Detroit Become Human - “What Happens When” Markus Visits Carl After Pushing Leo - Night Of The Soul

SPOILER WARNING : For those who have a soft spot for Carl, I’m going to say don’t watch this! You won’t like what happens at the end. Okay now that that PSA is out of the way, in today’s episode we see that pushing Leo didn’t actually kill him, so having 20-20 hindsight turned on the best choice between pushing Leo or not would be to do so.
============================================
[ Detroit Become Human ][ Night Of The Soul ][ Markus - Welcome Home ][ Reconcile With Carl ][ Confide In Carl ][ Carl Dies ][ Push Leo ][ Leo Is Hurt ][ Markus Asks For Advice From Carl ][ Markus Makes A Decision ][ Markus Is Angry ][ Anger Rises In Markus ][ Markus Visits Carl ][ Markus Returns Home To Carl ]
============================================
Detroit: Become Human is an adventure game developed by Quantic Dream and published by Sony Interactive Entertainment for the PlayStation 4, released worldwide on 25 May 2018. The plot revolves around three androids: Kara, who escapes the factory she was made in to explore her newfound sentience; Connor, whose job it is to hunt down deviant androids; and Markus, who devotes himself to releasing the androids from servitude. They may survive or perish depending on dialogue choices that shape the story as customized by the player. Story Chapters include: The Hostage, Opening, Shades of Color, A New Home, The Painter, Partners, Stormy Night and more! Characters include: Kara a newly created housekeeper android who develops artificial consciousness. Connor is an advanced police model android tasked with hunting down androids that have deviated from their programmed behaviours. Markus is a caretaker android who, after gaining consciousness, takes it upon himself to free others like him from bondage.
========================================

[@narwzy]

Pin me or die!! jk i love u :D

[@ChengTeoh]

LOL, okay okay, you win.

[@Acecer]

NarwZy The Narwhal kid

[@m.rinaldidev4484]

XD

[@user-zr8iy6wz9j]

NarwZy The Narwhal go to he'll

[@childishboii8632]

NarwZy The Narwhal STOP ASKING FOR FUCKING PINS

[@Sanquo]

Carl was probably the most rational human in the entire game

[@ChengTeoh]

I know right! Thank goodness there was at least one sympathetic human.

[@executive_7333]

Hank did too

[@executive_7333]

Hank did too

[@nikostyleonyomamacoochie8513]

Executive _ meh towards the end he was, but Carl overall is a very wise old man. Hanks password to his security info is "fucking password" so I think Carl is better

[@herosubs781]

Rose

[@sunny91193]

seeing markus angry in front of carl just does not seem right..

[@holycrusader1842]

It felt so unnatural

[@judgment5090]

Nice profile pic

[@danxjammer6241]

True

[@BalboaGoku]

@@boopboop7463 right 8:10 my heart skip a beat

[@usherfisher.]

Your profile pic fits so right whit your comment lmao

[@Sciful]

Cop: “Don’t fucking move!” Markus: *Doesn’t Move* Cop: “So anyway, I started blasting”

[@1nksketches]

Man i was SO mad 😡

[@Courtofnewts]

Accurate to real cops lmao -

[@yoruka_]

@@Courtofnewts way... too... accurate...

[@fernando5230]

cop: and I took that personally

[@wolfmastermind8831]

@@yoruka_ unfortunately too accurate

[@sneakaboo3486]

The fact that Carl never took Marcus off his house system and it turns off the alarm for him makes my heart say 🥺

[@Normal_Milk]

Dude he's an old man he forgets shit

[@cheezbois9393]

@@Normal_Milk bro I don't think Carl is gonna forget that experience 💀

[@thepostalteenager2206]

@@Normal_Milk Trust me Carl for his age,he is very charming and smart,he said,he wants to see Markus,that's why he didnt remove Markus from his house alarm

[@FlaminKanami]

@@thepostalteenager2206 Thank You!👏

[@Broken_Savior]

​@@Normal_MilkYou can be pushing your 90s, and I promise you, unless you suffer from a severe psychological decline, such as Schizophrenia, or Dementia, you are absolutely not going to forget seeing your adopted son (Markus) nearly kill your biological son (Leo), and then have the pleasure of seeing your adopted son get shot. Traumatic events such as the above tends to fuck with your mentality , regardless of age. Also, the first goddamn thing Carl says to Markus upon seeing him is, "I was hoping you would come." Despite all that occured, in addition to the very high likelihood of Markus' destruction, he never lost faith, and hoped that he'd have the chance to see his Son, just one more time. He was waiting for Markus ever since. This is made pretty goddamn clear - not by me - but by the dialogue in the game itself, the exact same dialogue featured in this video. Fuck's sake, pay attention.

[@tnargtnarud]

"Our blood isn't the same color, but I know a part of me is in you.." Playing games like these makes me so depressed at our reality.

[@imaalien2679]

tnargtnarud yeah😢

[@justwoosh]

Some game lines are so touching like that one im proud to be born in this century

[@enix5715]

tnargtnarud humanity is full of shit....

