December 2019 Eyeshadow Palette Collection & Declutter (Cruelty-Free)

[@kawaiimooncharms]

Oh lovely, I hate to be the bearer of bad news, but your Sultry palette I’m pretty sure is not authentic. I wanted to let you know because people have reported getting bad infections from accidentally using fake makeup. I also just want to say I really enjoyed this video and you seem like a sweetheart.💜🎀💜

[@AmyPetrucci]

Pastel🌙Pixie Oh no! Thank you for letting me know. I did think it felt a little funny but I chalked it up to being a defect. Thats probably why it was at Marshall’s. Shucks. I’m going to dispose of it to be on the safe side. Thank you so much for letting me know and for the sweet comments. Xx

[@emilydoesit8383]

Amy Petrucci: Marshall’s doesn’t sell fake makeup but that palette doesn’t look right though the slate color is completely wrong. Also the lettering shouldn’t be over the top of the glitters it’s more embossed into the packaging I’m going to agree with other people on this yours doesn’t look right but Marshall’s doesn’t sell fake makeup. I’m kinda curious if someone didn’t swap it out for a fake one m. 🤷‍♀️

[@tigerlaf6534]

You're absolutely right! The sultry palette is fake. The outside and inside aren't exactly like the real one.

[@kawaiimooncharms]

Amy Petrucci You’re welcome girlie.💜 I felt so bad telling you but I realize it’s important to say something if your health can be affected. I’ve heard mixed reviews on Marshall’s. I’ve never experienced fake makeup there but I know people have accidentally gotten fake makeup from there. I’m not sure if it’s people switching out the items or if it’s something with the vendor they buy from. Anytime I buy from Marshall’s, tj max, or Ross, I always ask them to open it at the counter just to be certain it’s authentic and untouched.💜🎀💜

[@AmyPetrucci]

@@emilydoesit8383 So strange, right? I thought it was real because I know Marshall's is an authorized retailer for ABH. I had no idea. I'm wondering if someone "returned" it. Thank you all for letting me know. I've notified the store and will throw the palette away.

[@bougiebrie]

I love the "I am not a minimalist" statement. Solidarity sis! I am right about at 900 eyeshadow palettes and I am not ashamed.....LOL enjoyed the video.

[@AmyPetrucci]

Yaas girl! You do you. Thanks so much for watching.

[@nauriini]

900????? I need to see it!

[@bougiebrie]

Yes ma’am. Lol

[@vfotn7]

Bougie Brie's Beauty Blog 900???? You gotta make a video of your collection!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@breannaturk7744]

Bougie Brie's Beauty Blog omg I wanna see!!!😍😍😍

[@rosalialoverde]

Your voice is sooooo relaxing. I love eyeshadow palettes for ASMR, but this is just as good!

[@AmyPetrucci]

Thank you so much for you kind comments. :)

[@CoffeeQueen90]

Love your Storybook palettes. I need them in my life. I also love the espresso yourself palette. It's gorgeous. The colors look amazing and they're coffee themed. I love anything coffee. It's even better that there's coffee eyeshadows. Amazing! Love palettes and doing eyeshadow looks!

[@AmyPetrucci]

Amber Greer Coffee makes everything better ☕️ ❤️ Thanks so much for watching. Xx

[@CoffeeQueen90]

Amy Petrucci yes it does! Coffee makes everything better. It’s a wonderful thing! Great video! Please make more videos.

[@erinaiwasaki502]

You have such interesting palette collection! Im addicted to watching eyeshadow palette collection or declutter video and got so bored over seeing sooooo many similar palettes in everyone's palette but your video was very entertaining and interesting!

[@AmyPetrucci]

I'm so glad you liked it! Thank you for watching. xx

[@taylorjade6918]

Those Storybook palettes are so cool! Absolutely after my heart 💞

[@CrissyBeee]

Your voice is very soothing, perfect to fall asleep to.

[@leslieott6463]

Oh I absolutely love your collection. I am far from a minimalist as well! Your collection has many unique pieces. So nice to see a collection video with different palettes. I was taking notes the entire time.

[@cindyphillips4517]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/rJmYaYiqapVpd80

[@AmyPetrucci]

I'm so glad you enjoyed. Thank you for watching!

[@michelleosborn5011]

GREAT COLLECTION I LOVE EYESHADOW PALETTES 😀

[@historychick5947]

Just found your channel and love it. This is my fav make up decluttering video EVER! Subscribed

[@AmyPetrucci]

History Chick Thank you!! I also really like your user name.

