Dialogue with History | Examining Why Pakistan was Created | GupShup with Aftab Iqbal

[@MegaEinstein5]

The only Pakistani that makes sense and talks the truth behind the pakistani establishment and there corruptions in a detail. Respect to u Mr.Isthiaq ahmed for penning down the reality and your true emotions about the divison of Punjab (Pakistan & India)!!!

[@sabihasammar4992]

Only Pakistani???? Prejudice on peak

[@johnxina900]

Probably one of the best dialogue I've heard from Pakistan... Love from india 🇮🇳

[@solomon4074]

Agreed,,, from pakistan

[@bharatt.v.5060]

@@solomon4074 When Pak is financially doomed...such programs appear...very soon the host will come again on Kashmiree Musalman Bhai.. Jihad... appears all drama till they get out of.FATF. in December

[@Prakhar9455305897]

Where is the discussion about Islami extremist idea of world domination???

[@SaleemChaudhry72]

I am angry and blow ☝ 🇮🇳 one min

[@SaleemChaudhry72]

Anything we welcome all....

[@VenkateshmurthyVK]

Best episode I heard from Pak. Tv. Real eye opener.

[@bloody_democracy]

Worst comment I read on a Pakistani episode ..

[@syedalishah4657]

❤PAAK FOUJ ZINDA BAAD ❤ ❤PAKISTAN 🇵🇰 ZINDA BAAD HO AMEEN SUMMA AMEEN ❤

[@kabeersingh3451]

We indian always respect the true knowledge..

[@AdventuresRide]

Aur Pakistaniyo ko prob hoti h truth aur fact se, yahi difference h dono me. 1 din h to dusra raat

[@AdventuresRide]

@Thappar se dar ni lagta saheb pyar se lgta h abe chutiye jb sb final ho gya tha tb ki statement hn wo, 1940 me hi start ho gya tha partition

[@rajendrajoshi983]

You would see the truth. Just listen to what this 'liberal' speaks at the end. He wants all Shiyas, Sunnis, Ahmadi to live in peace. Even for a liberal person in Pakistan - there is no place for a Hindu/Sikh or Christian. Islam doesn't permit co-existence. Muslims, by definition tend to become fundamentalists - would strive to finish all non muslims. Once they achieve this objective, they would find sects among themselves - and would start finishing them - the process would go on. There would never be a peace-loving society. Even the Turks could not sustain a liberal - forward-looking policy for more than a century. They are going back to the same concepts like Umma.

[@zeem113]

Deep Choudhury ajeeb bate nayi jo bate Pakistan ka khilaf ho wo such ha or jo india ka khilf ho wo joot....Aftab Ahmed na anti indian shows bi kiya ha ....jine ma , nehru, patel ki dimi bana ka joota mara osa b theek lo or such kaho osa

[@AdventuresRide]

@@zeem113 nzr ka ilaaz hota h, nzriye ka nhi. Pakistan ka base hi nhi h to sahi kya hoga. Army aur molviyo ne aesi tesi ki h tumhari. Bharat kabhi kisi pe pahle attack nhi krta, hr desh apne liye military rakhta h, pr Pakistan aesa desh h jo military ne rakha h

[@kingdomenclava2604]

I am doctor living in Korea , since 6 years .....i haven’t missed any program of aftab Iqbal ever so far I recount .......dr. Ishtiaq is good man , sometime also take Mubarak Ali Pakistani historian in program also to discuss civilization and fossils , archaeologists

[@irfanmasood7178]

You are homepathic doctor

[@irfanmasood7178]

Not MBBS right?

[@dhruvbhardwaj5349]

@@drsyedgazanferali2723 infact he is admitting what role Pakistan played since it's origin....Afghan me aatankwaad bharat me aatankwad....bengladesh me bhi paki fauj yahi kr rhi thi tbhi unhone alag hue

[@tm3793]

@@dhruvbhardwaj5349 Aor Kulbhushan Yadev Pakistan me phool bachnay gya tha?

[@zeem113]

owais akhter ایک ہندو کے منہ سے یہ باتین اچھی نہی۔ لگتی

[@bhupendrasinghrawat4450]

Brilliant honest discussion

[@mangomits]

Salute to the elderly, educated, matured, gentleman... Visionary indeed.. Lots of love sir

[@crazyvlog9095]

hahahha the just want to tel that it was a mistake and change the thinking of pakistani people

[@maryamnazakat169]

Yes right

[@wasifarsalan]

Listening Ishtiaq Ahmed for the first time & Its really good to hear such a knowledgeable person talking about the broader perspective which we have been undermining since the birth of this country . The golden word at : 28:00

[@anjamism]

Surprisingly happy to see such a honest and daring conversation on the side of Pakistan.

