joshua Tree, are far and away my favourites. I can't imagine them playing without Larry Mullen Jr., much like I can't imagine Rush playing without Neil Peart. I don't fault them, just don't know if I would pay to see them.

[@Speedo2550]

Larry is a one of a kind drummer who ads something totally unique to the band. Has to be there.

[@jimbojones101]

He is shite. Tosser.

[@ak47dragunov]

He wrote amazing parts, but live they are far from difficult to replicate

[@CandiceJoergan]

Absolutely correct. I certainly wouldn't go if Larry wasn't there. Surprised they are doing this.. Bono is loaded so he doesn't need the money that badly.

[@plaubelmakina8916]

If Keith Moon didn’t have to be there, I doubt Larry does.

[@CourtWatchAu]

@@CandiceJoergan Its bot about the money its about wanting to keep playing live. If a member is sick or passes , then trying a replacement is fair eg Motley replaced Mick Mars with John 5 due to Micks health, Quuen replaced Freddy, ACDC replaced BonScott . Why is rick complaining if Larry is sick ?

[@ThePoorBoy]

I'd have a problem with this if Larry asked them to wait so that he could fully recover, but he's given the band his blessing to move forward. If anything, I'd say it's a pretty selfless move so that U2 fans don't have to keep waiting to see the band live (and there are still a lot of younger U2 fans who have never seen them live). A lot of things can happen in a year or two, and the band isn't getting any younger. Plus, it's not out of the ordinary for someone to fill in for a band member. Things happen, but to quote a Queen song, the show must go on...

[@carlosdelgado8442]

Event the Beatles used a substitute drummer for a few gigs...

[@lilycat1694]

It’s not U2 without Larry Mullen Jr. He is my favorite member of the band.

[@jenniferdragolic4519]

Rick, Larry had surgery and is recuperating !! That's why they have a stand in playing with them !! Don't worry he's not leaving the band just recuperating!!

[@paulmurphy8993]

This band moves in mysterious ways.

[@fatlu1378]

too many Egos...

[@rodruvalcaba]

I loved so much when a free u2's album appeared in my iTunes. It turned to be my favorite album from them... weeks later I went to the store to buy it physical.

[@jkm9332]

Same!

[@ericMT]

Wow. It’s great to hear a positive story about that situation. All I ever hear is complaining.

[@rodruvalcaba]

@@jkm9332 Glad to know someone that likes the album!

[@rodruvalcaba]

@@ericMT Yes, I admit it was a little weird that the devices didn't ask for permission but it was just as simple as deleting one album if you were not into it. Anyway, I loved that album so much and it was a beautiful surprise to turn on you iTunes and see a whole u2's album in your account.

[@jkm9332]

@@rodruvalcabaOH, I love that album. 1. Achtung Baby 2. ATYCLB 3. SOI

[@jacarey72]

I of course would prefer they play with Larry but being a life long fan and having not seen them live since Dec 2019, I’m still very much looking forward to this show. Especially at this new venue which will probably be amazing, and Achtung Baby is my second fav album just behind The Joshua Tree. You definitely make good points but 3 out of 4 members (as long as one is Bono) will be sufficient for me. Zoo TV tour is still the best tour I’ve ever seen. I just pray that I can get tickets.

[@filiphron3147]

Larry is my favorite U2 member. I can't imagine myself watching a show without him on the stage.

[@astrosquirrel5038]

Me too.

[@warren_r]

Same. Larry's one of the two or three drummers that made me pick up the sticks in the first place back in the 1990s.

[@jmonger]

"What are you thinking?" could define the last 20 years of U2. I say this as a massive fan in 90s/00s.

[@JL3waco]

It was actually a (potentially) brilliant move. We were at the Sphere on the first night and the technology was the show. Don't get me wrong, the music was amazing but the experience was like standing in a pair of virtual reality googles. This sets up a second residency or tour billed as Larry's return. Expect "Pop Mart - 2027" at a "Sphere" somewhere in Europe, on the 30th anniversary of that album. We'll be there.

[@gjoinolywa5850]

Did you see the show, Rick. It was a concert of a lifetime.

[@brockjennings]

A group (or artist) knowing when to leave the stage at their peak is an elusive skill. Crossing the line between relevancy to being a musical curiosity is a thin one.

[@danielpalmer6266]

The Rolling Stones crossed this line a long time ago, converting themselves to a Theme park attraction.😒

[@richatlarge462]

Up through their last tour (pre-Covid), U2 was still focused on trying to be relevant, whether or not they were perceived as such. They played new songs from their most recent albums, and filled in the rest with many songs from Achtung Baby, actually. With the exception one-off of their Joshua Tree tour, this is the first time that they're not touring in support of a new release. So in my book, they haven't yet crossed the line into a tribute band of their younger selves (which is what 99% of other bands from their era have become).

[@Vivi_9]

@@danielpalmer6266 eh I don't know, if they called it quits I'd have been too young to ever see them play live

[@niallpadden]

@@danielpalmer6266 You nailed it. Years ago, I thought I'd better go see the 'Stones' at least once before they retired. That was 1976.

[@Lance37a]

It's tough to leave at a peak when people will still pay money to watch them perform. No one wants to leave money on the table.