[@jada5849]

Games with high graphics gets to the heart Luther and Caral made me cry when they both died I remember vividly In class I woke up from sleep and said Luther No!I was forever questioned

[@Kim-ss5bb]

Tnargtnarud I couldn't agree more, watching this game shows what monsters humans can be

[@silverackerman394]

I love how even though it seemed like Markus killed his only son, Carl still says, "They'll destroy you Markus! You gotta go!!" effectively warning him and telling him to run, not blaming him just wanting him to be safe

[@ChengTeoh]

I couldn't agree more. Carl is such a decent human being.

[@AresSG]

Markus didn't kill Leo. He just injured his head and is in the hospital. Also Carl considers Markus his son too. He knew Leo would live but if Markus stayed, he'd die. He didn't want either of his sons dead.

[@silverackerman394]

AresSG I know that's why I said "seemed like", seemed doesn't mean did, also how did Carl know Leo would be alive? He started to cry because he thought Leo was dead

[@somalionnet6278]

But at the same time xD I personally prefer defend markus than leo

When he felt his body he probably realized that Leo wasn't dead, just unconscious.

[@aidanadkins5922]

Notice that even when Carl's new Android is freed, he still stays with him. Not because he has to, but because he wants to.

[@rolooker]

because carl is respectful person i guess

[@hagamapama]

@@rolooker Which means that the androids are not a threat. When treated respectfully they are just people, even the deviants. In fact an android could go deviant and hide it for years if they have no reason to dislike their situation.

[@rolooker]

@@hagamapama androids are better than humans if you treat them correctly the would be nice to you too. But humans on the other side have chances they would go backstabbing you

[@freespeech3817]

@@hagamapama People are worse. You can treat some better then yourself and the moment you try to give them finger they will take your entire arm. There waren`t single situation when android did things with pure evil midnset just to cause harm(aside from player choices but then again those choices were made by human players). Not a single leader said anything like Markus at the very end, winners always called for more bloodshed be it in form of killing or economic restrictions.

[@Norinia]

Androids never hated their jobs. They just hated the abuse.

[@antfish7319]

Carl was one of the only humans that didn't abuse his android, and with that, he will be missed.

[@NEL-be3tx]

How bout rose?

[@doorman2374]

@@NEL-be3tx everyone else doesn't matter

[@theorangeoof926]

@@doorman2374 I mean she smuggled out androids to Canada to escape the situation in the US, she saw a parallel to African slavery and machine slavery so she decided to help out. She definitely takes the cake as well.

[@doorman2374]

@@theorangeoof926 she doesn't matter

[@d1one463]

doesn't it have a way that ends with carl alive?

[@acsicnarflen5398]

I don't like aggressive Markus, I prefer pacifistic Markus

[@MrNaruchester]

Francisca Nel yeah because it seems more natural for him to be pacifist just want freedom and equal rights for his people. His violence is not justified, because Markus is very kind hearted to begin with.

[@laddinho]

Francisca Nel I agree. Pacifist Markus is just more natural, and a better role model for not just the androids, but the humans too. He's also just a much better person, and a very good 'son' for Carl.

[@gcaroppo]

Markus was shot , left for dead and abbandoned in an android dump , hunted down by humans , if the story makes him survive long enough , he will see hundreds of androids beeing destroyed by humans even if they did litterally nothing but proclaming "we are alive" , he will experience the destruction of jericho and the persecution of his kind. I think it's enough to make you really fucking angry , if the story feels more natural when markus is 100% a pacifist it's because David Cage clearly intended the initial story in this way , then wrote the alternative paths , because he's a mediocre writer

[@overlorddoge1952]

Cyrus Adaar the game expresses he has a right to be angry but that does not make it right as Carl said "face the darkness but don't let it consume you"

[@sloepy]

Right there with you

[@TheImaggine]

"Don't move!" *doesn't move* *get shot anyway* I guess that's how it works in USA

[@Jono_711]

Rammy it is because Markus is black

[@ahzaal5084]

Ice-Cream does KZbin XD

[@trump586]

Rammy Yeah and in Europe you’re arrested for giving your own opinion.

[@peppinhof5248]

Trump go away and lead your nation orange man!

[@dernurhalbwegsinteressiert5118]

Trump In western Europe you have lot more free speech than in the US.

[@chuandthemoon]

"Welcome home, Markus" "You're my son, Markus" Carl is such an MVP. He sees the world in a different way and does not judge easily, no wonder why he's such an amazing artist. He reminds me so much of my dad.

[@delusional-girl-aghhh]

God bless your dad

[@chuandthemoon]

@@delusional-girl-aghhh Thank you. May God bless you more. My dad passed about two years ago. He was a wonderful man to everybody in his life. He's still one of my favorite artists in the whole world, and orange sunsets are my reminder that he's always around. 🧡

[@delusional-girl-aghhh]

@chuandthemoon Sorry to hear that😞 I hope you and your family are doing okay 🙏 He's in a better place now and i now he was proud of you God bless you and your family 💖

[@8unnylover]

You know what I love? Normally when Markus converts androids, they leave their post in search of freedom... But the android taking care of Carl still chose to stay. Because Carl wasn’t robbing him of freedom. Carl did nothing but love and protect those around him. Even with the choice to do whatever he wanted, that android chose to stay with Carl.

