Differentiating the Palestinian Cause with Pan Arabism and Islamism (With Marwan Abdelhamid)

A clip from our 1 hour conversation with TikTok influencer and activist, Marwan Abdelhamid.

[@Femmeaesthetic]

There a few things I disagree with you: - your talking about historical narrative because mostly you don’t have one since it’s weak. If your talking about the historical narrative claiming that “Palestinians lived there for centuries” is false because under ottomans before British mandate, when Jews were building economy there was mass immigration among Arabs. The things about pro Palestinians is that they rewrite a lot of history claiming that “Jews were the only people immigrating to the land” and there so tied into 1948. Many people lack understanding the Jewish diaspora knowing that Jews originated from that land, there were few Jewish groups that didn’t end up as diaspora which are Samaritans & other Israelite tribes who still held presence in that land. Yes there were times Jews were majority and minority since many empire conquered that land. Your historical narrative is weak because 1. The Palestine “Syria Palestina” was named by the Roman Empire after the Jewish revolt, renaming the land Judea to Syria Palestina in order to insult Jews & disconnect them from the land (Syria Palestina name didn’t last long since many empires conquered the land) 2. Under ottomans the land name was Syria, not Palestine but when British defeated ottomans then you had British mandate of Palestine and Palestine was not established as a country 3. The Arabs before 1948 did not identify Palestinian since they were involved with pan Arabism (the Palestinian flag originally represented pan Arabism) the Arabs wanted greater Syria, the only people who identified Palestinian were Jews but they dropped that identity in 1948 & after that there was no Palestine but Egypt that controlled Gaza & Jordan that controlled West Bank (Judea and Samaria) 4. The Palestinian identity among Arabs was adapted in 1960s by Yasra Arafat who’s Egyptian for Arab-Israeli propaganda war, the executive committee of PLO *Zahair Mohsen* said himself that there was no such thing as Palestinian people and that whole identity is based around fighting against Israel, without Israel there is no Palestinian identity cause other Arab nations would’ve annexed the land and there would be no protest for “free Palestine. And this is the reason why your cause does not differentiate pan Arabism or islamism since your cause supports the destruction of Jewish nation and getting rid of the Jews who had historical and genetic ties to the land. Your cause that claims to be anti Zionist does not support a Jewish nation or even 2 states because the whole point of Zionism is giving Jewish people right to have a nation in there ancestral homeland. - sure Zionist aren’t immune from criticism however Israelis didn’t steal history from you because they already have there history, they’ve evidence to prove they lived in that land by archaeology written in ancient Hebrew. Your confused why your side is uneducated, well that’s the fault of UNWRA that indoctrinates Gazans to k*ll every single Jews, now idk about West Bank but they would have similar “educational teachings” as Gazans since the governing Palestinian authorities are corrupt.

[@arimagoo4687]

Check out also “Palestine Center” in Washington, DC. Also on KZbin.🙏