[@Singh_BaL_]

Sir I’m very glad to hear your thoughts and I wish more people came forward from both countries for better future and love ..

[@ravindrakumarmaurya1708]

Accha laga jankar ki pakistan me aman pasand log hai.

[@ckhush]

This man speaks truth although host is not willing to accept it. Salute to this person.

[@anilagarwal2289]

Your comment is absolutely correct.

[@indrajitchakraborty6708]

Salute to the person.. Most reasonable speaker after long time from both sides. I strongly believe if we both country atleast 10years ek sath economy me focus kare ek common union banay.. Itna resources hamaare hai we will rule the world together.

[@razibhatti116]

Aisa krny k liye soch bdlni ki koshish krni pregi un logo ko jo aisa sochna b ni chahty k pak o hind friendship kaim ho

[@razibhatti116]

@@2sridhark aja krle kuch kr skta h to ...

[@dhruvbhardwaj5349]

Don't u listen him ....what ge he said....agr hindustan ka bantwara naa hota to musalmanon ka poore hindustan pr raaj hota.... pr ye inn musalmanon ke mooh pr jordar tamacha hai ki aaj bhi sanatan dharm aur sanskriti jeevit hai....nhi to ye jaha gye hain waha ki sabhyata ko samapt kr diya hai.... the only decision I admire Nehru ji was that of division....because the seed of daarulisaam was always in their minds

[@dhruvbhardwaj5349]

Aur anjane me hi sahi Brits ne bhi isme sehyog hi diya...

[@dhruvbhardwaj5349]

@@razibhatti116 hahaha....abhi to Balochavart,(jaise aryavart waise Balochavart) ban ne ka samay aaya hai....baloch jaldi hi apne mooldharm sanatan dharm) me waapsi karenge aur balochistan ko ajaad Balochavart ghoshit karenge....dekhta jaa...

[@gursharnjeetsingh537]

Very nice interview. Agar dono mulkon mein pyar ban jaye.toh dono mulk bhut ammer ho sakte hai. Varna dono hathyaar. Khreedne mein paise waste karte rehte hai.pakistan mein tomato 300rs kg ho jaate hai or india mein kissan inko excess hone ki wjha se Road pe fenk dete hai.nuksaan dono countries ke logon ka hota hai.aisi hi or v bhut cheezen hai So dono countries kw aam logon se v request karta hu.k social media pe v pyar failayen.nafrat se kabhi kush nhi niklna. Love to all from india.

[@anujitchakrabarty1524]

Well made and explained, thanks for the real true outlook, no biasing... Thank Sir

[@MohinderKalsi]

An interesting addition to my knowledge of Indian history (later Pakistani history) by an honest and knowledgeable Pakistani historian... A UK Sikh.

[@dhananjaymahto1690]

In last two minutes you have saved yourself and your job sir.

[@MrHajuu]

بہت اچھے ۔ آفتاب نے مرنا ہے کیا۔

[@MrHajuu]

Very good. Aftab doesn't want to die early.

[@dhananjaymahto1690]

@@MrHajuu ji, I don't understand the language you have written. But any ways I appreciate that you have some thoughts on my comment. Be blissful.

[@mahipalsathi5340]

Such a daring debate ! Astonishing ...

[@Yesh2005]

The professor is obviously a very erudite person. Very clear mind. God bless him. A good interview, Aftab. Only a balanced and a learned journalist like you can bring into lime light such personalities. You always do your bit to remove the poison from the social environment, for which you deserve compliments.

[@tahirshah5375]

Iqbal Sahib, before this videos I used to watch you just for fun with my son in Las Vegas. Now this historical debated put me to appreciate your effort of history. I am a history lover. So please keep it up and break the stereo type image of Pakistani helping the extra state elements. Bravo.

[@anilagarwal2289]

The write was very forthright in saying that stopping non state actors are the responsibility of the Government

[@muhammadumar9655]

I'm watching this show in England. I ully agree with you. We all need to unite as one nation to strengthen Pakistan by focusing on our economy, education, health and defense. And I as a youth take responsibility to play my part in achieving our common goal of a prosperous and peaceful Pakistan. Allah bless Pakistan.

