Did Israel and the US win in Syria? Professors Mohammad Marandi & Radhika Desai discuss

[@Naturee06]

"The US doesn't care who it is supporting, it cares who it's destroying". This, this right here.

[@Usapropaganda-t7h]

That’s a helluva statement. I hate how true it is.

[@pelaubenson1230]

@Naturee06.."America has no permanent friends or enemies, only interests"..Henry Kissinger.

[@pipster1891]

@@pelaubenson1230 Germany now is experiencing what it means to think of America as a friend.

[@johnsmith100]

Why is the interviewee here continuously uses the term "Israeli regime"', instead of just "Israel" or "Israeli government"?

[@HellBot-gi5si]

There major protest breaking out in Iran now because it is freezing and their are rolling black outs. It so great for American CIA, our spies are having field day in Iran. You have nice day. 🤣

[@Oasispalmier2]

"The United States of America is a country that has passed directly from barbarism to decadence, without ever having known civilization." ~Oscar Wilde

[@handleisGG]

their barbarism is abroad so they hide it... but it'll forever be a European COLONY in turtle Island, and if Spain can throw out the turks and everyone after 800 YEARS? natives GLOBALLY should have sovereignty and self determination on their entire lands

[@HellBot-gi5si]

Yea, think he was drunk when made that quote. LOL 🤣

[@hardcoregym7316]

100%

[@Tuliperose2]

"When two neighboring countries fight each other, just know the USA visited one." - Nelson Mandela

[@HellBot-gi5si]

@@Tuliperose2 That because most countries lack resource to "industrialize". To have basic "Industrialize Lifestyle" you need the following resources. Oil, natural gas and coal, to create energy such as electricity. You need coal and iron mines to make steel. Good farmland with fresh water rivers and or rain. You need "Pot Ash" mines to create industrial fertilizers. Most countries do not have any of these resources which means you going to war with your neighbors if they have what you need this what we saw both World War I and World War II.

[@doonn8]

"Consider this: HTS has been propped up by millions of dollars in foreign funding. Without this financial lifeline, the group would collapse, exposing the true source of its power-foreign agendas. This is not about Syria's freedom; it is about control."~ Kevork Almassian

[@willengel2458]

Strangely enough Qatar had/has been funding the mercenary from day one. Qatar wants a gas pipeline through Syria. Assad said, "No."

[@johndunne7900]

@@doonn8 , who is the biggest bug on the manure pile? , a playground for terrorist and failed dictatorships.

[@batteries76]

Syria has been propped up by foreign funding, and drug trade.

[@dwwd-i4r]

Either the United States or Israel or the West as a whole will have to provide the HTS and other terrorist groups with the state-run funding to stay in Syria, which adds more burdens after Afghanistan's retreat.

[@mon_66]

What's the source? What I know is that there were only humanitarian aids as there were around 1.5 millions living around idlib who escaped from the Assad regimen brutality. There were incidences where some people tried to go back and they were arrested. Also Al joulani since the beginning during nusra front he said he doesn't accept any aid from any country because it's always conditional. And they have enough weapons from what they took from Assad what and from his ties with Al qaeda. After governing idlib they started to make weapons especially for drones and few other things. I feel like most western people who are talking about syria doesn't know literally anything. They just say any bs based on some out of context articles.

[@domsilva5016]

Professor Marandi is a really good voice to hear. Great choice!!! Thanks!

[@guitpizz]

Always a pleasure to hear Mr. Marandi.

[@libertad9]

The American empire is collapsing and flailing about in desperation and will try to take as many countries down with them.

[@bayyinahzhaxx7620]

It's the resources U.S. is stealing to prolong its relevance. Other nations will have to stop working with them and allowing them resources in order to continue building and making weapons. Chinese just banned sending key resources to U.S. because of Trumps talk of tariffs. U.S. won't be able to create semiconductors to use or sell.

[@HellBot-gi5si]

Right now there protest breaking out in Iran. The weather is freezing and there are rolling blackouts all over the country. This great time for the American CIA or spies getting so much inside information. 👍😊 This what happens when have a bunch of Cleric that don't know anything about economics and industrial policy run a modern industrial country.

