Pan's Labyrinth - The Death of Dr. Ferreiro

[@Bonnie141617]

Its ironic that on a movie full of creatures and monsters that can give you nightmares, the most horrifying one of all is a human being.

[@luisfernandoguzmanleon1028]

Fuck you the only god comunist is a ded comunist

[@federicomachado811]

Apollon Abaddon Triggered much?

[@matchbox2482]

I think that may be the point....

Luis Fernando Guzman Leon They are no worse than fascists.

[@tennisdude52278]

Luis Fernando Guzman Leon Learn how to spell good, communist, and dead you dumb shit.

[@leahpatts6007]

It think this is the best death scene I've seen, because of the dignity the docter kept himself. Even when the captain shot him, he still kept walking as if saying, "Nothing you do will affect me" That was something else

[@skeem2455]

Yea same here ...very powerful scene indeed

[@elofkjellson3906]

Nah, he just didn't realise that he got shot. This is probably the most realistic gunshot death in film honestly.

[@jerrylou3435]

Doctor Bro carried the scene

[@derekescalante1355]

@@elofkjellson3906 yep also the scene near the end where they shoot the captain in the face is pretty real

[@MrNeuroMind]

3:50 song?

[@barrylyndon5552]

"You could have obeyed me.""I could have but I didn't."Total badass.

[@jerrylou3435]

Doctor Bro is the greatest Badass of all time

[@tequiness061]

@Old Time Home Sickness WoW well said!!

[@Harakan21]

What follows is his reasoning for not following orders sounds very poetic.

[@Elementalspecter]

🗿

[@GARGANTUANMASKEDFISH]

I love the irony of what the Captain did. In a fit of stupidity, he kills the only man who could have saved his wife.

[@anonymouslee2083]

Captain Vidal didn't give a shit about his wife. To him, she only mattered until his son was born.

[@is64611]

It was more about him being a spy for the rebels than euthanizing the stutterer.

[@jorgebersabe293]

@@anonymouslee2083 And Vidal cares about his son, but as an extension of himself, not as a real person.

[@anatoldenevers237]

Jorge Bersabe yeah, Vidal is just a complete monster

[@daniellelo532]

That Captain Vidal aus Spanien in that of Second World War’s second to last year was a dolt comparing to apropos of Austrian-born Deutscher Politiker Adolf Hitler.

[@kokomanation]

the sad thing is that the actor playing the doctor recently passed away this truly is one of the best scenes in the film

[@Salomious]

chris kokolios Yes, Alex Angulo awesome actor. RIP...

[@kokomanation]

this scene is very related with what is happening in the world today human evil never ends and coexists with the nature of good in everyone of us it only needs to be triggered by the timeline of our lives

[@jerrylou3435]

Doctor Bro was amazing, and this scene will always act as a reminder of his greatness We will miss you

[@timmaloney9976]

May he Rest In Peace.

[@DeepEye1994]

He was great as Padre Angel from "The Day of the Beast".

[@soloragoldsun2163]

"To obey-just like that-for the sake of obeying, without questioning...that's something only people like you can do, Captain." One of the best lines of the movie, and definitely one of the overall themes. I love how this comes back later on, when Ofelia is ordered by the Faun to harm her brother, and refuses despite the Faun saying earlier that she had to do everything she was told. In the end, that choice was her final victory, when she chose not to blindly obey.

[@soloragoldsun2163]

No, I'm an atheist.

[@soloragoldsun2163]

Really? That's interesting, though I feel that "without questioning" holds the same meaning as "without thinking it over." Both mean that you're considering the decision, questioning if it's right or wrong before doing or not doing it.

[@MrNeuroMind]

3:50 song?

[@josemiguelserrano3467]

Pp 😍

[@ikari683]

@@MrNeuroMind Pan's labrynth-16: the funeral. Soundtrack.