[@d.r.s3866]

First pakistani origin men tael truth about expot tarerisum issue

[@Hezklour]

Brave intellectuals. India and Pakistan both need such honesty.

[@sikhwarriors3270]

I agree with Dr. Ishtiaq. I am an Indian, but I realize that also, we need to each other in this condition, it's a 100% sure if we will stand with each other each can make a great Power after China not in next 20 years,i think only in next 10 years.

[@talhailyas7229]

But kashmir issue is still there

[@sikhwarriors3270]

@@talhailyas7229 I agree with you, but it's not a national matter, it's a international matter.

[@sikhwarriors3270]

@@talhailyas7229 Please you think about it, coz Dr. Ishtiaq say ,Kasoori formula is best on Kashmir issue.

[@talhailyas7229]

@@sikhwarriors3270 brother neither india wants to give up kashmir nor pakistan but isnt the land of the kashmiri people

[@talhailyas7229]

@@sikhwarriors3270 the loc could not be made irrelevant who would govern kashmir then and what policies will be implemented?

[@librettotv750]

Quite good information, it's like a lesson of political science!!!!!! Impressive 💞💞 love from India🇮🇳 ghaziabad

[@botpolice429]

Because it suits your idealogy

[@bateswardas2560]

@@botpolice429 becoz it is the truth bro...if you are a true muslim, find the truth.

[@gulfamhussain7751]

@amitava ghosh he who said bad things about Pakistan is your hero.its not only you all the indians are same like your mantality.have Indian ever consider thier mistakes ?? or they are bhagwans sent from heavens ??

[@mutirehman5268]

Mashallah and Jazakallah Doct Ishtiaq and Aftab Iqbal.

[@rajeshsivaraman9494]

Lots of historical information shared, I will definitely read this book it would have taken lots of research time to compile all these information

[@Bilalkhan-zy5oq]

Dr ishtiaq Ahmed sir muje ap ne apna fan banalia salute sir..... Awsome

[@khatronkaykhiladi]

Sir I am so impressed by your knowledge and rationality. We need people like you in both sides...and am going to buy your book sir

[@balkrishansharma7556]

Ĺ

[@mohammadazharuddin628]

bilkul shai baat bol rahein hai yein

[@khaldi1317]

Khalid from London, We need to be taught truth about histoy such as this one, not like the books we were taought in our schools to make us fool.

[@muhammadsalmanashraf8618]

kha ldi very good sahi kaha ap ny

[@sultanmahmood6396]

