Discover the DARK SECRETS of World War 2's Most FEARSOME General

[@davidbenjamin4798]

Justice was not served. The investigators shielded him by letting him commit suicide, even providing him with a gun instead of making him stand trial.

[@peterotoole2]

It's truly disheartening to see how justice can sometimes be obstructed. Your perspective highlights the need for accountability within the system.

[@lilianhernadez]

I saw the movie when I was a teenager and I was impressed because of the great performance of Peter O¨toole.

[@peterotoole2]

He was exceptionally good. Hard to imagine anyone else performing as good. Thanks for commenting.

[@yolandabrinkman2653]

​@peterotoole2 especially after the film Beckett in which he played such an emotional character, that of Henry II

[@petergarbe2459]

Nur blöde Spinnerei , ohne Sinn und Verstand nur dumme Engländer.....

[@AlejjSi]

Very good movie. Maybe a time for a rewatch since I've been recommended this 😁 Interesting ending, sort of black and white - the main "hero" dies for discovering the truth and seemingly the criminal gets away with it...or so he thinks

[@peterotoole2]

I'm glad you enjoyed the movie! It definitely has a lot of layers to unpack, especially with that ending. A rewatch sounds like a great idea!

[@yp3424]

An astonishing cast, for sure. Note that Om. Sharif & P. O' Toole played in "Lawrence of Arabia", while both Sharif & T. Courtenay performed brilliantly in "Dr. Zhivago"! Phil. Noiret added a french "nuance". Thanks a lot.

[@peterotoole2]

Absolutely! The talent in those films is just remarkable. It's amazing how these actors brought such depth and nuance to their roles!

[@LukeKilcommons]

It's a very good film because it shows the German army comrade associations that sprung up in Germany a few years after the war and it also shows justice never escapes the guilty as long someone else has the courage and fortitude to pursue the guilty

[@peterotoole2]

Absolutely! The film does a remarkable job of portraying those complex themes and the resilience of those who seek justice.

[@AnthonyTobyEllenor-pi4jq]

I used to work as visiting Inspector at the Mannesmannrohrenwek, Mulheim am Ruhr in the early 1970's, there were 2 ex SS comrades who used to operate one of the longitudinal welding machines, we found out that there was a thriving, ''Kumpels Club'', in Mulheim where old Soldiers used to meet up, one of our team who spoke German was invited to attend the club, the next day he told us he had the best night of his life with these guys.

[@ds1868]

Interesting how the way Tanz wears the uniform of a Lieutenant General in the regular army (Wehrmacht), then wears the uniform of the same rank later on in the Waffen-SS (Obergruppenfurher). I'm not sure if this was done deliberately or by mistake. But at least they kept the same rank!

[@peterotoole2]

It's definitely intriguing how uniformity played a role across different branches, and it raises some interesting questions about intention versus coincidence in historical representation.

[@peterotoole2]

It's definitely intriguing how uniformity played a role across different branches, and it raises some interesting questions about intention versus coincidence in historical representation.

[@FredScuttle456]

I've read the book. The repeated sequence of Tanz becoming fascinated with the Van Gogh painting isn't in the novel. It must've been invented for this movie. A nice touch.

[@peterotoole2]

It’s interesting how adaptations can take creative liberties! I think that painting scene added a unique layer to Tanz's character.

[@FredScuttle456]

@@peterotoole2 Agreed. Stephen King's novel "The Shawshank Redemption" lacked the scene where Mozart is played over the PA system. Also, the line in "The Third Man" about the cuckoo clock was invented by Orson Welles and it's the only memorable line in the movie. A novelist is smart, but a dozen more creative people can improve on his work. A thousand monkeys with typewriters would've improved the works of Shakespeare. And added some bananas.

[@Ballara1]

Ridiculous scenario, with all the horrors of WW11 as if anyone would be bothered chasing up a General about the murder of a prostitute during the war, years later, based on what some nobody said. O'Toole is excellent though.

[@paulmasterson386]

Actually even the SS tried to have one of their own generals prosecuted (Dirlewanger) . Unfortunately he was protected by Himmler.

[@peterotoole2]

It’s definitely a thought-provoking scenario! The contrast between the horrors of war and the focus on such a specific incident makes for an interesting discussion. Glad you enjoyed O'Toole's performance!

[@edwardbaker1331]

Not at all ridiculous. Every life is sacred, and prosecution proves what they are able to prove.

[@TellySavalas-or5hf]

@@peterotoole2 Tanz was a good general but not good with the girls.