[@Akanint]

Doctor Bro is my favorite character in that movie. He's kind enough to put the torture victim out of his misery, he's badass enough to tell Vidal off straight to his face, and he's even more badass when Vidal shoots him in the back and he just casually takes it like "Ugh, I think I have something in my eye." You went down with dignity, Doctor Bro.

[@santiagoz.s.1024]

Why you call him Doctor Bro? His name is Ferreiro

[@matthewogden2747]

Cause he's a bro

[@Andre12241]

Doctor Bro xd

[@anonymouslee2083]

That's how you know he's serious about being a doctor. He put the Hippocratic Oath before his own life by refusing to aid and abet Vidal's torture of POWs.

[@IvyHilts]

The actor that played Dr. Bro sadly died in a car crash a couple years ago. Great actor.

[@andreafernandezzinola6604]

'To obey-just like that-for the sake of obeying, without questioning... that's something only people like you can do, Captain'. I don't know how it sounds in English, but in Spanish you can feel the pain, you can really feel the words he's saying.

[@jerrylou3435]

There is no English version, they couldn’t translate Doctor Bro’s emotional lines in English in a way that would give the character honour

[@macedo8410]

@@helloman1051 It's the way he speaks these words more than the words itself, but he says: -Es que... Obedecer por obedecer, así, sin pensarlo... Eso solo lo hace gentes como usted, capitán.

[@cs8108]

The emotion came across in English. You could see it in his face. It was intense.

[@physiofred]

I don’t think it’s pain as such, I think it’s contempt.

[@ColdNorth0628]

@@jerrylou3435 that is untrue.

[@fettfan91]

The doctor’s line about obedience to the captain is so powerful, it beautifully explains his motivation while not becoming drawn out or cheesy.

[@olgaradulovic7684]

The world needs more people like the good doctor.

[@jerrylou3435]

Olga Radulovic Do you mean the good Doctor Bro?

[@kokunoskos6836]

the doctor was weak... Today world needs more people like captain Vidal

[@agrigoat]

Weakness = Shooting some in the back surrounded by soldiers loyal to you Strength = Keeping your morality and humanity when surrounded by petty thugs and not only that but acting morally without qualms then refusing to give in to the threats of lesser beings (not men mind, cowards who think a gun is the only mark of strength)

[@andromedanangel6042]

Shaun Murphy?

[@anatoldenevers237]

Kokunos Kos I hope this is a joke

[@allbeen]

The way he was walking & casually removed his glasses almost looked like he was expecting the gunshot, or at least didn't care less about what happened to him. As long as he got to leave the captain's service

[@jerrylou3435]

To me, Doctor Bro’s death is one of the most meaningful act of rebellion in the film and it’s also one of the few deaths in the film that stick with you because of how great the character was

[@theozlander4629]

He knew the moment he turned and saw Vidal had followed him out. But he just kept walking. A true legend.

[@WeaselKing1000]

He was tired of it all.

[@pushkaraksh123]

This movie's a fucking gem.

[@Lesak2]

Pushkaraksh Tiwari Almost perfect man.

[@tequiness061]

"Porque obedecer... así, sin pensarlo, solo lo hacen personas como usted". Great doctor. Great character.

[@jennaesgar7731]

There's a beautiful detail here I hope no one missed. When the doctor is about to inject (and mercy kill) his friend, he hesitates. You can see his hand shaking. The injured rebel looks down, noticing this, then covers the doctor's hand with his own. He guides the needle into his own arm. The doctor injects him afterward. It was a quiet, powerful gesture.

[@myriadd6272]

No I saw it too. Such a sad moment but also sweet, what the doctor does for him especially as he knows he'll probably die for it.

[@jerrylou3435]

I can’t imagine how are it must be for Doctor Bro to kill someone he knows and that’s on his side. The age difference also makes it look like he’s killing his son and that makes it even more powerful.

[@bag3lmonst3r72]

It's kinda obvious...

