From Dinosaurs to Birds: The Remarkable Evolutionary Journey Unveiled | Dinosaur Documentary

[@scottwells8064]

I've fallen asleep twice now before the end of the video. And that's not a complaint. This is easily one of the most relaxing channels on KZbin.

[@earl_r1863]

0:23 this part woke me up

[@bassbustingman]

must watch at 1.5X it sound like he is talking normally

[@Rome274]

He has a very soothing relaxing voice

[@vajamasaurusrex]

@@bassbustingman couldnt even take 1.25

[@dearthditch]

@@bassbustingmanthank you! 😅

[@catpoke9557]

"Birds aren't related to dinosaurs, they ARE dinosaurs" Thank you. Thank you for starting with this. Too many videos take too long to get to this fact when mentioning they've descended from dinosaurs. People misinterpret that phrase as meaning they have descended PAST the point of being a dinosaur, when they have not.

[@IamAWESOME3980]

strictly speaking, these categorizations are all artificial intellectual devices and constructs. they have no meanings beyond how humans like to categorized things. if we wish to say birds are not dinosaurs since the time they have feathers, we can do that and it will be equally valid just as if we wish to classified humans are not animals but somewhat superior godlike beings, we can do that as well. they are all valid because these really have no meanings beyond what we humans like to define them as.

[@JAM-ic8kv]

As an example, cetaceans are mammals despite being shaped like fish.

[@catpoke9557]

@@JAM-ic8kv Yup, it's even worse though because birds are shaped like a very typical theropod too. So even the shape is like a dinosaur, which makes it all the more annoying when people make it sound like they're not dinosaurs.

[@IamAWESOME3980]

@Cat Poke modern birds do not look at bit like the earliest dinosaurs. Heck, even many of the none avian dinosaurs do not look a bit like the earliest dinisarsus. There are over a hundred million years between the time dinosaurs' first evolved in triassiac and the time of like say a T Rex theropod. A T Rex would be closer to modern-day humans in the time line than it is to their earliest ancestors and would look very different than the first dinosaurs who branch off of the archosaur. To fly, there needs to be major changes to one's body just like to swim, there needs to be major changes to one's body as well. This is why creteceans look so drastically different from their fur ancestors. Major body changes is necessary to adapt to life in the sea as it is to adapt to life in the sky. The none flying birds like emu and ostrich are much more primitive looking and dinosaurs like.

[@catpoke9557]

@@IamAWESOME3980 Theropods weren't the earliest dinosaurs, so I don't see your point. Birds look like regular theropods, that's all I was saying. Although I will say the earliest dinosaurs looked a lot like theropods, so birds aren't too insanely far from them either. They certainly look more like them than whales look like mammals, haha! And yes, a lot of dinosaurs looked nothing like the first dinosaurs. Pretty much only bipedal carnivores and omnivores looked like them.

[@gluehuff43]

Man I’ve been waiting for someone to make this exact video for a while. Great job!

[@TheFoshaMan]

Man I love Dinosaurs...

[@Alexsedlex]

especially roasted or grilled

[@m1sty033]

@@Alexsedlexsame here!

[@1stHuemanAmerican]

They at the pet shops🕊️ all across America and at farms🐔 😊

[@PAR0812]

I live only 50 km away from the place where the first Archaeopteryx was found. :)

[@williamchamberlain2263]

Nice

[@josephcosta5382]

Nice! I'd be outside every day I had off work trying to find fossils. 🍻

[@nogoodgod4915]

It's tragic how little views this amazing channel gets!

[@melflo4651]

One more viewer and subscriber!!!😊

[@xalspaero]

I see lots of dinosaurs frequenting my yard. They are fascinating to observe. Strange critters indeed.

[@andrewgonzales6527]

Only those in the clade Theropod(3 toes) can be classified as modern dinosaurs. Calling all birds modern dinosaurs is a gross overstatement.

[@xalspaero]

@@andrewgonzales6527 which birds are not theropods?

[@andrewgonzales6527]

@@xalspaero any bird that doesn’t have 3 toes and claws on each limb should not classify as the clade Theropod, because that is one of its the main characteristics.

[@jaysons6101]

@@xalspaero Dont listen to andrew, he is a troll

[@shiannecostello6228]

First video I've seen that mentions the Argentavis! I love it. Keep up the great work, I really enjoy your videos!

[@2l84me8]

Very interesting video. I assume archaeopteryx could fly for short bursts given its hollow bone structure. It probably mostly used it for escaping predators since it's shaped more like a runner.

