Defending Felip's Bulan from Plagiarism Allegations

[@ginoongmaria]

Hi! I am Lay fan for a long time / EXO-L as well, both MV's napanuod ko na and FOR ME sobrang magkaiba talaga! :D I don't see any similarity pa nga ehh. I am half Chinese po, but what Lay's instrumental used for LIT are Pipa, bangu, and Ruan to create a dark and goosebump sound, while Felip used Rock Guitar and a grungy feel. In imagery, hindi talaga sya the same if videographer wise it will be based on the cultural representation of the song NO question at all (the moon, the lady, the dragon, the dancer even the concept has different depiction) they are different MAGKAIBA talaga. On the rhythm side naman Felip used a crumpy/rocky beat while Lay's used our traditional Tanggu, Yueqin, and upbeat to dance into it. Plagiarism can't be used here. LET'S ALL END THIS! Thank you Chuck very informative! and for those toxic Pinoy fans of EXO-L and Lay alone. TUMAHIMIK NA! wala kayo sa lugar to accuse.

[@pearlsarto8358]

finally, a co-L and co-xingmi has spoken, being a fan of both artist nahihirapan ako mag explain

[@Dreambig1104]

Hi sir, gawa po sana kau ng video re this matter, ang galing po kc ninyo humimay po, napakadetalyado po, salamat

[@jmb1819]

thank you for making this comment!!

[@minmaythedepressed]

Finally! I'm so happy to read this comment...thank you :D

[@RusDizon]

Naunahan moko magcomment ng ganito. charot Haha I am also both fan of Felip and Lay. Hirap ako magexplain kasi di ako expert sa music pero tama lahat ng sinabi mo. Haha Thank you bro!!

[@marjoriezabate1051]

Good job Chucks. . .You are truly the "Haliya" protector of Bulan (ken) towards Bakunawas(accusers). .Galing mu talaga Chucks. . You protected Ken with class, talagang may basihan. .

[@rosalie_3442_ph]

This really made me cry when Ken talk about his hardships. This KPop fans are toxic people that even made their Kpop artist to commit suicide with their toxicity.

[@marizgalo5850]

FACTS. Louder!!!

[@queenvictorian9026]

True!

[@nasechona]

Late ako pero ayon I'm a journalism student and I must say that plagiarism is far from inspiration. Please don't normalize using the "P" word in every situation. Experts have already given their insights on the issue, and it was properly and clearly stated that he did not copy someone else's work. Geez, what happened to you guys? It's a shame how quickly you guys judge and accuse someone. Please stop doing this! It's not good for these two different artists. I'm angrily expressing my displeasure with the toxic nature of my co-Exo-Ls. Awat na ha! Nakakainis lang talaga na mas inuna niyo 'tong gawin lalo na 'yung mga kapwa ko pinoy jan. Sheesh kayo! Hindi niyo man lang na-appreciate 'yung ginawa ni Ken kasi ako sobra ang pagka-amaze ko sa "BULAN". Although may similarities talaga sa "LIT" Kitang kita mo pa rin naman 'yung differences. Sadyang mga bulag at bingi lang talaga siguro kayo! Nalulungkot tuloy ako para kay Ken. Pinaghirapan niya 'to tapos gagantuhin lang? I hope that he's good right now and sana ginagamit niya lahat ng mga nangyayari to become much, much stronger than before. After all, he still has a long way to go pa naman as an artist. All love for Felip! Stop the hate uy! Nalulungkot na kami ni Xiumin at Pablo ko.

[@marizgalo5850]

LOUDER ❗❤

[@cynthiacruz1488]

Big HUG!!!!!!! Felip...we love you

[@DahliaFleurel_]

bumalik ako ulit dito after Felip posted IG story na mgpi-perform xa sa GRAMMY'S GLOBAL SPIN, now this video have a lot of meaning also. Sobrang na bless c Ken despite sa mga issues na binato sa knya, now he is the first full-blooded FILIPINO na mgpi perform sa Global Spin, nag ccmula pa lng xa and more to come 😭

[@jeanitats399]

I think this is the video that silenced them, hahaha ... Thank you, sir Chuck, now I know you're not just a reactor. Thanks for explaining and always defending SB19. Andito lang din kami para sayo.

[@jessicadumrique562]

Oo kunti na lng ung dadah ng dadah

[@jingsy2794]

Your going the extra mile is more admired especially now that you’re being hit below the belt. You’re being tested. Don’t let the ignorant break you. Chin up! We got you! Felip already said his piece, and you presented an objective opinion in his defence, complete with (in your face) samples. You’re not alone, other reactors are on the same page with you and so are we. This controversy gets to show how much SB19 has grown globally, intimidating other fans (the overly, irrational fanatic ones). You, being dragged in this ugly situation, gets to show that your videos are effective and have a great impact to your viewers - from both sides of the fence. You are an excellent story teller, you communicate very well through your contents. Keep it up. Don’t mind the few who trash you, because you are a gem. Carry on, Chuck! (I wasn’t able to follow who started this mindless “noise”. Hopefully it wasn’t a Filipino, if it was, shame on his/her crabby mentality and lack of culture appreciation!!!)

[@sizzlingfamhead6503]

Well, Pinoy nga po nag start. A'tin pa mismo na hindi nag iisip. She/he posted a side by side comparison ng shots. Di pa nakuntento sa fb kasi wala pumansin. Pinost pa sa tweeter. Kenophobic and ot4 ata ehh.. Then Pinoy fans nung Lay pinalaki pa and pinaabot sa Chinese fans 🤮

[@CashualChuck]

Thank you so much

[@jingsy2794]

@@sizzlingfamhead6503 A Pinoy A’Tin?!! Well.. talk about the crabbiest of the crabs! I’m not a legal expert, but if this one gets out of hand, he/she should be held accountable!

[@joyce-annarsenio7729]

Now I fully understand why those pips are so mad at you because you are clearly spitting fact right here and surely it hurts their ego especially that this video can literally slaps them. Ken and his team doesn't deserve all of the accusations. Some of them are too toxic and I even encounter some of their co-fandom that can't actually handle their toxicity. Ken is a very gentle man who's just doing his best to showcase what he can do. I hope this ends soon.