[@danfarrell6572]

Been a fan of the band for 30+ years. One of the most admirable and impressive things I find with U2 is their camaraderie and togetherness. The same line up without interruption for over 40 years. Simply put U2 is Bono, Adam, Larry and Edge. When Bono was injured in 2010, U2 made the decision to cancel Glastonbury. Yes it was a disappointment but if they couldn't ALL play it, then they'd wait until they could. I think it's really poor that they're willing to go ahead with the Las Vegas residency without Larry. I think it would have been better received by fans and the media (in terms of integrity and solidarity) if the band declined the gigs, saying sorry but we can't do this without Larry....maybe next year. Where is that group mentality? That integrity and loyalty? Larry was interviewed just before the Kennedy Awards and his answers appeared quite negative. Almost like he was unaware and uninformed of U2's plans for the coming year. Get the impression that Larry has decided he's had enough, Bono and Edge are desperate to continue at all costs and Adam is very torn and conflicted. Can't help feeling a bit disappointed.

[@timfear]

I'm sure they realize their opportunities for the cash grab are running out. Better get it while they can.

[@matthewcollins3887]

Graffiti augmenting a wheat-glue poster advertising their new album on the wall of a magazine shop at Prince and Sullivan in Soho sums up the calculus of U2 in the 21st Century rather perfectly: Songs of Surrender ...to the Status Quo

[@gazzaleavy]

Well said. They’re camaraderie and longevity has been part of their magic. The end must be around the corner. This, from a life long fan.

[@danfarrell6572]

Incidentally....all the songs they've pre released from Songs Of Surender, so far, all sound very bass and drums light. Larry has a very distinctive style and sound and I can't hear that on these new arrangements? I appreciate that this is a strpped back, almost acoustic interpretation of the songs but it sounds if Larry and Adam have had very little input. I've heard Edge comment on this new album and I've heard Bono comment too, but I haven't heard anything from Adam and Larry. As a musician, Edge is more than capable of playing the bass parts and the minimal drum parts for this album in the recording studio. Just wondering if Adam and Larry have had any input at all? Could this be another vanity project from Bono and Edge, to tie in with the autobiography? Or am I just being unreasonably cynical?

[@MsWAlexander1]

To be perfectly fair - it's a bit different to postpone their own tour (and in the case of Glasto, play it in 2011, which they did) than to break contract for something like this. It's also very different when it's your lead singer who is out as opposed to the drummer. And I say this as a ride-or-die U2 fan of 42 years who has seen them play 50+ times. This also isn't the first time U2 has played with a replacement (ZooTV Tour 11/26/1993) when Adam missed a gig because he went on a bender in Sydney. His bass tech, Stuart Morgan played in his place.

[@mrdave4714]

I originally thought doing the Vegas shows without Larry was a terrible idea. Since then I've seen some of the video footage from those shows and it looked and sounded amazing. This is something that took a few years to prepare for, so I can see why they couldn't postpone. Bran was a very capable replacement drummer for these shows. The fans that attended the Vegas shows looked like they enjoyed and had a good time. I had my doubts, but I was very impressed with how things turned out. Having Larry in the audience the 2nd last show and saluting him was a nice touch. Rick, keep posting these great videos.

[@kojam1]

I was a metal head when they came out. My sis friend told me I gotta hear this band. HOGWASH I said! Played me New Year's Day and I felt something that hooked me from then. Thank God I wised up!!! Soooooo many hours spent listening to them!!! Thank U U2!!!

[@mrsmck2910]

I've been a huge U2 fan for the past 43 years. Since Larry gave his blessing, I'm OK with it. They don't have a tour booked, just the residency, so my hope is that Larry will heal from his surgery and be back with the band.

[@EB-bl6cc]

yeah I don't see the huge beef Rick has here. Larry ok'ed it so it's fine

[@stephenbeeby8850]

I think this has been in the works long before Larry realised he couldn’t play! I’ve already started looking up flight costs (from Australia) for around that time. I’ve seen them play without Adam in Sydney 1993. It was fine. The guitar tech was amazing! It’ll be fine Rick, and if you are not into it, don’t go. Silly rant. 😂

[@RogerBarraud]

Good point.

[@edoardomaggiolo9464]

I was 9 when my father bought me my first drum kit, and Larry was the first drummer that fired up my imagination. Then came Ian Paice, Stewart Copeland...almost 20 years later, now I play jazz and experimental music; something that Larry probably wont like. But Larry was my gatekeeper to drumming and I still admire him a lot. Thank you Larry and I wish you all the best for your recovery. Also a big thank you from Italy to Rick for all your videos, which are super!

[@japhyryder66]

I was a U2 fan from the very beginning and was so excited to finally see them live during the Joshua Tree tour at the Fabulous Forum in L.A. I was only 21 and decided I didn’t want nosebleed seats so I spent quite a bit of money and bought tickets from a scalper (I worked a lot of overtime to do this). So, they played for ONE HOUR. One lousy hour. Part of this hour-long gig consisted of Bono berating anyone who bought their tickets from a scalper. He went so far as to call those people “losers and assholes”. I was so disappointed and pissed. Bono has gotten more and more arrogant over the years and I simply cannot stand him. Yes, I know all about his charity work, so don’t bother to tell me. Bear in mind, he wouldn’t be able to do his charity work without the money paid by hard-working people like myself. Bono can póg mo thóin.

[@edoardomaggiolo9464]

@@japhyryder66 Well sorry to say that i know i will be harsh, but form my point of view that's kind of karma thats give you back from buying a ticket form a scalper. Which isnt a good thing and for me Bono was right. Sorry to hear that the concert was not the thing that you expcted but U2 are (and still) one of the most professional band in any genre of music, so...if they did thatm they could have some good reason (maybe Bono was without his voice, which happened frequently during that tour).