Mr. Javed Ghamidi who is hell-bent to propagate moral corruption against the teaching of the Quran, by hook or crook, he will justify anything he wants with the help of academic [trickery] argument. For example, A committed Secular trickster called Chief Justice Manir of Pakistan in 1956 wittingly caused SHIRK & He engineered the Title Deed of the Islamic Republic of Pakistan instead of Dar-ul-Islam of Pakistan. Pakistan officially is called the Islamic Republic of Pakistan'' Subsequently, the shirk Justice Munir manufactured becomes clear only when you look at the definition closely, it means people & Allah share supreme legislative power over the state of Pakistan. Although the 1971 constitution of Pakistan contradicts power-sharing with God & refutes Republicanism, the damage Justice Munir deliberately caused has never been corrected since 1956 by any Pakistan Parliament. Therefore it is the wicked secular minority lobby, who have ruined the success of Dar-ul-Islam becoming a law bidding unitary community in Pakistan. Pakistan records show Justice Manir knew the Republic's definition. Therefore Muslims must stay alert of these Secular centric academic tricksters, they are extremely sharp, they are foot soldiers of Satan, they will never mend their ways. Unless Pakistan legislators change the official Title Deed of Pakistan, we all stand collectively guilty of committing a national Shirk-e-Khafi. If you look closely at Ghamidi's silence against the practice of Usury, it amplifies his wrong priorities & motives behind his worldwide centers in the garb of Quranic teachings centers. Quran talks of gold & silver currency that holds its intrinsic values. Ghamidi failed to contribute any national effort to ban Usury. A once of gold today will buy the same level of goods or services as it did 100 years ago. On the other hand, the fiat paper currency is unstable and it's value continually decreases & the poor masses around the globe are in dire need of fairness & the capitalist are exploiting cheap labor & causing havoc on the masse disparity between Rich & Poor. he's dead silent on usury. He just wants to Hellenize naive Muslims to become under the secular sphere of influence so that secular minority can swell their numbers in Pakistan, Ghamidi has no right to manipulate naive Muslims who are the potential assets of becoming more pious servants of Lord Almighty God. The Incorrigible neoliberal secular Ghamidi bitterly slanders even the gallantry orthodoxy of Ghazali for his successfully holding back the Dujjalic Secularism onslaught on1.8 billion Muslims since the 11th century. After carefully listening to Mr. Ghamidi's misconstrue constructions on Islamic Banking, Male Beards & Female outer-garment. I can safely repeat that all of his corrupt suggestions are fallacious & full of academic prejudice. Mr. Ghamidi sinfully denies the divine law & asserts that the law is only for Prophets pbuh wives. He is attempting to water-down Quranic Law & misleads Muslims in favor of secular ideology which constitutionally rejects the Quran & negates the successful Rightly Guided Khulafa-e-Rashideen & devalues the truthful successors of God's Messenger pbuh. Quran 33;٥٩ يَا أَيُّهَا النَّبِيُّ قُلْ لِأَزْوَاجِكَ وَبَنَاتِكَ وَنِسَاءِ الْمُؤْمِنِينَ يُدْنِينَ عَلَيْهِنَّ مِنْ جَلَابِيبِهِنَّ ۚ ذَٰلِكَ أَدْنَىٰ أَنْ يُعْرَفْنَ فَلَا يُؤْذَيْنَ ۗ وَكَانَ اللَّهُ غَفُورًا رَحِيمًا59 O Prophet! Tell your wives, and your daughters, and the women of the believers, to drape their outer-garment over them. That is more proper, so they will be recognized and not harassed. God is Forgiving and Merciful. Quran 33;59 O Prophet, speak unto thy wives and thy daughters, (((and the wives of the true believers))), that they cast their outer garments over them when they walk abroad; this will be more proper, that they may be known to be matrons of reputation, and may not be affronted by unseemly words or actions. God is gracious and merciful. Mr. Ghamidi sinfully asserts that the above divine command is for Prophets PBUH wives & is not for the other Muslim women, despite, a clear express statement that commands the messenger [pbuh] to tell your wives & your daughters and women of Believers to drape [cover] themselves with outer garment when they go out. Subsequently, Mr. Javed Ghamidi is guilty of slandering the Quran of double standards. I see Mr. Ghamidi as a secular shill, acting deceitfully under their Hellenistic sphere of influence, he will lend support to Godless Western ideals, he stands carelessly, affecting to be seen of modern academic, wavering between faith & infidelity, and adhering neither unto these nor unto those: Sadly he is professionally attempting to prejudice Muslim Orthodox beliefs via Imimitaing Greek Secular ideology. This is unacceptable to any intelligent Muslim society. Pakistan Police authorities must stop wicked secular propaganda agents operating on the national media platform & the government must prosecute all NGOs who are taking foreign funding covertly to weaken Islamic values within Dar-ul-Islam Pakistan.

[@ssingh938]

Ye karan tha kzbin.info/www/bejne/gZupp55phqiCqtE

[@razibhatti116]

@Jungoo yar mujy to ye samaj ni a raha hm sacha kisko kahen

[@razibhatti116]

@Jungoo matlab ?

[@maryamnazakat169]

Aftab Iqbal is an intelligent person

[@mandeepsinghsangha7017]

A perfect example of how historian should converse. I didn't know much of Mr.Ishtiaq ..but he earned huge respect. Calling spade a spade.

[@BharatKumar-ti3jt]

Meri dua hai ki saare insaan pyaar se rahe love all humanity sab khush rahe

[@Diwana71]

Great listening to this discussion. Many thanks and regards.

[@rahul254751]

Agree with this Gentlemen 👌👌

[@mukhtaraslam3996]

Salaam to, Dr Allama Iqbal and Qaide Azam Muhammad Ali Jinnah for having this vision of two state theory. Now look what's happening to minorities in bharat mata. Pakistan is a blessing to Muslims of this land, and other minorities as well. Insha Allah Kashmir Will get independence.

[@kinni0111]

Dr. Saab is a great courageous person who describe the things which a lawful and progressive country should do. The anchor must be a knowledgeable person rathar this man.

[@abbasiwrites1915]

بابا صاحب کی باتیں تقریبا ٹھیک ہیں۔ اب ہم کو اپنی پالیسیوں پر نظر ثانی کرنی چائیے اور ملک کی ترقی اور ہمسائیوں کے ساتھ اچھے تعلقات بنانے چائیں

[@cppak45]

Humsaya Chata hay aap us k paon pr jao aur bjran k Nara lgao cow to bilkul ziba ni krni aur meat kha say lay ho mrny k lye thyar ho jao Islam k nam mat lo bandy matram paro ye tumhara islami name bta rha hay tum bhe atan wadi ho gay sub krny k bad tum he desh drohi ho.mulmano ki halt dakh kr bhe in jasy brain washers k hathyc charh jaty hain pakistani.