[@sizanogreen9900]

Yeah, I feel like thinking of them as living similar to modern Secretary Birds (maybe not the kicking tho) is a pretty plausible analogy.

[@andersdroid]

According to a recent study Archaeopteryx flew like a pheasant.

[@ChromeStrand]

Love the calm voice and contents, only thing that can be improved is the scene transitional effect. It tears a lot and not looking good.

[@Momcat_maggiefelinefan]

Excellent video. I saw “the bird look” in some of my Dino toys and models as a kid. Not a difficult idea to latch on to. I have a resident crow family which patrols the neighbourhood. Once I started feeding them meat scraps, various fruit items, stale bread, etc. the family saw me as a provider. Being able to study these beautiful new age dinos is a joy for me and my cat. If I haven’t put out scraps for a few days, they peek in the window, wondering where breakfast is. The intelligence sparkles in their eyes, and the powerful beak certainly looks Dino-like! 🇨🇦🖖🏻🇨🇦

[@zakhelemakubo1477]

stupid adverts keep interrupting my beautiful sleep.. but this voice is such a pro sleep-hypnosis.. i get back in there within minutes... im gonna use this video to get rid of my insomnia.. thank you sir..

[@KAZVorpal]

You mistakenly show an enantiornith as your bird surviving the K-T event, when it's exactly what was wiped out at that boundary. Remember that MOST birds went extinct when the dinosaurs did. The enantiorniths especially. They were the most successful Cretaceous birds, which is exactly why they died out, while niche birds that lived in burrows or water survived.

[@dleddy14]

The effect of that voice in the opening soundtrack is awesome.

[@misterrickschannel2238]

Last evening I saw a beautiful Eastern Bluebird while out walking around the apartments where I live, near Jamestown, NY. I haven't seen one of them in a long time. Too quick for a pic, though.

[@machiavelZongo]

because birds are dinosaurs we don't need to say the world BIRD we can say DINOSAURS instead , it's more logic for me. I love that video and his voice his just amazing. Good boy i love him

[@gic8849]

From 6:00 on sounds like you’re speaking an alien language Man I love dinosaurs

[@dontwren]

great video so far but you know the narrator is insanely slow when x1.75 speed sounds normal

[@Ariu_the_furry]

Avien or not, i love dinosaurs no matter what

[@CUTTLOOSE1]

Love your work dude keep it up, watched this multiple times and will continue to in the future 👌🏽👌🏽👌🏽

[@gordonbartle1466]

Beautifully done. Please do more and expand with even more science even if speculative. I will/am supporting.

[@carnivesper]

Dromeosaurids have always been my favorite type of dinosaur , and to learn more about their ancestory is amazing .

[@SoulDelSol]

(Verse 1) In the ancient world, a fearsome breed, Dromeosaurids, born for speed. With razor claws and a hunter's eye, They ruled the land, the predators high. (Pre-Chorus) In the Cretaceous age, they roamed with might, Swift and cunning, a primal delight. From the dawn to dusk, they hunted their prey, Dromeosaurids, ruling their domain. (Chorus) Dromeosaurids, kings of the ancient earth, With serrated teeth, a thunderous birth. They ran like the wind, relentless and strong, Dromeosaurids, the rock 'n' roll of the long gone. Dromy-oh!-saurids, they rocked on and on. (Verse 2) Velociraptors, deadly and sleek, Utahraptors, fierce and unique. Feathers adorned their reptilian frame, A sight to behold, nature's wicked game. (Bridge) Their claws were sharp, their jaws locked tight, Leaping with grace, they struck in the night. Silent shadows, stalking their prey, Dromeosaurids, the rulers of the day. (Chorus) Dromeosaurids, kings of the ancient earth, With serrated teeth, a thunderous birth. They ran like the wind, relentless and strong, Dromeosaurids, the rock 'n' roll of the long gone. Dromy-oh!-saurids, they rocked on and on. (Solo) (Verse 3) Now they're gone, a distant past, But their legacy forever will last. In our dreams, their spirit survives, Dromeosaurids, rock 'n' roll revived. (Chorus) Dromeosaurids, kings of the ancient earth, With serrated teeth, a thunderous birth. They ran like the wind, relentless and strong, Dromeosaurids, the rock 'n' roll of the long gone. Dromy-oh!-saurids, they rocked on and on. (Outro) Dromeosaurids, we remember your might, In our hearts, you shine bright. Through the ages, your legend remains, Dromeosaurids, forever rockin' in our veins. Dromy-oh!-saurids, they're the rock 'n' roll flames.

