Watch full episode: kzbin.info/www/bejne/fJ_UoaR5bNKCp5o Study Islam online: www.arkview.org
@BumpedMyHeadAtTheMasjid3 ай бұрын
As someone who used to be Christian this just shows how we ( people who used to be Christian) were forced interpretations and they at face value may be that. I never looked at the verse in Genesis and thought who is "his" here and even considered it was Adam. This was very enlightening.
@abdelhakyac72853 ай бұрын
I think the paradigm is different, when scholars wanna be constantly avoiding any weaknesses to the creator, they will make effort to read the text in all ways possible, and find out that one of the ways is that its about giving the first human his due image ...... but when you aready accept that as a deity someone that can be lifted by earth, limited by a volume of flesh, having need to eat and drink and so on..... you wont care anymore
@sadofaraji59993 ай бұрын
Abu Huraira was mistaken, and people don't want to destroy their hadith business.
@abdelhakyac72853 ай бұрын
@@sadofaraji5999 shut up and go to sleep.... thats the kind of opinion i had at 14 years old, when i had no clue on hadith sciences and when i thought neosalafis were islam and so on..... either learn or just make way
@sadofaraji59993 ай бұрын
@@abdelhakyac7285 Abu huraira has learned previous scripture from a converted jew, and scholars has spoken about it, he and Abdallah ibn Amr ibn Al As,. has nothing to do with hadith science.
@sadofaraji59993 ай бұрын
@@abdelhakyac7285 That is verse from bible and you fall for it. anyway it's your choice and your problem.
@KillTherapy3 ай бұрын
Beautiful Mash'Allah, may Allah the King of all Kings bless & Preserve Dr. Shadee (Ameen)
@CommentsProbablyDeleted3 ай бұрын
Not a single Muslim believes we look like Allah.
@Uzair_Of_Babylon4653 ай бұрын
Great video keep it up you're doing amazing things 😁👍
@FatimaKhatun-d9g3 ай бұрын
MashAllah ❤
@saadibneharun9327Ай бұрын
MashaAllah
@majd48683 ай бұрын
Brother, it is a mistake to say that matters of the Iman in Allah and the Attributes of Allah (Literaly "Who is Allah and how do we know him) are matters of Ijtihad and opinion, we must follow the salaf in this matter throughly!
@abdelhakyac72853 ай бұрын
Maan, go to sleep please.... i lived 34 years..... i lived all my teenage years following like a sheep the neo salafis and this kind of completely deceptive rethoric...... man, read quran...... read quran, believe me you wont even need to go to hadith or the scholars to shatter all biggest fallacies of the shia, the muutazila, and the neo salafis alike..... read if constantly, and ponder upon it..... if everyone did that everyday, there will be no deception in any of the main matters, then you can find the detailed matters in hadith explained and processed via the madhahib (neo salafism is a non madhab)
@baselhakim20803 ай бұрын
And which righteous Salaf disagreed with him?? You want to just whine for no reason?
@majd48683 ай бұрын
@baselhakim2080 Pretty much All noteworthy scholars of the 1st Generation Of Islam after the sahaba (and the sahaba thselves) disagreed with him, and believed about Allah that he has an image that exists, that's why he CAN and WILL be seen in the Akhira, like the massager of Allah ﷺ himself said, and since something that doesn't have an image cannot be seen, therefore Allah has an image, as Allah سبحانه proved about himself in his book and his massager ﷺ proved in the sunnah. Only, it's that his image سبحانه is unlike the image of anything else in creation as Allah said: {ليس كمثله شيء وهو السميع البصير}(الشورى:11). I. E. He has an image, unlike any other image of creation, and we don't know the HOW nor the specific details of his image سبحانه except the attributes he proved to himself.
@baselhakim20803 ай бұрын
@@majd4868 So basically you're a Christian and not a Muslim, since that is your "Salaf" that you refer to. Not a single one from *Muslim* Salaf believed Allah has an Image. You don't belong here, go back to your church
@MohammadAshirIbnSaeed3 ай бұрын
@@majd4868 give your sources ya akhi. Direct sources from the righteous salaf or the Qur'an with citation
@shan013 ай бұрын
People forget the context of the hadith that is "slap" If mujsama say no it clearly say (He) refers to Allah ( Astagfirullah) Then what that mean it ist that its attribute ( face) of God And that attribute was one way or other harmed ( astagfirullah). Secondly if we look closely then its clear that What was referenced is relations between the one who slaped and who was slapped. Both were sons of Adam ( as) ( metaphorically ). Amd were created in his image.
@KASHMIRI_TERRORIST24 күн бұрын
Salafis are weird
@Iamfsaly3 ай бұрын
Christians believe the Father is a spirit and Jews believe Yhwh is literally a physical God, and I think we Muslims should not Affirm or negate it , We should contemplation and think about the signs of Allah creation and and the 99 names of Allah, not think about the self of Allah because this is something cannot be reached
@leom63433 ай бұрын
But God in the bible was seen etc
@gems81673 ай бұрын
@@leom6343 seen by who? Not even Musa could see God.
@leom63433 ай бұрын
@@gems8167 it literally says Moses spoke with God face to face. Jacob fought with God and won. There are so many verses
@gems81673 ай бұрын
@@leom6343 read exodus 33 20 your book is full of contradictions But interesting so you believe god lost to a man?
@Derqaysar3 ай бұрын
Just think about that statement you said about Jacob…does it make any sense whatsoever that God could lose to a human in a fight…
@smailayad91443 ай бұрын
What do you think about who said :خلق الله آدم على صورته (الله) في القدر المشترك ليوحده في القدر الفارق.
@_zaaphiel3 ай бұрын
Subhanallah
@JoFitClub3 ай бұрын
So "his" image not "His" image.