[@Cielturquoiiise]

Absolutely true!

[@jb2736]

Europe 🤫🤐🤔

[@Ace-v2x]

Only delusional people that are not rational, really thinks America’s so call empire is gonna collapse and fail. That’s only dreams you could imagine but not anytime soon or there won’t be a earth anymore which a lot of people wanna live. Russia is a puppet of China. Syria is long gone and see where this leads to the same word, the world spends is the same cycle of rotations of war.🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉

[@monazaelahi919]

Dr. Mirandi has explained the entire situation so aptly wth utmost calm & compusure. Loads of Respect.

[@colourinmyrainbow]

Always...

[@Freedomn9]

"Pride goes before a fall. Humility, glory. Long live to resistance freed from colonialism and Western imperialism."

[@josephc8440]

Brother are you aware of the alternatives?😂

[@Tuliperose2]

yes and long live the multipolar world . a world freed from all forms of hegemony, of a world freed from the dictatorship of the dollar and the blackmail of economic sanctions, a world of nations equal in rights, where sovereignty is the guarantee of reciprocal respect as well as the freedom of citizens

[@johndunne7900]

The very term Palestine or Palestinians comes from a Roman word used to describe Judea in 135CE after the defeat of the Jews. It is a term referring to a Greek people’s that settled in the Gaza area thousands of years ago. It has no relationship to the Arabs, who were not in that area until after 635CE the concept of imperialism is applied to the Arabs, who came into that area and conquered Judea, the land of the Jews,. The real imperialist are the Arabs, the real indigenous people to that area are the Jews.

[@johndunne7900]

The very term Palestine or Palestinians comes from a Roman word used to describe Judea in 135CE after the defeat of the Jews. It is a term referring to a Greek people’s that settled in the Gaza area thousands of years ago. It has no relationship to the Arabs, who were not in that area until after 635CE the concept of imperialism is applied to the Arabs, who came into that area and conquered Judea, the land of the Jews,. The real imperialist are the Arabs, the real indigenous people to that area are the Jews.

[@josephc8440]

@ history is written by the victors the rest is cope

[@shahjamalakhlaque2883]

Very comprehensive and practical analysis. Thank you.

[@siamajidi2761]

Thank you Radhika Desai for having professor MarandI. Imperialists ,colonialists have no room in our multipolar world.

[@densmoreken]

Marandi very great insight. Thank you

[@user-X-SAM]

PROFESSOR MARANDI IS THE BEST

[@ohdear2023]

Of commedians, yes, I agree 👍

[@PSmith-f1u]

So great to be able to hear Dr Marandi speak without being spoken on top of, interrupted and treated with disrespect like that racist bigotry and Zio mouthpiece Piers Morgan. Dr Marandi tells it as it it and speaks with wisdom..

[@johnkesich8696]

Only about 30% of those eligible to vote, voted for Trump, his popular support is greatly exaggerated especially by the media. Mirandi is terribly naive if he thinks Trump isn’t part of the deep state, or that it makes a dime’s worth of difference to US policy which sock puppet sits in the White House. Trump is at least as big a Zionist as Biden. Finally, hasn’t Mirandi been paying attention to Trump’s insane cabinet nominations?

[@Peter-m5n7m]

Wonderful insightful information. Thank You!

[@acethelin6803]

two of the very best analysts! Thank you!

[@karenmccartney9514]

Excellent explanation and analysis. Thank you so much Professor Marandi.

[@MrElOuargui83]

Thanks for a great analysis ✌️🇵🇸

[@yahyaghafari4645]

Dear lady you have great program i enjoy professor marandi comments good luck.