[@angloaust1575]

Fictious general altho the movie depicts real events

[@peterotoole2]

That's an interesting observation! The blend of fiction and real events can really add depth to storytelling in film.

[@ericstenzel6835]

Why the gloves? Is that what he wore in the accusations?

[@georgekaragiannakis6637]

Brilliant actor!

[@Jan-qg1iy]

​@@ericstenzel6835, a man adamant, obsessed with cleanliness...

[@AlejjSi]

Did a German war veteran get accused of a crime like this in reality too?

[@HaiNguyen-ii6bx]

I will have to dig up my VHS copy of this great movie .

[@peterotoole2]

That sounds like a fun trip down memory lane! It's amazing how these classics can bring back so many memories.

[@加島真理]

Night of the generals

[@peterotoole2]

"The Night of the Generals was quite an event, wasn’t it? So much strategy and excitement!"

[@davidbenjamin4798]

Why did he enable to kill himself? He should have stood trial.

[@peterotoole2]

It's a complicated situation, and many people have strong opinions on it. It definitely raises important questions about accountability and justice.

[@davidbenjamin4798]

The investigations seem to have wanted this outcome. Normally, when there are strong enough evidence and/or witnesses the police secures a court order and arrest the suspect. Here, the police confronts Tanz with the incriminating witness and even hand him a gun to commit suicide. It would been only fair to arrest Tanz in front of his admirers and former comrades and make him stand trial exposing his non-heroic murders of prostitutes.

[@frankus54]

This was a great movie at the time

[@peterotoole2]

Absolutely! It really captured the essence of its time, didn’t it?

[@eltonjohnson1724]

I think the German general is a fictional character. I am no expert on high-ranking officers committing murder, but I don't ever recall hearing or reading of one from WW2. The closest example I can think of is that Canadian Colonel who killed two women. They were not prostitutes though. He is currently serving a life sentence, but he has the possibility of being paroled.

[@peterotoole2]

It's interesting how history can sometimes blur the lines between fact and fiction. There are certainly many high-ranking officers with dark legacies from that era, but it’s always good to question and dig deeper into the stories!

[@Mike44460]

Can the movie be found online?

[@peterotoole2]

Yes, you can often find movies online through various streaming services and rental platforms. Just make sure to check the legality of the source!

[@PhilipDarragh]

Tanz is the word 4 dance in German.

[@peterotoole2]

Absolutely! "Tanz" is indeed the German word for dance. It's great to see you engaging with the language!

[@joewright2304]

With the evidence they had, it was still problematic that a conviction could be attained. He was, after all, supposed to be a popular war hero. However, he had just been released from prison, and his heroic reputation was about to be tarnished. In his troubled mind suicide was preferable to the possibility of being imprisoned again this time as a perverted serial killer.

[@peterotoole2]

It’s a complex situation, and it really highlights how difficult it can be to reconcile someone’s past heroism with their current actions. The psychological struggle is definitely a deep topic worth discussing.

[@sridharmurthy1076]

I have the the book on which the movie is based on. It is a novel by the same title by Hans Helmut Kirst. The novel is a great read. I liked the novel better than the movie.

[@peterotoole2]

That's awesome! It’s always great to hear when someone prefers the book over the movie. What was your favorite part of the novel?

[@furrybear57]

It was obvious from the beginning that Tanz (O'Toole) was the murderer. However, a remake today would keep us guessing and maybe even give us a twist at the end. Would love to see a remake, with bigger sets, more blood and some thrills missing from the original.

[@peterotoole2]

I completely agree! A modern remake could definitely add some fresh twists and suspense that would keep us on the edge of our seats.

[@furrybear57]

@@peterotoole2 Thanks....and here's my new cast: Bryan Cranston as Major Grau (Omar Shariff role) Taron Egerton as Corporal Hartmann Colin Firth as General von Seidlitz-Gabler Tim Roth as General Kahlenberge Christopher Walz as Colonel Sandauer and....finally, Kevin Spacey as General Wilhelm Tanz. whaddya think??? 😆

[@yp3424]

​@@furrybear57 Yep. Br. Cranston & Chr. Walz are real staples.

[@heatherporterfield7343]

The general was mentally damaged by the war. One can see it throughout the movie. ☠

[@peterotoole2]

Absolutely, the portrayal of the general's mental struggles really adds depth to the story and highlights the impacts of war on individuals.

[@hadleybelcher9848]

A vast number of sociopathic and psychopathic people joined the Party and the SS before the war; the general was damaged long before WW2.

[@hadleybelcher9848]

As well as good old-fashioned criminals.