@amir3243 ай бұрын
What legitimate scholars believed that Allah has an image ?
@majd48683 ай бұрын
Pretty much All noteworthy scholars of the 1st Generation Of Islam after the sahaba (and the sahaba thselves) believed about Allah that he has an image that exists, that's why he CAN and WILL be seen in the Akhira, like the massager of Allah ﷺ himself said, and since something that doesn't have an image cannot be seen, therefore Allah has an image, as Allah سبحانه proved about himself in his book and his massager ﷺ proved in the sunnah. Only, it's that his image سبحانه is unlike the image of anything else in creation as Allah said: {ليس كمثله شيء وهو السميع البصير}(الشورى:11). I. E. He has an image, unlike any other image of creation, and we don't know the HOW nor the specific details of his image سبحانه except the attributes he proved to himself.
@abdelhakyac72853 ай бұрын
@@majd4868 false, no single one the sahaba dared to think of this, the companions would hid their hands when hearing ’the hand of Allah” because in the guts they didnt wanna think a milisecond about that blasphemous idea, they just swept over the text and left it as it is...... imam Malik sid those questions shouldnt be asked its bidaa, thats the way of thecsalaf.... and not that way of neosalafis of attributing body parts to the creator this is flirting with blasphemy...... you are so quick to think of fallaciois logical implication like ” if he can be seen that he has an image”..... because you regurgitate blindly what your gurus say, but you cant understand the basic logical implications of being limited by a body, or being dependant to body parts, or being made of bodypart then created by someone else ....etc ..... think...... think...... and by the way even in the case whencfew sahaba said the prophet peace upon him saw his lord in israa, Ayesha debunked them with verses ”He emcompasses sights, but no sight can encompass him.....”
@baselhakim20803 ай бұрын
@@majd4868 Complete liar you are. Name just one person who said that. Not a single one used this Hadith to prove Allah has an image , especially since that would mean you ARE comparing Him to the image of Adam , so it's st.upid of you to say in the same breath you don't do comparison. May Allah curse anyone who attributes to Allah any attribute of creation
@baselhakim20803 ай бұрын
@@majd4868 False. When are you going to stop being a liar? And how do you not see the contradiction of using this Hadith to prove Allah has an image (astaghfirullah) since the Hadith would mean His image IS like that of Adam, and then you say you don't compare Him with His creation? Ya Hmar,
@amir3243 ай бұрын
@@majd4868 name one with a reference
@some19473 ай бұрын
❤
@huseinhuseinov4274Ай бұрын
Why all you sunni scholars explain this hadith different 😂😂
@henryleonardo3544Ай бұрын
وليس كل خلاف جاء معتبرا بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم والصلاة والسلام على رسول الله أما بعد فإني أقول لك نصيحة لله تعالى لا أراك إلا تريد الخير للناس كلامك هذا مرفوض فإنك تقول إن هناك قولا آخر معبرا بأن الله خلق آدم على صورته يعني صورة تشبه صورته وهذا باطل من وجوه أذكر منها هذا فإن الله لا صورة له إذ الصورة لها كيفيات والكيفية عن الله وصفاته منفية. ومن جهة أخرى كيف يستقيم هذا الكلام وقد عُلم أن المجسمة كفار على تشبيههم اللهَ بخلقه ومن قال بهذا القول مآله مآل المجسمة في التشبيه وهذا القول يصير إلى المحال وكل ما صار إلى المحال محال وهو يعارض الأصل الثابت في الدين وهو أن الله لا يشبه شيئا ولا يشبهه شيء لا أريد أن أبسط الكلام في هذا هنا وأظن أن ما ذكرته كاف ولا تنس ما قاله العلماء وليس كل خلاف جاء معتبرا إلا خلافا له حظ من النظر وهذا الخلاف لا حظ له من النظر كاتب هذه الرسالة هرون بن ڤلدمير الطويل
@samven5823 ай бұрын
Adam evolved on earth. With Allah swt divide intervention he was given cognition
@s_u_r_v_i_v_o_r3 ай бұрын
This is why the muslim nation is put in a state of humility by God below the people of the book. Because they have denied God's own Image and misinterpreted their own islamic texts which align with biblical passages regarding humanity's creation in God's physical Image.
@Aquacrystal783 ай бұрын
How were they in the State of Humility in the Islamic Golden Age during medieval Europe???
@eonzy3 ай бұрын
I have to disagree with you on this. The Hadith is very clear, he created Adam in Allahs image ie Allah has legs, eyes, face, hand, body but they are not like his creation and we don’t know how
@ulkucu34923 ай бұрын
This is crazy, you think Allah needs hands?
@_zaaphiel3 ай бұрын
Mujassim
@hungrythinker3 ай бұрын
Brother you're clearly joking right? 🗿
@AliA-im7xx3 ай бұрын
Allahhhhh. how may you apply form to the formless, Nauzubillah. Imo the hadith can be interpreted in the mystical way that we can reflect His light and were created in his image. like idk how to explain but let the heart understand
@hikkato883 ай бұрын
Mujassimah.. ليس كمثله شيء
@dom30733 ай бұрын
Allah has Two Hands, Two Eyes, Shin, Feet and Face. It has been proven with many strong evidences upon Sunnah and Salaf. Alhamdullilah. Negation of this is doing ta'teel of Allah's attributes thereby making one a partial Jahmi.
@dom30733 ай бұрын
@Shofixti6163 Nothing wrong with listing them, in fact there's more sifaat. For instance Allah has Fingers, Allah laughs, etc. All from Sahih narrations from six canonical books. Nothing wrong with listing them. If it paints a picture in the head, then just remember the verse "There is no similitude to Allah".