[@SoulDelSol]

Dromy-oh!‐saurids!

[@SON_ZER0_7]

I remember when I younger I noticed that birds look a lot like dinosaurs now I know it’s because they are dinosaurs 🔥

[@andrewgonzales6527]

Only those in the order Theropod can be classified as modern dinosaurs. Calling all birds modern dinosaurs is a gross overstatement.

[@jaysons6101]

@@andrewgonzales6527 lil bro you're been disproven 100 times stop spreading misinfo

[@andrewgonzales6527]

@@jaysons6101 I thought I deleted these comments, but one. I left an edit explaining that I didn't realize the ancestors of three toed animals can be classified as theropods, even if they themselves had more or less toes. My bad.

[@timmywood9677]

The secretary bird is like a modern raptor 🦖it uses it feet with fast acting strike to catch deadly poisonous snakes and lizards in Africa. Plus the forest eagles the Philippine and harpy eagle are super dinosaur like also with there with there head crests and massive claws

[@blacksheepbanjos]

The shoebill stork definitely has that dinosaur look too.

[@InformationIsTheEdge]

I dig that you opened with the hard, unvarnished truth that birds ARE dinosaurs and it is a proven scientific fact.

[@aspirativemusicproduction2135]

Is this "fall asleep channel?" Theory=proven fact. Anyway, I appreciate the labor you have put into this. Only it's better to watch it double speed😅

[@BleedingBasco]

I had to speed it up 1.25x, buts its a really good video.

[@dontwren]

29:40 that bird almost got pooped on and looked up so indignant lol

[@terrywestmorland3069]

Brilliant film...

[@Niki-xr6cw]

The amazing thing is before the arrival of early hominids birds where already there ,we evolved hearing the sounds of birds . that is truly amazing .

[@NotSoNormal1987]

Probably why bird song helps lift me out of depression. I have pet budgies. And they bring such joy to my life.

[@therestingrancor8259]

Nah, it's night here, the theropods are all asleep.

[@bassbustingman]

MUST watch at 1.5 play back speed too not fall asleep!

[@OdeeOz]

With the plethora of food sources, I have to wonder why the birds aren't larger like wayyy back when. 👍👍⭐

[@bendarkfangbravo4022]

The air had i higher oxygen level then it does today alowing them to be bigger thats why things are smaller today less oxygen in the air.

[@OdeeOz]

Finally someone with smarts, responds to my _Test_ questions,@@bendarkfangbravo4022 👍👍 5⭐🍀

[@This_birb_is_annoying...]

Compitison from mammals

[@jaysons6101]

You know, just a few centuries ago we had the Elephant bird and Moas(both the Largest birds ever), but we killed them for... idk

[@TheJuanTrueKaiser]

Lmao what’s with all the paleontologicaly challenged creationist in the comments?

[@funtimefoxy6136]

Could you a video explaining the evolution of crocodilians?

[@Juradolukas]

Great video to fell asleep in a few minutes! And yes! Thats a good thing!

[@patagonianthylacine6306]

If you're putting the work in to make these pay a human being to narrate them

[@PeterParker-gt3xl]

What a relief, enough to go back to sleep; giant lizards became birds, chicken is bird, now we get to eat chicken instead of being eaten, just watch out for the giant Komodo dragon.

[@Dr.Ian-Plect]

Lizards did not become birds.

[@AncientWildTV]

I love dinosaurs 🦖

[@mrsmerily]

when you eat chicken you are eating dinosaurus.

[@SoulDelSol]

That's ok 👍

[@Dr.Ian-Plect]

"when you eat chicken you are eating dinosaurus." - not at all

[@jaysons6101]

Nah you should search up "Dinosaurus" They gave the genus to an EXTINCT STEM MAMMAL😭😭😭😭

[@kiezen-_-3464]

Put speed playback to 1.25 so it sounds less like a bot

[@Alduintheworldeater]

Most ai voiced videos should be on 1.25

[@TheRopenNetwork]

Some of the questions I get is do you believe there's intelligent life outside of the Earth, the real question they should be asking is there any intelligent life left on this planet. If you really believe that a Tyrannosaurus turned into a chicken then you seriously need mental help.

[@AMC2283]

The theory of evolution in no way predicts organisms change species. Changes are hereditary.