[@arnelsonbautista7182]

Basta ako, I believe magiging challenge to sa kanila to be more creative and brave at the same time to try different things that will only make them grow as an artist, not only FELIP but also SB19 as a whole. Thanks CasualChuck for this video.

[@Mythical_Sisiw]

You know Felip is now popular because being accused of plagiarism means he's being noticed the same thing that happened to G Dragon. But as the cliche goes YOU CAN NEVER PUT A GOOD MAN DOWN. Thank you for this another eye opener. I hope this issue will end here because Ken has already been through enough. Happiest birthday Chuck keep it up.

[@CashualChuck]

💯💯💯💯

[@lctj.9989]

Oo nga ano. G-Dragon was once accused of similar thing. Si Skusta Clee also. And look at them now. I

[@dandelion6961]

Known for being a flop copycat with fans that are leeches

[@keun-q2f]

@@dandelion6961 You just can’t accept the fact that you made a mistake on your wrongful accusations . And you think SB19 fans will keep their head down on your tactics, well sorry we are better than that. We wanna put you entitled people on your place.

[@larrymctown9823]

very well

[@Prettyreina01]

W ITH THIS MV, Para sa akin Felip need not apologize... all aspects of his BULAN came from him and his groups talented mind. It may have similarities because of the story being told but all this are required to highlight what needs to be emphasized and to show what the story is about.... Plagiarism is such a harsh word to begin with. All they want is for our younger generation to know the story of BULAN. We Filipinos should be proud that one person and as such, FELIP did this for our youngsters to know and appreciate. KUdos to you KEN. Again! You are on the right track. Don't be discourage coz in the end, they will know your worth. THANK YOU CHUCK, SALUTE TO YOU DIN PO, Ang galing nyo po talaga! Grabe ka na. Thank you for being the voice of A'tin.

[@Jampp01]

Grabe kuyachuck ang galing mo! Tinapos mo yung issue ng 10mins. Masyado ako naalarma kasi umabot na ng news pero gumaan na pakiramdam ko dahil sa vid na to, safe na si ken sa mga bakunawa. Solid ka kuyachuck!

[@marsagrabio3872]

Totoo,talagang nawala ang kaba ko sa issue after watching this video ang galing lang ni sir chuck..SLMT sir chuck

[@enelradsky7555]

Oo grabe ang galing nya creative writing, editing, analyzing data bute andyan sya nakuha nya ng matindi

[@naida2dibdibnipablo295]

Kuya Chuck stay strong. Don’t mind these haters. They have nothing else to do. We are here to support you all the way.

[@rexymorales1135]

There's just one answer and i will say it again and again...THEY TOOK NOTICE OF SB19 BECAUSE SB19 IS SOOOOO POPULAR NOW...

[@czypherth]

The part when you sampled similar songs at the middle of the video. I have this though of SB19 is now starting to set new standards that can be comparable to these amazing songs. We are now getting into the mix of international pop when it comes to the sound and delivery which for me is a plus for our country to innovate and compete globally.

[@rubyamora4149]

Hello, kuya Chuck I came back here immediately after hearing that antifans were badmouthing you. I just want you to know that it sometimes better to be hated for what you are or how you genuinely feel and think than to be loved for what you are not. Dont let their hate destroy you because there are sincere people behind you backing you up. We might not there physically to comfort you, but I hope my words will reach you, "You did well, you will be fine." Did you know that they kept hating you because they want to break your heart and soul? But the best reply would not by ignoring them but by smiling and saying, "I will not trip and fall for you" Besides kuya Chuck, we don't know your past but it's you who know how far you have gone through. They got cruel words to you, but we got you sincere and supporting comments There are thousand of haters out there but that could not compare to the true people who cares for you They may hate you all day but we love you in this lifetime They may be cursing you but we are praying for you. Be good, and you'll be fine. They can't be compared to one Cashual Chuck.

[@RusDizon]

Thank you Ruby! On behalf of Chuck I appreciate your message. I got teary eyed. Thank you for always supporting our friend!

[@arisawang14]

♥

[@CashualChuck]

Thank you so much. Made me quite teary there

[@RoseAnn_Ramirez]

🙌🏼🙌🏼🙌🏼

[@marsagrabio3872]

💠💙🙏

[@rousdunton4204]

Respect your fellow artists if you're an artist, and respect your idol if you're a fan. And if you're not a fan, at least respect another human who put in so much effort and hard work to create such high-quality work. And, please, some anti-fans are trying to act smart but can't tell the difference between plagiarism and inspiration. Kuya Chuck, stay strong! Don't let them influence you. If Plagiarism is a crime, I'm just reminding you Bakunawas that Libel, Defamation, and Cyberbullying are also crimes. God bless you💙

[@ivyfoppen6926]

Kuya, super thank you po sayo. I hope na they cleared their minds accusing people not only Felip/Ken. In life, we have similarities story but different version only. That’s also in song they have some same beats or flows but different lyrics. Mahalima #SB19

[@ellaine157]

Kuya Chuck just want to commend you. You are one of THE BEST reactor A’TIN have, Whatever haters throw at you or to our #SB19 please don’t let them affect you both cause what they are doing is that they just want to destroy you and us why? Because they don’t expect That we Filipinos can do such things and they envy us. For my opinion because Ken’s BULAN is more stronger feels and more catchy and as they are in denial that BULAN is a Banger. All these Haters/cancers keep being a stage 4 cancers don’t mind them cause for me they are in the place where they belong. I am on your side Kuya Chuck we are here for you cause we know that you are genuinely protecting #SB19 and we are here for that. Count me in bro! Let’s rock these bitch! 😅🤘🏼✨

[@happymelody440]

Precisely

[@mritsdelatorre7952]

True.!

[@guptaflavio5383]

*I HEARD ABOUT A LOT OF EXO FANS ARE REPORTING THIS VIDEO. KZbin ISN'T DUMB. A LOT OF VIDEOS ARE REPORTED SIMPLY BECAUSE OF ACCUSATIONS AND FOR SURE THEY HAVE A TEAM THAT VERIFIES THOSE REPORTS. IF THEY'RE WAITING FOR THIS VIDEO TO BE REMOVED, THEN THEY'RE JUST STUP ID*

[@Sun_Sunnie]

Chuck, you're the best 👌 Sobrang galing ng mga research mo. Well-explained.