[@abbasiwrites1915]

@@cppak45 aap kahan sy hain bhai

[@Prakhar9455305897]

@@cppak45 you are the one that is brainwashed Pak jihadi mentality, Islam ke naam par muslim ne India me dhoom macha rakhi hai, aur tum apna propaganda spread karne me lage ho, People wake up and recognize the Islamic extremist propaganda that wants to convert the whole world to Islam

[@globexhelp9911]

first time i have seen aftab iqbal in a humble posture, otherwise he always speak arrogantly in his tv programs. sir keep this humble style. you are doing well

[@KhairatMuhammad]

well, thats because he is sitting before a person who knows more than him

[@saurabhkhanduri1733]

You have earned a fan across the border, Ishtiaq Ahmed sahab. Much love and respect to your ideas and thoughts on unity and peace. Namaste🙂🙏

[@abigt282]

Very very nice conversation...👍

[@TahirMButt]

Best program you have ever hosted!

[@notoinjustice1]

Amazing insight based on true historical facts. Pleasantly surprised that this interview of Professor Ishtiaq ran on a Pakistani channel.

[@waseefahmadg]

excellent Ishtiaq Ahmed I'm impressed,I'm gonna buy both of your books soon,thank you Aftab Iqbal for introducing such a genuine scholar.

[@asangha182]

Waseef sahib, please watch his 6 part show on the Partition with Arvind Saharan...

[@BharatKumar-ti3jt]

Bhai iski kitab Indian punjab me mil jaayegi

[@theRockerz217]

Sir ne aaj dil jeet liya, Sir aapke jaise log hi Pakistan me hone chahiye aur aap hi sacche Pakistani ho🙏🙏🙏

[@Hshshdhbdksmsbdhdh]

Nice .. honest person he is .

[@samiksharathore1123]

I thoroughly enjoyed this interview..gained so much knowledge and appreciate ur effort on writing and collecting facts .. love from India 🇮🇳 😍💓🥰

[@MrDillikisardi]

Impossible to have a conversation like this in India with Arnab and Chaurasia .

[@binnykataria1190]

Really honest and appreciable 🙏🏻

[@fazalwahid5113]

Suchi Suchi batain.... Highly appreciated. Thank you :)

[@muhammadaslamjavaidmalik3708]

Khoobsurat baten! Aftab is true scholar!

[@malikzadaali2868]

Bohat khoob sir🥰 bohat acha show start Kaya ha apne ya ☺️ history Mai interest rakhne walo ka laye ya 1 namat sabit hoge🙂

[@AliShah-sx6fs]

Amazing eye opening discussion

[@cppak45]

27 Ramzan. 14 1947 (Angrazon nay bnay abi bhe ye he smjtay Hain ? .) Fifth generation war hay ye Pakistanio kalma k name pr Allah nay bnaya Agr Pakistan Russia k kilaf larny k lay bna tha to 1965 main angrez bhol gay thy is bat ko ?jab Pakistan pr India Ka gabza hony lga tha Jo Allah ki madad say nakam ho Gaya.Its fifth generation war khud study Karo Islamic point of view say to aap ki samaj main aai gi bat na Europein citizen ship holder Dr Istiaq k point of view.

[@pictureworld131]

@@cppak45 han

[@sarajkumarpaul2730]

Professor Dr. Ishtiaq Ahmed, a very logical person. I am listening him first time and I become fan of him... 👌👌❤

[@virendraprakashsingh3874]

FOR THE FIRST TIME I HAVE HEARD A SANE VOICE FROM PAKISTAN. GOD MAY MAKE YOUR DREAM COME TRUE

[@razibhatti116]

Sir aik krwa such or b h k hum dono ko apni apni ghltiyan except krni prengi agr hum kuch acha chahty hain dono ka ( dono ko ye krna prega )

[@mumtazzafar1576]

Aap chutya media dekhtay rehto ho es liay

[@joychackalacal360]

Can't believe my ears hearing the hard truth, because, so often used to hearing distorted history from other side of the boarder. Even the interviewer himself tried to distort facts but Ishtaq sahib held on his opinion. One more opportunity for the world to know the true history!