[@japhyryder66]

@@edoardomaggiolo9464 So you took time out of your day to tell me I deserved what I got? You really are a tool. Bono was in fine voice at that show, and I was a very young woman who loved this band and just wanted good seats for a change. I worked extremely hard to pay for those tickets. Your shitty comment will certainly affect your karma, pal. GFY.

[@edoardomaggiolo9464]

@@japhyryder66 Well, honestly thats my opinion about scalping and people who use it. As i said my opinion could be not polite, but scalping is an issue, werether are the reasons that everyone could have to do so. And I think that Bono was right about that and you exaggerated in your resentement to him adn about that concert. Nothing personal about you, but I will not say to you that it was a good thing to do, from my point of view. As for the rest, well, I think i can use my time to respond to a comment that i persnally dont like. And as you can read, I'm not offending you...

[@chillguy2758]

Look at the venue! u2 has always pushed the boundaries of experiential concerts they couldn’t pass on this opportunity to be the first ones to perform there

[@writetovagelis1975]

6 months after...the world is glad U2 introduce the Sphere to the world and the internet is full of videos of that night - tickets start from 500$ and everybody wishes to get in. As much as i love Larry It was a briliant idea to do this.

[@thelittlecow6009]

I was skeptical, but in hindsight it was a brilliant move.

[@deanbibb3680]

The Rattle And Hum record wasn’t a misstep in my opinion. It was a solid album and the movie is incredible.

[@diarmuidkelleher5319]

"Pop" was the misstep record. A send up of tacky consumerism involving a lemon shaped........sphere?? Hmm!

[@zwerker]

Totally agree. "Heartland" is so damn atmospheric, easily among my top 10 U2 songs

[@bigdaddyminecraft2222]

Thank you, I directed the film.

[@MikkaShrednik]

Agreed. I still have the DVD.

[@michaelgriffiths8068]

The 9 studio tracks on Rattle & Hum range from epic to classic to very good. If they had included just those 9 studio tracks, it would have been a classic (easy top 5) U2 album.

[@Purplenpinkk]

Their first 5 albums are really my jam - special mention to the masterpiece of The Unforgettable Fire.

[@simes205]

After that they disappeared up their own selves.

[@jimmybootz1277]

Totally agree with you, The Unforgettable Fire is my favorite album by them as well, the title track and video still gets me emotional every time, just saying, appreciate your comment ✊🏾✊🏾✊🏾🙌🏾🙌🏾🙌🏾💯✌🏾

[@robertwiles8106]

I must be the only person who considers Zooropa to be their masterpiece.😄

[@jermnheat]

@@robertwiles8106 welllll....ummmm.....ok.....I mean it was good, had some different and brave sounds. Yeah it was good! 😊🙃😎

[@jermnheat]

Omg unforgettable fire!!! 😍 Start to finish I swear I have left this plant! Probably my absolute favorite albums of all time ever!!! Every song!!! My emotions are all over the place right now just remembering the first time I put that record on! I sat down on my bed looking at the cover and reading all the info!!! Became hypnotized by all the sounds, extra sounds even though faintly coming through, I could hear them. Ahhh. I have to go buy this now! 😩 It had gotten stolen long ago with so many other music I had collected. That's ok though! Love it!!!

[@steveharris4919]

Rick is an encyclopedia, exceptionally gifted, hard working and multi talented. Whether hes' talking about U2 or Bach his take is always amazingly refreshing and enlightening.

[@eduardosalas4794]

Love U2, specially the magical period between War & Achtung, saw them live 1st time in the amazing AB tour, will always be a special part of my musical life. Even through their ups and downs, it was always the same team, now it seems that no more and plowing through just for the sake of trying to remain relevant (& making big bucks in the process) is so just anti U2, at least the one I fell in love with. Look at Rush, when NP passed, they had the integrity to call it a day, and more power to them. Bono & Edge need to look into their hearts and stop, for the sake of their legacy. And don't get me started on the awful decision to record new versions of their classics!

[@margaretsch.3609]

They have been having a wonderful time in the Sphere and making many thousands of people very happy.

[@Gorf_Denroh]

Never thought I would see Rick reach the "old man yelling at clouds" stage, but here we are.

[@larrymullenjrband]

Rolling Stones would like a word with Rick.

[@oshima6451]

Think he has a point

[@Dreyno]

“Rattle and Hum” is a fantastic album. Captured a moment with the live stuff and the new songs were epic. “Heartland”, “All I Want Is You”, “Angel of Harlem”, “Desire”, “When Love Came to Town”, “Van Dieman’s Land”. That’s more great songs than some bands have in a career.

[@PaulTincknell]

It is a stellar album; "Heartland" is an underrated masterpiece. I think that because it came after the classic "The Joshua Tree" that it didn't meet people's unrealistic expectations. Though U2 is one of the rare bands that has knocked out 4 classic albums IMO ("War", "The Joshua Tree", "Achtung, Baby", and "All That You Can't Leave Behind").

[@Dreyno]

@@PaulTincknell I think it was just because “the Joshua Tree” was so big. As soon as you achieve that sort of success, people start tearing you down immediately.