[@user-iu2di2pm4k]

Thanks for reporting on whats going on ❤ from Hawaii

[@BestFitSquareChannel]

Dr. Desai! 🤸🏽‍♂️ Professor Marandi! 🌞

[@kanusesay1627]

This is a big win for Iran, not in a short term, but in the long run. gradually Iran will be the Victor in Syria mark my word

[@HellBot-gi5si]

Iran is collapsing. You have protest breaking out all over Iran because it is winter and it is freezing and your government has rolling black outs. Our American CIA is having a field day in Iran. It like a "spies paradise" in Iran so many officials are talking. You need a change of government.

[@galin95]

Your word stinks

[@ohdear2023]

You live in la la land with Marandi?

[@User-jr7vf]

Tell me this is a joke

[@umuravatvthesouthern4056]

A day dreamer you are!

[@mrblueyish]

Prof. Marandi is stellar as always, glad to see him on this channel!

[@ohdear2023]

Stellar high in another galaxy! Or his own la la land?

[@mrblueyish]

​@@ohdear2023 I can never tell what unemployed trolls hope to accomplish by their vague attempts at provocation.

[@mochawitch]

​@@ohdear2023explain why, otherwise keep quiet.

[@andrewkujan1457]

Amazing work, thank you.

[@willengel2458]

what happens five years from now? what happens to it's real when the empire of lies collapsed? the empire is in rapid decline. it's just a matter of how and when.

[@100c0c]

Two more weeks😂

[@smm5663]

Excellent discussion

[@KC-lc8dx]

Great!!!❤

[@Cherrytea558]

Marandi is absolutely correct. This is definitely not a win for Israel and the US in the long run.

[@mon_66]

Yes, most of those political analysts are just dumb. That's very clear to anyone who knows anything about al joulani, hts and syria.

[@StateOfPurgatory]

I agree with professor Marandi

[@taranehahmadi-parker1412]

Brilliant Dr Maranda

[@taranehahmadi-parker1412]

Dr Marandi

[@serpilozugurlu8812]

Professor is right, this is only the Erdoğan's victory, and I slso dont believe its a victory

[@Bahador_R]

Excellent content 👌

[@SCress-lv2be]

I second that from Oscar Wilde. So true, so true with no change in sight.

[@samina99]

Syria: *falls* U.S. and Israel: Yay, we won Iran, and Russia have been defeated Iran and Russia: have we, tho? *laughs in the background* I knew Iran was a lot smarter than what the West was making it out to be. Choosing to stay out of the Syrian fall was a brilliant move and good for saving up resources

[@kathleenhillock9366]

Wallstreet won in Syria.

[@HellBot-gi5si]

When the Ottoman Empire fell Syria is the part that Saudi Arabia and Turkiye abandon. That is why the small minorities of Alowates that lived on coast took over the country because know one wanted Syria. Syria has always been a failed state only the city of Damascus did ok for itself that it.

[@mon_66]

​@@HellBot-gi5si Have you seen idlib under hts?!

[@votewaldo9876]

Te fall of the ottomans was the worst thing to happen to the middle east

[@farsheedyas697]

Who ever claims to win, it must have a big pocket to rebuild Syria. Turkiye is a bankrupt country and has big debts. American & EU are also fighting in Ukraine. I bet, God should help Syria 🤣🤣

[@SueDalot-j1l]

Syria was left out of the news for years now, suddenly everyone has something to say

[@Peter-m5n7m]

Thankful for Rumble, MeWe and X.

[@ME2too2022]

Former USA Vice President and major September 11 planner Dick Cheney wanted an easement on SYRIA to run a pipeline to Turkey. President Assad stood up to him and said NO. Then SYRIA was occupied by terrorists and so much violence and destruction. And now this. 😢

[@christinecoughlan4699]

Thank you por bien informarnos .

[@joostroeters9087]

What will be the scenario? What happened in Afghanistan or in Lybia ? Inboth cases the position of women in the society becomes worse.

[@mariaacevedo2200]

Thank you for the high wuality content you offer ,!

[@esrefcelikcelik8789]

Our Problems are much worse and bigger with zionism and colonialism than with each other. I'm from turkey and shocked to see Syrians celebrating the gone of Assad while at the same time occupier alien entity of Israel stealing their lands..