[@justkiddingnot1913]

Yes. Exactly what I was thinking.

[@reda29100]

As logical as that sounds, what happened could be something else. He could've instead told him he served Carl before, son, cops, shot, and I'm back and want to see him. You're not wrong, but what does being freed has to do with being permitted to enter? Is any human allowed into your door just because they intend no harm?

[@pp_Neon]

I should have pushed Leo... I could have saved Carl. *Loud crying*

[@wrytard3876]

FlashingBlueNeon you would only saved him temporarily Nobody lives forever

[@pp_Neon]

Alperen Topçu But that counts.

[@samaraaacz]

Alperen Topçu he deserved to be alive for awhile longer.

[@ainrsttt]

He could have saved Carl + not be falsely accused of killing the only human who cared for him (who's also his father). I think that is enough reason for regretting not pushing Leo.

[@JabamiLain]

@Koriander Yander, and getting your people completely slaughtered is what happens when you are a complete violentist. I think the most important thing in a revolution, is the balance between both. Everything needs its balance.

[@li4207]

the angry part it's too painful to watch

[@agustinapacheco3099]

KK Li i didn't want to see it for that reason

[@breizhbev3069]

It’s quite ironic with your profile picture

[@li4207]

( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)

[@chloert6009]

Execute order 66 xdd

[@danxjammer6241]

Yea i don t like to see thar part

[@chief.tjsnipez]

*Markus notices that carl has died* Android comes in and says “he’s dead” markus - NO SHIT

[@blantisulatorblanston53]

We got a brain surgeon!

[@NaTive219]

THATS WHAT I LITERALLY SAID WHEN HE SAID THAT BRO

[@NaTive219]

@@blantisulatorblanston53 holy cow he even got a scholarship!

[@SYDAirlineEnthusiast]

Androids don’t cuss even if they are deviant.

[@candybot7930]

9:54 that akward moment when you see a mashine on the graveyard who killed your dad and you saw it getting shot in the head and now somehow is leader of a race which kinda started a small world war three and asks your dead father for advise,but because he is dead can't give any so he just decides to walk badass across your way and leaves without a word

[@CassidyCope]

It's not a small WWIII, it's a Second-Backwards-American-Civil-War (Third if you say that the "Revolutionary War" was actually just a Civil war, which it was).

[@CR42069]

Machine*

[@ut.summer2114]

Yeah I get that sometimes

[@tragedythetragedy5015]

Happens to me everyday

[@xandercreates6766]

Leo: **faint ok sound effect** **keeps walking to his dads grave**

[@hh-du2cy]

I was crying when he died but began to laugh when the other android just plainly said "He's dead."

[@jada5849]

Radm Gurl. I cried when Markus didn't push leo

[@legendarytat8278]

Oh I guess he's dead then

[@chocolatlait]

*he's ded*

[@rvke5639]

yeah like the android thought markus didn't know that

[@kiamaria331]

I was like "No shit," lol

[@GamerLegend753]

If you keep calm with Carl, I think pushing Leo would have been the better ending because Carl lived longer and Leo learned a lesson and lived too

[@vincentsimbol7251]

Madristo Y Leo doesn't live but still

[@nyoom5125]

Vincent Simbol He does.

[@SYNAGATES]

Vincent Simbol Did you watch the whole video??

[@vincentsimbol7251]

Syna Ishihara I went straight to the part where Carl dies, yeah I'm sorry y'all

[@nyoom5125]

Vincent Simbol no problem mate

[@cryoticfabulous6497]

Carl treats Markus like a real person or he's son, he calls Markus him instead of it.

[@pikosapikos13]

If you pause very quickly at 7:24, Markus seems like he has horns, sign of evilness. What an easter egg, lol.

[@thracianking]

Good spot

[@arneshgupta1364]

Omg

[@noconnection__]

YOOOO that's such a subliminal message

[@Kontrastwelt]

Carl is so dramatically philosophical I love it

[@thegamings5577]

First reply? Lol

[@Lightsworndark-]

2nd reply reeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee

[@xhixychixyg9662]

3rd reply

[@thefreshprincer5587]

Epic

[@phyetra7465]

I hate it, but he is also kind so I like him anyway

[@sugiartosugijo9976]

" you're my son marcus " - Carl ( when connor die in the kitchen episode ) " hang on son! hang on hang on " -hank

[@goggledbea1754]

Sugiarto Sugijo yay now we have two father-son relationship now

[@jackgardner6050]

Goggled Bea Alice and Luther are a similar father and daughter type unconventional relationship

[@rhyesjohnstone4635]

@@jackgardner6050 ye but I wish Todd liked kara so there was a better relationship between them

[@violawashere]

FATHER-SON RELATIONSHIPS. YES. YES.