[@benijager1372]

He deserved it for being a communist, not every men are equal, ask god how many victory he has gave us 🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱

[@benijager1372]

You are all weak men

[@jongon0848]

Ofelia's death didn't make me sad (probably because I knew she was in a better place) but Dr Ferreiro's death really got to me. He was a really decent guy and the way he died with dignity and the amount of courage he had was amazing!

[@ivanenhaced1751]

The magic realm doesnt exist ;)

[@jongon0848]

@@ivanenhaced1751 in the film it does 😉

[@fraundakelmbrilpondaprost90]

One of the most beautiful movie moments I've seen. Ferreiro fully recognizes his decisions will lead to his own death, but he's so fully compelled to his oath as a caretaker that self-sacrifice is his only option when faced with someone whose suffering must be ended. He is an absolute hero.

[@michaelacaleb7919]

I actually started crying during this scene, he didn't deserve to die.

[@cpegg5840]

"Deserve's got nothin' to do with it"-Clint Eastwood as William Munny, Unforgiven

[@DidaxS]

Michaela Caleb This really sums up many of the deaths during the Spanish Civil War: many people who were completely innocent and didn't deserve to die, killed by Francoists or extremist republicans (usually communists or anarchists).

[@jerrylou3435]

Doctor Bro should have lived and helped more people in the Spanish Civil War, but what he did was a noble act and he will be remembered.

[@toxiclady218]

In which scene did the captain hurt him so damn much?! 😱😥😭💔 IT'S not the same man the captain hits with a broken bottle with

[@alejandrorocker907]

@@DidaxS The civil war was started by fascism not republicans. Second spanish republic had begun to give rights people after other spanish dictator Primo de Rivera and Franco destroyed that.

[@strongestofemall]

This film should be shown in schools. The symbolism and what the film conveys in it's message is paramount to human intelligence and reasoning. Masterpiece.

[@n9nex19]

strongestofemall we r watching this in class

[@sevenwhatuknow]

I watched this in school

[@katemorley8147]

It is. It’s on the curriculum for spanish and film studies at the moment

[@crissycrossgaming]

Very fortunately it is!

[@kwayke9]

Which is exactly what I did 9 years ago

[@parrastaka]

rest in peace Alex Angulo.

[@HoshikoYui]

In the end, Dr. Ferreiro showed he was ten times more man than Vidal will ever be.

[@coralroper6876]

"There are no men like me." "There are *always* men like you."

[@jerrylou3435]

Did Doctor Bro say that?

[@coralroper6876]

No, it’s from The Avengers. It just works well in this context.

[@LetsGoOnASafari]

2:30 on = probably the most beautiful moments in film I've ever seen. It's a poignant representation of the serenity of martyrdom for a selfless cause. He ignores the orders of a tyrannical fascist to end the pain of a companion, and even when he is shot, he continues to walk away in the peaceful rain. Beautiful.

[@harveysengersmusic247]

This is what cinema should be about. Such a powerfull scene and even more powerfull mesagge. This movie is a absolute masterpiece. As my grandfather grew up in the exact same part of Spain being exactly as old as Ofelia, this movie means everything to me. I was able to show him this movie shortly before his passing and it was beyond priceless to be granted a look into his past with him beside me. Apart from that personal fact this movie explodes of symbolism. Its combines so much of this worlds art into one big message. Its dares you to think deeper about the harsh reality of fascism and how important it is to hold on to the child in one self. To me, the most brilliant movie of all time. Guillermo, if you ever read this; i named my daughter Ofelia after your amazing art. I can never thank you enough.

[@Th3SmartAlec]

*Shoots doctor* Five seconds later... We need a paramedic!

[@Fidelio116]

Who the hell is not a badass with guns in your hands and men obeying you blindly? He's not a badass. He's a sadist.

[@hopefullypg3431]

I always liked how this scene adds to Vidal's character when contrasted with the later betrayal by Mercedes. He murders the doctor not because he betrays his trust, but because he stands up to him to his face. Up until the ending, Mercedes is terrified of the captain and never talks back or contradicts him.