[@marpsr]

Sorry but Rattle and Hum can’t hold a candle to their first four albums. Someone described it as if they were kids on their first visit to the RnR HoF, grabbing at every bust that crossed their paths. The film just displays their unbelievably inflated egos.

[@billhenderson2661]

I always got the feeling that the scorn people felt for this album had to do with Bono's image at the time. I was in middle school when the movie came out, and I fully went for it, loved the album, had the other songs from the movie that did not make the album on tape, and played that amazing version of Sunday Bloody Sunday all the time. I watched the movie for the first time in a decade during the pandemic, and I was like "oh, yeah, he is kinda insufferable in this" I still love the album, tho

[@PaulTincknell]

@@marpsr I grew up with them - same age - and "Rattle & Hum" didn't achieve the heights of their first four; it was never meant to. It was a grab bag of leftovers, experiments, and explorations of rock that influenced them that allowed them to leave that phase behind and create "Achtung, Baby". But there is a lot of great material on it, and the live stuff rips. Give it a fair listen and a U2 fan shall be rewarded!

[@pjorge8363]

Good point Rick!!! Larry is a pivotal member as others are in U2, any of the musicians of U2 are "IRREPLACEABLE"!

[@dougscott188]

I think they made a commitment to MSG and Larry could not go and the call to be first at the Sphere was the draw. I saw them at Sphere and Bram I thought was great. I am no music expert and no U2 purist, but they put on a heck of a show in a unique setting and it was great and people loved it.

[@DesignRhythm]

Yes, as a fellow drummer it is frustrating how easily we are replaced... Devil's advocate though: maybe Larry isn't physically able to play all those songs in one night? Drums really take a toll on the body.

[@Lance37a]

It sucks but there are only two members of U2 that cannot be replaced, The Edge and Bono. The Who is still kind of the Who with Roger and Pete.

[@roadArt132]

Yes better alive and replaced than a potentially fatal alternative.. look at what happened to Taylor Hawkins

[@joelsislak5334]

Neil Peart wasn't. Keith Moon or Bonham either. The Who And Zep did replace them, but it wasn't the same. I'm sure the Stones will get some fill in for Charlie to make money cause that is what it is all about.

[@DesignRhythm]

@@joelsislak5334 You think the Stones care more about money than the music? Come on man. I'm talking more about up and coming bands who will switch drummers all the time - Bonham, Peart, etc. are in a league of their own.

[@Lance37a]

@Joel Sislak they replaced Watts with Steve Jordan who has played with Keith Richards in the past.

[@216trixie]

I walked into a Tower records when October came out. I was transfixed and it didn't leave my turntable for 4 months. Been a big U2 fan ever since. Well, until the 90s. But they were the real deal. Saw them in the 80s in front of 150,000 at the US festival and then in front of 80,000 people.

[@farmgene]

Excellent album

[@darrell6800]

I saw October at Cardi's in Houston. The opening act was a wet tshirt contest

[@margaretsch.3609]

Rick, have you considered updating your original take on this? 600+ thousand tickets sold

[@sethpk1]

Rick. I first saw u2 in 1984 at Birmingham NEC England. Fan since seeing under a blood...in 83 on the tube. True original fan. Like you it's not perfect. But what a catalogue. I'm 53 now. Hope to see them in the English Midlands again. Love your stuff.

[@svenvansjo2644]

I have been a big u2 fan since 1984, saw them for the first time in 1987 in Gothenburg, Sweden. I think Achtung Baby is their best album. Can't believe they're going to play without Larry Mullen Jr. absolutely sick. Can't they wait for him to recover?

[@laurisalokoski2719]

Instämmer. Hälsningar från Finland.

[@jamesmckellar4026]

Larry's work on Joshua Tree, in particular One Tree Hill, speaks for what a great drummer he is

[@schnitzolaus]

What do you think now after the most shows are played? Bram is doing a good job and Mullen will come back for the next album and tour. Tickets are too expensive but I would like to see them in Vegas. But it's not possible because music is not a product. But the show and the music is great performed.

[@lukej7758]

As a 29 year old fan I have to say Achtung Baby is in fact my favorite album of all time- but I realize this isn't an opinion I've ever heard someone my age express 🤣 I share your feelings about this residency, but also have other concerns. Larry Mullen not playing is really unfortunate, and as much as they say it's just because he has to have back surgery- I can't help but wonder if that is cover for the fact that he might be burned on out on playing with U2. Sad as it is no band lasts forever, and he has made comments recently (and in the past) that suggest he might be ready to move on, apart from whatever health issues he is facing. I think in 2010 he said "I don't see myself at 65 playing in Vegas".... Aside from Larry I have real concerns about whether Bono is up to the task of singing these songs again. If you've seen any of their limited live material of the last 3-4 years, it is clear his voice is not what it used to be at all- he can't hit any of the high notes he used to. After he completely lost his voice at a show on the last tour, and hearing how limited his range is in recent performances, I just don't know how he can pull off the big stadium belting rock voice that is required for this material. The Songs of Surrender release shows that even in a controlled, studio environment, he isn't able to sing the songs like he used to. Pretty much all of the songs are either lowered by many keys, or he just doesn't go for the high notes at all. U2 is a stadium band, and if Bono doesn't have the voice to fill these stadiums, I don't think there will be much steam left in U2's live shows. Breaks my heart to say it, I've been obsessed with this band for 15 years now, can sing & play most of their biggest songs on every instrument. U2 is a big part of the reason I love music so much today, but it might be time for them to move on 😢

[@monikaszymanowska5142]

Sadly, truth, every word of it.