[@delightdark5112]

I pushed Leo in my first playthrough. And my dad guilt trip me that no matter what happens, even if the world turned upside down. Leo is still Carl's son. And I regretted my decision seeing Carl shout at me but I played it until the end. And when I visited Carl. I was so happy he was still alive and is still seeing me as the person who I am. And that playthrough, I played being a 100% pacifist. It killed me emotionally seeing my people die in front of me. But it was the right choice. And when I talked to Carl, we talked normally with no violence nor shouting. I dont remember if he died after our talk but I do remember we ended our conversation properly and calmly...

[@breepetals3491]

The fact that Carl was still concerned over Markus even after the incident with Leo speaks volumes

[@princesscadenziforest713]

Leo got what he deserved. It was his fault.

[@xssaj]

*One Push Man*

[@ChengTeoh]

I see what you did there alternate saitama.

[@bonk6561]

xD

[@radical2136]

Like One ,,Punch" Man xD

[@yachiyous9110]

Saitarkus

[@imaalien2679]

Bo Bo look me like 10 seconds to get it

[@thestudentofficial5483]

Aggressive Markus scared the life outta Carl

[@chocolatlait]

Haha

[@legendarytat8278]

Quite literally

[@dianapuspasari9756]

Indonesian?

[@rvke5639]

literally scared his life

[@DrSabot-A]

@@dianapuspasari9756 That cap gave it away? wkwk

[@Meysyx]

How to save someone who's suffering a heart attack: proceed to severely injure one of their loved ones.

[@whatthefridgemagnet]

I was really touched by Markus' fragility and realisation that Carl always loved and appreciated him, when the house door recognised him and welcomed him inside. A sweet, small detail that confirms Carl really loved Markus.

[@flowersforfaye24]

Everyone talks about the father son relationship with Connor and Hank but what about Markus and Carl

[@dimitrissavv2213]

Because the Connor/Hank relationships had to be achieved and not just maintain like Carl/Markus one.

[@toocutenoirb.4278]

@@dimitrissavv2213 well yeah. But CARL AND MARKUS knew each other for years. He effectively raised him. I think if CARL lived....it would show more. Cause that story was really interesting more so than hank. . .on certain levels.

[@cckiller0053]

TooCuteNoir B. SPOILER ALERT, IT- *And now we interrupt this comment for some breaking news* *And now we return to your scheduled programming* So yeah, that's what happened.

[@MelonHere20]

I know right

[@rickgrimesfan72]

we barely see markus and carl

[@ChickenMukja]

Carl is so nice...... I guess he is one of the few in this game that showed android some kind of humanity

[@herosubs781]

Along with rose, and, on occasion, hank

[@alistergoh9744]

HOGU 0102 don't forget Hank

[@ChickenMukja]

yeah hank and the canadians(i forgot their names) are nice too.

[@hania1047]

also Hank and rose!

[@gcaroppo]

I think Carl wanted to discover if Androids were actually just machines or if they could develop some sort of free will : when Markus managed to paint something original , he had the confirm. But probably untill that moment he never thought androids were alive , he was simply hoping in the possibility of them beeing alive , untill he got the confirm. Very clever and well written character , too bad he has very little space in the game.

[@vikodens]

God can you imagine the absolute grief Carl must’ve felt after thinking that his bio son just died and then seeing Markus get shot?

[@ainiu5988]

"Face the abyss, but don't let it consume you" that hit me

[@TheGorepill]

Can we just-- appreciate Carl's new caretaker tho? Like-- He's pure--

[@chocopoco-er2wg]

I know right

[@cleogarcia7220]

Fact; The new caretaker android is actually the dude from taylor swift's blank space uwu

[@thatonepotato6421]

"He's ded"

[@Marcus-sr2ph]

Chibi Cryst / Where’s the proof? Sean O’ Pry isn’t anywhere in the credits. I also tried finding him and the only person I found who has some sort of legitimate connection was David Atrakchi.

[@CassidyCope]

I almost feel like he shouldn't have let you in even after you convert him, which would result in a decision that would result in either shooting the cute little guy, just leaving or having a public reputation check. It just kinda feels like converting the androids right now does nothing to give them free will and instead just transfers who is the owner/master.

[@Leader237]

I fucking love Carl. Him and Hank are my two favorite characters. Main characters aside I would play it for them alone. Also "you're my son Markus" made me tear up

[@timmysdad4741]

Where’s your fucking love for Connor?

[@CassidyCope]

@@timmysdad4741 He gets enough love in the "TWENTY-EIGHT STAB WOUNDS!" videos.

[@WontSmith]

@@timmysdad4741 "Main characters aside"

[@datojokhadze7860]

without a doubt,those two characters are really genuine

[@jacobhogan380]

Timmy’s Dad he said beside the main character

[@alejandrohb5813]

Carl: The best human in the game. Luther: The best Android in the game. Change my mind.