[@degew9367]

Nobody claims the t.rex turned into a chicken. Try again

[@krisdockers2047]

Yep yep yes sirEEE, i sppose a brontosaurus turned into a bid fat turkey??? This seems to be such a far fetched clutch at straws! Why??? Still tryin to work that out i guess

[@addersrinseandclean]

Just give us more time 🤣

[@jonathancummings6400]

Really? The Body design is similar. Also such a "Dinosaur" lies dormant in the Chicken genome. Jack Horner's team, over the past decade have developed the capability to create awaken the Maniraptoran Dinosaur genes in Chickens to create the mighty "Chickenosaurus" by perhaps as soon as 2025 they will have taken the humble, tasty Chicken, and restored it into a mighty Dromaeosaur, which is the lineage of Dinosaurs "Birds" belong to. The group of feathered Dinosaurs Velociraptor, Denonychus, and Dromaeosaurus belonged to also generated small flying types, one of whom survived to the present day, and we call them "Birds".

[@WonderfulDay2023]

Interesting

[@trvth1s]

The video screen picture is misleading. Dromeosaurs didn't evolve into birds. Dromeosaurids actually evolved after birds and mammals. Dromeosaurids are simply close relatives to birds

[@Dr.IanPlect]

What's your basis for 'Dromeosaurids actually evolved after birds'?

[@trvth1s]

@@Dr.IanPlect Early birds evolve during the early jurrasic, they were gliders at this time. Dromeosaurids evolved mid Jurassic

[@Dr.IanPlect]

@@trvth1s I'll ask again; What's your basis for 'Dromeosaurids actually evolved after birds'? - do try and answer what is asked

[@trvth1s]

@@Dr.IanPlect read my previous comment, it's in English which you seem to somewhat understand. For sources you're welcome to use the search engine Google. Don't expect others to do your homework.

[@savem2384]

@@trvth1s Your comment is very confusing? The earliest known bird is from the late Jurassic as focused on in the video.

[@jasonwilliams5477]

I've often wondered if the Tyrannosaurus arms were so short because they had wings?

[@jaysons6101]

No, its common in late dinosaurian carnivores(although not all) that they evolved more robust heads for smaller arms. Although it IS possible(and likely) that Juvenile Tyrannosaurus had feathers, Adult probably had little to none(take elephants for example, almost no fur)

[@catpoke9557]

That thumbnail is... very unpleasant. The first dinosaurs were feathery, not scaly. Feathers are not a trait their ancestors gained with time. Rather their feathers became more complex with time. A more accurate thumbnail would represent an early theropod with simple fuzzy feathers, then a dromaeosaur-like dinosaur with pennaceous and contour feathers (but probably no toeclaw), and then starting from the toothed bird in the thumbnail everything is more or less accurate.

[@MrCenturion13]

How do you know?

[@IamAWESOME3980]

He doesn't know. Evidence of feathers did not appear until jurassic and dinosaurs had been around since the triassiac

[@relentlesseducator]

Nerd

[@MrCenturion13]

@@relentlesseducator : like he was there or something....

[@catpoke9557]

@@IamAWESOME3980 No, we do know, at least we know that the answer of them having feathers ancestrally is the most likely by far. To start with, pterosaurs had feathers. Unless this very complex structure evolved twice in the archosaurs, with two animals that just so happen to be very closely related, this means the ancestral ornithodiran- the common ancestor between dinosaurs and pterosaurs- had feathers. And therefore, unless it immediately lost feathers when it became a dinosaur but did not when it became a pterosaur, this would mean the first dinosaurs were scaly. Considering many dinosaurs have feathers, this... is not likely to be true. Moreover, feathers are present in both saurischian and ornithischian dinosaurs, and are present in many basal dinosaurs and absent in derived ones. Example: Tyrannosaurids. Basal tyrannosauroids are all feathered, but derived tyrannosaurids are likely all scaly. The dinosaur that pushes the idea of ancestrally scaly dinosaurs to the point of being a near absurd idea? Kulindadromeus. Undeniably ornithischian, and a basal one at that, with not only undeniable feathering, but lots of different feather types- many of which look exactly how we expect basal feathers to look. In order for dinosaurs to be ancestrally scaly, feathers would've had to convergently evolve MULTIPLE times within the ornithodirans, and NO other group has evolved anything even similar, except possibly longisquama. This is so unlikely that unless someone can find extraordinary evidence, it is considered almost certain that the earliest dinosaurs were all feathered. And that isn't even all the evidence we have- just some things I can remember off the top of my head. Indeed, feathers seem to be the trait that separates dinosaurs and pterosaurs from all other reptile groups. Even the scales of dinosaurs without feathers are... actually technically feathers, just highly derived ones. So they're a trait all dinosaurs share with each other.