[@patsybob]

What's more horrifying is the fact that the doctor is the expert looking after the Captain's sick wife and unborn child. This scene shows the sheer cruelty and stupidity of the Captain. Not to mention the contrast of the characters. The doctor hates to see others suffer, the Captain enjoys it. It resonates with how the poor were treated too, the Doctor did the only thing he could but in reality most of the poor in Spain died in severe agony without even painkillers to numb the pain.

[@TheMaru666]

Apollon Abaddon , war feeds and allow to get power to psicopaths and violent people of all colors . If they happen to be between the winers , they can keep it in peace times as convenient haunting dogs .... He was sent to the middle of nowere to kill starving rebbels because he is good being merciless and he is feared. If communist had won , they surely would have a Capitain Anyname as cruel and merciless as Vidal for the same purposes. War feeds and allow to get power to psicopats .

[@TheMaru666]

And Doctor Ferreiro never says a word about polithics. I think he cares about gerrilla men because they are neighbours , friends , farmers ....and they are in a very bad situation.

[@jerrylou3435]

I don’t know why you guys keep confusing Doctor Ferreiro with Doctor Bro

[@Lesak2]

Such a great scene, the contrast in this movie its just amazing, the "real world" and at the same time the "fantasy world" working at the same time its just perfect.

[@gabrielgiron3320]

"... No sentirás mas dolor..." 💔

[@amany247]

No god but Allah Islam way for peace and real monotheist Search about the truth with honest heart.

[@Harakan21]

You will feel no more pain.

[@therealKINDLE]

To question is to think. To obey is to submit.

[@samsong24]

So upsetting to watch such a noble man die in such a stark setting.

[@rachellerydalch6106]

Entire film is excellent. Full of thought provoking scenes, Poignant moments, Dark fantasy, and frankly Vidal is terrifying in a very, very real way. This scene in particular, out of all the others seems to punch me in the gut like nothing else. I love this scene because it feels more subtle. Understatement as opposed to completely blowing it out of the water. Ferreiro knew he was going to die, and he faced it with a quiet dignity that I find heartbreaking.

[@Gary1q2]

best character ever...

[@randomaccount9151]

gary??

[@randomaccount9151]

+TheSasmam Aha gaaarrrrry

[@finnheisenheim8274]

Dude you autolocked fizz. Atleast have the decency to stay there and push.

[@jerrylou3435]

Yeah, I love Doctor Bro

[@toxiclady218]

Who?

[@jasoncavitt2043]

So good. If I were to come up with all the movie villains that were better written than Captain Vidal, I don't think it'd take long to finish the list. Brilliant characterization.

[@jasoncavitt2043]

***** Hopefully by the time my life's story is written, I will have come up with a villain for the ages.

[@jerrylou3435]

Remember to mention how Doctor Bro defeated Vidal’s need to follow orders and the fact that a villain has weaknesses makes him/her much better.

[@tazbahn]

RIP Alex Angulo :(

[@andresmora5192]

Captain Vidal perfectly embodies the evil side, scares his human monstrosity much more than the rest of the beings that populate history, Vidal does not hesitate to use cruel procedures to carry out brutal torture to achieve his goal (such as the sequence in the disfiguring a hare hunter with a bottle). His arrogance and military pride end up shaping this character that it is not easy to get rid of after finishing watching the film, the film by Mexican director Guillermo Del Toro has managed to portray as few times that essence mixture of fear and harshness that the character instills.

[@tankmaster1018]

One of the best villains from any movie I have ever seen. Seriously, this guy makes my top 10 list easily. Oh man, what a brilliant character for the actor to play! The material he was given to work with was just fantastic and the actor took it to the next level!

[@myoldmate]

Agree. Vidal is truly a sadistic evil c**t. My number 1 bastard ever.