[@KD-hv4ey]

Haters will always find ways to bring their target down, no explainations will suffice them. Music nowadays are really hard to be fully original since there are several years of music that have been created and made up which also inspires all new artists as well.

[@cengvlogs5308]

Love this !!! One of the most SAVAGED video here on YT !!!

[@CashualChuck]

Haha medyo late ka yata Ceng

[@cengvlogs5308]

@@CashualChuck may comment ako Dito nung isang araw pa ahhahah. NATABUNAN na ng mga BAKUNAWA 🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@atinermie5572]

A slap on their faces.. Thank you Chuck. Felip will get through this, We A'TIN too.

[@karyleannetabian476]

I have been a KPOP fan for almost six years and I've been seeing plagiarism allegations among fans. Fandoms calling out fandoms to make an issue to the point of mentioning the artist and even their company to do some steps about it. Sa observation ko po, kapag po sa mga similar scenes, umiinit lang yung topic for certain amount of time tapos huhupa na. Common yung mga statements na "apologize to [artist] for what u did" ganun po, depende rin sa material na tinutukoy nilang ginaya raw. Ayon po sa nabasa ko sa lesson namin about sa plagiarism, ang isang idea cannot be grounds or evidence against plagiarism kasi sa nakita ko po sa both MVs, there are similar ideas that were actually executed but not to the point of copying the whole masterpiece. Kaya rin po may disclaimers sa mga content because of that, I suppose. But yun po, we must always remember na hindi lang po idols ang mga hinahangaan natin, kasi yes, I agree Sir Chuck, they are people and they have feelings too and there is hard work invested for every comeback they have. Sharp tongues can wound and it affects a whole team, not just one person. Ang observation ko lang po talaga ay may idol obsession na magaganap kapag nagpenetrate na talaga yung idol industry sa isang culture. Since PPOP is rising and in the near future, it will be fully recognized and accepted also by our fellow casuals, it's our responsibility as PPOP fans, to let our fave artists feel they are understood as fellow humans. And to be understanding as well kasi yun po rin ang deserve nila.

[@ascendedkings6564]

I agree1001% and i continue following you on all your contents, thanks for all your positive contents bout SB, you continued educating us in so many things thank you so much.

[@atehtine]

Lord, thank you for blessing us with Kuya Chuck. Thank you so much! That fandom traumatized me when I was starting as an Army (my my BTS showed up while I was typing this 😳). They have so much time bringing other groups and artists down, I hope their idols give them content to stream so they can use their time. And you know what's worst? Most of that fandom accusing Felip are Filipinos!!! They are everywhere making fun of Felip and SB19. It's disgusting!

[@ivanjosue2469]

Grabe ka, Sir Chuck. Napacomment ako ng wala sa oras. Tagos sa puso. Napakabuti mong tao. Pagpalain ka ng Panginoon. Mabuhay ka, ang Pilipinas, ang SB19, at si Felip Suson.

[@xamseyer5392]

Sa ibang fans ng Sb19 pag alam niyong nasa Tama kayo Hindi masamang ipagtanggol Ang idol niyo.wag Kayong matakot Hindi toxic Ang matatawag dun. Kaysa manahimik kayo at Walang Gawin.Pero patuloy naman sinisira at binabash mga idol niyo. Saludo ako sayo Cashualchuck.

[@김요한-v2n]

FELIP WILL RISE UP. TOXIC FANS, YOU WILL WASTE YOUR TIME LOL. WE AINT BORN TO BE AFFECTED BY NONSENSE.

[@nasechona]

Naiiyak ako! Blessing ka talaga kuya Chuck! Eye-opener kumbaga! Want ko more contents like this in the future! BTW, Don't listen to them! Focus lang po tayo sa goal! Pasensya na rin po sa mga co-Exo-L ko, bawi na lang sila sa next life kasi di kaya ng pride nila na humingi na lang ng pasensya sa mga accusations nila eh. All love lang!

[@jhingmo1616]

This video is an enlightenment. Next time sa mga fans bago kayo mag accuse make sure napanuod mo bit by bit both sides of the mv and make sure na 100% yung pinagsasabi niyo na plagiarism. Minsan kasi piliin rin natin magpaka tao kesa magpaka fan na lang without thinking the works and effort na ginugol ng isang artist para mabuo lang ang isang masterpiece. Let's support our own if not just don't drag them down. Thank u chuck for this effort.

[@enaj.aneram]

I am not a musical professional and a reactor but about plagiarism issue, is too far of being inspired. Regardless if they have a similarities in sound or beat drop remember producing music can reuse a beat drop. But onhand I also watch the MV of Lit by Lay (EXO). The story of the MV is about religious belief in China about life and death, and Bulan MV is about Mythology of the God Moon and Bakunawa (Sea Serpent). That 2 MV has a different stories, but both has inspiration to share for their fans. Felip was inspired by Lay, and you cannot credit the inspiration to a certain person because they do not have a participation on making on your work. Now if the fandom keep saying that is Plagiarized, we can take it in legal but make sure you have enough evidence to present. Now when you watch the MV of both and has a lot of similarities, same amount of the MV, same production, same people who use to be on the said MV, same lyrics but in Filipino, same clothing and same place where the first video take off but not crediting to a person. This is a plagiarized. If you are not satisfied, then you have a problem. Not on the artists, not on the staff, not on the production but you, yourself. And Felip already released a statement. Hoping the both fandom will end this.

[@marizgalo5850]

Well what can you expect from narrow minded, entitled fans? Toxicity.

[@Iris-gu2gu]

Plagiarism is a strong word that can only be proven through court ruling. Learn its meaning, it's easy to throw hate than to study nowadays, I guess. Seeing both mv and listening to both songs, I can't deny that the feel and some visuals of the mv have similarities (maybe because of the dominant colors used in both mv) but when talking about Plagiarism, it should have been the EXACT SAME THING (identical), same concept, same storyline, same lyrics, same everything and make it seems like it's his own. Cashual Chuck just played with their own cards tho, he pointed out what's obvious by playing their own game and it backfired 'cause somehow it painted them in a bad light when this is what they've done to Felip in the first place 🤷🏻‍♀️ The take away from this issue is that, learn to view each side of the story, don't just throw judgments based on our own biases, be critical, and be open-minded.

[@ranmaringo2428]

Exactly- plagiarism is the exact word for word, line from line copy. Why can’t people just be happy for others!!