[@njez7563]

Why are the comments full of short bus people

[@luisito6314]

Their were already flying birds back when the dinosaurs were here, they needed to really fly no matter where they were when the asteroid hit not glide from bush to bush.

[@jaysons6101]

Birds are Dinos

[@krisdockers2047]

Sounds like bullshit to me

[@johngavin1175]

So what isn't bullshit to you? Science and its search for truth is bullshit?

[@pierre-samuelroux9364]

Like your creationnism

[@krisdockers2047]

@@pierre-samuelroux9364 No not like MY creationism???!!!This just sounds like Bullshit. Oh how we mere humans clutch at straws to show how we know all. This is an obvious example of that ( my opinion only)

[@NicholsonNeisler-fz3gi]

Never forget!

[@mistinewby9623]

I would like a study guide or worksheet to go along with this video. Has anyone found one?

[@prometheus9096]

Look out the window u see a Bird. China: What's a Bird?

[@SoulDelSol]

You need to translate word bird to Chinese and then ask

[@prometheus9096]

@@SoulDelSol There are regions in China where u literally see no birds. They actively hunted birds during the culture revolution (one of Maos insane ideas). Today a lot of pollution and relentless destruction of nature. There a city's with parks where you don't see nor hear any bird. It's really strange if you recognize there is something missing.

[@SoulDelSol]

@@prometheus9096 wow that's crazy

[@reyinfante5553]

It is NOT a fact, it is a theory, just like humans descended from monkeys and apes.

[@azrielmoha6877]

A theory that's based on mountains of scientific observation and evidence. It's the same fact as gravity and Newtonian force law.

[@degew9367]

You don't know what a scientific theory is

[@jounisuninen]

@@azrielmoha6877 "A theory that's based on mountains of scientific observation and evidence." Nonsense. There is not a single evidence, just loose talk. A scientific fact is the result of a repeatable careful observation or measurement by experimentation or other means, also called empirical evidence. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fact#In_science How many times has evolution been successfully tested and corroborated in accordance with the scientific method, using accepted protocols of observation, measurement, and evaluation of results? Answer is ZERO. Evolution's existence indeed has been tested innumerable times, but every empirical test has proved that evolution does not happen.

[@VisitPunjab]

Hen are dinosaur 🦕 now

[@Alduintheworldeater]

Check mark woah

[@pauly165]

Dinosaurs to birds 😂 Whatta joke.

[@gustavo-xd5uc]

Piada,nem tanto.

[@AMC2283]

Any rational criticism?

[@pauly165]

Ya, for one thing no animals have ever been observed changing into another kind. There arent any transitional fossil remains of this happening, there should be millions. The respiratory system of birds is completely different from dinosaurs or any other animals. How did that evolve? It just doesn't make common sense.

[@AMC2283]

@@pauly165 kind isn’t a category in taxonomy. Organisms don’t change species, changes are hereditary. The fossil record is replete with bird ancestors. How does anything evolve, mutagens and natural selection cause genetic drift.

[@degew9367]

​@@pauly165 1. Define kind 2. You don't know what evolution is, do you 3. Birds and dinosaurs are the only animals with pneumatic skeletons.

[@neilgansekoele5464]

Didn’t happen like that at all

[@ExcitedDragon-fp8yp]

The non bird dinosaurs went extinct, the birdosaurs lived on and became.....birds.

[@wingedhussar1453]

Thw really intresting thing is that the beak tht birds have really never was a thing until the jurrasic extinction .there were many other extinctions yet none of them evolved the beak which is weird😊

[@ricknorris1466]

Science is the Myth slayer.

[@spaalqutsi]

"Would have coexist with some of the most infamous terrifying creatures" shows a whale shark lol

[@Newt998]

Hypothetically, if a environment changes to be more like the environment the dinosaurs lived in, could a creature or a bird, like the cassowary slowly evolve into a dinosaur-like creature? Similar to an archaeopteryx? Or something in that general form? And this hypothetical environment isnt a real environment, and this is just a question. Something kind of like this 7:53

[@marioballadares4629]

I believe they are all birds, with and without wings, judging for the age of the fossils, birds and no avían dinosaurs have roughly the same age, seems like once they all share the planet at the same time

[@titanuspixel55]

Birds as a group (Aves) appeared during the late Jurassic, so they coexisted a long time, specially on the Cretaceous period.

[@palndan]

Why have you slowed down your voice?

[@valerykrasulya1208]

If dinosaurs had a brain of raven, they would survive asteroid disaster

[@jaysons6101]

No, its just that birds at the time were EXTREMELY small and could eat seeds, thus survived

[@mnbr6884]

Just think, every time you eat chicken, you're eating a dinosaur.