[@MissJenniferVlog]

I've watched this whole thing through but I come back to watch when I need to fall asleep. You have such a soothing voice and it helps my insomnia lol 💜💜

[@AmyPetrucci]

Aww that's so nice of you to say. I'm glad I was able to help :)

[@AmyPetrucci]

Hey loves! I decided to keep my Strobe Creepy Cute Palette. After some thought I just couldn’t do it so back into the collection it goes. 🤦‍♀️

[@ericac5854]

Lol I’m glad you are, I think those two palettes looks pretty different, I think they would work well together, based on the colors😊

[@kaylynnmae3332]

Please look at my other comment! Anything u cant sell or is too used or broken please I'm a single mom who makes 7.25 an hour. I dont even have stuff for a full face. :(

[@kaylynnmae3332]

Please don't think all I want is free stuff I just genuinely cant afford much besides what my son needs and our bills

[@irin6847]

I'm glad, that really stressed me out! I think its exact tones just aren't replicated in other pastel palettes.

[@taylorjade6918]

And from what I hear, it's incredible quality compared to all other pastels!

[@madanderson9338]

Your voice is so calming!

[@AmyPetrucci]

Why thank you! xx

[@aprilsilvers381]

Dont even worry about your hands..I haveny had a manicure in so long. I'm here for your content..

[@rishibeauty88]

great job! Your voice is amazing! Don’t let all the beggars & “do gooders” keep you from doing more. I read through your comments & I cant believe the sob stories & the “help” youve been offered. Other folks give the disclaimer of “ dont ask me to give makeup to you”...etc & Ive always thought people have more class & self awareness to do that. Nope- I’m wrong. You dont have to give your stuff to anyone! Don’t let the do gooders or the “righteous” keep you from doing more. I’m not a minimalist either. I LOVE palettes!! Keep them, love them, throw them away- they are yours. You can smash them all under a big wheel in your driveway if you want to. Don’t let people tell you what to do. Great job!! glad you know about the Sultry palette. PS You are my favorite to listen to as I fall asleep. So if you are getting a steady viewer stat on this- its me. Can’t wait until your next one!!!!!

[@AmyPetrucci]

Rishi Beauty This is the sweetest comment ever. Thank you so much for your support. I’m so glad you enjoy my videos and I hope to bring you more soon. Take care lovely. 😘

[@debwurtele5454]

Great video! Love the various kinds of palettes in your collection. You do have a very calming and soothing voice. Thank you! I am a new subbie now.😊

[@AmyPetrucci]

Thank you so much!

[@katjones4840]

I love that I love you color pop palette!! :)

[@Quit3Cut3]

I want the nomad Tokyo palette so bad it’s been on my list.

[@AmyPetrucci]

It's a great palette. I did a GRWM with it back in the summer. It's so much fun to play with. Maybe Santa will get it for you this year ;)

[@Quit3Cut3]

Amy Petrucci lol I asked Santa for diamond earrings haha. Hopefully the husband listened 🙃

[@Theartsymuslimah175]

I want the nomad palette too I love there shadows

[@elviraqueenofmakeup6608]

I love watching collection videos. They are fun to watch. Love yours. I filmed mine a while back..

[@StephLyons]

I really enjoyed your video. Great job and lovely products❤

[@iaso2003]

i find with the melt mattes especially you have to just gradually add the shadow and blending as you go rather than packing on the pigment then trying to blend it in. taking that method ive found the gemini palette has worked wonderfully for me

[@who2330]

You have such a relaxing voice and you seem so sweet! Hope you'll get more subscribers :)

[@AmyPetrucci]

That's so nice of you to say. Thank you! :)

[@FeiFeiKara]

That sultry palette looks like a fake! Is it just me?

[@AmyPetrucci]

Hi there! Yes, someone brought this to my attention in the previous comments. I thought it was just a defect and that's why it was at Marshalls. The more I looked into it the more I didn't feel comfortable keeping it, so I notified the store and threw it away.

[@tanhome7]

Amy Petrucci as you know by now, that doesn’t look like it’s supposed to however it is available to purchase still on the ABH website and I HUGHLY recommend you getting the real deal because it is stunning!! I never thought I would purchase it either and since I did it is one of my absolute favorite palettes amongst 400+ eyeshadow palettes. Very unique and excellent quality 👌🏼

[@CeiraMayberry]

Oh yes that's definitely fake. I am shocked that came from Marshall's. I'm so confused as to how that would happen! 🤔 I would be furious!