[@ranwalali7488]

Finally some truth from Aftab Iqbal thanks Dr. Ishtiaq

[@prateekkeer8487]

Lots of Love & Respect for you DR. ISHTIAAQ AHMED Sir. Love from Delhi❣️

[@islamresearch786]

Love you SIR AFTAB IQBAL May you live long with great HEALTH & WEALTH AMEEN.

[@MackGolds]

Great discussion, excellent program. Aftab sahib please do more programs like this. These kind of intellectual programs suit better to your personality. Long live Pakistan 🇵🇰

[@sunilbaluni5333]

Woh toh nahi rehega hum apni zameen wapas leke rehenge ek na ek din

[@batth0021]

Outstanding

[@AmitMishra-lx7er]

Very intellectual & scholar 👍💐💐🇮🇳

[@saptarshimukherjee19]

For the first time in any Pakistani series history is same as what I learnt in school.

[@chaudhrybe]

آفتاب صا حب ایک لمبے عرصے کے بعد گریٹ initiative . Great discussion .بابا جی کی تحقیق اچھی ھے لیکن conclusion confused ھے ،آفتاب صاحب Cleared him very well.

[@anwarmalik9045]

Yehi main bhi keh raha hoon conclusion par aa ka maingnyan daal jo hamari masaael ko jad unn ko safe kar diya aur jo ishtiaq sahib khush haali ka mansooba bata rahey jo Nawaz shareef ley kar chal raha aftab Iqbal Nawaz dushmani ki nazar ho gaya. Aftab sahib aqal kar lo yar

[@RanjeetSingh-ux1qn]

AFTAB VEER ZEE.SAT SHRI AKAL.I NEVER SAW A WELL WISHER OF PAK.YOU ARE DOING A COMPLETE JOB.PER KOI SUNE GA?IWILL TALK TO FURTHER.

[@khanbelgium7602]

Aftab Iqbal first time I see you got courage to say true whay we are fighting it's very different Idea you bring it

[@MeriYatra_24]

If this kind of talks continue it boost relationship in good way only

[@salmanramzan2032]

Absolutely brother, West always used us for their personal interests and they wanted us to continue fight in the name of religion. Neither USA, China, Russia, England no one is our friend. It is game of interests and we fools believe that these countries are our brother Nation etc. We should work together to bring prosperity in South Asia. 🇵🇰❤🇮🇳

[@MeriYatra_24]

@@salmanramzan2032 exactly bro if Pakistan government start taking steps that benefits india and not against so why would india go against you fr same simple, Pakistan ask medicine from india hence india delivered in good way bt in return what we got

[@faisalshahzad8313]

But it should be from both sides 😉

[@Mysterious387]

بہت ہی عمدہ معلومات❤

[@hassaanjavaid6186]

Excellent discussion and eye opener...

[@cppak45]

Ankain kukl gai Bhai Humsaya Chata hay aap us k paon pr jao aur bjran k Nara lgao cow to bilkul ziba ni krni aur meat kha say lay ho mrny k lye thyar ho jao Islam k nam mat lo bandy matram paro ye tumhara islami name bta rha hay tum bhe atan wadi ho gay sub krny k bad tum he desh drohi ho.mulmano ki halt dakh kr bhe in jasy brain washers k hathyc charh jaty hain pakistani.

[@abdussattar4574]

Excellent program, thx Aftab sahib.

[@rizwanulhuda4535]

I am glad and a little bit amazed to see this type of discussion in your program. I have never heard or seen any person from Pakistan discussing history of Pakistan in its original and true form. I believe and probably it's true that history should not be altered according to one's liking or disliking. It should be presented and preserved in it's original form. I am a Pakistani Canadian Citizen and feel bad seeing Pakistan's history being distorted and disoriented. Thank you Mr. Aftab Iqbal for speaking the truth.

[@djrulz123]

Excellent discussion...can’t believe such a wonderful chat in Pakistan between 2 such clear minds...fantastic

[@aghauri32]

Love this show, Kindly for the future videos add the guest’s names on the titles as well

[@1957raza]

Very very fantastic programme.DR.sahib has true and wonderful views.we need such legends in Pakistan

[@sultan2389]

Razabhai, sach mujhe nahi pata tha ki aise log bhi pak me hain

[@pictureworld131]

@@sultan2389 kasam say

[@sikanderdhillon8356]

Healthy talk ,keep doing this sir for better understanding

[@MUH_o300]

Dr ishtiaq sb. Allah give u good health.