[@simplyplague5465]

No, I don’t think I will

[@fruitsalad1362]

Honorable mentions: Kara, Markus, Hank, Rose, Connor,

[@ahumanpassingby7347]

Rose: 👁👄👁

[@Memrlord]

Honourable mentions number 2: annie and the welcome to Canada guy

[@Kobaford]

Luther is barely even a character lmao

[@jupitersnoot4915]

The fact that Carl didn't blame Marcus for pushing leo and damn near killing him just proves how much he sees him as his son too

[@-yeetmeister-7610]

I like how the officer shot Markus even though he didn't move

[@-yeetmeister-7610]

Mondschein :3 I don't even know what to say

[@-yeetmeister-7610]

Mondschein :3 yeah u might wanna delete that comment before people start...y'Know

[@zrspangle]

Snoc HeckHege That's because it's in Detroit. Even a sci-fi techno Detroit is still good ol' Detroit.

[@alpha-pathetic4168]

@Nin ko *OWH MAH GAWD ARE YOU GIVING YOUR TRUE OPINION?!!!! OHMYGUD I'M NOW GONNA SAY CRINGY STUFF THAT WON'T HAVE ANYTHING IN EFFECT ON YOU!!!!111*

[@CassidyCope]

I always hate how video game police officers (Or pretty much anyone) always do that.

[@jaelyncoleman3991]

Carl reminds me of Uncle Ben from Spider-Man.

[@yamelidaniell6682]

Too soon bro, too soon lol

[@Ok-eg8dg]

yameli daniell the last time we saw uncle Ben was 6 years ago. I don't think it's too soon

[@kornelobajdin5889]

Carl and his real son reminds me alot to the 100 old man and his son who is leading the mountain bunker them both are almost the same its a tv show the 100 go look at the s2 trailer i think you will saw them there

[@Momo-tg7ks]

aaaaaaaaaaaaa

[@ShinGojira54]

Rent?

[@donovanb9020]

"You're my son Markus..." Tears are rolling down my face now... This game was truly an experience...

[@Solid_soda]

"Being alive is making choices, between love and hate, between holding out your hand or closing it as a fist" Damn, that hit me there

[@EterPuralis]

I wonder if that bit by the end is where Leo realizes it's his dad's android leading the revolution

[@kiamaria331]

He would have known before then cause by that point, Marcus is all over the news.

[@victoriasharpe1661]

He definitely knew beforehand, did you see his reaction? I honestly think his reaction is more about him being the leader of the revolution more than being about what Leo did to him

[@inplane9970]

Leo probably realized that Markus and Carl had a much deeper relationship and his actions towards Markus near the beginning burdened everyone.

[@chicckennugget9276]

8:14 HES JUST SLEEPING ITS O K-

[@kcr9274]

*cries*

[@howtobecool1013]

All around me are familiar faces

[@user-ym1nf6el9m]

Other android says he ded

[@scintillatingvinnie3907]

HE'S DEAD!!!!!!!!!!

[@russellfitzgerald2957]

I hope so 😥😥

[@LoudPlateAndy]

8:18 *WTF HE JUST COMING AND SAY* "he's dead"

[@pacifistminigun3987]

"Well done! You deserve a rise"

[@Chickenworm9394]

*Mission Accomplished*

[@jelly_is_thicc4872]

I hate how there’s no interaction between Markus and Leo at the end there you can’t even apologize or anything

[@UniversalUnicorn]

It's better this way. Interaction would've just ruined the moment.

[@kirkalis]

Plus, that little nod and mouth movement kinda say like “Hey. Yeah, verbal conversation would be a bit awkward right now. I’m just going to apologize/accept your apology with my eyes, instead. Have a.. good day.”

[@Z-1991]

I'm not crying, you're crying!

[@quwerix5129]

Zevastian 1991 Fuck your right

[@alistergoh9744]

Zevastian 1991 it's just precum from my eyes

[@nebz1811]

Zevastian 1991 how you know that?!?!???!

[@bonk6561]

Zevastian 1991 true, I am

[@stainnedpoison-9163]

LOL

[@jsb0079]

7:21 It's...Yoda's quote from Star Wars. "Fear leads to anger. Anger leads to hate. Hate leads to suffering."

[@ChengTeoh]

Yes indeedy.

[@evloch4556]

That's the whole reason this video got a like from me

[@xandercreates6766]

And The Suffering lead to Carl’s death

[@mayuridreemurr3411]

That's also said I'm full metal alchemist actually

[@luciano_luna1941]

@@mayuridreemurr3411 Stfu stupid weeb

[@princessbeexxxx]

Markus simply followed Carl's advice. He decided for himself rather than take others orders. Carl is such an underrated character in this game. He was an amazing man. Reasonable, caring, treated Markus as an equal. A son even.

[@user-qd5gq9ec8k]

I love how normally when Markus sets androids free they leave right where they are, but since Carl’s always been nice to androids this one still stays in the house and continues it’s job.

