Did Mary Speak at Garabandal?

Join an unforgettable pilgrimage to Garabandal and Lourdes, August 22-29, 2024: tri.ps/EzdR0
Download our 2 page flyer for our Pilgrimage to Garbandal and Lourdes: insidethevaticanpilgrimages.c...
JOIN OUR COMMUNITY ON LOCALS: urbietorbicommunications.loca... and use promo code KZbin to support us at the discounted rate of $5.00 a month. Your support keeps our work independent and keeps you connected!
SIGN UP FOR THE FREE MOYNIHAN LETTERS: insidethevatican.com/moynihan... VISIT our websites:
SUPPORT OUR WORK TO BRING UNITY WITHIN THE CHURCH: urbietorbicommunications.com/
SUBSCRIBE TO OUR BI-MONTHLY MAGAZINE: insidethevatican.com/
EXPERIENCE AN AUTHENTIC AND IMMERSIVE PILGRIMAGE: insidethevaticanpilgrimages.com/
#garabandal #mary #catholic #podcast #pilgrimage #pilgrim #Lourdes #spain #spaintravel

[@urbietorbicommunications]

Join an unforgettable pilgrimage to Garabandal and Lourdes, August 22-29, 2024: tri.ps/EzdR0

[@sleepinglioness5754]

What is the music at the beginning and ending of your videos?

[@flyingtigers3747]

The Rev. Dr. Malachi Martin arranged for me to meet Conchita (Gonzalez) Keena at her family home in Queens, NY. She was holding a regular rosary holy hour in reparation for sins against the Immaculate Heart. A somewhat shy, unassuming woman whose deep faith was obvious. No haughtiness or attitude at all. *I was blessed.*

[@eoinmcg88]

You knew Fr Martin?

[@brendanculleton6368]

That's amazing that you met Fr Martin what a great Defender of the Faith from 🇮🇪

[@flyingtigers3747]

@@eoinmcg88 Yes, for the last decade of his life , while I was in NYC.

[@Byzntinhart]

Wow, you were blessed to know Fr. Malachi Martin

[@eoinmcg88]

@@flyingtigers3747 Are you Robert Marro? if not make a video about knowing him and post it on youtube - id love to watch that!

[@eugeneryan9705]

Was in Garabandal last August 2023. Had the honour of meeting Jacinta and Jeff Moynihan. Garabandal is at the crossroads of this world and Heaven. An absolutely amazing place!🙏❤️📿⚓️🇮🇪

[@AK5of8]

I’m just a couple years younger than your guest. I was over 40 before I understood that angels and demons were not symbols but real created beings. Good grief, the catechesis was horrible.

[@sadiewingbermuehle9378]

I’ve been privileged/blessed to visit Garabandal 20 times.

[@williamkieffer1827]

My wife and I recently registered for your August 2024 Garabandal Pilgrimage. Can’t wait to experience this Marian site.

[@mzarate6288]

Thank you very much Robert and Damian for this discussion on Garabandal. I hope the book you mentioned will soon be printed in English . Meantime I will look it up in Spanish. A blessed Lenten season to us all🙏🏻

[@cyfeltham3536]

Conchita also said 3 more popes, not counting the one that will rule for a short time….thus JPI not to be counted….

[@cyfeltham3536]

She also foretold of a ‘synod’ of which many tried to correct her thinking she meant council…but she replied, no the Lady said ‘synod’

[@femaleKCRoyalsFan]

Jp1 is still listed as a pope. Doesn't matter if reign is 33 days or 45 years. Look at the early popes...some were only pope for a few years because of martyrdom.

[@JohnDowFirst]

I don't believe she ever exempted one because his Papacy was so short. I believe others rationalised that bit. However, please advise me, with an original reference, if I am wrong.

[@codyj.braunva5406]

@@femaleKCRoyalsFansorry but Mr. 33 days pope doesn’t count

[@cyfeltham3536]

It is not that she ‘exempted’ a pope. She was ‘qualifying’ her statement…she said yes only 3 more popes, but 3 does not count the pope with a short reign…also, how did she know about a future pope with a short reign? Another type of validator to this message.

[@estherpaez6426]

Amazing interview! I never stop learning about the events that happened in Garabandal 🙏Please bring back your guest again Mr. Moynihan. God bless you.

[@Mylifetime63]

The passion of the christ film. Then the evidence of the shroud of turin should be seen. Beautiful God overcoming Satan. For to save us, please bring back altar rails for a start.

[@PrayNow4all]

The Warning, Illumination of Conscience, and the Sign that will remain are the most intriguing aspects of the Garabandal apparitions.