[@philipkwieser3315]

Right On Prof . Rite On . . . U r a Breathe of Fresh Air, called " The Truth ! "

[@musanyirongo9820]

As always we get to learn and appreciate the events in west Asia n the globe from Prof Marandi. Huge thank you to the host.

[@ME2too2022]

My keyboard wouldn't type and only let me select a few recent emojis. So I shared your video with a❤ Happy holidays. I get sick of this CYBER Crime.

[@SCress-lv2be]

Erogan is only interested in getting his way about his obsession with the Kurds. He should leave the Kurds alone and have them have their land and to live in peace without Erogan constantly chasing them to non-existence as Bibi does in Gaza. The people of Turkiye also want to live in peace, so Erogan should think more of his own peoples.

[@Roland_Deschain]

But they occupied most resource rich 1/3 of Syria with US backing while being the %10 minority group

[@Zara-um1nx]

This is very true thank you so much

[@ZuleikaMuslims]

We.love our beautiful brave Heroic Palestinian TIGERS 🐅 ❤️ ALLAH WILL FREE YOU SOONER THAN YOU KNOW AAMEEN YA RABBAL ALAMEEN Thank you Prof Marandi love Iran ❤❤❤❤

[@maikflors4091]

{{I want you to consciously mock me in any way you think, but pretend to be the most virtuous system in the world..}} That's capitalism.

[@barrone9317]

Libya in the works

[@ME2too2022]

KZbin FLOODS ads every 2 minutes! This is such a a criminal dynamic on Internet!

[@Capricorn964]

It was nice to hear Prof Marandi to correctly use Türkiye instead of Turkey. The name Turkey was used by Anglo-Saxons to refer to the old Ottoman Empire.

[@CimuraiSampi]

turkiye is actually what the levant ppl called them in their accent, and turkish ppl they called "atrak" or "al-atrak". now tell me how you going named the people of "turkiye" in english ... is it going to be "turkiyen" ? instead of turkish? 😅

[@Capricorn964]

@ it's Türkiye and Turkish people.

[@EduardoArtistaDelavega]

Events in Syria are not about democracy or human rights, it's about US, UK, Turkish, Israeli interests and the Qatar-Turkey gas pipeline project.

[@mon_66]

It's about al joulani. Turkey the main backer of the opposition spent months trying to convince assad to normalize relationships with them as they lost hope in the military win. Hts and the allied factions were the ones who did most of the things.

[@visionary-linkwithyameenkh2005]

In the saying our Sindhi that if a wise cow slipped with both legged otherwise he will not slipped, same situation the US and Israel both are slipped on Syria matter.

[@fuckbankers]

Palestine will be free 🇵🇸

[@eliso5973]

Sadly, it's a yes. Syria will end up like Iraq.

[@ezraez2297]

Perfidy War crime involving breaking of a promise. In the context of war, perfidy is a form of deceptive tactic where one side pretends to act in good faith, such as signalling a truce (e.g., raising a white flag), but does so with the deliberate intention of breaking that promise. The goal is to trick the enemy into lowering their guard, such stepping out of cover to accept a supposed surrender, only to exploit their vulnerability. Perfidy constitutes a breach of the laws of war and so is a war crime, as it degrades the protections and mutual restraints developed in the interest of all parties, combatants and civilians. Geneva Conventions Perfidy is specifically prohibited under the 1977 Protocol I Additional to the Geneva Conventions of 12 August 1949.

[@cecatomas4817]

And whoever pays attention to Geneva convention these days? Americans?😂😂😂

[@leifurthorleifs9869]

After this masterpiece they will have to cool things down and reorganise.

[@CimuraiSampi]

tq

[@tosamja117]

Absolutely not ! This is actually the worst scenario for them!

[@sebastiangill1447]

I agree

[@bebezibodonghanjosephyoude8266]

More a question than comment. Is Radikai Desai a daughter of Moraji Desai - once a prime minister of India?

[@cretumarius9616]

Yes they did win

[@urrywest]

Where is Hudson?