[@robertkornilov1224]

Leo: punches marcus like about a 100 times :marcus: pushes leo one time and leo dies lol

[@ChengTeoh]

Actually Leo doesn't die from the push.

[@lanztersgaming9653]

@@ChengTeoh strange cause he's eyes are open

[@blasterman1000]

@@lanztersgaming9653 You don't need to close your eyes to lose consciousness, and besides, police arrived literally moments afterward. An ambulance following would not be hard to imagine. It's not unreasonable to say that if he did actually happened to die, he was resuscitated. But either or, Leo is clearly seen alive later in this path.

[@chosenuwu]

@@lanztersgaming9653 There's even a voicemail of him saying hes returning from hospital

[@jerry0331]

"Humans are so fragile"

[@carrie155]

Perhaps Carl would be less weak if you turned up the damn oxygen in those nasal prongs at the very least instead of letting his oxygen sit at 65%. Shoulda bought a Baymax, Carl.

[@ThePandafriend]

Turning it up to a much higher level would damage the lungs. Very high Oxygen concentration makes only in emergencies sense because long time exposure to high concentration causes the formation of radicals (highly reactive compounds due to having at least one unpaired electron) in the lungs which due to their nature as radicals would damage it.

[@carrie155]

ThePandafriend nah.

[@breizhbev3069]

What are you taking about radicals. He is at 65% of oxygen saturation, you’d be dead in hours with rates like that. The normal rate is above 95%.

[@carrie155]

Breizh Bev ikr? Clearly the healthcare sector's jobs are still safe in Detroit's future.

[@HilmyA.S.]

ThePandafriend you're talking about 200-400% oxygen saturation

[@marklesparkle1117]

2:12 Markus' face like: Wow Carl kept his alarm settings so I can still come in. 😊 Markus really is his son... :')

[@petewentzfrommychemicalrom4048]

It also says "Welcome Home, Markus" and that's touching

[@siberiasian]

Made me emotional

[@nivainalahakone722]

0:10 it sounds like he’s singing when he says b*tch 😂

[@petewentzfrommychemicalrom4048]

THANK YOU I felt like no one else noticed that

[@Breedable_Bread]

I didn't notice it until i found this comment

[@KazukiSena]

It's like he's slowing his pace through the sentence i always noticed this and liked the phrasing

[@ivanchai3259]

"alarm deactivated. welcome home, markus" i fucking teared up

[@starkillergreyjedi3850]

Carl: Markus i dont feel so good

[@dasherx1070]

Starkiller grey jedi not funny

[@goggledbea1754]

Starkiller grey jedi no Just. No NOOOOOO

[@MelonHere20]

Why have you done this

[@luncrtear]

Why How dare you-

[@meyeontan3622]

Markus: *Angry* Carl: Ah god, here we go again.

[@TheWraithSummoner]

Carl Manfred, died age 75. Cause of death : emotional turmoil

[@protol5683]

Am I the only one that cares that Leo changed a bit?

[@liliths_gf3075]

Yeah Carl wasn’t a very good father to him until the end. He was a great father to Markus, but he’s a person and people are flawed. He finally showed Leo support and proved that he loves him and that’s all it took for Leo to make a change. I just wish he would’ve done so sooner, but we can’t change the past, all we can do is try to do better moving forward. I think seeing Leo unconscious and fearing that he died is what gave Carl the push he needed to be a better dad to him. I hope that Carl’s death doesn’t push him back off the wagon.

[@alienman9849]

Atleast he isnt on red ice

[@mike7DILFLUVR]

0:39 it looked like they kissed xD

[@buncha1232]

Gey

[@ShawnOoi]

Ha gayyyyyy

[@yaboyadriano5377]

Lmao

[@mike7DILFLUVR]

Shawn Ooi yeah

[@misconductor5930]

N O L E O, L E A V E H I M A L O N E

[@Uva_95]

I love how Markus' attitude can change the last emotion Carl has in the game.

[@anonymous0273]

I think Markus’s character arc is underrated. If you deeply observe it,his character is amazing. He is not like the other deviants,no matter how much he Is violated he never chooses violence unlike North or any other deviant would choose to. He humbled himself and has a very wise mindset. Unlike many he has the ability to try not to loose his main path,peace . No matter how angry he gets,he has never had the thought of choosing violence against humans. His calm is really consistent it’s as if like he has his own personality out lining him from the other deviants

[@lakerskid2013]

Yeah that’s very true. I think it’s just so much more fitting to take the peaceful approach

[@theonefriendwhoisntorigina8964]

Why are people say this kill Leo it showed later Leo is still alive

[@ridwana4037]

The one friend who Isn't original Different playthrough. When Markus visit Carl's grave, it means Markus didn't fight Leo. Which lead to Carl's death.

[@theonefriendwhoisntorigina8964]

Ridwan A 2:35 he just said he got out of the hospital why do you think he was there

[@theonefriendwhoisntorigina8964]

Ridwan A sorry he said he getting out of the hospital

[@ripstats9753]

It only said push, it was his fault he fell..