[@riddlegunnermanuel6503]

One of the best movies and scene I seen in my life, Wow! What a masterpiece!!

[@Tsumami__]

This movie personifies the excerpt, "head bloodied, but unbowed"

[@nocountry4oldfreeman]

Sergi Lopez was amazing in this as a real bastard. Oscar-worthy, imo.

[@anonymouslee2083]

Also, that's a REALLY stupid place for Vidal to keep his gun. The whole film, I was waiting for him to snag the trigger on something and blow his junk off by accident.

[@carolkewley7410]

He'd deserve it.

[@alisonpurgatory85]

I doubt he thinks he'll end up doing that, he's too.... cocksure I'll see myself out lol

[@nuahS]

Only the evil can follow evil.

[@you_can_call_me_robin]

Everyone talks about the doctor but i think Tarta is the best character. He was so innocent and nice. I liked him so much and it was the only time I cried in this movie; when he died. 😔❤️

[@Flowerbarrel]

Poor man, and poor, sweet doctor....they were good men.

[@jerrylou3435]

Serasia I I’ll always remember the sweet Doctor Bro

[@andresmora5192]

Captain Vidal, is a Spanish officer of the army of the Caudillo of Spain, General Franco. Vidal is a sadistic Fascist whose huge ego is a perfect complement to his cruelty. For him, cruelty is a matter of routine, of protocol, the only way to punish those who dare to challenge him. He is the best villain created by Mexican director Guillermo Del Toro.

[@omnivorous65]

We can all learn from the good doctor how to stand up to the Captain Vidals of this world, who, unfortunately, are making a big comeback everywhere.

[@insidevoice9139]

I'm horrified what is being done to civil liberties across the world. Government Mandates to wear masks, schools & businesses to remain closed in many places; 3000+ People in Australia put on Government Lockdown unable to leave their apartment buildings for any reason. A wounded Lady in Canada being escorted out of a Hospital by security for refusing to wear a mask. I guarantee if they come up with a Coronavirus Vaccine it will be MANDATORY. Those who refuse will be put on house arrest indefinitely, fined greatly, or arrested and tried for the crime of refusing to be vaccinated. Everyone completely willing to forfeit ALL civil liberties while scolding and condemning those who dare to refuse to not comply with Any & All government orders for the intangible "greater good".

[@austinzwibelman8985]

@@insidevoice9139 I think you’ve got it mixed up. The people who want to help others run less risk of dying by minding the pandemic are the good guys.

[@alisonpurgatory85]

@@austinzwibelman8985 yes, and the conspiracy theories about covid and vaccines being eeeeevil are pushed mainly by fascists to recruit people vulnerable to such conspiracy theories

[@neofit0]

This movie is excellent. Great work Mr Angulo, rest in peace

[@ninadiener9806]

This whole movie is a work of art, and this is one of the best scenes. It's epic in the book too

[@theozlander4629]

I love the look of genuine shock on vidal He genuinely doesnt understand why ferreiro did this. He cant fathom doing something for no other reason than to be merciful.

[@pablobulacios7312]

Una de las mejores escenas de la película.

[@LiTTleGaBi21]

These vials at 1:35 exactly are like bullets. One for the captain, one for the doctor.

[@chrisencinas4142]

Those are the unsung and true heroes against tyranny. The civilian who does right for people that knows he will be killed if caught.

[@Bakedbeans737]

Keep in mind, during this time period these guys wanted a monarchy for spain and the Nazis supported them.

[@mr.brightside9885]

The whole civil war was basically Fascists vs Communists

[@RetrousseRaptor]

Fascists and a broad array of conservative elements who wanted to roll back the clock to a "simpler" time where the lower classes "knew their place" versus a coalition of democrats, socialists, progressives and communists (the communists did come to dominate the military defence of the republic because they received the lion's share of the weapons from the USSR but were entirely marginal to the pre-civil war government)

[@yoholup19]

Common Visigoth I would have supported them more if they didn't have Communist in their ranks but they at least didn't torture their powa

[@varric]

@@mr.brightside9885 More like Fascists vs Republicans.