[@simonlee8889]

Busy with other things... like appearing with Prof Richard Wolff on Nima's Dialogue Works

[@urrywest]

@@simonlee8889 Desai-Marandi seems like people comming from compleatly different frameworks....

[@MujahidIslam-u7x]

It's not Erdogan, it's Turkey. It's not a setback or tactical defeat to Iran and axis of resistance. You said yourself Sayyed that indeed Iran was aware and was distanced from Assad. And today Iran wants the wishes of Syrians to be prioritized, even if they disagree with some of this and know it's potential and real dangers. But it doesn't mean it's a defeat. Why is it a defeat? Iran did what it had to do, and its strength is not weakened with loss of Assad's Syria

[@johnbennett6665]

Every war involves genocide. Hanoi, Tokyo, Iraq, dresden, London ww2, a bombs, Cambodia etc etc ad nauseum!!

[@fassilgabremariam7849]

How about confrontation with the Kurds vis a vis Turkeye??

[@mon_66]

Both sides are getting ready for war.

[@noemiarias9669]

👍

[@amjadpanhwar3320]

Libya peaceful country for 100 years..then democracy came now libyan citizens being sold as salves....democracy really helped them...

[@homersimpson5501]

Imagine going to fight for a country and after the fighting the countries people tell you to “F…off”. I feel bad for the foreign fighters if the Syrian people throw them out

[@ohdear2023]

The sadness and madness in the eyes of Marandi... priceless 😅

[@Yahoo273]

Is that what you saw? I think you need new glasses because I just saw a man stating facts and totally composed.

[@zoltanbarath7371]

Every weakling would wish that.

[@zoltanbarath7371]

There are always those wishful thinkers.

[@classicmoviez3909]

Iran left voluntarily so NO israel and usa did not win. Just wait and see what happens the fight is far far from over.......

[@nextime3927]

Why Syria couldn't complain to the World's Court for the stolen oil?

[@zoltanbarath7371]

Probably bc the US used the Syrian Kurds as a cover.

[@serpilozugurlu8812]

thank you very much and Prof. Marandi is right, half of Turks are secular, so we dont want to be in dirty games, the other half is not educated president is deceiving the easily, again thanks muh

[@BrianPrint]

Iran Russia all ashamed for being poor in intelligence and power 😂😂

[@muhammadaquil2256]

Genociders never win but they loose !

[@nomkatung8746]

Prof, did you say Hamas and Hesbollah has won this war against Israel?

[@jubai12345]

This is The Plan and The WILL Of Our Heavenly Father.

[@Roland_Deschain]

Alawites have a lot of backlash from majority sunni population due to Baas party policies of decades.

[@rchltmedia]

yes? yes.

[@brenoobr]

What... Wait what... What was him saying about Trump being against the establishment

[@Global_just]

This guy things that Iran will win!

[@NeoliberalNightmare-eu5zs]

Obviously not, weak human animals

[@alimodiri6165]

Yes, they (USA/Israel) have definitely won.

[@fitofight8540]

Hes the comical ali of Iran

[@SueDalot-j1l]

I think Putin got rid of him

[@WilliamUmil]

Hope it will not be biased reporting and one sided

[@NoBorder-ue4ex]

The world love underdogs and rags to riches narratives.

[@johnsmith100]

Why is the interviewee here continuously uses the term "Israeli regime"', instead of just "Israel" or "Israeli government"?

[@rsync9490]

The west does the same to its enemies. 'Putin regime' and the 'Iranian regime'. Regime is a connotation that the entity is nefarious in some way, and Marandi is an Iranian pundit, so of course, he is going to refer to his enemies as a regime too.

[@johnsmith100]

@ Israel is not an enemy of the Iranian people.

[@rsync9490]

@johnsmith100 That country doesn't seem to have the best interests of any of its neighbors. The Russian and Iranian people are not the enemy of the people of the west.

[@IronWarrior86]

Because he confuses the Israeli government for the mullah gender apartheid regime of which he is a mouthpiece for.