[@EmilyRosalie]

New subbie here! I’m a youtuber too ☺️💕 I just came across your channel and got so excited because you focus on cruelty free makeup and that’s really important to me! I’m glad I found you, I’m looking forward to seeing more from you. ☺️💕👍🏻💗 I love the Urban Decay naked heat palette it’s one of my faves!

[@AmyPetrucci]

Emily Rosalie Thanks so much lovely! I’m glad you enjoyed the video. And yes, the Naked Heat palette is the bomb!

[@AmyPetrucci]

I'm sorry for my delayed reaction. I just subscribed! You have a lovely channel. ☺️💕

[@Lulusvideos1]

That Little Women palette is adorable. Yes, I have the same issue with the Gemini palette, I have to really work with it, but I do enjoy the colors, they're unique to my collection. I also have the smoke palette and it's a little more workable.

[@lipbalmqueen]

Great declutter

[@acac7730]

The youtuber Angelica Nyqvist has had similar problems to you with the Nabla Secret Garden Palette. She has a full videos dedicated to the Nabla palettes.

[@MakeupwithMariela1]

Nice collection Abs declutter 😊

[@lucille3281]

Ur voice is so therapeutic ☺️

[@joannafalcon9543]

what a great collection!! :)

[@AmyPetrucci]

Joanna Falcon Thank you so much for watching! Xx

[@NonaSmith_mysocalledlife1977]

I love going through ppl's make-up with them. So satisfying. You have a great collection. I am so jealous of your LC palettes. Lol! New subbie! I look forward to watching more of your videos. I do beauty content as well if you would be interested. TFS! ~ Nona

[@AmyPetrucci]

Hi Nona! Thanks for watching, subscribing, and for the sweet comment. So nice to meet you :)

[@cindyphillips4517]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/rJmYaYiqapVpd80

[@mini_mew775]

Turns out all the colors in Two Faced Hot Buttered Rum palette you can get the same ones plus extra in The Gingerbread Extra Spicy Palette

[@AmyPetrucci]

MiNa ChAn Good to know! I only have the Gingerbread Spice, but I’ve heard great things about the Extra Spicy Palette.

[@nikkyg8950]

MiNa ChAn I’m actually really happy to know this I picked up extra Spicy but wasn’t able to get hot butter rum

[@mini_mew775]

@@AmyPetrucci I wasn't thrilled with it when it first came out but after buying it on sale I really love it

[@erickahope9864]

Yeah that sultry palette does not look right...idk if it's a knock off or if it was a mess up in manufacturing, as long as you love it and it's not hurting your eyes and the ingredients aren't awful, I don't think it matters! New sub! Xoxo

[@AmyPetrucci]

Thank you for the sub! Yes, someone brought this to my attention in the previous comments. I thought it was just a defect and that's why it was at Marshalls. The more I looked into it the more I didn't feel comfortable keeping it, so I notified the store and threw it away.

[@allieandjbforeva]

They have come out with many more story book palettes have you got any yet?

[@AmyPetrucci]

No, not yet. I'm actually on a no-buy this year (gasp!). I would love to try more next year though. I've heard they've been working on a Starry Night palette which I would buy in a heartbeat.

[@JustKiwiJess]

please do a video on your menagerie cosmetics singles! would love to see the swatches and know what they are called

[@AmyPetrucci]

You got it! I'll try to film this weekend.

[@AmyPetrucci]

Hi Jessica, I finally got around to filming this. The video went up this morning. Enjoy!

[@JustKiwiJess]

@@AmyPetrucci yay thank you!! 😁❤

[@ericac5854]

I wished I saw this before buying myself a Christmas gift. The nomad palettes looks gorgeous. I would totally buy it especially since they have the bundle sale of 4 palettes for $89, but I’m soo broke cause it’s near the holidays, would totally be buying it if it’s still on sale in a couple of weeks

[@cindyphillips4517]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/rJmYaYiqapVpd80

[@JustKiwiJess]

formula wise do you think the nomad cosmetics Tokyo pastel palette is better?

[@AmyPetrucci]

That's a good question! I prefer the Tokyo palette slightly more because it has the topper shades at the bottom. However, I like the gray and black shades in the Creepy Cute better because they're strongly pigmented.

[@JustKiwiJess]

@@AmyPetrucci the new menagerie pastel pup palette sounds right up your alley! pastel and has a black in it too, it looks adorable! 😊

[@AmyPetrucci]

@@JustKiwiJess I'm so interested in it! Looking forward to getting my hands on it eventually.

[@JustKiwiJess]

@@AmyPetrucci please do a review when you do!!