[@mr.brightside9885]

@@varric the Republicans wanted Socialism. Their Salute was the raised fist and they even had support from Stalin

[@marianaramirez3828]

Le amo Don Guillermo del Toro. Le amo Sergi López, que talla de actorazo tiene. 💛💛

[@DonQuijoteDeTijuana]

Y Álex Angulo, que descanse en paz, uf... ♥

[@jerrylou3435]

No matter where you go You’ll never find someone greater than Doctor Bro

[@kingkongchief1177]

Fun fact this actor who played the villain is a famous Spanish comedian in real life and the producers argued with director Del Toro saying he was out of his mind to pick one of Spains most famous comedians to play a villain LMAO.

[@mostafamd2144]

The more you know🌠

[@nancyblair6187]

They're eating their words now!

[@camiloordonez4906]

You talk as the "rebel uprising" was fictional, it's the Spanish Civil War, stuff like this happened and Vidal is based in real people, that's what scary about him, people like him really existed and may still exist.

[@federicomachado811]

Apollon Abaddon Internet though guy detected.

[@legoy6415]

It does sound, if I may say, quite based.

[@JTomas96]

@@legoy6415 U HAVE NO IDEA WHAT U ARE TALKING ABOUT (I'm spanish) Fascist spain was as brutal and cruel as nazi germany. The only thing it lacked is racial brutality, but MANY leftist were put in front of walls and systematically shooted. Nowadays only the right side is remembered and there are even graveyards for them, leftist names are forgotten forever and buried together shamelessly in mass burials. This film portrays clearly fascist spain and even it's hebraic plus celtic/germanic basque and GALician love for grim fairytales and the supernatural. Farytail-fever was so rampant that Cervantes had to write El Quijote like saying "U guys chill" lol. About Vidal character, he is the most realistic fascist spaniard character I've seen, they were like that, even the way he speaks. Even the accent he fakes is nailed 100%.

[@acc314]

@@legoy6415 fascism doesn’t work

[@tfe1788]

This scene represents key characters meaning it is great for analysing them. This scene is also great at analysing themes like Faschism and historical (+ political) context. This scene highlights Vidal's characterisation he is the most horrifying being in the film even with the monsters and creatures throughout furthermore without his evil act of killing the doctor, other people such as his wife would've survived. Dr Ferriero is highlighted as a man who doesn't want to feel like a puppet "Only men like you can make an order without questioning". Also at his death, him touching his nose before death implies he is at peace with the situation and knows he did what was right. Vidal's repetition of "Why didn't you obey me? highlights him as a ruthless, demeaning character who wants to be in control of everything and even though he thinks he has, someone like Dr Ferreiro (a man on honestly and respect) will ignore his words to what's right even if it leads to his demise.... but eventual demise of those who Vidal cares about. Also the score in this scene is great at intensifying the atmosphere

[@timmaloney9976]

When an act of mercy is considered disobedience worthy of getting murdered over, that's just a crime against all decency.

[@nailarahmaputri9505]

He murdered the doc was more like bcs the doc was a spy, i guess

[@amparoespinozagomez6366]

Amo mucho esta película del laberinto del fauno

[@Chunkeecheeze]

The Captain looks like some sorta wife beater... All he does its kill kill kill when he doesn't even at least COMPLETELY think twice. JUST because they disobey him doesn't mean he can do that. Especially for killing Ofelia

[@justanotherbohemian3827]

Current 93 Spoiler alert!!!

[@yoholup19]

Chunkee Cheez he's a fascist that's why he has that mindset

[@nosorab3]

I mean, I get it's supposed to reveal to Vidal that the Doctor's a rebel, but those ampules are standardized. They could have come from any medical kit in the area.

[@awokenlight2060]

The captains like shooting random people for nothing

[@Ouromia]

Ferreiro died as a hero.