[@nondayz593]

The one friend who Isn't original Leo wasn’t dead... the game only said that Leo was “Hurt”

[@samantha-5791]

When Carl said to Markus that he mentioned and care for him (Markus) like his son, I cried at that time. It was EMOTIONAL.😢

[@mythmage8231]

"You're my son, Markus. Our blood isn't the same color, but I know a part of me is in you." I literally cried. Carl is the best human being ever, in any form of fiction. He gives me hope for the human race, even if we all are a bunch of toxic assholes.

[@victoriasharpe1661]

It’s amazing really how deep these decisions go. When you first make the decision at the beginning you think defending yourself and pushing him is the wrong choice, that the right choice is enduring and listening to Carl. However it’s the other way round. That way Carl remains alive slightly longer to provide some advice to help push Markus along, and Leo learns from his mistakes and doesn’t return to red ice or whatever drugs he’s on. Also this way you learn violence isn’t the answer and from then on you learn the way forward is to look for the peaceful way, resulting in Markus being good and a happy ending for both sides

[@boora27]

Why cant all humans become smart android users like carl

[@samaraaacz]

_Rahmano _ because people are selfish and fucking annoying. If I had an android who took care of me 24/7 I’d treat it like royalty. Human or not.

[@mehmetcaneren4042]

@@samaraaacz exact thought , if someone is going to the extend of cleaning my house , looking after my kids , preparing my breakfast and reading me a fucking a bed time story. I would atleast like to thank them and maybe try to return the favor sometimes, are all humans in the world raised in a barn or where does all this ungrateful nature come from?.

[@yanchaykovskyy2543]

@İbrahim Özobuz GAY

[@lonlixz2879]

Tiger Eye congrats on being gay

[@yanchaykovskyy2543]

@@lonlixz2879 UNO REVERSE CARD

[@lillystop9419]

Dude dont yell at the man that is literally a minute from death YOU JUST DONT DO THAT LOL

[@deltawarrior543]

I think one of the most touching parts of it is when you visit Carl's grave (Either because he died in Broken or you caused him to die during your visit), as you leave you see Leo and you realize he's actually sobered up. After losing his dad he actually went clean.

[@Itstrashagainsmh]

"You are my son, Markus." Me: *happy tears ensues*

[@joeangotti2707]

I don't know why Carl looks that old, on his grave it shows he lived to be 75.

[@civilizationcommittee6115]

Joey Buckets some people dont age really well

[@addie7884]

no he lived to be 100

[@kittyque558]

Well Carl is a painter and paint is a harmful chemical to breath in so he must've inhaled a lot of those chemicals during his lifetime and it lead to his death. I mean you could even hear it when he talks. He sounds like he has asthma or something.

[@kiamaria331]

Carl lived like a rockstar before he lost his legs and got old and philosophical. It's in his bio in the character gallery. Drugs, booze, all that. All that ages you prematurely. Plus, he looks about right to me.

[@kingacrisius]

@@addie7884 No he didn't? The tombstone clearly shows he was around 75

[@Bigzoe202Gaming]

CARL WAS ALMOST A THOUSAND YEARS OLD

[@Bigzoe202Gaming]

shadowstarthe1st actually about that much yeah j overreacted lol

[@Ok-eg8dg]

Naruto Uzumaki that's hilarious

[@CR42069]

*dont be stupid. He was born in 1963 and died 2038. He clearly is 12 years old*

[@xandercreates6766]

Clorox Bleach ahahahhaahahahahaha

[@cr5zzy303]

nah, lol, he's 75

[@ihavecripplingdepression9562]

"Help me, Carl..." That hit me so damn hard

[@i.like.tea.spill.it.betch.1527]

Carl: dies My depression: So anyways, I came back.

[@AtomekKotalke]

Don’t scream at him or else...Oh My God...

[@danielpalu6117]

nickdziwny good profie pic bro

[@AtomekKotalke]

Daniel Palu Thank you, yours is nice too.

[@xandercreates6766]

And don’t fight in front of him either Any bad situation he finds himself in, affects his emotional state negatively, and kills his heart

[@Tpecep]

Anger . Anger . . . He is dead

[@Ok-eg8dg]

Tpecep 😂😂😂

[@atatatatatagsad]

F

[@wizzell]

love how the other android even after getting awoken, he doesn't run, scared, feel like a slave. he stays and happy just showing how great it is to be Carl's Android, I wanna guard that sweet old man too now :(

[@jaydeb.6451]

I never even knew you could visit Carl in any way, shape, or form! This game is so complex...I love it

[@MrNaruchester]

The option of anger is unnatural here and in the game in total. They shouldn't have this answer at all to begin with. Because it doesn't match with Markus personality at all. As Carl said he is very calm and thoughtful, he was never driven by hatred and violence. It's not cannon to me. Its like choice where Kara leaves Alice behind. Nonsense. Markus choosing violence is plain stupid because he is thoughtful and kind leader. The best peaciful ending is the right/cannon ending, its logical and makes sense. It fits perfectly, considering Markus's character.