[@myelin3062]

Yes, Bulan is not a straight copy, Felip changed just a bit.

[@Iris-gu2gu]

@@myelin3062 how so? 🤔

[@angelicadediamante]

Just a bit? Like a whole different tune and lyrics and a whole different storyline?..... You are ridiculous! Pag Puyo!

[@marzchanneldavao2013]

Laban lng kuya chuck ito na ang simula ng pagtatag era. U cannot pls everybody. Ito lng po ang maiitutulong ko embrace ur enemy.. gumawa ka pa po ng another content don't stop ur passion as a content creator. Don po namin kayo nakilala. Bilang isang mabait na ama, anak, kaibigan,kapatid and as a fan. Ipakita mo kng anong tao ang isang casual chuck through ur content po. Ayaw ko lng po sumali sa gulo kc baka dagdag lng ako sa init. Ito lng po ang kaya kng maibigay as a fan din po nin u. I been there before naranasan ko po kng paano mabash din. Ang kailangan lng din po ay laging handa andito po ang totoong Atin to support u.

[@wooannie9592]

Thank you so much, Cashual Chuck, for your unwavering support towards SB19 and FELIP as a soloist. With FELIP's release of multiple amazing songs and music videos, it's evident that his talent knows no bounds, proving any doubters wrong. For the accusers, your idols can never do things like how FELIP does them.

[@vmizmc]

Kaka compare nila sila na yung bumababa, I mean back in the days na inaccused nila bangtan ng plagiarism. Look who's on top now kaya never drag others para lang mai angat mo yung sayo karma is real.

[@polopatrick3246]

someone's on full camille vasquez mode. you made some excellent points here atty chuck! really hope that this doesnt in anyway neagtively affect our dear 🐔 & his future works.

[@Beerrnah]

Wow!! The amount of effort and research you did was amazing! You are the best!!!

[@alecsmariballarta5345]

Been a fan of Felip and SB19 for years but I've just found this channel now, completely amazed by how you showed your point about plagiarism. You clearly showed what I also thought about their allegations about Felip. Thank you for protecting him!

[@tiffany123tiffany3]

Tong mga toxic fans natoh pag mga Hindi pa kayo magsitigil mas lalo mahahalungkat mga tinatago ng idol nyo plagiarism kau ng plagiarism ayan nag research tuloy si cashual chuck nasampal tuloy kayo ng facts..mag idolize kau in a positive way hindi yun mga nega na at mag down pa kayo kalahi nyo. Hayz naman… thanks sa video casual chuck 👌👍

[@angeliquemanalang76]

Masakit masampal ng katotohanan. Ang masakit lang na naiisip ko eh baka nakita or nabasa din ni K ang ibang a'tin na naniwala na copied yung kanta and even sumang-ayon na bigyan sila ng credits.

[@giliandelaluna2115]

SUPER AGREE. I just remember the instrumental bg music at the intro of Unwell (Matchbox twenty) and Taylor's Swift "Our Song" intro.. magkahawig din mas makapal at mabagal lang yung sa Unwell but when you hear it magkatunog.. but wala namang issue na nangyare, so why FELIP's Bulan? :'((

[@RusDizon]

THANK YOU FOR DEFENDING OUR CHICKEN! OF COURSE HINDI LANG SI FELIP NADEFEND DITO BUONG PAGOD DIN NG PRODUCTION TEAM. HAPPY BIRTHDAY!!!

[@genesisabanilla7864]

mygassshhh lodi ka talaga! Ganyan mga content creators, effort kung effort , may basis, may research.. hindi lang basta basta own POV..

[@purpleprincess0204]

I don't care what other people says about Ken or Sb19. For me sobrang unique at napaka-ganda ng MV nila at walang katulad. Sb19 pa rin ako hanggang sa huli. #Pablo💜

[@barbielyntv6675]

LOUDER !!! kuya chuck 📢📢 Thanks for this video.. hope someone has come to their senses and enlightened by what is happening and hope they move on and stop the conflict. Let's love each other No fandom war💙🥰

[@sheesinnertheatermind3047]

Di ko ma gets kinaka galit ng ibang fans nila. On point naman lahat ng sinabi mo. That kind of malicious mentality will be forever a mystery.

[@ssob5373]

I just wanna say I appreciate everyone's effort for supporting and defending our boys because I'm a hundred percent sure if they knew all about what we did for them they would be so thankfully I especially thank A'TIN especially casual chuck who keeps working hard to make this kind of vids to make things clearer for us and this is why I joined the fandom on the go up era even tho SB19 don't have the most fans but they still have the most loyal and dedicated fans I want to thank atin for everything to ensure our boys safety keep safe MGA KAPS ❤️

[@rapalma9640]

Lol chuck... thanks for being one of ATIN'S too... kudos sa mga gawa mo... amazing tlga, taba ng utak mo...galing... God bless po

[@MediumKid_MKTV]

I appreciate the commitment and heart you put in this video. Thank you. Mabuhay ang OPM. Mabuhay tayong mga fans na sumusuporta sa umuusbong na OPM evolution.

[@lorenaracan7307]

YES TO OUR OWN O.P.M.!☺💙👍

[@lleannamarry6248]

Ken's Explanation: "While there may seem to be some similarities between the sound of 'Lit' and 'Bulan,' a closer examination of the chord progressions, instrumentation, samples used, and even syllabication will prove the claim otherwise," FELIP said in his statement. He added, "Moreover, the melody and the ethnic chants in 'Bulan' were based on indigenous Filipino ritual music, made modern with the addition of rock and hip-hop elements." Regarding the other visuals in the music video, he cites the Filipino game "Bulan-bulan," the Filipino mythological creature "Bakunawa," and the Filipino mythological goddess Haliya, among others. He says, "Apart from the lyrics, the music video for 'Bulan' was made to be a metaphor for real-world issues, while staying true to common knowledge of what transpired among the characters in most versions of the ancient lores." FELIP continued, "'Bulan' was heavily and responsibly researched that details in the MV had its cultural basis, executed with some variations so as to not offend any cultures/indigenous populations."