[@Chatterbox-94]

One of the unique concepts about the film is that in a world of fantasy and evil, the most sadistic and evil creature is the captain. It proves that evil doesn’t simply exist in fairytales but the world we live in. That mankind is just as much a monster as the ones in storybooks.

[@anatoldenevers237]

One of the many things that makes this film great

[@CodyGall]

This doctor is one of the greatest warriors I have ever laid eyes upon. I love him.

[@sv-xi6oq]

One of my favorite scenes of all time.

[@rafaelmelendez5475]

Obedecer por obedecer, sólo lo hacen gentes como usted Capitán... Tómala en donde más le duele, en su soberbia!

[@fishwoz17]

Came here after watching The Platform. Ivan is a fantastic actor

[@Pilum1000]

Existentiality of Evil manifests itself in fascism ..

[@robh9075]

Went out like a goddamn boss.

[@strictscrutinizer]

Hubiera podido obedecerme… - Hubiera podido, pero no lo hice… 🔥🔥🔥

[@sebastyann123]

The fact that the clip is in spanish makes me so happy lol

[@w1lbert10]

El doctor se fue pero con honor y respeto

[@edg5973]

Damn that Captain guy reminds me of Amon Goeth from Schindler's List. 😐

Apollon Abaddon Triggered fascist.

[@andyw.8893]

The real Amon Goeth was much worse than this. He was so sadistic that even the nazis couldn’t tolerate his behaviour.

[@Michelle-ew6ws]

All the scenes in this movie were soo effective they just stay with you

[@aquaholic1004]

That is the best summation to this move that i've ever seen

[@FRONT-rc1qg]

The movie is a gem

[@elofkjellson3906]

Too many people don't seem to understand that he isn't "taking" the shot. He didn't even realise that he got shot, and if he did, he certainly did not feel it. This scene is exceptionally realistic filmmaking, if you got shot from behind in vital organs like he did here, you wouldn't feel it at all. You likely wouldn't even hear the gunshot, and possibly won't know you got shot before it is too late.

[@__-vb3ht]

It may be realistic, but I don't think it was meant to be about realism. Del Toro doesn't strike me as someone who would strive for hyper-realism, especially in a literal fairy tale. Probably his intention was to really serve the narrative, to portray the doctor's resistance and dignity. That just happened to look like what it might look like in the real world.

[@NoriMori1992]

Of course you would hear the gunshot, gunshots are extremely loud, way louder than they show in movies. I think he does realize he got shot (otherwise why would he even react at all), and is just having a realistic reaction to it.

[@christianmohr2993]

Beautiful scene , sad , but beautiful.

[@SyahmiRosli]

Wow. I watched this when I was six... How did I not get messed up hahaha

[@SyahmiRosli]

***** well that came out of nowhere hahaha

[@SyahmiRosli]

Eddie Adams nah it was televised on a new local channel that literally just released that time. It was the first movie they played ever. And it was late night sooo.... there's the reason why it is so haha

[@hernandogalvan9447]

Obedecer por obedecer asi sin pensarlo, eso solo lo hacen gentes cómo usted , capitan.

[@bacondropped]

I seem to forget, what exactly did Vidal take from the doctor's kit at 0:40?

[@bacondropped]

Ah, right, it's a vial of antibiotics identical to the one which he found earlier at a rebel camp.

[@jerrylou3435]

He took Doctor bro’s second vial of antidote that the great doctor used to help the rebels

[@MasterControl-MCP]

Bet that interrogation took bloody ages.

[@madhatter1888]

Best last words of all time

[@ronniebarnett240]

There is a very important chunk cut out of this sequence. Does anybody know where I can find a length with it in? It's the scene where the mandrake root is thrown in the fire.

