Difference Between Dizi and Xiao (Chinese Flutes)

[@somebody9033]

Tek = Dizi Siu = Xiao Just in case it helps someone

[@bhujgredgjoimnhnvssrbb4902]

ooooo thankyouuu and would the tones be tek2 and siu1, and then chek5 bat6? im trying to learn cantonese, but im also a flute fanatic and love any and all instruments from any and all cultures xD

[@yifanyu7113]

1:07 dizi playing 4:32 low pitch xiao 4:42 high pitch xiao

[@Gabi-hx6ok]

Thank you!

[@cshgeo]

Damn, I love this man’s knowledge, energy, and passion.

[@Chiinnature]

thanks! dont forget my other big channel - tin yat dragon taoism!

[@dreamerofvocaloids]

I was so confused and frustrated about exactly this topic, you're a lifesaver! Thank you so much!

[@yehabon]

That was really helpful. I was deciding which one to try first!

[@billysangma5891]

Thank you so much brother. After listening to Tails of Angel I want to get a Chinese flute for myself and now I know I was looking for Xiao.

[@novelistusonthewater]

thank you for a great explanation. I play NAF and I think I'll get both of these after your video

[@BluesRoadHK]

I just realize this may be the first time I leave comment on your video after I've been watching soooo many videos from you... Anyway, 好正! Thanks!

[@lordtomosdecree]

Mate you're the most asian guy i know on youtube haha I mean EVERYTHING you mostly do is Asian related! which is cool :)

[@Chiinnature]

LOL! Well I am Asian, HAHAHA! Don't forget to LIKE and sub!

[@ChromaDrum]

LOLL

[@601salsa]

I would love to buy a xiao flute. What maker would you recommend for a beginner?

[@HriataRL]

DIZI = TEK!!

[@HoanTa]

Could you compare the Chinese Xiao and Western Recorder?

[@theWZZA]

Mr. Mak, you have the most stuff. I keep learning about new stuff you have :)

[@Bullbrain]

Are those guns above the keyboard?

[@jeffreyhoogveld9461]

Thank you for this information! 🙂 I love the sound of the Xiao flute. Do you know where I can find sheet music for my Xiao flute?

[@hippiechick73]

I am also learning xiao. Here is a site with some music in western format: www.goamcan.com/lessons/Xiao-02.html

[@SubhamBoro]

Hey bro you are awesome.... Do you recommend to buy Dizi TOMTOP add in your channel, the key D or Key C, I'm 21 yr....

[@SirBeekers]

Been looking all over the place for info on these. Turns out when looking for asian things, go to asian people for help. Thank you man, happy holidays and stay safe!

[@grammarnazi6672]

Very good teacher. He explained it all very well.

[@KamenRiderRei]

Can i play the same music with both? For example if i wanted to play a song like "Wizard of Oz" by Chen Yue which was played with a Xiao, can i also play it with a Dizi?

[@Dyasaraujo]

I know i'm too late but, he says in the video that the fingering is the same so it wouldn't be much different

[@ben_patel]

Sorry for replying too late too. But, it's wrong, the fingering is totally different. A xiao requires 6, 7, 8 or 9 fingers to play (usually ppl play the 8-hole ones, the Vietnamese ppl even create the 10-hole xiao, the 11-hole xiao and the 12-hole xiao which are much more difficult to play). A dizi requires only 6 or 10 fingers. Here are some pictures to demonstrate my point: +) 8-hole xiao: kenhtieusao.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/01/he-bam-thang-am-tieu-bat-khong.jpg +) 10-11-12-hole xiao: tieusao.net/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/he-bam-tieu-viet-80-800x600.jpg +) dizi: kenhtieusao.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/01/sao-6-lo-va-10-lo.jpg

[@tanyauberoi6342]

Can anybody share an online website (that hopefully delivers internationally) from where one can buy a Dizi ?

[@MattLeGroulx]

Hi, I noticed that in another video the xiao had an open mouthpiece but this one is closed. I have a bamboo flute that I think is a xiao with an open mouthpiece but I don't know, I'm trying to figure out what it is. Is it common to have an open mouthpiece? Thanks!

[@Chiinnature]

the southern style have open mouthpieces, and it's the same kind of technique to blow them. Closed mouthpieces could be easier for newbies, but eventually it feels the same.

[@MattLeGroulx]

@@Chiinnature Ok, thank you! I can get some notes out of it now. It has five holes on the front and one thumb hole so I'm assuming it's more of a traditional style? It also has red paint on the inside. You wouldn't happen to know anything about the Tsing Sheng company, would you? Sorry to ask so many questions! I haven't been able to find anything online about this xiao.

[@Chiinnature]

Red paint in the inside is good, its for anti-crack. Don't know about that company but your Xiao should be very easy to play. 5 holes are good and sound more "asian", I have 5 holes for most of my xiao too. Left hand 2 fingers on top hole, right hand 3 fingers on the bottom. Make sure you don't cover the holes with the TIP of the fingers. We use the middle section of the finger to cover the holes so the hands don't cramp up during playing and it's much more relaxed, but it's weird at the first stage because it's very "strange". Spend 15mins playing it daily, put it beside your computer, and after a month or so you will be having fun playing like a pro. lol!