[@martinblumrich8296]

He's been regularly torturing his voice for decades. I hear what you're saying. It isn't aht it used to be.

[@rutriders2840]

I've been a fan since the mid-80's. I also sing and play their stuff at home on many instruments. I hardly ever reply to comments, but really appreciate yours and agree with you. However, I am interested to see what comes out of the Edge saying he wants to release new material that is back to being guitar-driven. Also, I saw the Achtung Baby show at the Boston Garden on St Paddy's Day and I remember it to have been amazing. That was one of the toughest tickets to get back then and also was when being a member of the fan club got you something even better than you bargained for. I saw them many other times in arenas and agree with you that they are better suited for stadiums. Keep playing! When you have kids and get them into playing music, it gets even better.

[@great_live_music]

Nice comment Luke. I share most of the concerns you have. I have been listening to U2 since my childhood (41 now) because my father loved U2. I've seen them several times, and I feel the JTTour wasn't on par with the rest of what I've seen before. One point you didn't talked about is Bono's health, who I feel has been a problem since he had the "incident" no one wants to talk about (most likely a heart attack). It has had a clear impact on his energy on stage, and his ability to carry a stadium as he was able to do before. Today I was listening to Bono's mic recording of the Seoul concert (2019). I've only listened to the mix the taper did before, and I was blown away by the lack of power there was in Bono's voice. He was also so close to missing some notes. Unfortunately, we are all getting older, and Bono as godly as he sometimes acts is also older and weaker than before. The thing I regret the most is witnessing this LV residency, considering AB being a European roots album. The prices and the location make it almost impossible to see the only "AB Tour" they're willing to do (look at the last Apple Music video where Bono says they will not tour with AB). I might be wrong, but this residency might be the last concerts they do. They have a lot to work on to build their legacy, such as the U2 museum that was planned to replace their Hanover Quay studio. They seem to lack real inspiration to write some new great stadium hymns. Living in different places might not help at all (Edge is living in the US, Bono between Ireland, France and NY, etc.). Remote working isn't great for sharing emotions and passion.

[@AshwinAshwinRamdas]

Same here re Achtung Baby and I'm 30

[@hgkress3501]

I love Rick´s rants. It´s pure passion. By the way: when legends start to perform in Vegas, this is mostly the beginning of the end. Just my 2 percent.

[@maxlimit18]

A good indication they should have hung it up a few years back…

[@PeachTube1968]

The Vagas point is actually on point! I Think the writing is on the wall but the band hasn't got the memo yet! Maybe a gig to far!

[@nigelholroyd2942]

Neil, Geddy & Alex went out the right way. with a BANG, 'They-2' should-a, could-a done the same, 'Vegas' lol, Rush would never even have contemplated playing so low.

[@DavidLPeel]

From what I understand Larry has given his blessing for the band to play with a stand in drummer.

[@albertomieryteran2944]

Rick, I'm a big fan of your videos and I've learned a lot from watching them. I probably wouldn't have ever listened to Joe Pass if it wasn't for your video on him. I also love the "what makes this song great series." I play the drums as a hobby and I think the first song I learned to play well was "Sunday Bloody Sunday." I'm also a huge U2 fan. I've seen them 48 times and was also at Aloha Stadium for the U2 / Pearl Jam show that was epic. I'll never forget watching Eddie Vedder jumping all over the stage with U2 singing "Rocking in the Free World." I've now seen U2 3 times at the Sphere and I have no words to describe what an amazing spectacle it is and the band sounds better than ever. It's like nothing I've seen before and recommend to all that it's a must see. I was also torn about the Larry situation but.... I'm ok with it and actually think that Bram van den Berg is a better drummer than Larry and seems to enjoy himself much more than Larry ever did at a gig that I saw. Larry always looks pissed. Maybe Bono get's under his skin. Bram can play some of the grooves without having to rely on an extra floor tom on his left (I know you and drummers will understand what I mean by this). I know he formed the band and he'll profit tremendously from the U2 residency and.... he'll be back. At the end of the day, I'm totally ok with it and respectfully agree to disagree with you on this one. Keep doing your videos! Rocking in the Free World, Alberto

[@AlbertWeijers]

I totally agree with your words. Who are we or is Rick to question their decision? The Sphere should open with U2 and Larry has to have his surgery, so this is a win-win situation for everyone. Ever for the 'haters' who can stay at home and save 300 bucks. I'm sure you had a unique experience there, I can see that from the video even. Well said.

[@DaveElke]

I’m a fan of your channel Rick, but I totally disagree with this one. Page and a plant played w/o Bonham or JpJ and I was so grateful to see them, Pimk Floyd played without Syd or Roger and again I was so grateful to see them. Larry is amazing and yes, it’s a bummer he’s not playing for sure, but if the other guys want to rock then they surely should.

[@kenimiller3896]

I've been a fan of U2 since the first album, but it actually took me a few decades to realize the heart and soul of U2 music, the real magic of the band has always been that rhythm section. Adam Clayton & Larry Mullen Jr., no one has done it better.

[@davidwennberg5694]

It took me forever to realize that With or Without you is just a whole lot of build up for one amazing Larry moment.

[@ryukan250]

It's been done better by so many bands though. U2's drummer and bassist wouldn't even crack a top 30 list of legitimate rhythm sections across rock. Even those guys would admit it.