[@mochawitch]

Because it is a regime

[@vovatocai]

I don't understand why you don't call the people in power behind Biden by their real names.

[@elevenfiftynine]

The host might consider going off camera as the guest is speaks. Tending to his or her phone should be a no-no

[@metamoralia]

Marandi's a very smart guy and a terrific propagandist but hardly objective. Where's that crushing Iranian response he's assued us was coming?

[@johndunne7900]

Perhaps Syria should not have been the conduit that Iran made it into to supply terrorist in Lebanon and also to build up forces near the Golan for a possible attack on Israel. The major blunder was not that Yahoo. It was the Arabs who thought they had a money deal with Iran, which quickly fell apart as their terrorist were eliminated by Israel to the point where they are defenseless against the state of Israel. It was a genius move by Netanyahu, who is on the cusp of defeating the entireArab world along with Iran. Pick your fights carefully, my friends, for you may end up in a place you don’t wanna be. When you start a war, you get war afterwards you can have intellectuals like the one on this broadcast rationalize stupidity.

[@ohdear2023]

100%.

[@jhingoorpatima237]

Stop occupations problems will solve!!!

[@johndunne7900]

@ you cannot occupy your own land. The mandate for Palestine, which included the Balfour declaration and the San Remo convention, as well as the treaty ofLuzerne under article 80 of the United Nations, which adapted the mandate for Palestine for the settlement of Jews throughout the mandated geographic area. Which means Judea and Samaria, as well as Gaza.. news, flash, the Arabs never had a state called Palestine.

[@jhingoorpatima237]

@@johndunne7900 Egypt is in Africa not Europe !!!

[@conniedean3787]

Bashar al-Assad gassed his own people

[@josephined8576]

MENTIROSO

[@AllanMunk-k7s]

Probably not, the report from chemical watchdog was manipulated, several whistleblowers have challenged the conclusions.

[@mochawitch]

The so-called "rebels" are head choppers

[@jps2363]

Iranian Gorbachev and his Zarif gang betrayed Syria and the resistance to beg for a new nuclear deal. I am truly sorry, but Israel won, and Palestine dream is dead.😢

[@StandinOnBuniss]

The Iranian adviced the resistance that it was not a smart move to go into offensive mode right now and the Palestinians did this act of desperation without consulting their allies. With these facts Iran did everything it could to support their allies at great cost of their own. The resistance should have focused on securing Syria instead. This loss is a tragedy

[@historydiscover]

I can tell you haven't been following the Palestine struggle for very long. It has always been endless dark days with little hope. Nothing changed.

[@evita9284]

I just attended the speech by the Lisan Al Gaib on this Syrian matter. It was beautiful, it was incredible. The Lisan Al Gaib was able to point out that someone in the audience had a dream of giving water to the dead and another whose grandmother passed 9 moons ago. He said that he foresaw there would be green paradise and everyone rose up to embrace him. I don't think Syria is lost- with the Lisan Al Gaib, I'm happy to follow in his footsteps.

[@StandinOnBuniss]

Sounds like a false prophet

[@pkia898]

Hahahahahahahaha

[@mahadhassan2894]

WHAT IS THE MAIN CAMPAIGN OF IRAN AND IT'S PROXIES?

[@ramstrong1961]

Judge Napolitano w/ Col Douglas Macgregor: America's next War of choice

[@EWOverland]

How many BS speked here, this guy is a theoretican and clearly anti west that presents his wishful thinking woth no any conection to reality. The picture is different.

[@mariadamen7886]

Please, elaborate on your view of the west and the situation in west Asia. Now your judgment is completely fact free.

[@ohdear2023]

I watch his videos to have a good laugh, he never disappointed me so far 😂 what a 🤡 he is

[@ohdear2023]

I watch him to have a good laugh 😂

[@Yahoo273]

@@ohdear2023your just a sad person if you call this a laughing matter. Go and watch cartoons that seems more up your childish troll mind.

[@markgreen8045]

LOL! Iran is the cutting edge. Good joke, too funny.