[@icreate6025]

Omgeee! Ang galing galing ng ken ken😭

[@gapdayag7000]

Bkt kc kailangan gayahin ung mv nya dna lng cla,nag isip ng iba

[@janjazz8690]

sino ba kasi ang naunang nag accuse di ba? there are fans na di matanggap na may ibang artist na kaya din gumawa ng great music. minsan kapwa mo pa pinoy humihila pababa. natural na i defend nya artist na sinusuportahan nya tulad ng ginagawa nyo ngayon. feeling entitled. at dahil sinagot kayo at binigyan kayo ng reason a reference tapos kayo ngayon magrereklamo. to those saying "nag debut na yan sa weibo, lagot sya". sino ngayon ang toxic? gusto pa palabasin na sobrang lakas ng fandom nila at di ka pwedeng mag comment sa kanila at masisira ka. sino ngayon ang toxic? now i understand why they are saying that these fans goes beyond just being the fans, they don't realize that they are also dragging down their idols. meron naman talagang toxic fans kahit saang fandom but to know that yours are the worst, then you deseved to be famous. just saying my opinion.

[@ra_lg9504]

Grabe on point lahat ng sinabi mo kuya Chuck! Nakakabelieve ka talaga!

[@tazzyredz]

Supporting Chuck and SB19.. Great job everyone!! Let those negative people do what they want because at the end of the day what important is we know who we are and the people we are supporting.. these negative people are bunch of losers..

[@angied.officialvlog2485]

Salute to you kuya chuck.. Thank you for this video.. I'm sure ken will appreciate this❤️

[@pabloajero5838]

This is very informative para malaman nung iba na napakalawak ng mundo ng musika Hindi maaring walang magiging magkakatunog or magkaparehas ng concept. Walang karapatang mang-angkin kung Hindi rin naman pala original at the first place. Sir Chuck is just opening the minds of some fans na sobrang close minded na. Don't disregard the efforts and his other good contents na nagawa nya para sa boys dahil Lang sa isang video or video clip. Or just to be in good terms with that specific fandom. Sila ang nag open ng issue so let them taste their own medicine. Let Sir Chuck learn from his mistake kung meron man.

[@janjazz8690]

some fans cries "cancel" and saying "insensitive" because of this vids reference. but they did not even reflect that they are the ones who are insensitive of what might the artist would feel because of their accusation. nagagalit sila kasi nasagi yung ego nila dahil may maipupuna din pala sa artist nila. i hope and and i pray talaga na sana di tumigil si ken and and SB19 na gumawa dekalidad na mga kanta. nakakalungkot lang na minsan kapwa pinoy pa humihila pababa. i could say blessing in disguise ang nangyayari ngayon sa Bulan. it means napapansin na nila na kaya din pala gumawa ng pinoy ng ganitong masterpiece pagdating sa music at kaya ng ipantay at ipagmalaki internationally. SB19 definitely put their marks in OPM music history. and for you @cashualchuck sana wag ka rin panghinaan ng loob to make more contents to promote our filipino artist and music but also to spread awareness on some social issues and struggles when it comes to mental health that some of us are might also experiencing. God bless to you and to your family.

[@jessa1697]

True, this is a slap to their faces. Di nila matanggap yung katotohanan. Egoistic entitled fans mostly sa kanila

[@hartue1333]

Sa tingin q pinoy ang pinaka toxic kpop stans nkakkatakot maging kpop stans baka maging toxic na din aq pag nagkataon gosh wag nman sana

[@MELANIEADUCOL]

Tama, kaya tumigil ako sa pagiging k-pop fan E. Nakakainis lang sa mga pinoy na mas sumosoporta pa sila sa dayuhan kay sa ating mga artist (hindi naman seguro lahat) kaya hindi naten palalagpasin to laban Felip at sb19. And thanks you also sir chuck sa pag-defend ni Felip I hope sa mga exo fans na ma-enlighten thier minds🙄🙄🙄 hayy naku

[@rubyamora4149]

Yes, I agree. By this, it doesn't mean that we ignore plagiarism. The main point here is that there was really no plagiarized content and other Filipinos were the ones kept insisting on this. Therefore, we can say that Pilipino rin ang hihila sa kapwa Pilipino kasi the accusations could destroy the artist, music and dreams when in fact, wala ngang plagiarism case. According to my father who is a lawyer, the definition of plagiarism in the Philippine laws do not coincide to the accusations of fans because their opinions on plagiarism were not stipulated on the constitution. Instead, sila pa ang pwedeng ma filed for defamation and other cases. Defamation is just one, pero sabi ng lawyer marami pang pwedeng ibato sa mga accusing fans if ever Felip will escalate this matter on them and he said that it would cost him much to file in court if isa isahin nyang idemanda ang mga accusers. If only I have got my law degree now, I can help Ken without service fees, but sadly I am still a student. Moreover, hindi lang service fee ang babayaran for the lawyer, but there can be miscellaneous fee to file in court pa.

[@bellaclover1933]

di kc nila alam ung ibang pilipino na merong methology ang bisaya about bakuna or the dragon eating the moon, thats y theres eclipse, bisaya ako kaya alam nmin yan, c ken din ay bisaya, kaya meron sya concept na ganyan.

[@lorkiarisr9571]

Mag aral ka mabuti kaps, we will be happy na mag karoon ng A'tin na abogado na Tutulong sa artists natin in the future! God bless your kind heart!

[@happymelody440]

Sana isa mga mga spcialty na pwede mong idagdag sa pagaaral mo ay ung mga ganyan sa plagiarism or the like...para may A'TIN na taga defend..malay mo isa ka sa magiging legal adviser ng SB19...why not coconut

[@blackpinkwithblinks3193]

@@bellaclover1933 I'm not bisaya at alam kodin po yung tungkol sa bakunawa pero maliit lang at tama po kayo dahil yung mga toxic pilipino na walang alam ay sila yung nagpapalala at nags-spread dito papuntang china tapos sila pa may ganang sabihin na tayo daw yung nagpapalala dito di sila makaintindi

[@majestyintegro612]

Sadly yung mga puro accusers ngayon ni Felip puro naka RP account. Hays. Sarap nila ipakulong lahat parang sarap kausapin yung fandom na magambagan para ipakulong yang mga bakunawang bashers na yan. Puro naging expert sa music. Instant nga expert agad.

[@hirohosokawa1112]

Inspiration is different from plagiarism and you said it so eloquently and I have so much respect on the effort you made in your research. I can just imagine the tons of time you devoted thereon. Keep up the good work in putting the bashers in their proper places.