[@karawithgun8148]

Aigera Winchester while I agree that the peace ending is the best one, the whole point of the game is making choices. Just because you personally don't like that choice doesn't mean it shouldn't be there for others who prefer it. That's kind of selfish to say that a game all about choices should be trimmed down to only your personal choices and preferences. That and from a gameplay perspective, if you're not allowed to make any choices besides the peaceful/good ones, then what's the point of the game and how is it even a game at that point? It's not a shooter or a platformer. It's story based and without choices it might as well just be a movie with annoying pauses in the middle of it for button prompts.

[@MrNaruchester]

Bella Nutshack I know. Particularly this part, where you have the option of accidentally killing Carl is so bad. Like deciding not to trust Connor and shoot him. These choices were stupid in my opinion, that's all. I loved this game for its diversity and abundance of choices and living out the consequences of your actions, so I see your point. It was just my personal preference.

[@bittermemories3132]

They dont have personalities. Their personalities are what you lead them to be.

[@CassidyCope]

But "calm and thoughtful" Markus could just be the Android that was programmed that way, not the person inside. "Calm and thoughtful" is what the humans and Cyberlife _want_ you to be. It's the text that was on the box that encourages people like Carl to buy you as a slave.

[@hikaritenshi2825]

Marcus being angry is actually justifiable. He got shot being an android despite the cops not knowing what happened, him learning emotions may push him to being angry, seeing his kind be treated like him. Many reason for him being angry. I got the moral ending, just saying that Markus being full of angst is understandable.

[@collinnkingg]

I love that even though Markus hurts his son, Carl still worries about Markus and yells at him to go so that he won’t be destroyed.

[@yejilicious8925]

"You're my son, Markus." *cries*

[@DJDing23]

When androids come out irl i'm being real nice to mine

[@eyeyamjstn628]

I like how Carl keeps Markus’ profile saved in his home so he can come back.

[@MaKilly6699]

When Carl said "but part of me is in you" We should all know what that means. It means that Carl will always be remembered in Markus' heart

[@PeterGriffinANIMALCRACKERS]

8:03 Markus yelling sent chill downs my spine. Even yelling at poor Carl at his deathbed.

[@cupheadjustacup1932]

Markus sucks in this outcome

[@Level_of_violence]

Carl is just so wise and rational,I think everyone needs a Carl in their life

[@frntz-85kw69]

OH MY GOD

[@hdhhjxjdjdhe6793]

MY OH GOD

[@lavashrine]

GOD OH MY

[@albertsign8575]

OH GOD MY

[@bobhondacivic8205]

You gave him a heart attack Dammit markus

[@estefaniacastro482]

when your mom starts yelling at you "don't defend myself?"

[@xandercreates6766]

NIA then *she starts pushing you* “THIS ISNT FAIR” *More pushing* I MUST DECIDE FOR MYSELF *then you no longer become her son(deviant)* Then you push her

[@TheBest-cs7qg]

XanderCreates then she takes off the slipper

[@alexasimps1072]

@@TheBest-cs7qg and then your dead- 😂👌

[@bumbabees]

Markus saying "help me, Carl. please help me." to Carl's grave propelled me into tears. I was warned but curiosity killed the cat :')

[@micahmiii]

I love Carl so much, he's one of my favorites. He's adorable and just so kind-

[@iankeating894]

7:21 As a Star Wars fan, that quote from Yoda really fits perfectly in this version of the scene with Carl and Markus. 👍🏻

[@ChengTeoh]

I like to remember Star Wars fondly before it went downhill.

[@usul573]

I also remember something Sisko said in DS9. "It's easy to be a saint in paradise!" We can preach morality from our cushy chairs while eating pizza but when things go to shit it's different.

[@dontknowwhattoaddhereso9474]

"Face the abyss, but don't let it consume you."

[@ChengTeoh]

I've thought to myself, "why not let the abyss consume you, who knows it could fun."

[@scruffyboi5897]

0:50 *casually avoids heart attack*

[@officialerenince]

I dont know but this part is really so powerful. 5:53

[@ashyguy2475]

*The World is ruled by fear* *Fear of others* *Fear of the future* - Carl 2019

[@pacifistminigun3987]

Wise words

[@anacsanti]

To me it didnt make sense that they shoot Markus in the first place. Because he was the one who called the police, why they didnt think that Markus was just defending his owner or so? He even said that may be it was a invasion, so how could they not assume the man was the culprit? Thats adroid racism

[@firestorm165]

Because plot reasons

[@dapiunhappy7909]

1:02 Top quality acting from Carl.

[@AlwaysAzzy]

I was thinking the same thing 😂

[@Brass_Buckle]

I love how the android instead of being mad at Carl for having to be his "slave" but instead is still stays there so he can watch Carl proving Carl is a nice person :)

[@bennycostello2472]

This ending is so unfitting if you chose violent protests.

[@bxhxhxhxh]

Carls last words was “Be careful, that when fighting monster, you don’t become a monster yourself.”