[@wyewye2156]

I did not get bored, just didn't get enough. Thank you

[@marshallkinsey8799]

I agree 💯 with Mr Migallo. I was born in 1966 and my catechesis was post Vatican ii and although mine was pretty solid, I still felt very strongly as a young man that something horrible had gone wrong. I knee there was a huge disconnect between the practice of all the saints of the past and my experience in the 70s (and today for that matter). I had great difficulty finding a place because I was so hungry for tradition. I made this known to vocations directors and told I'd never be accepted with such a mindset.

[@CerebralThinking]

Yes, my friend, those opining on your perceived "mindset" were always going to express their view in this way, given they were moving along on the post-Vatican 2 tide of "modernisation" while ignoring the vital messages of Garabandal, for example. Catholic Tradition (doctrine and values) were always going to be -- in due course -- gradually erased and made unwelcome. Of course, this has never been more self-evident than the catastrophic "woke" policies being unwrapped by Francis; not only does he appear to be an 'anti-pope' (for it seems increasingly likely that the seat of St Peter was not vacant to begin with given the revelations in recent books on this matter) -- but he appears to be anti-catholic too; not to mention the most diabolical position of consciously working against God, Himself. It is clear to see, from current apostasies, that he is tightly in lock-step with the chief globalists and this technocratic communist agenda. The shift is clear and palpable.

[@marybeth6750]

Wonderful! I especially like the many details you bring out through your thoughtful questioning. Please do not think you bore anyone with these facets of your topic! We tune in for your manner of sharing!

[@anneweigel2713]

Brilliant dear Dr. Moynihan and dear Damion!! Can’t wait to see you again in August in our beloved Garabandal. 🥰❤️🙏

[@robertryan2542]

Thank you gentlemen for this very interesting interview. From Ireland ☘️

[@stmartin17773]

St Peter Damian pray for us.

[@dmlm66]

Conchita was interviewed by the Australian 60 Minutes in 1983. That's how I first learned about Garabandal (I was 16). But I wonder if anyone might have taped that interview as it'd be interesting to see it again.

[@ElizabethVanDeerlin]

Thanks sooo much for this fabulous and very enlightening show. God greatly bless you both!!

[@ElizabethVanDeerlin]

What about Conchita mentioning that the Vatican would hold a Synod? Supposedly Conchita's mother or aunt asked her if she meant a Council....but she sais no. our Blessed Mother used thw word SYNOD and Conchita didn't know what a synod was

[@smithface8791]

Is the synod later this year?

[@smithface8791]

The Synod of Synodality.

[@femaleKCRoyalsFan]

We've had a few synods...Amazon synod had pagan worship

[@anndonbrinson2520]

Thank you both.

[@jerryvearrier9441]

At Fatima; Our Lady said in the 3rd Secret: "The Mass must not change." At Garabandal Our Lady said: "The Mass will hard to find." True, where can you find the Latin Mass. Read the book: "The Last Warnings" by Jerald James

[@diyqueen5812]

I believe in Garanbandal with ALL my heart. I've been to other parts of central and southern Spain. My heart is buring to go here. Im just a housewife/ grandma. I want to go with someone knowledgeable. My husband wants to go, but not as believing in all this appriation info. I do not want a big crowd pilgrimage.

[@aloyalcatholic5785]

very interesting. I learned a lot from this.

[@Fred-qe5dl]

Very interesting and informative…I’ve always say to my fellow parishioners to take heed of the Marian apparitions coz that is how God will most likely communicate to us from now on. I hope Ed will cover from our Lady of Good Success Up to Our Lady of Akita that us feign discredited right now.

[@kathylorenz303]

July 2, 1961 was my 8th birthday

[@fratertimotheusmariae2029]

+ Dear Bob, PLEASE listen to your own video and notice an interference-echo on your part. Whilst your guests are easily understood. Fans of your programs do not watch simply because your voice is difficult to listen to. Saint Clare, patron of communications, pray for us.

[@amycraig3956]

It is always good for the soul to be reminded of the need to repent and turn back to the LORD and sin no more. As an unschooled Catholic - born in '66 and not one day spent in a catholic school, although attended 'religious ed' until my confirmation in complete '70s style groovy-style - I have had to figure out everything by the help of the Holy Spirit. I have read a couple issues of the Garabandal Magazine and listened to other men and priest speak of the event. I have sought out a few interviews with Conchita. I have a comment and a question I would love some help with. Firstly, Damien's comment on "Catholic Spain" of the early '60s seems off to me, village life notwithstanding. The Spanish Civil War in the 30s - if I am to belive the history reported - devastated the Catholic church and ushered a deep and long suffering hatred in the hearts of many and like elsewhere socialism was on the rise. Secondly, why would the visionaries permanently leave the place where this prodigy in The Pines will happen. I understand the intense scrutiny they would be under (and were) but in time they should have been able to return, especially considering much of the financial health of that village today is likely attributed to their visions.