[@Jen-ss8mc]

Guillermo Del Torro makes the best movies!!!! ❤️

[@thefoxoflaurels3437]

This is another example of the themes of chaos and disobedience. Captain Vidal represents the Alpha Male: authoritative, strong, and powerful, but also stoic and indifferent. Whilst the Doc is a relatively weak, but gentle, intellectual, and compassionate man. Vidal uses his masculine strength to kill the Doctor, yes. However through his gentleness and compassion he is able to die a dignified, proud, and good death whilst Vidal succumbs to his own intimidation tactics, misogyny, and ego. Beta trumps Alpha, I suppose.

[@smkanim2009]

Well said. *Tips Fedora*

[@thefoxoflaurels3437]

It was physically painful to use the terms "Beta" and "Alpha" in an unironic context.

[@tamasvarga9862]

your analysis is shallow and wrong. the doctor is only weak physically. it takes an immense amount of strength to do something like he did fully aware that the captain will kill him for it. and the captain is only strong physically. everyone can be an alpha male with a gun. he isn't indifferent and stoic, he is a violent psychopath.

[@kjendrock1366]

Captain Vidal was an alpha in his estimation only. And maybe to the ass-kissing toadies he constantly had in tow. When his time of reckoning came, he showed his true, pathetic nature. He was nothing without his little troupe of boot-lickers.

[@jjviolator]

Wrong. The captain was a pussy and a bully, real alpha males do not shoot unarmed people in the back while they are walking away. His power comes from his gun. Remove the gun and he's powerless. The doctor had more balls by standing up to him, knowing that he would be killed for doing so. He died but went out like a man.

[@Zennofobic]

love this movie so much, think it's due for another watch... I think i still have a packet of microwave popcorn in the cupboard

[@iSynthh]

whats the music playing in the background?

[@swnerd-2320]

Ironically, because he killed the doctor here, he had to stitch the cheek scar the housekeeper later gives him all on his own. He was right, that pride was his weakness.

[@rociomontoya4842]

Mi favorita , la mejor 🤩

[@flymaster]

Well said good sir...well said

[@Thekidloquendero9745]

4:02 Women: captain, your wife is about to give birth Vidal in his mind: good damit! I've just killed the only man who could do attend her!

[@Moncayowind]

The actor that plays Captain Vidal is Catalan, in favor of independence, and his politics are on the left: Sergi López.

[@Moncayowind]

I'm not sure who the "you guys" are that you are referring to. Yo no he pretendido representar ni a México, ni a España, ni a ningún país - pero sí eso de "doomed" se refiere a la desaparición...we're all "doomed", aren't we? Or are you planning on living forever? ;-)

[@adrianmaciascatalina1040]

Paul no truly leftist can be with Catalonian secessionists. Their speech is intoxicated with supremacism and absolute contempt towards poorer southern states which they don’t want to help through taxes. They say they are lazy, stupid and even “moorish”, while Catalonia is linked to the European tradition and the empire of Charlemagne. How is that exactly leftist?

[@TheAmazingchickens]

sad that after all these years there are still people who seem to support facism..

[@Efargee]

Trump supporters for example

[@NormanOsborned]

There is still communist supporters so you know...

[@anatoldenevers237]

Marshal Zhukov communism and fascism both suck

[@DonQuijoteDeTijuana]

Right or left, doesn't matter... extremes and dictatorships should exist no more.

[@RatFeetJourney]

Shooting civilian in the back... Total shame and no honor for the soldier.

[@EternalMuscovite]

Ye

[@dirtydupe]

What is the significance of the liquid in the vial, and the fact that each man has the same vial? I saw this movie about five years ago on heavy psychedelics and am not ready to rewatch lol.

[@petercdowney]

3:29 First law of holes: If you find yourself in a hole, stop digging.

[@Lizzielyn]

U know whats fun? The captains actor is my friends neighbour and he is that kind of man that is so nice and always laugh and make jokes 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@kevinfaustino2019]

Wow ana jajajaj

[@kevinfaustino2019]

Que irónico

[@ewanfraser]

Now they have no doctor.