[@CashualChuck]

Wow, thank you!

[@autophile0712]

Thank you for this kuya Chuck! I'm a low-key fan of SB19 pero after watching this mas nagustuhan ko'pa sila especially Ken. I actually started defending them from those bashers. ❤️

[@CashualChuck]

Thank you

[@sb19videosandupdates78]

As an A'TIN, don't tolerate this kind of behavior

[@streamtamed-dashed5206]

@@sb19videosandupdates78 hilom oi. Gi akusaha na gani si felip kamonpod mura mog itoy

[@autophile0712]

@@sb19videosandupdates78 Bruh you don't understand what I'm saying. I said i 'Defended' them from the bashers I'm not saying nakipag away ako. Iba ang offense and defense.

[@sb19videosandupdates78]

@@autophile0712 you didn't understand what I said, sabi ko wag mo itolerate ang ginawa ni Chuck, he went beyond the line of defending Ken and even used other members of E/X/O to prove his point. He should be condemned of it. I was so tired defending Ken too bc he's my bias but this kind of behavior doesn't subside the argument, he keeps adding fuel to the fire.

[@musicmundo4881]

TAGAL NG TOXIC NG FANDOM NILA KAHIT NOONG NAGSISIMULA PA ANG BTS DIN NOON, INAACCUSED NILA NA KINOKOPYA SA EXO ANG KANTA NG BTS which is good thing na namentioned dito. Tingnan mo kung nasaan na ngayon yong binabash nila at inaakusahan? Ayon nasa tuktok na. Nag-exceed na sa narating ng faves nila. This is just the starting point of Felip's career. Malayo pa ang mararating niya. Ang itinataas ay ibinababa at ang ibinababa ay itinataas. Laban, Ken.

[@carrie_silver13]

need to share this.. (Some fans are feeling entitled ) duh.. I sincerely admired Felip for that unique MV in Phil Music Industry.

[@algreacts6587]

HAPPY BDAY!!!!!! SORRY AB THIS! ADDITION: WHICH DOESN’T MAKE SENSE BC IM A FAN OF LAY AND KEN AND WHEN I HEARD KEN NEW SINGLE NEVER IN A MILLION YRS DID I THINK TO COMPARE THIS TO LAY WORK! BOTH WORKS HAVE TWO DIFFERENT MEANINGS AND 2 DIFFERENT CULTURES PLUS IF I WOULD HAVE HEARD A SIMILAR SOUND I WOULD HAVE SAID SOMETHING BC IM HONEST AND LISTEN TO BOT SONGS!!

[@Rain_RC]

OMG 😭 I literally heard April saying this as if I’m watching her. I felt every word and yes! Those accusations doesn’t make any sense AT ALL. But those negativity were just too loud to ignore. They can’t expect us to just stay silent. Felip already released his statement and these haters and bashers are so damn committed in accusing ken of plagiarism WITHOUT SOLID/TECHNICAL BASIS. They become the embodiment of BAKUNAWA and we need to make noise to defend our BULAN! Anyway, our Bulan continued to shine despite all of this. Big hugs to us A’tin! 💗

[@kaikimmierin919]

hi the only thing that exo-ls want is credits since ken already admitted that he took inspiration from lit of lay that's all we want but things got out of hand when both parties took it too far by involving culture

[@dayneapa8228]

pero pag e claim to ni Lay.sigurado! HAHAHA NA TAKEDOWN NGA YUNG Mv ni young lex na di masyadong copy!! HAHAHA

[@anapecatarman3725]

True! Louder Ms. April👍

[@luvslorna]

@@dayneapa8228 hindi naman si lay nagpa take down ng vid ni young lex. production team ni young lex nagtake down ng vid, para wala nalang siguro mga fans na mam bully. but felip's vid will not be taken down, kahit ibully nyo pa siya, magsawa kayo, happy sya na nakalivestream pa nga today naglalaro ng Pubg habang kayo stress na stress ipatake down vid,. si lay at ken masarap tulog

[@renatinacu8673]

the best example here for what happening right now is EXO's love shot. tomlinsons fans and exo-l's...thats why i dont get it why are they doing this to Ken...Credits is given to someone who is part of the production and contributedto the output of the song in overall.

[@renatinacu8673]

@@realpcy2892 its up to you, if you're an EXO-L you will get what i mean right? most EXO-L after crediting tomlinson says otherwise....

[@seoulfeels]

May tumatak saakin na kasabihan galing sa movie. Sabi, 'you have to be strong in order to protect someone.' Salute po kuya.

[@de-annce5508]

Thank u Kuya Chuck for defending Felip/Ken..We cant please everyone..God bless you Kuya and your family..

[@di.pinanindigan]

Thanks Kuya Chuck, protektahan natin si FELIP from those bakunawas!

[@kensuson9296]

Di talaga ako nauumayan sa issue na to. Unstan ko na EXO. I would rather choose SB19 than any other foreign artists.

[@glaizamae8883]

Kahit foreigner or filipino artist pa yang sinusuportan mo be a healthy fan nalang...

[@keunsat.1819]

Same unstan muna dahil sa mga toxic

[@novera_mas8478]

HAHAHA! OMG! Why do u make us cry or sad on that ending song😔? Well, thank you very much, Chuck, for this content. It helps a lot!!! A'Tin are really the Best Fandom for #SB19!!!Attention! Bashers should take note of these because Some Songs are not All being considered as "Plagiarism"!!!

[@asielzal4790]

Padayon Chuck! yes it's hard to ignore people criticizing or badmouthing you for what you do or stand for...pero cge lang! Isa ka sa mga "Agila na sumilip" and not everyone taglay ang traits ng isang Agila kaya let them be! BULAN & LIT are totally 2 different masterpieces! And the words "plagiarized" & "inspiration" sobrang magkaiba spelling pa lang ang layo na (hehe yes pun intended!)