[@Idellle]

I want to buy a palette with blue, purple and green. I can't choose. Help me

[@AmyPetrucci]

Hi there! The palette that immediately came to my mind with all those 3 colors in it is the Blush Tribe Hasina 2 Palette. I've never bought from them, so I can't speak about the company or quality. Was there a palette in my collection you were eyeing? I can let you know based off of that. Alternatively, you can always grab the 9-pan monochromatic shadows from Colourpop. They have a green, blue, and purple one.

[@jeaninehinsey7745]

I have decluttered and repurchased a few palettes a few times, lol

[@AmyPetrucci]

I'm so glad I'm not the only one haha!

[@caralyn7366]

love u and your collection just sub'd xx Caz

[@samanthalewand5648]

I love your voice it’s so smooth. Do you do any giveaways? New subscriber. Can you do I a video on rating drug store and non drug store products? Please. Or by brand

[@AmyPetrucci]

Thanks for watching, Sammie! I would love to do a giveaway soon. Perhaps when I reach 500 subscribers. Yes, I can certainly do a video rating products. I'll add that to the list of videos to film. Keep an eye out :)

[@itzayaaax1344]

Loved this declutter!💞 so good. Is it okay if ask something so basically I've had some problems lately and I havnt been able to afford stuff and few things have been happening this is not a lie I'm being honest x most of the stuff you have, i think me and my daughter will love them even the palettes u have ive seen ur videos xx❤ seriously it would mean so much I couldn't been able to give her a proper gift but if u say yes it would mean so much but if no then it's fine xx

[@marisp2588]

I want the Aether Beauty palettes so badly, but they're so expensive 😭

[@AmyPetrucci]

They are, but if you sign up for their newsletter you will be notified when they have a sale. That's when I purchased mine. xx

[@AmyPetrucci]

Also I have a 20% off discount code with them now. It's in the description section of this video. I hope this helps!

[@ruberipi6811]

Anastasia been playing with colors, it was just before the Mario collab

[@AmyPetrucci]

I think that was right before I starting falling in love with makeup. There's so much makeup history I need to learn. Thanks for watching :)

[@chunloh]

I quickly took out my Sultry to compare afraid I got a fake one. I bought at Ulta on sale

[@AmyPetrucci]

Uh-oh! If you got it at Ulta it should be legit. We found out mine wasn't from this video. I got mine at Marshall's. I've thrown mine away because it's not authentic.

[@marywright7111]

The secret garden palette has a weird formula compared to their other palettes

[@allieandjbforeva]

So sad they are no longer selling the alien palette

[@AmyPetrucci]

I know it's such a bummer. It's such a unique color story. I think you may still be able to get your hands on it before they run out.

[@aprilsilvers381]

I'm one of the people who had way to much fall out with my ABH Jackie palette. I've tried it twice. I just realized this is a year old..sorry

[@shaolindragon3461]

Are you selling the mini clover palette I’m interested!!

[@AmyPetrucci]

Hi there! I'm so sorry I already sent it out to sell at Galmbot.

[@dakotajohnson2283]

Your sultry palette looks different thean mine.

[@AmyPetrucci]

Hi there, this was brought to my attention in a previous comment. I bought it from Marshalls and thought it was legit, but upon further investigation it's not authentic. I have notified the store I got it from and have thrown it away. Thank you for your comment!

[@dakotajohnson2283]

@@AmyPetrucci i seen it and was hoping you would notify them so you could get your money back at least. It just sucks that people have to make counterfeit

[@bridgetsclama]

Since you have a "trash can" option, please consider sending those to me next time! Expired, broken, whatever, I'm not wearing them, so don't send them to the landfill, Facebook me and let's go a little green :D

[@Katkattarotandparanormal]

What is glam bit

[@AmyPetrucci]

Glambot is an online used makeup site.

[@ChreeNumber12]

New sub here.. If I paid for delivery, can I get any palettes you don't want?!

[@cindyphillips4517]

Here is another declutter video that is a must see!! She has a series of them kzbin.info/www/bejne/rJmYaYiqapVpd80

[@elizabethannferrario423]

No no I hate large and ugly palettes and the layout matters to me as I find a haphazard palette disturbs me , I would be distressed by the arrangements .

[@kaileewesley9510]

I bought a lot of my friends non cruelty free items so she could feel better about her collection

[@AlyssaEm]

Your Sultry isn’t the real deal... and Marshall’s f’d up

[@lipbalmqueen]

Great declutter and I just subbed to your channel and I hope you check out my channel as well