[@RiteshShrivastavaBhopal]

Wow . Kudos to Dr.Ishtiaq Ahmed and interviewer Aftab Iqbal ..This discussion gives me hope

[@abhishekagrahari1352]

Very true! On line with our history syllabus.

[@shersingh-ov9pf]

very academic , respect this learned person ; a peace monger , will surly reed his book . I am glad he brought up the initial matrix of tragic bloodshed in Punjab ; the Sikhs genocide which resulted this havoc .

[@naveennj5270]

Dr ishtiaq Ahmed app muje ache lage Madarsa band Hona chahiye Love you from India

[@naveennj5270]

@PISCES PISCES me khud BJP se Hun Jai Shree ram

[@ajitdurge7254]

​@@naveennj5270bjp chutiya party 😂😂 kuch bhi yogdaan nahi chaddi gang ki azadi me

[@BKMisr]

Prof. Istiaq Ahmad's books are widely read in India with authenticity. A great political scientist.

[@ahsangul7973]

The truth with clarity was told in this dialogue. We need to concentrate on our issues and resolutions to make Pakistan a progressive and prosperous state. We all must rise above personal, religious and cast hatred and prejudices. What a learned man? Sincerely

[@punjabitourvlogs]

انگریز ہندوستان تو چھوڑ گئے پر اپنے انگریزی بولنے والے بچے چھوڑ گئے... مجال ہے کہ آج کا پاکستانی یا ہندوستانی اپنی قومی زبان میں بات یا بحث کر سکے.

[@garygeorge-wi7co]

My mohajir friend tells me only Bengali and Punjabi Muslims benefited from the division of India, other Muslims did lose a lot, their language, identity and their culture.

[@dr.ksartplace3785]

gary george It is a perfect test case. Take Urdu speakers from UP and Bihar. Those who migrated are the rulers of Pakistan Their cousins in India are nowhere close. Count number of doctors, engineers, and government officers. Compare their wealth You will clearly see the difference.

[@dr.ksartplace3785]

@Vijay Agrawal Pre-partition a close friend of grandpa was an Agarwal businessman in Lahore. He was as Punjabi as anyone else. Whenever grandpa visited Lahore, they used to get together fir a meal. They kept in touch even after Agrawal family migrated to Delhi and our family to Lahore How about your family. I gather they are not Punjabi????

[@shankarparikh938]

the moral of the story is that you cant make a country based on one belief. it has proved time and time again not to work. That is why the indian civilization has survived unbroken for 10 thousand plus years despite all that has been thrown at it.

[@dr.ksartplace3785]

Shankar Parikh Sad that so many Indians and Pakistanis comment here based on zero amount of study. All of these comments are based on what you hear from media, parents, or worse history books from grade 5 schools. Pakistan is typically 15-20 years lagging India in technology. The same time it is ahead 15-20 years politically. Indians are electing and supporting a religiously intolerant government these days. Pakistan did it 20 years ago. Resulting from such intolerance, Indians will see a complete breakdown of political institutions 20 years from now. So you see subcontinent of India was the land ruled by foreigners, and if Modi experiment is successful, it will again be ruled by foreign kings. You will learn if you read unbiased history. Peace.

[@garygeorge-wi7co]

@@dr.ksartplace3785 The same time it is ahead 15-20 years politically. ... Joke of the century. There is no politics in Pakistan. Just military rule.

[@abdulwaheed384]

Reality check. We need more with same mindset.

[@bhuvanc4992]

Respect for Dr Ishtiaq from India

[@krishanpalsinghmalik9812]

Very intelligent and honest person

[@ismailkhan3261]

Best analysis on PAKISTAN creation.

[@tm3793]

Don't forget the meanness of Hindu leaders of All Indian Congress that actually helped partition of India. Otherwise, Mr. Jinnah never asked for partition when he was member of Congress. Present situation of religious minorities in India substantially proves that Mr. Jinnah was absolutely right in demanding Pakistan. Read the history. This video is telling only one-sided story.

[@atirjan8320]

سر آفتاب اقبال صاحب! آپ نے بہت عمدہ پروگرام شروع کیا ہے آپ کو بہت بہت مبارک ہو! اللہ آپ کو بہترین کامیابی عطا فرمائے آمین

[@pervezhussain1347]

This is great discussion.