[@chongco659]

If they think there is an issue just file a case to stop this non-stop accusation , and by the way Kuya Chuck thank you you’re such a blessing

[@cricheltkenfelip9639]

Slamat po.. 🤙💙💠🌙🌙🌙🐣🐣🐣

[@lemonadejuicesuperfresh8289]

This video just aims to defend Ken/Felip from the accusations of plagiarism. Kung hindi naman pala kayo kabilang dun sa mga nag aakusa ng plagiarism/copying/stealing edi hindi ito patama sainyo. This video is not for you. Plagiarism is such a serious term and it is a crime punishable by law. Alamin muna ng iba na nag aakusa kung anong ibig sabihin ng plagiarism tutal may oras naman kayo mag comment ng masasama sana may oras din po kayo mag research.

[@helenbeltran6420]

Haters or envy will surely show up. But they can never put a good man down. That last part broke my heart. Thank you for sharing this. Kudos to your videos.♥️🇵🇭

[@homecooking7495]

Sa realidad ng buhay lagi tayong nabubuhay sa pagkukumpara sa ibang tao.Ito ang “CURSE OF COMPARISON”!Kaya madami sa atin ang mga walang tiwala sa sarili abilidad at talento.Kaya IKAW,TAYO AT AKO ang BAKUNAWA na lumalamon sa ating mga sariling kakayanan.

[@jasmineuy6976]

Please know the difference between INSPIRATION and PLAGIARISM. You will see PLAGIARISM if you actually see it and are not a fan of either groups.

[@jancyruslabrador4941]

Kaya nga nagiba sila ng narrative eh.. pina pacredit kay lay.. hahaha

[@jasmineuy6976]

@@jancyruslabrador4941 please elaborate on what you are implying. You are making unnecessary misunderstandings.

[@ren-dz1bd]

this video is just lesson learn. being toxic fan will kill the dream of an artist. sinasabi na may naisali daw na hindi dapat . pero sa ginagawa nila na manira sa dignity ng isang tao . hindi ba nila inisip na nakakasakit na sila? pinakita lang dito kung ano ang resulta ng isang toxic fan. nakakatakot maging part ng ganitong fandom...

[@myxed21UP]

HAPPY 1 MILLION VIEWS "BULAN" by Felip!!!! Keep winning! While LOSERS keep WHINING! hindi nyo ikakayaman o ikakaganda yung INGGIT. tandaan nyo yan.

[@shamhere414]

SLMT for this informative video kuya. SLMT also sa pagprotect at pagsupport sa boys. Ignore also your haters dahil bumalik sa kanila ang sakit na pinaramdam nila. Let them bark! 😎

[@lunamoon1848]

nagpapaiyak ka Chuck!!! Ngayon ko lang napanood ito abala sa sa pagstream for Bulan and La Luna... Very well said i don't know y some people find this offensive. You just laid your research on the table objectively. You never cease to amaze me bro!!! Keep it up!

[@vivzskye661]

Hello Cashual Chuck, thank you po for standing out for our dearest Felip. Saka huwag mo nang pansinin ang mga komentong hindi maganda. Marami yan ako rin noon nakaranas ng makabasa ng basher comments sa sobrang asar ko turn off ko nalang yong notifications saka yong iba ni hide ko sa comments section ko. Eh di tahimik buhay. Saka iwas iwas rin sa twitter na mapanakit. Nag twitter lang naman ako at IG dahil sa SB19 at dahil sa votings.

[@sb19sakalam28]

Same po.. Nag Instagram at tweeter lng din ako dhil sa voting.. D nga ako nag fb.. Messenger lng gamit ko... Peru ng live kase sila sa fb kaya nag log in ako...

[@komentarista_mayor]

Nobody is original in music! Only God is original! Like what Rico Blanco said, that no one is original in music, its just different how we use it, tempo, rhythm, progression and other music elements. Its like we all know how to tie our shoe but in a different way.

[@johfelsolo2118]

Worth to watch kaps Chuck.Thank you for this Lezzz go FELIP/KEN 💪🤟

[@lovediesfaster]

As I was locked out of my Twitter account i really didn't know about this issue. I watched the MV the day it went out but I didn't really see any problem with it. Hope Felip and his team is ok. I know they can get through this. Ken if you are reading this Jiayou! You can do it. 坚强 ! Be strong. You are not alone. You have your family,friends, SB19, and A'tin behind your back. Thank you Chuck for this wonderful video as always.💠💙

[@Ken_suson0112]

Other fans bashing ken... We did not if Ken is okay right now. After he out his Music video he was so very excited when his song is #3 in trending music but now that his MV reached 1M views he did not tweet. Why some of them bash him....

[@arisawang14]

Same here. ♥

[@aiaheunicesapphire5271]

This casual chucks documemnary explains it all. Felip does'nt plagiarized, come on people just spread love. By the way i had to admit casual chuck your are BRILIANT. Amazing work!💖

[@happymelody440]

Very passionate fanboy😊

[@ririherts9654]

Mad respect to you sir Chuck for being there for our great artist..❤.Tanungin naten ung mga bashers if ano na progress sa life nila ..meyged...it's just bouncing back sa sarili nila...mema lang kasi and just mirroring to their own self insecurities of what they can't do for success....lablab Chuck...lablab #SB19...lablab Felip❤

[@jinnfree259]

Hindi ko alam ang MV na sinasabing may SIMILARITY sa Bulan. When I watch Bulan the first time mas naging curious ako malaman ang Mitolohiya Ng Pilipinas, I love history Kasi, mas nadagdagan ang desire ko to dig deeper Kasi naipakita ni Ken Kung gaano kaganda ang Mitolohiya natin. Siguro din kaya may issue na ganito siguro dahil SB19 ang gumawa. Nagulat Lang sila siguro na kaya din Pala ng Pilipino ang ganito. No matter what happen I am and will always be an A'tin, I'll protect SB19. SB19xA'tin hanggang sa Huli. Thank you kuya Chuck ISA ka sa mga treasure ng fandom...keep it up po...medyo rocky ang daan pero magiging smooth din yan. Marami kaming sumusuporta sayo kuya Chuck deadma na ang mga nega.

[@mheannlorna]

Thank you for this, sir Chuck! All I know is that you have been supporting SB19 right from the time that you have discovered them. Chill lang tayo. Pabayaan mo na ang mga haters tutal sila naman ang maha-high blood. Malakas ang loob na magbitaw ng hateful comments behind a computer. And if they ever virtually attacked your family, may karma naman eh. I'm sure malakas ang balik nyan sa kanila. Let's just stream #FELIP_Bulan & other great works (including solos) of #SB19.