[@charlesmarkley220]

Dinosaurs still exist. Batoven proved it.

[@andrewgonzales6527]

Only those in the order Theropod can be classified as modern dinosaurs. Calling all birds modern dinosaurs is a gross overstatement.

[@jaysons6101]

Lowkey secretarybird is one of the coolest modern dinos

[@mikeheavyheart5114]

36:50; 5:44; 0:03;

[@yassasloan7308]

Am the only person who loves documentaries but hates A.I. narrators? 🤔I

[@Joe-lb8qn]

"......lived in late Cretaceous Mexico" ... oof, thats not a good place to choose.

[@AaaaNinja]

1:01 I think you meant descendants not ancestors.

[@InformationIsTheEdge]

I caught that too. ;)

[@2RANbit]

Was the pelvis of Archeopteryx Sauruschian or Ornithischian?

[@dontmindmyname1234]

whichever hip structure theropods have would be the answer

[@jaysons6101]

Actually is Sauruschian it was named back then when they didn't know which family(ornis or saurus- chain) birds belonged to, so they named the clades based on how the pelvis looked

[@raycavazos8927]

From Dino to dinner

[@deborahdonnelly8423]

dinosaurs were colored like birds

[@HumbertoGomez-ip4wx]

My parrot can say a few words. His favorite word is gay. He calls everyone gay. I wonder if dinosaurs could do the same.

[@OptimusPrime-od3zh]

Possibly yes maybe dinosaurs could mimic lots of animals speech I doubt it will be as advanced as parrots

[@pierre-samuelroux9364]

​@@OptimusPrime-od3zhhow is cybertron?

[@OptimusPrime-od3zh]

@@pierre-samuelroux9364 good

[@pierre-samuelroux9364]

@@OptimusPrime-od3zh :)

[@OptimusPrime-od3zh]

@@pierre-samuelroux9364 thanks

[@AF-gi6pr]

Urvogel T.T

[@vivekvishwanathan1989]

Humanosaurus yu forgotten!😂😂😂

[@outdoorangerify]

Play at +25 speed as the ai narration is unnaturally slow. And BTW birds are a branch of the dinosaur family. Eat a chicken or a T Rex it's the same though a T rex could feed an army. 😂😂

[@janusatthegate6201]

The theropods had arms that were wings. Obvious.

[@AMC2283]

Some problem criticizing the actual theory of evolution instead of making of premises and anatomies?

[@pierre-samuelroux9364]

Not all

[@markmatulic9905]

"We fucked up go back."

[@paochainlay5758]

Well today' house cats are so grateful to the asteroid fell on that day or there won't be any catchable birds in these days.

[@indricotherium4802]

Sounds like this robot narrator evolved in North America, forcing its human biological equivalents to the brink of extinction.

[@SideWalkAstronomyNetherlands]

No it is NOT örwogel, it is Urvogel pronounced like ou in you or oe in shoe...do your home work! And with a v and not a w..

[@brettcourtenay569]

Great Video ! Except... just before the end , the Narrator states that birds "...are the direct descendants of the amazing reptiles that once ruled our planet" Reptiles? Dinosaurs WERE NOT Reptiles! Sheesh!

[@pierre-samuelroux9364]

Dinosaurs were reptiles bruh it proved

[@jaysons6101]

Birds are Reptiles

[@petefluffy7420]

If birds are dinosaurs, then obviously the ARE related to dinosaurs. Is the script writer related to any English speaker?

[@DS9TREK]

That's like saying humans are humans and therefore humans are related to humans. We say humans are related to chimpanzees because we're separate species with a common ancestor. Saying birds are related to dinosaurs implies they are non-dinosaurs but share a common ancestor.

[@stephenrusso6019]

@@DS9TREK but they are dinosaurs lmao avian ones

[@SoulDelSol]

​@@stephenrusso6019put it this way, an eagle is not a velociraptor. One is a bird and one is not. Both are in same branch of therapod dinosaurs

[@glenliesegang233]

Yup, I've had to kill 3 little male T-rexes for attacking my grandkids. We called them roosters. But the genetic remodrling of scale to feather is absurdly complex.. and the little hooklets which hold barbs together with preening...wow which hold the

[@Dr.Ian-Plect]

T. rex isn't ancestral to birds.

[@oscartorman3127]

Kkkkk, nem que se desse a eternidade!

[@knotskieskyramirez9491]

What a ?????????

[@This_birb_is_annoying...]