[@MattLeGroulx]

@@Chiinnature Ah, thank you! Yes, the hardest part for me right now is the right hand fingering, especially the lowest note. I need to practice!

[@Chiinnature]

blow less hard on the low note, then the sound will come out. Good luck!

[@kuku68578]

Love Japanese...I had a japanese and chinese friend long time...ago. They went for life in USA. Yeah nice people good food grate talking.

[@lukalebanidze]

HI! I watched all your videos about playing Xiao, but my Xiao has 12 holes (9 from front side), I play it vertically, but could you suggest some tutorial to play it horizontally? (I guess those holes are for that or should I cover them with membranes)?

[@amymcauliffe2894]

Is there a flute similar to the dizi but smaller? From the pictures I've seen I thought it was alot smaller.

[@CM-mu9hi]

Can you go over different keys of the xiao?

[@patleo123]

Thank you. You taught me so much.

[@Italygirl110]

I have a Chinese flute bamboo but my mouth piece is very different then yours. Can you help me identify it? It is 3 different pieces. The blow hole is in a metal section and the hole is more of a slit and not a hole. On the other piece there is a fancy chunk that I think is what causes the sound.

[@pavelnovak3543]

I think you get or bought flute called " Bawu" its a bit rare but not immposible get it or buy search over net or Google

[@noen3978]

i had fun watching this video, and also learned a lot! thank you for sharing~ i know a lot more now 😊💖

[@rongsenakiliolusang2902]

Boss where can I buy these flutes? The same flutes u are using for this video? I am from India. Please help

[@lutfiyemasur4738]

Hello. I have a question. I am playing clarinet, which one do you think easier for me to learn by myself, and which key should I use?

[@uinsinoriabhaigh7758]

What is the difference between the 8 hole XIAO and the Recorder.

[@BiologicalClock]

The recorder has a mouthpiece that is placed inside of the lips and is very easy to get a sound out of. The Siu/Xiao has a slotted opening that requires air flow to hit the opening at a specific angle in order to create sound.

[@feliciachai316]

really helpful. ty!

[@amymcauliffe2894]

Where would you recommend buying a dizi from and what keys like g,e or f?

[@Diziflute-DanTang]

😀

[@artao5]

Do you know of anywhere to get a bass dizi?

[@Diziflute-DanTang]

😀

[@keniceeunice2644]

thank you so much， even I am Chinese, I mix up 笛 and 簫。

[@KevinMoras13]

Hello, which one would you say is easier especially for a beginner?

[@Chiinnature]

Kevin Moras it really depends on the person, some prefers this and some prefers that. Best to try it out yourself instead.

[@KevinMoras13]

I play the tin whistle so I guess I would get used to xiao more. Thanks

[@ben_patel]

How's your practice? Xiao is the most difficult one to play and you chose it. I'm impressed, tin flute is nothing comparing to dizi or even xiao lmao =)) wish u the best

[@Sir_Flopsalot]

What key is most Chinese music in?

[@YnnadzCatacutanizer]

This is so amazing, I have seen these videos a long time ago, now I am going back to learning Dizi with my other traditional instruments. I am glad the basics are still here! Thank you very much! #ekozither

[@tanyauberoi6342]

Hey! I've recently gained interest in flutes, and I'm curious how you were able to buy the Dizi? Is there a website you can recommend?

[@tobii6939]

@@tanyauberoi6342 I mean, you can get some pretty decent ones on Amazon to start off

[@engchoontan8483]

Many youtube channels have chinese flute versions of "fly me to polaris" but soprano flute...

[@emilygoestochina]

Thank you for this useful video! :)

[@sooney001]

Oooh, this is SUCH a good video! 👍🏻 Great explanation!! 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻Thank you so much! 😊🌸

[@Chiinnature]

You are so welcome!

[@kairinase]

Xiao always reminds me of Huang Yao Shi.

[@gracecurtis8982]

Wow you know Hunag Yao Shi? Impressive!

[@stevetaylor5265]

Thank you so much for this video!! It helps a lot!! :)

[@jurekzavadil6965]

As a western man : We could play the beer bottle

[@lilyl5643]

very informative videos, love the American/Canadian accent? ;)

[@alvintham8792]

good to know the difference between the two instruments as they sound nearly alike.. haha

[@nf3922]

IT most certainly comes in different sizes 🤣

[@davidbogojevic8131]

The second flute looks like a Serbian duduk and that is what i play

[@alexrodriguez351]

Right on. Thank you. (Buddha Salutation)

[@rostislavhonus7021]

Ohhh, thanks a lot!!! Now, I know ;-)

[@amir021idm]

Nice :D

[@Chiinnature]

amir sabbagh Thank you!

[@MrAmulyamishra]

Your accent is like jackie chan.