[@princesand8361]

Pareho kami ng brand ng brief ng tropa ko, BENCH BODY. Mas luma yung sakin, meaning nauna ako bumili. Guess what, di ko siya hiningan ng credit.😂

[@Vinces.Eunice]

😁😆😁

[@SunRay_1990]

😂😂😂😂

[@irahcac8762]

🤣🤣🤣🤣Omg dami kung tawa mozet! 😂

[@SunRay_1990]

At tsaka credit niyo na din ang color sa crayon company🤣🤣🤣

[@princesand8361]

@@jm-pl2zq sssh.. wag na maingay, kaps 🙊😂

[@LuzbeeAntolo]

Warning: Don't watch this in public. Grabe, I literally cried watching this. Jonghyun's tragic end & Felip crying just breaks my heart 💔😭 Let's all be open-minded. World peace, y'all! 🫂

[@pialee4687]

Nailed it again CashualChuck! Without your deep dive I wouldn't even know that there really are people whose life goals are to accuse other artists of "plagiarizing" their idols' work (they srsly need to get a new hobby). What really hurts me most is that some of them are fellow pinoys. Chinese stans don't put their CPop idols down. Filipino stans do it a lot to the PPop idols. 😞

[@ja_1983]

Ghost writers & music/beats producers exist in diff country. Like in Korea, there's some foreign ghost producers based there then if an Entertain Company gonna release a song or album they will contact them then those ghost producers gonna contact their fellow ghost producers too outside Korea to inform if they're interested to submit their demos/sample(s). After that the company & their in-house producers or the artists itself will choose among those samples then the choosen ghost writers or producers will either come to Korea or just through online. Then all those choosen will create another beats from their samples until they the whole song. If the company is satistfied, they gonna buy the rights & their in-house producers & artist that gonna release it will just folish it with their own & will take the credit or copyright. While the rejected samples/demos gonna be recycled by those ghost producers & if there's a new client they gonna present it. That's why there's a lot of songs around the world that sounds similar to each other. Yes the edited out part was inappropriate & disrespectful but it mean no harm imo. They just choose to IGNORED the POINT w/c was supposed to be an eye opener or awareness of the extent of one's HURTFUL WORD(S) effect or will affects one's life either mentally or emotionally. Not just netizens, haters, bashers, ssasaengs (obsessive fans) but an actual fans too of a certain idol(s)/celebrity(es) ang nang-aatack if the issue(s) was not on their favor. They doesn't care if bias pa nla yan. Kung baga "sentence w/out investagation" ang peg nila. That's why Korea has high rate of depression w/c sadly often end tragicly & yong mga baby bra aka immature kpop fans na pinoy ay nahawa na rin. Cancel culture again sa kapwa pinoy. So kung wala lng namang magandang ilalabas sa bibig or ita-type sa keyboard, it's better to keep it to yourselves na lng at least malinis ang conscience mo. PS. Padayon lng Chuck. Keep up the amazing work. God bless always

[@martin4374]

Good arguments like this bring tears to my eyes.

[@gemg6164]

Thank you, Chuck! Pagdating sa mga ganitong vids, talagang maasahan kang we'll get a quality & informative video! Again, thank you for all the hardwork! Wish I could support your channel more but for now, all I can do is share these informative vids you have as much as I can. 💙

[@phoejantonio]

Happy birthday, kuya Chuck! Grabe. Imbis na kami ang mag regalo sa'yo , ikaw pa ang nag treat samin with this video. Super thank you! Abangers na agad ako.

[@swiftiekeun]

this video of yours Chuck, definitely silence the accusers, at least in twitter, haven't seen that much of stupid tweets anymore. You hit them on their weakest spot.

[@streamtamed-dashed5206]

Tama ito lang ang napatahimik sa kanila. Naiinis ako sa ibang A’tin parang mga tuta inakusahan na nga nila si felip ang babait pa din. Kakainis.

[@swiftiekeun]

tapos yung ibang a'tin fanbase pa pina patake down tong video ei eto nga yung eye opener ei, samantalang sila nagka clout chasing lang.

[@ayesha45days]

may nabasa ako, they planning na imass report si kuya cashualchuck

[@euniceysabel3166]

Thank you huhuhu #ProtectFelip Nakakaiyak I'm so sad about what's happening these past few days :( I hope Ken is ok.

[@letterfrommary1741]

It’s okay to love and adore foreign artists and their music, but don’t forget to patronize music from your own country too. But if you really don’t like it then at least don’t say anything bad because at the end you are still part of your own country.

[@you9838]

Chuck is like Jose Rizal right now, and they are trying to stop him from publishing his books. These toxic haters will become part of creating something someday, may it be furniture, art, clothing, designing, music, food, videos, etc., but they themselves could be attacked by the very same monsters they have created, especially if it becomes a common thing in the future. If the haters have waited for the BTS, Felip would probably mention his inspirations in creating the mv just like they always do, and Ken's fans who don't know about EXO would probably check it out, earning EXO more popularity and fans. Felip became someone who can be like his Idol, he probably dreams of collaborating with Kai or anyone from EXO. Future artists will probably avoid creating a homage for their idols for fear of being attacked by toxic haters. Felip is probably an Exol himself, but he was attacked by who knows if it was indeed an Exol as well or just a pure toxic haters that wants fandoms to fight each other for their own entertainment.

[@tipsandtricks8524]

THANK YOU FOR CLEARING THIS TO PEOPLE WHO ARE TOO RASH TO ACCUSE FELIP... IT IS INDEED RIDICULOUS... THOSE TOXIC BAKUNAWAS ARE DOING EVERYTHING THEY CAN TO DRAG PEOPLE DOWN JUST BECAUSE THEY ARE INSECURE. MORE POWER TO YOU, CHUCK! YOU ALWAYS STICK TO THE TRUTH.

[@happymelody440]

MAYBE those BAkunawa like fans experienced the same accusations to their idol so in return they want to accuse other artist too. Para nga naman di sila nagiisa.

[@ren-dz1bd]

ang cute ng fan name nila . now they called bakunawas hhaha...

[@cricheltkenfelip9639]

Salamt po.. Sana nmn maunawaan na po nLa.. 🤙💙💠🌙🐣

[@someone-sb7ql]

trust me it was never based on insecurity lmao

[@naida2dibdibnipablo295]

Agree to this.