[@sharpvidtube]

@@ryukan250 They're the best U2 rhythm section, same way as Paul and Ringo were the best Beatles rhythm section.

[@sharpvidtube]

For me, the Edge makes U2 as well, that's why I don't like the albums where he doesn't feature as much, or is just repeating things from the past, most of the albums since Pop. Bono was amazing until his voice went, don't think he's sounded good since the 90's. It isn't U2 without any of them, and without the voice Bono had, they will never be the same, but if they want to carry on, that's fine by me.

[@stephanegosselin2861]

@Ruy Kan… you don’t know what you are talking about but I am waiting for your list of top 30 rhythm section that are better 😉

[@metrodrumstv]

Hardly seems fair to expect that a band can only perform live providing that all original members are on stage. Why should the illness or death of one member dictate the end of everyone else's passion and career? Ticket sales will reveal how people feel about it anyway. Hopefully Larry is able to heal up well and get behind the kit again soon. His drumming is unique and is an important part of the U2 sound!

[@Funkymonk004]

I'd say lots of people would buy tickets without even knowing, then get there and be like what the fuck, who is that drumming? Saw people do that with RHCP in the dark days of Josh being their guitarist.

[@5000rgb]

Yeah, if one person leaves the band, I don't think the rest are obligated to quit. I don't know what Larry's prognosis is but I think illness and injuries are a little different. We don't know when the residency was booked or when Larry became unable to perform. I do feel like this residency is different than if they were playing a set at Coachella. It is the celebration of the band's career and, unless Larry is questionable to return, I think postponing the residency would have been better, but there are a lot of things that might sway my opinion if more information comes out.

[@patrickmalone9380]

I must be one only feels since atomic bomb that music been slow slide .to bottom .for me this seems band trying inject life with cheque book .drum up hype sad think have buy peoples love back .all need to do be themselves rediscovey they best assets .not sell out there friend and yeah

[@sash7551]

True poor starving musicians can’t afford to postpone a gig to accommodate their drummer! Give me a break

[@stefansnijders8943]

@Into the Superunkown I felt the same not too long ago; Gang Of Four touring but the only original member left at this point was guitarist Andy Gill, so we didn't bother getting tickets. Also, on 2002 had bought tickets for The Who live, bought them before Entwistle died. Still went to see them play and they were technically excellent, but lacking a little feeling overall.

[@NeilPW-wx8qz]

After seeing footage from the shows it’s clear the production has been planned well before the building construction and from what I’ve seen the sound is something unique to the venue and needs to be experienced to truly appreciate. What is interesting is Larry is with the band as they had been all together when shooting the video in downtown Las Vegas. U2 has been a band I’ve always wanted to see in concert and had been worried I’d not get to see them as the original lineup however they sound incredible in the footage from the sphere.

[@edvanesch178]

I think that Bram van den Berg has nothing to do with this. If you were a drummer, and U2 would ask you to play gigs with them, would you say, no thank you? Come on... And Bram said, that there is only one Larry Mullen Jr.. So what he did, will do, took a lot of guts, and is fantastic. Look at Bono, Edge, Adam, and Larry. Beause they decide.

[@skinner5334]

I stumbled onto a Yamaha drum piece about Larry some 6 months back. They were visiting him at home etc. He was heavily hinting about being beat up physically and needing serious time off to heal- he also hinted and at possibly being done with touring live as well.. His choice in the end. It ain’t easy when you got that many miles in your rear view mirror. Let’s collect all the data I’d say.. all the best⚡️

[@jasonr3424]

We were out in Vegas in August 2022 and I asked our Lyft driver what that big sphere thing was when we drove past it. They were still finishing it up at that point, but he said it was a new entertainment arena. He also said that U2 was slated to be the first act with a residency in it when it opens in 2023, so they had to have that deal inked for a while even at that point. I'm guessing they were working on it way before Larry had to go into back surgery.

[@86FxBdyCpe]

Exactly! Which part of this dont people understand, ie. Rick???

[@coolgaucho]

yes...exactly....rick doesn't know about contracts....just clicks

[@samverhagen9984]

Hey Rick, love your videos always! Even though I don't like the idea of U2 playing without Larry, he's not being replaced by some random drummer. Bram vd Berg is the drummer from very successful Dutch band Krezip. Their stuff is very nice :)

[@fitycalibre7555]

As an avid U2 fan. I can see why this move definitely upsets people. I think it’s important to take into account that contracts for this were probably signed way before Larry had to get surgery. If anything this is being done with his blessing, we all know how close they are. Larry would want them to play

[@christianparsons6050]

Yep, its highly likely that is the case. I'm sure they don't need the money, and they probably are just desperate to play. its all they know and are at an age where they don't know for certain that they'll get many more opportunities.

[@christopherjohnson2221]

As Pat Metheny said in your interview, it doesn’t matter who the headliner is on the marquee, it’s the drummer. Larry Mullen is the tightest drummer I’ve ever heard. When U2 played Live Aid, he and Adam Clayton kept a vamp going in rock solid time for something like ten minutes while Bono surfed the crowd… it was amazing. I’m interested but skeptical to hear what they sound like with someone else behind the kit.

[@dwaynerichardson5380]

Achtung Baby is their near perfect masterpiece. Saw the ZooTV tour at Yankee Stadium. The first time I heard 'One' live, I openly wept. The lyrics, the sunflowers, the buffalo falling off the cliff...speechless. I can't vision anyone else behind the drum kit other than Larry. But if tickets aren't in the Taylor Swift range, I'll be there.