[@Pine_eagle_1985]

Hello Amy. Damian refers to 1960s Spain during a staunchly catholic military dictatorship, when it would have been simply too much to implicate and condemn Catholic Cardinals as being that sinful. They were seen as beyond reproach, as were bishops and priests also. So that line in the Second Message in 1965 was toned down by the diocesan and Jesuit priests in the village by not mentioning cardinals. By the dawn of the internet in the 1990s the cat had been let out of the bag. As with 3 out of 4 of the young visionaries leaving Spain, they simply married 3 Americans and settled in the USA.

[@aliciaalvarez5624]

El Padre Pío vio el Milagro y dejó encargado a su último hijo espiritual que le diera a Conchita el velo con el cual cubrieron su rostro en su funeral y los mitones. También dijo "creerán cuando sea demasiado tarde"

[@lucs0091]

Fr Pio Pietrelcina believed in Garabandal

[@femaleKCRoyalsFan]

You mean SAINT Padre pio?

[@lucs0091]

@@femaleKCRoyalsFan Yes😃

[@danieldimond5734]

Saint.

[@stmartin17773]

I tried to persuade Patrick Coffin to have another look at Garabandal but we got our wires crossed. Someone else might like to try.

[@tau7260]

Dr. Moynihan and Señor Migallo, thank you for what I believe is the best discussion on Garabandal I have heard. Great questions, a real sense of the people there, their history, and what the evidence strongly suggests to be the messages that Our Lady imparted to these children.

[@ichthus1890]

Mr. Moynihan, it would be helpful if you would equalize the sound levels between yourself and your guests in the future, so I don't have to turn my sound way up to hear both of you. Thank you for your content.

[@juliekozlowski4902]

I agree that teaching of the faith is horrible! It doesn’t matter what Vatican II papers said what was implemented was bad!

[@BCSTS]

Too bad there are no captions...some parts difficult to hear.

[@aliciaalvarez5624]

El día que murió Juan XXIII, Conchita dijo a su madre y a su tía que la Virgen le dijo quedaban cuatro Papas, aunque uno duraría tan poco tiempo, que no lo contaba, para que se iniciara el final de los tiempos.

[@nguyenngoibmintcvet2785]

sound is not clearly

[@roisinfurlong4457]

Please provide a link for the book

[@karentarnell3366]

So interesting to hear Mr. Migallo's experience. Just wish he would've been given a chance to talk at greater length.

[@bryanmarks3749]

Yes, and without irrelevant interruptions.

[@kitstr]

They disregarded John Paul 1 in counting the remaining popes.

[@emmetsweeney9236]

Please Dr Moynihan, let your guest talk.

[@user-wq3ty4uj1p]

Wish Dr Moynihan would let his guests talk, and he listen more.

[@Byzntinhart]

Robert, It is definitely time to break down and spend some bucks on a professional microphone. Your voice does sound hollow as tho muffled like underwater, of course not that bad but bad enough to notice it's every week.

[@veritasity2126]

Moynihan’s overtalking and interruptions to this wonderful guest almost totally destroyed the interview. People of such little faith shouldn’t interrupt great believers like this guest with their feeble skepticism.

[@BCSTS]

St. Faustina's Divine Mercy messages was suppressed by the church for a very long time as well.

[@barjonah9466]

Two things have bothered about this: Michael having teeth and the girls walking backwards

[@alexgriss5295]

It is hard to say this in a nice way; I could not finish watching because the continuous interruptions by the host, became unbearable.

[@jefffinkbonner9551]

Agreed. The poor guest could barely share his knowledge

[@se9428]

The moderator’s job is to provide context and summation for all listeners, many who may not be familiar with the events. I thought it was well done. I’m 65 and had no trouble listening. But maybe a better mic would help others. I’ve been reading and following Garabandal events since I first watched Ricardo Montalban narrate the video years ago!❤

[@paulturner5679]

That apparition was it approved it sounds fishy 🤔🐧

[@bryanmarks3749]

Dr. Moynihan, in all charity, please try to not interrupt your guests. It made the interview so difficult to follow as his chain of thoughts kept getting derailed by unnecessary comments, such as reading aloud some viewer’s post on the show.