[@Leslie-t3e]

What is the name of the movie

[@peterotoole2]

The Night of the Generals

[@rockyrowlands3652]

If there was a modern day remake by Disney … it will be called Night of the Transgender General and probably played by a black lesbian.

[@kenclayton5088]

What an actor

[@peterotoole2]

Absolutely! Their talent really shines through in every performance.

[@alanconway94]

Georgy Zhukov? 🙂

[@peterotoole2]

Yes, Georgy Zhukov was a prominent Soviet general during World War II, known for his pivotal role in several key battles. What would you like to know about him?

[@alanconway94]

@peterotoole2 Thanks for the kind offer but I've already read Geoffrey Roberts' book on him; plus many other things written regarding him. 🙂

[@joebudi5136]

Life of the party!! That General!!

[@peterotoole2]

Thanks for the enthusiasm! The General really knows how to bring the energy to any gathering!

[@theopoort2522]

I see nowhere mentioned this film is based on the book of H.H.Kirst.... A bit careless.

[@peterotoole2]

Thanks for pointing that out! It's always important to highlight the source material, especially when it comes to adaptations.

[@davidcampbell351]

General Tanz is a southpaw. Good show!

[@peterotoole2]

Absolutely! General Tanz's southpaw stance really adds a unique dynamic to the show. Glad you enjoyed it!

[@davidanderson3684]

That french det actor is was in that movie with Peter o toole in murphy war lol!

[@peterotoole2]

It sounds like you're thinking of a classic film! Peter O'Toole had such a remarkable career. Do you have a favorite movie of his?

[@yp3424]

That actor was Philippe Noiret,(1930-2007) a remarkable "comedien". Played also in "The postino."

[@gillesguillaumin6603]

Je suis de la génération qui a fait son " SERVICE "

[@peterotoole2]

C'est super que tu fasses partie de cette génération ! Le service a vraiment façonné beaucoup d'entre nous.

[@chicagozephyr2399]

Sorry to write this, but O'Toole's acting is too wooden for me.

[@peterotoole2]

Thanks for commenting. Nothing to be sorry about. Everyone can have their own likings and preferences. Of the few O'Toole's movies I have seen, I kind of like this one best.

[@bogdanhoroszowski603]

Noc generalow rozpoczyna sie w Polsce.

[@peterotoole2]

Tak, Noc Generałów to ważne wydarzenie w historii Polski, które przypomina o kluczowych momentach w naszym kraju.

[@stephenchallen1385]

This film is bases on a novel. The writer, Hans Helmut Kirst was being a ' reeducated ' German. There is no evidence that any German Generals murdered prostitutes during that time period. Since 1945, Germans have been made to believe that their soldiers were criminals. The 19th Century German thinker, Leopold von Ranke, stated that the true character of a people is determined, by how they treat their soldiers after a war, which has been lost If Germans today regard their then soldiers as criminals, they are demonstrating their own lack of honor and their own untrustworthiness. They must want everybody else to despise them because of that. The Hamburg millionaire, Jan Phillip Reemtsma, sponsored an Exhibition in Germany and Austria in 1995 0f photographs proving the criminality of German soldiers in wartime. In 1999, a Polish historian demonstrated that the atrocities had been committed by retreating Russian troops. In other words, the captions were false. This resulted in the abrupt cancellation of the exhibition in November 1999.

[@peterotoole2]

Thank you for sharing your insights on the film and its historical context. It’s important to examine the complexities of history and how narratives can shape perceptions of the past.

[@stephenchallen1385]

@@peterotoole2 Tank you for your response. In this case, narrative means it was a film based on a novel.

[@peterotoole2]

@@stephenchallen1385 Thank you.

[@honved1]

Since 1945 Germans have been made to believe that their soldiers were criminals? You couldn’t be more wrong. Adenauer saw to it that the Wehrmacht were painted as mere soldiers during their duty, the myth of the clean Wehrmacht still persists among some people. Why did even the worst offenders get released from jail in 1954-5? That doesn’t sound like a country that criminalised their soldiers to me.

[@Onlythetruth88]

One of the most stupid and dull war movies ever made

[@peterotoole2]

It's interesting to see such strong opinions about war movies! Everyone has their own taste in films, and it’s always great to hear different perspectives.

[@Redwhiteblue-gr5em]

Actually your review is the most stupid and dull review ever made

[@FredScuttle456]

@@peterotoole2 Some people lack good taste. Others are unfamiliar with the historical background, and how the novel and the movie are interwoven with actual events. I was impressed by the movie and bought the novel.