[@Toom2112]

AB is one of my top 10 albums off all time.

[@Gary_M]

I'm sure they will be in Taylor Swift territory.

[@johnarrington6292]

Yankee Stadium was awesome.

[@PauloARod]

For me it was the image on screen of the little kid playing the drums, right at the start - I saw 90.000 people going absolutely crazy! Note that it was the first time U2 were playing in my country so everyone was in ecstacy (not the drug, although some may have been) ;)

[@kenbagwell8551]

For me it sits third behind The Unforgettable Fire and The Joshua Tree.

[@dlmblodgett]

As someone who’s attempted to play his parts, I’d say Larry is tough to replace

[@fredericperrin3279]

Totally agree with you Rick. U2 is not aging well and have been too obsessed with money. Simple Minds are doing much better in their old days. As an aside, Achtung Baby is a good album, but it was past peak. U2 was at its best from War to The Joshua Tree (with The Unforgettable Fire, in the middle, their deepest album in my opinion).

[@tomcooreman9454]

Simple Minds makes songs as 40 years ago. They are not innovative enough

[@fishfingers160]

Achtung Baby wasn't past peak, your opinion is absolute nonsense.

[@nicksimon7364]

Mainly agree Frederic - I just think they’re trying to stay as relevant as they can - understandably as legacy acts will do - but the management decisions recently have been shaky and that can come across as $ chasing

[@touringband]

For what it’s worth for the two people to read this, I’m a life long fan of the band’s. Seen them 17 times. Even in Times Square when Bono couldn’t join. If Larry gave his blessing, then so be it. I hope to see the Vegas show. The sphere just screams U2!

[@JamminClemmons]

Wake up! The bass player (Clayton) hasn't evolved one minor scale in decades beyond the "Thump-de-thump" 4/4 beat. Rhythm section speaking, they're boring as hell. - But if they float your boat, go get 'em boy.

[@CraigEggleton]

Kinda the only opinions that count.

[@touringband]

@@JamminClemmons wake up? You enjoy what you enjoy, and I’ll enjoy what I enjoy. No harm being caused?

[@johnvcougar]

@@touringbanddon’t let the trolls upset you! 🤫

[@adamrobinson8620]

@@JamminClemmons I agree. All of that focus on serving the song and playing the right notes when they could be off seeing how many notes they can fit into a bar and exploring polyrhythms. Adam Clayton is not my favourite bassist in the world, but when that band hits the stage it is tight.

[@zachsears5719]

saw them front row at Soldier Field 6/28/97 on the Pop Mart Tour...changed my life. I can't imagine them without Larry behind the kit.

[@teleguy5699]

Front row in Foxboro, Mass. On my birthday. Changed my life direction as I have ben to so many shows since.

[@DamascusHounds]

I was wondering who that was. I wish they had let him be on stage with them. Unfortunately they are committed to a certain image and aren't allowed to vary from it.

[@AndyeRoy]

One of my earliest memories of songs playing on the radio is U2. I’ve seen them 4 times. I thought the special they did on Disney + was so strange not having Adam or Larry. I know Bono addresses why they’re not in it, but I agree with you Rick. U2 is all of the band in my mind. They had Paul as their manager their whole career until he retired. The band has always been a package deal. Sure, they can do what they like, and I will still love their music, but when I saw them in 2018 I was afraid their chapter of live performances was coming to a close.

[@WaveGlydr]

Just came back from seeing U2 at the Sphere, they would’ve been stupid to pass up this show, with or without Larry (see what I did there?). A mind-blowing marriage of music, technology (the sound is incredible) and digital art. A must see.

[@timoloef]

I can't help feeling that Achtung baby is their best album... one of the best albums that came out in those years at all. Not a single song an that album disappoints and I bet I will still listen to it when I'm old(er) lol.

[@domd8290]

The greatest album ever imo

[@dragmio]

Not a single great song on it. Literally all the songs on Zooropa are better.

[@charlesc7950]

I still say to this day. My favorite concert ever was U2 The Unforgettable Fire Tour May 1985 . Can't imagine them without Larry.

[@mailpedromorais]

Sir.. luv your content and honesty. I also actually somewhat agreed with pieces of what you said here , back when I listened to it 7 months ago but… .. after just watching U2 at the Sphere, it’s time for you to acknowledge this aged poorly and that the band made a great decision. Groundbreaking and the perfect marriage… I’ve been to 15 U2 gigs, all yours since 97 and this was the best

[@margaretsch.3609]

Indeed, an update is called for here! Thankfully, fans are filling in the gap. Bram is way more than "some fill-in drummer." RESPECT THE BAND and reap the benefits.

[@albertomieryteran2944]

totally agree with you!! Been to 3 U2 shows at the Sphere is Bram is the real deal.

[@CMPProductions]

I think the harsh reality may be that the average person going to see a show in Vegas doesn't know anyone in the band other than Bono and maybe The Edge. The band and management know this. The hardcore U2 fan will be pissed, but 80-90% of the concert going public can't name most members of a band or their albums, they know the hits and show up expecting to see Bono and whoever else is playing they really don't care about.

[@beerchicky]

Went to see U2 with friends, in Tampa Florida, on my Birthday in 1987. The moon was full and it was cold out. It was the best concert I have ever attended.