What is a bird to you

[@thenightscythe2030]

It is said that once something Evolves, it cant really evolve-back... So as soon as Birds evolved to have Hollowed-out bones... And Wings, they were separte from their cousin Dinosaurs... Which were still Heavy, with dense bones. I find it interesting that you can see this with how these Bipedal creatures Arm's/Wing's become more Vestigial by how Large they become, with T-rex's/Carnitores being obvious examples of this extreme to one end, and Small Bird's like Hummingbirds can show the other extreme for Bird's. After the Extinction Event, Birds would definetly divert more into this extreme, especially as they evolved their Diets after the chain of events that completly romoved the Dinosaurs from the food chain... And ate more fish ect

[@afa78djd]

The thing is, birds were contemporaries to their non-avian counterparts. The birds we see today likely evolved from birds of those times, and aren't evolved raptors or ornithomimids. Think of it this way, let's replace dinosaurs with mammals. Imagine all the mammals died out due to some catastrophic disaster, and only a few species of bats survived. Those bats went on to evolve into hundreds, then thousands and ultimately millions of new flying mammals. Future paleontologists discover mammal fossils, some small, some gigantic, but none with evidence of possessing flight. Woah! People might erroneously think, this giant mammal was about to develop wings like a bat, I mean, look at how they share features and traits?

[@paulingvar]

Correct, I asked once and got the answer that the hollow bones stopped the birds evolving into large dinosaurs. But I also suspect that the evolved mammals would take a toll on large eggs on the ground

[@DS9TREK]

You can always evolve back, whales returning to the sea is proof of that, and so too are large flightless birds. Who says their bones will still be hollow one million years from now?

[@radicalthunder5740]

​@DS9TREK evolution would need to give them a reason to de-evolve but as it stands now and for the future. Nature has a winning formula that won't change in a million years

[@paulingvar]

@@DS9TREK Some professional- I do not have the name

[@elh305]

🧐 . . . . . . . . . . ........🤌🏼

[@v1e1r1g1e1]

Utter bosh. Stick around, people. Within a decade this entire ''dinosaurs to birds'' theory will be ditched.

[@mixtheory1412]

Nah not happening

[@v1e1r1g1e1]

@@mixtheory1412 Gotta crystal ball, have you? I've got history on my side.

[@mixtheory1412]

@@v1e1r1g1e1 yeah well even history would tell you that times have changed. And that it is time to move on and accept the newly discovered reality

[@v1e1r1g1e1]

@@mixtheory1412 Tell you what: how about the two of us come back here in ten year's time? Should be fun. Write it in your calendar. See you then. Have a nice decade.

[@mixtheory1412]

@@v1e1r1g1e1 hah sure man

[@benquinneyiii7941]

He 219 uhu Corsair

[@jonhohensee3258]

STUPID TITLE.

[@jonathancummings6400]

Yes. It's not what happened. It's more accurate to be "From ancient more primitive Dinosaur to modern very advanced flying Dinosaur people call "Birds".

[@jonhohensee3258]

@@jonathancummings6400 You don't have to capitalize "dinosaur".

[@This_birb_is_annoying...]

We birds are assholes

[@straighttalking2090]

Just being descended from dinosaurs does not make a bird a dinosaur. Humans (and dinosaurs) are descended from fish - that does not make humans, or or dinosaurs, fish.

[@Dr.Ian-Plect]

birds are dinosaurs by ancestry _and_ the traits they possess

[@AlbertaGeek]

Clue for your clueless self: no organism out-evolves its ancestry.

[@andrewgonzales6527]

@@Dr.Ian-Plect Only those in the order Theropod can be classified as modern dinosaurs. Calling all birds modern dinosaurs is a gross overstatement.

[@Dr.Ian-Plect]

@@andrewgonzales6527 Your comment exposes your complete lack of knowledge; "Only those in the order Theropod" - The name is Theropoda, and it is NOT an order, it is a clade "can be classified as modern dinosaurs. Calling all birds modern dinosaurs is a gross overstatement." - how are you defining 'modern dinosaur'? - now, regardless of what you mean by 'modern dinosaur', the fact you state 'Only those in the order Theropod can be classified as modern dinosaurs', INCLUDES birds! Birds ARE IN Theropoda! By your own wording, birds ARE dinosaurs! -------------- You clearly have no understanding of this topic, but address each point I answered and by the end of this you will understand much better.

[@andrewgonzales6527]

@@Dr.Ian-Plect you’re right about it being a clade, not an order. I was using the plural form of the word. However, it’s real convenient that they include those with 2 and 4 toes in the clade that means 3 toes.