[@susiefromomaha]

My hearing is not good, but even with earphones in, your audio is too mushy, Robert. It's too bad because I really would like to watch'listen but it's just not clear enough. The guest is always clear though, so it's perplexing. God bless.

[@amdgbvmh7661]

Apparently Robert's mic was Thomas Edison's prototype.

[@JohnDowFirst]

For future reference, fix the echo on your microphone father. It is very distracting.

[@amdgbvmh7661]

Mr. Moynihan, With all due respect, you sound as if you are under water. PLEASE change your mic so that we can hear you clearly. Your programs are excellent, thank you. However 7:45 the folks that want to listen won't tolerate the annoying sound of your voice. Do we need to take a collection to buy you a normal sounding quality mic!?

[@Byzntinhart]

Agree

[@andytraditio2983]

Please take this in the charity it is given: Please allow your guest to talk. Too many interruptions. Please fix your audio. Otherwise very informative.

[@erict.35]

If you don’t want to see how the comments on two councils by the pope Benedict are related to you, sir Moynihan…

[@uneqejam]

Most certainly, NOT!!! Again, just like with medjugorje, never before, but I mean NEVER, would the Church have fallen to the trap of these two "apparitions" - the whole concept of the "illumination of conscience" is so theologically unsound that it would have dismissed them right from the start!!!.....May God have Mercy on us few who would like to see God in His full True Stature : we're waiting for you Jesus, we're waiting for You!!!! ✝️ ✝️ ✝️

[@bryanmarks3749]

Thank goodness we have experts like you to dispute the judgement of St. Padre Pio!

[@uneqejam]

@@bryanmarks3749 These days they put anything in the mouth of Padre Pio, so I don't quite believe that.... But, even if it was True, he was mistaken there, there can be times Saints are mistaken in things of no great importance....There is sound logic into refuting these "apparitions", time also HAS proved they're not of God....AND, I'M GIVING MY LIFE FOR THIS, so there is - from one "expert" to the other!!... ✝️ ✝️ ✝️

[@bryanmarks3749]

@@uneqejam St. Pio had his funerary veil (basically the handkerchief placed on his face while lying in state), his rosary, and one of his blood-stained gloves given to Conchita Gonzales (one of the seers) after his death. Those weren't words put into St. Pio's mouth. Those were actions that confirmed his thoughts about Garabandal.

[@uneqejam]

@@bryanmarks3749 I'm really sorry, after all this time, with everything that has happened, it's more than obvious that Garabandal and all "apparitions" that move with the same spirit, are not of God... The whole concept of "Illumination of conscience" is a compete hoax, to which NEVER would the Church before fallen to.... I'm not sure how informed Padre Pio has been of all this - it was a time that an apparition was a rare event....And not everyone has the gift of discernment, although I rather think he's not been informed of everything....

[@uneqejam]

@bryanmarks3749 (I was outside, I left a reply, but it's not appearing, so I'll write it again) With everything that has happened since then, it's more than obvious that Garabandal is not of God!...The whole notion of "Illumination of Conscience" is a complete hoax, to which the Church would have NEVER before fallen to...And by dismissing Garabandal, I dismiss all "apparitions" that move from the same spirit! About Padre Pio, I say he's not been well informed - maybe there were many details that he's missed seeing which would otherwise have made him understand the Truth!!! It was a time that an apparition was a rare event, those were children, and that might have been enough to convince him about it....Not everyone has the gift of discernment - there are other issues in the Church I personally would love to know what Padre Pio's opinion was about them - because it's been quite a long time that error has crept in, and Padre Pio has been active while those were flourishing... It's a mystery we'll know after death... God tells things even now if one prays enough - we can hardly breathe, let alone contemplate that, so we'll leave it to God that mystery.....Let's hope that God will have Mercy on us and relieve us soon from these great "mysteries" and "secrets" and so on - ALL tricks of Satan to imitate and send people away from Fatima, Whose message has not been heeded YET, and Whose Voice has been silenced from a long time - let's hope God will reveal all the Truth in the Light of the Day to us, and we'll live in Peace after that !!! ✝️ ✝️

[@princessmommy8]

Why would mary pick 4 girls to appear to and then only end up coming to see one girl alone? And didn't the girls do weird things during the visions? Like climb walls? also they chewed gum during a vision.. just weird to me

[@bryanmarks3749]

St. Padre Pio bilocated to Garabandal to tell the girls that the apparitions were authentic. He also had his rosary, his funeral veil, and one of his gloves to Conchita upon his death. Sounds like he might know what he was talking about.

[@dianebelanger7056]

This was a very disjointed interview.