[@OSBA71]

My money would be that they had a contractual agreement to be the first band to perform in The Sphere set years ago, likely before the ground was even broken to build the thing. Given this arena was built specifically for visuals and sound and some supposedly awesome live experience, U2 would be the perfect band to open the place, probably with some special effects and visuals that have been in development for a long time just for this show. I would imagine it would be far too expensive for them to back out at this stage. Larry isn't out of the band, and no doubt he's still going to get a quarter share of those shows. I would imagine he was likely pushing them to move forward so he could get that check (or at least didn't have to pay back what they likely were already paid)

[@coolgaucho]

money isn't as important to them as opening the sphere.....

[@hanswesterbeek2465]

This didn’t age well, because a) the show turned out great, b) it’s commonly understood now that the contract predates Larry’s injury and c) the ‘nobody’ is doing fine.

[@LosihoTTT]

Zoo Station has one of the best lyrics in music imo. "Time is a train, makes the future the past. Leaves you standing in the station, your face pressed up against the glass". Ranks right up there with Billy Joel's "they're sharing a drink they call loneliness, but it's better than drinking alone".

[@domd8290]

Zoo Station is the most underrated song of all time. Personally my favorite

[@OxaudioPhilly]

@@domd8290 same here. That song cranked up sounds unreal.

[@lucasoheyze4597]

"I'm ready for the shuffle, Ready for the deal, I'm ready to let go of the steering wheel"

[@xThisGameRx]

And in Zoo TV, the intro of Bono kick dancing on screen is iconic

[@krimekiller4]

Really funny to see that we Dutch people and media are really proud that a Dutch drummer is going to play with U2. But from a U2 fan perspective I can fully understand your criticism.

[@maaikeroeleveld2415]

I sort of thought to myself, how does U2 actually find a Dutch drummer, drummer of Dutch band “Krezip”? 🤔 As a Dutchie, I WAS someone who liked U2. Sorry to say it, but I lost interest in U2 quite a while ago…..

[@Mixey360]

There are only two things I can't stand in this world. People who are intolerant of other people's cultures; and the Dutch.

[@krimekiller4]

@@maaikeroeleveld2415 I'm really interested in story about this indeed. But first let him play and then we'll soon enough hear the story

[@rubenvanderkooij1571]

Maybe Anton Corbijn has something to do with it :)

[@cortical1]

Oh that's cool. Long time U2 fan here--since 1981. I'll have to look up this Dutch guy. I'm sure he's great.

[@Alejandrakoxxx]

Larry: Guys, I can´t go to the Super Bowl gig... Are you guys still gonna do it? Bono: With or without you...

[@ernest345]

Rick, As usual, You ROCK! Spot on; I've been a fan since the inception.

[@urbanfolkie]

Achtung Baby for me is one of the best records of all time and the one that influenced me the most. And it's not just the songs, it's the sonics too. To me, it always sounds like the Berlin of the early 90's resonating with the Berlin of the 20's and 30's. The Fly must have one of my favourite guitar solo's of all time. It's not a difficult solo in terms of notes, but the sound is sheer genius. I still try to capture that exact sound on my guitar to this day. No idea how they got that sound on the record.

[@geekUSA101]

Edge borrowed that riff & some of the solo turns out..

[@geekUSA101]

@@lauraallen55 look at the dude who sued them for the fly…same riff & you can hear his lead guitar part sounds like the fly solo 😂

[@geekUSA101]

@@lauraallen55 doesn’t make the allegation untrue. Taking on a billion dollar corporate behemoth like U2 is a tall task

[@misubi]

Totally agree that wah flanged tone is so thick and nasty and utterly unique in guitar history.

[@geekUSA101]

@@lauraallen55 uh huh..hope you’re up to date on your COVID booster shots Bono & his buddy Kill Gates want you to get so bad because they care about you 😉

[@druwk]

Regret never seeing them, but can’t imagine traveling expense and show expense to see this show? Their whole catalog is so deep with HITS! Great band , great music. LM Jr. (…the rhythm section of that band) is the heart and soul.

[@gavinkitchen1472]

Heh Rick, I saw U2 live a few times. One time I saw them on the 1st night of Zoo TV Tour in 1993. Lineup was Bono, The Edge, Stuart Morgan, & Larry Mullen Jnr. It was the 26th the night they were supposed to be doing the Zoo TV Video, however they pushed that back to the 27th. Maybe they used footage from the 26th, but minus any Bass Guitarist. They were pretty coy about it, & Stuart Morgan played brilliantly or perfectly. Most People in the stadium had no idea. They did not use the spotlight on Stuart. Although I knew, so did the People around me. * I was right up front, 2nd row of compressed People right in front of Stuart Morgan, & had I been further back I would of had no idea. Also I only knew it was Stuart Morgan a few years latter. I knew it was someone different, just I didn't know who, until researching it years latter.

[@MartinJofre]

@rickbeato Hey Rick I travelled from Argentina to see the show and it was the most breathtaking audio visual experience of my life. I'm 40, I'm a fan of u2 but would not consider myself hardcore fan, but I basically like the old records and not much anything after 2000. Anyway, the show brought me to tears and I was wondering if you had the chance to go and what is your reaction. If you didn't, you should, get on a plane

[@evilbyron]

I am really looking forward for that concert. I have been a fan since I remember, actually I was in that concert in Honolulu in 2006, there was a marathon the next day and I had to sleep on the beach because I couldn’t find a hotel. Nice memories.