[@davidsheckler4450]

From people to Sheeple...how society has fallen

[@This_birb_is_annoying...]

What is a bird to you

[@mixtheory1412]

Look who's talking

[@Stormbringer2012]

Pseudo science.

[@AMC2283]

Any rational objection or just against your religion?

[@jaysons6101]

lil bro

[@williamsparks1036]

If dinosaurs all died out at nearly the same time, then where did birds come from?

[@Dasple]

They come from dinosaur

[@Dr.Ian-Plect]

william, are you about for an honest exchange on that question?

[@This_birb_is_annoying...]

@@Dr.Ian-Plect he his ready

[@AlbertaGeek]

All dinosaurs did not dies out. You really need to update your education.

[@jaysons6101]

the Avian lineage of Dinosauria had already evolved in the Late Jurassic contrary to popular believe, a TON of birds also died during the extinction event, but only the smallest survived No other dinosaur could compete with the flying, seed-eating, small dinos so they died as well.

[@jerrychacon8814]

Birds were alive and flying around and living when dinosaurs were alive. So how can birds come from dinosaurs. Birds are warm blooded, reptiles are cold blooded?????

[@HaHa00193]

Dinosaurs ARE warm bloodee, they arent really lizards, they are archasaurs which are a type of reptile but not a lizard. Therapods had existed since the triassic, they evolved feathers first. So in some different lineages of feathered small theropods split into bird like and some slit off into dino bird like. We also know they are related to dinosaurs due to skeletal and (kinda) behavioral structures as well as feathers

[@mixtheory1412]

Both you, your parents, grandparents and your siblings are alive, correct? Well that's how things work. One species of dinosaur was the ancestor of birds, the others still existed, like you and your siblings or cousins can be alive at the same time, but you all came from your parents or grandparents. Birds and dinosaurs share a common ancestor, which was a dinosaur too.

[@jaysons6101]

How do you not realize that maybe, just MAYBE, the Avian Dinosaur lineage we see today had already evolved back in the day. also no, some lizards are warm blooded, such as the tegu. Also, MOST reptiles EVER to be alive were warm blooded.

[@jerrychacon8814]

@@mixtheory1412 were talking about changing into a different species, fossil evidence shows no gradual change of creatures found.

[@jerrychacon8814]

@@HaHa00193 dinosaurs are cold bloodee

[@Dark-Sentences]

God made birds as birds. They were never dinosaurs.

[@火災のアイスクリーム]

there was never even a god, genius.

[@Dark-Sentences]

@@火災のアイスクリーム By your word I receive all that was intended for you. You can't have it back. Thank you.

[@aengor]

Another lying creatard. And like nearly always, American. What the heck is wrong with that country?

[@Alduintheworldeater]

God made very animal and set dinosaurs on the path of evolution God made evolution Look I’m Religious and I can still find a way to combine both worlds it’s not hard and it’s very releaving

[@Alduintheworldeater]

@@aengornot everybody is like that cmon

[@yellowbird2279]

This is completely false. Brids are not dinosaurs, nor are they related to dinosaurs.

[@Dr.Ian-Plect]

wrong and wrong

[@titanuspixel55]

Negating it won't change reality.

[@andrewgonzales6527]

@@titanuspixel55 Only those in the order Theropod can be classified as modern dinosaurs. Calling all birds modern dinosaurs is a gross overstatement.

[@titanuspixel55]

@@andrewgonzales6527 Uh, what's your understandment of dinosaurs-birds taxonomy?

[@HaHa00193]

​@@titanuspixel55he is just spamming this because he is a scientifically illerterate vegetable

[@macdavid9986]

Proven fact? That’s laughable…

[@AMC2283]

And rational criticism or just against your religion?

[@macdavid9986]

@@AMC2283 Facts are easy, there are no proven facts. This is all conjecture.

[@AMC2283]

@@macdavid9986 you needn’t accept the facts as presented by evolutionary biology but to say there’s none is just petulant. Surely you can criticize what they state instead.

[@macdavid9986]

@@AMC2283 SMH, if you think this “KZbin” or a “KZbin” video has presented proven facts about evolution you are intentionally misinformed and intentionally gullible. If it was a proven fact then the theory of evolution wouldn’t have the word “theory” in front of it.

[@AMC2283]

@@macdavid9986 no actually a scientific theory is an exhaustively verified set of principles that explains why things happen. It’s not a law because we can’t predict what will happen to millions of genes for billions of species forever.