[@baig838]

100% agreed with you.. very true said

[@farrukhiqbal1767]

Dr Ishtiaq Sb gave the motive to success for Pakistan with truth which is not sweet but truth and we should accept it as Pakistani

[@abrmuni569]

Part 3 of 3: One more thing, no one mentions that Jinnah did not want a partition but a power sharing agreement with the Brahmans on the ground of provincial semi autonomy, which is very close to the current form of Pakistani (and to some extent Indian) constitution. But the Brahmans did not want to share any part of Akhand Bharat with a minority. This position of Jinnah was true until June of 1946, when he ordered a Direct Action (by the people, instead of negotiation by the leadership; just 14 months before the partition).

[@chaudryabdullahkhalidladaa7032]

Jani don't know you, but your understanding of history is amazing. Sending love & Respect.

[@singhparihar8530]

Abr muni aap ki jankari k liye bata rha hu k pakistan se jada Muslim India me rhte hai okk jinha was British agent

[@sultan2389]

Bhains ke saamne been baja dali

[@powerpia2000]

Just ordered The book mentioned. Right while watching the video.

[@chander10980]

great "LOVE FROM INDIA"

[@navishkotwal]

Great talk. Love from India.

[@vijeeshvijayan7426]

India pakistan reunification must done as soon as possible...

[@ks9072]

No need

[@thethpunjabi6246]

This man z spot on with his views.....talking with facts n z nt even biased or supporting pak unnecessarily, though aftab at some points z trying hard to put words into his mouth bt he kept sticking to his point n explains it with valid reasons.....Bravo!!!

[@muhammadshahrukhkhan9776]

Hahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha...

[@zeeshanahmad-qp2wu]

ڈاکٹر اشتیاق صاحب نظریہ پاکستان سے مختلف راۓ رکھتے ہیں۔ اور تقسیم ہند کو کلی طور پر انگریزوں کا اقدام قراردیتے ہیں جو کہ درست بات نہیں ہے۔ اس میں اور بھی بہت سے عوامل کارفرما تھے۔

[@thatsawkward101]

Please explain your point of view Sir

[@zeeshanahmad-qp2wu]

@@thatsawkward101 ڈاکٹر صاحب نے قاٸداعظم مسلم لیگ اور مسلمانان ہند کے کردار کو یکسر نظر انداز کر کے تاریخ سے خاصی نا انصافی کی ہے۔اور دہشت گردی پر ریاست پاکستان کومورد الزام ٹھہرانا انڈین بیانیہ ہے۔

[@zafarbashir8489]

zeeshan ahmad Pakistan mein Hanfi nazria kion popular khai because majority Saudi Arabia mein salfi Iran mein jafria yeh sub majority ki wajah say khai 2 qaoomi kuchh nahei humm sub aik dosray say jouray howay khain yeh karoroon musalman bahar say nahei aaya siraf halal aur haram ka faraq khai allah taala nay zamin ko apni masjid kaha khai es ko taqseem hum nay kia khai baqi haq talfi aur zulm tu musalman Musalman per b kar raha khai

[@saleemullah8737]

@@zafarbashir8489 ; your writing is not being understood. Please, explain it in simple English.

[@aarifboy]

En sab ke kaley kartoot dekhne hain tau yahan dekh lo kzbin.info/www/bejne/oYbCn2N7jrWpm5I

[@dr.ghulamfareed6460]

A Good discussion.

[@rajeevsangar9567]

Pakistan is a failed State . Which was created by Britishers to weaken the United India as in future India could become the superpower which British know. That is the whole reason they hired Jinnah to divide the country.

[@umakantkulkarni8810]

Good discussion,with Truth

[@sanjeetnandal4061]

What a meaningful discussion.... Really good..

[@myunus9892]

THE INDIA WAS DIVIDED BY THE BRITISH FOR THEIR OWN INTEREST.-----MR. JINNAH WAS GIVEN A ROLE TO PLAY .

[@eye.in.thesky]

Absolutely correct. I gave some details about the British interest in creating Pakistan.

[@bharatt.v.5060]

For undivided India,he was bargaining with Nehra, Gandhiji to become PM of whole India to give services to Britishers.. which was not acceptable.. his desire to become PM was only fulfilled when India was divided, also he could have stopped Partitions riots..if Liaquat Uncle did not commit genocide in Mach.. finally killed by Maratha Army while Attack on Hindu train

[@eye.in.thesky]

@@bharatt.v.5060 You gotta be a gao goo eater to produce such a big bull crap.

[@bharatt.v.5060]

@@eye.in.thesky Write synonyms of Bhikaree... Which country owns the trademark.. ""KASHKOL'"